• No results found

Visualization of Molecules with Positional Uncertainty

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Visualization of Molecules with Positional Uncertainty"

Copied!
8
0
0

Laster.... (Se fulltekst nå)

Fulltekst

(1)

()*+,.-

/+0121436587209:12;4<=12>@?8<A1CBED472FG9IHJ<A14KMLONJ>P7Q9SR

T6UV&WYX@Z\[\]^V`_=[ba@cd%ae]^WOfJ[\V&ZMg=hGijV&_Jh&VX@_Jk'l.mjV&h&[\Znijh X mlo_Opij_OV&V`Znij_Op

q

_AijreV&Z\snij[nt'acu'X@Z\t,mIX_Ok2vCw%X mj[nij]xa,Z\Vd%a,fJ_=[nt

wX mj[nij]^aeZ\V,vou'UzyA{ye|,}=v

q

g=~

,€YO‚&ƒJ„J…@ƒY†,‡=ˆo‰SŠ=‹eŒY‡o‰n,,Š

€JŽ=Ž,\‘=‘,’=’=’o‰\‡=ˆC‰“Š=‹,ŒY‡C‰\,@ŠY‘',€YO‚&ƒJ„J…@ƒY‘O‚GƒJ=,”•‰:€JŽ@‹Y–

—

d%VGmjh&aeZ\V˜™_Oh,š

›eœ

}e}^Oa,Z\V`s\[bž%iŸmŸm•˜nZ\V&_JV %kQš

uV&]^WJ¡=ijs&v2¢b£

›,œ

{ y,|=v

q

g=~

ˆ=¤=¥=ˆ@€2‚e†=‡==–=‡,¥,¦o‰\‡,¥@‹

§¨o©&ª&«¬J­=ª,®

U"V&snijp,_=ij_Op'_JV&¯zX@_Jk'°4V&[\[\V&ZMhG¡JV&]^ae[\¡OV`ZPX@W4V&fJ[nijh^h&ae]^W4aefO_JkOsZ\VP±

²

f=ijZ\V&s%X_^fJ_OkJV&Z\s\[PX@_Jk=ij_Op^ac2[\¡JV%]^V&hP¡4X_Aijs\]³°=t¯"¡AijhP¡[\¡OV%kJZ\fJp,s•V&´=V&Z\[o[\¡JVGijZ

°=ija@mja,pijhX mµVG¶2V&h&[\s&šY¢"¡Aijs"ij_=r,a@mjreV&sh&a,_JsnijkOV`ZPX@[nija,_6a@c•[\¡JVpeV&a,]^V`[\Z\ta@c•[\¡JVX@hP±

[nijr,Vsnij[\Vev4kJV&[\V&Z\]ij_YX@[nijae_Ea@c·[\¡OVpeV&a,]^V`[\Z\t¸ac•[\¡OVkJZ\fJpOv2X_Ok¹X@_YX mjt=snijsac•[\¡OV

º

[^°4V&[™¯%V&V&_»[\¡JV&]š•¢"¡AijsWJZ\a,°=mjV&]¼ackJZ\fOp±™s\fO°Js\[\ZPX@[\V

º

[&v•ac½[\V&_»hX mŸmjV`k¾[\¡OV

kJa=hG¿,ij_JpÀWJZ\a,°=mjV&]v·hX@_°4Vp,Z\VX[nmjtij_=ÁYfOV&_Jh&V&k°=t'fO_Jh&V&Z\[PX&ij_=[ntÀij_6[\¡OV^WYa,sniŸ±

[nija,_6a@c"kJZ\fOp'snijkJVhP¡YX ij_Js&šo¢oZPX@k=ij[nija,_YX mM]^amjV&h&f=mIX@Zp,ZPXWO¡=ijh&s^[\V&hP¡J_Ai

²

fJV&sc™X&iŸm

[\ahXWO[\fJZ\Vb[\¡JV"kAijs\[\Znij°JfO[nijae_Àac4mŸij¿,VPmjt'X@[\ae]ÃW4a,snij[nijae_Os&š2¢"¡=ijs+WYX@W4V`Z%kOV`s\h&Znij°4V&s

X¸ZPX_OpeVac"[\V&hP¡O_=i

²

fOV`scSa,Zs\¡Oa¯%ij_Op6X@[\ae]ÄW4a,snij[nijae_OsX@sWJZ\a,°YX@°=iŸmŸij[ntÅk=ijs\[\ZniŸ±

°JfO[nijae_Os[\¡4X[]^a,Z\Vh&ae]^WAmjV`[\VGmjtEkJV&s\h&Znij°4VWYX@ZPX@]xV&[\V&Z\s¯"¡AijhP¡EkJV&[\V&Z\]ij_JV

º

[&š

š&š&š

Æ Ç4È"É2Ê2ËÌÍÎ.É2ÏPËÈ

Ð720ÀÑC0Ò½BÓN=ÔB2<AK`<ÅÕ49:>PÖC<AÒI9:×e<AKP9:NJ1ÓN=Øo0FP>À;JF&<=Ù2729½Ú<AÒ>PNOÒIÖQKP9:NJ12>'KGN¾9:1YKG0FPÙQFP0KG9I1Q;ÛÒ½<=FG;J0

<=ÜÀNJÖ214KN=Ô¹B2<AK`<QÝßÞàNJÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò½<AF;JF&<=Ù27Q9SÚ >69:>ENJ1Q0Â>GÖCÚG7á<AFP0e<Óâ720FG0ã<äԙ0@âå;JN4N2BÃ9:Ü'æ

<=;O0>¹Ú@<=1Û;OFP0e<AKPÒ:3¾0127.<=1CÚ&0E9:12>G9I;O74K9:1YKGNÂKG720ÙQFPNJçQÒI0@ÜÂݕè0>G9I;O129:12;Å120âé<A1CB¾ç.0KPKG0F

ÚG720ÜNOKP720@F`<=Ù.0Ö2KG9½ÚÚ&NJÜÀÙCNOÖ21CB4>¸êëB4FGÖ2;J>&ìFG0eíOÖ29:FP0><A1»Ö21CBî0FP>GK`<=1.B49:12;NAÔMKP720¸Ü0eÚG7C<¦æ

129:>PÜÀ>•ç43â7Q9SÚG7KP720^B4FPÖQ;J>"0&ï20FGKMKG7209:F"ç29:NOÒINO;J9½Ú<AÒJ0&Øo0eÚ&KG>eÝ2Ð7Q0>PKPFGÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0^N=ÔoKP7Q0B4FPÖ2;

ÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0<=1CBÀKG7C<=KNAÔKP7Q0x>GÖ2ç2>GKPF`<AKP0ÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI09:14ðCÖ201.Ú&0KP7Q0xçQ9I1.B49:12;ÙQFPNJÙ.0FGK\3à<A1CB

KP720^0&Øo0eÚ&KG9:ÕJ0120@>P>NAÔKP7Q0BîFPÖ2;B4N2ÚGH49:12;'Ù2FPN2Ú&0@>P>eÝ

Ð720ßBîNîÚGH49:12;ÙQFPNJçQÒI0@Üñ9I14ÕONJÒ:ÕJ0>•Bî0KP0FGÜ9:129:12;KG720MÙ.NJ>G9:KP9:NJ1<A1CB^NOFP9:014K`<AKP9:NJ1NAÔCKP7Q0

B4FPÖQ;'ÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò:0â9:KP7EFP0@>PÙ.0eÚ&K^KPN'KG720>PÖQç2>PKGF`<=KG0>GÖCÚG7»KP7.<=KKP7Q00120FG;J3EN=Ô%9:1YKG0F`<OÚ&KP9:NO1

N=ÔKG720EK\âMNÅ9:>ÜÀ9I1Q9IÜÀ9j×0,BoÝoÐ720E9:14KP0F&<JÚ&KG9INO12>'<=FP0EÕO0FP3Ó>PÙ.0eÚ&9òÑ·ÚÀ9:1Û1C<AKPÖ2FG0JÝMó%ÕO01Ã<

>PÒ:9:;J74KÚG7C<=12;O09:1¾KP7Q06>G9½B406ÚG7C<A9I1¾NAÔx<»B4FGÖ2;ÂÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI0'Ú<A1Û9:12729:ç29:K^NJF0127C<A1CÚ&0EKP7Q0

9:1YKG0F`<OÚ&KP9:NO1•Ý"ô14ÔnNJFPKGÖ21C<AKP0Ò:34õ%>P9½B40»ÚG7C<=9:1öÙCNO>P9:KP9:NO1Û9:>'12NJK<AÒ:âß<,34>âM0Ò:ÒB40@KP0FGÜ9:120eBoÝ

