• No results found

For peer review only

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "For peer review only"

Copied!
38
0
0

Laster.... (Se fulltekst nå)

Fulltekst

(1)

For peer review only

3852%0

%286'5-47 &1.34)2 57-'0)!;4) )6)%5',

%7) 8&1-77)(&;7,)87,35 2%

3140)7)-673*87,356 8+)67%(287%+2)"2-9)56-7;364-7%03*357,35:%;35:)+-%2

%7-32%0)27)53*27)+5%7)(%5)%2(!)0)1)(-'-2)

3581%2357,)5235:%;)+-32%0)%07,87,35-7;75867 ),3* 7)*%2)0+)0%2(364-7%03-%2%)4%571)273* 85+)5;

64)9-/%29)-+)0+)0%2(364-7%03-%2%)4%571)273* 85+)5;

-2+&)5+"22-35(&;)25-1%5;%5)**-')

)67930(!3582235(0%2(364-7%0!58673(<)4%571)273* 85+)5;

#32)2%57,30(35(0%2(364-7%0!58673(<)4%571)273* 85+)5;

/5<96)7, 7)-2"2-9)56-7;364-7%0357,35:%;35:)+-%2%7-32%0 )27)53*27)+5%7)(%5)%2(!)0)1)(-'-2)

-2(6)7133090)"2-9)56-7;364-7%0357,35:%;)4%571)273*

%6753-27)67-2%0 85+)5;

&5-1%5; 8&.)'7

)%(-2+& 2'303+;

)'32(%5; 8&.)'7)%(-2+ 85+)5;9-()2')&%6)(45%'7-'))%07,6)59-')65)6)%5',)%07, )'3231-'62'303+;

);:35(6 '3035)'7%0'%2')5*3003:845+%2-6%7-323*,)%07,6)59-')6!

# !!!,)%07,6)59-')5)6)%5', "$

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml

(2)

For peer review only

4

#)(#)'(.

4.5.:

.#$&)".

6.:

.(#$.

7

.#*'%* .

7

.###&.

8

.$&)##'(*$!.

9.

&($!$##.

9.:

.(#

!* &-*'(.

4

.$!*1!#'("$.

5.:

0

4

$&+#($#!#(&$ #(&(&#!"#.#*&'(,$'%(!$

$&($&+,.&$"'-.$&+,0

5

%&("#($'(&$#('(#!)&&,.#*&'(,$'%(!$$&($&+,.&$"'-.

$&+,0

6

$&(&#$&+,$#!!()($&(,(&)'(.$-.$&+,0

7

%&("#($)&&,.!!#$'%(!.$#.$&+,0

8

$&,#&"&,&.&$"'-.$&+,0

9

$&!#$'%(!&)'(.$-.$&+,0

:

#'(()($!#!#.)!(,$!(#'.#*&'(,$&$"'-.$&+,0

$&$)#(/6983

#)(#)'(.

$&+#($#!#(&$ #(&(&#!"#

#*&'(,$'%(!$$&($&+,

;36:&* .$&+,

$#/337:;:7;;775

1"!/ #)(0"#0)'(2(!"0#$

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(3)

For peer review only

4

!!!!%" %,# !'

"" !.!/%"#"""#"'./( !!"(

!"" !!( "!"%,#+

!" " +

" %'"#" "' #!"(6" #!"!(33!"!::

#"!+

""!!# '" " (!"!# !

#"'!+

46"%,# ""#!""#"'

"" +!# %,## (!

!# "" ""!!% #!+

'#"% (!# '""

!,52(,7+ '#"!% !","$!!

"" !!+

332""!% !"" $".<77/ " .<77/(

%'9:!.;64%,#"!/92!# !.;64%,#"!/(

!"$'+ "!(" %!!" $"

!" "$.<2+225/(#" !"% #!% $.

"3(5(8(;(34(37(3:(4346"%,#""!/*") 0-4+45(<2+42),7&)0-2+32(<2+6:(,7)0,3+3(<2+66+ % !"" # " !!.57'!$!+!# 67'!(

<2+68/(36 # !% "".8$!+!# :/9"!"!!!# ! .5$!+!# 6/+%,# ""33:8"

""!.89:$!+!# 72:/(3327!""!"!.7;4$!+!# 735/

99:!"" $!.472$!+!# 74:/+ !%,#%!!!"

%"!"!"!$!.1:455$!+1;::;(=2+223/+

!%,#%!!!"%"( !

"" # " !!!"!$!+

!+$" 22794365+

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(4)

For peer review only

/

"#(! ! " # "

"!""1(-,3'

!$ #(!

'

! %* +& ( " %#(!

!#'

#(! # &

! & "'

%# #(!' ( "#(!

'

# -220 #(! ! " !'

1.3! ## #%'

!&2,3!!# %'

# #&!%

%! " '!( #$!

# #%$ !""'-&. %

! # ! & # ! "

!!""""! '

"#"!#(!"! "

"(%!""% ! $ " ) # #%

%! " !%'.(0#"&

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(5)

For peer review only

:

+#"'"')''"#("&&&")'(+(""("'*# #+1)$

'(&(-'#) "( 0

;1>

+')&* "(& '"$&#&''&"#( -(#) -'((

('')(&0

?178

("#"#(* " &#!!"(#"'#&# #+1)$

*&''%)( -'(+&('# #+1)$'#) #)&/#")(

-'$ '('+##&" -(&(("&(#'$( '.#&"(#'# #

"& $&((#"&'42'50

8

"&'" -.("('#&(&"*# *!"(#

$&!&-&$&#*&'"(#"1#"!"!"(#&#" "'''&&#"'0

79

* ## #+1)$&!-&( -" )"%) (-# "#'('.'$ -"

&)& &'+( #"'("'(#(&* #&#'$( '&*'0#+*&.')

#"'&(#"'!)'( ""'((!$&(*((# #""&')&**#&'

&*('(&* 0"( -.('(#" "&)&**#&'$"((*

&#"'("(#* #$"+!# '#"&&((')$$#&($("(' &.

