• No results found

Congenital Aniridia: Exploring Visual Disabling Manifestations in the Ocular Surface and Ocular Fundus through Clinical and Translational Approaches

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Congenital Aniridia: Exploring Visual Disabling Manifestations in the Ocular Surface and Ocular Fundus through Clinical and Translational Approaches"

Copied!
165
0
0

Laster.... (Se fulltekst nå)

Fulltekst

(1)

#

"%$$&

# "#!"

"#!"

)'(*

(2)

© Erlend Christoffer Sommer Landsend, 2020

Series of dissertations submitted to the Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo

ISBN 978-82-8377-563-1

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be

reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without permission.

Cover: Hanne Baadsgaard Utigard.

Print production: Reprosentralen, University of Oslo.

(3)

Y

),()11-)(&3, &.#)(-#('#,,),6."(1-"&&- .) 8 )1%()1#(*,.6."(-"&&%()1 /&&350(-' /&&3%()1(8

W,1&+3%&+2WYAWX

(4)

Z

(5)

[

,'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''4 WBWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB_

WBX BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB_

WBYBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB_

-'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''',.

.'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''',0 /'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''',1 ZBWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBW\

ZBXBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBW\

0''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''',3 [BWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBW^

[BXBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBW_

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

G8E8C8(.)'3888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888EG G8E8D8)($/(.#088888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888EH

(6)

\

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

G8F8C8 #(#.#)((&--# #.#)(888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888EK G8F8D8.")*"3-#)&)!3888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888EK G8F8E8#)'#(&(3- /(.#)(88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FB G8F8F80*),.#0,33#--888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FC G8F8G8( &''.),3#.),-#(,33#--88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FD G8F8H8( &''.),3#.),-#(,33#--88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FE G8F8I8,33#--#((#,##88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FF [B[BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBZZ G8G8C8(.,)/.#)(8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FF G8G8D8/(/-/.) &/),-(#(/&/.88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FG

[B\BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBZ\

[B]B

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBZ\

1'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''/3

\BWB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBZ^

\BXBJBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBZ^

\BYB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBZ^

H8E8C8./3C88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FJ H8E8D8./3D88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FK H8E8E8./3E88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FK 2' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''0+

]BWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB[V I8C8C8./3C(D88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GB I8C8D8./3E88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GB ]BXB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB[W ]BYBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB[W I8E8C8-/,'(.) ,,)/.#)(888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GE I8E8D8)&&.#)() ,&/# ),(&3--888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GF I8E8E80&/.#)() ,#&'/&#.38888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GF I8E8F8----'(.) /&,/, .#(#(!8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GG I8E8G8/(.# #.#)() ),(&(-#.#0#.388888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GH I8E8H80&/.#)() #)'#(&(2*,--##&#.3(#/'/&#.388888888888888GI I8E8I8/$.#0(&3--) #)!,*"3'!-8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GI

(7)

]

I8E8J8#!#.&(&3--) #)!,*"3'!-8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888GJ I8E8K82'#(.#)() 3&#**,(88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888HB ]BZBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB\V ]B[B BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB\X

]B\B \Z

]B]B BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB\[

]B^BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB\]

3''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''14

^BWBWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB\_

^BXBXBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB]Z

^BYBYABBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB]^

4' ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''3, _BWBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB^W K8C8C8(,&)(-#,.#)(-8888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JC K8C8D8/(.# #.#)() 3'*.)'-888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JC K8C8E8-/,'(.) ,,)/.#)((-')&,#.388888888888888888888888888888888888888888JC K8C8F8-.- ),#)'#(&(3- /(.#)(88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JD _BXBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB^Y K8D8C8)&&.#)() ,&/#88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JE K8D8D8(&3-#-) ,&/#88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JE K8D8E8(&3-#-) . ,)'."/&.#*&2--388888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JF _BYBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB^Z K8E8C8")#) .")-)(.""),3"#(/(/-/.) &/),-(88888JF K8E8D8")#) .")-)(.#&#.3) &.,;1# #&((#(!-,

*"."&')-)*3888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JG K8E8E8")#) .")-)(&#(#&.#&#.388888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JH _BZB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB^\

,+''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''32

WVBWB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB^]

CB8C8C8,)/.#)() ,-88888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JI CB8C8D8,#&'-')&,#.3-,%, ),,33#--888888888888888888888888888888888JI CB8C8E8&/),-#(#.&.#(#(!#-&..),.)*."3(/),(&

(-#.#0#.388888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888JJ CB8C8F8")&) #)'#(&(3- /(.#)(#((#,##888888888888888888888888888888888JK

WVBXB BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB_W

CB8D8C83.)%#()((.,.#)(-#((#,##()(.,)&,)/*8888888888888888888888888888888KC CB8D8D8"(,&(*# #)&) ,3.)%#(-888888888888888888888888888888888888888888KD

(8)

)(&*&+&!!$%! %% &&&&&&&&&1+

)(&*&,&!!$%! !!%&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&1, )(&*&+&!!"&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&1-

)(&+&)&""" "!" !!&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&1.

)(&+&*&"" "!" !!#% %

! %&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&1.

)(&+&+&!!$#% !!%! %%

!%&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&1/

)(&+&,&"" "!" !!#% %

!%&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&1/

)(&+&-&"" " $!'&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&10

(9)

_

>5

%&23%"2&2&2!"!& 3"!3,/"12,+26&3% ,+$"+&3)+&1&!&+!,3%"111"

,+!&3&,+2B

>5>

%"%BB/1,'" 3%2""+24//,13"!#&++ &))881B,+B12"+D2#,4+!3&,+?

3%"/3&"+3,1$+&93&,++&1&!&,168?3%",16"$&+22, &3&,+,#3%")&+!

+!13&))8&$%3"!?3%",16"$&+/%3%)*,),$& ), &"38?+$"1 ,)*D2

*"*,1&)#,4+!3&,+?+!3%""/13*"+3,#/%3%)*,),$8+!"/13*"+3,#

"!& )&, %"*&231832),+&5"12&38 ,2/&3)B

>5?

)&+& )"7*&+3&,+,#/13& &/+32&+3%"/1,'" 362*&+)8/"1#,1*"!33%"

3&,+)"+31"#,1/3& 2?&2&,++!8"1"?+&5"12&38,#,43%J23"1+

,168?,+$2"1$?,168B,13,186,1(&+234!8X62 11&"!,433

"/13*"+3,#"!& )&, %"*&2318?2),+&5"12&38 ,2/&3)?2),?,168B ++&+$)2"1,/%3%)*,2 ,/8&*$"2&+234!8Y6"1"3("+3"/13*"+3,#

/%3%)*,),$8?2),+&5"12&38 ,2/&3)B

>5@

6&))3%+())/"12,+26&3%+&1&!&+! ,+31,)&+!&5&!4)23(&+$/13&+3%"

234!8B%"&1(&+!+"22+!/3&"+ "6"1""+ ,41$&+$#,13%"6%,)"/1,'" 3B

8*&+24/"15&2,1?,12("3%"&*?&+31,!4 "!*"3,+&1&!&1"2"1 %&+XVWZB "1" 14&3"!*"3,3%"2 &"+3&#& ,**&33"",#+&1&!&,168?+!33"+!"!3%"

*""3&+$&++&1&!&41,/"&+"+& "3%"2*"8"1B33%&2*""3&+$1")&9"!3%"

(10)

WV

&+3"1"23&+$ %))"+$"2+&1&!&1"2"1 %62 ,+#1,+3"!8B%"2"&+2/&1"!*"?+!