Ð720E0&ïC<JÚ&K'Ò:N2Ú<AKP9:NJ12>N=Ô<=KGNJÜ>¸9I1ö<Å>P9½B40»ÚG7C<=9:1öÚ<=1öç.06>GÖ2çJ÷&0eÚ KKPNÛ<ø>PÖQç2>PK&<=14KP9½<=Ò

<=ÜÀNJÖ214K^N=Ô^Ö21CÚ&0FGK`<A9I14K\34Ý%Ð720»<=ç29:Ò:9:K\3ÂKGN¾Õ49I>GÖC<=Ò:9:×0À12NJKNJ12Ò:3¾KG720EçC0>GK0>GKP9:Ü6<AKP0ÀN=Ô

(2)

üµý½þ.®eÿ4®

ij_JVkOZPX&¯%ij_OpZ\V&WJZ\V&s\V&_=[PX[nija,_EacoVGijpe¡=[c™X]iŸmjt']^V&]°4V&Z\s&š

KPN4NJÒ9I1ÅKP7Q0>PKGÖCB43¾NAÔß>GKPFPÖ.Ú&KPÖ2FG0»<=1CBÅ9:14KP0F&<JÚ&KG9:NJ12>çC0@K\âM00@1zB4FGÖ2;Â<=1.BÅ>PÖ2ç2>GKPF&<=KP0E9:1

KP720B4N2ÚGH49:12;ÙQFPNJçQÒI0@ÜÂÝ

Ð720'B4FPÖ2;»B4N2ÚGH49:12;EÙ2FPNOç2Ò:0Üå9:>Ú FPÖCÚ&9½<AÒ"9:1Â01Q×34Ü0'Ú<=K&<=Ò:34>P9:>eõo<=14KG9I;O014æP<=14KP9:ç.N2B43E9I1îæ

KP0F&<JÚ&KG9:NJ12>,õMB4FGÖ2;zB40@>P9:;J1•õb<=1CBö<OB4ÕJ<=1CÚ 0eBöÜ6<AKP0FG9½<=Ò:>¹Bî0ÕJ0Ò:NOÙ2Ü014K,Ý%Ð720»ÙC<AFPKP9½Ú&ÖQÒS<AF

B4FP9:Õ49:12;^ԙN2Ú&ÖQ><JB2B4FG0>P>G0eBE720@FP09:>KP7Q0xÜÀ0eÚG7C<=1Q9I>GÜ çY3'â7Q9SÚG7»<=14KG9jæ\KPÖQÜNJF"B4FGÖ2;J>0 ïî0@FPK

KP720@9IF^ç29:NOÒINO;J9½Ú<AÒo0&Ø·0,Ú&KP>PÝ.D4341YKG720KG9SÚ¸NJÒ:0;ONJ14ÖCÚ&Ò:0NOKP9½B40><AFP0Ö2>P0eBÅ<=>^ÜÀNîBî0Òè

>P34>PKG0Ü>ÀKPN¾>GKPÖCB43 KP720ÂBîFPÖ2;Óç29:1CB49:12;¾Ù2720@12NJÜÀ012NJ1+Ý"!9:;O7ÛÑ.0Ò½B#Þ»5 9:>Ö2>G0eBÃKGN

0&ïC<=ÜÀ9I1Q00e<JÚG7»>GNJÒ:Ö2KP9:NO1»êëBîFPÖ2;<A1CBÀ>PÖ2ç2>GKPF&<=KP0¸Ü9òï2KPÖ2FG0eìM<AKKP720¸ÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò½<=F"Ò:0ÕO0Ò\Ý%$\129òæ

KP9½<=Ò.;J0@NJÜ0@KPFP9:0>bN=Ô%ÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0>M<AFP0Ú&NJ1Q>PKPFGÖCÚ&KG0eB»<=1.B'KP7Q0>P0;O0NJÜÀ0KPFG9:0>ß<AFP0^NJÙQKP9:Ü9:×0eB

Ö2>P9:12;0120@FP;J3EÜÀ9I1Q9IÜ'9:×e<AKP9:N=1'Ú<=Ò½Ú&Ö2Ò½<AKP9:NJ12>,Ý

Ð720xB4FGÖ2;'ÜNOÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò:0Ö21CBî0F>PKGÖCB43'7C<A>ß<¸>P9½B40ÚG7C<=9:1Àâ729½ÚP7ÀNJFG9I0@1YKG>ßBî9jØo0FG014KPÒ:3'ԙNOF

0e<JÚG7EÚ&NJÜÀÙ2Ò:0&ï•Ý'&12N=âÒ:0eB4;O0NAÔKP7Q0xÙQ7Y34>G9SÚ@<=Ò.0&ï2KP014KN=Ô%KP720^Ö21.Ú&0FPK&<=9:14K\3NAԕ>P9½B40ÚG7C<=9:1

ÙCNO>P9:KP9:NO16Ú<A16ç.0^N=Ô%;JFP0,<=K720Ò:ÙE9:1ÜÀNîBî9jÔn3Y9:12;.õ=FP0 æB40@>P9:;J129:12;.õ2<=1CBÖ21CB40@FP>PK&<=1CBî9I1Q;KP7Q0

9:1YKG0F`<OÚ&KP9:NO1xNAÔ2KP729:>•B4FGÖ2;â9:KP7^KG720">PÖQç2>PKGF`<=KG0JÝ=è9jØo0FG014K•ÕJ0@FP>P9:NO12>•NAÔîKG720MB4FGÖ2;ÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI0

â9:KP7Å9SBî014KP9½Ú<=Òb<=KPNOÜ><=1.BÂÚ&NO12120eÚ KP9:Õ49IK\3Åç2Ö2K¸ÙCNOKP014KP9½<AÒIÒ:3ÂBî9jØo0FG014K¹<AKPNJܼÙCNO>P9:KP9:NO12>

ԙNJFGÜ<Ôë<AÜ9:Ò:3N=ÔÜNOÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò:0>,Ý·ó<JÚG7¾Ôë<AÜ9:Ò:3'Ü0Ü'ç.0F>P7C<AFP0>Ü'ÖCÚG7ÂNAÔßKG720ÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI0

>PKGFPÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0OõxB49òØo0FP9:12;ÓÜ6<A9I1QÒI3¾9:1ö>P9½B40¾ÚG7C<=9:1ÃÙ.NJ>G9:KP9:NJ1³<A1CBöNOFP9:014K`<AKP9:NJ1•Ýb/%FP0@ÕY9:NOÖ2>PÒ:3

<ÀÔë<AÜ9:Ò:3»N=ÔÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò:0>â<=>>P72N=â1Ó9I1Óâ9:FP0&ænԙF`<AÜ0ԙNOFPÜ 9:1ÛNO1209:Ü6<A;J0Jõ â9IKG7Û0e<OÚG7

çCNO1CBÀ>P72N=â1Eç436<Ò:9:120JÝ(+9:;JÖQFP0)^>P72N=â><A1E0&ïC<=ÜÙQÒI0N=Ô%KP729:>KG0eÚG72129½íOÖ20JÝ*$\16>G0eÚ&KG9INO12>

â720FG0'KP720'ÜÀ0Ü'çC0@FP>NAÔMKP7Q0Ôë<=ÜÀ9IÒ:3'7C<,ÕO0'9½B4014KP9½Ú<AÒ>GKPFGÖCÚ&KPÖQFP0Jõ%Ü'Ö2Ò:KG9IÙQÒI0^Ò:9:120>^Ò:9:09:1

KP720^>&<=Ü0ÙQÒS<OÚ&0ԙNJFGÜ9:12;<¸720e<,Õ43'Ò:9I1Q0JÝ$\1E>G0eÚ&KP9:NO12>â720FG0^Ôë<=ÜÀ9:ÒI3^ÜÀ0Ü'çC0@FP>MB49òØo0Feõ.<

Ôë<=1øN=ÔNJÙ2KG9INO12>^>P72N=â>ԙNOF^KP720'>G9SBî0¹ÚG7C<A9I1+ÝoÐ729:>^FP0Ù2FG0>P0@1YK&<=KG9INO1Û9:>Ôë<=9:FGÒI3E>GÖCÚÚ&0>G>\ԙÖQÒ

<=K>P72N=â9:12;øâ729½ÚP7Ó>P0eÚ KP9:NJ12>'7.<,ÕJ0Ù.NJ>G9:KP9:NJ1C<AÒßÚ 0FPK&<=9:14K\3z<=1.B¾â729½ÚG7zB4NÅ12NOKeõ+ç2Ö2K'9:>

Ò:0>P>À>PÖCÚÚ 0>P>ԙÖ2Ò'<=K>G72N=â9:12;¾>PKGFPÖCÚ KPÖ2F&<=ÒB40@K`<=9:Ò:>eÝ+$\1Ã>G0eÚ&KG9INO12>Eâ9:KP7ö729:;J7ÃÙ.NJ>G9:KP9:NJ1C<AÒ

(3)

