• No results found

Gjenstand, verk, bilde. Kunstteori og tingestetikk på 1900-tallet

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Gjenstand, verk, bilde. Kunstteori og tingestetikk på 1900-tallet"

Copied!
269
0
0

Laster.... (Se fulltekst nå)

Fulltekst

(1)

!

"# $

(2)

% &

' ( ) * & + , , - - - . ( - , ,

(3)

!

" # $ %&! $ ' ( ) ( !

* +

! ( ,

-

! %

. " - #

/! # -' & %* ! ! , 0

1 - %0 2 + 2 , 2 &

3 - & ) # 4 - 5 ! ( 6 *

$ 7 8 2 -

+

! !

. $

! + $0

9

: $ 4;

6 << <==>

(4)

<

(5)

!

"# $$

% & ' ($

)

($ ( * " $" (* +,

*" $ (' # ( (( " $ $ +

$ * -, ++

($ ( * $ $ $ +.

/ "(( "% $ & +0

($ ( * % $ ( '$ +1

$ ( $ $ ($" ( +)

# (# '$ % (' ##($ +

' ($$ $ (' & *"(

"# $$ +

' ($$ $ (' & *"( $ *

2 3 "* ( "% % ' # $2 1

($% ' $ ( * ' ($ $ (# $ ( " .

$ * 4 ($ ( * '%"( ( '$ .

($$ $ (' #" " ..

% & 3 "* '' .0

$ ( ($ (' ' ($$ .1

($ (' ' $ ( (* 4 5 * $ 6 .)

'(' (4 $ ( (* ( & ' ' "(* -

2/ ($* 2 ' $ ( (* -+

6

-

"# $$

" 7 " 8/ $34 "** * $

0

* 0+

59:" 4 $ % 0-

" ( &; ( 0

< ( * $$ 3''( " 0)

* (' $ ($ $ '' ,

(6)

.

3 = 3 $

($ $ (' % ' $ .

" 8/ $3 ' ($$ $ (' & *"( 0

"# $$ +

" $ ' ($% ' $( $ # *

)

% ' $ 1

#; (*> $ * $ 1+

<? $ %? 1.

( * ># "% %? 1-

$ *&"$$ 10

( " $ *" (* 11

$ % '* (( % % ' $ ),

( ' ($$ )

$"&3( '' $ '' * $ ' ($$ ).

($ ( )-

" ( $ )1

"# $$

@" $ "* ( " (# ( (% '

,

$ & $ "& (' ,0

" $ "$ % ($ ' ,1

($ (' ( $ ,

A# "% $ ( * $ +

/ *" $ ##%>' -

($% ' $ ( * ( $ 0

$$ 2' ($ ( * > '" "'$ 2 1

$ *# "( "'$ % (* B +

%( $ 4 ($ $ ''

+-

/ 6

' ( (*"$ * *$"

+

%"' ' ($ ($ (' ($ ** ( +)

/ ($$ $ (' ,

% (($ ( " (* 4 " $( ; = *" $ ( * #" " *

" (* *" -

$ " # (# '$ % $( 2(3($ * *2 0

5"* " (7 "8* 1

" ( " (* ( * # *( .,

" $ $ "% & * .

" (* $ % ( " (* .+

$ *" (' '$ ..

(7)

-

8 ($ ;( ( " (* .-

" (* *" ( * (%"' ' ($ ($ .

+

A > ## "% ' ($ 4 7 " ( * &

-

( * 2($"3 2 -.

$ (# ( & '' -0

' $ " $ # * & (* -1

($ '' 8' ($ 0,

$( '' 8$ ($ %? ( 0

"$ " $ $ 0.

'' 8' ($% ' $ 0

( * $ "$ " B 0)

2/ ( $"( " $ $2

'( $ (' ' ($ ($ -

( * & 0

"$ % $ $ ( $(" (' "&$ 1

< ' ($ $ '' ' $ " &" ( ($ $ ''B ($ $ (' &"

' ($ # $

1

C 4 ($% ' $( (" $( ($ $ '' 1.

($ $ (' &" "%" $ " 1

($ $ (' &" ( * ' ($ &" 11

6 ($" ( ;( $ 1)

26 ($" ( $$ $2 )

;** ' "&$ )+

($ $ (' &" # $ ' ($ )

( '( "% % ' # $ )0

< ' $ ( * (3 '' )

$ ( ;( % ))

.

" % ' $ ' $ '($B

+,

2 $ " (* 2 +,

$ '($ ( * ' **" +,-

$ ' ' $ ( * +,1

$ (' & '( "% ' $ '($ +

"' $ '" (' ("** +

-

* (' ' ($$ B

+

D / $$( (' #$ " *" "( ++,

/ $$(E ## "% " 8/ $3 +++

'' ( " $ "$ % & * # ++.

(8)

0

"' &" ' ($$ ++0

" ( * & * (' ($ B ++)

*"$ % $ $ * $ & * ;( $ + ,

* (' ($" ( B +

2/ ($* 2 ($" ( + .

* * $ + -

"** * * *" (* + 0

" ( * *" (* + 1

* ' ($ + )

%( $

% (' &$ ' ($

+.

A ; ($ +.

##($ ( $ $ $ (' % (($ $ +.0

" ( & $(' ( +-,

$$ "$ ($

+-

(9)

!" # $ %

% # &

' " ( " "

# ) "

! '

( !! # * +

+' + +' ! '

, ( # & !

' ! !" ! '

!! '

' ! # * '

!" '

! , $ ( #

' "

% % # * &

- ! ' ( '

' $ ' !" " "

. $

( #+/ ( 0

" + + "

" !! $ # & ,

' ' !

! # ) , " " $

$ ' ( #

) #

) ) ) 1 ' !!

' 22 #

/* & 1 +34 5 + 6 7/8'

* 9 : #;1 ' 3 #<# 22 /7#

(10)

=

> " $ # ?

$ ! !! #

3 '

$ ' " " #

# < " (

" + +' " " ,

' " + +#@A" ! !"