&$ """"!"('(#)(#&'#)&'0

7:

"#&+-.'! &"(#"

"((*'*" )"0"('(& .+('((!"-$#(''((# #"

"&$("('# #+1)$-(&+#) ,$&"'! &#&&'#&'#"

%) (-# !')&'( #+&#'((" (&"(*#'$( #"(&# '0#(&!' +&(#('(#&&"'#&!'""('"# #+1)$$&#&!.00&(#

'&#)' " *"('45.(!(#"#''#""&&)&&"."

&%)"-#!('(''')&&-0

'+'&"#!'#"(&# !) ("(&(& &&#)("#&(#&+- ( )(#&(-(&)'()'"$&*#)' -$) '$&#(## 0

7;

&'($("(+'" ) 7

'(

# )"866=.( '($("(" )7;

(

#!&86770"(&!" -''+&

$&#&!" )"86780

#" #!!((#& '&('.#&(#&+-$$&#*('

$&#(## "866<4=?3866<50("('$&#*+&(("#"'"(#&

"(&"((& 0(& +'&'(&" " & '0#*+("(&

66;=87:90)(##&"'(#" -((& +'&'(&77

(

#!&

866=.'$'()-'(&(" " & '0#*' )"866=0

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(6)

For peer review only

5

$"!#!&!""#75(!"&#!#"$!!(!!&#

$"0"#)!+##"!%"#"$!$%##!(."

$"-$"-/&!"+'$"!#!&!##"!#

75(!")####!#!$"##!####!)#

#!%!"#$"+

!"#"$%!"#("#!##+!'#(211

##"&#!!"$!(#!#$(##"$!"#"+551

"#!!%&!##!#)448""##!###

#!+

!!(#%&"#!##"- $#("#"&,$(

#!!##"$!$###+!!((#""&"##

##"&,$(#!&$'!"!!##! "!".#

#"/#&!"#+"!(#%&"##"#&#!#

"!$"%#"./&$"!!##"&,$(

#!!"#""#.#!!$/)"!((#""####"

&,$(#!&$%(##!"#"

! $(""#!"+

#""'#!%#)""#"%!#!#!#"+

26

"$!&,$$!(##"##&,$)&

$"""$!##"!###!%#+

27

$")##!%#

""##&!#"*

2+

##"&!!!!##!!

!##!!"#!#%&,$!##$".#

2/+!#&"%$#"$!!()(#")$"-"#)#

##!(.!$"-##"/)!"!$!!+

3+

%##""$##) For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(7)

For peer review only

4

" "#"). %!!("## !" ! # )."$"" ).# ""%,

##!(++!#"!# "!(!"&, '(

" !"$ #" !#(!'&").

"! "!!!'"!"" # ).!! #!$""%""!( $"

# !"" "%!$+

2+

"""!""" !""

""""" "+!""!

"!""" $++ "#"%,##!(

!!!'"! # $# !" "'"!!#!

# +!#!"! "%,# $"""

"%!$+

""!"" %,## "'!# "'

"# "!"#' + '(""!"!"%,# #

-" !.% "!#"" "'"+"%,##!%

"!"#' !""!% % #""%' !+%,

# !!"%,#'!%" # &"!(

!# "(!"& '(" !"$ #" !#!'-"0.+

0+ %!" "!" #-.1//5%,# +

*"" ""-13"!(6%,#'!.+* '"+

"!"#'" '(""!% ! !$!"'" $!"" ""

" $ ! # " # ! "

!"&, '

" !"$ #" !#-.

!'

!# "

&"

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(8)

For peer review only

=

!%"&)$&+$(%'$&$& &""$!*&+91:)%

"!%&!"$&(+0&&%(%&- * &! )%"$!$ !$&!

!'&&%&!!+ $%'&%!&%'$$+)%%$)&"& &0 &

"& &%"$!( !$! % &-&+)$$ !%&!!!)1'"&$+&$

4 &$( &! 5!$&&%'$!'&"& & 4! &$!%5'% )1%

$ !%&! %$( +&!$) ($%&+! !!+

4)))0 & '0 !50$ !%&! $&!)%7/7-"& &%)$%&$&!$ &!

&'%2%& 4--5 )&$&+%&!0!&$ (%&&!$)%

!& (!( &%'%#' &!!)1'"""! & &% +)+0$'&"& &%

)$ !& !$!'&!&$"& &%$$'& &%&$0$+- !

!$&! $$ &$"$!$%% !&! )%$(&!"$&"& %!$

%'$! %0!)($-%!$ %!!)1'"$"$% & )"$&- )%

!&"!%% & &$( &! $0

$$+!'&!%'$ &%&$)%&!&%&&'%! &1 96#'%&! $0!%'$ &%)$!&&% 9-<-?-78-7;-7>-87 8:! &%-0/

% #('&"196 !$"!$&% '&1&%%/(' &!

%%4"+%-$!-! &(-!&! %!5.&$%+"&!%%4&'-

" - '%3(!& 5. !&%&&'%3%0*% 1&%%$

%! '4+%" !- %! -""&&!%%-! %&"&! -$$!

'&%50

7>

$)%#)! &"

%

%& $, $ %&$' &"!+&!%'$!&!'&!01;

%'$%( %! %!&1$&!45/!&+-%1$-'%'

&(&%-" 3%!!$& *&+3"$%%! 0 %! %$&&&$

(%/ !"$!%475-%!"$!%485 !$"$!%4950

7?

%!

"$$ %&$! $"!"'&! -1;&%&&%4007171817195+

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(9)

For peer review only

<

#"*&("(#)( (-'#&'4=",'#&'. 50 "('(& +)'$&&"' (&#!$#$) (#".'"#'! &#&+"$&&"','(0

97

') " #) 45&#&'(&'$#""(6'' 1&( ('(()'#"

*&( -&)(4738775*') " #)' 0

'#)&')'4' "(#9:!#"('5+&&'(&$&#'$(* -'#"&$#&(' -($("('"#"#'$( &*+0#'( !"('" )#'('& ((#

#'$( *'('.*'('. #&(#&-('('.&# #-,!"(#"'.# #"#'#$-.