, q ›

KP720^ÜÀNJFP0>PK&<=ç2Ò:0^>P0eÚ KP9:NJ12>KP7200/Oèñ>PKGFPÖCÚ KPÖ2FG0¹Ú<A1EçC0B49216Ú&Ö2Ò:KKGN>G00B4Ö20¸KPNKP720Ò½<OÚPH

N=Ô"B40Ù2KG7àÚ Ö20>eÝ

3 46587:9+É5•Ì<; Ë"Ê=

>

NJÜÀÜ'NJ1B49:>`Ú FP0KG0<=1CBE>GK`<AKP9½Ú^KP0,ÚP7Q129½íJÖQ0>Ö2>G0eB»KGNB49:>PÙ2Ò½<,3ÀÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò½<=F>PKGFPÖCÚ KPÖ2FG0'9I1îæ

Ú&Ò:ÖCB40Eâ9:FP0ԙF`<AÜ0B40ÙQ9SÚ KP9:NJ12>'NAÔxÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò:0ÀçCNO1CB4>eõ%ç.<=Ò:Òß<A1CBÓ>PKG9SÚGH¾FG0Ù2FP0@>P014K`<AKP9:NJ1Q>

>P72N=â9:12;ç.NJKP7»<AKPNJÜÀ>ß<A1CBÀçCNO1CB4>,õ2FP9:ç2ç.NJ1Q>KPN'KGF`<OÚ&0NJÖQKKP720ç.<JÚGH4çCNO120>NAÔMÚ&NJÜÀÙ2Ò:0&ï

ÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0>eõ<A1CB^>GÙC<JÚ&0 æ™ÑCÒ:Ò:9:12;ÜÀN2B40Ò:>o>P72N=â9:12;0,<JÚG7¹<AKPNOÜ@?>CÕJ<A1B40FAÛ<J<AÒI>oF&<JB49:Ö2>+B PÝ

ÞENJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò½<=FB4341C<AÜ9½Ú&><=FP0Ú&NJÜÀÜNJ1QÒI3'B49:>PÙQÒS<,3O0eBÀÖ2>P9:12;<A129:Ü6<AKP9:NJ12>,Ý$\1ø>P9:KPÖC<AKP9:NJ1Q>N=Ô

Ò:9IÜÀ9:KP0eBB4341C<=ÜÀ9½Ú&>eõO>PÖCÚG7Â<A>9:16Ú&FG3Y>GK`<AÒ>GKPFGÖCÚ&KPÖQFP0>,õoÒ:9I1Q0xB4F&<,â9I1Q;J>>P7QN=â9I1Q;¹<AKPNJÜÀ>M<=>

KP720@FPÜ6<AÒòæëÜÀN=KP9:NJ1^Ù2FGNJçC<Aç29:ÒI9:K\30@ÒIÒ:9:Ù2>GNJ9½B4>%7C<,ÕJ0ç.001EÖ2>G0eBCEDFÝGöԙ0âöFP0@>P0e<AF`ÚG720FG>x7.<,ÕJ0

Ú&FP0,<=KP0,B¾ÜNOFP0Ú NJ14KP9:14Ö2NJÖQ>xFG0Ù2FG0>P014K&<=KP9:NO12>'N=ÔÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0>ÖQ>P9:12;»ÕONJÒ:Ö2Ü0^KG0eÚG72129½íOÖ20>

KPN¾FG0Ù2FP0@>P014K»0Ò:0eÚ KPFPNO1³B401Q>P9:K\3H/FPÝJI1Q0EԙN2Ú&Ö2>ÀN=ÔKP720øFP0>G0e<=F&ÚP7 Bî0>`Ú&FG9:çC0eB â<=>KGN

Ú&NJÜ'çQ9I1Q0B49:>`Ú&FG0KP0'<=1CBÀÚ&NJ14KG9I14Ö2NOÖ2>KP0,ÚP7Q129½íJÖQ0>9:14KPN<¸>P9:12;OÒI0^Ö21Q9jÑ.0eBÀÕY9:0âÝ

Ð720FP0@Ù2FP0>G014K`<AKP9:NJ1¾NAÔBQ<=K`<â9:KP7EÖ21CÚ&0@FPK`<A9:1YK\3ø9I>^<=1»<JÚ KP9:ÕJ0'<=FG0e<'NAÔµFG0>P0,<=F`ÚG7¾9:1

KP720ÑC0Ò½B¾NAÔLK^0@NJ;JF&<=Ù27Q9SÚM$\14ԙNOFPÜ6<AKP9:NJ1ÅD434>PKP0@Ü>ÀêNK$PD2ì@õ%Ö2>P9:12;Å>PÖ.ÚP7ö<=Ù2ÙQFPNY<OÚG720><=>

KP720'ÖQ>P0NAÔ8Ú NJÒ:NJF,õoKPF&<=12>GÙC<=FG01CÚ&34õ%Ò:9I1Q0â9½B4KG7•õoç2Ò:Ö2F,õo7C<=×@0Jõ%9:1YKG0F`<OÚ&KP9:ÕO0'Ù2FPNOç29:12;Cõ•<A1CB

<=129:ÜE<=KP9:NO1OPõPFPõQRTSTPõQUDFRPÝVAÃ9:KP729:1ÀKP720^Ñ.0Ò½BEN=Ô"Õ49:>PÖC<AÒI9:×e<AKP9:NJ1+õJFG0>P0e<AF`ÚG720FG>7.<,ÕJ0

<=Ò:>PN^FG0eÚ&NJ;O129:×0eBKG7209:ÜÙ.NJFGK`<A1CÚ&0bN=ÔoÖ21CÚ&0FGK`<A9I14K\3'B2<=K&<KPN<OÚÚ&Ö2F&<=KP0Õ49I>GÖC<=Ò:9:×e<AKP9:NJ1<A1CB

7C<,ÕJ0çC0@01Â<JÚ KP9:ÕJ0^9:16B40@ÕJ0Ò:NJÙQ9I1Q;'120âFP0Ù2FG0>P0@1YK&<=KG9INO1»KP0,ÚP7Q129½íJÖQ0>eÝ.Ð7209:FKG0eÚG72129½íOÖ20>

7C<,ÕJ0'9:1CÚ ÒIÖ.B40eBÓ9:KP0F&<=KP0,BÅԙÖ21.Ú&KP9:NJ1Ó>P34>PKG0Ü)ԙF`<OÚ&K`<AÒ9I14KG0FPÙ.NJÒ½<=KG9:NJ1•õ.Ô\<=K>PÖ2FÔë<JÚ&0@>eõM<A1CB

>PNO129òÑ·Ú<=KG9:NJ1NAÔÖ21.Ú&0FPK&<=9:14K\3@WBGPõEXTPõQEYTPÝ

Z [\5+Î]ÈÏ:^Í_58`baË"Êdce]ËgfÛÏPÈihkjËJ`4ÏÉîÏGË"È_97mlÃÈÎQ5+Ê4É9%ÏPÈÉ n

o"NOKP7B4FGÖ2;'<=1CB>PÖ2ç2>GKPF&<=KP0<AFP0>GÖ%16Ú&9:014KPÒ:3Ú&NOÜÙ2Ò:0&ïKP7C<AK·÷&Ö.B4;J9:12;^KP7Q0xíOÖC<=Ò:9:K\3N=ԕKP7Q0

ÑCK"9:>B49216Ú&Ö2Ò:KeÝ $\1ÀNJF&B40FbKPNÜÀNJFP0Ú ÒI0,<=FPÒ:39:ÒIÒ:Ö2>GKPF&<=KP0KG720^ÙCNOKP014KG9S<AÒ4ÑCKbçC0@K\âM00@1à<¸B4FPÖ2;

ÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0<=1CBøKP720K`<AFP;O0K>P9:KG0Jõo<Õ49:>PÖ.<=Ò:9:×e<=KG9INO1E>P72NOÖ2Ò½B»>G72N=âñKP720'F&<=12;O0NAÔMÙ.NJ>P>G9:ç2Ò:0

B4FPÖQ;¹Ú&NO14ÑC;OÖ2F`<AKP9:NJ12>,Ý

pQ qUrG %sUt)%u v%wsTxsTzyJ

Ú&NJÜÀÜNO1'ÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò½<=Fb;JF`<AÙ2729½Ú&>KP0eÚG72129½íOÖ20â7Q9SÚG7Â<OB2B4FG0>P>G0>^KP720Ù2FPNOç2Ò:0ÜùN=Ô"9:12>PÖ4ԓæ

Ñ·Ú&9:014Kb>P7C<AÙC0Ú Ö20>9:1KG720^â9IFG0ԙF`<AÜ0bԙNOFPÜÄ9:>bKP720^çC<AÒIÒo<=1.B'>PKG9½ÚPHÀFP0ÙQFP0>G014K`<=KG9:NJ1•Ý*$\1

KP729:>^FP0@Ù2FP0>G014K`<AKP9:NJ1•õ"<AKPNOÜ>x<AFP0'FG0Ù2FP0@>P014KP0,BÃ<=>>GÙ2720FG0>N=Ô<=Ù2Ù2FGNJÙ2FG9½<=KP0Ú NJÒ:NJF<A1CB

