ISBN 978-82-326-5158-0 (printed ver.) ISBN 978-82-326-5159-7 (electronic ver.) ISSN 1503-8181
Doctoral theses at NTNU, 2020:404
Anker Stubberud
Digital Technology Biofeedback for the Prophylaxis of Pediatric Migraine
Doctor al thesis
Doctoral theses at NTNU, 2020:404Anker Stubberud NTNU Norwegian University of Science and Technology Thesis for the Degree of Philosophiae Doctor Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences Department of Neuromedicine and Movement Science
Thesis for the Degree of Philosophiae Doctor Trondheim, December 2020
Norwegian University of Science and Technology Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences
Department of Neuromedicine and Movement Science
Anker Stubberud
Digital Technology Biofeedback
for the Prophylaxis of Pediatric
Migraine
NTNU
Norwegian University of Science and Technology Thesis for the Degree of Philosophiae Doctor Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences
Department of Neuromedicine and Movement Science
© Anker Stubberud
ISBN 978-82-326-5158-0 (printed ver.) ISBN 978-82-326-5159-7 (electronic ver.) ISSN 1503-8181
Doctoral theses at NTNU, 2020:404 Printed by NTNU Grafisk senter
! "
!
#
! ! ! "
!!#$$%
!
!"#
# #
$ % $
! "# $
! % &'
! & (
! ) (
! *
! % &
$ +
$ ,
$
$ + ,
& $' ( )* $+
- , , ( . ,, #*
/ * . + 0&
. 1 / + ., ! % & ! 2 ! % & $ + '
! 3 4 5
! . 5
! 3 (
! 6 *
! . *
$ .
$ . #
$ .
$ .
$ .
, )-(.
/ & ! . ! 2 $ /4 ' . /(+
! (
! % & *
! 7 , &
! + #3
!! #3 !
!$ 7 # & 5
!' 8!*
!' !*
!' !*
!' 2 !
!' . 9 ! 0 .(
' -..
1 0' 5 :. 9 $' 5 : $(
5 :2 1 '
! "
##
$! " # % &
&& &
'( )
* % ( +
& + &
&
, * &
-&
& + && &
! ./
&
/ % &
/ +( #$.01 . % .
( *+2
&&
3453 2 &
( # 2& & 5*
. &
* &&
6767
! "#
$%&'(&)*+$,
-. /0- / 1 ." /.
/.2 3 4.$%&*()+&,&
/0- 50 5 2 60 "
0 . 7
$%$%('%+8,**9#9%&
2- . 2 50 5/0 # . /.
": .;
! "
" "" "#
$
%# % $ "% &
% %
"" '"%""
() $*# %
$ " $
& $ "
$(+,+-. /0$1,1$(1(
2 # )3()-3"
" # 4)+)5+-./0)36$)+,' $"" " "
" 7"" 8
' $
# " ($9 1+1 +-. $()):39"4)(9--$3 (3- +-. $1)(-,1"4)6+-
"
" % # % ""$
$"" % # "
&
; 2 "
"
""""
<<
=>? " < *"#@
#<" "
$ " <<
=<<"
" ?
" << $ A
""" & BC<+-.
D0<7<
*=>? "<
* < " " ""
1) 7 < $ E" < $7 "
0DD DDD*<<
" " ()"
* <$<
"<"D <
" < A0 "
"" <"
""<$" A$ $
<C " "< <
"?7C?$D'$1" *< $"
<<(:< A ""
$ *"< < $"
E "7"
E < <"<"$" * < "< A<=
$ <($9 <-$3 "<
E < "<"< $= $2
<*
$ <" "
E $(+,+-.D0$1,1$(1("<"< $ " <F<H&
<8 0DD4)3(5+-.D0)-, )+1 0DD4)-35+-.D0)(+)3(<
DDD4)+)5+-.D0)36$)+,<
" < " $ E" 7 "
A<"*""
<"" 0 "
"" < A 4(1 49 A0
" $ E <
<($91+1+-.D0$()):39"4)(9- <-$3(3-+-.
D0$1)(-,1"4)6+-*"" <
I +-.D0$9)+)
"4)36)* <
E "
"" < "< $ &""
<
"""$ 0 "
" =>?
"" B >"""<=>? * "" E <
"*
"" <
"< "
""<
&D
?" ""
D "
D
D $""
D
8
8 >
>A
0
!
0 D >&
"
0 >?
0 $$
#!
J
#$
J
#$
J <
!