,!"(#"')(#')'$(& $'4&# #-.# #"#'#$-.#(#&,"2#&

#!".'"5.(&(!"(#&)&&".(&* "2(&"'$#&((#".$&#)(#"

#'''.#1$-!"('"#(&$("(2! -,$"''0

!(#"&"#''+'"'((!&#!#)&&"#'&#)' "

*"(4.("(&&& #&#'$( &#&5)"( ((#"#''

#0+'"'"$'#+&"&&)&&"+'')'$(0

"(&&-(&'-!$(#!'&$#&(4(# #+1)$#&"(+"# #+1)$5.

" ""'(# #+1)$#&""'-'&""('(0-!$(#!'" "

""'"((""#'(1)$+&"'/"&')'$( '#"&*

(# #"#'#$-."&'"!')&!"(''#+"-&$(!')&!"('. ##

"'(## ((-(!#45('(.)",$ "#!" $".)",$ "

+( #''#;)&"( '((&!#"('."&1')'$( '#"'((-

&( ,!"(#".$ $ -!$""#$(-.!('((')'$( '#"''#+"- '(,1&-.) (&'#)"# *&#&'"."&')'$(""'( "

,!"(#".#)&&"#"&& ('-!$(#!'0

((' "$$#"(!"(.$("('&&)(&*""%)'(#""&'4'$&(#

($("('#"1')$$#&($!$ (5#&&'$#""+((""# #+1)$- ' 4( 850%)'(#""&'#"("%)'(#"'#)(#$("('('(#"."

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(10)

For peer review only

A

%)*$()%+(+*")*%$1+)*%$$()-((*+($.#",(.*(#%$*) .*&*$*)*%**("$*(+$*":<#%$*)&%)*%&(*,".1)'+)*%$$() -(%&*"".("0$%$)+*,".()*($**("*)1()(

)))*$*-)()&%$)"%(*%""*%$0*)$&+*$&*$*(#$() -$#))$'+)*%$$()1(#$()-()$**%&(*&*$&*$*)-$

*'+)*%$$()-(;#%$*)%,(+*)*#*%""%-2+&)+"1""

'+)*%$$()-(*$-%+"*+)#%$*%(*("&(%())%$1$)%

#))$$%(#*%$%+*%)*"#$*)-*((,-*%)&*"0%(

&(%(#*"&%$$*(,--*&(*&*$)+(%$)0)%(&*$*)1

$+$:88?)#&")/"+"*%$)-()%$)$$","%=B$

&%-()**@8B0*)$***-$9;>&*$*)*%**98+$*)%

($511)#""*%#%(*#&(%,#$*6%$2;8"%" "*

)%(-*)*$(,*%$%:81$*%$%3)#""*%#%(*#&(%,#$*

%$%45198+$*)%$*"%""*)%(60$)*$(,*%$)*#*)%

%5%"%$$(&*$*)-*"%")))60-((*(,(%#&(,%+)

&+")&+"*%$)1

:90::

+"$)%(%$%#$".))"%$)($%#)%$*(%""*(")-(

#&"%.1

:;

)**("(,"$%($$'+"*.%"0%)*2#$#)*%$

$".))-)((%+*1%$%#,"+*%$)%*"&()&*,1;B )%+$*(*-)+)*%)%+$*+*+(%)*)$$*)1%(*)&+"*%$%)*

"#$*),$%$,(*(%#%(-$!(%$(56$*%(*)%+$)**

(*%97CA0;A)%*%(-$*%$"$!*:?

*

%+$:89:1

*")%*+$*%)*)))$*%"*(()%+(+)()%-$$*":1

%$%#,"+*%$*($,(".&%)*,".)!-0$*('+()$

"*($*,$".))1+)%%*)*(&&$*$'+0-#!)$%))+#&*%$) (($*'+"*.0,($%()&%*)*(+*%$0$*!)$*%%+$*

)!-$))1

:<0:=

% +)*%()!-$))%)*-(%%*)*(&&-*9888(&"*%$)*%

)*#*)%((*%$$$*(,")1%%*)*(&&$*$'+-) +$(*!$+)$**)*),9A18

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(11)

For peer review only

98

! 0(*$ $%'%* *$$($&$%!$$$$%#!&$% $$!%#$&%$

"%!'# /!%!$%!:<0! %!!(0&"($$$$$!#!(-$

"&%'&$- %#$&%)"#$$$ * "&%$-! !&%"&%%!# !#%/

! #$ #+%*!!$%%( !& %#$-& %!$%$#!%(#

& %$ $%'%* *$$/!$%!#! $&%%! !$%%$% -$

#"!#%%!;80<8B#% & %$!$%"" %$%# #' %!$%

%$(# #$!# * $ $%'%* *$$/:>

:/%$!%& %!$%$$$ %!%##$!&#&$%/

C:=B

!$%$!$"%%#' @@

!%!'# % ?<

#'%##%$ 8/:"#

# 98/>

) 9/;"#

&$ :/>

C:=0<8B

! $&%%! :8 9@/=

! ! $&%%! 98 =/;

# *! $&%%! ;8 :>

C:=0<8B

&#! !&%"% %! $&%%! ;8 >A

! ! $&%%! $&#! 9= 98/>

# *!&%"% %! $&%%! ;8 >A

C:=0<8B

!!$"$ =

$%00#* :=

! %#$% &%#$!& '# 9=;

! 98=

%!#) 98=

!! !$!"* :A;

$ :>>:

C:=B

!'# %#&#$ %9*(!#$ 98:

C:=B

!$%!! $&##* 9<9?>

!$%!'#$&##* 99=A>

!$%!& $&##* 9;8>9

5) #%:A%! & :89:.97DA/;>!#( #! #.

