Asearchfornoveltreatmentsagainstventriculararrhythmias
2of46
© Jonas Skogestad, 2020
Series of dissertations submitted to the Faculty of Medicine, University of Oslo
ISBN 978-82-8377-613-3
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be
reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without permission.
Cover: Hanne Baadsgaard Utigard.
Print production: Reprosentralen, University of Oslo.
3of46
Acknowledgments
TheworkinthisPhDthesiswascarriedoutattheInstituteforExperimentalMedicalResearch(IEMR) atOsloUniversityHospitalUllevålunderprincipalsupervisionofAssoiciateProfessorJanMagnus AronsenandcoͲsupervisionofProfessorIvarSjaastad.Theresearchwasfinanciallysupportedby AndersJahre´sfoundation,theResearchCurriculumStudentprogramatUiO,theNorwegian ResearchCouncil,SPARKNorwayandUiO:LifeScience.
Ifirststartedattheinstituteatamedicalstudentresearcherin2011,butthebeginningcanbetraced backtotheUnderwaterPubin2010whenNilsTovsrudnotifiedmethatHelsehøyskolenwaslooking fornewstudentteachers.IgotthejobandmetMagnusduringahistologyclass,whorecruitedmeto IEMR.UnderMagnus´sinspiringsupervision,Iwasgivenanacademicfreedomalmostwithout limitations,whichwasbothinspiringandgavemetheopportunitytoexploretherichnessofcardiac basicsciences.Frommyperspective,thisjourneyhasbeenintellectuallyrewardingandwehave accomplishedsomescientificachievementsthatweallcanbeproudof.
Firstandforemost,IwouldliketothankMagnusforthemanyyearsofexcitingscientific
collaboration.Becomingascientistwasachild´sdreamcomingtrue,andIwillalwaysremember theseyearsassomethingunique.Magnusisincrediblyinspiringtoworkwith,alwaysbringingnew ideastothetableandalwaysallowingmetoputmyindividualfootprintonthework.Thankyoufor allyoureffortsandpassion,ithasbeenanhonortoworkwithyou.Healsogatheredatalented groupofresearcherstogether,inwhatwecalledthe“PDEgroup”,whichconsistedofIngrid,Mira, SerenaandGustav.Ihavebeentrulyluckytoworkwithyouall.AspecialthanksstilltoIngrid,forour collaborationandconversationsduringthelastcoupleofyears.
WhenIstartedattheinstitute,Ivaropenedthedoorandgavemethechance.Thankyoualsoforthe highgradeofindependencethatyougavemeandMagnus,whichenabledustoexploredifferent scientificdirections.Finally,Iwouldalsothankyouforbeingmy“privatecardiologist”duringthe yearsof“geneticuncertainty”.
ThesocialenvironmentatIEMRhasalwaysbeenspecial,andIwillmissthediscussionsduringlunch.
IwillmentionMichael,ArneOlav,BillandPerAndreasinparticular,forbeingmylunchpartnersover alltheseyears.
Severalotheralsodeservementioning,althoughyourfullandindispensablecontributionscannotbe accountedforinthisshortsection.FredrikandMathisforteachingmepatchclamp.Karinafor teachingmecellisolations.Maniforallyouraltruism.ProfessorOleSejerstedforintroducingmeto therealmofsodiumandNKA.ProfessorFinnOlavLevyandLiseMoltzauforopeningthedooratthe departmentofpharmacology,OUSRH.Royformakingallthesesmallandcomplicatedtechnical things.Drs.EmmaRobinsonandCathrineCarlssonandMarianneLundeforyourimportantscientific contributions.AndtoIdaforyourpersonalsupport,Itrulyappreciateit.Thankyouall.
Finally,Ineedtoexpressmydeepestaffectiontomyfamily.Wordsareinsufficient.Thisthesisis dedicatedtomyfather,whoismymostimportantrolemodelandwhoalwayshasbelievedinme.
4of46
5of46
Contents
Acknowledgments... ....3
1Abbreviations... ...7
2Summary... ...9
3Listofpapers... ...10
4Introduction... ...11
4.1Cardiacarrhythmias...11
4.1.1Ventriculartachyarrhythmias...11
4.2Cellularmechanismsofventriculartachyarrhythmias...13
4.2.1Hypokalemia...14
4.2.2ArrhythmiamechanismsinAnkyrinBsyndrome...15
4.3NKAͲmediatedregulationofNCXactivity...15
4.4Currentandfutureantiarrhythmictreatmentstrategies...17
4.4.1Currentantiarrhythmictreatments...17
4.4.2Developmentofnewantiarrhythmictreatments...17
5Mainaim... ...19
5.1Specificaims... .19
6Methodsandresults...20
Paper1... ...20
Paper2... ...20
Paper3... ...20
Paper4... ...21
7Methodologicalconsiderations...22
7.1Animalmodels...22
7.1.1Ethicalconsiderations...22
7.1.2Rodentmodels...22
7.1.3Aorticbanding...22
7.1.4Transgenicmodelsvsdisruptorpeptides...23
7.1.5Ventriculararrhythmiasinvivo...23
7.2Cellisolation... .24
7.3Electrophysiology...24
7.3.1Fluorescentdyes...24
7.3.2NKAcurrents...25
7.3.3Globalandlocal[Na+]measurements...25
7.3.4Cellulararrhythmias–Ca2+wavesandafterdepolarizations...26
7.4Statistics... ...27
6of46
8Discussion... ...28
8.1ReducedNKAactivity–aproarrhythmicmechanism?...28
8.1.1Hypokalemia...28
8.1.2AnkyrinBsyndrome...29
8.1.3NKA–anupstreamnoderegulatingCaMKIIactivityandventriculararrhythmias?...29
8.2NKAɲ2/NCXasanupstreamregulatorofarrhythmias–dependenceoflocalNa+gradients....31
8.2.1NKAɲ2asapreferentialregulatorofNCXactivity...31
8.2.2TheroleofintracellularNa+gradientsinNKAregulationofNCX...32
8.3PDE2inhibitionasanovelantiarrhythmicconcept...33
8.3.1PDEregulationoftheNKAcompartment...33
8.3.2PDE2inhibitionandNKAactivationpreventventriculararrhythmias...34
8.3.3PDE2inhibitionasapotentialtherapeutictargetinhumans...35
9Mainconclusions... .36
10References... ...37
7of46
1Abbreviations
AKAP–AͲkinaseanchoringprotein AnkB–AnkyrinB
AP–Actionpotential
APD–Actionpotentialduration ATP–Adenosinetriphosphate
BAPTA–1,2Ͳbis(oͲaminophenoxy)ethaneͲN,N,Nඁ,NඁͲtetraaceticacid CaMKII–Ca2+/CalmodulinͲdependentproteinkinaseII
cAMP–Cyclicadenosinemonophosphate cGMP–Cyclicguanosinemonophosphate
CICR–Ca2+ͲinducedCa2+release
CPVT–CatecholaminergicPolymorphicventriculartachycardia DAD–Delayedafterdepolarization
EAD–Earlyafterdepolarization
EͲCcoupling–ExcitationͲcontractioncoupling ECG–Electrocardiogram
EDTA–Ethylenediaminetetraaceticacid HF–Heartfailure
ICa–Ca2+current
ICD–Implantablecardioversiondefibrillator
IK1–InwardrectifyingK+current IKr–RapiddelayedrectifyingK+current IKs–SlowdelayedrectifyingK+current IKur–UltraͲrapiddelayedrectifyingK+current INa–Na+current
IP3–Inositoltriphosphate Ito–TransientoutwardK+current LTCC–LͲtypeCa2+channel MAB–Minimalankyrinbinding MI–Myocardialinfarction
mRNA–Messengerribonucleicacid
8of46
NCX–Na+/Ca2+exchanger
NHE–Na+/H+exchanger NKA–Na+/K+ͲATPase
ORAB–OͲringaortabanding PDE–Phosphodiesterase PKA–ProteinKinaseA PLM–Phospholemman
PVC–Prematureventricularcontraction RMP–Restingmembranepotential RyR–RyanodineReceptor
SA–Sinoatrial
SBFI–SodiumͲbindingbenzofurzanisophtalate SCD–Suddencardiacdeath
Ser–Serine
SERCA2–Sarco(Endo)plasmicReticulumCa2+ATPase2 SR–Sarcoplasmicreticulum
Thr–Threonine
VF–Ventricularfibrillation VT–Ventriculartachycardia
9of46
2Summary
Ventriculartachyarrhythmias,suchasventriculartachycardiaandventricularfibrillation,areleading causesofdeathworldwide,andareespeciallyprevalentinpatientswithchronicheartdisease.
Currentantiarrhythmictreatmentslackefficacyandhaveasevereburdenofsideeffects,highlighting theneedfornewandspecificantiarrhythmictreatments.
WehypothesizedthatreducedactivityoftheNa+/K+ͲATPase(NKA)couldleadtoCa2+overloadand arrhythmiasbyalteringtheactivityoftheNa+/Ca2+exchanger(NCX).Inpaper1,wefoundthat extracellular[K+]correspondingtomoderatehypokalemiainducedCa2+overloadandCa2+wavesin ratcardiomyocytesbyspecificallyreducingtheactivityofNKAɲ2,therebyalteringthe[Na+]sensed bytheNCX.Moreover,inpaper2,wefoundthatspecificdisruptionoftheNKAɲ2fromAnkyrinB (AnkB)ledtoalteredlocalregulationof[Na+]and[Ca2+]andincreasedfrequencyofCa2+wavesinrat cardiomyocytes,whichpotentiallyrepresentsanimportantproarrhythmicmechanismintheAnkyrin Bsyndrome.
