Feasibility in finite time

(1)

Working Paper No. 26/07 Feasibility in Finite Time

by S. D. Flåm J.-B. Hiriart-Urruty

A. Jourani

SNF Project No. 3085

Design, implementation and evaluation of environmental policy

The project is financed by the Research Council of Norway

INSTITUTE FOR RESEARCH IN ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION BERGEN, OCTOBER 2007

ISSN 0803-4028

Ytterligere eksemplarfremstilling uten avtale og i strid med åndsverkloven er straffbart og kan medføre erstatningsansvar.

(2)

!

" # " $ #

# ! # " $ "

% " " ! $

! & ! &

' ! # !

( % " ) %

" ! * " &

$ "

( +, -. /0 1- /234- /2 -.

5 # #

# # $ # " !

$ (

! 3 $ # # #

# 6 5 7 #

% ! ! " ! "

! ⁴ * "

3 " ' " # 8 " 1 .--2

7 $ ' 9 : ;

# < = > ? = ' 9 ; 6 !

# < " " ? < 6 " " = 02,2-

+4-22, 9 ' 9 ; " " !

4 # @+A @0A @.A @41A @42A @++A

4

(3)

9 # " # " 3

# ! ! " !

B4C

!

9 # " ! ! $

# !

B4C &

$ & *

* & B4C # $

B C # * 6 ! ' @+A

@0A @.A @2A @42A @++A $ # ! $

* " 6

* ! $ " (

= % ( ! 5

# " # !

D ! " # #

5 ! 7 "

! $

5 # $ "

! " ! * )

" ! & "

@1A " 5 $ $ #

# ! ! "

* ! "

) % 5 ! " $ #

5 5 $ " # $ !

6 & # ( 8 !

# ! "

! # # $ /E0

" ! . # 5 : $ !

1 " ! !

5 +

(4)

! # ! $ " /

$ " 0 "

. # * 5 1 $

# ! !

!

# $ ! ⁺ !

$ 5 !

! ! D $ " ! $

" * ! #

!

B+C

BD & C

B4C

!

$

! D

F # ! $

! !

+G 3 5 $ "

@2A @4+A @+0A @+.A @+1A @/-A

/

(5)

" $ ! #

$ 5 ! "

! !

$ #

$ H " # $ 5 !

! #

B/C

$ &

B0C

$ # # "

# $ H " # $

9 ! " &

! $ # $

! !

! * F # " "

%

B.C

$ ! %

! " "

$ & # $ % & '

! B1C

= + 4 @+4A 8* , ./ @+,A

86 B1C " " " "

" ! $

* " % !

$ "

% &

0

(6)

! $ I# " I " #

I I $

& # B.C 9

# ! # ! < ? 5 #

5 ! " " " B.C 9 )

! # #

" ! B4C $ $ 6

B2C

B2C 6 % ! ! !

! $

! ! G 6 B2C

! ! !

) J J ! > +E/ B44C

D $ 6

" 3 &

! 5

" & "

" 5 !

! " 5 #

! $ 5 $

! . E 1 $ B4C !

B,C

G : * # # * "

" # " & !

$ G & " " ! $ $

" $ 5 " 6 &

" * % ! $

#

! "

! " 5

" % ! 5

!

.

(7)

B,C ! ! $

$ " I I !

* G & < ? 5 #

! B1C *

" # $ &* ! $ ! !

! B# $ C ' G

6 !

# $ % B "C

@++A " # ! 6

# ! % &

!

& ! " " # #

"

? & ! ( & (

! $

$

! # $ & (

!

"

% !

D! ! " ! ! &

3 5 " ! ! $ ?

5 # " 6 8

9 " G &

3 5 " ! ! <

" : * # < 6 #

? 5 # ! ! ' @4-A !

1

(8)

) ! " " # @+2A

# ! %

'

) ^/

$ % ! # * $

" # * !

B C &

B,C * %

B2C

! # ! > 4 ! # 5 " $ *

! $ " " !

B # # ! " C # +

%

$

$ BKC

> 3 5 # # !

3 " % %

$ " %

! $

$

3 6

$

$ $

$

/G $ $ #

2

(9)

# 5 " " 3 5 " !

! BKC ! $

? # ! " 6 BKC

G & 6 B1C

$ G

' 4 KK @++A # $

$ $ H > +

? 5 # "

B? ! C &

B,C '

%

+ B2C

$ % !

$ $ &

$ & $ $ $

> ) $

$

$ $ $

> )

$ $ $

$ 3 6

> + " #

$

B2C

,

(10)

,- + !

! FL * %

,- + '

B,C B2C

FL * # # $

$ # ' @KA

7 B2C $ !

! ! ! H

$ # B4-C

# ! $ $

! $ # $ ( &

! ! $ 6 # " @.A

" ! $ " B1C

4 KK @++A D B2C !

$ #

" " !

6 B+C # "

" % ! *

# *

! ! $ %

#

5 ! % $ B,C *

&* #

G % "

' $ # !

" $ ' $

" "

! 6 # *

B,C " # 9 &* & !

K

(11)

9 =

$ B,C "

9 B C !

) $ $ .

D " " " # # " ( #

" $ $

# & !

G $ % & $

& " ! *

( # < $

% G $

5 @4-A $

6 # % " ! !

G " # ! $

"

M 3 5 G 5 @4.A )

! ! $ % )& !