(((/ / !2 2&## *$%1D,$%D6

#$! !& %! !#%!#( % $%#%! 3 4.=<88888&% &

%#')" $$2A=8888 &"% %%#'$D@@7"#%#'

!%/

!#( %! &#&!% %#'$.%%".22(((/"$ %#$#/ !2 #0$"#2 $/

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(12)

For peer review only

==

'*/!&!$++'!,!'&4'*/!&'$!1'-%&,'*'.*&%&,$!%-*+%&,+!&

*!%*1*8+,$,*!&9><==4///5$'*&!&&5&'7&'*%$,*!7+,$,*!:><=<5(5

=?B8><%!&'&+-$,,!'&9G?DB(*(,!&,&&-$$15++-%!&=<

'&+-$,,!'&+(*(,!&,&&-$$1H?D7'&+-$,,!'&5&,',$=C@(*'&+-$,,!'&H=D5A;5

'*/!& $, -, '*!,!+5!%-*+%&,&/! ,!&!&'*/!& '+(!,$+><=>4 ,,(477///5 $+!*#,'*,,5&'7(-$!#+"'&*7*$.*#6!&&+,++,1*,6!&&+!*!&6

><=>7!*7-$,5+(05

#?D><E5 ! "E>?2/! ,<5<=C5 C=<2/! ,<5<C>5=C<2/! ,?5@D@5><=2 /! ,>5DA<5CB2/! ,?5>=

,,!+,!+!&'*/1><==4.*&&-$+$*1CA<<<<8D<<<<;9 '+(!,$'&+-$,&,5 '+,*,+(*,%&,'!'$'1&-$*!!&&!.*+!,1 '+(!,$'*, '*/15

'*&* 5'*!5,'##$&5'*!51+,%,!'$$'/6-(,*-*,!.+-**1'*'$'*,$

&*!&'*/14('(-$,!'&6+-!,',!.&++5'+,+5&'%($!&5+,*'!&,+,-*

><<A*3E8?94?><6D5

+,!%,*'%%!&!&'%'?A<<<<71*7(,!&,+*('*,1(,!&,+-+%($!&

*-$*/'*#,,!%'+-**15

+*!(,!.+,,!+,!+/*(*'*%1(*&,+2>0>'&,!&&1,$+2 ! )-*2!+ *0,,+,&,6,+,5 ++&$1++8&H==<2B<<'%($, '$$'/6-()-+,!'&&!*+71$+9/*(*'*%'&!&,&,!'&,',*,(*!&!($5

*,%&,*%+/*'%(*/!, *+(,,'(',&,!$'.*!,+-+!&'&,!&-'-+

&,'*!$-&!.*!$&$1++5 %!&&$1++0%!&/ , *!*&+

!&'-,'%,/&+$!&2?2B2E2=>2=A2=D2>=&>@%', +0!+,!&$$' '-,'%%+-*+86?<&6A95&*$$!&*%'$/+

%($'12/ *,!%8=6>@%'&, +9&!&,*.&,!'&*'-(8+.*+-+-*'&9 /*(*!,'*+!&&$1++'.*!&8,/&*'-(+95!++!&!,%+!&

'*%&/ &%!++!&'*%+2%!++!&,/*!%(-,1, $+,'+*.,!'&

**!'*/*895'&!,!'&$('/*89/+!&+, &',,!&

+,,!+,!$$1+!&!!&,*+-$,+,, &', ,*!$!.&, ,+'*5

>C2>D

!&I=AF++-!!&,, *+ '$,'+,'(*$15

>E

+-$,+/*0(*+++

%&!*&+'*'&,!&-'-+'-,'%+/!, '**+('&!&+,&*.!,!'&+

892EAF'&!&!&,*.$+2&++'!,(6.$-+56.$-+/**('*,/!, ,/'!%$($+/!, (6.$-+$++, &<5<<=*('*,+(I<5<<=5'*$$,+,+/

-+(H<5<A$.$'+!&!!&5$$&$1++/*(*'*%/!, ,,!+,!+

.=E5<8'%(&1><=<9&!*'+',0$'*><==5

==<(,!&,++-*!$$1,*,'*'$'&&*%,, !&$-+!'&*!,*!&*,' (*,!!(,8!-*=95 '&,*'$&!&,*.&,!'&*'-(/*%, ,+$!&'*

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(13)

For peer review only

,-

!

!(.)%

30(205)(/, %//)!!,-$03 (0-5)(-4 %-4)!!-/%.-!

(,2 %,0)$,/(3 % 1)%-+(4 %,,)!!

(,)%

1.1"102(415)$1++

(4,5)(-44 %.+,)!

#%-,(/5)(,, %,+)!.1 (,3 %,3)!"#

%

! !#

-+,+$!#(. %1 ) ("# %)%2&

#$#!-+,-(3+5

$,33/!&)%!/5#

(%%!)!

$!!%

.%%

"

#!!

"

#!!

"

#

60+ -(.'1) 1(,+'4) 2(1'.) +%,+

0+&04 3(,/'0) 1(,+'4) ,/(,-'2) +%01

1+&14 -.(/,'3) -/(/.'1) /2(/-'2) +%3/

2+&20* --(/+'+) ,4(./'0) /,(.3'+) +%00

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(14)

For peer review only

68

3& &%@<:+$%)$ ' %'$(+.('%'&)&%#'$-&&%& %$*&&%&) ""$!"$&.

$)% !% &&! &! !'&!%'$%. !)($-! &

/85%'%%-&$)$% &&% (!'$!!!)/'"-..

$!' &! 1"?5.572-!&! ' &! 1"?5.562 " 1"?5-56219- '$8--2.

