Procedia Engineering 197 ( 2017 ) 3 – 12
1877-7058 © 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Conference on Dynamic Fracture of Ductile Materials doi: 10.1016/j.proeng.2017.08.076
ScienceDirect
+.-#! /
!" - +& ,$ ( +$ -
0 ( % " & $ ($
% $$
1#$
2%232 4 1
2 , *
22 - '"
2 - '"
2%2 ! 567
2%!"#$
%&'(!"
)*!!* )**#$%&'(!"
) +, ")+,)!!-! .
/01%&' $1(21% .*
!" $& $ 8 $ " % ( $ 09:';0< ; $ ($ " $$ $%= % !" $ "7 $% (&
8 $$ 8 !" " 8 ( / / 8 ( $ ($ " $ " % $ $ &"> "
"" $ $ " & $ "
!" 8 $ $ % ( ( , $ ; ,$ $
" , $ $ # " ( % " 7
% " 8 !" " ( %& " " $
$( !" $ $ " " 8 2 % %" "
% ( " 7 " " " $& !" $ $ "
($ ( ,<) (( " & ( " ) ($ " ,<) & (& " % " 2 $ $ (
!" #$" $%" %& '
$ %& ( ?@#- :, !A :94#@)B#!):@C
3 * $" !D EF/GFH (8D EF/GF
$!! 3 $I$
9
© 2017 The Authors. Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
Peer-review under responsibility of the scientific committee of the International Conference on Dynamic Fracture of Ductile Materials
7! 3 5 H J & "&H % &H H ($$$ H 09:';0<
# $ "K$ ( K$ ( $(( " " $$
% A2 %( $" " % $ $ " ( ( %$2 %& (( %" " " & 8 ( ( " $ "& " %2 8 $ % $ $ $ $ " ?C?C L" $ 2
" & 2 "" 2 $ ( ($
$$ (K$& $ % " $$ && "
" & % " $$2 " ( " && " "7 (& " " " <$" $$ ( K$ ( " > > ( 7 " !" $ " $ ( " ( , " "" 7 "
($ " $ " > !" " > "(
($ %" " > ( " 7 2 & $ $((& (
" " & ( " 7 # ( " ( "$ $" ( " A2 " *0 & % ( " $(& ( " "2
% $ " % ( " ( #-9 $ ($ % 9 " , 09:';0< ; ?/C ( #-9 % $(
"" 2 "" 7 " #-9 " $ " #-9 &
% ( " ($$$ ,<) $2 %$
( " ( " ($ " " $$ % $ $ ( "
($$$ (
!" $ " ( ( % #-9 ($ ( & " "
$$ 8 % # ( "7 $% 8 "( ( %" % ( " $ $ !" "7 $% "K$ ($% % $
""8 $ % % %& ?FC2 " 8& ( $ (2 " ("2 (% " " A > $ & ( $ 2 " $
&"> " "" $ $ " & $ "
/++)* <&"> ( " $ $ " " &
% "$" ( " & ($ ( ,<) ((
!" $ $ ( " % ( " 8 , ; ?/C !"
%= ( " $& 7 " % ( % #-9 $ ($ % " ($ ( ,<) (( " ( " $$ % - ( " %"$
(& " &% ($
1/(/
!" "7 $$ $($ ( "2 " "
( " & @ #L AF $ %& A )$ ' !" GG M $ $$ $%=
%( % 7 " %& !" & $ "
%& " $($ % - N -2 &
! % ( " % ( " K$
%"$ ( " 2 " " & 7 ( " $ ?C?C !"
( B79 B/ " ( ( !"
,$ @ $ ( $8 $ ( ; ,# " " ( !% H % K$ $ $ 7 ( " 2 " 8 1 " $ % " ( " !%
,$ 8 $ ( " <)-'% <"7 !$% ,& <<!,D <7" ( 8 $ ( %2 $ ( % +)* 7 ( " " $$ 5" " % " $$
( "
( F ( $ " ( !" ( "
(( 2 F 2 G " " ( " !