>P9:×0Jõ%â7Q9IÒ:0ÀçCNO1CB4><=FG0EFP0Ù2FG0>P0@1YKG0eB<=>'>P7.<JB40eBÓFGNîBî>'NJFKPÖ2ç.0>eÝ 8NJFPÜE<=Ò:Ò:3»KP7Q06ç.<=Ò:Ò

>P9:×09:>x<ÔnÖ21CÚ&KG9INO1»N=ÔbKP720ÕJ<=1ÂBî0FAÛ<J<=Ò:>F&<JB49:Ö2>8ԙNJFKP720'<=KGNJÜ <=1.B»Ú&NJÒ:NOF9:>xÚG72NO>P01

KPNÚ&NO14ԙNOFPÜåKPNÀKP720>PK&<=1CBQ<=F`BàÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò½<=Fb;JF`<AÙ2729½Ú&>Ú&NO1YÕO014KP9:NJ1Q>eÝCDî9I1.Ú&0>GNJÒ:9½BÀNJçJ÷&0eÚ KP>

<=FG0Ö2>G0eBÀKPNFP0Ù2FG0>P0@1YK^KG720<=KPNOÜ>"<=1.Bç.NJ1.B4>eõ4NO120;O0KP>ç.0KPKG0FxBî0Ù2KP7»Ú&ÖQ0>bԙFPNOÜÄKP7Q0

FP01.B40FP0,BÅ9IÜE<=;O0JÝJÐ7Q0>GNJÒ:9½BNOçJ÷&0eÚ&KG><=1CBEKG720<OÚÚ&NJÜÀÙC<=14349:12;>P7C<OB49:12;NAÔµKG720'<=KPNOÜ>

<=1CB¸ç.NJ1CB4>Ú&FG0e<=KG0<A1'NJçJ÷&0,Ú&K"ç.NJÖ21CBQ<=FP3ÔnNJF%KP720^<=KGNJÜ>,Ý,Ð720>P0^N2ÚÚ&Ò:Ö2>G9:NJ1'ç.NJÖ21CBQ<=FP9:0>

Ú&NJ14ÕO036<¸>PKGFPNJ1Q;'FP0Ò½<=KG9:ÕJ0B40Ù2KG7»9:14ԙNOFPÜ6<AKP9:NJ1'<=ç.NJÖQKMKG720>PÖQÙC0FG9:ÜÙ.NJ>P0,B>GÖ2F\Ô\<JÚ&0>,Ý

ô14ԙNOFPKGÖ21C<=KG0Ò:3Yõ>P9:ÜÙQÒI3¾ÙQÖ2KPKG9I1Q;ÛçC<AÒIÒ^<=1CB >PKP9½ÚGHÃFG0Ù2FP0@>P014K`<AKP9:NJ1Q>»N=Ô<=Ò:Ò8Ôë<=ÜÀ9IÒ:3

(4)

{

ü%ý½þ.®}|Q®

l.ijp,¡=[•c™X@]iŸmjtx]^V&]°4V&Z\s%s\¡Ja¯_2vJXU~ VXhG¡x¯µij[\¡^c½f=mŸm2aeW4XhGij[nt,vJ°'~ V X@hP¡¸¯%ij[\¡X_a,WYX@hGij[™t

ac•}Ašj{ye|AšîdXZ\°4a,_X[\a,]^sMXZ\Vp,Z\V&t,vY_Aij[\Z\aep,V&_Z\V&k2v4a´=t=p,V`_'°AmjfJV,v2X_Ok'¡=t=kJZ\a,peV&_¯¡=ij[\V,š

A¾NJFG>P0%3J0K,õ,KP720"Ò:0e<A>PK%Ú&0FPK&<=9:1ÙC<=FGKP>•NAÔ2KP720bÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0%Ù2FPN2B4ÖCÚ 0MKG720"ÜNO>PKo>GNJÒ:9½B4Ò:3ÙC<JÚGHJ0,B

<=FG0e<=>NAÔKP7Q09:Ü6<=;O0>eÝVñ>PÒ:9:;J74KbÜN2B49òÑ·Ú<AKP9:NJ1'NAÔKG720çC<AÒIÒo<=1.B>GKP9½ÚGHKG0eÚG72129½íOÖ20âbNJÖ2Ò½B

<=>G>P9:;J1'KGN0e<OÚG7'Ôë<AÜ9:Ò:3xÜÀ0Ü'ç.0F"<^ԙF&<JÚ&KG9:NJ1'N=Ô"<,ÕJ<=9:Ò½<=ç2Ò:0"0@120FP;O36Ú&NOFPFG0>PÙ.NJ1CBî9I1Q;'KPN9:KP>

Ò:9IHO0Ò:9:72N4NîB ÝJD400\(+9:;JÖQFP00D=ç•Ý

$\1Â<JB2Bî9IKG9:NJ1»KGNÜ6<AH49I1Q;KG7209:ÜE<=;J0^Ò:0>G>Ú FPN=âB40eB õoKP729:>KP0eÚG72129½íOÖ20'9:>0 Ø·0eÚ KP9:ÕJ0'9:1

>P0Ù.<=F`<AKP9:12;¾KG720»9:Ü6<A;J0'9:14KPN¾K\âbNÂFG0;J9:NJ1Q>eÝ"Ð7Q0»NJÙC<OíOÖ20EÙC<=FGKFP0@Ù2FP0>G014KP>»KG720EÜNOFP0

>PK&<=KP9½ÚÙ.NJFGKP9:NJ1ÅN=ÔKP720EB4FPÖQ;»ÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0Jõ.â720FG0e<=>KP720'ÜÀNJFG0KGF`<=1Q>PÙC<AFP014KÙC<=FGK>P72N=â>

ÙCNOFPKG9INO1ÂNAÔMKP7Q0'ÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò:0KG7C<=K^9:>B4341C<=ÜÀ9SÚAÝCÐ7Q9I>^;O9IÕO0>^>P0eÚ KP9:NJ12>N=ÔbKP720ÀÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò:0<

Õ49I>GÖC<=Òoâb09:;J74KÚ&NOFPFG0>PÙ.NJ1CBî9I1Q;KPN'KG720Ò:9:HJ0Ò:9:72N4N2BKP7C<AKKG720^>P0eÚ&KG9:NJ1»9:><JÚ KPÖC<AÒIÒ:3E<=KKP7Q0

B49:>PÙ2Ò½<,3O0eBÒ:NîÚ@<=KP9:NO1•Ý $\K<=Ò:>PN;J9:ÕJ0@>M<>G012>G0xNAÔÜÀNJKP9:NO1ç2Ò:Ö2FbKPNKP729:>bÙC<=FGKMNAԕKP720^9:Ü6<A;J0JÝ

pQ €ƒ‚%„ƒ…yQyw†b‡y„ƒˆOtM'u '8sUx*sUzy

$\1'KP720^Ù2FG0Õ49:NJÖ2>bKP0eÚG721Q9SíOÖ20@>0e<JÚG7ÜÀ0Ü'ç.0F%N=ԕKP7Q0xÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI0Ôë<AÜ9:Ò:3x9:>B49:>PÙ2Ò½<,3O0eB'<=><

>P0Ù.<=F`<AKP0<A1CBB49:>`Ú FP0KG0Ù.NJ>P>G9:ç29:ÒI9:K\34ÝeD4Ö.ÚP7FP0@Ù2FP0>G014K`<AKP9:NJ12>Ú&NOÖ2Ò½B9:ÜÙQÒI3KP7C<AK%KP720>G0<=FG0

KP720NO12Ò:3¹Ú NJ14ÑC;OÖ2F`<AKP9:NJ1Q>"ÙCNO>P>G9IçQÒI0OÝ$\K"âbNJÖQÒSB¸ç.0ÜNOFP0<JÚÚ Ö2F`<AKP0^KPNÚ NJ12>G9SBî0FMÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI0

Ôë<=ÜÀ9:ÒI3bÜ0@Ü'çC0FG><A>>&<=ÜÀÙ2Ò:0>•NAÔ <8Ù2FP0>GÖ2Ü6<Aç2Ò:3Ú&NJ14KP9:14Ö2NOÖ2>%ÙCNO>P>P9:ç29:Ò:9:K\3^>PÙC<OÚ&0JÝV$\1>GÖCÚG7

<>GÙC<JÚ&0OõJKG720ÙCNO>P9:KP9:NO1N=Ôo0e<JÚG7'<=KGNJÜ 9:>"<ÙQFPNJç.<=ç29:Ò:9:K\3Bî9I>GKPFG9IçQÖ2KP9:NJ1+ÝU$\1NJF&B40F"KGNÚ&FP0e<AKP0