Thefindingsinpaper1and2suggestthatNKAregulateslocal,NCXͲsensed[Na+],allowingthe NKA/NCXcomplextofunctionasanupstreammodulatorofarrhythmias.However,towhatextent [Na+]isdifferentiallyregulatedintheNKAcompartmentandwhethersuchlocalizedsubsarcolemmal Na+poolsexist,arenotknown.Inpaper3,wefoundthat[Na+]washeterogeneouslydistributed betweendifferentcompartmentsinthesubsarcolemmalspace,suggestingthat[Na+]canbe
discretelyregulatedinspecificdomains.Thisprovidesabiologicalbasisforthemainfindingsinpaper 1and2,andalsosuggestthattargetingtheNKA/NCXcomplex,duetothecompartmentalized regulationof[Na+]and[Ca2+],couldrepresentanopportunityforspecificantiarrhythmictreatments.
Inpaper4,wefoundthatinhibitionofphosphodiesterase2(PDE2)increasedNKAactivityand reducedintracellular[Ca2+]bymodulatingNCXactivityinratcardiomyocytes.PDE2inhibitors reducedthefrequencyofCa2+wavesandafterdepolarizationsindiseasedcardiomyocytes,and preventedventriculartachyarrhythmiasinmicewithheartfailureandingeneticallymodifiedmice resemblingtheAnkyrinBsyndrome.
ThisthesisthusconcludesthatreducedNKAactivityrepresentsanupstreammechanismfor
ventriculartachyarrhythmiasinchronicheartdiseasebylocallyregulatingtheNCXͲsensed[Na+],and thatPDE2inhibitorscouldrepresentanovelantiarrhythmictreatmentbyspecificallyactivatingNKA andlowerintracellular[Ca2+].
10of46
3Listofpapers
Paper1
HypokalemiainducesCa2+overloadandCa2+wavesinventricularmyocytesbyreducingNKAɲ2 activity
AronsenJM*,SkogestadJ*,LewalleA,LouchWE,HougenK,StokkeMK,SwiftF,NiedererS,SmithNP, SejerstedOM,SjaastadI(2015).*Equalcontribution
JournalofPhysiology,Mar15.
Paper2
CouplingoftheNa+/K+ͲATPasetoankyrinBcontrolsNa+/Ca2+exchangeactivityincardiomyocytes
SkogestadJ,AronsenJM,TovsrudN,WanichawanP,HougenK,StokkeMK,CarlsonCR,SjaastadI, SejerstedOM,SwiftF(2019).
CardiovascularJournal,2019Apr5
Paper3
EvidenceforheterogeneoussubsarcolemmalNa+levelsinratventricularmyocytes SkogestadJ,LinesGT,LouchWE,SejerstedOM,SjaastadI,AronsenJM(2019).
AmericanJournalofPhysiology–HeartandCirculatoryphysiology,2019May1
Paper4
Phosphodiesterase2inhibitionactivatestheNa+/K+ͲATPaseandpreventsventriculartachycardia
SkogestadJ,RobinsonEL*,MellebyAO*,BørstadM,LundeM,MarshallS,AlbertI,SjaastadI,Carlson CR,AronsenJM.*Equalcontribution
Manuscript
11of46
4Introduction
Fromthefirstfeebleheartbeatsinyourmother’swombuntillife’sfinalmoment,theheartdiligently pumpsbloodtoprovidetheentirebodywithnutrientsandoxygen.Cardiovasculardiseaseisa leadingcauseofmorbidityandmortality[1],andcommonheartdiseasesincludemyocardial infarction(MI),heartfailure(HF),andgeneticdiseases(e.g.hypertrophiccardiomyopathyandlong QTsyndromes).Despitethedifferentetiologiesofchroniccardiacdisease,acommoncauseofdeath inthesepatientsislethalrhythmdisorders(ventriculartachyarrhythmias).Currentlyused
antiarrhythmicdrugshavesuboptimalefficacyandahighsideeffectburden,andthereisaclear unmetneedfornewantiarrhythmictreatments.Thus,theoverallaimofthisthesishasbeento identifynovelmoleculartreatmenttargetsagainstventriculartachyarrhythmias.
4.1Cardiacarrhythmias
Eachheartbeat,andhencehumanlife,isdependentonasynchronizedcontractionandrelaxationof 3Ͳ5billioncardiomyocytes[2].Thenormalandsteadyheartrhythm,thesinusrhythm,isinitiatedby aspecializedgroupofmyocytesinthesinoatrial(SA)node,whichgeneratesanelectriccurrentthat rapidlyspreadsthroughtheheartthroughtheconductionsystem.Thiscausesaneffectiveand synchronouscardiaccontractionbyinducingopeningofvoltageͲgatedCa2+channels,leadingtoCa2+
influxandsarcomereshortening[3].Theprocessthatlinkselectricalexcitationwithcontractionin individualcardiomyocytesiscalledexcitationͲcontractioncoupling(EͲCcoupling),brieflysummarized inFigure1.However,inawidevarietyofcardiacpathologies,theconductionsystembecomes defectiveorpathologicalrhythmgeneratorsintheatriaorventriclesdevelop.Thismayleadtoan abnormalheartrhythm,collectivelycoinedarrhythmias.
Arrhythmiascanbeclassifiedaccordingtotheirorigin(atrialorventricular)andtheirpace(bradyͲor tachyarrhythmiaswhenthearrhythmiaisslowerorfaster,respectively,thanthesinusrhythm).The prevalenceisusuallyinverselyrelatedtotheseverityofthearrhythmia.E.g.prematureatrial contractionsarealmostuniversallypresenteveninthehealthypopulation[4],butrepresentsa clinicalproblemonlyinexceedinglyrareoccasions.Atrialfibrillationisrelativelycommon(e.g.
prevalenceisabout4%inEuropeansaged60Ͳ70)anddoublestheriskofdeath,mainlyduetoafiveͲ foldriskofstroke[5].Finally,themostseveretypearrhythmiasareventriculartachyarrhythmias (ventriculartachycardia(VT)andventricularfibrillation(VF)),whicharelifeͲthreateningunless properlyaddressedimmediately.AlthoughVT/VFarerareinthehealthypopulation,theyrepresenta seriousclinicalproblemforpatientswithcardiacdisease[6].
4.1.1Ventriculartachyarrhythmias
VTisarapid(>100beats/min)rhythmoriginatingfromtheventricles,whichacutelythreatensto compromisethehemodynamicstabilityofthepatient.VTcanalsodeteriorateintoVF,wherethe ventriclesfibrillateandareunabletopumpblood.VTcommonlyandVFinevitablyleadstosudden cardiacarrest,andpreventionofVT/VFiscriticalinpatientsatrisk.MIrepresentsthemostcommon causeofVT/VF,whereVT/VFarepresentin5Ͳ10%ofpatientsadmittedtothehospital,while additional5%ofthepatientswilldevelopVT/VFwithinthenext48hours[6,7].VT/VFarealsoan importantcauseofdeathinHF.E.g.about20Ͳ30%ofHFdeathsarecausedbyVT/VFwithout concomitantworseningofpumpcapacity[8].EarlytrialsshowedanageͲadjustedfiveͲfoldriskof suddencardiacdeath(SCD)amongHFpatients[9,10],althoughtheriskofSCDhasdeclinedinlater trials,probablyduetoimplementationofevidenceͲbasedmedications[11].Nevertheless,50Ͳ80%of
12of46
patientswithHFhavenonͲsustainedVTduring24ͲhourHolterelectrocardiogram(ECG)registration [12,13],emphasizingthehighprevalenceofventriculartachyarrhythmiasinHFpatients.
Figure1:OverviewofEͲCcouplingandcardiaccontraction.(a)Thewallofheart(i)consistsofthreelayers:pericardium, myocardium,andendocardium(ii).Myocardiumisthecontractingelementoftheheart,comprisingbillionsofindividual cardiomyocytesinanadulthumanheart.Theouterboundaryofacardiomyocyte(iii)issarcolemma,whichhasregular invaginations,TͲtubules,tofacilitateefficientpropagationoftheelectricalsignalandcardiaccontraction.(b)Schematic overviewofEͲCcoupling.Na+channelopening(1)depolarizesthemembranepotential,leadingtoopeningofLͲtypeCa2+
channels(LTCC)andCa2+influx(2).Ca2+bindingtoRyanodineReceptors(RyR)triggersreleaseoftheintracellular sarcoplasmicreticulum(SR)Ca2+stores(3),andthereleasedCa2+bindsthemyofilaments,causingcardiaccontraction.
RelaxationisinducedbyCa2+extrusion(4),eitherintotheSRthroughSarco(Endo)plasmicReticulumCa2+ATPase2 (SERCA2)oracrossthesarcolemmathroughtheNa+/Ca2+exchanger(NCX),whichexchangesCa2+for3Na+.NKAremoves theNa+thatenteredthecellduringEͲCcoupling(5).(c)Thetimingoftheactionpotential(AP),cellularCa2+fluxesand contraction.(d)ThetimingandsizeofthemajorcurrentsconstitutingtheAP.
Other,rarercausesofVT/VFincludecongenitalchannelopathies(longQTsyndrome,
catecholaminergicpolymorphicventriculartachycardia(CPVT),andBrugadasyndrome),acommon causeofSCDinpersonsbelowtheageof35[14],electrolytedisturbances(suchashyperͲand
13of46
hypokalemia),andsideeffectstoQTͲprolongingdrugs(suchastricyclicantidepressantsand antiarrhythmicdrugs)[6,15].