12 ;;0<1<082 ;9051=0<2 ;:091=062 5.5>

871:=072 881;5052 ;:1:>062 5.=9

781960=2 77195052 9:1950>2 5.=9

$$+ 7518;082 6=1870<2 8=1890:2 5.;=

! $+ 7618=062 7:19:092 9;1960=2 5.9>

($%&+@9+$% =1690:2 :1>052 681660=2 5.8<

($%&+A9+$% ;1650>2 <1670<2 681660=2 5.<;

142 87/97555 87/97555 87/97555

"!+ & 671760=2 6<1850>2 7>17;082 5.7<

! 81:092 >16;082 66165052 5.5;

'&!)!$ 5152 6160=2 6150>2

%! $ 951<70<2 7=1:50>2 ;=1;60=2 5.56

($%&+!%"&1 ?62 891;60=2 8<1;<082 <61;90:2 5.::

!!%"&1 ?82 7618=062 6=1870<2 8>18:092 5.::

,' 681780;2 681780;2 7;1780;2 6.5

% % >16;082 :1>062 691670<2 5.7:

$ %($%' 91<072 :1>062 >1=062 5.<7

% 6160=2 9160=2 :190:2 5.6:

! 7=1:50>2 7=1:50>2 :;1:50>2 6.5

(&"$!"$&( 6>1890:2 781960=2 9718=062 5.::

"$!%!"%'$$+ 6917:0:2 66175052 7:1770<2 5.9>

" %'$$+ 961<90:2 991=5052 =:1<<082 5.9>

'% 671760=2 66175052 791760=2 5.=6

'% 7:19:0:2 851:90:2 ::1:5052 5.89

'% 6=1870<2 6917:0:2 8717>052 5.95

)%'$$+'&!!"&! % ;1650>2 >16;092 6:1680;2 5.95

$ &%&! =1690:2 <1670<2 6:1680;2 5.<=

;! &%!&$"+$ 6=1870<2 6917:0:2 8717>062 5.95

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(15)

For peer review only

,/

/%!!"!$( &.+&0)"!#

!! %

!!

(405) *

,-! -/!

" 2+%2(--%0) 20%4(,4%-) 30%+(,1%3)

2+%/(-+%3) 3,%.(,2%+) 31%0(,1%-) &-%-.(&0%2',%-) +%-+

" 3+%0(-.%1) 33%3(,0%+) 33%+(,2%+)

2/%0(-/%4) 4+%1(,1%1) 4.%.(,1%+) &-%/(&0%2&+%3) +%,/

" 1-%0(.2%.) 3.%3(-1%0) 4+%.(,3%1)

1-%2(.2%0) 4,%1(--%,) 4.%2(-+%2) &0%,(&4%2'(&+%0)) +%+-

" 32%/(,3%,) 32%2(,1%,) 32%2(,1%4)

30%3(-.%-) 4,%4(,0%3) 4/%/(,2%.) &.%2(&1%3'(&+%1)) +%+,

" 32%+(-+%1) 31%0(--%3) 4+%.(,0%+)

2-%/(.,%3) 4,%,(,2%+) 4.%+(-,%.) &,%2(&0%+',%/) +%-2

" 2+%2(.+%0) 32%+(-.%3) 4+%/(,0%1)

2-%/(.,%3) 4,%1(,2%.) 4.%+(-,%.) &/%-(&3%/&(&+%++4)) +%+/

" .-%.(-1%,) ,4%-(,2%,) ,/%1(-.%/)

.1%4(-3%+) --%-(,4%4) ,3%.(-+%3) +%-/(&.%2'/%-) +%4

" 1%+(,-%/) -%3(3%0) +%4(.%4)

1%0(,/%,) .%0(4%4) /%.(,+%.) &+%3(&-%3',%-) +%/

" --%.(-1%1) ,,%,(-,%4) 4%1(,1%4)

,4%,(-3%-) 4%.(,/%+) -%3(,/%2) /%0(+%3&3%-) +%+,

" ,3%,(-1%.) ,/%-(-+%-) ,+%0(,4%/)

-/%+(.-%2) ,-%,(-.%.) 2%-(-,%-) .%+(&,%-'2%-) +%,

" --%4(-0%/) ,3%0(-0%2) ,2%0(-0%2)

-3%1(./%0) ,/%2(-.%/) -.%1(-0%+) -%4(&,%2'2%0) +%-

" ,0%0(-.%,) .%2(,+%1) ,%2(2%1)

-+%4(.,%2) ,%4(2%4) /%,(,,%-) +%3(&-%4'.%4) +%1

" -2%/(.-%+) -,%-(-4%4) ,+%0(,4%/)

,3%1(..%0) 2%3(,1%0) ,0%-(,4%1) 0%,(+%3&4%/) +%+,

" -/%/(-4%1) -,%-(-0%.) -/%0(-/%/)

.,%+(..%1) --%0(-1%3) -.%1(-3%1) &,%+(&0%2&.%0) +%1

" 4%3(-1%-) 4%-(-+%/) 2%+(-,%+)

1%4(-,%-) ,%4(2%4) /%,(,,%-) -%2(&+%/&0%3) +%+3

" +%3.(+%,1) +%30(+%-+) +%4+(+%,/)

+%24(+%--) +%32(+%,3) +%34(+%,.) &+%,+(&+%+.4&+%+,3) +%/3

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(16)

For peer review only

26

$! 83*3,29*:- 89*3,27*3- 93*5,27*7-

78*5,28*5- 8:*1,25*7- 94*6,25*9- +2*21,+4*:+2*8- 1*55

/$"#!!!2911&+$#")**711 $"#!",3::%"*

"$!412-*

!&!"#!!!( "$!,#"##$"-)

"#"#(""&!!!*##889#!%","$##")

!%"##")"(-#"#&!!"#!)639#"$!

!$361#!$)!"#%(*##2297#+!##"

,!$!##")!(##")"$##"-&!!"#!) 789#!$%!"$"619#"$!!$,#6-*"#&+$

!##!&+$(&"03:3!$0462"$!!$

,;1*13-,$!5-*%!"#"#!##!35#"&+$&!

0:99:#"$!!$09344#!$,<1*112)#7-*

6*"$!$"!&+$!!*

"!!

"!!