,162(&+!3,,##"1*"/1,'" 33%3)3"1#,1*"!3%"2"#,1*8%BB6,1(B ,1&2+,3#1&!,#/1,*,3&+$231"+$3%2+!04)&3&"2,#,3%"1/",/)"B%&2&2314)8

*,3&53&+$K+,3,+)8#,1,+"2")#K43)2,#,13%"&)&383, 1"3"+!*,5"

#,161!B%5")2,)"1+"!),3#1,*%&23)"+3&++"36,1(&+$+! ,,/"13&,+?

6%& %%2)"!3,+"6"7 &3&+$/,22&&)&3&"2#,1*"+!2"5"1),3%"12B&+))8?6&))

%&$%)&$%3,1D2/,2&3&5&38+! %""1#4)+"22B

8%BB +!&! 82313"!&+XVW\B*$13"#4)3,,13"+123"+2,"?%"!,#

3%",/%3%)*,),$8!"/13*"+333%33&*"?6%,$5"*")"5"#1,**8 )&+& ) 6,1(B&3%,43%&24+!"123+!&+$?3%"/1,'" 36,4)!%5"""+&*/1 3& )"B

,23,#3%" )&+& )6,1(&+3%"/1,'" 362 11&"!,4333&,+)"+31"#,1/3& 2?

&2&,++!8"1"&+,+$2"1$B%"1"?3%" ,)),13&,+6&3%*8 ,J24/"15&2,1

&$*,1B12+!%BB +!&!3" &)!".$""1$"!"12"+%2""+5"18

&*/,13+3B%5")"1+"!*4 %#1,*3%"&11"2"1 %+!//1, %"23,5&24)2 &"+ "B &)!"D2/1))")&+$/1,'" 3,+,41 ,**,++&1&!& ,%,13%2""+$1"3&+2/&13&,+

#,1*"B62)2,$)!8$4++223%"&* ,4)!3("/13&+3%"234!&"2B "1

"7/"1&"+ "#1,* )&+& )6,1(+!1"2"1 %?"2/" &))8&+!18"8"+!, 4)1241# "

!&2"2"?62 14 &)&+/)++&+$+!"7" 43&,+,#3%"&+5"23&$3&,+2B2/" &))8?

//1" &3"!3%"$,,! ,)),13&,+6%"+"7*&+&+$234!8/13& &/+32&+,+$2"1$B

"&)$)&?)2,*8 ,J24/"15&2,1?%2""+%&$%)85)4"!*"*"1,#3%"234!8

$1,4/B &2"7/"1&"+ "#1,*+&1&!&1"2"1 %62"22"+3&)B413%"1?,416,1(%2

""+&*/1,5"!8%&24+!"123+!&+$,#3%"1"2"1 %1"24)32+!3%"&1&*/)& 3&,+2B 6&)))2,3%+(*83%&1! ,J24/"15&2,1?$+%"&!411$!,33&1?#,1%"1%")/#4)

,**"+32+!!5& "2B6&))"7/1"22$13&34!"3,))*8 ,J43%,12+,3*"+3&,+"!2,

#1A&7&+&,?4%**"!2&+!&)?"%9,!2%8"5?1)"+"++133? +2

%1&23&+)2,33"+22?+!,1&+&)5&4""$$B"&1(2")5)"%2""+("8

(11)

WW

/"12,+&+$1/%& )"!&3&+$B41!&2 422&,+2%5"$&5"+*"5)4)"/"12/" 3&5"2,+

3%"/,3"+3&),#$1/%& )/1"2"+33&,+B

*3%+(#4)#,13%"24//,13#1,*3%"/3&"+3,1$+&93&,++&1&!&,168M&+

,16"$&+A+&1&!&,1$"NB%1,4$%3%"&1%")/?6"*+$"!3,1" 14&32423+3&) /1,/,13&,+,#/"12,+26&3%+&1&!&&+,168B!!&3&,+))8?3%",1$+&93&,+ ,5"1"!

315")"7/"+2"2+! ,**,!3&,+#,13%"/13& &/+32B,23&*/,13+3)8?+&1&!&

,168%22%,6++&*/1"22&5"!"5,3&,+3,&*/1,5" 1"#,1/",/)"6&3%+&1&!&B

%&2%2&+!""!&+2/&1"!*86,1(B

%"$1+3#1,*1B,+B12"+D2#,4+!3&,+M&+,16"$&+A1B,+B12"+2 23&#3")2"3&)#1"**"5#,12(+&+$/,#3)*,),$&N*!"&3/,22&)"3, ,*/)"3"*8

%BB/1,'" 3B8"!, 3,1,+B12"+62231,+$)8!"!& 3"!3,3%"24'" 3,#

,/%3%)*,),$8+!3,%&2/3&"+32B362+%,+,413,1" "&5"24//,13#1,*%&2 )"$ 8B

&+))8?6&))3%+(*8#*&)8#,13%"&1"+ ,41$"*"+3B8/1"+32"1!+!

1&23,##"1%5")682*!"3%" ,+!&3&,+22#5,41)"2/,22&)"2,3%3*8

&)&3&"2 ,4)!!"5"),/B8#3%"15"18*4 %6+3"!3,2""*"!"#"+!3%"3%"2&2B +#,134+3")8?%"/22"!68"#,1"&36224*&33"!B ,6"5"1?3%"6,1($5"%&*

),3,#',8B6&)))2,3%+(*81,3%"1)#+!*82&23"12)&++! &)!"?+!3%"&1

#*&)&"2?#,1"&+$$1"3&+2/&13&,+B

1)"+!?

2),?1 %XY?XVW_

(12)

WX

(13)

WY

?5

+&1&!&22, &3"!("13,/3%8 04",42!"#& &"+3!18"8"

IX 2& #&1,)23$1,63%# 3,1

)423"1,#!&##"1"+3&3&,+

,+#&!"+ "&+3"15) /&))183"231&$%3"8"

/&))183"23)"#3"8"

18"8"!&2"2"

5/,13&5"!18"8"

+98*"J)&+("!&**4+,2,1"+3228

4+!4243,#)4,1"2 "+ "

)4,1"2 "&+1"(J4/3&*"

,5")!&23+ "

&1,)23$1,63%# 3,1

J 1+4), 83" ,),+8J23&*4)3&+$# 3,1

1"8)"5")

Jɶ +3"1#"1,+$**

+3"1)"4(&+

JW +3"1)"4(&+W1" "/3,1+3$,+&23 +3"1+)1"#"1"+ "

WX 83,("13&+WX

"+2,/ &3&"2 )22&#& 3&,+2823"*

JW ,+, 83" %"*,331 3+3/1,3"&+W

1,/%$"&+#)**3,18/1,3"&+

*/_ "3)),/1,3"&+2"_

(14)

WZ

"&,*&+$)+!

"&,*&+$)+!!82#4+ 3&,+

2 "&,*&+$)+!2

I ,3//)& )"

+* +,*"3"1

/3& ) ,%"1"+ "3,*,$1/%8

!!213&,

4)1241# "!&2"2"&+!"7

H &1"!J,7$"+"\

\ &1"!J,7/1,3"&+\

%,2/%3"J4##"1"!2)&+"

)3")"3J!"1&5"!$1,63%

"3&+)/&$*"+3"/&3%")&4*

3+!1!!"5&3&,+

3 '&&3

%&1*"13"23, 4)42!"73"1M1&$%3"8"N %&1*"13"23, 4)422&+&23"1M)"#3"8"N

"1&)* 4)1, &"38188",1(2%,/

Jɲ dƵŵŽƵƌŶĞĐƌŽƐŝƐĨĂĐƚŽƌɲ

&)*2:34*,41?+&1&!&?$"+&3,41&+18+,1*)&3&"2+!