Insummary,VT/VFarebothprevalentandanimportantcauseofSCDincardiacpatients.Inorderto developnewpharmacologicaltreatmentsagainstVT/VF,itisnecessarywithacomprehensive understandingoftheunderlyingcellularmechanismsresponsibleforinducingventricular tachyarrhythmiasincardiacpatients.
4.2Cellularmechanismsofventriculartachyarrhythmias
ThetwomainmechanismsforVTarereͲentryandtriggeredarrhythmias.Althoughregularly describedastwoseparateentities,bothmechanismsareofteninvolvedintheinitiationand
maintenanceofaVT.MostVTsinnonͲischemicHFandabout50%ofVTsinischemicHFareinitiated bytriggeredarrhythmias,andthenoftenmaintainedbyreͲentrymechanisms[16,17].InreͲentry arrhythmias,thereisastructural(fibrosis,scarring)orelectrophysiologicalabnormality(e.g.delayed regionalconduction)thatcausesanabnormalelectricalcircuit.ThetypicalexampleisreͲentry circuitsaroundapostͲMIscar[18].Triggeredarrhythmiasarecausedbyearlyafterdepolarizations (EADs)ordelayedafterdepolarizations(DADs),whicharespontaneousfluctuationsofthemembrane potentialduringanactionpotential(AP).Ifthespontaneousdepolarizationreachesathreshold,a new,abnormalspontaneousAParises.Whenthisoccurssimultaneouslyinasufficientnumberof cardiomyocytes,anectopicbeatisgenerated,potentiallyinducingaVT[19,20].
DADsarecausedbyaseriesofeventsthatstartswithspontaneousCa2+releasefromthe
SarcoplasmicReticulum(SR)throughtheRyanodineReceptors(RyR),calledspontaneousCa2+sparks.
ThisoccursinsituationwhereSRCa2+concentration,theSRCa2+load,isincreasedabovethe
thresholdforrelease,orwhenthethresholdforreleaseisreduced,i.e.whenRyRopenprobabilityis increased[21,22].IfthespontaneousCa2+sparksaresufficientlylargetoactivatetheneighboring RyRs,thenthespontaneousCa2+releasecanspreadalongtheSRasaCa2+wave[23](Figure2a).The Ca2+releasedduringtheCa2+waveisthenextrudedacrossthesarcolemmabytheNa+/Ca2+
exchanger(NCX),whichgeneratesaninward,depolarizingcurrent,Iti[3].Itiisobservedasa
fluctuationofthemembranepotential,aDAD,duringtherestingphaseoftheAP(Figure2b).EADs occurduringtheplateauphaseoftheAPorearlyintherepolarizingphase,andtheyaremainly causedbyreducedrepolarizationreserve,i.e.increasedinwardCa2+currentsorreducedoutwardK+ currents,orbyCa2+waves[24Ͳ26].DuetotheprotectivesourceͲsinkmismatch,600000Ͳ800000 cardiomyocytesmustdevelopafterdepolarizationsinordertogenerateaPVCinahealthyheart, althoughthisissignificantlyreducedincardiacdisease[27,28].
Previously,digitalisͲderiveddrugswerewidelyusedasinotropicagentsinHF,butdigitalistoxicityhas longbeenrecognizedasacauseoftriggeredarrhythmias[29].Themechanismofbothcardiac inotropyandarrhythmiasisbelievedtobeinhibitionoftheNa+/K+ͲATPase(NKA)withsubsequent riseinintracellularCa2+concentration[Ca2+]duetoalteredNCXactivity[30].ReducedNKAactivity hasalsobeenproposedtobeinvolvedinthearrhythmogenesisofhypokalemia[31]andAnkyrinB syndrome[32],butmorestudiesareneededtoconfirmthehypothesisofNKAasanupstream modulatorofarrhythmias.Inthisthesis,weaimedtoinvestigatewhetherreducedNKAactivityis involvedasaproarrhythmicmechanisminhypokalemiaandtheAnkyrinBsyndrome,asintroduced inthefollowingparagraphs.
14of46
Figure2:MechanismforconversionofCa2+wavesintoafterdepolarizations(a)SpontaneouslyreleasedCa2+ionsfromthe SR,aspontaneousCa2+spark,havethreepossiblefates.(I)ReͲpumpingbackintotheSR.(II)ActivationofnearbyRyR, leadingtofurtherreleaseofSRCa2+.Ifensuing,thismaytriggeraCa2+wave.(III)SomeofthereleasedCa2+isexchanged acrossthesarcolemmathroughNCX.SinceNCXmovesanevenamountofcharges(3Na+for1Ca2+),thisleadstoa depolarizationofthecellmembrane,calledadelayedafterdepolarization(DAD).(b)IftheDADreachesthresholdforNa+ channelopening,aspontaneousAPoccur.Reprintedfrom[33].
4.2.1Hypokalemia
HypokalemiaisdefinedasserumK+<3.5mMandisawellͲrecognizedriskfactorforVTs,inparticular TorsadesDePointesandVF[34,35].Hypokalemiaispresentinnearly20%ofhospitalizedpatients [36,37],with5%ofpatientshavingserumK+<3.0mM[36].Thiscorrespondstomoderate
hypokalemia,withanincreasedriskofcardiacarrhythmias[34].Themostcommoncauseof hypokalemiaisdiuretics,oftenusedbyHFpatientsalreadysusceptibletocardiacarrhythmias[38].
Hypokalemiainducesamultitudeofeffectsontheheartpossiblycontributingtothe
arrhythmogenesis.ThisincludesfunctionalreͲentrycircuits(duetoregionalvariabilityinconduction velocityandactionpotentialduration(APD)),reducedcardiacrepolarizationreserve,andincreased intracellularCa2+[31,38].ThelatterwasexploredbyEisneretal.alreadyin1979,wheretheyfound thatPurkinjefibersexposedtoK+ͲdepletedsolutionsdevelopedaftercontractionsdependentonNKA [39,40].However,sinceNKAishalfͲactivatedbyextracellularK+at1.5Ͳ2.0mM[41],andveryfew patientsdevelopK+<2.0mM,theclinicalrelevanceofthesedataisquestionable.Inaddition,others havereportedthatlowextracellular[K+]reducesratherthanincreasesintracellular[Ca2+][42].Thus, inpaper1,ouraimwastoinvestigatewhetherNKAinhibitioninducedbymoderatehypokalemia(2.7
15of46
mM)isanupstreammechanismfortheensuingCa2+overload.Further,sinceNKAɲ2hasalower affinityforextracellular[K+]thanNKAɲ1andisknowntopreferentiallyregulateintracellular[Ca2+], wehypothesizedthattheeffectsofhypokalemiaonintracellular[Ca2+]weredependentonNKAɲ2.
4.2.2ArrhythmiamechanismsinAnkyrinBsyndrome
SpecificmutationsintheAnk2geneoftenleadtoacomplex,inheritablearrhythmiasyndrome referredtoas“AnkyrinBsyndrome”(previouslyLongQTsyndrometype4),characterizedbysinus bradycardia,conductionabnormalities,andVTs[32,43Ͳ45].TheAnk2genecodesforAnkyrinB (AnkB),ananchoringproteinthatassemblesNKA,NCX,andinositoltriphosphate(IP3)receptorsin macromolecularcomplexes[46].ThisfacilitateslocalregulationofNa+andCa2+,andtheAnkB+/Ͳmice exhibitsdysfunctionalregulationofCa2+,leadingtocardiacarrhythmias[47,48],buttheroleofNKAͲ mediatedregulationofNCXͲsensed[Na+]inpromotingarrhythmiasisnotknown.However,the molecularmechanismsarenoteasilyinferredfromstudiesontheAnkB+/Ͳmice,astheprotein assembly,proteintraffickingandexpressionofNKAandNCXarealteredinthismodel[32,46].Thus, inpaper2,weaimedtospecificallystudytheeffectofdisruptingNKAfromitsbindingsiteonAnkB onNCXͲsensed[Na+]andcellulararrhythmias.Tothisend,wesynthesizedadisruptorpeptidebased ontheMinimalAnkyrinͲBinding(MAB)domainonNKA,a25aminoacidresidueontheɲsubunitthat mediatesbindingtoAnkB[49].Wehypothesizedthatdisruptionofthisdomainwouldalterlocal [Na+]and[Ca2+]andleadtoCa2+waves,therebyprovidingevidencefortheNKA/NCXcomplexasan upstreamregulatorofcardiacarrhythmias.
4.3NKAͲmediatedregulationofNCXactivity
NKAhasforlongbeenrecognizedasaregulatorofintracellular[Ca2+]andcardiaccontractilityby regulatingintracellular[Na+].ThismodulatestheactivityofNCX,whichextrudes1Ca2+for3Na+ions, providinganinterfaceforNa+andCa2+regulation.NKAregulationofNCXhastwoaspectsof
particularimportanceforphysiologicalregulationofcardiaccontractility,andpotentiallyalsoforthe developmentofarrhythmias.First,theevidencesuggestthatNKAregulationofNCXisisoformͲ dependent,and,second,NKAregulationofNCXͲsensed[Na+]isprobablycompartmentalized,i.e.
dependentonintracellularNa+gradients.Thesetwoaspectsarestudiedinthisthesisandare introducedinthefollowingparagraphs.