KP729:>'>GNJFPK'NAÔÚ&NJ14KP9:14Ö2NOÖ2>'Õ49I>GÖC<=Ò:9:×e<AKP9:NJ1•õ+KP7Q0Ñ.FP>PKÀ>PKG0ÙÃ9:>'KPNÛÚ&FG0e<=KG0ÂKG720EÒ:9IHO0Ò:9:72N4NîB

ÕJNOÒIÖQÜ0KG7C<=KBî0>`Ú&FG9:çC0>'KG720ÙQFPNJç.<=ç29:Ò:9:K\3»N=Ô<=1Û<AKPNJܼçC0@9I1Q;ã<AK0e<JÚG7¾Ò:N2Ú<=KG9:NJ1•ÝoÐ7Q0

NJFG9I;O9:1C<=ÒJB2<AK`<8>P0K%9:>B49:>&Ú&FP0KG0ß<A1CB^Ö21Q>PKPFGÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0eBg‰JKG720MÒ:9:HJ0@ÒI9:72N4N2BÕONJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ09:>%Ú&NJ14KP9:14Ö2NOÖ2>

<=1CB>PKGFPÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0,BoÝ

Ð729:>KPF&<=12>ԙNJFGÜ6<AKP9:NJ1ԙFPNOÜ<A1»Ö212>GKPFPÖ.Ú&KPÖ2FG0eBÛBQ<=K`<>P0K^KGN6<>PKGFPÖCÚ KPÖ2FG0eB¾NO120Ú<A1

çC0E<JÚÚ NJÜÙQÒI9:>G720eBÅÖ2>G9I1Q;Â<»ÕJ<AFP9½<=KG9:NJ1ÅN=Ô>PÙQÒS<AKPKG9I1Q;CÝ8A¾0>PKGN=ÕJ0F9:1YKGFPN2B4ÖCÚ 0eB¾>GÙ2Ò½<=KPKG9:12;

<=><=1ÀNJçJ÷&0eÚ K\æ\NJF`Bî0FÜÀ0KP72N2B¸Ô™NOFßBî9IFG0eÚ&KGÒI3ÀFP01.B40FP9:12;'>GKPFGÖCÚ&KPÖQFP0eBEÕONJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ0>_U/F Ý4ô>G9:12;

KP729:>ÜÀ0KP72N2BoõDJèáԙN4NJKPÙQFP9:14KP>N=Ô"ÕON,ïî0@ÒI>N=ÔM<)/Jè ÕJNOÒIÖQÜ0x<AFP0Ú NJÜÙ.NJ>G9:KP0eBÀNJ14KGN6<)DJè

(5)

, q

ü%ý½þ.®}‹Q®Œ

XfOs\sniIX_s\W=mIX@[\[nij_JpX@_Jkijs\aes\fOZnc“X@h&VV&´=[\ZPXh&[nija,_2šYXT~ ijs\amjV&r,VPmoreX mjfJVbaco}=šE=v=°'~ ijs\a@mjV&reVGm

reX mjfJVa@c•}=šEe|Aš

Ú<=1ÓçC0EÖ2>G0eBÓKPN»>&<=ÜÀÙ2Ò:0'Ö212>PKGFPÖCÚ KPÖ2FG0eBÃÙ.NJ9:14KP>9:14KPNÂ<ø>PKGFPÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0,BöÙCNO9:1YK>P0@Ke݊KGHQ?>

K<=ÖQ>P>P9½<A1CD4Ù2Ò½<=KGKP0FÚ&NOÜÙ.NJ>G9IKG0>0/Jè ԙN4NJKGÙ2FP9:14KP>^9:14KPN»</Jè ÕONJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ0xç43Â<OÚÚ&Ö2Ü'ÖQÒS<AKP9:12;

KP720^ÜE<,ï29:ÜÖ2Ü >PÙ2Ò½<AKMÕJ<AÒIÖQ0<AKM0,<JÚG7»ÕJN,ï20Ò\ÝOÐ720>GÙ2Ò½<=KPKG9:12;ÔnÖ21CÚ&KG9INO1Ö2>G0eBE720@FP09:>KP7Q0

Ö2129òԙNOFPÜkK<=ÖQ>P>P9½<A1àBî9I>GKPFG9IçQÖ2KP9:NJ1+Ý4Ð720ԙÖ21CÚ&KG9:NJ16Ú@<=1»ç.0Ú<=>GK9:14KPNKP720ԙNOFPÜ

Ž êqw‘’‘“JìJ”d•U–G—˜ ™š}›œwžqŸ ê}eì

â720FG0x>9:>ß<>&Ú<=Ò:0Ôë<JÚ KPNJF,õOÔ"9I>KG720^0&ï2ÙCNO12014KÔ\<JÚ&KGNJFÚ&NO1YKGFPNOÒIÒ:9:12;Bî0eÚ<,3F&<=KG0Jõ2F9:>KP7Q0

B49:>PK&<=1CÚ&0¸çC0K\âb001¾KG720ÙCNO9I14K<A1CBEKP7Q0 K<AÖ2>P>G9½<=1»Ú&014KP0@FÙCNO9:1YK,õC<A1CB»5ñ9:>KP720F&<JB49:Ö2>

N=Ô%9I1îðCÖ201CÚ 0N=Ô%KP720\K¸<=Ö2>G>P9½<=1•Ý

ô>P9:12;ÅKP7Q9I>KP0,ÚP7Q129½íJÖQ0JõM<A1ÛN=ÕJ0@F`<=Ò:ÒԙÖ21CÚ KP9:NJ1ÓKP7C<AKÙ2FG0eB49½Ú&KG>KP7Q06Ù.NJ>G9:KP9:NJ1¾NAÔxKP7Q0

B4FPÖQ;'ÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò:0Ú<=1»ç.0Ú&NJ1Q>PKPFGÖCÚ&KG0eBoݕó"<OÚG7à<AKPNOÜÄԙFGNJÜÄ0,<JÚG7»N=Ô%KP720¸ÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò:0bÔë<=ÜÀ9IÒ:3

Ü0Ü'ç.0FG>x9:>>PÙ2Ò½<AKPKP0,BÛ9:14KPNÅ<@/OèÄ>GKPFPÖ.Ú&KPÖ2FG0eBöÙ.NJ9:14KP>NJçJ÷&0,Ú&K'KPNÅÙ2FPN2B4Ö.Ú&0»<=;J;OFP0;4<=KG0

9:14ԙNJFGÜ6<AKP9:NJ1•Ý,Ð729:>bFP0>GÖ2Ò:K`<A1YK<A;J;OFP0;4<=KP0^9:>KP7Q0xÕJ<AÒ:Ö20NAÔKP7Q0ÔnÖ21CÚ&KG9INO1KG7C<=K9:1CB49½Ú<AKP0>

KP720^Ò:9:HJ0Ò:9:72N4N2BN=Ô"<=1»<=KGNJÜÄN2ÚÚ&ÖQÙY349:12;'KG7C<=KÒ:N2Ú<=KG9:NJ1•Ý

1»9:>PNO>PÖ2F Ôë<JÚ 0Ú<=1øçC00&ï2KPF&<JÚ&KG0eBEÔnFPNJÜùKP7Q9I>ÕJNOÒIÖQÜ0Jõ4Ö2>G9:12;'KP720Ü6<AF`ÚG729:12;'Ú&Ö2ç.0>

<=Ò:;JNOFP9:KP7QÜ¡E¢F Ý4Ð7Q9I>9:>GNJ>PÖQF\Ôë<OÚ&0¹Ú NJ14K`<A9I1Q>KP720ÕONJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ09:1Eâ729½ÚP7»<AKPNJÜÀ>ß<AFP0ÜÀNJ>GKM0&ï4æ

ÙC0,Ú&KP0eBøKPNÀçC0¸ÒIN2Ú<AKP0eB Ý·Dî00\(+9:;JÖ2FG0\/J<QÝ2Ð720çQÒINOç2ç43Ù.NJFGKP9:NJ1E9:1»KP7Q0KPNOÙÂÚ&014KP0@FxÙ.<=FPK

N=Ô%KP720^9:Ü6<A;J09:>KP720<AFP0e<7C<,Õ49I1Q;729:;J7EÖ21CÚ 0FPK&<=9:14K\3»ê™KG720B4341C<AÜ9½Úb>P9½B40ÚG7C<A9I1ENAÔKP7Q0

ÜNOÒI0,Ú&Ö2Ò:0eìÝOÐ720ÚG72NO9½Ú&0N=Ô"9:>PNOÒ:0ÕJ0Ò+0ÜÙQÒIN=3O0eB'KGN'0&ï2KPF&<JÚ&KKP7209:>GNJ>PÖQF\Ôë<OÚ&07C<A>x<;JFG0e<=K

9:14ðCÖ201.Ú&0NJ1KP720ÚG7C<AF`<OÚ&KP0FG9:>PKP9½Ú&>bN=ÔoKP7Q0bÑC1C<=ÒQ9IÜE<=;O0JÝWö;JN4N2B¸9I>GNJÒ:0ÕO0Ò29:>%NJ120KG7C<=K"Ú<A1