' !" '

" ' " ( " ( '

" !" # * ( ' +( +

" ' " #

3 ' ' #

? $

# & $ !!

$( " !! ' !

! ! #B3 ' $

! ' !

!" ! !

( '

# ) ! !

' " " !"# > !

( ! % '

! '

# > $ "

' ! $ C " '

" + +#

? + " +7'

' #

@) ( D 1 ! " ' A E F 2 #

B) G D (1 +< + ' * 3 : #;1 "

# # ' ) ==# G " !" ! ! ' - +

-H 1 < $ ' ! +#

7C & * 1$ % & " ' ( '

% 6 8' IJ B #

(11)

. & !" 722 (

+ + " '

! ! !

" !

' !" ! # +& ' !! +'

& ' " " ( # &

' + !!' ' 6K8 !! +='

#

! + + '

$ + ! +' G L M

#

3

! ' ( '

+ $( +# < '

$ !" ( ' , "

# &

0 ( #

( ( '

( ' " $! !"

! # " =22

1 ) I

' + ! + 1 A" '

A ' + $( $ " ' !"

" #+ 2< "

( " ! ' , $

# & (

' !! "

" " " !! ' !" #

& < G (1 ! ) " * !

' ( @' B#

= # = #

< 1 +9 3 N+ 6 @8' * 9 : #;1 "

% % ) + ' 3 #<# 22 #

2 I 1 + ! 1 & A M + 6 @8' I 1

# " ) ' ' <4 = 77#

(12)

2

)

' !" 22

+ +# > I 0 '

! % % % % (

!" " ( # & !!

' # 3 !

I + ! +'

! !"

+ !! $ +# ) ( " & D ! -? !

( - / =2'

!" # 3 "

, ! 1 &

" !" " ! !!

#

" !" '

( !" " # &

" !" (

( !! # '

# ' ( !"

! + +# < !

! " ' !"

" # $ !" " +

+' "

1 " !! 22 $(

& D )# + +

' ( ' + + % # &

# I 1 -< & ! 3

5 - 6 = 8' I 1 # " ) ' ' <4

=#

I !! + E ! ! '

E E E (' !

E ( ' ! ' ! #+

I 1 +H M & H +' ( ' * ( < O ( : #;1

, - # ' D ==# ) ' ! -&

/& D !1 -? ! +# ( + 6 =28' . ( / '

D < # /#

(13)

" ! " ( (

#

> " " $ # <

! #

" '

( # *

$ !" " + +' ! , $ !" . + " " $

3 K+# @ +3

+ B' ' 1 +P

" $ ' ! +# 7P

" % % ( '

9 # +I C ! + %

% $ 1 +3

, " +#

) !! $( " $

' " "

' ! 22

* # )

!" " ' " $

# 0 ' $ =2'

# < ! 0

# P

!#

- , - * * ' ( "

- -' # * !!

- - =' ! , - - '

@ 1 6 =28' Q 22 @2#

B 1 +R 3 # E ) E : ; C ( < ( : ;-

* 9 : #;1 " % % ) + ' 3

#<# 22 ==#

7

9 1 +I C ! + 6 / 8' 0 ! % +

# % ' 3 #<# 72#

= ' 1 !# # #

# @2#

(14)

+ +# 2

* , " + + (

% # $ ! #

!" " $

% $

, + ! ( +# ) , ,

#

$ ' 9 '

( !"

" !" # <

' '

# -G +' '

+ , 0 ! 0 ! $ #- /I "

'

, " " ( !! # *

, !" ! " ! '

+ " +#

3 , $ ' (

' ! # A"

!" " ' + +

!! $ ' ( $ (

# ) $ + + ,

+ ! +# *

" $ + ! ! $ +' ,

( !

" ' ! ' ! "

2 # #

' +R 3 K+' !# # =B#

& ! * 9 9 : #;1

" % % ) + ' 3 #<# 22 #

/ ' 1' !# # 7#

(15)

/

# *

' "

I ' , # 3

'

+! +N

& '

! " ! !"# ) # &

" # %'

' " @&

" !

' " 1 & !! !"

22 ' (

! ! # I $

* + ! ! +#

+ !" ' '

" +# B *

$ + + ( ' (

' #

S

I % %

' +

' +# 7& !" "

$ !" " , + +# &

" # )

$ !

! " ! '

" $ # &

@* 9 ! * " # ) +P +'

9 : #;1 3 #<# 22 #

B* 1 ) 0 6 =@8' <4 @ /2#

7 I 1 +P +' # " ) ' ' <4 =

@# I 0 ( ( '

( #

(16)

@

$ " " $ ' #

& #2 % * 0 "! '

! % ' $

$ $ "

% % # < ! 22

$ 0

$ " % " * %

# % " ! !" " # &

' !!

! " ! + + ! #

% ! ' %%#

& $ 22 ' !" " (

! " '

% # " '

( ' ! ! % %

* # P ! ! % + ( ( + %

$ $! ' $ ! '

( ! !

" # > !

< < (' <

* 9 '

#

C $ "

% %%' +! + !! $

+ ! + :I ; !" " '

!! ( !" 22 #

) %

!" ! %

) & * ' !# #

(17)

B

!" =22 "

#

) (

' " < & ! '

" " + +

!!

' ! " # )

* %% !

! % # & (

3 # ? , " "

" !! + +' ## #

) '

" !!

! # G $

' !

# G $ "

' 4 %

# & ! $ ! '

( # & '

! ' $ " !

( " $ ! !