"

:14 9:8 2911

! 29: 1*73 224 1*48 413 1*61

' 48 1*23 33 1*18 6: 1*1:

$" :7 1*42 44 1*22 23: 1*32

! 1 1 9 1*13 9 1*12

'!""# 54 1*25 23 1*15 66 1*1:

'#!#!%$#

!"#"

215 1*45 63 1*28 267 1*37

!%"""## 6: 1*2: 21 1*14 7: 1*22

# 8 1*13 2*8

,22-

9 1*13 3*1

,23-

26 1*13 2*9

,22*7-

# 639 2*86 361 1*94 889 2*3:

"#

0,-

267*:

,256*1.

87*8,271*2)

<1*112-

228*2

,268*8-

! 266 1*62 428 2*17 583 1*89

' 8 1*13 25 1*16 32 1*14

$" 28 1*17 46 1*23 63 1*19

!%"""## 1 1 26 1*16 26 1*13

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(17)

For peer review only

+0

+13 *%/3 -2+ +%,1 /0* *%3-

)&'

.%+

&1%3'

3%*&3%+$

5*%**+'

0%0

&2%3'

)&'

,%1

&1%1'

.%-&+/%*$

4*%+*'

-%/&++%3'

+/0 *%/, 3%0&+1%2' -,3 +%+* ,*%0

&+3%3'

.2/ *%2* +/%+

&+3%0'

0+ *%,* +%*

&-%3'

3. *%-+ +%1

&.%-'

+// *%,/ +%.

&.%+' #

,- *%*2 +%3&+,%,' -1 *%+, -%,

&+.%.'

0* *%+ ,%0

&+-%-'

,,1 *%1/ /,%-

&3-%2'

+2/ *%0+ .-%-

&+*.%+'

.+, *%02 .1%2

&33%*'

.+ *%+. +%./

&/%1'

-- *%++ +%,

&.%.'

1. *%+, +%-,

&/%+'

/*2 +%02 012 ,%,0 ++20 +%31

)&'

00%.

&+**%+'

1*%+&++,%,$

4*%01'

02%,

&+*0%+(

,*- *%01 -%-

&/%+'

-** +%* /%+

&0%2'

/*- *%2- .%,

&0%*'

"# +/* *%/* +,%,

&+,%,'

+,2 *%.- +*%0

&+,%+'

,12 *%.0 ++%.

&+,%,'

++* *%-1 /0%,

&1.%*'

33 *%-- /+

&1,%/'

,*3 *%-. /-%2

&1-%,'

# /* *%+1 .3%,

&++*%-'

0/ *%,, 0/%+

&+,,'

++/ *%+3 /1%+

&++0%1'

/+- +%1* /3, +%31 ++*/ +%2.

)&'

+,+%+

&+/,%2'

+-,%,&+00%1$

4*%-3'

+,0%0

&+/3%2'

!&'

+1 +, ,3

#!

&'

,+/

&+02'

+32&+3*$

4*%13'

,*2

&,+3'

)&'

,..*

&+3*0'

+22.&,*3,$

4*%./'

,*20

&,*+.'

,, ,0 .2

)&'

,0+%0

&+/1%1'

/1-%+&2-2%3$

4*%+.(

...%*

&00,%.'

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(18)

For peer review only

17

!!$!!" 8 6 14

#"#"""$!!" 4 3 7

"#

/-.

9037+2

-5117+5.

13316+0

-1489+0) ;0+22.

10871+0

-4366+3.

#!%"#!" ##!%")"#2+$"$#&#"#30 +$! !"##"#-"#!%#.!###"$" &&! &!

##"$!#!##+ *!&"#!#"#!!$ +&,$ (;3

#"+*#!"#%!$#!"$+$! !"##"#-"#!%#.

&!$ #"#"-)"#',!()" (.!###"$" &' !"!$"

%#+$! !"##"#-"#!%#.!###"$" &

!!#"#"""$!!(+

6+"#!&,$

"!

(''

('' ($$#

351 292 324+1 0+02

#"#! 95:+ 315,386 255,327 296,348

!/ 58

%& 3178 2651 2917 0+03

#"#! 95:+ 2833,3485 2228,3006 2660,3147

!/ 529

1098 914 1007 <0+001

#"#! 95:++ 1062,1139 877,954 981,1034

!/ 184

%& 9889 8233 9068 <0+001

#"#! 95:++ 9569,10194 7904,8619 8823,9320

!/ 1656

"###!"#"#)("&# #"##-;600++1800&,$

#".&!$(""-"#1.+"##!57&,$ ("&!

'$!(""- # !#!#$!!".+"#"%&"$"#!"

!#!"#+"#"!$"%#"#"#"""$!!"&!$"#!# !#

%#"+$*&,$ ++*#!%)"1000"#!##"#! " "+

"#!&#!#"# #%!"#"#"&"",%&

("#&,$ #"#""#" ##!%"+!""#!##

#!%"&,$ ##"! #%!"#&,

$ !!-$!5.+

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(19)

For peer review only

/6

26! #!$"!,-# ("#"!!! #!

$"%!23'!"!# #13'!" #,8.*24-*

""!%"(/2""! # 5""!,3.7-%

"!"!!!# '*""!! # %!0/'!"

#, 0+05.'!-1.'!"!# #, 1+23'!-*$

""!,"!#!'!!" -# "%+#

,/$!*!# 2-*

!""$#"""!!# '" " ""

"!" (%"&" $ " !

!$ "'*"!!"#'""!% % #""%' !(**" %"

!" # !! #!$"!(%%#"

!"!%+#*$!%""" ! %+#

%" ("" '%! $!" $""

% !#!!) #"("#"*!!"

!"" $#"""! !%+#

" # "$ !" *!" #'"

""! ' (" ! !%+# %!

!!"%"""!"!$!#" !!" ' !#""!

!!!"" $!* ""'(# !#"!%!""%+#%!"

!!"%" !""!!"#! # ,13

$ !#!23'!(8.*24-(" #'%!! " #!*

"#"!$%+#!!!"%" $!# $$(" !"

" "" $ !!%"!" !%+# ""!*

!" $ !! "%$ ""%+##!*

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(20)

For peer review only

08

3+6

&"("##!%&")!&+$#!"%$"*

1)2

$#

#%!##&+$!!"$#"!%&")#"#""#

!#"##"$##")#"#")"()!