0&ï2KPF&<JÚ&K%KP7Q0M>GKPFPÖ.Ú&KPÖ2FG0x<A1CB^;J0@NJÜ0@KPFP3^NAÔCKP720b>PK&<=KG9SÚÙC<AFPK%N=ÔCKG720bÜNJÒ:0eÚ Ö2Ò:0JõHO00Ù29:12;^KP7Q0

ç2Ò:NJç2ç43FP0ÙQFP0>G014K`<=KG9:NJ1ÅN=ÔKG720B4341C<=ÜÀ9½ÚbÙC<=FGKN=Ô"KP720^ÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò:0Ö21.ÚP7.<=12;O0eBoÝÒ:KP0FG1C<,æ

KP9:ÕJ0@ÒI34õ=KG7209:>PNOÒI0@ÕJ0ҕÚ<A1ç.0ÚG72NJ>G01EKPN';O9IÕO0x<AKPNJÜÀ>"9:>PNO>PÖ2FÔë<JÚ&0@>â729½ÚP7»<AÙ2Ù2FPN,ï29:Ü6<AKP0Ò:3

Ü6<AK`ÚG7»KP7Q0'ÕJ<=1ÂB40@F\AÛ<O<=Ò:>F`<OB49:Ö2>N=ÔKP7Q0<=KPNOÜÂÝ*KPNJÜÀ>9:1Å>PK`<Aç2Ò:0>G0eÚ&KG9INO12>'<=Ù2Ù.0e<=F

KPN'ç.0>GÙ2720FG0>eÝ8KPNOÜ>9:1EÜNOFP0B4341C<=ÜÀ9½Ú>G0eÚ&KG9INO12>^çC0,Ú&NJÜÀ0Ò:0>P>FP0;OÖ2Ò½<=F9:>GNJ>PÖQF\Ôë<OÚ&0>

(6)

£

ü%ý½þ.®:¤.®,

a@mjfJ]^VZ\V`_OkJV&Znij_Jp¸acomŸij¿,VGmŸij¡Ja=a=kErea@mjfJ]^V,šCXT~%V&]xWO¡YX@sni.-Gij_Jp'XZ\VX@s"ac•p,Z\VX[\V&s\[%mŸij¿,VGmŸiŸ±

¡Ja=a=kQvY°%~%peZ\VX@[\V&ZMh&a,_=[\Znij°JfJ[nija,_'c½Z\a,]mjV&s\s"mŸij¿,VGmjtXZ\VX@s&š

B49òØo0FP014K^<=Ù2Ù2FGNY<OÚP7ø9I>KPNÀFP01CBî0F^KP720Ò:9:HJ0@ÒI9:72N4N2B'ÕONJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ0Ö2>G9I1Q;6B49:FP0,Ú&KÕONJÒ:Ö2Ü0

FP01.B40FP9:12;.Ý4Ð729:>ß<AÙ2Ù2FGNY<JÚG7EÚ<=1E>P7QN=âÃKP720^â72NOÒ:0xB49:>PKGFP9:ç2Ö2KG9:NJ1'N=Ô%KP720^ÕONJÒ:Ö2Ü0Oõ=F`<AKP720F

KP7C<A1x÷&ÖQ>PKbKP72NO>P0Ù.NJFGKP9:NJ1Q>0&ïCÚ&00eB49:12;<KP72FG0>P72NOÒ½BÒ:9:HJ0@ÒI9:72N4N2BoÝ=Ð%0eÚG721Q9SíOÖ20@>MKGNÕONJÒ:Ö2Ü0

FP01.B40FÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò½<AFÙ2FPNOÙC0FGKP9:0>0&ï2Ù2FP0@>P>P0,BÛ<=><>PKPFGÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0eBÓÙ.NJ9:14KxB2<AK`<A>P0K7.<,ÕJ0ç.001

Ù2FP0@ÕY9:NOÖ2>PÒ:3Ö2>P0eBÀç43K^N4N2B4>P0@ÒIÒE/TPÝ%o"3'ÕONJÒ:Ö2Ü0bFP0@1CB40FG9I1Q;Cõ2âb0xÚ@<=1>G00KG7209:14KP0FG9:NJFbN=Ô

KP720¸ÕJNJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ0x<A>P>PN2Ú&9½<AKP0eBøâ9:KP7»KG720NOçJ÷&0eÚ&K,Ý.Ð729:>xÚ<A1»;J9:ÕJ0<'ç.0KPKG0F^9I1Q>P9:;J74Kx<A>KGNKP7Q0

B49:>PKGFP9:ç2Ö2KG9INO1N=ÔoKP7Q0MÙ.NJ>G9IKG9:NJ1'<=1CB¸NJFG9I0@1YK&<=KG9INO1N=Ô.KP720ÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&Ö2Ò:0M<AÒ:NJ12;â9IKG7KG720bÖ21CÚ&0Fæ

K`<A9I1'FG0;J9:NO19:1â729½ÚG7KG720^>P9½B40^ÚP7.<=9:1ÜE<,30&ï29:>PKeÝQÐ720xÚG72NO9½Ú&0^N=ÔKGF`<A12>\ԙ0@FbԙÖ21CÚ&KG9:NJ1KGN

Ú&NJ14ÕO0FPK"ÕON,ï20Ò2ÕJ<=Ò:Ö20@>"KPNFG0>PÖQÒIK&<=14KÚ&NJÒ:NJF"<A1CBNJÙC<OÚ&9:K\3ÕJ<AÒ:Ö20>"Ú<=1À;JFG0e<=KGÒI3ÚP7.<=12;O0KP7Q0

ÚG7C<=F&<JÚ&KG0FP9:>PKG9½Ú&>^N=ÔKG7209:Ü6<A;J0Ù2FGN2B4ÖCÚ&0eB Ý¥(+9:;JÖQFP00B'>G72N=â>ÕJNOÒIÖQÜ0FG01CB40@FP9:12;J>N=Ô"KP7Q0

Ò:9IHO0Ò:9:72N4NîB8ÕJNOÒIÖQÜ0%Ö2>P9:12;B49òØo0FP0@1YK%KGF`<=1Q>\ԙ0FµÔ™Ö21CÚ&KG9:NJ12>,ÝF(+9:;JÖQFP0+BY<0@ÜÙ27C<A>P9:×0>%KG720<=Fæ

0e<=>%â720@FP0<=KPNOÜñN2ÚÚ&Ö2ÙC<AKP9:NJ19:>%Ù2FPNOçC<=ç2Ò:0JÝ (+9:;JÖ2FG0JBJç9:1CÚ&Ò:ÖCB40@>µ<8;JFG0e<=KG0FMÚ&NO1YKGFP9:ç2Ö2KG9:NJ1

N=Ô"<=FP0,<=>â720FG0<=KGNJÜÄN2ÚÚ Ö2ÙC<=KG9:NJ1E9:>Ü'ÖCÚG7Ò:0>P>Ò:9:HJ0@ÒI34Ý

¦ Ç'§k¨i7:5w§<5oÈ"É9+É2ÏPË"È

Ð720^KP0eÚG721Q9SíOÖ20@>Bî0>`Ú&FG9:çC0eBø720FG0<=FG09:ÜÙ2Ò:0Ü'0@1YKG0eB'ÖQ>P9:12;'KP7Q0©Š9:>PÖC<AÒI9:×e<AKP9:NJ1ÀÐ%NYNOÒ:HY9:K

ê™Õ4KPH2ìEªTPÝwŠKPHÓ9I>'<àԙFP00@ÒI3ö<,ÕJ<=9:Ò½<=ç2Ò:0)/Jèù;OF`<=ÙQ729½Ú&><=1CBÓB2<=K&<ÅÕ49I>GÖC<=Ò:9:×e<AKP9:NJ1¾KGNYNOÒ:HY9:K

â729½ÚG7ÂÚ<=1Åç.0Ö2>G0eBàԙNJF^<â9½B40¸ÕJ<=FP9:0K\3ENAÔßÚ&NJÜÀÙ2Ö2KG0F;OF`<=ÙQ729½Ú&><=1CBÅB2<=K&<'Õ49:>PÖC<AÒ:9I×,<,æ

KP9:NJ1øÙ2FPNOç2Ò:0Ü>,ÝCÐ7Q9I>¸>PN=ÔnK\âß<AFP00ÜÙ2Ò:N=34>x<A1¾NJçJ÷&0,Ú&K\æ\NJFG9I0@1YKG0eB¾<=ÙQÙ2FPN4<JÚG7¾Ö2>P9:12; > ««

â9:KP7»<=1ENJÙQKP9:NJ1C<AҕÐÚ&Òz¬AÐH9:14KP0FÔë<JÚ&0OÝCÐ7Q0ÙC<JÚGHJ<A;J0Ú<=1øçC00 ïîKG01CB40,BÅâ9IKG7EKP720Ú NJ14æ

>PKGFPÖCÚ&KG9:NJ1'N=ԕ<JBQB49:KP9:NJ1C<AÒ2Ú&Ò½<=>P>G0>eÝOÐ%NÔë<JÚ&9:Ò:9:K`<AKP0bKP7200&ïCÚG7C<A12;J0NAÔ·9:14ԙNOFPÜE<=KP9:NO1xç.0K\âb001