*"+3)1"31!3&,+

C &)*2D34*,41W$"+"

(15)

W[

@5

B '''"$"? BB"!"12"+?BB3%"&*?B&,?BB!&)?B

2%8"5?B$)&?BB133?BB12?BB3%"&*B"&,*&+)+!

82#4+ 3&,++!"13,/3%81"22, &3"!6&3%188"&2"2"&++&1&!&B ,*"."&')&8XVW_@WVYMWNAWW_JWXZ

B '''"$"?BB3%"&*? BB"!"12"+? BBB22?B$)&?BB 133?BB12?BB3%"&*B

%""5"),#+#)**3,18"183,(&+"2&2)"53"!&+,+$"+&3)+&1&!&

+!22, &3"!6&3%"&,*&+)+!82#4+ 3&,+

(0-.8*"."&')&8#-8#8XVW^@[_M[NAXW_]JXXVZ

B '''"$"? BB"!"12"+?BB3%"&*?BB4""$$?BB12?B

$)&?B1$!Žǵ33&1?BB,"?BB3%"&*B

5)43&,+,#4+!4243,#)4,1"2 "+ "&+,+$"+&3)+&1&!&42&+$ ++&+$

2"1/%3%)*,2 ,/8M24*&33"!N

(16)

W\

A5

A5>5

%#,' %1,*,2,*"WW6&3%3%"1"$&,+WW/WY

%#-' "5"),/*"+3,#+&1&!&22, &3"!("13,/3%8

%#.' 3,12&+5,)5"!&+/3%,$"+"2&2,#+&1&!&22, &3"!("13,/3%8 %#/' 1,$1"22&,+,# 31 3&++&1&!&

%#0' %", 4)1241# "

%#1' &24)&93&,+,#3%"3"1*"+&2 426&3%"13,$1/%[

%#2' 1"(J4/,#3%"3"1#&)*,2"15"!&+2)&3)*/&,*& 1,2 ,/"

%#3' )4,1"2 "&+5&3)23&+&+$,#3%" ,1+"+!4)1 ,+'4+ 3&5 %#4' )&3)*/&*$"2,#*"&,*&+$)+!,1&#& "2+!2" 1"3&,+

%#,+' +#11"!&*$",#*"&,*&+$)+!2&+4//"1"8")&!

%#,,' ,*/43"1&9"!+)82"2,#&+#11"!*"&,$1/%8&*$"2 %#,-' &##"1"+323$"2,#+&1&!&22, &3"!("13,/3%8

%#,.' ,11")3&,+"36""+ ,1+")23&+&+$?23$",#+&1&!&22, &3"!

("13,/3%8?+! ,1+")2"+2&3&5&38

%#,/' ,11")3&,+"36""+ )&+& )/1*"3"12+! ,+ "+313&,+,#

51&,42&+#)**3,183"1 83,(&+"2

A5?5

!,' 5"15&"6,#!18"8""7*&+3&,+2

!-' "+31) )&+& )/1*"3"12&++&1&!&+! ,+31,)$1,4/&+234!8W

(17)

W]

!.' "1 83,(&+"26&3%&+ 1"2"! ,+ "+313&,+&+,3%"8"2,#

+&1&!&/3&"+32

!/' ,*/1&2,+,#1"24)32#1,*&*$"+)82"2&++&1&!&+! ,+31,)

$1,4/&+234!8Y

(18)

W^

B5

B5>5

%&23%"2&2!!1"22"22"5"1)2/" 321")3"!3,3%" ,*/)"7!&2"2" ,+$"+&3) +&1&!&B*&+/13&2!"5,3"!3,, 4)1241# "!&2"2"B++&1&!&?/1,$1"22&5"

, 4)1 ,*/)& 3&,+21" ,**,+B*,+$3%"2"?+&1&!&22, &3"!("13,/3%8 MN2""*23,"3%"*,23#"1"!B*8 42"2&$+&#& +3/&+?/1,$1"22&5"

5&2&,+),22?+!"5"+34))8)&+!+"22B+22, &3&,+"36""++!!18"8"

!&2"2"%2""+24$$"23"!B%"1"#,1"?6"&*"!3&+5"23&$3&+$3%", 4)1 241# "&+,1!"13,#&+!+26"123%3 ,4)!/1"2"15"5&2&,++!1"!4 "28*/3,*2

&++&1&!&B

23/13,#3%"3%"2&2 ,+ "1+23%", 4)1#4+!42&++&1&!&B,5")%8/,/)2&

##" 32*,23/3&"+326&3%+&1&!&+!&23%"*&+ 42",# ,+$"+&3)5&24)

&*/&1*"+3&+3%"2"/3&"+32B8234!8&+$#4+!4243,#)4,1"2 "+ "?6"&+3"+!"!

3,!!(+,6)"!$",433%"1"3&+)//"1+ "&++&1&!&B ,/"#4))8?3%&26&)) 24//,13 )&+& &+2&+22"22&+$5&24)#4+ 3&,++!/1,$+,2&2&++&1&!&/3&"+32?

43)2,&+*,+&3,1&+$31"3*"+3"##" 322$"+"3%"1/8*8"+,/3&,+&+3%"

#4341"B

"+ "?3%"3%"2&21&+$23,$"3%"136,*&+ 42"2,#5&24)!&2&)&38&++&1&!&K 6&3%3%"$,),#&*/1,5"!31"3*"+3&+3%"#4341"B

(19)

W_

B5?5

G8D8C8

,+$"+&3)+&1&!&&2/+, 4)1!&2"2"/1&*1&)8 %1 3"1&9"!851&,42

!"$1""2,#&1&2+!* 4)1%8/,/)2&B+*,23 2"23%"$"+"3& ,1&$&+&2

*433&,+&+3%"H$"+"?6%& %)"!23,#4+!*"+3)!&2341+ "2&+"8"

!"5"),/*"+3B"5"1"?2" ,+!18 ,*/)& 3&,+21" ,**,+?&+ )4!&+$

("13,/3%8?$)4 ,*+! 31 3B%"2"3"+!3,//"1#1,* %&)!%,,!,1

!,)"2 "+ "?+!,#3"+)"!3, ,+2&!"1)"5&24)&*/&1*"+3,1)&+!+"22B,+J , 4)1#&+!&+$2,#3%"!&2"2"1")2,"&+$1"/,13"!?+!3%"3"1*+&1&!&

28+!1,*"&2+,6*,1"#1"04"+3)8&+42"B+&1&!& ,4)!" ,+2&!"1"!*,!")

!&2"2"#,12"5"1),3%"1, 4)1 ,+!&3&,+2?&+ )4!&+$ ,1+") ),4!&+$&+)&*) 23"* "))!"#& &"+ 8? 31 3?$)4 ,*?+! ,+$"+&3)!"#" 32,#3%"/,23"1&,1 2"$*"+3B "+ "?(+,6)"!$",43+&1&!& ,4)!)2,$&5" )&+& &+2+!

1"2"1 %"12&+2&$%3&+3,,3%"1/3&"+3$1,4/2B

G8D8D8

,+$"+&3)+&1&!&&2 ,+2&!"1"!C11"!&2"2"D ,1!&+$3,3%"3&,+) 1$+&93&,+#,11"&2,1!"12BW++1"&+3%"233",#& %&$+MN?3%"

&+ &!"+ "62"23&*3"!3,WA\Z?VVVBX%"/1"5)"+ "&+6"!"++!,168%2

""+1"/,13"!3,"WA]X?VVVBY

G8D8E8

+&1&!&&2&+%"1&3"!&++43,2,*)!,*&++3/33"1+6&3%%&$%/"+"31+ "BZ ,4336,J3%&1!2,# 2"21"#*&)&)?+!,+"J3%&1!&22/,1!& B[+//1,7&*3")8 _Vb,#/3&"+32?+&1&!&,1&$&+3"2#1,**433&,+&+3%"/&1"!J,7$"+"\

MHN?\), 3"!33%"2%,131*,# %1,*,2,*"WWMWW/WYN?M&$41"WNBH

(20)

XV

"+ ,!"2/1,3"&+M\N3%32"15"22J&+!&+$31+2 1&/3&,+# 3,1B%"

/1,3"&+&2%&$%)8 ,+2"15"!3%1,4$%,43+&*)(&+$!,*B],1&+23+ "?