%"##"%!#'"#$#"*

1

!!"#!"!

$!&(,) )-$#!"$#"!"#((!"&(*

8+00

&

$""$!%("%%$###!"&+$!!*&

"$!%("%!!# $#(!!(!"&+$!!)

""#+#%""(""#""#"&+$&"$"

1//3*

2/+21

$!%("%"""#&+$!&"##*

!#!"#%"$!%(203##"&!""""&#!!"#"#)

"$""!#$!#%"$!!(* #&"$###"#"$""$$!#%

"$!!(&".14178)##$!#!##"$!!"$

#*

22

!"$##"&+$!!"!('!*

"("#!#""#%#"#"&+$!!$&*$!!#

"$!%"#""!"$!#")#"!!""%!

#""!#"* !#"$!%()#""&###"#$!(

"!"$!#"&)"#(#$#%$*

23

""#"

!!#&"&+$!!)"""#%#"#

!("#%####" $#(*()#"#!'"#

"!%!&+$"#!#")#!#(##%*

24

""$#!"#&!#&+$"#!#"*

!#!!#"!"#+#%&("!"&+$"

'#"%("!%$#*!!"#!##")$!"#

!"&+$""#+#%

25)2627

&#!"#! $(

*

28

%!#"")# $#(!!(!!#""##*

3/+31

$!#!""%!"#!#"*!"#()#""#!"#!"#!!""#

#"##!$!!#!""!"

!&+$!!*%"&##!"&+$)%&#

!"! $(#!##")&"""#&#"#"%"

$#(*()!$""&#

!!"#!!&+$!!"*

32

&%!)#"#"$!#

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(21)

For peer review only

20

#""')"'", $##$%)+##% "$

$'# "$$$"&$$ $$$"#$'-

% "&##% "$$,$#$"%$#"$'-%

#%$$#$#$'"&,&$###% "$$$"%$$

'-% %".$6+582$#$#&#,#%"513$#$#/,")+

'&#'$$$"$$$##""%""#

"$'"% #, %" +$##$"!%$!%$)

"#'-% "",

"(#$$$#,"#$)+$$"%$$''"## "$$

"$)#$" $$#%"&&,'&"+$#$"'#

# "")$&%$'$"" "$'-% "#%$#$

$$# !%$)#$$&##,'$$$#

$$ $$#"&"!%)#"%#&$#$$

"##+#"%"""%""#'%&

%""'$"'-% $,")+#$#' $)"

'-% $,'&"+'$"#$'-% #)## "$) .$5+%"3/+#$# #"#$)'"$"% "$

$#%""% ,)+"*$)#$$"#"$)"##

%"#$#$+#$##$$)&")" $ ,

44

$$"%$$$###%$")$"'$$"*$), '&"+'$$$##$#, "'-% $"#&

""%$"#+++%#$"+$"#,

30+37+38+45

#

#%"&)#")$$%# $#"*, "')+$#

$"$$ "%$ )#$"""#%"%#

#")",")+)%" %$"#&$""#$

'"$ )#$""#$ "$###")$"

#"&, %"$"+%#"'$# $#"*$)

$"#"$)'" +&"$#%$##$#'"%$

##$&$))##.#%"4/,

44

)+$$"'##$ $"1774'-% $#%$#$$

$$"&$$#" $$'$'-%

"",##$$+#$' $$$" "$$""%"",

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(22)

For peer review only

-,

"!%" ! !$

!"/2$"

'

$""

!%

'"!%! "

(!"( %% $!

"!'%!

"( !$! '

!% !$'$

! "( %

#$!(

$"$'"!%"! $ "(

& "0% "(

"!'!$ $!

%$ !'

$ "#!) 0-!! ,+-

!* )0*' " % $ ' $!%"

!!$

',. %

",1$)* '

"%$%!

'

!% "( " $

" !' $

"( ! $%

"( '

!%"( $!

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(23)

For peer review only

44

"!" !"%!&'"! #'"!&/"%!&""*0(# ,!')

*,"%(!'(%!"!(&,"&#'!&/

#%&!'&'(,&(&'&''""!!%""*0(#!&,#%"% ,&.

*'!"!') #'"!$(',"!'""*%"&'/"*)%.'%+&' ''"!&/3581!9362#'!'&""!!%%(%%!.'&"*%(%%!%'

& "&',(&, '"!'% ""*0(#& "&'%(%%!&"(%*'!5 ,%&/(%'% "%.'&'" !'"!""!&(''"!&.%""'&'.""

& #&!""!"&"#,''"#' -&!%&(%))&&'(!!"*!/'%"%

%(''"&'%)! !'&"""!!%&(%)!&"(%', )('.*!&!!! # !'!""*0(##%"% &.&!%

&(%)!%#%&!'&(!!(%!"%&"',/!,.''&!"*!"(' '#"'!'% &"""*0(#.&#,*!'" &'"' #'"&#"&') '&'&/(%'%%&%&!'"&'''&"!'%")%&&.!!* '"&"

&"!0!,' "!!" !'"!*' %!'%" "!0"!

%!" &'%& (&'##/

67

!"!)!&!'%&%.!*%%&#"!&"%'

")% !&'%'"!!%'"!"'&'(,.'!,&&!!'%#%''"!"'/

!&!'&''&'!,&&/ '&''&'!,&&/

'"!" !,&&*'&&&'!%" .*""!'%(''"'&!.'

!,&&.!!'%#%''"!"'!!&/.!#*'#'!'