# ) & " > # ! %

# = 6 M 5 ! @+2A

! ! # " * (

B # " # *

C & B,C

B2C

B/C *

$

* ! $ #

= 6 M 5 ! @+2A $ 5 $

< # # $ # " 6

4-

(12)

$ ! $ ! > 4

G 5 / "

! $ ! = 4 . @+-A ! #

* $ #

B44C

/ # ! FL *

" B2C

D ! # B4-C H

" B4C " % # " (

! B3 ! 9 # ⁰C B4C

% B,C

* &

"

G " @/-A * $

% $ " !

0 6 # # @44A

44

(13)

3 6 ! # H $ #

> " $

$ $ " !

$ ! $

G # *" " !

# " &

# * G $

" !

3 6 "

M " " $ # # * &*

# "

! ! /

! ? @+/A # #

6 " $ " "

4+

(14)

! 3 !

" " # $

!

B,C " &* # !

# "

B4+C

$ # " 9 !

8 " $

& B2C % $

" #

G $ ! ! * "

M +

$ $ % * # +

,

, $ # +

$

< # # * ? # 9

"

1 4 3 5 B4KK,C 3 6 "

B,C 4 /

# $ % & $

6 ! ! "

& 8 G & * $

- B4/C

$ - # * $ G

# # & -

B40C 4/

(15)

G B40C % *

9 $

# * ! " # - $ #

> $ ) $

! - # *

$ " * @/A

M / ! ! "

# B $ # C * I ) I ! $

) $ " " 3 5 B4KK,C 3 0 +

# ! $ "(

! B " " & C

+' -

+

/ B4/C

0

" " # ! " $

$ # * 5 $ M : " !

" &*

I ! ! # *I * .

$ " ^. ( .

. ! 3 # ' @4A @4,A !

40

(16)

. $ " !

! $

$ %

& + / !

/ $

= / # # * /

! # " /

# ! ! # * +' % !

/ $ # $ $ B,C $

/

3 " # " # $ " ! $ "

BM " # * 5 & C

+' % / 1

/

B,C

' %

* # ! "

$ B C ! 8

3 6 ! .

. # !# ." $ &

$ G " %

4.

(17)

! $ 5 ! 5 $

$ D ! 5 !

$ ! " $ $

$ 5 $ !

$ # 5 &

!

! #

$ # ! .

&

. . . . .> " "

" 9

# ! &

B4.C

> $

# B4C !

B41C

G $ # & $ " %

$ " # $

% + )

% % $ # * ! !

& ! B41C $ $ !

! 0 & ' 0 ' &

# B & # ! # C2

/

* * B41C

B42C

41

(18)

! " ! # G

" & %

$ % $ "

7 $ # 5 B4.C " !

9 $ $ * ! $

B # B41C C "

! ! $ 6 #

H ! B42C #

$

( ( 5 ! !

" # & 5 7 = 9 M87

8MF ! & # < = # # <

" " !

@4A 8 3N O # * 400 +/.

+0- B4K1KC

@+A = 3 ( & " P "

B4K,0C

@/A = 85 * 3 * G 7 $ Q 5

B4K,0C

@0A = 5 $ 5 '4 * 5 R

B4KK-C

42

(19)

@.A = 4 5 R B4KK4C

@1A F + S $

= B4KK/C

@2A 8* ! # * $ " 5

( & /0 410 +,1 +K. B+---C

@,A ? $ = ) 5 M F % !

! " " ) " 5

* * 4+, .4+ ./0 B4K,2C

@KA ? $ = ) 5 8* !

5 04 B0C 2-+ 2+- B4K,KC

@4-A ? 5 > D # ! " !

3 * * 0, ++/ +01 B+--+C

@44A " 3 ? < P D 6 #

$ 9 %

6 .. 0. .4 B+--1C

@4+A 3 3 " P < T U # * $

* + * < 4 B4K20C

@4/A 3 3 " V ? P 8# 6 " #

$ " '4 * 4-K 4/K B4KK/C

@40A 3 3 " ? = ? ? 6 8#

$ # * # " 1 ./ 2/ ,2 B4KK1C

@4.A 3 5 M = M G 5 = *

$ 3 5 + * + 442 400 B4KK.C

@41A 3 5 Q > # M = M G 5 3

* " P " B4KK,C

@42A S " ( & /0 F B4KK+C

@4,A 8 # # # * (

# # * * 7 ++

02 1+ B4KK,C

@4KA G 5 " ! ! 3 '

* * 1. 11- 121 B+--1C

4,

(20)

@+-A > ? " %

'4 * / ,2 4-- B4KK.C

@+4A ? 5 # * + 1 ! )

7 5 ? $ B4K,,C

@++A ? 5 # 4 * , ) ( &

" B+--1C

@+/A ? < " *

W 8 * 1 +11 +/, +0- B4K1+C

@+0A ? M : # * # $ * + '

* < 4. B4K24C

@+.A ? = T <# < # *

8' * 1 $ *'9 +21 2K4 2K0 B4K2/C

@+1A ? 8# $ # " # *

5 ( & /0 +1 /02 /20 B4K22C

@+2A M = 6 M M 5 ! > > % !

! * /.+ 44 .+/4 .+0K B+---C

@+,A M M 5 ! M G 4 * "

B4KK,C

@+KA $ )

= ! 3 DM( 3 ! * D ) 3 9 7

# /.4 /.1 B4KK2C

@/-A > $ " $ " " 5 ( & '

/0 4K/ 4 +1 B+--/C

4K