ϰ͘ϯ͘ϭE<ɲϮƌĞŐƵůĂƚĞƐĐĂƌĚŝĂĐĐŽŶƚƌĂĐƚŝůŝƚLJ
NKAconsistsoftwosubunits,ɲandɴ,andintheheart,therearethreedifferentNKAɲisoforms[50, 51].NKAɲ1isthedominantisoform(70Ͳ95%)inhumanandrodenthearts,whereasNKAɲ2exhibitsa lowerexpression(10Ͳ30%)[52Ͳ55].WhilehumanheartsexpressNKAɲ3[53],thedataismore uncertainregardingNKAɲ3expressioninrodents[56Ͳ58].NKAɲ1isubiquitouslyexpressedinthe membrane,whereasNKAɲ2clustersintheTͲtubules [55].SeveralgroupshaveshownthatNKAɲ2 playsanimportantincontrollingcardiaccontractility[54,59,60],potentiallybyregulatinglocal[Na+] closetoNCX[61,62],andtherebymodulatingintracellular[Ca2+][59].
Twoaspectsofparticularimportanceforthisthesisare:
1. AnkyrinBisananchoringproteinthatassemblesNKA,NCXandIP3receptorsinamacromolecular complex[46],possiblyfacilitatingcompartmentalizedregulationofNa+andCa2+.Althoughboth NKAɲ1andNKAɲ2coͲimmunoprecipitatewithAnkyrinB,itisnotknownwhetherthedomainsare functionallysimilar.Inpaper2,weexploredthepossibilitythatNKAɲ1andNKAɲ2bindingto
16of46
AnkyrinBdifferedfunctionally,andhypothesizedthatNKAɲ2bindingtoAnkyrinBwasimportant forregulationoflocal[Na+]and[Ca2+]andforthedevelopmentofcellulararrhythmias.
2. ThehalfͲmaximalactivationofNKA,k0.5,forintracellular[Na+]is8Ͳ25mM[51,63],butthe intracellular[Na+]dependencyissimilarbetweenNKAɲ1andNKAɲ2[64].Incontrast,NKAɲ1has alowerextracellular[K+]dependency( 1.3mM)comparedtoNKAɲ2( 2.7mM)[41].This difference makes the NKAɲ2 activity more susceptible to changes in extracellular K+ at physiologicallevels(3.5Ͳ5mM),butitiscurrentlyunknownhowNKAactivityisregulatedat pathologicallylow[K+]e(i.e.hypokalemia).Inpaper1,wehypothesizedthathypokalemiaͲinduced arrhythmiaswasmediatedbyNKAɲ2.
ϰ͘ϯ͘Ϯ>ŽĐĂůEĂнƉŽŽůƐĂŶĚƐƵďƐĂƌĐŽůĞŵŵĂůƐƉĂĐĞ
SeveralpublicationssuggestthatNKAɲ2preferentiallyregulates[Ca2+]andcardiaccontractility comparedtoNKAɲ1[54,59Ͳ62,65,66],andthisisexplainedbytheabilityofNKAɲ2inregulating localpoolsof[Na+][62,67,68].However,theconceptoflocalNa+poolsishighlycontroversial[69Ͳ 71].Basicchemistrysuggeststhationswouldfreelyandrapidlydiffuseandequilibrateinacell, preventinganylocalaccumulationofNa+ions.Nevertheless,severallinesofevidenceindicatethat localpoolsofNa+doexist,althoughtheexactnatureofthesepoolsremainelusive.Leblancand HumewerethefirsttoshowthatNa+influxthroughNa+channelswassufficienttoinduceCa2+Ͳ inducedCa2+release(CICR)byactivatingreverseNCX[72].Thisfindingrequiredrestricteddiffusion ofNa+withinacellularcompartmentcoined“fuzzyspace”,anundefinedandsmallspacebeneath themembrane,inwhichNa+channels,NCXandRyRreside[73].Sincethen,severalstudieshave shownthatNa+couldaccumulateinsubmembranecompartmentsnotdirectlyinvolvedinCICR (includingNKA)[54,60,74Ͳ77],andtheterm“subsarcolemmalspace”referstotheideaofadiffuse submembranelayerwithrestrictedmovementofNa+andwithdifferentconcentrationofNa+ comparedtobulkcytosol[68].
Adifferentpossibilityisthatthereareseveralsubmembranecompartmentswithdistinctive
regulationof[Na+],where[Na+]islocallyincreased(“hotspots”)orreduced(“coldspots”)dependent onlocalNa+influxorefflux[68].Theideaofaheterogeneoussubsarcolemmalspacecouldexplain whythereapparentlyisnoNa+accumulationaroundNHE[78],whilestudiesthathaveusedNKAasa sensorofsubsarcolemmal[Na+]concludesdifferently[75Ͳ77].Thehypothesisofaheterogeneous subsarcolemmalspacewith“hotspots”ofNa+isintriguingbecauseitcouldprovideabasisforNKAɲ2 asapreferentialregulatorofNCXͲsensed[Na+]andtherebyintracellular[Ca2+]andcardiac
contractility.Thus,inpaper3,weinvestigatedwhetherNa+wasdifferentiallyregulatedbetweenthe Na+channelandtheNKAcompartments.
Inthisthesis,amainhypothesisisthatNKAisanupstreammodulatorofventriculararrhythmiasby regulatinglocal,NCXͲsensed[Na+].Byextension,wehypothesizedthatincreasingNKAactivitymight holdpromiseasanantiarrhythmicstrategy.Theprospectoftargetingapotentialupstream
mechanismofventriculararrhythmiashaspotentialbenefitsoverthecurrenttreatments,which havelimitedefficacyandunfavorablesideeffects.
17of46
4.4Currentandfutureantiarrhythmictreatmentstrategies
4.4.1CurrentantiarrhythmictreatmentsCurrentpharmacologicalantiarrhythmictreatmentscanbeclassifiedasclassIͲIVaccordingtothe classicalVaughanWilliamsscheme:ClassIisNa+channelblockers,classIIbetaͲblockers,classIIIK+ channelblockers,andclassIVCa2+channelblockers[6,79].Digitalisisantiarrhythmicdrugthat worksbyinhibitingNa+/K+ͲATPase(NKA)(andhencefallsoutsidethissimpleschematics),which currentlyisprimarilyusedtotreatatrialfibrillationinHF.Inaddition,althoughamiodaroneis classifiedasaclassIIIantiarrhythmic,ithasabroadclassIͲIVeffect[79].
Betablockersaretheonlyantiarrhythmicdrugsusedforprimaryorsecondarypreventionwitha proveneffectonmortalityinlargerandomizedclinicaltrials[6,64,80].Theexactmortalityreducing effectsofbetablockersaredifficulttoidentify,asbetablockersexertabroadrangeofeffects[81], andonestudyfoundnoreductioninarrhythmicdeathdespiteanoverallreductioninmortality[82].
However,betablockersappeartohaveahighlyprotectiveeffectinpatientswithlongQTsyndrome (withstructurallynormalhearts)[6,83],althoughnorandomized,doubleͲblind,placeboͲcontrolled trialshavebeenperformedduetotheethicalaspectsofrandomizingpatientsatriskofsudden cardiacdeathtoreceiveplacebotreatment.
Besidesbetablockers,severaloftheantiarrhythmicdrugshaveseveresideeffects,e.g.classIantiͲ arrhythmicdrugs(e.g.flecanideandlidocaine)andsomeclassIIIdrugs(e.g.dronedarone)are contraindicatedinstructuralheartdisease(e.g.postͲMIandHF)duetoaproarrhythmicriskand increasedmortality[6,84].Inaddition,Ca2+channelblockershavenegativeinotropiceffectswith littleeffectonVT[85,86],andhavenoroleinpreventionofVTinHF.Finally,amiodaronehasalong halfͲlifeinbloodandaccumulatesinorgans,causingorgantoxicity(e.g.thyroidglandandlungs)in about20%ofpatients[87].SeveraltrialshaveshownthatanImplantableCardioverterDefibrillator (ICD)reducesmortalitywhenusedinselectedpatientpopulations[88Ͳ90],butthereducedriskof SCDcouldinsomepatientpopulationsbeoffsetbyincreasedriskofdeviceinfectionsandby inappropriateshocks[91,92].
4.4.2Developmentofnewantiarrhythmictreatments
DespitethedevelopmentofthecurrentevidenceͲbasedtreatmentforHF,includingintroductionof ICDs,ventriculararrhythmiasandsuddencardiacdeathremainaprevalentclinicalproblem.Lackof sufficientantiarrhythmicprotectionisalsorelevantforpostͲMIandthechannelopathies,including longQTsyndromes,CPVT,andAnkyrinBsyndrome.Themainproblemofcurrenttreatmentsis, besideslackofefficacy,ahighburdenofsideeffects,whichlimitsthenumberofantiarrhythmic drugsavailableforuseandalso,inmanycases,preventstheuseofoptimaldosages.E.g.beta
blockershaveabroadrangeofintracellularpharmacologicaleffects,givingrisetoseveralsideeffects (e.g.bradycardia,dizziness,fatigue)thatpreventsmanypatientsfromreachingtheevidenceͲbased targetdoseusedinclinicaltrials[93].Otherantiarrhythmicdrugs,suchasNa+channelandK+ channelblockers,haveabroadandunfavorableelectrophysiologicalprofile,prolongingtheAPand theQTinterval[94,95],increasingtheriskofTorsadedesPointesandSCDinstructuralheartdisease [96Ͳ98].
Toovercometheselimitations,newantiarrhythmicstrategiescouldfocusontargetingspecific signalingdomainstoreduceundesiredintracellularpharmacologicaleffects.Inaddition,targeting
18of46
compartmentalizedionregulationcouldalsopreventAPprolongationandreducetheriskof proarrhythmicsideeffects.