%"3"1,98$,42*433&,+&+3%"*,42"$"+"3M$"+"2&*&)13,3%"%4*+HN )"!23,*& "6&3%4+!"1!"5"),/"!?2*))"8"2B^?_

&&/-.,.#)() ",)')-)'CC1#.".",!#)(CC*CE51"#")'*,#-- ."!(-H5C(C8,.#&&#(-#&&/-.,.&(!.") ."!(-<().

-&=8,)'(-(.&8DBCI8F

%"*,4+3,#/1,3"&+/1,!4 "!8,+"+,1*) ,/8,#3%"H$"+"&2

&+24##& &"+33,*&+3&++,1*)/1,3"&+#4+ 3&,+B^?WV "+ "?),22,#,+"#4+ 3&,+) ,/8,#3%"$"+"&222, &3"!6&3%!&2"2"BH/1,)8 ,+31,)2)1$"

+4*"1,#31$"3$"+"2BWW,+2"04"+3)8?1"!4 "!*,4+3,#\/1,3"&+6&)) %+$""7/1"22&,+,#3%"2"$"+"2?+!#413%"1&+#)4"+ "!"5"),/*"+3,# "))2+!

3&224"2B

(21)

XW

1&,42*433&,+2&+H*8)3"13%"/1,3"&+/1,!4 3!&##"1"+3)8BZ3&2%2

""+/1,/,2"!3%3'#--(-*433&,+2)"!3,\/1,3"&+23%31"

!82#4+ 3&,+)" 42",#*&2#,)!&+$,1&+&)&383,&+! ,11" 3)83,31$"3$"+"2BWX )(-(-*433&,+2 ,4)!3%",1"3& ))81"24)3&+2,J ))"!314+ 3"!/1,3"&+23%3

*,23)&(")81"#4+ 3&,+))8&+ 3&5"BWY ,6"5"1?/1, "22 ))"!+,+2"+2"J

*"!&3"!!" 8/1,)8/1"5"+32#,1*3&,+,#3%"2"/1,3"&+2B%&2&23%,4$%33,

"/1,3" 3&5"*" %+&2*6%"1"*&2!"$1!"!&+,1!"13,5,&!

4*4)3&,+,#314+ 3"!/1,3"&+/1,!4 32&+3%" "))BE%" 4*+H

433&,+32"FM%33/AII/7\B%$4B*1 B B4(IN$&5"2+,5"15&"6,#1"/,13"!

H*433&,+2BWZ?W[ ,1!&+$3,3%&2!32"?Z_W4+&04"51&+326"1"

1"/,13"!2,#4$423Z?XVW^BW[

"2&!"251&+32!"2 1&"!&+H?*433&,+2&+ "13&+,3%"1$"+"2%5"""+

,++" 3"!3,3%"+&1&!&/%"+,38/"B%"2"$"+"2&+ )4!"C5W\D?W]+!

FFBW^)3"13&,+2&+C+!D ,4)!)2,$&5"1&2"3, ,+!&3&,+22&*&)1 3,+&1&!&?27"+#")!J&"$"128+!1,*"B[?W\

73"+2&,+,#3%"$"+"3& +)82&2!,6+231"*,#H%21"5")"!!")"3&,+,#

3%"F+!C$"+" 42&+$!&2"2"BW_&*&)1!,6+231"*!")"3&,+2+!

%1,*,2,*)!&214/3&,+2%5"""+#,4+!&++&1&!&?!"*,+2313&+$3%3H

#)+(&+$1"$&,+22%,4)!"&+5"23&$3"!&+3%"2"/3&"+32BZ5"+34))8? %+$"2&+

H&+31,+2*8)2,$&5"1&2"3,3%"+&1&!&/%"+,38/"BXV

7 )42&,+,#H!")"3&,+23%3"73"+!3,3%"C$"+"&2/1&*18$,)&+$"+"3&

"5)43&,+,#+&1&!&/3&"+32B")"3&,+2&+C/433%"/3&"+3231&2(,#

!"5"),/&+$+"/%1,)23,*?&)*2D34*,41B["7323"/&+3%"$"+"3&

&+5"23&$3&,+&2&+31$"+& *433&,++)82&2,#H?+!&#+" "2218+)82&2,#

,3%"1+&1&!&1")3"!$"+"2BZ

433&,+2 ,*/1&2&+$/1"*341"3"1*&+3&,+ ,!,+&+H1"$"+"1))8 22, &3"!6&3%+&1&!&,1 ),2")81")3"! ,+!&3&,+2BWY&22"+2"*433&,+2&+

(22)

XX

H1"424))8 ,++" 3"!3,*&)!"1+&1&!&/%"+,38/"BWY?XW%&2&+ )4!"2),6"1

#1"04"+ 8,##,5")%8/,/)2&+!)"222"5"1"5&2&,+),22B\?WV%,4$%?3%"

*&22"+2"/%"+,38/"22""*!&##& 4)33,/1"!& 3B,*",#3%"2"1"*,1"2"5"1"

3%+ )22& )+&1&!&?&+5,)5&+$"3"12:+,*)8?*& 1,/%3%)*&?+!,/3& +"15"

!"#" 32B\

+2,*" 2"2?3%" )&+& )"7/1"22&,+,#+&1&!&51&"26&!")86&3%&+#*&)&"2BXX?XY 3%"1#*&)&"2?%,6"5"1?2%,6)"22/%"+,38/& 51&"38BXZ"$1"",#&+31#*&)&)

!&5"12&38*8!"/"+!,+38/",#H*433&,++!&*/ 3#1,*31+2 1&/3&,+

# 3,12&+3"1 3&+$6&3%HB

G8D8F8; <=

"13,/3%8&++&1&!&%2""+!"+,3"!+&1&!& ("13,/3%8?+&1&!&1")3"!

("13,/3%8+!+&1&!&J22, &3"!("13,/3%8MNB "1"?6&))"42"!B (*+"3)B24$$"23"! )22&#& 3&,+,#&+W_]_X[?+!3%"1"#3"12&*&)1

$1!&+$21"/1,/,2"!BX\JYV,**,+#,1))3%"2" )22&#& 3&,+2&223$&+$,#3%"

("13,/3%82"!,+/1,/,13&,+,#3%" ,1+"##" 3"!+!), 3&,+,#3%"

&+5,)5"*"+3? ,+2&!"1"!82)&3J)*/&,*& 1,2 ,/8B+5&5, ,+#, )

*& 1,2 ,/8X^JYW+!#)4,1"2 "&++$&,$1/%8YX1"!!&3&,+)3,,)2&+22"22*"+3 ,#B ,6"5"1?3%"2"1"+,3&+ )4!"!&+3%" )22&#& 3&,+2B

%"&+&3&)23$",#&+ )4!"2/3&"+326&3% )"1 ,1+"?+!&+3 3 ,1+") )&*42M&$41"XNB"73*&+23"/&+5,)5"2+,1*)&38,#3%")&*42+!