'

+ + #

(18)

7

(19)

! " # $ %"

# # # # &

# '(

)* +,,- . // / /

0 1 " 0 0 2 1&3 . // 2# *

4 / 12# - /15 / #

/ ! / & . // #442 / # 1% / - 1

& 2 / # " # / $*

$ 0 / # #$ #/ # # "$ * # 2# #/ 2# /

$ & 2# . // * # #/ #44

#44 / # 2# " & 1 " # #$ 2# "$ 16

#/ * &

. " 1 0 0 2 1 $*

/ # #44 #/ 4 / & . // $ / 4

$ $!0 / # * / #/ $ / 4 //

1# 2# - /1 4 / " &

4 / / / # $ 0 #/

#44 / / & 2# - / * * # 2# #/ *

$ 0 / 7 2 4* / 20 & # . // $ / #44 #/

# * 4 $ / # / 2# ! * " $

#/ # "

# 05

8 0 ++9 +:&

3 . // 5 1 ; < $ 1 2" & & +(, (&

6 . // 5 )2" / +' = #4 5 >< " /

? / $ 2 @ # 5 ;" % " A 1 #/ # // B &C5

! " # $ % & 2" & & 3,,3

6 &

(20)

:

(21)

+ 4

2# "

D E D ::' 0 2# # ' * 7 $ ! #/

2 0 ! ' $ ! ( #

" / # # 2# ! 4* * 1 " " #4 1&9

4# # # " #/ 2# E D $ # * 1

1& * E D / " #/ 2! 4* * *

" 2# 2# 4 & . " 0 / # #

2# " & 2# # 2# / * " /5 1 2# #

# 2# # " #44/ * / / "

$ 1& E D 1 *4 1

1 / / 4* #/ " "

/ / 2# $ #/ 2# " 2 1&(

E D " * # " # # * " 2#

!0 & . * " $" $ 2

D / $ " 0 7 2# ) #

/ ! $!0 / * $" #/ # &

1F " 2# * /* " 1 0 E D "4"$

2 / &'F " # E D $ # 2 2 * $ 0

D # * * $ #44 # / 2 # #44 !0

! &

E D 2 # #2 * 4 / # " / 2# # # 1 "

" 1 #/ # / $ # 1 " #44/ 1 1 1

1 " * 1 #/ & F * 2# 2 " 12! " * 1 #/

# 1 # 0 1 / E D # $

" " 44 2 / 2# !

2 & 2# # $ 2# * " / " 0

9 D E D 5 >F "D $ 1 0 2# # ! ' $

! ( G : 3H* ! ' $ * + ! % G ::'H

" / ++6 :&

( D E D 5( * , G ::'H I D +:: 9(9&

' E D - # < 5- %! $# / 3,, ,(&

(22)

3,

#/ # 2# 4 " # #

4* 1 # 7 #/ # " /1 # - 1 #/

/1&

E D 4 4# # * / 4 1 " " 1 #

1 /1 # $ / 2# " /*

" * & " " 2# ' " #/ 0 !2 #

2# ! / 2 / # 0 $ / 4 . & E D

1 " " 1 # #/ 4 #22

# $! 4* # # 4# 2# // & . 2! # #

2" # $ / # # 4* ! " #/

# # #/ / 1 " " /# 1 ! 4 27

#44 !0 / & # / " 2# $

#$ #/ 2# / / # &

2# # # " #/ # E D 4*4 / #

" 2 / 4* 4 #$ # 2# 2" / #

" /# " #/ # " 2! / " #/ # * / #

+,,- & ) #$ " $ 2# / #/ " #44 / / / 4* / /& #

E D # 12 0 /1 #/ 12 /1 # # 4 " !

1 4 4 #$ 1 14 #$ # 1&:

%* $ ,,- 2# $ 1 " " " 1 # E D

/ / 4 4* " #/ ! 7 / //

#/ # & " #/ #

# # $" * & " $" 7 $

2# # # / #

1 ! " 1& " #/ * # " #4 # 4* #/ #2

# # # # 7 ! 4 /" & $

" 4* ! # #/

* $ / 4 # # " # " # 0 4

E D >F "D J> #4&D & 6&

: $ & &

(23)

3

/ / ! $ & " # " 7

2# ! # * / ! " " / &

" 2 # #2 2 * # ,,- # 2# ! 4* * 0

" # " * 2 2 & " #/

" 2* 4 7 # 0 / 2# ! & 1

2# "2 1 # * K 4 #/ # * K # 2 1

4 2# "2 1 # * K * 2 27 2# # #/ /# &

# $! 1 1 . ) B +,C " 2# ! *

$ / # 1 # 1 ! #/

& # * " / 7 4 2 2# 0 4 /

#44 " / 2# 7 #/ # * " $ &

F ! # " 0 $

2# *4 / # 2 4 / $ / 4 " &

# # " 4 # #

1 # " # # 1 #/ 1 # 1 $ 2" #

# " $ " / $ / 4 . $ #44

7 2# *4 / & # 0 & = D 4 *

1 /# " #44 * #44 0 / # " " # #

" " / K 4 2 # # " " / * # "

2 / * $0// $ # # # # 4

2 # 2! . 1+ 4 4 " / #

/ / 4 #$ # 2# *4 / 2" $ /

# # ! = D 1 " /# 1& , " " / #/

" / 2 2 ! # " #/

/ /&

E D / / 4 4* " "

/ 4 # / / 4 #$ #

+ # 0 & = D 5 1 22 D" 0 #2 1 ' / & ) $" / ++: 9 &

, $ & 9,& F # ! 2 #/ 4 / # #/ /

" # 2# # 1$ 1 1F # 2 / L

2 / #/ " $ / 4 1&

(24)

33

$ 2 / 2 # #2 2! / &

* / 1 /# 1 #/ 4 / 4 #

# $ / 4 " $ 4* ,,- #/ 2# ! * ! 4*

* & / # " / D

"#44 ! / 4 #$ 4 / # "$ #/ #$ #/ 0 2

#/ 4# & #442 " # / 4 # #

#/ # / ! & D D / 2# " / * "

7 14 #/ " 4# 1 * 0 # 2# // # # /

#44 * # # 12 # M / /

/ $ $ 2" 1&

# # # $ #

2 # #2 / 2# / # # #

4 # # " * # # * #44 #/ 4

#44 * / * 2 4 #/

/# & 2 ! # # # / /

2# / 5 $ # " # / * / "

" & 3 / * # # 2# // #/

# * 7 $ $ 2 / & .

$ " 7 2 / #/ # # $ "#44 ! / 1 / 4*

1 6 / * 4 $ & / " #

# 2 * $ " #/ # " 7 4* # " & <

8 " 4 / 5 1 "2" / # 2# " #

# $ # " &1 9

/ #2 # " ,,- # # 1

" $ / 4 1 #44 #& ) " / 4* +(,- #

D D / 5 1N ?" N-2 / G +:H D / 5. 0

" / + : + &

3) 44 O D#" -O $ #/ -O"D D05 1 ,' 1

! 2 G + :H P Q# +:: &

6 # ! / 5,' 3" - 4 R " ++' 6,:&

9< 8 5 - . 2 G + +H .