ϭ͘ϰ͘Ϯ͘ϭdĂƌŐĞƚŝŶŐƐƉĞĐŝĨŝĐƐŝŐŶĂůŝŶŐĂŶĚŝŽŶĐŽŵƉĂƌƚŵĞŶƚƐ͗<WƐĂŶĚWƐ
Oneapproachtoachievespecificnewtherapiesistotargetlocalsignalingdomains,e.g.distinct cAMPcompartments.CatecholaminesandprostaglandinEgiveasimilarintracellularincreaseinthe secondmessengercAMP,butthefunctionalresponsesareverydifferent[99].Thisisdueto
compartmentationofthecAMPsignaling[99Ͳ102],facilitatedbyAͲkinaseanchoringproteins (AKAPs),whichassembledifferentproteinsinvolvedincAMPsignaling,includingadenylylcyclases, phosphodiesterases(PDEs),proteinkinases,andphosphatases,inuniquesignalingdomains[103].
ThismoleculararrangementallowsdifferentialregulationofcAMPanditsdownstreameffectsin differentintracellularcompartments.OfparticularimportanceforthefineͲtuningofthecAMPsignal aredifferentisoformsofPDEs,whichdegradecAMP(andcGMP)withdifferentkineticsandmaximal velocity[104].TargetingisoformsofPDEsinuniquecompartmentsmightbeastrategyfor
developingspecificandefficienttreatmentswithlessundesiredeffects.
OnesuchcompartmentistheNKAcompartment,andacentralhypothesisofthisthesisisthatNKA activationcouldbeanovelantiarrhythmicstrategy.ThiscouldbeachievedbytargetingspecificPDE regulationoftheNKAcompartment,butcompartmentalizedɴͲadrenergicregulationoftheNKA compartmentisscarcelystudied.AprimaryregulatorofNKAactivityisphospholemman(PLM),a smallaccessoryprotein(72aminoacids)thatreversiblyinhibitsNKAactivity,mainlybyreducingthe affinityforintracellular[Na+][105].PLMhasthreephosphorylationsites,Serine(Ser)63,Ser68,and Ser69,whereSer68istheProteinKinaseA(PKA)site[106,107].ɴͲadrenergicstimulationincreases thephosphorylationofPLMatSer68,whichrelievestheinhibitoryactionofPLMandincreasesNKA activity[108],andɴͲadrenergicactivationofNKAisimportantissituationswithincreasedNa+ loading,e.g.exercise[105].ArecentstudyfoundthatPDE2andPDE3werethemainregulatorsof cyclicadenosinemonophosphate(cAMP)inthePLMcompartment[109],butalthoughAKAP150is showntointeractwithNKAinparotidglands[110,111],PDE/AKAPͲmediatedregulationofNKAhas notbeenshownincardiomyocytes.Inpaper4,westudiedcompartmentalizedregulationofNKAby PDEsandhypothesizedthattargetedactivationofNKAcouldbeanovelantiarrhythmicstrategy.
19of46
5Mainaim
TheoverallaimofthisthesisistoidentifyupstreammechanismsofVT,andusethesetodevelop novel,targetedtreatmentsagainstVT.
5.1Specificaims
1. TostudywhetherreducedNKAactivityoralteredactivityoftheNKA/NCXcomplexrepresent anupstreammechanismforarrhythmiasinhypokalemiaandAnkyrinBsyndrome.
2. ToinvestigatewhetherspecificsubmembraneNa+compartmentsarepresentandtheroleof localNa+poolsinregulatingtheactivityoftheNKA/NCXcomplex.
3. ToidentifyNKAactivatorsandtotestwhetherNKAactivationpreventsventricular tachyarrhythmiasinpreclinicalmicemodels.
20of46
6Methodsandresults
Themainmethodsandresultsfromthethesisarebrieflysummarizedinthissection.Acomplete overviewofmethodsandresultsisfoundintheattachedmanuscripts.
Paper1
HypokalaemiainducesCa²ЀoverloadandCa²ЀwavesinventricularmyocytesbyreducingNaЀ,KЀͲ ATPaseɲЇactivity
HypokalemiaisawellͲknownriskfactorforventriculararrhythmias,andinpaper2,weinvestigated theunderlyingcellularandelectrophysiologicalmechanismsinisolatedratcardiomyocytes.Low extracellularK+([K+]e=2.7mM),correspondingtomoderatehypokalemia,increasedCa2+transient amplitudeinfieldstimulatedcardiomyocytesthroughabiphasicresponse.Experimentsinvoltage clampedandfieldstimulatedcardiomyocytesshowedthatlow[K+]ereducedNKAcurrent,increased intracellular[Na+],increasedNCXͲsensed[Na+].ThisreducedNCXͲmediatedCa2+extrusion,leadingto agraduallyincreasedCa2+transientamplitude,Ca2+overloadandCa2+waves.Mathematical
modelingsuggestedthatthehypokalemiaͲinducedCa2+overloadwascausedbyreducedNKAactivity andreducedNCXͲmediatedCa2+extrusion,similartotheexperimentallyderivedresults.Specific inhibitionoftheɲ2isoformofNKApreventedhypokalemiaͲinducedCa2+overloadandincreased NCXͲsensed[Na+],suggestingthatNKAɲ2ismoresensitivetochangesinlow[K+]e.Ourdatasuggests thatreducedNKAɲ2activityandsubsequentreducedNCXͲmediatedCa2+extrusionmightbean importantmechanismofhypokalemiaͲinducedCa2+overloadandventriculararrhythmias.
Paper2
CouplingoftheNa+/K+ͲATPasetoAnkyrinBcontrolsNa+/Ca2+exchangeractivityincardiomyocytes
WefoundthatfunctionalinteractionbetweenNKAandNCXwasdisruptedinvoltageclamped AnkB+/Ͳmicecardiomyocytes,possiblycontributingtoincreasedriskofventriculararrhythmiasthis modelandinhumanAnkBsyndrome.However,duetoarangeofunspecificalterationsintheAnkB+/Ͳ mice,thismodelisnotoptimalforstudiesaimingtoinvestigatetheNKA/AnkB/NCXinteraction.To thisend,wesynthesizedadisruptorpeptide(MABpeptide)fortheNKA/AnkBinteractionbasedon publishedinteractionsequences.SimilartotheAnkB+/Ͳmice,dialysiswiththeMABpeptidereduced thefunctionalinteractionbetweenNKAandNCX,andincreasedNCXͲsensed[Na+]involtageclamped ratcardiomyocytes.TheMABpeptidedidnotalterglobalCa2+amplitudeorextrusioninfield
stimulatedcardiomyocytes,butcaffeineͲinducedCa2+extrusionwasslower,suggestingthatNCXͲ mediatedCa2+extrusionwasreduced.TheMABpeptidefurtherincreasedthefrequencyofCa2+
sparksandCa2+waveswithnoeffectonCa2+transientamplitude.InhibitionofNKAɲ2prevented increaseinNCXͲsensed[Na+]involtageclampedratcardiomyocytesandcellulararrhythmiasinfield stimulatedratcardiomyocytesfollowingNKA/AnkBdisruptionwiththeMABpeptide.Ourresults suggestthatNKAɲ2bindingtoAnkBisnecessaryforlocalregulationof[Na+]inaNCXͲsensed compartment,andthatdisturbedNKAɲ2/AnkBinteractioncouldbeaproarrhythmicmechanismin humanAnkyrinBsyndrome.
Paper3
EvidenceforheterogeneoussubsarcolemmalNa+levelsinratventricularmyocytes
ToinvestigatethepropertiesofsubsarcolemmalNa+,weperformedaseriesofexperimentsin voltageclampedratcardiomyocytes.WeestablishedaconcentrationͲresponserelationshipbetween
21of46
theNKAcurrentandintracellular[Na+],acurvethatwouldlaterbeusedtoestimateNKAͲsensed [Na+]basedonthemeasuredNKAcurrents.DuringlongͲtermexposuretophysiological[Na+](130 mM),therewasagradientbetween[Na+]intheNKAcompartmentandbulkcytosol.Shorttrainsof Na+currentsdidnotincreasedNKAͲsensed[Na+],whereasNa+accumulatedintheNKAcompartment followinglongertrainsofNa+currents,whichdissipatedveryslowlyfromtheNKAcompartment.We nextaimedtodeterminewhetherNa+accumulationinsubsarcolemmalspacewasdistributed homogeneouslyorheterogeneouslybetweentheNa+channelandNKAcompartment.Mathematical modelingpredictedthatifhomogeneouslydistributed,NKAͲsensed[Na+]wouldincreasemore following20secondsof6HzactivationofNa+currentscomparedto240secondsof1Hzactivation.
Whenexperimentallytested,wefoundtheoppositeresult,andmodelpredictingheterogeneity withinthesubsarcolemmalspacelargelyresolvedthediscrepancy.OurresultssuggeststhatNa+is differentiallyregulatedindifferentsubmembranecompartments,whichcouldhavegreatinfluence ontheregulationofNKA,cardiaccontractilityanddevelopmentofarrhythmias.