ÐÚ&ÒM<A1CB > «« ÜÀ0KP7QNîBî>eõo<=Ö2KGNJÜE<=KP9½Ú<AÒ:ÒI3';O0120F&<=KG0eBÅâF`<AÙ2ÙC0@FÚ&N2B40'âFP9:KGKP01¾9:1 > 9:>

Ö2>P0,BoÝÙ2Ù2Ò:9½Ú<=KG9INO12>bÖ2>P9:12;'KG729:>KPN4NJÒ:H49:KM<=FG00e<=>G3KGN'9IÜÀÙ2Ò:0Ü'014KM<A1CB'Ù.NJFGK`<=çQÒI0<OÚ&FPNO>P>

(7)

, q

° cßÍ_§<§k9%Ê%n±9%È̳²ÂË"ÈÎQ7GÍ_`4ÏPËÈ_`

Ð720ÀÑC0Ò½BÓN=ÔB2<AK`<ÅÕ49:>PÖC<AÒI9:×e<AKP9:NJ1ÓN=Øo0FP>À;JF&<=Ù2729½Ú<AÒ>PNOÒIÖQKP9:NJ12>'KGN¾9:1YKG0FPÙQFP0KG9I1Q;ÛÒ½<=FG;J0

<=ÜÀNJÖ214KP>bN=ÔMB2<AK`<QÝ2ÞENJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒS<AF;OF`<=ÙQ729½Ú&>9:>NJ1Q0x>GÖCÚG7ã<AFP0e<â7Q0FP0'<¸Ô™0âñ;ONYN2BÀ9:Ü6<A;J0>

Ú<=1¾;OFP0e<AKPÒ:3Å0127C<A1CÚ&09:12>G9:;J74K9:14KPNEKP720ÀÙ2FPNOç2Ò:0ÜÂÝ.Ð720À;JN4<=Ò"NAÔßKG729:>Ù2FPN,÷&0eÚ&K'â<=>KGN

Ú&FP0,<=KP0ÅKP7Q0>P0øԙ0âå;ONYN2BÓ9:Ü6<A;J0>,Ý%Ð720»â9:FP0EÔnF`<=ÜÀ06<A1CBöKP7Q0»çC<=Ò:Ò<A1CBö>PKG9½ÚPHöÜÀNîBî0Ò

;J9:ÕJ0<¸;JN4N2B'>GK`<AFPKP9:12;Ù.NJ9:14K"ԙNOFMÕ49:>PÖ.<=Ò:9:×9:12;KP7Q0Ú NJÜÙQÒI0 ï ÝVo"3ÀÙ2Ö2KPKG9:12;¹<AÒ:ÒCKG720Ú&NJÙ29:0>

N=ÔKP720BîFPÖ2;»ÜÀNJÒ:0eÚ&ÖQÒI0¸9I14KGN6NO120'9:Ü6<A;J0<A1CBÂÚ NJ14KPFGNJÒ:Ò:9I1Q;6KG720'NJÙ.<JÚ&9:K\34õCKG720'FP0@>PÖ2Ò:KP9:12;

9:Ü6<=;O0¹Ú@<=1öçC0»B49:Õ49½B40eBÅ9:14KPNÅ>PK&<=ç2Ò:0»<=1CBÓB4341C<=ÜÀ9½ÚFP0;O9INO12>eÝ"DîÙ2Ò½<=KPKG9:12;»Ù2FGN=ÕY9½B40@><=1

>PKGF`<=9:;O7YKԙNJFGâß<AF`BE<=1.BÖQ>P0&ԙÖQÒâ<,3EN=ÔMÚ&NO1YÕO0FPKG9:12;KG720Ö212>GKPFGÖCÚ&KPÖQFP0eBÅÙ.NJ9:14KxB2<AK`<A>P0KN=Ô

<=KGNJÜåÙ.NJ>P9:KG9INO12>9:14KPNE<À>PKPFGÖCÚ&KGÖ2FP0eBäÙCNO9:1YK>P0KB40>`Ú FP9:ç29:12;»<ÀÒI9:HO0Ò:9I7QNYN2BÀÕJNOÒ:Ö2Ü0JÝ4Ð7Q0

ÚG72NJ9½Ú&0"NAÔC9:>PNOÒI0@ÕJ0ÒOԙNOF•KP7Q0"9:>PNJ>GÖ2F\Ô\<JÚ&0ԙFPNOÜñKP720b>PÙQÒS<AKPKG0eBBQ<=K`<Ú<=1¸çC0<=Ò:KP0@FP0eB¸KPN^Ú&FP0e<AKP0

Õ49I>GÖC<=Ò:9:×e<AKP9:NJ12>â9:KG7»>PÒ:9:;J74KPÒ:3»B49òØo0FP014K^;JN4<=Ò:>eÝÒIKG0FP1.<=KP9:ÕO0Ò:3YõQKP720Ò:9IHO0Ò:9:72N4NîBÀÕONJÒ:Ö2Ü0

Ú<=1øçC0'B49:FP0eÚ KPÒ:3EÕJNJÒ:Ö2ÜÀ0^FP01CBî0FP0eB õ•Ú&FP0,<=KP9:12;»<ÜNJFG0^72NJÒ:9:>PKG9SÚFG0Ù2FP0@>P014K`<AKP9:NJ1¾NAÔMKP7Q0

014KP9:FP0^Ò:9:HJ0Ò:9:72N4N2B'B49:>PKGFP9:ç2Ö2KG9INO1•Ý

´ µzÎ*=ÈËQf¶75•ÌihJ5w§k5+È"É`

Ð729:>•âbNJFGHâß<A>"Ú&NJ1CBîÖCÚ&KP0,Bâ729:ÒI0KP720<AÖ2KP72NOFP>%âb0FP0<AKKG720ô129:ÕJ0@FP>P9:K\3NAÔ·ÞE9:>P>G9:>P>P9:Ù2ÙQ9ëÝ

è^<=K`<â<=>Ù2FPN=Õ49½B40eBÀç43»èFeÝCè^<,Õ49½BK^F`<,ÕO0>eõoè0ÙC<AFPKPÜÀ014KN=Ô

>

720ÜÀ9:>PKPFG3Yõ2ô8129:ÕJ0FG>P9:K\3

N=ÔMÞE9:>P>G9:>P>P9:Ù2ÙQ9ëÝQÐ729:>ÜE<=KP0@FP9½<=Ò+çC<=>G0eBENJ1øâMNOFPHE>PÖ2ÙQÙCNOFPKP0,BÅçY3EKG720\<AKP9:NJ1.<=ÒDQÚ&9:01CÚ&0

(2NOÖ21CB2<AKP9:NJ1'ÖQ1CB40FK^F`<A1YK N.Ý

>

$P5·ªªVªXSGB'/QÝ

4¸5QaW5•Ê5+ÈÎQ58`

{eš ¹X[\V^w+V X@Z\kX@_Jk)ºøiŸmŸmŸiIX]éu'X@hP¿,X_OV`s\s»

,

ijs\f4X&m•~bh&h&V`s\s[\aUMX@[PX0¼bf4X&mŸij[ntij_

Œ

V&aep,ZPXWO¡=ijh

˜™_Ac½aeZ\]X@[nijae_gAt=s\[\V`]^s&šCd"X@Z\[\a,peZPX@WJ¡Aijh XAv2r,am½š

›

}=v4_JaOš2y&±

›

š½\{WU

› ~ ›

¯&±

{ |

y=šu¸ijhP¡4XVGmßw+fJZ\_OV&[\[X@_JkÅd"XZ\Z\a@mŸmûa,¡J_Os\ae_*»¿¾ .¢Ml•ú·±™˜\˜\˜»¥¾X@¿6 +ijkOpeV'¢"¡OV&Z\]X mMl.mŸmŸijWOs\aijk

ú.mja,["úoZ\a,peZPX@]^s•c½a,Zd%Z\t=s\[PX mîgA[\Z\fJh&[\fJZ\Vb˜“mŸmjfJs\[\ZPX@[nijae_Os&š¾X¿^ +ijkJp,V£MX@[nija,_YX m X@°Ya,ZPX@[\aeZnijV&s

 %V&W4aeZ\[ ¾ "£ ±ë|A{

›eœ

š½\{WT

£ ~

›

šg4šCU8š

Œ

a=a=kOs\VGmŸm½v gîšCu¸iIX_Qv·X@_Jk'~šCû=š¾mjs\a,_»· µV`_OkJV&Znij_Jp'r,a@mjfJ]^V&[\Znijhxk4X[PXij_']^amjV&h&f=mIX@Z

s\t=s\[\V&]xs&š.ûa,fJZ\_YX m•a@c ua@mjV&h`fAmIXZ

Œ

ZPXWO¡=ijh&s&v2r,am½š¯=š½\{W

œ

U~

{

{P±

{ ¯

{

šg4šCU8š

Œ

a=a=kJs\VGmŸmz»

