• No results found

Adaptation to Climate Change: Understanding the Contingent Nature of Spatial Vulnerability Assessments

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Adaptation to Climate Change: Understanding the Contingent Nature of Spatial Vulnerability Assessments"

Copied!
80
0
0

Laster.... (Se fulltekst nå)

Fulltekst

(1)

9>HH:GI6I>DCHJ7B>II:9;DGI=:9:<G::D;

D8IDGD;*=>ADHDE=N*= >C"JB6C!:D<G6E=N;GDBI=:

:E6GIB:CID;-D8>DAD<N6C9"JB6C!:D<G6E=N 68JAIND;-D8>6A-8>:C8:/C>K:GH>IND;)HAD

EG>A

(2)

© Lynn D. Rosentrater, 2016

Series of dissertations submitted to the

Faculty of Social Sciences, University of Oslo No. 602

ISSN 1564-3991

All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be

reproduced or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without permission.

Cover: Hanne Baadsgaard Utigard.

Print production: Reprosentralen, University of Oslo.

(3)

#

,-6:35/:%61%()4366-&0)&<7,)453.)'737)27-%063*%2(-1-7673 (%47%7-32-235:%<*82()(&<7,))6)%5',382'-03*35:%<%1

4%57-'80%50<+5%7)*8073%5)2F5-)2*35-29-7-2+1)734%57-'-4%7)-268',%(-67-2+8-6,)(

)26)1&0)%6:)00%6*35,)5%&82(%27)2'385%+)1)27-26-+,7%2(4%7-)2')7,538+,3877,-6 453')66

)9)5%04)340)5%00-)(%77,)0%671-287)73,)04675)2+7,)27,-6(-66)57%7-32:-7,7,)

%((-7-323*5)6)%5',-27,)5)%013*64%7-%040%22-2+<6-2')5)677,%2/6*357,)-5

-29%08%&0)-2487+3735-%2((<.)567-5%28122)-6)#%(30-0-6%&)7,C5)2 59)6)2>6,-0(%8+))'-0-)0<)2%2(%7,%0-)%&32237)

85-2+1<453+5%13*678(<&)2)*-7)(+5)%70<*5317,));4)5-)2')3*7:3*35)-+2 5)6-()2'-)67,)*-567-2%77,)!2-7)(7%7)6F%7-32%0)27)5*3571364,)5-'

)6)%5',%2(7,)6)'32(-2 %77,)-22-6,29-5321)27267-787)$

:380(0-/)737,%2/0+%#-0,)01-%7%2(-/%)0-0(@2%7$*357,)-5 +)2)5386,364-7%0-7< -137,<%57)5*35-2'35435%7-2+1)63)**3570)660<-273$F6 (%-0<5387-2)6%2(%5-%301&)5+7)*%2532=)/%22%)0%%2(-2%"-57%2)2*35 4539-(-2+%2%1-%&0):35/)29-5321)27

,538+,9%5-38632+3-2+%2(64327%2)386'329)56%7-3266)9)5%0'300)%+8)6,%9) 82:-77-2+0<6,%4)(1<7,38+,76327,)45%'7-')3*%2(1)7,3(6-2+)2)5%0237%&0<

"-5+-2-%2732-.)9-'%5%,%7,-6)2%85-'-3A2)5%%2((%/-9)2)6 ,)1-(9-7F)56

%7E)64)'-%00<0-2)0&3)%2(-567)2!0658(E:)5)%2-29%08%&0)6385')3*

'%1%5%()5-)+8-(%2')%2(68443577,)56:,3,%9)738',)(7,-6:35/&37,(-5)'70<%2(

-2(-5)'70<-2'08())0)2)182(6)2-5-5-/6)2 35?/322()5&)5+)5-7

5-673**)56)2-5--77)72+)5-6)%+0-)%5-%22)%2(%2(-2(%<+2%%2<7,%2/6 73<38%00

-2%00<:380(0-/)737,%2/1<4366)3*',))50)%()56*357,)-5&382(0)666844357 2%%55%6'3)()5.)5(581%5-2%,0675D1%26)2%5-2%27)5)2%)9-2