Paper4
Phosphodiesterase2inhibitionactivatestheNa+/K+ͲATPaseandpreventsventriculartachycardia WeinvestigatedPDEregulationofNKAandfoundthatinhibitionofPDE2,butnotPDE3orPDE4, increasedtheNKAcurrentinvoltageclampedratcardiomyocytes.NKAandPDE2coͲlocalizedinrat cardiomyocytes,asevidentbyproximityligationassay,andcoͲtransfectionofNKAandPDE2in HEK293cellsrevealedcoͲimmunoprecipitation.AluminescenceͲbasedcAMPassayrevealedthat therewasnoglobalincreaseincAMPfollowingPDE2inhibitioninratormicecardiomyocytes.Inline withthesefindings,disruptionofPKAͲRIIabolishedtheincreaseinNKAcurrentfollowingPDE2 inhibitioninvoltageclampedratcardiomyocytes.PDE2inhibitioninfieldstimulatedrat cardiomyocytesshowedreducedCa2+transientamplitudeandincreasedNCXͲmediatedCa2+
extrusionwithoutaglobalincreasein[Na+],suggestingthatPDE2functionallyregulatesalocal NKA/NCXdomain.VoltageclampexperimentsshowedthatPDE2inhibitiondidnotaltertheLͲtype Ca2+current,K+currents,ortheNa+current.PDE2inhibitionreducedCa2+wavesfrequencyinfield stimulatedandpreventedafterdepolarizationsinvoltageclampedAnkB+/Ͳcardiomyocytes.Acute inductionofventriculartachycardiawaspreventedinAnkB+/ͲmicepreͲinjectedwitheitherBay60Ͳ 7550orPF05180999,whichalsopreventedQTprolongation.Similarly,PDE2inhibitionincreasedthe NKAcurrent,reducedCa2+wavesandpreventedinvivoventriculartachycardiasinHFmice.CaMKII waslessautophosphorylated,suggestiveoflessactivity,inAnkB+/ͲandHFmicereceivingPDE2 inhibition.PKAͲRIIdisruptionwithsuperAKAPpreventedtheantiarrhythmiceffectofPDE2inhibition bothinfieldstimulatedcardiomyocytesandinvivoinbothAnkB+/ͲandHFmice,suggestingthatthe antiarrhythmiceffectofPDE2inhibitionistargetedanddependentuponregulationoflocalcAMP pools.ChronictreatmentwithaPDE2inhibitororthecombinationofPDE2inhibitorandmetoprolol wassuperiortometoprololaloneinpreventingventriculararrhythmiasinAnkB+/Ͳmice.RealͲtime quantitativePolymeraseChainReaction(RTͲqPCR)showedthatPDE2ͲmRNAwasupregulatedinflow sortedcardiomyocytenucleifromAnkB+/ͲandHFmiceandinhumancohortsofleftventricular hypertrophyandHF,suggestingthatPDE2couldbeatreatmenttargetinchronicheartdisease.Our findingsidentifyPDE2asamainregulatorofNKAactivity,andweshowthatPDE2inhibitionactivates NKA,preventscellularCa2+overload,andpreventsventriculartachycardiasinAnkB+/ͲandHFmice.
PDE2inhibitorsspecificallytargetingNKAmightbeafutureantiarrhythmictreatmentinhumans.
22of46
7Methodologicalconsiderations
Inthissection,Iaimtocriticallydiscussthecentralexperimentsandmethodsemployedtoreachthe conclusionsinthethesis.Theintentionisnottoprovidedetaileddescriptionsofalltheindividual methods(whicharefoundintheattachedmanuscripts),buttodiscussstrengthsandweaknessesof themethodsandwhetherthemethodsemployedareappropriatetosupporttheconclusions.
7.1Animalmodels
7.1.1Ethicalconsiderations
Ideally,allcellularexperimentswouldhavebeenperformedincellsisolatedfromhumansamples.
However,thisisnotfeasibleduetoethicalandpracticalconcerns,andbasicscientistscommonlyuse animalmodelsintheirstudies,whichofcourseevokesotherethicaldilemmas.Wehaveworked alongtheprinciplesofthe3R’s:Replace,reduceandrefine[112].Inparticular,wehaveemployeda micemodelofHFthatincreasesreproducibility,reducestheinterͲanimalvariationandreducesthe numberofanimalneeded[113].Inaddition,differentpeopleonthelabcollaboratedand
coordinatedexperimentswhenpossible,enablingseveralpeopletousecellsfromthesameanimal.
ExperimentsonmiceandratswereapprovedbytheNorwegianNationalAnimalResearch CommitteeandconformedtotheGuidefortheCareandUseofLaboratoryAnimals.
7.1.2Rodentmodels
Wehavemainlyusedrodents(miceandrats)inourexperiments.Rodentsarerelativelycheap,easy tohandle,andareconsideredarelevantanimalmodelforstudyingcardiacphysiologyand
pathophysiology[114]..However,therearesomeimportantdifferencesbetweentherodentand humanelectrophysiologythatneedtobeconsidered.Theheartrateisapproximately300beats/min and600beats/mininratsandmice,respectively,comparedto60Ͳ80beats/mininhumans.The fasterheartrateinrodentscorrespondstoamuchshorterAPD,andinmiceinparticular,wherethe APDisabout5Ͳ8timesshortercomparedtohumans(40Ͳ50msvs250Ͳ300ms)[115Ͳ117],mainly causedbyhighexpressionandactivityofItoinrodents[118].ThelargerItoleadstoaprominentnotch ontherodentAP,amorenegativeplateauphasepotentialand,hence,ashorterplateauphase comparedtohumansandotherlargeanimals[119,120].Otherdifferencesbetweenrodentsand largeranimalsrelatedtoCa2+andNa+homeostasisincludealowercontributionofNCXtototalCa2+
removalinrodents[3]andhigherintracellular[Na+]inrodents(10Ͳ15mMcomparedto6Ͳ8mMin largeranimals)[121,122],thelattercausedbyhigherbaselineNa+influx[123].Thesedifferencesare importanttoconsiderwhenextrapolatingexperimentalresultsincardiacelectrophysiologyfrom rodentstohumans.
DuetothebriefAPD,rodentsarenotpertinentmodelsfortypicallongQTarrhythmias,inwhich reducedK+currentsincreaseAPDandtheriskofEADs,astheseK+currentsareoftennotactivated duringtherodentAP.Incontrast,duetothehighrelativeSarco(Endo)plasmicReticulumCa2+ATPase 2(SERCA2)activity,rodentsareeasilyCa2+overloadedandconsideredtobeasensitivemodelfor Ca2+Ͳinducedarrhythmias[124],whichistheproposedmechanismforthearrhythmiasstudiedinthis thesis.
7.1.3Aorticbanding
Inpaper4,weusedmicewithaorticbanding(AB).Thebandingwasinducedbyinsertingarubber ringintheascendingaorta,anoveltechniquecalledORAB(OͲringaortabanding)recentlydeveloped byoneofthecoͲauthorsinpaper4[113].ThenovelORABmethodallowsforhighlyconsistent hypertrophicphenotypes,andmostmicedevelopsovertHFwithdilatedleftatrium,increasedheart
23of46
weightandpulmonarycongestionwithinweekswiththeringdiameterusedinthisstudy.Inpaper4, weperformedinvivoandcellularexperiments14Ͳ18weekspostͲbanding,andonlyinmicewithHF confirmedbyechocardiography.
7.1.4Transgenicmodelsvsdisruptorpeptides
Inpaper2,weusedthetransgenicAnkB+/ͲmiceasatooltostudytheeffectofAnkBontheNKA/NCX interactionandregulationofNa+andCa2+.However,trafficking,assemblingandexpressionofnonͲ AnkBproteins(includingNKAandNCX)arealteredintheAnkB+/Ͳmice,andmightobscure
straightforwardconclusionsregardingtheNKA/AnkB/NCXinteraction.Tothatend,wesynthesizeda disruptorpeptidebasedontheMinimalAnkyrinBinding(MAB)domainonNKAandperformed experimentsinvoltageclampedratcardiomyocytes.Thisapproachallowedustodirectlystudythe effectofdisruptingNKAfromAnkB.ProximityligationassayverifiedthattheMABpeptidecoupledto NKAintheTͲtubules,andvoltageclampexperimentsshowedthatratcardiomyocytesdialyzedwith theMABpeptideandAnkB+/ͲcardiomyocyteshadasimilarlackofcorrelationbetweenNKAandNCX currents.WethusconsideredtheMABpeptideapertinenttooltostudythefunctionalconsequences ofdisruptingtheNKA/AnkB/NCXdomain.
ϳ͘ϭ͘ϱVentriculararrhythmiasinvivo
Inpaper4,weaimedtoinvestigatewhetherpharmacologicinhibitionofPDE2preventedventricular arrhythmias,andweusedtwomicemodelsofventriculararrhythmias,HFmiceandAnkB+/Ͳmice.
TheidealapproachwouldbecontinuouslysurveillanceoftheheartrhythmbyusingatelemetryECG systemthatregistersallarrhythmicevents.However,intheabsenceofproarrhythmicstimuli,such asisoprenaline/adrenalineandcaffeineinjectionsorexercise,miceveryrarelyexhibitVTs.Although itispossibletodetectprematureventricularcontractions(PVC),theseareonlysurrogatemarkersfor moreseriousVTsanddeath[125],withquestionableclinicalrelevance[126,127].Sincea
proarrhythmicstimulusisneededanyway,wechoseonlytomonitortheheartrhythmpriortoand followingtheinjectionoftheproarrhythmicdrug.Comparedtousingacohortofmicewithtelemetry recorders,thissavedusatremendousamountoftimeandresources,allowingustoincludeahigh numberofmiceinthestudies(about100miceinpaper4),muchhigherthanothercomparable papersinthefield[128].Webelievethatthiswouldincreasethereliabilityandreproducibilityofthe resultsinourstudy[129].
Standardprotocolstoacutelyinduceventriculararrhythmiasoftenincludeinjectionofboth isoprenalineandcaffeineinhighdoses(0.2Ͳ20mg/kgand120mg/kg,respectively).Inpaper4,we hypothesizedthatPDE2inhibitionwouldpreventarrhythmiasbylocallyincreasingcAMPandthereby activatingNKA.InjectionoftheseveryhighdosesofisoprenalinewouldlikelysaturatecAMPinall cellularcompartments[130,131],andwealsohaveunpublisheddatashowingthatmaximum contractilityinrodentheartsisreachedatisoprenalineconcentrationsintheμg/kgrange.The proarrhythmicmechanismofcaffeineismainlytoincreaseRyRconductanceandthereby intracellular[Ca2+][132,133],butitcouldalsoactasaPDEinhibitorathigherdoses[134].1mM caffeineelicitedventriculartachycardiain100%ofhealthyhearts[133],whereaswefoundthata singleinjectionof120mg/kgcaffeinewasnotsufficienttoinducearrhythmiasinWTmice(paper4).
