Alexander Jüterbock
“Climate change impact on the seaweed Fucus serratus , a key foundational species on North Atlantic rocky shores”
PhD in Aquatic Biosciences no. 10 (2013)
“Climate change impact on the seaweed Fucus Serratus, a key foundational species on North Atlantic rocky shores”
Alexander Jüterbock
A dissertation for the degree of Philosophiae Doctor (PhD)
PhD in Aquatic Biosciences no.10 (2013)
Faculty of Biosciences and Aquaculture
PhD in Aquatic Biosciences no. 10 (2013)
Alexander Jüterbock
“Climate change impact on the seaweed Fucus Serratus, a key foundational species on North Atlantic rocky shores”
University of Nordland ISBN: 978-82-93165-09-5
Print: Trykkeriet UiN
University of Nordland N-8049 Bodø
Tel: +47 75 51 72 00 www.uin.no
All rights reserved.
No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying or otherwise, without the prior written permission from University of Nordland.
! !" #$%
& #&" ø" &'* / $ " ;<*;=*>;<;
?<*;@*>;<?" E GH $ ' ' " K & ! G* E ' L M &' O!QRVW E
<X=Y;Y" >;?@?X" ><=Z@Z [ O*
E ' \
¨" ]W" #&"
" " #&" $ " " #&" %$
" " #$ [" & " %$
!^ _¨ K ø" _ >;<?
`
` ' K K * $ [ O" _ _ j #$ [" &
E * ` * $ E *
[" K $ * ` / 'K * K $ $ "
^ K' ^ %
* ` $ z * ' $ $* ` ' E K"
K $ Q{* _" K
^ ^ ' * _"
K $ *
` ' K \ M ]" &
R / $ $ *
W K W R* V ' ` L&! 'K| K } %
~ ` ' K K' R R H ø* R" K $ L % ' * ` K j$ & 'K L * K _ & } * * " ` ' K K O L" WE '" R H" M O/" ! ] ¨ ] OK $ $ % * K R L ' * ` j$ R ] $ ! *
W ^ ' ` ' K K ' }\ L L WEø$K" } !" j$ %
" ] R " W _" R R L H* W K L } " ] } #Q% W K ' * W % ^ ' K $ ]K ' *
``
` ' K K R$ R" ] WK & L R $ ' ` ** " K L * ] K O]W 'K } H W $ _ ' *
` ' % K / ~
` K _ M M #$ " #W!
'* _" K W"
'K K ' ^ * K '
" $ * !" K $ '*
` >;<<" ` $ L [ j$ MK [ #$ * ` ' K K O Q % } * " K ' & ]" " " $ * O" K & ]%
'K* K R j$ MK K' *
` ' K K $" [ [ #$
j" [* [" ` ' ' *
[ K W ` ] ' =; ! ] >;<>* ` ' $*
` K' L M &' O!QRVW E
<X=Y;Y" >;?@?X" ><=Z@Z" # * ` ' K K ' %
" ' K ' \
& ! W #W!" W" _ W*
` $ E ' 'K\ W¨E '" ] ]" M O/" ]
" W R" ] " !$ W" " !
!$" ` " O O" LE" }" M " M
}" R} ]K &'" ! }" O R L" ] $ " R¨" ! " M M" WE W$" !
```
Wø R* ` ' K \ ]" K $| M"
WE" W" O" ] R $ ¨ ` ' *
` ' K K E $ [ $ *
` K " ` W* `" $ % K' ' * ` K / % ^ * !" K ' ' %
! * V $ K ' ` ' K K ' % K $*
` $ " ' ' % * K ' " ' ` K *
`Q
!
!!
"
"!!
# !$
%% $
&
& !' (
M * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ? L ' * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ? M * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Y H $ ' * * * * * * * * * * * * @ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * X * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * X
! * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <;
!} * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <<
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <<
! * * * * * * * * * * * * <Z
` * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <
Q
M & %! K * * * * * * * * * * * * * ><
$ * * * * * * * ><
K ' K * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ><
& %! K * * * * * * * * * >?
% ' * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >Z ] E$ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >
) * )+
] * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >@
L * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >X H^ K * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >X H^ K * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?<
R * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?<
M} ! * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?>
M * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?>
M $$ * * * * * * * * * ?>
M % $ * * * * * * * * * * * * ?Z O / ' * * * * * * * * * * * * ?Z
( %%', (-
` $ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?=
&^ % % * * * * ?
. (/
0 1 .2
Q`
< M Mj> $ Z;;";;; ?
> ] * * * * * * * * * * Z
? Mj>" Mj>
E WLHW <" !<" !> * * = Z ]% ' * * * * * * * * * * * = Y '$ WLHW
<" !< !> * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
= M * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * @
' $
H & ] * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <?
@ ' <Z X & 'K %K OW * * * * * <Y
<; H/ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <=
<< j_` $ K
$ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <
<> [ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <X
<? W$ ' * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * <X
<Z ` ' ! * * * * * * * * * * * * * >;
<Y M% ' % K & %!
K * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >>
<= & %! * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >?
< & ' <Y°M WW * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >?
<@ % ' & %! K * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >Z
<X * & %! >Y
Q``
>; [ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >=
><
W L * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * >=
>> R * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?;
>? ` $ * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * ?