%
>
%
$
&
&
"
''
!
'"!
! $ $
"
C E
$
B
"
;C" 0?C< $ 7
"
?"
&()
' 1-.
&)*
' -).
+"
=
(
! "
88
<
" "$
" "*""
&
0 D >&6 0D>&$6
0 >?0>?*
" ""7 K &?
<< -)
=<
1)(: ""
86
#L
" < F H
A" ""
" ""7
" "5"
" 5
" "
K " "
"
K $<
1
$
""
"
"
*" <
"""#
*""
< "
* " " <"
" &
"" $
""DKC;
*""
"
<" "
A ""
* A "
"
*" "" <
" "
"*"" "
# 5 "
7" "
" A
"A " 1$6I
6
2 (+3)
*"A
<
*"A " "
" 7 "
""
* "
""
"" "<""
"
"""
" E <
*""" E
0 """
E " ""
89
*
><
*
<(3<0 "
"$ " "
9
7<A :961 11,19+
" +(. <
<$ " ,,.
<< "" <
" $<
<
"(M(
"
B
!< $ < "
8:
8:8 3
*" " ""
""
J "
E * "" "
" *<
"
"
<
"
8:6 *&
= ""
B$$
-
!?70& "
*
"
*" -$>* < ""-$
>*
"
""DKC; 0 "
!?70& "
*"
0
!< " ""
(1>< D <
" A"
<
< E
E B>* B>
<"<
= E $ E"B>""
8:9 +
;" " " A A
"" <
7<"
"" "
:
<"" A <
*"
7 7! 7
>?1)(+ #""
" ""
B "" " A < "
"
="" "
" " <"
$ D>7;$
A 6)) " ""B
<< 78
?
" "$ <"
$
"
1)(+
$ A
*<" "" "
<""
8:: (+
! $" " ""
" ?<<$
D <"1)(3
"
" 7 < "
""
#
"""
2 $
< $
<$E "
,
0 <
< ""
; < " " "
8; 5&
*(+:)$,) ""
A E" ""
< < *
""
" (=
""" "" <
<
"
$ ""
3
$<$ "$
"
"" >< $ E
" " E"
""< $ 8 "" $ "$
" $ ""
+ 8;8
"""" "
* <"
"" " "
" ""< "
" <"
*
"< "$""
* " "
""
*
< "
"
"" $
" <
"
8;6 "
> "
"";;K*;;K< (+63
>A "A
"
*
""" $ J8& "
8"
"
"
*;;K""
< 0
()
< "
< " J8& "
* "
" "
*<
$ 8DK
7 " D>C
0 7""=
7""0 7"
K;8 " ;
? 0 < "8DK<
<
8;9
*A "
"?8K*?8K
" " "A *"A "" *
"" "
$ <
*"" "A$
0" <
F" H "
$#
*<"
A?8K
*
((
" <
"< 0 "< !<-)>A5$
"()$1)>A 5 <$"()))>A
*<$" E <
?8K-))>A*E !EE $ < ""
* A
<A " E EC? <<
E
8;: 5&
* "
"" $
" !0<" "
" "
* "
"
*
< " " "<
" 0 " (+,6
$ $"
* <"" "
(1
<"<
5 << " <*
< $ "
J # "
"
*""" "
"
K " < <
$ <
< <
N"
"" "
" 0 < ""
"
*""
< "
" &
""
7 "
*
"" "
0 L ""
*
"" $
(6
"<
><
B < "
"
8<
8<8 & &
0 "
>7>>
" "" "" < ""
= < " $ ""
*
" <""
" >< <
<"L " * < *
<
< <
2
" >
<
<
(9 8<6 &
="> ""
< "
= >"
><
"
D
>$"
"D* $
D > """
"
8<9 & &
* > ""
>E >
"
*" "
>""A2 "" "
"7
" <
<" <
0
5 "
"5 < " <
>
D " " ""
<"> "
(-
L< "#" <>
" *
" " <>
" F$0 H "
(,
#
, -
"""
$ " <<
% -
$7" ""
""" < $
;"0
$8 < "
"" " <" ""
$ ;"00
$&" """ <
O ;"000
$7
""" <
"" "0'
(+
$ %&
98 %
* <"# " "
*" ""
0 "<<
" <"
*< $ < <
" 0 "<
=>? ""
L?8K"" " >
"
<
?8K " "
*<" "';
""<*" <"
" <"
*" ';<
? <
=>?*"<"<
< =>? $ "
E" <
*< <"
""
<
0 < <<
1)
< "B <"<
""=
" $
J " ""<
" 7"" A$ $ "<
"
96 (
0 < ""
" <<<$
D D
;
C" 0?C< $7 ;C0?7
968 /&
0 <E"" A "" "
;" < "(3
" = E"
0>?D D(+33
0D>&$001))9
0>?0D>&$6
?<
" <
< <
< " "8"
"< < 5 $"
1(
"< 5< $ 5 E < " ;$"
<M" E -).