Assumingthatina25mgmousethevolumeofdistributionforcaffeinewas~80%[135],120mg/kg correspondsto~0.75mM,atwhichtherateofPDEinhibitionislow[134].
SincewehypothesizedthatPDE2inhibitionwouldactantiarrhythmicbyreducingintracellular[Ca2+], wechosetousecaffeineasthemainarrhythmogenictrigger.Inunpublishedpilotexperiments,we
24of46
alsotestedlowerconcentrationsofisoprenalineandcaffeineincombination(50ng/kgand60 mg/kg,respectively),whichyieldedsimilarresults.
Themicewererandomizedtoreceiveinterventionalorcontroltreatmentpriortoinitiationof experiment.Thenextmouse,oftenalittermatecontrol,wasthenstratifiedtotheothertreatment group.WealsobenchmarkedtheefficacyofthePDE2inhibitorBay60Ͳ7550againstthecommonly usedbetaͲblockerMetoprolol.Inthistrial,themicereceivedtheassignedtreatmentas
intraperitonealinjectionsfor5days,assomeofthechronicbetaͲblockereffectsstarttomaterialize afterlessthan1weektreatment[136,137].
Intheinvivoexperiments,weusedthePDE2AinhibitorsBay60Ͳ7550andPF05180999indoses(3 mg/kgand1mg/kg,respectively)wheretheydonotinfluencetheactivityofotherPDEs[138Ͳ141].
7.2Cellisolation
Theabundanceofexperimentsincludedinthisthesiswereperformedonisolatedrodent cardiomyocytes(ratsormice).Allelectrophysiologicalexperimentswereperformedonfreshly isolatedcardiomyocytes,6Ͳ8hourswithinexcision,asalterationsincellstructureandfunction appearrapidlyincardiomyocytesinprimarycultures[142].Individualcardiomyocyteswereselected forexperimentsmainlybasedontheirappearance(rodͲshaped,striated,absenceofspontaneous contractions).Forisolationofratcardiomyocytes,weemployedamodifiedLangendorffsetup,in whichtheexcisedratheartwasmountedonacannulaandperfusedwithaconstantpressure retrogradelythroughaorta.Forisolationofmousecardiomyocytes,weslightlymodifiedanovel techniquedescribedbyAckersͲJohnsonetal.[143],whichinvolvesmanualinjectionsofisolation buffer(withcollagenase)throughtheleftventricleoftheexcisedheart.Implementationofthis isolationtechniquedramaticallyimprovedthequality,yieldandconsistencyofourmiceisolations comparedtopreviousapproaches(usingretrogradeperfusion),andallowedrapidprogressthrough criticalstagesoftheprojectsdescribedinpaper4.
Severalmeasuresweretakentoincreasethelikelihoodofasuccessfulisolation.Weintubatedthe ratsandplacedthemiceonfacemask,whichallowedoxygenationoftheheartthroughoutthe surgicalprocedurepriortoexcisionoftheheart.Ratsreceivedanintravenousheparininjectionin theinferiorvenacava,whilethemiceheartswereinjectedwithasolutioncontaining
ethylenediaminetetraaceticacid(EDTA),bothtopreventbloodclotting,whichcompromisesthe perfusionoftheisolationbuffer.Followingexcision,theheartswererapidlytransferredtoiceorice coldbufferwithoutK+andCa2+(hypothermiccardioplegia)toreducemetabolicdemands.
7.3Electrophysiology
Electrophysiologicalexperiments,i.e.measurementsoftranssarcolemmalorintracellularionfluxes ormembranevoltage,constitutethemainpartofpaper1Ͳ3,andarealsoimportantinpaper4.The intentionofthefollowingparagraphsistocriticallydiscusstherationalefortheexperimentalsetups.
7.3.1Fluorescentdyes
MeasurementofintracellularCa2+isakeymethodthroughoutthisthesis.Inallfieldstimulation experiments,thecardiomyocyteswereloadedwith5μMFluo4ͲAM,afluorescentdyethatissimple touse[144],ataconcentrationthatminimizesunspecificeffects[145].Smithandcolleagues
reportedthat1,2Ͳbis(oͲaminophenoxy)ethaneͲN,N,Nඁ,NඁͲtetraaceticacid(BAPTA)Ͳderivedfluorescent dyes(includingFluo4andFura2)hadaprofoundNKAͲinhibitingeffect,especiallyathigher
concentrations.Theauthorsfoundthat10μMFluo4ͲAMsuppressedNKAactivityinculturedmice
25of46
cardiomyocytesby30%,while2μMFluo4ͲAMhadnoeffect.TheNKAsuppressionwasofparticular concernintheCNS,whereswellingandastrocytedeathwasfound[145].Ofnote,thegenetically encodedCa2+indicatorGCaMP3didnotinhibitNKA,butthisapproachrequiresatransgenicmice and/orviraltransfectionofcellcultures,andarelessconvenientforexperimentsinfreshlyisolated cardiomyocytes.
7.3.2NKAcurrents
ThereareprincipallytwodifferentwaysofmeasuringtheNKAcurrentinvoltageclamped
cardiomyocytes.OneistousetheNKAinhibitorouabain(orothercardiacglycosides),whilethemain alternativeistoaddorremoveextracellularK+.Themaindrawbackofthelatteristhattherecould benanomolartracesofK+eveninasupposedlyK+Ͳfreesolution,whichcouldkeepsomeNKAsinan inactivatedstate,especiallywhenextracellular[Na+]iszero[146].Themainadvantagebymeasuring theNKAcurrentasaK+Ͳsensitivecurrent,isthatunliketheslowwashͲoutofouabain,K+isreadily washedout,convenientlyallowingsequentialactivationsofNKA.
Inpaper4,wheretheaimsimplywastocompareNKAactivityatdifferentinterventions(e.g.PDE inhibition),theNKAcurrentwasmeasuredinsymmetricalNa+solutionsbyremovingextracellularK+ fromthesuperfusate,andthecellswerenotexposedtoK+Ͳfreesolutionthatmightinfluencethe recordings.Intheseexperiments,wealsoemployedsymmetricalNa+solutions,i.e.solutionswhere thesuperfusateandtheinternalsolutionhavethesameNa+content,inordertoreduceanyeffects fromlocalNa+poolsontheNKArecordings.
Inallpatchclampexperimentsinpaper4,wherePDEfunctionwasstudied,5μMcAMPwasincluded intheinternalsolutiontoinvestigatetheeffecstofPDE2inhibitiononawiderangeofionchannels andpumps.5μMcAMPwaschosenbasedonastudythatmeasuredcAMPconcentrationsincytosol atdifferentdosesofIsoprenaline;5μMcAMPwasatthelowermiddlepartofthedoseͲresponse curve[147].TheideawasthatthecAMPaddedinthepipettebecomesasubstrateforthePDEsand activatesPKA,andthisapproachhasbeenemployedpreviouslybyothers[148Ͳ150].Thelowseries resistanceintheseexperimentsensuredthatpipettecAMPbecamethemaindeterminantof cytosoliccAMP,andthatanyeffectsofPDEinhibitorswereduetolocalregulationofcAMPin specificcompartments.AsaproofͲofͲprincipleoftheseassumptions,wehaveunpublisheddata showingthatPDE3inhibitionincreasesSERCA2activityinvoltageclampedcardiomyocytesonly whendialyzedwithcAMP;intheabsenceofcAMPPDE3inhibitionhasnoeffectonSERCA2activity.
7.3.3Globalandlocal[Na+]measurements
ComparedtotheadvancementswithinCa2+imaging,thetoolsforNa+measurementsare unsatisfactoryandlackthepropertiesnecessarytodetectsubsarcolemmalchangesinthe nanometerscale.Tomeasureglobal[Na+]inbeatingcardiomyocytes,weusedsodiumͲbinding benzofurzanisophtalate(SBFI)AMinthesingleexcitation(340nm)anddualemission(410nm/590 nm)mode,asdescribedbyBaartscheer[151],whichcandetectchangesinglobalintracellular[Na+] above2mM.Intheabsenceoftechniquestoadequatelyvisualizeandmeasuresubsarcolemmal [Na+],wemeasuredNCXorNKAcurrentsincarefullydesignedexperiments,andinterpretedtheseas ameasureofNCXͲorNKAͲsensed[Na+].
x MeasurementsofNCXͲsensed[Na+]:Inpaper2and3,thereversemodeNCXcurrentwas measuredbyrapidlyswitchingfromaCa2+Ͳfreesolutiontoasolutioncontaining2mMCa2+. Extracellular[Na+]wasconstant,whileintracellular[Ca2+]washeavilybufferedwithEGTA, andthecurrentamplitudewasthusinterpretedasNCXͲsensed[Na+].Inpaper2,we activatedreverseNCXintheabsenceandpresenceofactiveNKA(e.g.Fig.1A).Upon
26of46
activationofNKA,intracellular[Na+]decreases[108],andreverseNCXisreduced
correspondingly[54].Innormalcardiomyocytes,thereisalinearcorrelationbetweenthe reductionsinNKAandreverseNCXcurrentsfollowingNKAactivation[54],acorrelationthat isabolishedinfailingcardiomyocytes[152].Arecentpublicationsuggestedthat
glutathionylationoftheNKAɴsubunitcouldinfluencethecurrentdecline[70].Similarly, anotherpapersuggestedthatthedeclinecouldbeduetoNKAsequestration[69].However, theideathatNKAactivationlowersintracellular[Na+],andthatthisinturnreducestheNKA activity,isinlinewithbasicbiologicalconceptsandseveralindependentobservations.Thus inpaper3,weusedthismethodtoinvestigatewhethertheNKA/NCXcorrelationwas presentinAnkB+/ͲcardiomyocytesandinnormalcardiomyocytesdialyzedwithanNKA/AnkBͲ disruptingpeptide,butweinterpretedtheseresultsinthelightofotherdatausingdifferent methods.