Q```
,'
3 !
!
*4 M &!
* $ j^
*4 ^ !
54 H & ] 567 H^ W
[ [
!6 [ ` W
[ M
, O }
6 O WK 61 O WK L
! ` $ M M
[ ]^
*4 ] &!
4* & !
Ee H/$ W}
46 &^ [ W
1 M L
W/Abs ! `^
%%
6
14 L !
67 W !
6* W ]
64 W &
6156 W L H W &K$
" >;;;
667 W W
`
%%
% ! " *" Q O*" M _*!*" j _**" O [*
>;<?
M ' ' & ! K
? Y" <?Y=%<? ?
% !! " R W*" W `*" _*]*j*" M _*!*" j _**"
O [*
' & %
! \ } W
% !!! " R W*" M _*!*" j _**" O [*
! & ! K % '
]
! Mj> <@ ` L$" * ' $ ' * " ^ K % $\ < | >
| ? * M "
" K / * ] % ^ $ "
' * j K "
' * O K | % " $ E K
& ! " $ $ / $ * !" $ E$
' ' ' & %! K ' ' % *
# " H & ] %
$ K & %! K "
" ' ' G G*
! M" [" W ' ><;;* W ZY°& ' ' & ' % & %!
>>;;* " '$" K $ $%
*
*
&'" K" W" % % K '
% ^ * $ % /* ` " ' % ≥>Z°M W >>;;" W ' % * O'$" $ ^ $ W K *
<
$ $ $" % ' * * ' $ " /$ }"
$ $ &'" K"
" W* W ' $ ' >? <? " $* j HW%K ' ' &' $ ' % K" W ' * &' W &<Y;" ' ' &≤><; $ * j$
" W / X;*
` " } $ * K z $ ^%
* ` ^ K H ' K E % * } $ * $ ^* 'K
" " ^ " $%
$ K '*
$ / *
>
& !'
3
! Mj> $ <@ ` L$ % $ >@; >?@; " >;;Z| W " >;;Z* ` ]
>;<?" Mj>$ $ Z;; K \**>;<?;YZ;; * ' <;; $ ' Z;";;;
" <XXX| ! " >;;Z| O%[ " >;; * <* % Mj> "
R" >;;X" "
>;; O%[ " >;; | " >;;X*
$ E * *
&8 M Mj> $ Z;;";;; *
' Mj> ?@; ` L$ <@ *
\'''* z*$*K" j [$
$<*;*
1
Mj> [O[" ' " $ $
<°M >; " >;;@" >*<°M ! *
>* M " $ ;*Y°M
?
>; " >;;@ ;*X°M ;; " "
>;;@ >;;< % >;;Y $ K $ % <*Z O " >;;=* ` " ! j ' " >;; | " >;<<
" >;;Y ` j* ] " % WW Z*Y°M & %! * >* ]$" % ' ^ $' H
" >;;;| " >;; * W ' ^ $ <;
<X=; <X ; M H V " >;;>| R K R¨"
>;;?| !^ " >;;= H '$ >;;? >;<;
W " >;;Z| W¨ _ }K" >;;Z| " >;<<
E ^ ** [ " >;;X| W " >;<;*
9:
9:
)8] " $ <XY< % <X@;" ;*YZ °M " $
<@ ; % <X;; °M >;;< % >;;Y* L O >;;=" * <
* ? ' & ! W" #*W*!*
Z
3 %'
W [O[ "
/ [O[ * `%
$ M M `MM ^ WLHW W L%
H W &K$ " >;;; ' $ K ' $ E `MM ! L ] " >;; \ <" !< !>*
;& 6 < % " '' $ $ % &K$ " >;;;* " [O[ '
< ] " >;; ' K Mj> * <>
[ M %< >;Y; * ?" ' ^ K % } &K$ " >;;;* Mj>
* YY; ><;;
>°M * ? ><;; ' ^ Z*Y°M ! * Z*
&; 6 !< $%
' $ &K$ " >;;;*
[O[ ' < !>
] " >;; * ! < " } &K$
" >;;; Mj> ^ K * >;Y; ' <? [ M %<
* ?* Mj> ' ;; ><;; % ' * ?°M * ? ' ^ °M ! * Z*
) 6 !> '
&K$ " >;;;*
[O[ !> ] " >;;
' Mj> * >@ [ M %< ><;; *?* Mj>
' ^ * @@;
* Z°M ><;; *? ' ^ % @°M ! * Z*
Y
(8]% Mj>" Mj>
E K \±< $ <X * \ $ ' ' K $ WLHW K <
' " !< !> * ! ] >;; " *
<;*>=*
.8]% ' "°M
< " !< !> " " >;<< >;?; " >;Z=
>;=Y >;@; >;XX * ! $ $ <X@; <XXX*
' ] >;; " * <;*@*
=
" WLHW '$ $ ] " >;; "
* Y* O '$ H O $ >;;? >;<;
Y <; $ ^ Z;
$ " >;<<*
9:
9:
08[ $ '$ ^* ^
^ Y $ ' ^ Y°M
|9:
<@ ; >;X; WLHW < ' " !<
!> ' % $ ' $ " 9: WLHW !<* L >;;=" * >" * ? ' W*
5 , '# %
& ' % O" >;;;| V" >;;?| L " >;;?| " >;;=|
L}' " >;;@ $ ' ^ K " >;<<*
<*@%>*;°M >;Y;" <Y % ? '
^ $ >; " >;;Z*
&$ " ^ K $\ < $ ' % | > } | ? $$ $ $ $ ' L " >;; | E K" >;<> * =*
7%
,
6 #
3<
=' ' '
%' 6%
-8M * !