8 /5 5 ' ( I D ++: 3:&

(25)

36

1 " # 0 1 ( # # # $ / 3,, * /

4 * " (, $ /0 4* 1 * " $ / 41&

$ /0 0 $# / / #22 / 5 " $

2 2 20 / / / #44 / #/ " #/ " 0

# 2# $ /0 * $ #44 # " #/

# " & / # / #/ # 0 2# " 2 &

/ $ / 4 " # $ " #/ # # 2# 1 ! " 1

2 / $ & # / 4 # 2# $ " /

@ 8 " / , * !0 / * (,&

# # #44 # 1 * " $ / 41 * /

" $* 2! #/ (, 7 4* 4 #$ *#/ #/

* # 2# / $ / 4 # L "

2" " / / # $* / / # #/ * & / ! K

/$ / 4 " K # # # / #/ !

0 " # 2 & " #/ * #/ * # &

" $ # * / / / - #/

2# 4 #$ # # #/ # & . $7 1 * " $ / 41

* 1 1 / * / ! # # # 2# 4 / #

#/ 2 #/ 2 # #2 L

2# / # (, #/ 2# 1 * " $ / 41 " / ! #

! 44# # S # #/ # # #/ - " #

/ / & 2 $ " #442 / #/

$ / $ L 0 7 // / #

/ # * 22 # # " $ / 4 #/ " $ / 4 2#

* " /* * # * / $ " /* # #/ * * # #

& # 2# 5 F* $ / 4 # " #44 " *

$ / 4 # " & . 4* +,,- $ # " / # * " /* * 4* *

# # " 2 * # 4"

# " ' #44 # #/ # /

( 4# / ! 2# " / 0 0 ) "

2 +( T(3 # 5. * #D # ++'&

(26)

39

$ / 4 # " & # / # (, / ! # !0 0 / $ /

S # #/ # # #/ / "$ #/ &

# # #/ 2# / # (, #

* 2# & * * $ / " # 2# / # " #

/ / # /* * 2# / $ / 4 # & " $

* # $ # # / $ / 4 #/ 22 /

2# # / #/ # 2# # / & 4*$ #4

/ 4 44 # /2# / / # # " / 2# " $ / 4

#/ 0 4 # " * * $ / " /

0 0 4* 2# / # (, 2# * / #

E D " " 2# * 2# / " # 4 #$ #/

1 " /# 1&

O # 2# * ! #44 # 2# / # (, / * 2

" 4* ,,- $ /0 * $ 2# * # # /

/ ! 1 " 1 4* 0 . & $ !

2# * 1 1 " $$ 8 "@N 1 ' 6 7

8 9 B ! " " 2 4 44C 2 9'& .

/ # * 1 ! " 1 # 2# /

# ' #/ ) 4 # EN: :

$ .; 3 - '

: 2 :( # / &

" # # 2# * # #/ # 2" / &

# 2 # 2 # 2 $ / "

#/ " &

F 4 * 2# 4* ,,-

7 / / " & 2# " /* " * / <

# 2# # # #/ *

' $ & 992&

-) )" 5 >< 1 #44 / # E 8 D & & B &C5&

! ' 3$ ' ' -" $ ' " / 3,,( (9+&

(27)

3(

$ ! # 2# # & # 0 4 / 2 "

/ #/ 0 " / ! 2 4 4 7

" #/ ! 4 4 / # # & . "

/ # # # / #/ & " = *

2# / " #/ ! / $ $* 2

* / # # #/ / # # $*

#/ * * * * # 2# &

* $ K " * " 2 K * # #

" # # #/ 2 4 * 2# / #

(, $ / 4 " )

#/ 2# " / * 2# * " # # / # 2# 4 / "

* # #/ 2# 4*& $ / 4 / 2# / " $

$ # S # 2# / #/ * # #

) #/ # & # 1 * " $ / 41 2 #/

2# / # (, " # # 2 " 2# 4 #/ 2# // 2#

0 2 / #/ # #2 // ! /

! / 2# * 2* ) &

2! / / $ / " 0 1 * " $ / 41 /

2# * " # 2" / # # 2 4# / #

# #/ 4& $ " # 4 # * /

" / / $ " # / #/ / / 4 #4 / &

. / * // 12 / ! / 1 $7 " *

# $ / 4 & #

# # 2 #44 0 / K " # # "$ 2 / ! / 2

" #/ / / K # " 4 4 * * /

& / # $" " #/ # $ / 4 # # 4*

,,- 1/ " // 1& :

" " / * # ! 2# / # (,5 ,,- 1/

# 1 " #44 0 / 1/ # 1 # 4 / $ #/

: $ & (3+-(965 1 % " /" / ? D < $ / 22 1&

(28)

3'

$# / / #22 / & # / # (, $ /

" $ / 4 #/ / " " 2 #/ "

# # * / $ 2# #/ " 2# & #44 * #/ *

# # #/ #44 # $ " " #

$ / 4 #/ 2# 22 / 2# # & ! #/ $ 2# #

2 * # # 2# / # (,& # *

2# / # 4 " # #

/ 2 # # #$ 2# 4* #/ # #$ 0

" #/ " 0 &

" " E D # / 4 # # $ 4* :,,-

/ / 2 ' # / # 0

$ 0 " " 2 ,,- & + # & < D # #2

# # " # 2 / " 4 " $

$ " $ " $ # / !0

#44 # #/ " " / * / ! & 1 " K

# 7 < D K 4 * # #

#/ / 4* !0 1&3, " # / # $

" #$ / #/ * / " 4 2" - /

$ # # 2# / # 2# 1 2# #/ # 1&3

# # " 4 " / < D 2# #

" * 1 " / 4 * 4* #/ * !0 2! /

" *4 # # * / #/ 2 /

# / / $ 1&33 " 0 / ' #/

& < D 1 2# $" # "