x MeasurementofNKAͲsensed[Na+]:Inpaper3,weusedtheNKAcurrentasasensorfor[Na+] intheNKAcompartment,wherewecalibratedtheNKAcurrentagainstintracellular[Na+] (Fig.1).TominimizetheinfluenceofintracellularNa+gradients,weexposedthecellsto symmetricalNa+solutions.WethenmadeaconcentrationͲresponsecurvebetween intracellular[Na+]andNKAcurrents,whichwouldlaterenableconversionbetweenthe measuredNKAcurrentamplitudeandNKAͲsensed[Na+],similartotheapproachby
Verdoncketal.[153].IntheabsenceofClͲcurrentinhibitors(e.g.niflumicacid),NKAcurrents weremeasuredatͲ20mV,i.e.thecalculatedequilibriumpotentialofClͲ.However,this theoreticallycreatesaslightinwardNa+leak,possiblyleadingtoasmallerrorinour calibrationcurvethatwouldhavebeenavoidedbymeasuringNKAcurrentsat0mVand inclusionofNiflumicacidinthesuperfusate.Althoughthisdoesnotaffectanyofthe conclusionsinthepaper,itcouldleadtoanunderestimationoftheactual[Na+].
x ExperimentalapproachtoinvestigateheterogeneoussubsarcolemmalNa+levels:Tostudy thecommunicationbetweenNa+channelsandNKA,wemeasuredtheNKAcurrentbefore andaftervoltagepulses(Ͳ70mVͲ0mV)thatwouldactivatetheNa+current.Weinterpreted increasedNKAcurrentasincreased[Na+]intheNKAcompartment.However,ithasbeen showninskeletalmusclethathighfrequencyvoltagepulses(60Hz)activatesNKAandlead toapostͲactivationreductioninintracellular[Na+][154,155].Thisisaplausiblemechanism inskeletalmuscle,whereNKAactivationcouldpartlycounteracttheNa+loadinginducedby rapid,repetitivecontractions.However,cardiomyocyteshavemuchlowerstimulation frequencies(e.g.1Hz)andtheincreaseinintracellular[Na+]issufficienttoreachanew steadystate[156].WealsoconductedNKAmeasurementsbeforeandafterincreasing extracellular[Na+](Fig.2)andatdifferentholdingpotentials(Ͳ20mVvsͲ70mV,datanot includedinthethesis).Asallexperimentalinterventionsweredesignedtoincrease
intracellular[Na+],andallexperimentsyieldedsimilarresults,ourinterpretationwasthatthe increaseinNKAcurrentfollowingtrainsofdepolarizationswasduetoNa+influx.
7.3.4Cellulararrhythmias–Ca2+wavesandafterdepolarizations
Ca2+overloadinducesCa2+wavesandafterdepolarizations(EADsandDADs)andinitiatestriggered arrhythmias.600000Ͳ800000cardiomyocytesmustdevelopafterdepolarizationsinordertogenerate aPVCinahealthyheart[27,28],butitisstillmeaningfultomeasureCa2+overloadinindividualcells, asthisrepresentsameasureofthethresholdfortriggeredarrhythmiageneration.However,any findingsonCa2+overloadincells,shouldbereplicatedinexvivoorinvivoexperiments.
27of46
TomeasureCa2+waves,cardiomyocyteswerefieldstimulatedatdifferentstimulationfrequencies, andCa2+wavesweredetectedduringstimulationͲfreeperiods.WavedetectionduringastimulationͲ freeperiodispossibleinrodentcellsduetothelowcontributionofNCXtoCa2+extrusion,which preventstherapidreductioninSRCa2+loadfollowingcessationofstimulationseeninlargeranimals [124].WealsomeasuredafterdepolarizationsincurrentclampedAnkB+/Ͳcardiomyocyteswithand withoutPDE2inhibition.Itwasnotnecessarytoprovoketheafterdepolarizationsinthesecellswith isoprenalineorcaffeine,asbothEADsandDADswereprevalent.
7.4Statistics
Appropriatestatisticalanalysisisoftenneglectedinthebasicsciences[157],whichcouldcontribute tothereproducibilitycrisisinpreclinicalresearch[158].Inthisthesis,wehavestrivedtoapplythe correctstatisticaltestsonourdata.Tothisend,allrelevantdatasetswereanalyzedfornormal distribution,andtͲtestswereonlyemployedinthecaseofnormaldistribution;otherwise,nonͲ parametrictestswereused.Whenmultipledatasetsorendpointswerecompared,ANOVAtests withmultiplecomparisonswereused.Whencomparingbinaryoutcomes(e.g.presenceorabsence ofarrhythmias),weusedFisher’sexacttest.
28of46
8Discussion
Theaimsofthisthesiswastoprovidenewinsightinarrhythmiamechanisms,andtousethis knowledgetodevelopnoveltargetedtreatmentsagainstventriculartachyarrhythmias.Ourfindings suggestthattheNKA/NCXcomplexisanupstreammodulatorofarrhythmiasinhypokalemiaand AnkyrinBsyndrome.ThismechanismlikelyinvolvesregulationoflocalNCXͲsensedNa+pools,making NKAͲmediatedregulationofNCXapromisingtargetformorespecificantiarrhythmictreatments.By usingPDE2inhibitors,wewereabletoactivateNKA,lowerintracellular[Ca2+]andpreventventricular tachyarrhythmiasinmicewithHFandAnkyrinBdeficiency.WesuggestthatactivationofNKA,e.g.
withPDE2inhibitors,couldbeafutureantiarrhythmictreatment.
8.1ReducedNKAactivity–aproarrhythmicmechanism?
8.1.1Hypokalemia
InhibitionofNKA,accumulationofintracellular[Na+]andsubsequentincreaseinintracellular[Ca2+] byreducinginwardNCXhasforalongtimebeenrecognizedasamechanismofdigitalistoxicity[159, 160],aconditioninwhichtoohighserumlevelsofdigitalisinduceavarietyofdifferentarrhythmias, includingVTandVF[29,161].Similarly,NKAhasbeensuggestedtobeinvolvedinthe
arrhythmogenesisinhypokalemiaandAnkyrinBsyndrome[31,44].Inpaper1and2,weprovide furtherevidencethatNKAisanupstreamregulatorofintracellular[Ca2+]andcardiacarrhythmiasin hypokalemiaandintheAnkyrinBsyndrome,andourresultsinparticularsuggestthattheNKAɲ2is importantbylocallyregulatingNCXͲsensed[Na+],therebymodulatingtheamountofCa2+extruded byNCX.
Inpaper1,wefoundthatextracellular[K+]correspondingtomoderatehypokalemia(2.7mM) reducedNKAactivity,increasedNCXͲsensed[Na+],reducedNCXͲmediatedCa2+extrusion,and inducedCa2+overloadandCa2+wavesinfieldstimulatedratcardiomyocytes.Followingspecific inhibitionofNKAɲ2,hypokalemianolongerinducedCa2+overloadorincreasedNCXͲsensed[Na+].A previousstudybyEisnerandLederershowedthatCa2+overloadandarrhythmiasinpotassiumͲ depletedsolutionsweremediatedbyNKA[40],buttheyused[K+]e=0mM,whichrepresentsan extremeconditionneverencounteredinpatients.Severalothermechanismshavealsobeen proposedtobeinvolvedinhypokalemiaͲinducedarrhythmias,includingreducedrepolarization potentialduetoreducedK+currents[31],buttheirrelativeimportanceareexpectedtovarywiththe serumlevelofK+,necessitatingstudiesonclinicallymeaningfullevelsofextracellularK+.Tothisend, thecellularexperimentsinpaper1wereperformedat[K+]e=2.7mM,correspondingtomoderate hypokalemia.
Whiletheresultsinpaper1suggestthatNKAɲ2inhibitioncouldbeanupstreammediatorof hypokalemiaͲinducedCa2+overload,wedidnotinvestigatetherelativeimportanceofCa2+overload comparedtootherproarrhythmiceffectsofhypokalemia,e.g.reducedK+currents.However,this wasinvestigatedinapaperbyPezhoumanandcolleagues,whichshowedthathypokalemiaͲinduced VT/VFinrabbitandratheartswaspreventedbyloweringextracellular[Ca2+].Incontrast,theK+ channelblockerdofetilideprolongedtheAPD,butdidnotelicitVT/VF[162].Importantly,alater studyalsoshowedthathypokalemiainducedCa2+overloadinbeatinghearts[163],whichconfirmed themainresultsofourcellularexperimentsinanintactheart.Mathematicalmodelingpredictedthat hypokalemiaͲinducedVT/VFwasdependentonNKAasanupstreammediatorofCa2+overloadin rabbitandrathearts[162].Basedonthis,leadingscientistsinthefieldhavesuggestedreducedNKA activityasakeyproarrhythmicmechanisminhypokalemia[164],inlinewithourmainconclusionsin paper1.