'$" " * ' "
' ^*
@
*' 3<
M V" >;;?|
" >;<; K " ?;
Y; K $ W'" >;;<* ! ' ' >;
^ $
** " " " " " }K $%
" >;;>| V" >;;?| OK " >;;=| "
>;;=| W " >;<;* ] $ <X;
K W " >;<; =*< K ' =*< " V" >;;? ' ^ >Z K H " <XXX >Y; K " >;;>| " >;;X* L
$ " '$" % * K $ '
$ " $ $$
^ ' '% } ' ^ ' " <XXX| $ W'" >;;<| " >;;<| O " >;;Y| ! K " >;;@*
3#% % '#
`$ "
" $ E " >;;=| %¨
" >;;@* ] % E $ >; $ " % % "
' ' O}" >;;=| " >;;=| ] " >;; | ' O}" >;;@* ! % < >
" " " " $ % $ K " '" " " $
$ $ >*? %< V" >;;?* ! % ;; $ $ $ Y*<±;*< %
%<$ >; ' ^ >Z
%< &
! L " >;;?* ` " ><
X
'K %<= 'K ' ZY " '
$ $ H'" >;;X*
!} K ' ' $%
^ K '$" ' $* O'$" ' _" >;;Y *
%'
$ "
% % E K" >;<>* L $ $ $ ' % $ % [ " >;;@* ! $ %$ W" >;<;" $ ' ' O}" >;;=| R " >;<<*
O'$" $ '" $ ' O}" >;;=" >;;@*
^" " %
$ VK '
<; <? ' ^ $ L´ "
>;;?| ^ " >;;Z* j$ >Z% "
% % ' ' O}" >;;<* !
$ " $ <@% " ' ! ' } ' $ " !Q ! "
>;<?*
W ^
' '% # [
" >;;@" ! # " >;;Y $ " >;;?| $ H " >;;Y| " >;;=* ! ^ ' $ " $ " '
<;
$ z K
$ W'" >;;<| O%[ " >;; *
!$ $ $ $
$ $ ' K j #K" >;;@| ´ " >;;X* " $%
/$ } $e L}} " >;;@"
} ' $ % M' " >;;X* `Ne '" $ ^ $ L}} " >;;@| M' "
>;;X* " '$e / } ^ $ L" >;;Y| L}} " >;;@| ^ L" >;<<| E K" >;<>* !"
$ $ Ne L}} " >;;@ % ' ^ K ** W
" <XX@| & " >;;<* O $ K /$ $ ' % $ M' " >;;X| E K"
>;<>*
#> 3 %
^ K " $%
** " >;;@| W " >;<;|
W " >;<<* $ E " " / * ' '% ' < " >
" ? $ $ *
' ' 3<
& ' $ % * ' / $ R" >;;=*
<<
GG % E % R " >;;X* W ' ^ %& >;Y; ! % WLHW < < R " >;;@* ! E 'K ^ $ K' !" >;;X % $ K '" >;;?| R " >;;X*
` " G$G GH &
]G H&] GW ]G W] H 'K" >;;X|
R " >;;X $%
$' [ " >;;;| H
'K" >;;X E } % * * [`W $
$$ **
} $%
* E K "
' [`W ^ " $ $ * ` E "
^ ' $ % * $ ' E H 'K" >;;X* ` " $ % % * *
' " >;;?| " >;; | H " >;<;| ! Q &"
>;<<" ! " >;<<
" >;;Y " >;;Z| W' } " >;;=|
" >;;X* " } E K " ' [`W ' $ '
* *
<>
Present-day conditions Georeferenced occurrences
Dissox (ml/l) SST (◦C) SAT (◦C)
Realized niche space
2000 2100 2200
Mapped distribution predictions
Climate change scenario predictions
SST (◦C) SAT (◦C)
SST (◦C) SAT (◦C) SAT SST
Dissox
?8 ' $ H & ]*
[% [`W $ ^" ' ' \ ^" $ ^| W!" | WW"
' } $ * O ' E % ' % >;;; * E $ * } ' E $ " [`W '
* H 'K >;;X" * <*
<?