E 78
966
7 "
<
* 8&J0!887?8D8!*C7J D0!7>J ;0!B*<" !161)(-0 $"A A <" (3 "" * <
#< $ ""
*<
0 <""
<
969 +
D <<C<<
$ =" ""
0 <
""< $ "
""=" A <<
11 96: &
< M <
E 5 <
5 " <$"5 "
< "$" ";
< "" " <
*< F<HFH F H*< < " ""<
99
0 <" ';<<
<
998 1
"A
<
1) 7"" (;" <
"
*!?
8P;70!7?B!<<<
< "<
;7?;BC*? I?*";;?$1(6( <;7?;BC*
*" ;?$1(1- 7J ;?$61));0 CD7
2?7 Q?I9)7
16
E" < 7&0 0 & !<R "
<-$J<I$
7";<J3I6-?8K 8DK 7&0?
"""
996 /+
;" < +)$ "
*<!?
<"""
"A< < " "D, ?8K < "
E" <"1
!? <"1* $ <9
*F" H E" <"
" "D,(;"00*
<<<<*< " <
< ""
<"< "<
0 "" <- < "
* < ""
F H * C "A < 6) *
" << "
"?E "" <
19
""""A 7 'D <" " :
*
?8K < *<
*J0 2?7 " ?E "" <
" -).'D-) 1-.'D1-
" "" <"
" (-"
+)$ 7"
"" < <-$ E
"
999
*!? (1$7&D "()19>A<$
()S93)>A "*;<J"?8K 1)))
>A<$<"-))>A $"
()>A0 -)$>A <""
7 <" 8DK*
<<? <
< C? C?< A " <
<
" "
1- 9: &
*"< <L L< """ $
" ?B2 >"
* !<?"1)(,T 1)(30 "
<" " """<
" *
""< " '; *<
(1$(3 <
0D>&$6
" 7
<" "
" $
9:8 5&
*" "
; Q<Q7"" 1;($6
* "<
!?
;7?;BC*? I?*"
*;;?$1(6(><*<
!?
0 0B
K
;8 "< <<
9:6 #&
2 """
8 < "M(""" 51
1:
< ""
5 6
*<< $
?B2 >"* & "" <
<""*<"""E"
" () ;" <
E0
"" "- <1)
< * < <$<""
*"" < <<; Q
< ""<" <"
() < 7
"" < " $
""" & < <
" " *"
< <
" &"
"" " <A"
9:9 5&
*< "
"" " *<
< #"A
"" < "
1,
"< A """ 7
< #"" <<
"" O" "" < "
)S())"<? <
< "$*<
<" " "
< "
*<
=" " <*
< A"
" < " <"
9::
* " " <""
" << <
"" 2 < -$" J ($F"H-$F"H*<
"" =" "
<JBD "
= A"" "
" "
<" D <
13
F<H< E666.<
""<< <
$= "
" <"
9; &
* < ""6M(
A$ $ "?B>"
* !<5 B2 >"B!<<"
T 1)(+T 1)1)
9;8
*"$< "< $<
"< """"*< $ (1$(3 < 0D>&$
6
<8"" <
" <" &
"" <
" ""7 13$ "
"" < < "
"$ $ A 0 ""
,-. " 1-.
";" << "" -$
""*-$ << "
E 9) B
1+
< $ ""<
< """" ""
" -$ A <
""< L "" "
< "6M($
A A <<$"
"" < <"-$ "
""& "" <
" E
"" < "";" <
< E <E" "
< < 78
" "" <
<$ " 78E E"
9;6
* "$ ""
$ *"""$
" () 7"" 1;9* "
; "" <
<
E" < " ?<
$ ;"000
6) 9;9 2
*"< E ? <"
-). E 5 "
9$" )4 645 9$" )4 "
<64"<5
< " 5 78
>$ " <
"$" " < "
"
="$"
"#"<
" < "$"
< <"= "$"
" 6). E < "$ "
"
9;: &
* O <
" "0
" 78< E
*(;"005 7"" 67 """ <
" AA 7 78<
6(
778 "<<" $#
9<
9<8 (
< &<
+-. D0 $=
BC<+-.D0<$
B< < "" $ $> A<
= !!*
" "
? <$
9<6
* C? "A "" <?