# * 2# 2" # &136 " 2 /* # #

// 4* &

+ <# 2/ / D 53 . > 2" & & 3,,( ((- (&

3, $ & 6&

3 # & < D 5! ;' 3 (

- G ((H " / ++( 3,&

33 # & < D 5! . , G '9H - #

< 5 1 / ? 1 - %! $# / 3,, ' &

36 D #4&D & 6&

(29)

3

. $7 * 2! #/ 2 0 / / #/

# # / 4" 2 / " # # 4 4 4*

/ # #44 !0 & < D / /

$ 2 / 04 " $ / " 4* 4

& " # 4 # # " #/

&

2 #/ # " 4 / / #

$ / 4 " # # / #

/ " // ) 4 # E& . $ K " K

$ # 12" / 1& 1 2# * / 1 2

1 / 4* 0 2# * / 1&39 * #/ " # 2 " 2#

$ " / 4 4 #/ ! & " /

// "$ # . # < D #/ /

2 $ ! 20 2# & / "

2# / "2# / / #/ # & . " 0

* " 4* 2# # / # / #

$ /0 * # 2 # / # / / &

# # < D 2 4 / / / # !

/ / / # %&<& & . / # # " # $ &

" 4 " # # 2 " . / # # 1 #

2 !0 2 1&3( # . / # 2 # #2 #/ #

# # 4 # / # * 2* #

// " / #/ / # *

44 " #/ /* 2# & " 2# . /

" / / 4" 2# 0 #/ 2# * / 1 "$

39 # E )" #4&D & (9:&

3(%&<& & . / 5 ) ? # # #/ % G :, H -O"D D05 ( G ++9H

2# ++' 9(&

(30)

3:

# / # * #/ / "$ 1&3' 2# . / # *

1/ $ 2 #$ &13

# . / #/ < D 4 2# #/

/ -#44 " & 8 // 4# # / 2

# 4# - / #/ 2# 2# 14 #/

" 4# 1 & 2# / 2# #/ #44

2 * 1 " " 1 # ! / 4* /# #/

4 # ,,- 2 &

. / # / 4* :,,- /# 2 #

4 #$ #/ $ # * $ " # #$ 2# 4 & $ #

#/ * * $ " # # 4 &3:. / #/

/ " 4* 4 2 # 1 / 4*

1 #/ 2 # / " 2#

$" $ " & " 2# . / #$ / 2# / * /

#/ # * # # $ / # " 4 #/

2 # #2 "4 &

* . / $ " # # 12# / / 1 #

" # 4 S $ 0 / " # " $ /

/ / # * $ #44 # # -4 K

#$ & " " $ #/ 2" $0 # #/

$ #44 0 * 7 / 2 / #/ 2 / &

G :3,-3 H $ . / * 1 #

" 13+ # / $ # " / & )# /

1 * / " / 1&6,

3' %&<& & . / 5: ;' & G :3,T3 H . / 5& ?@?? " / +

('+&

3 = D #4&D & (,& / / 2! / / 2# # . /

&

3:F 2 . / " # # $ / 4 $ 2 D )# #5 A

, P . +:3&

3+%&<& & . / 5: ;' & G :3,T3 H = D #4&D & (3&

6, $ &

(31)

3+

/ " # / $7 * $ /

2# * " # 2 # #$ 4 0 / &

#/ * " $ # # * $ " # 2 / #

/ " / / 4# # $

1#$ 1 2# $ #/ * " 0 2# # # * # #44 #/

" # " / #$ #/ 2# ! &

)# # # 2# " 4* 4 2 / #/ 2

0 * 1 / " / 1&

) 4 " / 2# / # $ / - #/

$ " / " # 4 / - #/ #4 # " & . /

-O"D D0 $ # # 1 / # " 0

#/ # * / # " " * 2 " 1&6

. E D :,,- / 2 1 1 4*

/ 2# / / 4 # /

" # $ 1/ 2 #$ 1

# #/ " / ! #44 " 2# "2# / / " &

0 # $ ! " $ " :,, 44# #

2# / # 2# / *4 $ / & F *

# 2# * # # # " / " "

2 ) $ 0 / * $ 2# #/ #

/ #/ / 4 #2 #/ /& # " 0 2# 4

0 " 2# 6 ( & 2 $ $ /

(9 < D # $ ! & "

" #/ " 44# #

! # / * 2 -

4 # & 8* ) 4 # " / #/ 2 # #2 . 22 $ 4*

/ # * # 2# &63% #

. " / # # $ 5 # * 2 2#

2 # # *4 $ / " # &

6 D0 *#4&D & (&

63 D #4&D & '+ #/ ,& #/ * 8 / 5 ' 4*#4&D & : 2&

(32)

6,

2 5 @ # ( 3

(33)

6

F 2 / " 2 4* 0 $

2 # # 2 /" " * / 2

/" # / 27 # #

# * & " / ! / / # " #4 #/

# #/ 7 7 2 & ' #/

$ / # # / # / 0 & #/ 2 -

" /* $ / $ " # //

2# $ 4 4 # # #/ 2 * / /

#/ / & 8 ! " # #/ " 4 # 4 2

# $ 2 &

. # " #/ # 4! * #

#/ # # 4 4 22 # # # # #/

# & $ " 4 $*

0 / #/ * / 2# #/ /" # / &

" / ! 2! / 0 2" 4 2" &

#44 # # $ /" / # # " 2# "

/ # #44 # 4 4 #/ / &

# # 0 / * 7 / $

# * * # 2 # # // / #/

& " / $ #

2 # # / 2 / " 2 / #

2# 2# 2 # &

F * " #/ 6 ( 2# // #

2 # 0 $ / $ 4 $ # "