%%(' !'!%!" -'"!.!'""''%!!'%#%''!!&/

)&"!''%#%"'"".(!'"&'!% (%& !'#%'!#% %,%/

)&"!#%"'""*%'!!#%'%& #&-('"!&! !(&%#'

%)&"!/ *%"''%&'%'/('"%&%!##%")'! !(&%#'/

(&&'"''!'&'(,!!%&#"!&',"%'

&"!'"&( '"%#('"!/

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(24)

For peer review only

;<

""+*%(),%#&"**+$%(#)"%)+(%(#*

---6# 6%(7%:)"%)+(6&8,""%$('+)*(%#*%(()&%$$+*%(9

$"(5)*+/-)+$/()(($*(%#%(*($%(-$ "*

+*%(*)6+*%()"(***/,$%%$"*)%$*()*6

*$!($ $)$*%(-$$*(%($*(*($"#$%(

#$)*(*,)+&&%(*$%(#$*$$*()(*)6*$!&(%))%(

%(%$)$4&(*#$*%+" "*$$("(*4%(-$$,()*/

%$$$%"%/4%()))*$$&(%*%%"-(*$$)$%*("6

*$!&(%))%(()**$4&(*#$*%&#%"%/4%(-$$,()*/%

$$$%"%/%()))*$$&()*+/)#&")0"+"*%$)6*$!

%$%)444&(*#$*%#"/$$%##+$*/ "*4) )*($)(,$,()*/4%(,"+"%##$*)%$%+(()($#$+)(&*6

*$!((%"$*+$8+("&(*#$*4%2%$" %)&*"94(

$(**(*+$8+("&(*#$*4 ()* %)&*"94%(%##$*)%$*)*+/

&(%*%%"$$**%$%&%*$*"*("&(*&$*)6*$!($! +%

8+("+*&*$*"$4$,()*/ %)&*"%%(*%(-/9%()))*$$

($%#)*%$$$**%$%&%*$*"*("&(*&$*)6*$!(*($$

"!1)$4%(-$$,()*/%$$$%"%/4%()))*$-**- )($%#)*%$)(,6

%*%$"*,""6

%(()&%$$+*%()*(**%($*%$"%""+*%()$%)($*

%$"%""+*%()4-%("-"$*%*+")()$*)"$))$

&(&*+*/4$""%(#)4%(#*)$#8-*(!$%-$$%-%((*$*

+*+(94*%9&+")4(&(%+4)*(+*4)&"/$)*%(*%$*(+*%$49

*($)"**%$*(+*%$$*%%*("$+)4(*&**%$)4(&($*)4$"+

-*$%""*%$)$(*)+##()4.*(*)$7%(4)*(*)%*%$*(+*%$4

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 1

2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

(25)

For peer review only

@B

!!!=*,&1', **!.,!./'*#<+=+'&, '&,*!-,!'&5!.=,'0($'!,$$

+-+!!*1*! ,+!&, '&,*!-,!'&5.=, !&$-+!'&'$,*'&!$!&#+*'%, '&,*!-,!'&,', !*(*,1%,*!$/ *9.*!,%1$',6&5.!=$!&&1 , !*(*,1,''&1'*$$', '.8

? *+&5!,'*8&*!&'*/1@>>G8 !%$%@>??67?:?DG8

@ *18'$$'/9-(+,*,!+'*(,!&,+,*,'*&'&9%,+,,!'$'*,$

&*8!@>>E7?:A?8

A "&*5 &8'$$'/9(,*-*,!.+,!'&''$'*,$&*7 ,9&$1+!+8 !"@>>E6 7?EFA:GG8

B !-*'5-%$5*'-&5!('$$'/9-('(,!&,+/!, -*,!.$1

*+,'$'*,$&*7(*,!-!$!&8@>>A67@D8 C '$!$5!,'*8-!$!&+'*, &%&,''$'*,$&*8

!!%!!@>>E67?:??E8

D 3$'/5!,'*8,&!&+$!&!*'*!&'+,!#' &$!&#'$'*#,$&*

<&!+ -!$!&+=8 !"@>>G67?:?ED8

E '&&5!,'*8+"'&$, &$!&+(*'*%%*,&!&+$!&"*'*!&'+,!##5 &$!&''((2$!&.#*,!,1&&,*%'&,*%<'*/!&-!$!&+=8

$ !! !"@>?>7?:?D@8

F &+,*'%5!,'*8$!&!$*,!-!$!&+!&&'$'1'$'&&*

8@8@>>G8! #!$@>>G67?:E?8

G '$$'/9(,-1',!&,+ ' .&*'&-**1'*,5,5'*

,'$'*,$&*8$!&!$,*!$+8'.8@>>G7?:B8

?> *'++%&&5' &+'&5!*'5'&'5'++,!8'$$'/9-(''$'*,$

&*(,!&,+,**+,!'&/!, -*,!.!&,&,;, ,*!$8"

%@>>B67??G:@B8

?? !$$92*&+&5-**5**!)-!*15!(&!&,*!%&$1+!+'**-!,%&, ,', ,*!$8! @>>G67ECD:F8

?@ !$$92*&+&5$$18'$$'/9-(!&'$'*,$&*7)-+,!'&+,'

&+/*8! @>??67GCG:D>8

?A '& !%*5&* 5*-% 8%(*'.!&(*!%*1*'*(,!&,+/!, *'&!!$$&++8 ' "! !@>>@67

?EEC:G8

?B ,!'&$&*-*.!.'*&!,!,!.8!!!&

For peer review only - http://bmjopen.bmj.com/site/about/guidelines.xhtml 2

3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60

Referanser

RELATERTE DOKUMENTER

Det er desto mer bekymringsfullt som det i dette argumentet ligger en erkjennelse ikke bare av de betydelige problemene med kvalitetskontroll og peer review i det

Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the 8th International Conference

This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published

Peer Reviews finden in alle drei Arbeitsformen dieser Aktionsforschung statt: das Peer Review im Plenum (siehe 2.1.3), das digitale Peer Review im Diskussionsforum (siehe

Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the CENTERIS - International Conference on ENTERprise Information Systems / ProjMAN -

Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the CENTERIS - International Conference on ENTERprise Information Systems / ProjMAN -

This is a post-peer-review, pre-copyedit version of an article published in Review of

No systematic reviews have studied the effects of this training in grant peer review (Guthrie 2017; Sattler 2015), and the most recent review of studies