$ $ " ( !" $ &"> " " (
$ %& " "&$ " ( F A>
!" $ $ ,$ 2 " ,$ % " K$
$ " $ 7 ( " ) % " "
"& %" ( ($
1/1/"89
!" % ( " <)-'% <"7 !$% ,& <<!, @!@0 # (
" $ ( ( % ($ 9( ?FC !" 8 "K$ (
& % 8 " % 2 ( ( $% "" ""$ "% ,$ ( $ "%
,$ $ $ " # $ ( " " "7 " " " $ "%2 " ( 8 " ""$ "% 0 & % " " ( " $ "%2 "
8 $ (( ( "7 $% " & " " ( ( " $ "
" "7 $ $ ( " ( 8 !" (
% $$ & " % $ %& " ( " $% # (% %= " % " $& ( ,<) (( $ " & 2 " " $ (( %& " $$
) " 72 " " ( " N 2 &2 %" "
( G !" % & %& " " $ " 2 "
" $ " % !% " 8 $ "2 " "
$% ;. "" ; 9 $$ # . " (
$ % " !" $ % % ( ,$ %2 " "
" $$ $ $ %$& ,$ $ $ (
" $ % ,<) (( " " $$
5" " " "7 ( " $$ "
N
N " ( ( " $% " (8 %$&
,$ % !" " 8 ( / / K$ " (
" $%
!% 8
! $ ?7C #% $ ?7C #% $ ?)C
9 NN /
9 NNF GG N
9 /
# NNG G /
# G /
# G G
> $ O N/5 $ $ " $ /F < F
< $ " ,$ !" $ ($" $ " $% 2
$& " " "7 < " (K$& ( 7A> -2 " K$ " $ " 2 ">
$ " $ %$ %$&
! %" % ( ( " $$ " $ $2 " $$
& " 7 ,$ " /++)*
& $ $ " ( !" " ( 7 %
> " (( ( " +)* $ ?FC " $ ( " ""
" N $ ,$ !" /++)* ( $ "$ +)*
* " &$ ( ( " 7 ( " ( $ ($ " " $( ( ($ !" $ $ &">
" " "" ( F 7A>
!" $ $ " & 9( ?FC2 " " &
( ( " ( " $$ % "
$ $ < /
:/(/!
!" $ " .5+) ; ?/C2 "" ( ( 2 "" 2 $ ($ $ ( !" & %& " -
& 2 " ( $ ( J"*7 ( " ( !" $ "
( & & ($ " %"$ ?C
3
2 /
2 2 2 P D P
8
! ;
< )
" ; " K$ - 2 " ( 2 " K$ 2 "
K$ 2 $( ( 2 " & 2 2< ) 2 2 P " ( " *$"& !" "$
$ ( 3 2 " " %$ $2 " %
$ " $ ( " < " $$ ( % "
& " $ 2 " $ $ $ % $
% " ?C !"$2 K ( & " !2 " !
%"$
+$ ($ $ " %& $ " *7('" *' ($ ?C
"" &% $ " Q 7R $ $ ($ " !"
" $& $$ ( " $ "
8
2 8 2
= !
= =
" = " ($ ($ %& " = $8
" K$ " $ " ($ ,$ $ " " "
$
!" ($ ( 8& " $ 9( ?C !" 2 " K$
2< )2 % %& $ , ( "
< 2 " " "& 7 ( 9( ?C ,$
" $ ( " " , $ ; " " >
2 " ,$ % " K$ $ $ 7 ( "
" ( " 8 ( " ( K !" >
!% ) % " " ( % % " K$
( " & ( " "
!% - "& ( " @ #L AF $$ &
?-C
<
?-C )
?C
<
?-C )
?C ?C
?C
?C
=
?-C
?OC
?OC / G F F F N G/ G/
!" *' = K % " , $ %& " 8 " Q 7R = ) "> " " = ($ ( " " ">
!" $ " ( " " ( & " 7 " " >
($ " ( " 7 :& " " ( " $ "
(2 "$" " ( "" " ($ " " F G ,$ !" =% 2 "" 8
& (( " $ $ A2 ( & %& " ( " $& !"
$ 8 =( " , $ %& ,$ 2 " $ !%
!" = " ( ($ $ " $ :/1/!"