#44 !0 #/ * / # & " $ / / /

$ 7 " / #/ * 7

* # 2# # / /& " $7

# #/ / < D 2# #

. & # " #/ $ " # # #

2! / / / # 2#

/ 27 # 6 ( #44 / 2 &

(34)

63

F * " " #/ 1 " " " 1 # " " / 4* :,,-

#/ * " 2# # #4 4 & )* :,,- #

2# $ " " / # / #/ /

# # " # # #/ 4 /

#$ 2 & / * 2# * " # # " # 2

2# / $ / / 2 #

!0 "2# / / " / " / 2# #

/ ! ! & " $ $ # # 2

2 # # # #/ - # " # 7 4 4 #

# # # $" # &

" K 1 " " 1 K #44 # /

1% " P 1 1 " 166 # 4 #/ " 0 #

/ 1 # # 0 169 2# # & / # /

# %" #/ * # 2# ! 4 2

" #4 & # // 4* # 4* "

/ / # $ # 1 $ # " 2 " 4" 16(

20 # /& #/ #/ # /

2# // * 4 #/ $ # " &

" * / ! # 14 #$ 1 2# #

# 0 / 2# // 4 4* # 2# !

D # # . / # # 1 $ # " * 1&

/ # / / 4

/ " // / 7 / 2# " " " # * / #/ # 2

1 " " 1& " 2 2# / * * #

#44$" *4 # # # 2# ! &

2# // " # " #22 / " / # #/ $ $ #

66 # U" 5, , ) $# +:+ -3,&

69 $ &

6( I / 8"$ 5 1V$ / 8 /" / / / P? / A 1 G + 6H &

2" & & +:+ 9&

(35)

66

/ # ! / 4* 2 # #2 # #/

# *4 * /&

* # 4* 4 # " # # # 2# / #

(, " * * ' # 2# // $ $0/ / #/ # $

" 4 #/ 2" 0 !4 * / ! &

$ 2# / # " #/ * " 0 #/

" $0// #44 # 2# / # # # 2

#/ 4# ! 2# 4 & $7 1D# #

1 # $ / 2 # // * 2#

4 $ # 2# 0 #/ 1 / 7 1 #/

" $ 4 # / 2# / / " #

# 1 " 1&

* " 2# * # # #$ # 4 " 2#

$ 0 * $ # $ 7 " # 2#

4 # " / #44 "

2# * 2* 0 / 4 4* " / & # / 2# *

/ # 2 " 2 # 2# / #44$0// / $

$ # 2# / #/ & 2 # #2 # K / #

# 4 K # 2# ! * 4 #$ #/ $ #

" / / 4" #/ " / 2# *4 #/ " /

* $ # # $ / " ! / #

* 2* 2# 0 0 /&

* 7 # . // "

1 0 0 2 1& 1 0 / 1 /

# #44 # 1 " $ / 41 $ 1# / / " 1

# " # 4 #/ // # / # $ 0 ! / 4*

1 /# 1 4 #/ / 4* 0 & /

" # 2# # 5 F $ "

" 2 " / 2# * $ *

4 / 4* # & 2# #

(36)

69

# # * $ / " #/ 4 #$

2# 1 " 1& . / #44 / / #

# #/ M # $ / # 4* & F /

/ 2# / # " # # # # K 2# " " /#

# 1 " 1 K 2! # 2 2 / # &

# / 2# / 4*4 4* 2 * 2# "

2# 4* 1 " 1 4 # / / ! * 0

1 1 2# 1 1 2# /* " $ #/ " # " &

" # 2# # # 4 # " *

S # # 1 " $ / 4 1 #/ 2# # # (,& #44 *

#44 2 / 2 " #44 # 4* *

#44 * $ / 4 2# / " (,&

" # 2# # $7 # " / #/ # # / 2#

0 4 / & # " # 2# "

$* # 2! #/ $# / $ 0 /& " #

2# # # " / # " #4 - / ! #/ * " #4 - 4 /

* / / 4* #44 0 / / " !

// # 7 / * 2* !0 4*& " # 2# #

* / ! - 2# ! / / 7 / #

4 #$ #/ * * " &

" # 2# # / # /

$ 0 / / 2# $ # " #/ 2# $

# # " #/ " # 2# # # #44

" # # " 2" 2 * $ #/

4 # 2 & # 2 -O"D D0

# # / K # / # # # #

K #/ 44 * / " / 44 * $

" 4 " &6'

6' D0 ( #4&D & 6&

(37)

6(

" # 2# # 4 # " 2 # / "

(,& 2# " / " # # #/ #

$ / " * 7 2 2# * 2# 4 /

! # "$ & " # 2# #

# 2# " # /2# /L / #

" # # / /2# / # #

2# * 4* * & " # 2# #

#/ * * 2# / "

1 " $ / 4 1&

2# # # " # 2# # # #

" #/ # L # #$ 2# $ " # 2# #

22" & " # 2# # // 4* 2# * 4* #$ *

#/ # 2# 4* 2# # &

" * / 4 / /& . / # # 4* 2# * $ 0

# / * #44 # # 2#

#$ # & . # # 2# # # # " #/

"$ 2 4 / / / # #/

# L # 2# 4 # * 2 *

4 # # 1 " $ / 4 1 #/ 4 4 #$ 0

$ / 4 " & " " # 2# # / #

* // " #/ " $ / 4 2# " * / # #

/ /& / # # # #

/ 44 " 2# $ 2 # ! / # / / &

2! # " / - #/ #44 ! / 2# # $ 2# K #

$ / # 2# / K 1/ # # #/ 2#

2# N # N16 / 2# "

12# 1&

. " # 2# # # #/ # L #

L 2# 4 / " #/ $ #

#$ ! / # 2# " #$ & 2# -

6 5 1 D #"D " 5 / #/ # 1 , 6T9 +++ #/2 % ' 9'T9 +++-,,

B2 " 1 # K /W # 1C # #/ / +++ '9&

(38)

6'

/ # . // * # #

" // 2 4 * 2 & F " #

2# # -#$ $ #/ B ' 2#

#$ #/ # & / * 2 / / &

" # 2# # # # # #44 2# /

/ 0 / # # #44 / #

#/ 2# &

#/ #44 / # ' * 2

" / # / 2# / !