/"1&/%"1)3,*&!J/"1&/%"1) ,1+"?!"2 1&"!252 4)1/++42?X\*4!!8&+$,1 ),4!&+$&+!& 3&+$&+$1,63%,#5"22")2?X]?X^,1 ,+'4+ 3&5)&93&,+?X_?YVM&$41"XNB

%"242"04"+3)"5")!"#&+"2("13,/3%8##" 3&+$ "+31)/13,#3%" ,1+"?

6&3%52 4)1&93&,++!&+5,)5"*"+3,# ,1+")231,*M&$41"XNB&+))8?3%"

*,232"5"1"23$"21" %1 3"1&9"!83,3) ,1+") ,+'4+ 3&5)&93&,++!

(23)

XY

52 4)1&93&,+M&$41"XN?+!&+3%""+!31+2#,1*3&,+,#3%" ,1+"&+3,+

,/04"?3%& (&11"$4)12314 341"B

28**"318&+23$",#"36""+"8"2&+2&+$)"/3&"+3%2""+#,4+!&+

YVb,#+&1&!& 2"2?6&3%4/3,3%1"")"5")2!&##"1"+ "842&+$#&5"J23"/

)22&#& 3&,+BYV

"'.#,1#(!-")1#(!0&)*'(.) (#,##--)#.

%,.)*."387&,),(5(#(..),(&&#'/-87)($/(.#0&#4.#)() ."*,#*",&.)'#;*,#*",&),(51#."#(!,)1.") 0--&-8%,.)*."3 .#(!(.,&*,.) ."),(51#."0-/&,#4.#)((#(0)&0'(.) ),(&-.,)'8.).&),(&)($/(.#0&#4.#)((0-/&,#4.#)(8

<&&/-.,.#)(7,&(",#-.) ,)'',(-((#,%-&0&=

(24)

XZ

G8D8G8

62&!"+3&#&"!&+^Vb,#XXW"8"2,#+&1&!&/3&"+32#1,*6"!"++!

,168"7*&+"!6&3% ,*&+3&,+,#,/%3%)*,2 ,/8+!!&$&3)

/%,3,$1/%2BX]%"$",###" 3"!&+!&5&!4)21+$"!#1,*XK]^8"12?6&3%*,1"

!5+ "!&+,)!"1/3&"+32B ,*/1)"/1,/,13&,+M]^bN6&3%62 ,2"15"!&+1"31,2/" 3&5""5)43&,+,#WY]"8"2,#+&1&!&/3&"+32#1,*%&,?

+&3"!33"2BYY%"2"/3&"+326"1"$"!XK^X8"12?6&3%*"!&+,#YY8"12B +2415"8*,+$+&1&!&24'" 32,1$+&9"!&+3%"+&1&!&,4+!3&,+

+3"1+3&,+),+)8Z[b1"/,13"!3%"8%!BYZ ,6"5"1?XXb,#3%"/13& &/+32 6"1"4+241"&#3%"86"1"##" 3"!83%&2 ,+!&3&,+B

"+31) ,1+"),/ &38/1"2"+3#1,*&13%62!"3" 3"!&+WYb,#X]["8"2,#

,1"+/3&"+32!&$+,2"!6&3% ,+$"+&3)+&1&!&BY[%",/ &3862 )&+& ))8

!&23&+ 3#1,*?+!*81"/1"2"+3 ,*&+3&,+,#+&1&!&+!"3"12D

+,*)8B"+31) ,1+"),/ &386222, &3"!6&3%%&$%"11&2(,#$)4 ,*+!

*,1"1"!4 "!5&2&,+3%+ 2"26&3%B

G8D8H8

1"!4 3&,+,#5&24) 4&38%2""+,2"15"!&++&1&!&/3&"+32,5"13&*"?"5"+

6%"+"7 )4!&+$24'" 326&3%$)4 ,*+! 31 3BYY%&224$$"232!" )&+"&+

5&2&,+" 42",#B2"!,+#&+!&+$28,/%3%)*,2 ,/8?62"7/" 3"!

3,&*/ 35&24) 4&38&+X\b,#&+!&5&!4)2&+ ,%,13?3%"8,4+$"23,#3%"*

"&+$#&5"8"12,)!BX]

G8D8I8

+?3%" ,1+",2 )"1))&*42&2 %1 3"1&9"!83&224"1"2"*)&+$ ,+'4+ 3&5?

6&3%,/04""/&3%")&4*+!/1"2"+ ",#),,!5"22")2BX_+2,*" 2"23%&23&224"

(25)

X[

#,1*2 ,+3&+4,42#1,+3/1, ""!&+$&+3,3%"/"1&/%"1),1*&!/"1&/%"1) ,1+"B +,3%"1/3&"+32?2/,32,# ,+'4+ 3&5)&9"!3&224"!"5"),/%"!,#3%"#1,+3B +5&5, ,+#, )*& 1,2 ,/8,#3%")&*)+!/"1&/%"1) ,1+"&+"1)823$"2,#

%21"5")"!/"12&23"+3242)+"15"233%""!$",#3%"/1,$1"22&+$3&224"

#1,+3BX_%"2"+"15"26"1"2"+3&+*,1"2"5"1"23$"2B%"$1,6&+$3&224"&32")#

%! ,+'4+ 3&5)//"1+ "+! ,+3&+"!),,!5"22")2B1"24*"!

&+#)**3,18+!$,)"3 "))2&+5!"!3%"/"1&/%"1)+!*&!/"1&/%"1) ,1+"?

+! *"&+3,5&"66&3%&+ 1"2&+$2"5"1&38,#B

413%"1?&+5&5, ,+#, )*& 1,2 ,/8,#3%" "+31)+!/1 "+31) ,1+"&+

+&1&!&2%,6"!$1!4)31+2#,1*3&,+,#3%""/&3%")&4*&+1")3&,+3,23$",#

BYV%""/&3%")&4* %+$"!#1,* ,1+")3,*&7"!3, ,+'4+ 3&5)38/"6&3%

*,1"2"5"1"B%"2")3"13&,+26"1")2,!"3" 3"!&+%&$%/"1 "+3$",#

"8"26&3% )"1 "+31) ,1+"8,/%3%)*,2 ,/8B42)+"15"!"+2&38&+3%"

"+31) ,1+"62!" 1"2"!&++&1&!&+!!&*&+&2%"!6&3%&+ 1"2&+$23$",#

BX_?YV,1",5"1?/1"2"+ ",#&+#)**3,18 "))2+!),,!5"22")2&+3%&2/13 ,#3%" ,1+"62 ,++" 3"!3,*,1"!5+ "!("13,/3%8BYV

+%&23,),$& )"7*&+3&,+,#"+4 )"3"!"8"2#1,*+&1&!&/3&"+32?1$,

!"2 1&"!24/"1#& &)52 4)1/++424+!"13%" ,1+")"/&3%")&4*BY\%"/++42 ,*/1&2"!#&1,52 4)13&224"+!2,*" %1,+& &+#)**3,18 "))2B,6*+D2

*"*1+"62+,3"5&!"+3&+3%"1",#/++42B+,+" 2"?52 4)1&93&,+

"73"+!"!&+3,3%" ,1+")231,*B"2 "*"3D2*"*1+"+!3%" ,1+")

"+!,3%")&4*6"1"+,3##" 3"!&++8,#3%"/3&"+32B

++,1*)"8"2?1!&)#,)!2K2,J ))"!/)&2!"2,#,$3K1"2""+&+3%")&*) 1"?*,23"5&!"+3&+3%"4//"1+!),6"1/13B3%2""+224*"!3%33%"

/)&2!"2 ,+3&++& %"26&3%23"* "))2BY],3)2"+ ",#/)&2!"2,#,$362

#,4+!82)&3J)*/&,*& 1,2 ,/8,#+&1&!&24'" 32BY^ ,6"5"1?)2"12 ++&+$&+

5&5, ,+#, )*& 1,2 ,/82%,6"!3%32,*""8"26&3%"1)8J23$"%!