,$ / $ " $ " $$ "2 " " && ( " %
$> %& & K$ ( " %& $ & %$& ,$ / ,$ /% $ " ($ ( " 8 $ % %& " K$
&& !" ($ ( " %& & $ ( $> $ # " &
$& " " " > ( " K$ " % ( % "
8 A2 " $ ' > " > ( 8& N " % " F 9- " <&> " N ( "$" " "7 !" ( % " " ( " ( #-9 9( ?NC
!" %"$ ( " %& " .5+) " "& (
!% ,$ $ " " "
" " $ ( $& ( " K )
" 7 % " 82 $ #-9 %& " !" 2
" " ( $ $( ( " $ ( (
!" " " ( %& " ($ $ " "K$ ( 9( ?C !"
" ( & " ?NC ( " K$ " $ " $& ) ">
" ( " " > ( 2 " " "$ % $((& ( &
%( " ?NC !" $ " " > " = 2 "
" " > " , "2 ( ( "
!" $& $ $ " $ ( " " ( 2 $
$ > ( "
!" % ( %& %7 )-? "
" .5+) " "" $ %"$ $ " "& ( 9( ?C
" % K$ @ " 2 $ $ %
" ( " !" $ ( %& " ( % &
( 2 " 8 $ " % " % " $ ( ,$ / !" $ $ " " $ 9( ?C2
$ $ ( FF - "$"$ " $
!" % " 2 ( " % $ "" % %
,$ / @$ " $$ "D " K$ % " %& ( "
&& !" ( " % &2 " $ "
" " $ " 8 2 " $ ( &
$ " & % " ( " %
& " !" (( % ( ( " % (2 2 "
( " " %2 " " $ ( !" "7 ( " $ (
%& & ( F 2 "( ( " "7 % " " ( " $( !" ( (( % " ( "
%" & ((2 & $ ( " $ ( $$
( ,$" ( " " % ($ 9( ?NC
!" $ " $ " ( " < " % " " " $$ !" 2 " $ " 9.
$ % ( #. !" $$ " 7 " " $ " " $
$ %& " (2 "" ( ( " %"$ !" ( , K$ && $ " $ "& " " " " ( % 7 ?C?FC2 2
28
8 2
!
! !
/
" 28 " 7 ( $2 " % $2 " ( ( " % " 2 E " $ ( " " " 8 & (( !"
( $ E " & $ %&
28
8
!
!
!
F
!" % 282 ! & " % $ & ( " 8 & ((
K F !" % " , $ % 8 %& K / !" $ $ ( " 9. "( > %& $( " , K$ $ K /F $(& %$ $ " 8 ( " $$ !"
9( ?FC2 %$ !% / ( " ( " $&
!% / , $( " $ $ "
! 28
?7C
E
?C E
?7 C
?C 9 NN/ G /N G 9 GN/ /N NN
9 N / /
,&2 " ($ ( " %$& %& " & "
%& " ( !" ( & " 8 ( "
,$ / " " " ($& (8
!" $ $ ( ( " 8 ,$ F @ ( " # $ &"> " " "" !"
" ,$ F "( # # # 8 ( " ( " " % 2 "
% ( % ) 2 " ( %" " %& " ( " $ " $$ " # 82 " ( " ( "& " " " %& ) "> " "$" " ( " 8 ( " $$
" ,$ F2 " & % " " %& !"
$ " ( " " " $$ " ,<) (( "(
+ &"> % " $ " # 2 " 8 $ ($ " %$& " "( K$ % ( ( "
& ($ " $ ( # ,$ ) % " " $ 8& " ($ " 8 !" 8 % " 7 " " ,$ %( " 7 " $ ">
,$ % " $& %$ " ( !" " " $
" 2 82 % & ($ " 7 " ( " ( "
%$& " ( " ,$ % # % 8 ( " "
" & ( " 2 " ,$ A2 " $ ( " # " "
,$ * ( 7 " # $$ $ !" ( ($ " "
"$ " " 2 " 8 ( , " K ,$ F - ( " $ $ ( " % $$ D # % # !"
$$ $ " " ($ ( ,<) (( $ " & 2 " "
( $ " (( ( " %$&
& ($ % " #-9 % ( ($
"
!" ($ ( % #-9 $ ($ " %& "
#-9 $ " " $ ( $ $ $( " > ( N "
) ($ ( (( ( #-9 %" ( " 7 ( " *0
# $( " ( N & ($ " # (($ " >
($ 2 " $( " ( " ($ " " #-9 %$
( *0 8& " " #-9
:/:/)!"