3 %3# %
`$ $ % $ ' ' ^ O%
" >;<;* ' $ % } * @\ < % K >
* Fitness
Temperature Benign
Stressful Stressful
Lethal Lethal
Photosyntheticperformance Hspexpression
+8 * ! %
^%^
* ` " ^ OW * OW ^ $ ' K ' * ] Wø K >;; " * <*
! $ % K OW K OWL / O" <XXX| K" >;;@| O "
>;<;* $ OW % K $ **
$ K O" <XXX| ' " <XXX* W $ OW" }"
O" <XXX| " >;;Z } * X*
! ^ } '
$^ OW" OWL ^ / %
$$ !% $' O" <XXX|
/" >;;Z| Wø K" >;; *
<Z
Protein denaturation
Aggregation
Refolding
Resolubilization Prevention Stabilization
sHSP
HSP60
HSP70 HSP90
HSP100
/8& 'K %K OW * % / % OW $ $ K* } !% *
! } * OW ; OWX;
% $ % OW*
>;;Z*
OW ^ $ '
$ * ^" ^ $ ; K OW OW ; $ ' j$ } O" >;;Y
'K$ %
K W O" >;;Z* W
$ K OWL ' $ $%
<<;°M % OW ^ "
$ $ >>;°M OWL ^ K" >;;@" >;<;*
K OW ^ $ $ ** ! % } " >;;<| MK " >;;@| MK K" >;;X" MK
" >;;@ K $ K W" >;;X* ! $ $
** $ / \ / ' ^ ' OW ^ K" >;<;* "
$ $ $ "
' K $%
K" >;;@| W" >;<;| K" >;<;*
W $ EK"
<X@;| WK" >;;X| W $ " >;<<" % % * @* O $ $ /
<Y
EK" <X@;| " <X@>| " >;;Z Mj>
K " <X@@| W$ M%"
>;;Z| WK" >;;Y* W `` ' $ O$^"
<XX?| ]^' _" >;;;| LKK " >;;;* z " ' =@; W `` ;; W ` W " <XXZ| K" >;;@ * <;*
PS II P680
PS I
P700 NADPH
Calvin Cycle CO2fixation decrease Photochemistry
e−transport decrease
Photochemistry e−transport
decrease Heat
Fluorescence measurable
increase
Heat
Fluorescence
h∗ V h∗ V
&28H/ * $ h∗ V
W ` W `` 'K
%* 'K &! &!O" ' % ^ M$ M* $ /
^ " 'K* ` %
" / * j^ >;;Z| K >;;@| W <XXZ*
! %
W `` W " <XXZ| " >;<;"
' " % K R K / R K <X=; ]^' _ >;;;* ] j_`
$" * << ^ $' ]^' _" >;;;| K" >;;@|
" >;<;| W $ " >;<<* F0 ' j j_` " * <<"
' K% ^} % * W " " ' " ^ $Fm j_`
" * << ]^' _" >;;;*
! ' ^ W
`` ^ "
<=
Fm
F0
&&8 j_` $ K $ $
Y;; * " K j F0 Fm * ^ * ! >;<;" * <*
Fv/FmFv/Fm= (Fm−F0)/Fm]^' _" >;;;| " >;<;*
" F0 Fv EK" <X@;* O'$" ' ˇ$ˇ´K " >;;@| " >;<;| ] ´ı} "
>;<>| $ " ^()Abs' W " >;;;* ^ $ ˇ$ˇ´K " >;;@| " >;<;| W $ "
>;<<\ < " > %
" ? ^ ^ W ``* KFv/Fm"
()Abs $ j_` $ % ˇ
$ˇ´K " >;;@| " >;<;*
/ ' / $
^ $' R'K H " >;;Z ' %
$ / $ K $ ^ ^%
* ! $ $ } % $ /*
!'# ' %'
' $ '
$' Q " >;;Y| L " >;; | O " >;<>\
<
< " ' $ $ ' * > " ' $ $ ^ $ %
$ ^ G'G $ L " >;; * % _ " >;; | ] " >;<;
$ $ $ L " >;;
$* $ $
$ '" ^" $ $
% % ! ** & " >;;X| K%
" >;<?" ' O " >;<; ! "
>;<<* O'$" $$
$ " z $ ' $ ** j " >;<>*
`" ' ' $ $ * "
$ $ $ K * ^"
# %
' $ ^ $ K "
j " >;<>*
! $ ' ** " W& !
K K W O" <X Z ' * <>*
G %K%G K Q
" >;;Y* j } ^ / '" ' / W O" <X Z| K " >;;?| Q " >;;Y*
/ * %
" G$ 'G $ K " * <? } $
} H / ' %
$ / ^ FS T&" <X > K " >;;?| O MK" >;; * <>*
<@
cM
0 100 200
0 0.5
1
0 0.5
1
FST Heterozygosity
Genotyped loci Outlier locus
Selective sweep Selective sweep
&)8[ * W / %
K ** " W& !
* %^ ' M]*
K" / ^ ^FS T&" <X > % $ } * ' ' }* W$ ' * <?