#$ & R 2 # # # / 2 #/ # "

$ $ ! * 7 # * ! # / #/

# & 7 # * / ! / 2# # & #

#/ * 2! 2 / 2# # $!0 / #/

# # & # #"D " # # 12# 16: #

/ / ! / & / ! / #44 * / 4* / " /

/ . // * 6+

$ 1 1& R / ! / * / #/

" # 2# # $ 0 # # / * 7 "$

& # / 7 # * 2# *

" " D "-)# 0 # # 1# 4*

1&9,

6: $ & ,&

6+ . // 5 1 4! * # 1 G +(9H C * # ++' :+2&

9, " D "-)# 05 1 4 D " D P / > G +(3H

, ! % . $" / 3,,6 9 &

(39)

! " " !

#

! $ #

!

% & ' ()**# + "

"(

, ! !

(-**#

. ! /

! /

" 0" 1 ()**#

.

2

!

" "

!

3

4

(% & ' + 5 63 6& ()

7 38 + 5 () 9 :

(40)

-

! " " #

+ 3 ! " "

" "

" "

; < = !

# # 2

! $

!

,

+ " > "

! 2

2

2

= ! 4 = ? ()@-

(41)

)

"AB B C " < #7 $

! ' , $

" 2 "

$

! 5 > 4 D >

! (- 2

E 4 D >

" ! "

! 4 D >

" ! " " "9

" "

"

" @

4 !

:

< #7 $ +"# $ $ % # F()9*G

H 3 > +& ' ( ) * +, 8 > ())9 (*@ $

$ #; & + "$ + > " -

H **( ( @

95 > 4 D > + . , / + 0 . F !

(--: (- G $ ()) 9@

@ -

:$ < #7 7 + I& " D 3 > J K+1

. , 2 3/ , , -* : $ **@ @@-

(42)

9*

(-**# LB L

2

1

E E " ! "

! "

"- !

3

! 2

)

!

! !

6 #

E

! , (*4 D >

" " ! E

3 " "

! 1

()** E

3

; < 1 > + 4 +,

4 +, 5 % M !

> 7 ())@

-; E " ! " < + , 3* - 6 N

()): (

) & 3 3 #

3 !

$ "O 3 " () ) & 3 +7 - F() 9G

5 ())*

(43)

9(

4!

"

" 2 3

((

!

1

()**# 2

!

():* ! > 5

" , " ( % & ' 1

"

" ( , ()**# '

(9

E ()**# " "

!

! D $

> + "

"(@,

(*7 > @@:

(($ < !+ ( ( 8 4

3 ! A ' A ())9 ()-# *(

( > 5 + "' ; > " F(): G " ;

6 **( 9- $ " " "N > 5 "

( % & ' +1 5 () * )

(9' + 4 = ? ()-: (

7 > @-*

(@ D $ +1 9 * ' ( 3 , 8 > ()): @-

(44)

9

!

! P

() ( ,

!

(:1 2 /

/ E $ !

" " E

$ !

" ! " ( E = !

" > " " = " (-

!

!

3 !

,

(:7 > @: 7 P + " ' (

E () (

( E $ ! E 3 + ' F()-9G 8 >

())9 (@*

(-$ % $ Q + / , N ()-) 9-

(45)

9

!

()

5

! %

!

D#

* '

"

" (

!

"

/ " $

() !

R 3 ! ,

7 F()@-G , ,

" " #

!

" /

/ ! I $ < +

- 3 () )

*$ "; "

(< P > +1 : 5 ** -(

(46)

99

" "

9

4

!

E

" " " "

!

! '

@

4 ' > & "

" :

+ # 4

P ; () (

2 2 !

$ H , +< / 0

, / F())9G HS ()) -)

9P > >

@$ E 3 + < , ( 8 > ())- ) )(

:' > & + I > = " ' P $ J K+

4 . * ) 5 **

" E "

(47)

9@

" B B /

' / " - &

" "

" " )3

! & !

7 > #

!

! ! !

()**#

3 ! #

#

2 2 $

" " " " *3

( **#

(E

! < Q

E H ! ()**#

2 $ < Q +

F() -G R > A ()- 9 "P "

-& > (@

) (9:

*R 3 I " (-9@ (-9: H #E +

1 - = * * , F()) G

S ())) -@

($

& > $> E 5 $>

! + "

!

" J5 & < $> + "O , T 8 D 4 F(-* G

& 3 = B $> + ) ' $ ()-

((

(48)

9:

+ " "

! 2 ()**#

$ 3

! / /

$

,

" ! ()**# "

! ()**#

+ $ # !

" "

" " !

9

7 ()**#

" " !

E

"

" @ " " :

" "

< H E L +" 5 7 " F():)G L +

. 5 ( 5 ()): (

$ I I I5 ."

9$ " " "M "

@P8 3 + "O 3 =T U " F() G 3 +

1 5 ()-) * $ I I I,

. 1 I

:38 >

(49)

9

", " !

" "

/ /

/ /

, E

!

" "

> #

# " " $

! !

5

! +

L N 2

" " !

$

! "$ " " " " " /

,

" #

" E

" 2 ! " -

> + < ) 1

5 **

-5 $ + "; 2 ! 2

" $ % +' , 0 >

, ! **@ ' > B 1 2

R

+"1 FVG

2 " +

(50)

9-

$2 ! ()**#

+ P ()** L &

" "

;

$

$

4

!

" "

!

! A

! $

I I ( 3 **: : $ I I ",

. 1 "

(51)

9)

# 1

" " "> " #

!

P8 3

2 "

! " )

()**# E

#

" " " > " "

" $

%

" C C " "

" 2

!