! " ($ ( ,<) (( " ( " $$ 2 %" ($&
$ ,<) ( " 8 $ ,$ !" $$ " " % ( ( " $ $ (& ,<) (( $ " &
!" $ $ " " " " % & % " ( " $% 9( ?FC !" ($ $% " ($& $ $
"( + $ N $ " !" 2 " ($ $% & "
%& + ( $ .0 & %& /+ ( $ ).0 !" $ ,$ N "
$ " > ( " + " & ( " 2 " " >
" 7 $ " !" $ .0 2 ).0
" ($ $% !" ( 2 $ & " 8 (7 !" 7 " $ ($ " $ " (8 " " ($
" L" , > && $ ( $$
< /2 " $% > " $ ($ & % ( $ ,1 ($ ,1 " & ( 8 " "" " K$ (
" $ ($ ( !" " "
($ $ " " ($8 $ " " = $ !"$2 "
,1 " K$ " ( " $ " , " "" ($% &
$$ $ $" % 9( ?C !" ($& $ $ "( $ " ,
> < / ( " $$ (2 ,1 " ($ $%
!"2 " $ ($8 % = ,1 $ $ " 8 A'8 '* A''* 9 ?/C2 " %& " " ( " 8 $
,$ N *$ ( " ($& $ ,<) $ !" ,$ / % " ($ $% &
2 " ( " + ( $ " "
$ %& $ *$,"'& (( ( F # % ,<) "K$ 0= ?/C?GC
$ ( " $ " ($$$ ,< ( ,<) #-9 " ($ $%
% $((& ( ($ " " ,< ( !" $ " K$ ( ( " >*@5 ?/C " ( " $ 7 ( "
$$ !% , " 8" " ( " $% $ (
%& (& " $" F " 5*,# ; ?/C
!" ( ( " ($& $ $ " $$ "
8 ,$ F (& ,<) (( ) % " " (
$ %& 8& M " ,<)2 " " ($& $ $ " "
%& ( " ,$ F $ 8 " " 8
% !" " ($& $ $ & % K$&
" " 8 ( " & * " *0 ( " $$
$ " ,$ F2 " *0 " ($& $ $ %
" ( G M ) "$ % " " ($ ,$ % " $
$ ( " #
!" ($& $ $ 8 " " 8 2 " " $$
" " & %& 8& M !" $ " ( $ ( $ ( ,<) (( " " & ( % (8%
!" $ $ " " & ($ $ % %&
& &% !" $ ( % #-9 (
$ ($ % "$ $" ( % *0 !" & % % ( $$ " && " " &
% " $$2 2 ( " && " "7 (& " " "
<$" $$ ( K$ ( " > > ( 7 " A2 ($" % $ $ $ ( % #-9 !" ( ( ($$ 7
!" 7 " % $ " ( $ ( <,)<)-'% <,)*#<# " @ 0& ( < !"& @!@0
!
?C 1 #$2 ,"2 O : A$2 - '"2 ! 5672 8 $& " ( " $$ $%=
% 2 ) J$ ( ) G N N
?C 1 #$2 4 12 , *2 - '"2 - '"2 ! 5672 @$ $& " $$ ( % "
$$ 2 ) J$ ( ) GG /FF
?/C 09:';0< $S $2 J 9" *2 "D$8$=$$ ? //C
?FC 1 #$2 ,"2 - '"2 ! 5672 # "7 $% (& % $$2 ) J$ ( <$$ N /F/NN
?C - 4 *7(2 + J '"2 +$& " 7%& ( 2 J$ ( " )$ ( -2 GN GN ///G
?NC 1 #$2 4 12 , *2 - '"2 ! 5672 : " & ( % " "$ (
"2 ) J$ ( ) +:)D N==F #
?C , *2 +>2 , 1$2 # " ( " ( $( ( &2 ) J$ (
*$ -" / /
?C - '"2 , *2 8 8 ( "2 ) J$ (
<$$ NGGN
?GC , *2 - '"2 @ '2 < 7 ( ( ($& ( ,<) " ( & ( % ( $$2 ( " *:-+.@ *(2 *($2 42 -& 2