} ^ '*$* ` ^" ' ' ' K*
Before Selection After Selection
Selective Sweep
&(8W$ '* ! $
< <; * ' ' * W$ K '
$ K '
* L Q >;<>" * < ' & ! W" #*W*!*
` " $ $ } % $ ' / ' $ * ]%K% % } H / FS T ' ' K !%
H^z " >;<; * <Z ^ " \
\'''%*E%** " / Q " >;;<| K " >;;?| Q " >;;Y* ` G$ 'G" G G
<X
' K * j " ' $ " '
$ ** [ " >;<;| M " >;<<*
&.8H^ ! $* ?*Y H^z " >;<; %
* H ' ^ ^FS T }
$H * ' $
$ ^ ' %
* $ XY
$ $ * ' Y
$ *
O'$" ' $ $ $ / ' %
* ' >;<<" Y%<; $ K $ Y K <;*;;? $'
" >;<<" ' $ $ % $ * ` $" " >;<<* [ '
>;
' ^ $ " $ % $ $ $ " >;<<* M "
^ $ $ *
3 % 43@ ' # 3 73 ',# ' % 3
M W % ' " <XXY| O%[ " >;<;| W " >;<; <"<*
' < $ $%
" >;;X| H'" >;;X| W " >;<;* ` " $ $ $ % ' $ %[
M " >;; | " >;<?* " ^ " ' % " $ ^ $ ^ * O'$" $ % ' W" >;;Y| O " >;;=| W" >;<;| K" >;<;*
H$ ^ ' % ' ' W ' " <XXY| O " >;;=| " >;;@| W " >;<;*
$ "
' O " >;;=*
73 # 3 # '
M / % W" <XXX| R " >;<<* j K " % ' * <Y <X > M " >;;X|
" >;<<| O " >;<>" \ < % " <XX=" > ^ ' ' M
><
H " >;;?| [ " >;<;" ? $ " " % M" <XXY| EK " >;<>*
9: % '
% %*
9:LK ' " $ ' *
&08M% ' % K & %! K | 9:
_ K >;<?" * <*
' " <X@@| H " >;<>| W " >;<> ' WW ¨ " <XX;* j$ >< " =;; K ' WLHW `MM !> < O "
>;;=" ' K ' ]¨ " >;;X| " >;<<* ^" W ' % W %! " >Y $ ' $ K ^ '
>< " >;<<*
' % ' $ K * ^" %$ % ' ' $ $ % W " <XXX| " <XXX| W " >;;Z| M" >;;Y| W"
>;;=| W " >;; " >;<<* " & %! K ' $ ^ % ' *
>>
43@ ' # 3
& %! $ % ' ' Q OK" <X Y * <=*
! " % % Q OK" <X Y| K !" >;<>* j " $
% ' % Q OK" <X Y| ¨ " <XX;*
&-8 & %! " <Y°M
>;°M ' *
<Y°M WW '% % & %! Q OK" <X Y ??; K '
<X@Y >;;; ]] O" >;;= * < "
! WW ;*Z°M % <*=°M $ Y; % =; O " >;;=
$ ' WW *
&?8 <Y°M WW ! <X@Y >;;; " '
??; K* L ]] O >;;= ' _ W*
' K ' & %
! "
* <@* * $ ?;
^ <<° <">Y; K ' & " >;<?* W % ' '
>?
<;; K| <@; K <X < +
" >;; | $ ]" >;<> <Y; K , ! K ' ' >;;@ ]¨ " >;;X|
]¨ " >;<;* ]$" */ $ $ ^ ' !E´ " >;<<*
9: 9: 9:
&+8 % ' & %! K
*
73 %#@ &ƵĐƵƐ ƐĞƌƌĂƚƵƐ
WW " $ ^ ' & %! K * `
? % Z " ' ' & %! K ' < % > M " >;;=* ! K K E }
<<> ! " <XX?" >;;>* ' * ^ ;*Y % > K M " >;;?
' ;*> % ;*= K M " >;;=| ' " >;;X*
j H %! " * ^ W
¨ " <XX; & ! " <XX?| " >;;X|
QE " >;<<| ] ´ı} " >;<> ' &
W ' K K Q OK" <X Y| ¨ " <XX; * <X* j %! " $ &$ W H ' <@=;
' " >;;X| _ " >;<>* ` ' ` &' <X ` >;
M " >;;=*
>Z
9:j 9:W 9:!
&/8 * & %! * j
9: % '* W 9:$
' 9:*
^ []" * <@ >; K"* ' E \ & ' %` " W ' %`
O% / M " >;;?| O "
>;; * <X" >;* $ % ' $ $ O " >;;Y| ] " >;;@| K W" >;<>"
' * M " >;;?| O " >;; * ` "
& %` $ $ ^ } M " >;;?*
W % & %` $%
* O"* ' "
' ' * M "* ' % \ W * ` W" >>°M ' *
>Y°M ¨" <X@Z| ¨ " <XX;" ' "
$ ! " <XX?" >;;>| QE "
>;<<| ] ´ı} " >;<>* j$ " $ W % L ^ * ><" $
^ * M *
` " ' $ K ' <Y°M"
% }
* " >;;X* ] ' K % ' #R " >;;X* %
>Y
)28[ * L<%L? W ' %`"
& %` * / &! / * ' $ ' ^ ^
<@ % >; K* L O >;; " * < ' _ W*
9:<XXX 9:>;<;
)&8! W L%
* $ * " 9:<XXX 9:>;<; X; $
<<% * L _ K >;<?" * W=*
>=
* z $ ^ & %` *
B',
$ E$ ' ' ' & %! * ' \
• % !\ %
& ! K E*
• % !!\ ` '*
' \ ^ K *
• % !!!\ ` $ '*
& %! ' $ $ $ *
$ %% !!!!!' $ * H %! * <X\ < & &' RK" | > K ø| ? % L/" $ M " >;;?|
O " >;; | Z W L" % ' $ M " >;;?| O " >;; * / " / *
&' }
>°% <?°M $ ' @°% <@°M ' W <>°% ><°M " '
* ^ $ ' % * <°M ><°M*
>
) *
'
M & ! $$ ' ]¨ " >;;X| " >;<< '$ W¨ " >;;Z|
" >;<<* $ $
" K W" >;<;| K"
>;<;* j K " ' M " >;;X| O "
>;<>* !" $ E$ ' ' ' & %! K ' ' % * ] %% ! ' % ' ' $ E ' ' & %! * !%
" ` ' ' ' $$ * ]
%% !! ' ' %
'* $ ^
% ` * ] %% !!!