(26)

X\

&!"+3&#&)")&*)/)&2!"2314 341"2BX_+3%"2" 2"2?3%,4$%?3%"*,1/%,),$8 62!"$1!"! ,*/1"!3,+,1*) ,1+"2B+"8"26&3%*,1"!5+ "!23$"2,#

?+,1" ,$+&9)"/)&2!"26"1"#,4+!B

G8D8J8

"$1!3&,+,12"+ ",#3%")&*)/)&2!"2,#,$36222, &3"!6&3%*,1"

2"5"1"BX_,+2"04"+3)8?)&*)23"* "))!"#& &"+ 8&2)&(")83,"&+5,)5"!&+

3%"/3%,$"+"2&2,#("13,/3%8&++&1&!&M&$41"YNB%" ,11")3&,+"36""+

&+ 1"2&+$23$",#+!),22,#"/&3%")&)2) "))2+! ,1+")242) +"15"2#413%"124//,133%&2%8/,3%"2&2B)2,?*,42"*,!")2%5"2%,6+&*/&1"!

)&*)23"* "))#4+ 3&,++!&+24##& &"+3$1,63%+!*,5"*"+3,# ,1+")

"/&3%")&) "))2&+BY_%&262"5&!"+38),6"1+4*"1,#2H*433"! "))2 M2HcIJN1")3&5"3,6&)!38/" "))2M2HcIcN&+3%" ,1+")"/&3%")&4*,#*,42"

%&*"12B,1",5"1? "+31&/"3)*,5"*"+3,#3%""/&3%")&4*3,3%" ,1+") "+31"62,#3"+!&2341"!&+2HcIJ "))2M&$41"YNB

7\6,1(23,$"3%"16&3%+,3%"131+2 1&/3&,+# 3,1?34*,41/1,3"&+\YM/\YN?&+

2/" &#8&+$)&*)23"* "))2BZV413%"1?3%"/1,3"&++3] ,+31,)27\&+

!&##"1"+3&3&,+,#3%" ,1+")"/&3%")&4*B"!4 "!)"5")2,#7\/1,)8)"!3,

&+ ,*/)"3"!&##"1"+3&3&,+,# ,1+")"/&3%")&) "))2?ZWM&$41"YNB2"+ ",#

+3]+!7\ ,4)!)2,31+2#,1*)&*)23"* "))2&+3,2(&+J)&(""/&3%")&4*BZV

!!&3&,+))8?7\1"$4)3"23%""7/1"22&,+,# 83,("13&+WXMWXN?6%& %&2

&*/,13+3#,1/1"2"15&+$"/&3%")&)23&)&38BZX83,("13&+WX&22"+3&+)&*)

"/&3%")&) "))2,#+&1&!&/3&"+32?ZYM&$41"YNB7*&+3&,+,#3%"*))"8"

*,42"*,!")?&+!4 &+$2H%/),&+24##& &"+ 8M2HcIJN?!"*,+2313"!+,1*)

!%"2&,+"36""+ ,1+")"/&3%")&) "))226"))?&+ )4!&+$ %+$"2&+

!"2*,2,*"2314 341"?+!)$"12/ ""36""+ "))2?ZZM&$41"YNB

(27)

X]

+2HcIJ*& "?3%" ,1+")"/&3%")&4*2%,62*,1"2"5"1"2&$+2,#,7&!3&5"231"22 3%+&+6&)!38/")&33"1*3"2BZ[%",7&!3&5" %+$"26"1" ,++" 3"!3,1"!4 "!

6,4+!%")&+$?"7/1"22&,+,#+,1*)#&1,)23*1("12?+!&+ 1"2&+$ ,1+") ,/ &38B "+ "?2HcIJ "))21"/1,)8*,1"242 "/3&)"3,,7&!3&5"231"223%+

3%"6&)!38/"2B

*/&1"!6,4+!%")&+$&2/1,)8)2,3(&+$/13&+3%"/3%,$"+"2&2,#BZ\

"#& &"+ 8,#3%"*"3)),/1,3"&+2"_M*/_N?6%& %&2+,1*))84/1"$4)3"!8 2H!41&+$ ,1+")6,4+!%")&+$? ,4)!)"!3, ,+!&3&,+2&*&)13,&+

*& "BZ]%42?3%""7/1"22&,+,#*"3)),/1,3"&+2"_&2/,22&)8)3"1"!&++&1&!&?

+!*8)"!3,&*/&1"!1"2/,+2"3, ,1+")!*$"?Z\M&$41"YNB+!!&3&,+

3,1"!4 "!)"5")2,#*"3)),/1,3"&+2"_?&+ 1"2"!/,/3,2&2,# ,1+")231,*) "))2&2&+5,)5"!&+3%"+,1*)6,4+!%")&+$&+2HcIJ*& "BZ^

%"1,)",# ,1+")+"15"),22&+!"5"),/*"+3,#&2+,3 )1&#&"!?M&$41"YNB

" 1"2"&++"15"262,2"15"!2,+",#2"5"1)2&$+2&+3%"/1,$1"22&,+,#

BZ_3%2""+!"2 1&"!3%3 ,1+")+"15"223&*4)3" ,1+")"/&3%")&)

$1,63%B[V,1+")"/&3%")&) "))2#413%"124//,13+"41&3""73"+2&,++!2415&5)B ,1!&+$)8?!" 1"2"! ,1+")2"+2&3&5&38&++&1&!&/3&"+3262#,)),6"!8

&+ 1"2"!5&3)23&+&+$,#3%" ,1+")"/&3%")&4*B[W+ 1"2"!23&+&+$62&+341+

1")3"!3,*,1"!5+ "!B

2&$+&#& +3 ,11")3&,+%2""+#,4+!"36""+&+ 1"2&+$2"5"1&38,#+!

%&$%"1+4*"1,#&+31, 4)1241$"1&"2BX]%"22, &3&,+1"*&+"!"5"+#3"1

!'423&+$#,1/3&"+3$"B

(28)

X^

.),-#(0)&0#(*.")!(-#-) (#,##--)#.%,.)*."387

&#'&-.'&& ##(3)((..)!,.#)(),-() &#'&

*&#--) )!.87#()'*&.# ,(.#.#)() ),(&*#."&#&&&-87

#(-/ ##(.!,)1."(')0'(.) &&-87,/&0&-) 3.)%,.#(CD5 .#(!*#."&#&-.#&#.38"(!-#(-')-)'-.,/./,1%("-#)(- .1(."&&-87#'*#,1)/("&#(!#()((.#)(.),/&0&-) '.&&)*,).#(-K<'*K=8<*)--#&=7,/-.#'/&.#)() ),(&*#."&#&

!,)1."/-) ),(&(,0&)--8<&&/-.,.#)(7,&(",#-.) ,)'', (-((#,%-&0&=

G8D8K8

13&#& &)3"1#)4&!6&3%,43/1"2"153&5"21"$"+"1))81" ,**"+!"!22&

31"3*"+3&+/3&"+326&3%B[X?[Y/" &#& ))8?3"12423&343"2 ,+3&+&+$

(29)

X_

%8)41,+& &!?[X?[Y+!!"7/+3%"+,)[Y1"24$$"23"!B ,6"5"1?+,234!&"2

"5)43&+$3%""##" 3,#!&##"1"+313&#& &)3"1#)4&!2,+%2""+#,4+!B +&1&!&/3&"+3231"3"!6&3%43,),$,422"14*"8"!1,/21"/,13"!1"!4 "!