< <E" <<
= $ & JB7< $ 7 "<"
= $
0DD<<$<$
D <" 0 <J O DDD
0DD DDD < "
<$< *<
61
)( # A*0DD< "D
L)))$)9)4 "I"5)9($):)45):($),-45 ),-S())4
9<9 &
&<" ?& E 0UC2<"< <<$
= $ A< 0UC=
; <
< $
<$ * <""
$<" $ "
7 " < "
;$V))-<
9<:
7"<" 0** A
" " 13<-$3
><"" " <-$3
" < 0**0** * 0** "" <E","
13 <-$3"" "
<($9<
" <($9=
< "
66
= $" < A<<$= $ A<&<+-.D07<$ $= $2<
" < <"
<+-.D0<"<>$J <
A " <
<<$"$A<&
<+-.D0!" < "
;$<))-
6-
' %(
* "
& """
:8 /&& +
* <+)3*
";"0(
< D *1;"0E
" < $ 0 $
< < "
<"< $ <
E &4$(+,5+-.D0$1,1$(1(5"V)))("<< $ ;"06;" <<
"V)))("" "
"<< $ BC41,,(5+-.D0:::((-6-;"0 9*!!*<1 # <
< 5 B 9).# <<1 ;"0
"
:6
71)"" < ""
"B(1< <19,W1, (3S1+*6 ;"00
8 < ?8K *
6:
0DD"
)-3+-.D0)(+)3( )3(+-.D0)-,)+1 'D*< <
;"009 < 8DK
?8K 8 < "
"DDD4)+)5+-.D0)36$)+,7 "E" " "
< ;"00:
:9 #&
* "" < (-W(: (6$(,<
? <* "" <
""" "
"" ""-). 7,1
<"*"
<6,W(:* <" ""<9
< << <(
2< <
< ;"000(
7; O"$ "
< < $9) 4)3-"V)))(<< E M$4,9(
X)3- <"V)))(;"0009
<;"000*1<
< < <
-;"000
6, :: / &
*< $"" < "(3?B 2 >" B2 >"? ""
"" < (:" < A 4(1 495( "0'=
" E 1+1 I +-.D0$()):39"4)(9-< <($97 E (3-I +-.D0$1)(-,1"4)6+-< <-$3!
$ " <
< "*1 "0'!
E < <"< <
($9)-I +-.D0$+)(:)"4())) <-$3$() I +-.D0$+)9)"4),:)
& "" <
FH 41FH 4(30 <1)"" "
E" < " 0
<1) <F H< <FHB 1) (9<FH<
FH <FH&
" 78<""" "
63
?8K"*<!
"$"78<" "
6+
) *
;8
B< "
* $ <
E < "< $ 2 "" "
$ <
" =>? "
""D" E" <"
" "
<?8K "A!<" <>
$ <
" * $
" A"
"" ""
< " J "*
" " ?7C?$
D'$1" ! E ""<?"
" E <
78
9)
;6 5& +
*<<$ "
"" "
< &""
"" <
"$ ;
< $ " " "
<< #9).
*""
B < "
""
< " "
"" "
"" <
><
" "
< """ $
" "" "
! $" ""
"" "
*
" "6-.
"-).
"" $""
2 "" <
9(
" "
$"
"" "
"" "
*<"" "
<" < $
< *
"" $ "$
*< "<
" "" $"
L " ?$
"$ "
L
$ "
* " $" $ "
<E M0"
< <E Y
0 < E
" $""
0 (+,3 "
F"H " " "
* "
" " "" FH
" $" ""
91
" 7 (+3( $
< $ "
/< (+3)
<
$
0
"L " "
L "
*< # $
"" " !
""< F"H$A$
" !
$"< "#
$ $ A
"FH"
* <" # "
><E " " <
" "" <
$ * "$
$ ""
$ *<
;"000 "0'0 "$""
< <
E
< <" "
96
" * " "<$
<"I < $?$<
"I" "
"" < $ $"
*" <
" L L ""<=
" <<
" "
L< "
;9 !& &&&
* ""$$ " "
=>?""= "
?8K $ "
"
0