' $ * $ $ $ H %!
* ] K " $} >>" '\
• % !\ # E" H & ] H&] % ' ' ! % ' ' ' ZY° & >>;;*
& %! ' ' K %
*
• % !!\ ' $
^ W %
* z $ ^ *
• % !!!\ [ $ ' %
* $ $ *
/$ } $e ' '
$ * " $
>@
W ' ^* j % K z $ *
1 3
W' ** M " >;;X| O " >;<>
K % * M " ' K '%
& %! ' '%' !%
' ' >>;; %% !*
^ ' ' } ' H&] \ $
* %% !!!!!* * % K $ % % "
%% !!! ' M " >;;?| O " >;; *
5'' 3 3
* & %` ' ^ ><;; $ $ ' %% !* !
$ $ W ' <? "%% !!!* O'$" % $$ j #K" >;;@| L}} " >;;@| [}}"
>;;X X; W= %% !"
%% !!!* /$ }" W % $ ' $ $ L}} " >;;@| M' " >;;X| E K" >;<>
%% !!!* ] ' W * ' ' ! " >;;>| QE " >;<<| ] ´ı} " >;<>
$ ^
' K" >;;@| W" >;<;| K" >;<; %% !!* `
" K * z $
$ ^ & %` ' ^ >;;
%% !* * $%
>X
Predicted range shift
(Paper I) (Hoarauet al., 2007a) (Paper III)
F.serratus, 2200, SRES A1B scenario, ,
Gain Remaining Loss
Biogeographic history
Glacial refugia Allelic richness Ne
Phenotypic plasticity - Accllimatization potential
(Paper II)
Resilience
Photosynthetic performance
in 2200
Constitutive HSP expression
Heat shock response
Genetic changes over the past decade
(Paper III)
Genetic change (Dest)
Change in allelic richness Change inNe
Temporal outliers
))8R % '
* * % !!!!!
H %! * O >;; * }
E %% !! $ $
} / $ GG GG* >>;; ^ WW >>;;* } %% !!! % /$ %} $e
$ * M Ne
$ $ $ >;;;*
' *
?;
/ " / M " >;;?"
$ O " >;;
% $ O " >;;Y| K W" >;<>| &$
" >;<>*
5'' ;C#
* ' ^ [ >>;; %% ! " * % $ %% !!!" $%
& %! ' $' ] " >;;@* O $ ' $ % ´ " >;;X| E K" >;<>" ' %% !!!* &$ "
' %% !!" % ≥>Z°M >>;; %% !!* O /$
} $ %% !!! $ / L}} " >;;@| M' " >;;X $ % $ $ ^ %% !* $ $ [}}" >;;X" >;<<| E K" >;<>
$ *
'% O " >;;@ ' O W '}" >;;Z| L " >;;Y| " >;; | H
" >;;@* M " K * /$ $ *
3 DC
>;°M ' X°M % <<°M %% !!!!!* ! % $ ^ $ ?>°M"%% !!
-&" ' ' } $ ' $ %[
M " >;; * ! " $" % %% !! $ ^ W%L "
?<
>;<; ^ ' $ ' % W * >>"%% !!!*
>' %' '
! M" [ W ' $ ' >< %% !*
' } ! K " '$"
^ K* &' %
* ' $ /$ } %%
!!!" $ G'G $ ' L}} " >;;@| E K" >;<>* ! $ E $ W'"
>;;<| " >;;<" } '
$ " >;<?" * $$ $ $ $ R " >;;=| H^z L" >;;@| ]` " >;;X*
" ' $ * % $ ! * ! [ W$ **"
$" ' % ! _" <X Z| Q OK" <X@ | j " >;<;* ` " %
* ` M ' M
" >;;=| ' " >;;X| _ " >;<>" K $ K E %% !* " * " ' H ' z *
3 %
3 , , '%
M $$ $ / O " >;;=| " >;<<| O
" >;<>* ^" E % }" ^ ' $ K ' H " <XXY| & ¨
?>
" >;;;* O' '% ' % $ WW $ % $ $' O " >;<>*
H&] " '$" WW $$
' %% !* ! ' " ' ' ' ' %% !* " ' WW " <X@@| H " >;<>" H&]
%% ! $ ^ '" >;;?| !´E [" >;;=*
O $ $ % * ! % $ / * $" " >;<<* ^"
% ' % / '" >;;Z* % ^ " $"
$ ^ ' } W" >;<;* ! '$ ' % <°M % >°M %< <X°M >=°M" ' ? 'K >=°M " >;<<"
O $ >;;? L " >;;Y* ` "%% !! $ ^ * ' ¨"
<X@Z| ` " >;;Z| " >;;X| " >;<;* % ^ " '$" / * $ $ ^%
K ' $ %%
!!" " >;<>*
!" %% !!! $ $ $ " & %
! ^ $ "
" " #Q O "
>;;@* ! / ' ** ! " >;;?|
} " >;<<| " >;<<" H&] $ ' ' %% !* ` } % W %H W ' " <XXY| O'K " >;;@| O
" >;<> %% ! ^ * %% !!!*
??