28*/3,*2#1,*?&+ )4!&+$)"22"/&/%,1?/%,3,/%,&?+!#,1"&$+,!8 2"+23&,+BX\6"+38J2&7"8"2MWY/3&"+32N6"1"31"3"!6&3%2"14*!1,/2"&$%3 3&*"2!&)8#,136,*,+3%2B"24)32&+ )4!"!&*/1,5"!3"1#&)*23&)&38+!

,1+")"/&3%")&)&93&,+?+!1"!4 "!204*,42*"3/)2&,#3%" ,1+")

"/&3%")&4*B

G8D8CB8

%2""+31"3"!241$& ))86&3%312,11%/%8?[X*+&,3& *"*1+"

31+2/)+33&,+?[Z?[[/"+"313&+$,1)*"))1 ,1+")31+2/)+33&,+?[\J[^)&*),1 ("13,)&*))),$1#331+2/)+33&,+?[_?\V 4)3&53"!,1)*4 ,2"/&3%")&)

31+2/)+33&,+?\W+!("13,/1,23%"2&2241$"18B\X?\Y

G8D8CC8

%"/1"5)"+ ",#$)4 ,*&++&1&!&51&"2#1,*Z\K]Vb&+!&##"1"+31"/,132B\ZJ

\]+1"31,2/" 3&5"234!8,#W^V"8"2M_W/3&"+32N&+++!&+/,/4)3&,+6&3%

+&1&!&?W^BYb,#3%""8"26"1"!&$+,2"!6&3%$)4 ,*3#&123/1"2"+33&,+B

"+$"623%"+WVY*,+3%2M^B\8"12N&+3%"6%,)"$1,4/+!W[BW8"12&+

3%,2"6&3%$)4 ,*B41&+$*"+#,)),6J4/,#^BW8"12?!!&3&,+)\BX[b,#3%"

"8"2!"5"),/"!$)4 ,*B+3%"2415"8*,+$*"*"12,#3%"+&1&!&

,4+!3&,++3"1+3&,+)?$)4 ,*62!&$+,2"!35"1$"$"WYB\8"12B\\

(30)

YV

G8D8CD8

&+"3)B234!&"!3%"5&24)/1,$+,2&2&+\Z+!&++&1&!&/3&"+32MWX^"8"2N

!&$+,2"!6&3%$)4 ,*#3"13%"$",##&5"8"12B\^"+$"3!&$+,2&262 W[B_8"12+!3%"/3&"+326"1"#,)),6"!1"31,2/" 3&5")8&+*"+]B]8"12B33%"

"+!,##,)),6J4/?Y],#\Z/3&"+32M[]B^bN%!"23 ,11" 3"!5&24) 4&38)"223%+

YI\V&+3%""23"8"B%&138J3%1"",#WX^"8"2MX[B^bN%!"&3%"1+,)&$%3/"1 "/3&,+

,15&24) 4&38"04&5)"+33,)&$%3/"1 "/3&,+B,12"5&24),43 ,*"6222, &3"!

6&3%%&$%"1&+31, 4)1/1"2241"32")&+"?#*&)&)+&1&!&?+!%&$%"1+4*"1,#

, 4)1241$"1&"2B

G8D8CE8

+5"23&$3&+$[X"8"2,#,16"$&++&1&!&/3&"+32$"!ZK\Y8"12?!"+"3)B ,2"15"! 31 3&+X^M[YB^bNB\_!!&3&,+))8?XW"8"2MZVBZbN%!""+,/"13"!

#,1 31 3B%42?_ZBXb,#3%""8"2"&3%"1%! 31 3?,1%!$,+"3%1,4$%241$"18

#,13%&2 ,+!&3&,+B+)83%1""/%(& "8"2%! )"1)"+2"2B21"24)3?_VBYb,#

/%(& "8"2&+3%" ,%,13%! 31 3B8"7*&+&+$\V"8"2,#,1"++&1&!&

/3&"+32?1("3)B!&$+,2"!)"+2,/ &3&"2&+^XB[b,#"8"2%5&+$3%"&1,6+)"+2B]V 31 3"731 3&,+%!""+/"1#,1*"!&+YYBYb,#3%""8"2B,3))8?^^BYb,#3%"

"8"2"&3%"1%!)"+2,/ &3&"2?,1%!""+,/"13"!#,1 31 3B$"1+$"!#1,*

VBWK[X8"12&+3%"6%,)"$1,4/B+ ,+ )42&,+?3%",16"$&++!,1"+ ,%,13

%! ,*/1)"/1"5)"+ ",# 31 3+! 31 3241$"1&"2B,*"6%3%&$%"1 , 411"+ "&+,16"$&+2*8""7/)&+"!82)&$%3)8,)!"1/3&"+32&+3%&2$1,4/B 31 362!&$+,2"!3*"!&+$"3%1""8"12YZ+!WZ8"12]W&+36,!&##"1"+3 234!&"2,#+&1&!&/3&"+32B"+2,/ &3&"2/1"2"+3"!"1)&"1&+24'" 326&3%

,+ ,*&3+3$)4 ,*B]W,+$"+&3),1"1)8,+2"3 31 362!, 4*"+3"!&+#&5"

,#X\,16"$&++&1&!&24'" 32MW_BXbNB\_

(31)

YW

G8D8CF8

3%2""+24$$"23"!3%3 31 3!"5"),/2&+38/& )/33"1+&++&1&!&M&$41"

ZNB\_&123?!&2 1"3"/,23"1&,1/,)1,/ &38"5,)5"2M&$41"ZNB" ,+!)8?

/,23"1&,124 /24)1#)" (2,11!&))8231"(2//"1&+3%")"+2*&!/"1&/%"18 M&$41"Z+!Z?1"2/" 3&5")8NB%"1!&),/ &3&"2"73"+!3,61!23%"/,23"1&,1 /,)"6%&)"*&!/"1&/%"1)1&+$ ,*"2&+3,5&"6M&$41"ZNB&*4)3+",42)8?3%"

)3"13&,+2&+ 1"2"&+!"+2&38M&$41"ZNB!5+ "!)"+2 %+$"2 ,*/1&2"A 8")),6+!341&!)"+2+4 )"42M&$41"ZN?*341" 31 3M&$41"ZN?+!

%8/"1*341" 31 3M&$41"Z NB

+3"1&,1/,)1 31 3%2)2,""+!"2 1&"!&++&1&!&B\_?]X*))+3"1&,1+!

/,23"1&,1)"+2,/ &3&"2 ,4)!"/1"2"+3#1,*&13%B]X1"24*)8?3%"2"!,+,3

##" 35&2&,+&+*,23 2"2B

"+22/" &*"+2 04&1"!!41&+$ 31 3241$"18,#+&1&!&/3&"+32%5"""+

"7*&+"!%&23,/3%,),$& ))8+!8")" 31,+*& 1,2 ,/8B]Y%"&+5"23&$3&,+2 2%,6"!3%&++3"1&,1)"+2 /24)") (&+$+,1*)2314 341"B#1$&)"+!3%&+

)"+2 /24)"62#,4+!3,$"3%"16&3%!"$"+"13&,++!/1,)&#"13&,+,#)"+2

"/&3%")&) "))2B/24)13%& (+"22*8518 ,+2&!"1)8"36""++&1&!&

24'" 32?"&+$6&3%&++,1*)1+$"MWZKXWh*N&+2,*"?+!1"!4 "!Me^h*N&+

,3%"12B]Z" 1"2"!3%& (+"22%2""+22, &3"!6&3%&+ 1"2"!#1$&)&38,#3%"