,

ijs\f4X&mŸi.-Gij_Op6w ijamja,p@ijh X mßua@mjV&h`fAmjV&s&š gAhGijV`_=[ni

º

h~b]xV&ZnijhX@_2vCr,a@m½šCy

£

¯=v2_OaJš

|=š½\{WU,yU~

|=šb~MkOZniIX_»žV&Zq-`a,pV»·ua=kJVGmŸij_OpZ\VGmŸiIX°AiŸmjij[nt»a,_6s\[PX@[nijs\[nijhX&m"s\fOZnc“X@h&V&s°=tW4amjt=p,a,_

º

mj[\V&Znij_JpOšo˜™_

¢"¡JV~bh&h&fJZPX@h`ta@cg=WYX@[niIX mUMX@[PX°4Xs\V&s&vCu¸ijhG¡YX@VPm

Œ

a=a=kJhG¡=iŸmjk»X_Ok¹gAfJhG¡YX@Znij[PX

Œ

a,WYX m½vCV&kJs&šòš

¢•X&t,mja,Z:ÀJZPX@_JhGijs&v a,_JkOae_Qv½\{W

œ

T~My,}U ±ëyA{

œ

£

šg=fOZ\V`s\¡ a=kO¡YXAv2~"mjV&´'úoX_OpJvCX@_JkE %a,°YV&Z\[g=¡OV`V&¡4X_Qv·X@_Jkd%ZPX ijp\ºøij[\[\V&_=°JZnij_O¿%»

q  ¾JºÁ»

,

ijs\f4X&mŸi.-Gij_4p

q

_Oh&V`Z\[PX ij_=[ntij_Qmjf=ijkQmja@¯š¦ú Z\a=h`V&V&k=ij_Opesac2˜\l•l•l

,

ijs\f4X&mŸi.-X@[nijae_ÂE

£

š˜\l•l•l

d%a,]xWOfJ[\V&Zg=a=hGijV&[™t'úoZ\V&s\s ½\{WU

£

~My

{

 ±ëy,|

{

¯=šg=fOZ\V`s\¡ a=kJ¡4X=vodbšuÀšºøiŸmjs\ae_Qv•X_Ok6 %a,°4V`Z\[^g=¡OV`V&¡4X_*» ˜\g=¢Ml+£ »4s\aefO_JkAij_JpfO_Jh&V&Z\[PX&ij_=[nt

r,ijs\fYX mŸi.-X[ni:ae_Qšîú Z\a=h`V&V&k=ij_Opes%a@cY˜\l•l+l

,

ijs\fYX mŸi.- X@[nija=_ £

š˜\l•l+ld%a,]^WJfJ[\V&Z•gAa=hPijV&[ntxú Z\V`s\s&v

½\{ÍT

£

~8{

œ

 ±P{Í

£

œ

š+ºÛšol%š aeZ\V&_Os\V`_EX_Ok»žš2l%šod+mŸij_JVT»·u'X@Z\hP¡Aij_Jpd%fO°4V`s».~³žµijpe¡» %V&s\a@mjfJ[nija,_

›

Ug=fOZnc™Xh&V

d%a,_Js\[\Z\fJh&[nija,_~mjpea,Znij[\¡J]šCd%a,]^WJfO[\V`Z

Œ

ZPX@WJ¡=ijh&s&v2r,am½š2yA{eš½\{Í ¯U~8{ ±P{ 

(8)

œ

=š+ºÛš4g=hP¡OZ\a=V&kJV&Z&vv¹šJu'X@Z\[nij_2vòšîX@_Jk0ºÓšYlµš a,Z\V&_Js\V&_»O¢"¡JVU"V&snijp,_X_Ok˜n]xWAmjV&]xV&_=[PX@[nijae_Àac

X_0¾b° Ä\V&h&[n±™a,ZnijV`_=[\V&k¢oa=amj¿,ij[+c½a,Z

› U Œ

ZPXWO¡=ijh&sMX@_Jk

,

ijs\f4X&mŸi.-X@[niIa,_2š2úoZ\a=h&V&V&k=ij_Jp,sbac2˜\l•l•l

,

ijs\f4X&mŸi.-X@[nija=_b £

˜\l•l+lÂdµae]^WJfO[\V&ZMg=a=hGijV&[™t'úoZ\V&s\s&v½\{ÍT

£

~+

›

±P{}e}

{ }AšßUbX&r,ijk'¢"¡OV&ae°4X&mjk*»2~Mh&h&fJZPX@h&tX_Ok°AiIXsµij_s\fOZnc“X@h&VZ\V&WJZ\V&s\V&_=[PX[nija,_2š2˜n_¢"¡OV~Mh&h&fJZPX@h&tac

g=W4X[niIX mßUbX[PX@°YX@s\V&s&vu¸ijhP¡4XVGm

Œ

a=a=kOhP¡=iŸmjk¾X@_JkÂgAfJhP¡4XZnij[PX

Œ

aeW4X&m½v+V`kOs&šo¢•X&t,mjaeZ:ÀOZPX@_JhGijs&v

a,_JkOae_QvQ½\{Í

œ

U~JT ±P{ }

£

{e{,šß ßšuÀšQº6X@kJ¿,ij_Js'X@_JkÂU8š•l%š

Œ

ZPX&r,V&s»•˜n_=[\V`ZPX@h&[nijae_Osa@cM~M_AiŸmŸij_Ja=Xh&Zni:k=iI_OV&s'¯%ij[\¡Â£fJhGmjVGijh

~MhGijkOs» l·¶2V`h&[\s^a@cgAfJ°Os\[nij[\fJV&_=[ua=k=i

º

hX[nija,_4sacUM£~"±\woij_Ok=ij_Op6WOZ\aeW4V&Z\[nijV&s&šw ija=hP¡OV`]±

ijs\[\Z\t,vYr,am½š

›

}AvY_OaJš.{ïAš½\{ÍT={W~

{

yU¯T¯ ±

{ y

œ,›

{ yAšßu'X@[\[\¡JV&¯CºEXZ\k^X_OkûfO_=¯V&__Å4¡OV&_JpV»

,

ijs\fYX mŸi.-X[nija,_ac2g=WYX@[nija@±™¢oV&]xW4a,ZPX&m2UMX@[PX+¼bfYX mŸij[™t,š

úoZ\a=h&V&V&k=ij_Jp,sa@c

Œ

˜ëgVÆ ˜ëgM ›

š½\{WU

›

~J¯eyT¯ ±N¯

›

¯Aš

{ › š šUºÀV&s\[\areV&Z»JOa=ae[\WOZnij_=[l reX&mjf4X[nija,_¸cSa,Z

,

a@mjfJ]^VM µV`_OkJV&Znij_JpOšYd%a,]^WJfO[\V`Z

Œ

ZPXWO¡=ijh&s&vJr,am½š

y {

š½\{ÍTe}T~

›T£

¯ ±

› ¯ £

{ {

šßdµZPX&ijp ºøij[\[\V&_=°JZnij_J¿%»4˜\ogOZPXh&[PX mY˜n_=[\V&Z\WYa@mIX@[nijae_ac2yeU¾X@_Jk

› U ,

ijs\fYX mŸi.-X[ni:ae_Qšîú Z\a=h&V`V&kA±

ij_Jp,sMa@c•˜\l•l•l

,

ijs\fYX mŸi.- X@[nija=_b,|=šO˜ël+l•lÅd%ae]^WOfJ[\V&ZßgAa=hGijV`[nt'úoZ\V&s\s&v½\{WTe|T~J¯T¯&±

œ{

Referanser

RELATERTE DOKUMENTER

Within the visualization fields, uncertainty has generally been treated as an attribute of data, with the research fo- cus on developing methods to signify and interact with

Figure 1: Visualization of predicted 2m temperature anomaly (colors), forecast skill (isolines) and ensemble spread

The potential of our method is demonstrated by an interactive volume rendering of three-dimensional data, where the gradient estimation is directly computed by the field

Second, the bend- ing of the propagation curve can be captured by the angles between surface normals of the traversed probability levels and represents shape differences of

In this work, we present a number of strategies from the field of Visual Analytics that have been recently designed and implemented, for the visualization of data, processes

Visual Analytics for the Exploration of Bladder Variability and Toxicity [RCMA*]. Visualization Strategies Addressing Uncertainty at Each Step of the

One way of showing these 3 distortions is by drawing the average in a radar plot where low distortions values are placed closer to the center and higher ones farther out.. In

I still don't get if the radar plots encode the change of the area etc or just the new area, and if it's just the new area I don't understand how this should help without knowing