j <X" '$" $ "
" ' K E $ *
" % ' / $ j " >;<>* O'$" $%
$ ' $
$ *
% 3@ %' 3 ,
K " E $ $ O" <XXX| Wø K" >;; | H " >;<>*
^" % + $ &! $ E % ^ } ' $$ ' M´ " >;; * " HW %K* * ^ " >;<;*
" ^ ' * ]$" ^%
' % " ' % % % "
>;;Y| O " >;;@* " OWL
' '
%% !!* $ $ %
$ ^ ^ ^ * !
$ EK" <X@;|
WK" >;;X| W $ " >;<< / % * "
$ %
" K ^
' H " >;<>*
E
_$ $ ** ' _%
" <XX<| W " >;;=* ^" '* ' ;°M >Y°M ¨ " <XX; " ' E$
?Z
><@°M ! " <XX?* *
' $ %% !! E$ z * M " ' ` ≥24°M "%% !! $ E$%
* ! W " ' ' ' >Z°M >>;; %% !!"* *
^ %% !
' < % > ** M "
>;; * M " $ E$ *
" % %% !!!"
$ "
' K K $ $ * $" ^" $ $ ' " >;<?*
?Y
( %%',
!', 3 %%3
H&] '
" ' WW "
<X@@| ¨ " <XX;| H " >;<>* &$ " $ ^ K %$ % V" >;;?| OE [" >;;=| !´E " >;; | " >;;@|
$ " >;<;
` $ } %% !! $ %
$ %% !!! * $
^ [ %% !* O'$"
' %$ $ %
" " " % " ] "
>;; | $ " >;<; >?* ! $ ' } ** '" >;;?| [ " >;;Y| [ "
>;;=| $ " >;<;| W " >;<;" ^ K *
H&] $ * ^"
' $%
" >;;@*
H / $ ' %
$ ] $% "
>;; * ] < $ $%
!" >;;X| R " >;;X" % ** R " >;;@" >;;X| R " >;<;* $ ' "
>;;?| M} '" >;;=| " >;; | K" >;;@| H " >;<;| ! Q &" >;<< $ R
" >;;X| ] " >;;X| ]K " >;<<* ! % 'K ' $ 'K ' % % " ' % '" >;;?| [ " >;;Y* ` %
?=
Future distribution Niche modeling
Phenotypic
plasticity Adaptation
Dispersal Biotic
interactions
Eco- evolutionary responding potential Present-day occurrence
Heat shock response Outlier loci
Occurrence records Environmental conditions
Stable realized niche
Niche shift/evolution Mitigation of habitat-loss Increased invasive potential
)(8` $ * M $
$ ' $ $
*
K ' $ ' ^ K ' %
*
4 ' F % 3 G@ @ %
! %% !!!
$ " ' % Q " >;;Y * % ' ' MK " >;<;"*
O'$" / ^ ' K R " >;;Y" K $ " $ * # % $ '% ' %
$ &^ [ W &[W ] }K" >;<; $' W "
>;<;| HK [" >;<<* ! * <"<;; ] " >;;Z ' * %
$ $ ' " *
?
* O'$" ' K / $
^ ' / $ % / $ $*
&[W $ % ' K "
W& W " >;;X* O $ $ % $ K $%
[ " >;;X| W " >;<;| HK [" >;<<* &[W ' % >;;
" >;; | HK [" >;<< % ' +* L " >;<;"
. W'} " >;;X ,/ - [ " >;<;* &[W
$ $ $ % *
! $ &[W L&!% ' "
' $ " >;;X|
Q " >;<;| O " >;<>* $ % ML ML %% !! ' z ^
" L&!% K $ $ ' K HK [" >;<<* L&!% $$ HW &! $ L&! $ ' [ " >;;X| " >;;X* ^"
$ ^ $
0
" >;<<* ! $ ^ $ $
" ' % " ' H " >;<; K ' L " >;<;* ! L&!% $$
%^ ' % % [ " >;;X| HK [" >;<<"
% * M " &[W ' ' $$
$ ** W OK " >;; | HK [" >;<<
" ' ' K '
*
?@
.