! ()**#

R H

H !

? ( 9 ( 1

! ()**#

)3 > (-

(52)

@*

H

2 >

H !

9*1 2

! H 2

> 9(

7 & 3 " "9

H

H N

>

! >

9* H R

H + "% = = A > " 9 ( , 9 4 = ? ()9*

I' > " 9 ( , @ 4 = ? () ) " 7 "

@ , ( 4 = ? ():( ' ! E & J K+

ABCC8ABBC ;L ())

9(1 % & ' L

E * F()99G 5 ** I

' T " ' +

, ; ())(

9 & 3 + I = !W > > P D I F() :G

' ( D ) , 5 () $

I& 3 "

(53)

@(

4 H " "

! ()**# !

#

C

H !

H

! H

H

7

() *# H

A 3

" " 9

H + 3

>

E , !

2 +

#

" " 1 E

+ 3

,

9 A 3 3 > > (() !

(54)

@

! +

3 " "99 E

4 H

" "

3 H

, + / H !

/

!

, , H " "

" "

" "

H

! ! " "

$

5

# >

' ,

H % & '

99$ 1 & ; + "3 > $! " H 3

E 7 J K+- , E ' , , 8 > ())@ :*9

(55)

@ /

/

N

!

, " "

+ "' !

"9@5

" # "

E > " " 9:

#

H

!

>

" "

H 5 " ! "

6 $

! ()**#

5 ()**# "

" P

9@R + " 6 6 " 3 > D J K+

1 . , 9 $ ** (

9:$ % & ' + " 8 " + " ,

5 (): (--

(56)

@9

"=

> > "9

! 5 + <

! ! 2

2 H > 5

E " "

" # " !

!

+ " #

" " "

E " " " "

" " 2

9-;

2 E

" " !

# 9)

,

" "

" " ;

!

9 P "% " E 5 J K+

( $ ()- :9 $

+ + < R ())

9-

(57)

@@

" "

5

" " !

( **# !

9)

(58)

@:

(59)

! " #

#

$ % & " &

'

( " & ) & &

" '

&

#% & ) " &

) ) & )

*+

( , ( , % " - #%

#% +.//0 ' 1 , & # )

2 , & ) " 3 - 4

) " ) ' &

4 4'

#& 4 ) 4'5

) ! ! -

# ) " &

, % ! 4 0 4'6, 47 " 4' 1

+, ( , 4 8) *4& 9+:..;&

) < '

5< # 4 - 4 =' , ) +.6/& 4 - 4& 7 8) , > '?

" 5& < +. 5 5 ' , -

& 4 0 4'

6@ A & 8 ) +..6 BC'

(60)

:

# 4 4 & B&

-# ' # " #% % " &

" & ' < %

) , & -

4< 4

&

& - &

- &

& - '

1 ## '

$ # ) &

" ) )

' )

% # 4 4&

- ' $

# % 8) # # " " # & )

% # )

& % " - # % # #%

' ) & %

" # 4 4

% ) '

% # )

+.//0 ' D - 4

4 4 4 " # " ) ' )

# " - +.//0 " #'

, "

0 & ) % -# #

- #% +.//0 &

# ' $ #

B2 ( " ! & 8 ) +..: +/'

$ , ( , 3 ) 4& " 9+./ ; ) < '

(61)

.

'

% ) ( 8 ( 0@ -& (

1 = < &

# " ) ' % " )

& ) ) #

& " %

#% # ' ## ) &

#% % '

- #

) # ' ) +.//0

% " )

& '

- # ! "

! - ) % % '

& " ##

) %# # " '

(62)

C/

(63)

C+

& # +

( 8 ( 0@ -

) ) #

& ) ) '

7 ) C

, - @ AEF - & # ) "

) 4 ##) % # & % " & % )

4' 4 G 4 ) & %

) # ) # ) ( 8 ( 0

@ -' ( 0@ - ) # $#

! @ # ! +.B & ) - 4AEF

4' 1 % AEF ( 0@ -

& '

( 0@ - ) # &

#% % " % &

# ' $ # "

& " )

" ! " "

' ##

' ( 0

@ - " # %

% ) !

% " % # " )

" ! " "

" '

( 0@ - % ) # )

- , E 8 ' 8 " #

) ) &

C 7 ) H ' B +. I ' + +. :& 7 ) & J-

, " 2 K % % $ $ & L 5//C C.'

A & & #'8 ' BC'

Referanser

RELATERTE DOKUMENTER

Siden 1911 skulle forbrukersamvirket i prinsippet lignes som alle andre foretak for inntekt fra handel med ikke-medlemmer, mens inntekt fra medlem- mer hadde vært unntatt fra

Det ble imidlertid ikke avdekket liknende steinheller rundt andre deler av kirken, og dette er heller ikke synlig på bilder fra kirkens sydside fra tidlig på 1900-tallet.. Det er

Kriminalantropologene tok særlig opp spørsmålet om tilregnelighet. Domsmyndighetene hadde i uminnelige tider tatt hensyn tilregnelighet og straffeansvar, så det var ikke noe nytt

Rundt midten av 1900-tallet finner vi tilløp til et kjønnspolitisk perspektiv på Hauge-bevegelsens kvinner i kirkehistoriske verk – som når Ivar Welle (1875–1957) i

Jeg vil besvare bekreftende på spørsmålet ved å vise til hvordan Metodistkirken i Amerika drev misjon blant migranter på 1900 tallet, og hevde at deres måte å integrere

Begrunnelse: Nasjonalbiblioteket, opprinnelig oppført også som universitetsbibliotek, hører med blant de store nasjonale byggeprosjektene tidlig på 1900-tallet, med første

Det er rimelig å anta at Dickie her var inspirere av Danto (1978). For ifølge Danto var det vår kunnskap om kunst som styrer bruken av ”kunstverk”. Danto viste til Sokrates og

industrietableringene og arbeiderkulturen utover 1900-tallet utfordret bildet av Hardanger som et nasjonalromantisk landskap. I kapittel 5 presenteres mitt datamateriale