+3"1&,1)"+2 /24)"!41&+$ 31 3241$"18B]Y?]Z

(32)

YX

3*#&*,)!,--#)() .,.#((#,##87-/.&*)-.,#),*)&, )*#.387*)-.,#),-/*-/&, &%-#(."&(-'#*,#*",387,#&-.,%-

#(."-',87,#&)*#.#-2.(.)1,-."*)-.,#),*)&-

'#*,#*",&,#(!**,-87&.,.#)(-#(,-#((-#.3873&&)1(./,#

&(-(/&/-87'./,.,.8 7"3*,'./,.,.8<&&/-.,.#)(7#,%-&

0&=

(33)

YY

G8D8CG8

8/,/)2&,#3%"* 4))43"&2 %1 3"1&23& #&+!&+$8,/%3%)*,2 ,/8,#

+&1&!&/3&"+32B[+,1*)2314 341",#3%"* 4)1#,5" ,+2&23"+36&3%

%8/,/)2&%2""+!"3" 3"!&+]_BVK^\BVb,#24'" 328#4+!,2 ,/8B[?][%"

)3"13&,+2&+ )4!"!) (,##,5")//"1+ "+!/1"2"+ ",#1"3&+)5"22")2 315"12&+$3%""7/" 3"!#,5")1"B][%,*2"3)B24$$"23"!$"+"1)23$&+$,#

* 4)1%8/,/)2&2"!,+,/3& ) ,%"1"+ "3,*,$1/%8B]\//)8&+$3%&2 )22&#& 3&,+,++&1&!&/3&"+32?#,5")%8/,/)2&62!&$+,2"!&+XY,#X[

&+!&5&!4)2M_XbNB]],1"2"5"1"%8/,/)2& ,11")3"!231,+$)86&3%1"!4 "!

5&24) 4&38B

)" 31,1"3&+,$1*2#1,*+&1&!&/3&"+32%5"2%,6+)3"13&,+2&+*',1&38,#

2"2B]^%"1" ,1!&+$251&"!#1,*)*,23+,1*)3,2"5"1")8&*/&1"!B,!+!

,+"#4+ 3&,+6"1""04))8##" 3"!B2 &))3,18/,3"+3&)26"1"*,231"!4 "!?

#,)),6"!83%"J65"?+!3,*&)!"1!"$1""3%"J65"B+!&5&!4)26&3%

*433&,+&+3%"/&1"!!,*&+,#3%"H$"+"%!$1"3"23!"/1"22&,+,#3%"

")" 31,1"3&+,$1*2&$+)2B

*))8")),6J6%&3")&/,&!)!"/,2&32&+3%"/"1&/%"1)1"3&+%2""+!"2 1&"!&+

+&1&!&B]_413%"1?2&+$)" 2"2,#1"3&+)!"3 %*"+3&+22, &3&,+6&3%$&+3 1"3&+)3"121"!"2 1&"!B1&,1, 4)1241$"18?5&31",1"3&+)+,1*)&3&"2?+!

4/%3%)*,2 ,4)!/,22&)8 ,+31&43"3,3%"2"!"3 %*"+32B 2",#

52,/1,)&#"13&5"1"3&+)34*,41%2""+1"/,13"!&++&1&!&B^V

G8D8CH8

/3& +"15"%8/,/)2&%2""+#,4+!&+WVB]b,#+&1&!&/3&"+32B^W,5")+!

,/3& +"15"%8/,/)2&*8"22, &3"!?43233&23& ))82&$+&#& +3 ,11")3&,+

%2+,3""+!"3" 3"!B+&)3"1)/)2&,#3%",/3& +"15"621"/,13"!&+,+"

(34)

YZ

+&1&!&24'" 3B^X+,3%"1 2"2%,6"!+,/3& /&3&+,+""8"+!*,1+&+$$),18

!&2 +,*)8&+3%",3%"1"8"B^Y

G8D8CI8

+&1&!& ,4)!"/13,# "13&+28+!1,*"2B+",#3%"2"&2?6%& %&+ )4!"2

&)*2:34*,41?+&1&!&?"+&3,41&+18+,1*)&3&"2+!*"+3)"31!3&,+B

%" 1,+8*&242"!"5"+&+ 2"26%"1"))#,41#"341"21"+,3/1"2"+3B E!")"3&,+F&+5,)5"2!")"3&,+&+H53%"$"+"1"2/,+2&)"#,1+&1&!&?

+!C53%"&)*2:34*,41/1"!&2/,2&3&,+$"+"B[

&))"2/&"28+!1,*"&2 %1 3"1&9"!8&)3"1)+&1&!&? "1""))137&?+!

,)&$,/%1"+&B^Z433&,+2&+3%"C$"+"%5"""+1"/,13"!3, 42"3%&2 ,+!&3&,+?^[?^\+!H*433&,+21"+,3!"3" 3"!BWV%"+&1&!&/%"+,38/"&+

&))"2/&"28+!1,*"!&##"12#1,*3%3&+ )22& )+&1&!&?6&3%&1&2%8/,/)2&

%1 3"1&9"!8#&7"!?!&)3"!/4/&)?, 2&,+))86&3%&1&!,)"+3& 4)1231+!2B 413%"1?* 4)1%8/,/)2&&2)"22 ,**,+B

+&1&!&%2)2,""+!"2 1&"!&+28+!1,*" ,*/1&2&+$+&1&!&?/3,2&2?+!

2)&$%3*"+3)1"31!3&,+B^]

$+"3& 1"2,++ "&*$&+$%22%,6+51&,421&++,*)&"2&+%&$%

/"1 "+3$",#H*433&,+ 11&"12B^^%"#&+!&+$2&+ )4!"!2"+3/&+")$)+!?

+!%8/,/)2&,# ,1/42 )),24*+!3%"+3"1&,1,1/,23"1&,1 ,**&2241"B ,6"5"1?+,+",#3%"1&++,1*)&3&"2 ,4)!"!&1" 3)8)&+("!3,/13& 4)1 H*433&,+B^_)2,?&+)1$"#*&)86&3%+&1&!&+!!")"3&,+!,6+231"*

,#H?3%" "1"1)&*$&+$62+,1*)?&+ )4!&+$/1"2"+33&,+,#3%"/&+")

$)+!B_V

%&)!1"+6&3%+&1&!&1")3"!3,H*433&,+2 ,4)!%5"4!&3,18/1, "22&+$

!"#& &32?&+ )4!&+$!&##& 4)3&"2&+), )&9&+$2,4+!+!4+!"123+!&+$2/"" %&+

Referanser

RELATERTE DOKUMENTER

The speed of the striation patterns along an array can be related to the target speed, taking account of the target’s track with its offset and course in relation to the

Analyses of 16S rRNA gene copy yields found that bacterial numbers decreased with increasing humidity, peaked during spring for air sam- ples (Additional file 1: Table S4; Figure

Anyone interested in how a camouflage pattern on a given target performs in terms of detection by human observers has to do an accurate evaluation of the scene and a

A styrofoam mannequin was dressed up with the two suits, one at the time, and the two camouflaged targets were then recorded in 6 various natural backgrounds (scenes) in Rhodes in

This research has the following view on the three programmes: Libya had a clandestine nuclear weapons programme, without any ambitions for nuclear power; North Korea focused mainly on

The dense gas atmospheric dispersion model SLAB predicts a higher initial chlorine concentration using the instantaneous or short duration pool option, compared to evaporation from

On the other hand, the protection of civilians must also aim to provide the population with sustainable security through efforts such as disarmament, institution-building and

Based on the above-mentioned tensions, a recommendation for further research is to examine whether young people who have participated in the TP influence their parents and peers in