j$ ^ ' " $ E K & ! ' % E ' !* H/$ } $ ' K $ * " } $*
$ " " K * O'$" '* " } $ % K z $ ^* H^ *
K H ' E * 'K $ $%
K '* $ / *
?X
0 1
! K W&" V W" O _!" " M%] W >;;@* ! " ^\
* &" XY–<<<*
! _" O _" ] >;<<* M *1 %(+" ?@?–?X?*
!^ Q" " M" M _" [ " R K !][" >;;=* [ $ ^ *1 . &&&*
! ]" %] !" RK L" >;;?* W % $ %
$ } ' *0 "&&" <;<–<;=*
! ]_ >;;X* \ * &' VK\ j^ #$%
*
!´E ] [ ! >;;=* $ *1 %(("
<= –<=@@*
!´E ] ] >;; *
*! %&-" Z?– Y?*
!´E L" W˜ H!" W% `" >;<<* / \ ' ' / % *1 (.?" ZY<–Z=>*
! _ <XX?* W*
( '/(" <@?–<X?*
! _ >;;>* ] ^ ' W* %&.&" <;YX–<;= *
! " M" L" _]" ]" M H" >;;Z* H ! *$ ".)/" =>?–=>@*
! ] Q & R >;<<* `$ \ $
*1 %(+" <–@*
K &L >;;@* M \ * . ( %0/"
@X–<<?*
_" j _]" O L" [ [" W >;;=* [ K ' # !!*'"(&(" < ?–< Y*
" " ! L R]" [K _" W " [ _]" >;;Y*
% ' ' *'"(2/" >@Z–>@ *
K !" ] }K &" W" [j" W' } " " >;<<* O H ^
^ $$ ".?&" Y<–Y *
" H]" _" L]" [´%O L >;<<* >;<;\
' H*'"(()" >>;–>>Z*
[" }K M" H' ] >;;X* L K & ! j*! + %&0" < X;–<@;?*
[" L M" `} " _!" H' ] >;;>* L} & ! $ *'")/-" <=X>–<=XZ*
Z;
[ [}} ! >;;X* H$ $ ^ ' $ * ,/&)" XZ>–XZ@*
[ [}} ! >;<<* ! $ ^ $%
*'"(()" <?> –<??;*
] W >;;Z* H^ $ $
*! ( +".." <–X*
_ EK j <X@;* * . ( ((&" ZX<–YZ?*
^ " L " ]! ![" W >;;Z* R ' \ $) + %.." <Z;–<Y<*
&" _" H " " $ >;<<* \ ' * )2" >;ZZ–>; >*
E L K Q >;<>* [ $ $ * 0" << –<>X*
_W <XX=* O $ '
' * &?" = – Y*
Q" jL " M _" " } >;<<*
' ! ' '
** "&2-" Y;;–Y<;*
' H O} M] >;;<* [ ' '%
*( $ '/+" <ZY;X–<ZY<<*
' H O} M] >;;=* M % $ * '"(&)" <Z –<Z @*
' H O} M] >;;@* [ \
* &?" <Y –==*
' WO" M _!" K !]O" O [" _ H" _H" >;;X* O $ } ! & ! ' $ * ( $ '&2-" @>?X–@>ZZ*
' WO _ H <XX<*' & & ! 2 ! *
!] <X@@* L$
'\ ^ $** ..)" <XX–>Z<*
K ! W [& >;;X* &! $ % ! % ! ^ * H*( %()"
Z;?–Z<Y*
K >;;@* K }
$ * H* $ &?&"
" L" ]" M M >;<;* _` \ *' 1 .)0" Z?–Y;*
M & H ! >;;?* ' "
K } W * + '& '0+" >=Y–> *
Z<
M !Lj <XXY* \ ' % *("(."
<–?>*
M' >;;X* H/$ } $ $*$
. &2" <XY–>;Y*
M O" & R]" K W >;;X* ] * ( ' (/-" >><–>??*
MK ]W" R" K W >;;@* ! $ OW ; K * H*+ ' +"&(" ?X–ZX*
MK ]" R" K >;;@* K OW ; K ' ! $%
* H*( %(&" <;YX–<;=Y*
MK ] K >;;X* OW ; O K $ ! %
\ %$'* ")" <<–<@*
MK _]" M W]" ' M" !L >;<;* \ ' $ $ K *$3 ( &++" <–Z*
MK _]" W K " L} " W " ! !H" ! } [" >;<;*
$ ' *$ ".-0" =< –=><*
M´ _" [%] `" ´ __" M >;; * L '+ *$3 ( &?-" ZY–YY*
M W >;;Y* ! \ / * ( ')+/" Y?–=<*
M _!" O [" [" ] M" _ K !" ! " >;<<* [
'
<> K * "." Z<–ZX*
M _!" O [" WK ]" W " j _ >;;=* j O K "
` \ % * 1 (.&" >?Y–
>Z=*
M _!" O [" W " j _ >;; * O} ^ ' *1 %)2" >?>>–>???*
M _!" !" W " j _ >;;?* % } /
* " & H* &)" <@< –<@>X*
M} ' [ >;;=* M % % * $ &-?" @Y?–@==*
/ H >;;Z* \ * . (--* ]`\ <ZX Z;<" <@?–>; *
$ ] W' L[ >;;<* L $ *'"
)/)" = ?–= X*
<X >* *( & +4 + (!* H* K* '"
R\ ! * M* ' / ]] W" ! " @<–X=*
_ [ >;;Y* H$ \ *
$3 ( &--" <;<–<<@*
Z>