%2-'))0-%2%5)2361%27)9))44)5<09-%',:%& )55<%2(8=< %<035%2(

1<&-++)67&3367)53*%0009-236)275%7)5<1367453*382(7,%2/6+373%56%26)2

<2236)275%7)5 80<

(4)

(5)

)(.(.-

(897')9;//

'5+78/39./8/88+79'9/43/=

3974*:)9/43

-IJ9N6>B6C9G:H:6G8=FJ:HI>DCH

68@<GDJC96C98DCI:MI

,:H:6G8=H8DE:

:3*'2+39'143)+598

A>B6I:KJAC:G67>A>IN

96EI6I>DCID8A>B6I:8=6C<:

-E6I>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH

+J6A>I6I>K:!#-

"+8+'7).+8/-3

':I6I=:DG:I>86A DJC96I>DCH

.G6CH9>H8>EA>C6G>IN6C9'>M:9':I=D9DAD<N

':I=D9H6C96I6

$.+ '5+78 .=:EDI:CI>6AHD;6C9A>B>IHID8A>B6I:H8:C6G>DH

':CI6ABD9:AHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:

&:HHDCHA:6GC:9;GDBB6EE>C<KJAC:G67>A>IN>CI=:(DG9>8G:<>DC

0JAC:G67>A>IN>CHE6I>6AEA6CC>C<

,:I=>C@>C<KJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH

/8):88/43 43)1:8/43 /(1/4-7'5.>

55+3*/)+8 '5+78A&

(6)

(7)

-.,.

A>B6I:8=6C<:6;;:8IHE:DEA:6C9EA68:H9>;;:G:CI>6AAN6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN>HI=:EG>B6GN B:6CH7NL=>8=IDJC9:GHI6C9=DL8A>B6I:>CI:G68IHL>I=AD86A8DCI:MIHHH:HH>C<

KJAC:G67>A>IN8=6G68I:G>O:H8A>B6I:G:A6I:9>BE68IH6C9I=:B:8=6C>HBHI=6I;68>A>I6I:8DE>C<

G:HEDCH:H.=:E6E:GH>CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DCH=DLI=6I9>;;:G:CI;DGBHD;@CDLA:9<:6C9

@CDLA:9<:H::@>C<6;;:8I=DLKJAC:G67>A>IN>HJC9:GHIDD96C9I=JHB6C6<:9I=GDJ<=

696EI6I>DCG6L>C<DC<:D<G6E=>8G:H:6G8=IG69>I>DCH6HHD8>6I:9L>I=:CK>GDCB:CI6A

<:D<G6E=N7:=6K>DG6A<:D<G6E=NKJAC:G67>A>INH8>:C8:6C9<:D<G6E=>8>C;DGB6I>DCH8>:C8:

#8G>I>86AAN:M6B>C:>C;DGB6I>DC6HHD8>6I:9L>I=KJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH6C99:BDCHIG6I:

I=6II=:8DC8:EID;KJAC:G67>A>INCDIDCAN:C8DBE6HH:HI=:C:<6I>K:B6I:G>6ADJI8DB:H 6HHD8>6I:9L>I=8A>B6I:8=6C<:7JI6AHD=DLI=DH:DJI8DB:H6G:9>;;:G:CI>6AANE:G8:>K:9 6C9K6AJ:97HIG68IH8:C6G>D76H:9>C;DGB6I>DC6ADC:9D:HCDIBDI>K6I:696EI>K:68I>DC 7:86JH:9>K:GH:EGD7A:BJC9:GHI6C9>C<HA:69ID9>;;:G:CIEG>DG>I>:H67DJI=DLIDG:HEDC9 ID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>C8AJ9>C<7>6H:HIDL6G98DBEA68:C8N6C9>C68I>DC":JG>HI>8

:C<6<:B:CIH7:IL::C696EI6I>DC68IDGHI=6I8DCH>9:GI=:L6NH>CL=>8=E:DEA::ME:G>:C8:

6C9G:HEDC9ID8=6C<:>CEG68I>8:A:69ID9::E:GJC9:GHI6C9>C<HD;KJAC:G67>A>INI=6IG:K:6A BJAI>EA::CIGNED>CIH;DG696EI6I>DC;G6B:LDG@IDHJEEDGI6C6ANI>89:A>7:G6I>K:9:8>H>DC B6@>C<>CI=:8DCI:HI:9HE68:7:IL::C:E=:B:G6A6C9B:6HJG:67A:@CDLA:9<:L=:G:

H:K:G6A>CI:GEG:I6I>DCHD;KJAC:G67>A>IN86C7:K6A>96II=:H6B:I>B:>HEG:H:CI:9.=:

A:HHDCHA:6GC:9=:G:6G:G:A:K6CI:K:C6HI=:#*H=>;IH>IH;D8JH;GDBKJAC:G67>A>INIDG>H@

(8)

(9)

**,-#(."#-#--,..#)(

# ,DH:CIG6I:G& ,:EG:H:CI>C<6C9JH>C<H8:C6G>DH;DGG:HEDC9>C<ID 8A>B6I:8=6C<:)25.A7<.:-2;,29527*:A$.>2.?;526*<.1*70.

## ,DH:CIG6I:G&#-[A:CHB>C9: @HIGTB!T=BDHIGDB"6CHH

,)cDCCDG ;;>868N.G69:);;H>C#C9>K>9J6AHc-JEEDGI;DGA>B6I:

=6C<:*DA>8>:H7>2:876.7<*7-.1*>28:

### ,DH:CIG6I:G&HJ7B>II:9 HH:HH>C<KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:1=6I6C9 L=D >HB>HH>C<$.0287*57>2:876.7<*51*70.

#0 ,DH:CIG6I:G&6C9%)cG>:CHJ7B>II:9 1=6IcHI=:EGD7A:B.=:8DCI>C<:CI C6IJG:D;KJAC:G67>A>IN>CHE6I>6AEA6CC>C<;DG8A>B6I:8=6C<:696EI6I>DC>C(DGL6N 7>2:876.7<*7-"5*77270

0 ,DH:CIG6I:G& #CI:<G6A!#-1>9:C>C<I=: G6B:D;,:;:G:C8:;DG 96EI6I>DC*A6CC>C<#C%)cG>:C6C9-:A7D::9H &1.-*9<2>.1*55.70.8/

526*<.1*70. 6B7G>9<:6B7G>9<:/C>K:GH>IN*G:HH

)I=:GEJ7A>86I>DCH8D6JI=DG:97NI=:86C9>96I:6HE6GID;=:G8DJGH:D;HIJ9N>C8AJ9:

DHIGDB,)cDCCDG!T=B"6CHH)D9> @HIGTB*"6A9:G-

$:H8=@:'68@'+J&,DH:CIG6I:G-6C9K:#-[A:CHB>C9:

6JH6AI=>C@>C<6C9HJEEDGI;DG8A>B6I:8=6C<:EDA>8>:H#CI:GC6I>DC6AHJGK:N

;>C9>C<H58+*57>2:876.7<*51*70.=6*7*7-"852,A26.7;287;

6GI:G.- GDCO:@#C@>C:C#&6=I>C:C"':A6%)cG>:C&,DH:CIG6I:G, ,JJ=:A6&->BDCHHDC.:GQBQ =6G68I:G>H>C<KJAC:G67>A>IND;I=:

:A9:GANID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>CI=:(DG9>8G:<>DC$.0287*57>2:876.7<*51*70.

*,)0# *,)0#!J>96C8:DCHH:HH>C<0JAC:G67>A>IN#BE68IH6C996EI6I>DC IDA>B6I:=6C<:(6>GD7>%:CN6/C>I:9(6I>DCHCK>GDCB:CI*GD<G6BB:

EE

(10)
(11)

#(.,)/.#)(

A>B6I:8=6C<:>H6<AD76AEGD7A:BL>I=H><C>;>86CI>BE68IHDCAD86A8DBBJC>I>:H

>I>:H6C9IDLCH6GDJC9I=:LDGA9>C8G:6H>C<AN:ME:G>:C8::MIG:B:L:6I=:G:K:CIHI=6I 86JH:L>9:HEG:6996B6<:6C9H:G>DJH9>HGJEI>DCIDI=:CDGB6A;JC8I>DC>C<D;96>ANA>;:

-:K:G:HIDGBH96B6<:>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:6C9>BE6>G8G>I>86AHNHI:BH;DGIG6CHEDGI6I>DC

8DBBJC>86I>DC6C9:C:G<N9GNL:6I=:GG:9J8:HAD86AL6I:GHJEEA>:H6C9>C8G:6H:H;>G:G>H@

6C9E:G>D9HD;EGDADC<:9=:6I8G:6I:EJ7A>8=:6AI=G>H@H:HE:8>6AAN;DG:A9:GANNDJC<6C9 9>H69K6CI6<:98>I>O:CH-8>:CI>;>8:K>9:C8:HJ<<:HIHI=6I8A>B6I:8=6C<:>H>C;AJ:C8>C<6C9 L>AA:M68:G76I:I=:;G:FJ:C8N6C9>CI:CH>IND;:MIG:B::K:CIHA:69>C<ID6<:C:G6A>C8G:6H:

>CKJAC:G67>A>IN6C9EDI:CI>6AADHH:H#* *G:E6G>C<;DGI=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;

8A>B6I:8=6C<:I=GDJ<=EA6CC:9696EI6I>DC>HI=:G:;DG:6C>BE:G6I>K:;DGAD86A

<DK:GCB:CIH

96EI6I>DCI6@:HEA68:>CG:HEDCH:IDD7H:GK:9DG:ME:8I:98=6C<:H>C8A>B6I:6C9 8A>B6I:K6G>67>A>IN_L=>8=>C8AJ9:HI=:;G:FJ:C8N6C9>CI:CH>IND;:MIG:B::K:CIH_

I=GDJ<=68I>DCHI=6IG:9J8:KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:G:A6I:9>BE68IH-B>I:I6A '6CN 696EI6I>DCEGD8:HH:HJH:<:D<G6E=>8>C;DGB6I>DCHNHI:BH!#- ID<GDJC9I=:>G6C6ANH:H>C HE6I>6AANCJ6C8:9:K6AJ6I>DCHD;G>H@*G:HIDC:I6A7 !#-8DCH>HIHD;6H:ID;

EG68I>8:HI=6IDE:G6I:68GDHHK6G>DJHH86A:H>:<:D<G6E=>8I:BEDG6A6C9<DK:GC6C8: ID 699G:HHHE6I>6AEGD7A:BH-8=JJGB6C 6C9>HL>9:ANJH:97NAD86A<DK:GCB:CIH;DG EA6CC>C<6C9B6C6<:B:CI7:86JH:>IEGDK>9:H6;DGB6A;G6B:LDG@;DGLDG@>C<L>I=

HI6@:=DA9:GHID;68>A>I6I:>C8AJH>K:9:8>H>DCB6@>C<G6><:I6A'86AA6C9JCC 9>K:GH:6HH:B7AND;>CI:G:HI:9E6GI>:H:68=L>I=I=:>GDLCK6AJ:H6C96<:C96H E6GI>8>E6I:H>C696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<7N9:A>7:G6I>C<DK:GI=:=6GB;JADGJCL6CI:9 8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:.=:H:9>H8JHH>DCH6G:>C;DGB:97NKJAC:G67>A>IN

6HH:HHB:CIHI=6I9:H8G>7:=DL8A>B6I:>HEGD?:8I:9ID8=6C<:6C9=DLI=DH:8=6C<:HB6N 6;;:8IE:DEA:6C9EA68:H

(12)

0JAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH6G:@:NIDJC9:GHI6C9>C<I=:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:

DCHD8>6A6C9C6IJG6AHNHI:BH.=:EG:B>H:D;6HH:HH>C<KJAC:G67>A>IN>HIDJC9:GHI6C9I=:

EDI:CI>6A=6GBI=6IB6NG:HJAI;GDBI=::;;:8IHD;8A>B6I:K6G>67>A>IN6C98=6C<:9<:G

#* 0JAC:G67>A>IN>H6G:A6I>K:8DC9>I>DC9:I:GB>C:97NI=:7>DE=NH>86A6C9 HD8>6AEGD8:HH:HI=6I9:H8G>7:AD86A8>G8JBHI6C8:HL=>8=B6@:H>IE6GI>8JA6GANL:AAHJ>I:9ID HE6I>6AG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH*G:HIDC:I6A7 0JAC:G67>A>INB6EH6G:688:HH>7A:6C9

EDL:G;JA9:K>8:HI=6I8DBBJC>86I:8A>B6I:G:A6I:9G>H@H;DGHDB:<:D<G6E=>8:MI:CI>:6 G:<>DC8>INDGC:><=7DG=DD9':I=D9H;DGB6EE>C<KJAC:G67>A>IN6G:9DB>C6I:97N

>C9>86IDG76H:96EEGD68=:HI=6IH:GK:EDA>8NB6@:GHcC::9H;DGH>BEA:<:C:G6A>O:96C9 68I>DC67A:>C;DGB6I>DC VHH:A "DL:K:GKJAC:G67>A>IN>H6HJ7?:8I>K:8DC8:EII=6I

=6H6HBJ8=ID9DL>I==DLE:DEA:E:G8:>K:I=:BH:AK:H>CG:A6I>DCID8A>B6I:8=6C<:6H>I 9D:HIDI=:EDI:CI>6A;DG=6GB)G>:C6C91DA; :HE>I:I=::M>HI:C8:D;

CJB:GDJHB:I=D9DAD<>86A<J>9:A>C:HHE6I>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH6G:HI>AAA6G<:AN 8=6G68I:G>O:97N:ME:G>B:CI6I>DC*G:HIDC:I6A7 'DHI;G6B:LDG@H6G:76H:9DC D7?:8I>K:>::MI:GC6AANB:6HJG:67A: K6G>67A:HI=6IFJ6CI>;NB6I:G>6ADJI8DB:HL>I=DJI I6@>C<>CID688DJCII=:CDCB6I:G>6A8DC8:GCH:<>9:CI>IN7:A>:;H6C9K6AJ:H I=6I6G:

>BEDGI6CIIDHI6@:=DA9:GH.JGC:G:I6A I=:67H:C8:D;HJ8=HJ7?:8I>K::K6AJ6I>DCH

>CKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIHB6N688DJCI;DGI=:A>B>I:9:K>9:C8:D;696EI6I>DC68I>DCI=6I

=6H7::CD7H:GK:9ID96I:*G:HIDC:I6A6.DBE@>CH:I6A DG9:I6A .=::;;:8ID;!#-DCD7?:8IHD;>IHH8GJI>CN=6H7::CE6HH>DC6I:AN9:76I:9>C<:D<G6E=N H>C8:I=::6GANH-8=JJGB6C .LDH:B>C6A8DAA:8I>DCH_$D=C*>8@A:HcH:8=7-

&:=<1 6C96HE:8>6A>HHJ:D;*:<80:*91A*7-.80:*912,7/8:6*<287%A;<.6;:9>I:97N G>8-=:EE6G9 _HJBB6G>O:I=:JC:6H:L>I=L=>8==JB6C<:D<G6E=:GHK>:L:9

!#->CI=:N:6GHI=6I;DAADL:9<:D<G6E=NcHFJ6CI>I6I>K:G:KDAJI>DC.=:E:G>D9L6HB6G@:9 7N`H8>:C8:L6GHaL=>8=8DCH>HI:9D;6H:G>:HD;>CI:AA:8IJ6A:M8=6C<:H7:IL::CH8>:CI>;>8 G:6A>HIH6C9HD8>6A8DCHIGJ8I>K>HIHG:<6G9>C<I=:`:E>HI:BDAD<>86AEG>K>A:<::C?DN:97N

(13)

H8>:C8:6C9I=:9:<G::IDL=>8=H8>:C8:>H8JAIJG6AAN>C;AJ:C8:9a-8=JJGB6C 1>I=>CI=:9>H8>EA>C:D;<:D<G6E=N8DCHIGJ8I>K>HIH6G<J:9I=6I!#-L6H>C6II:CI>K:ID I=:DG:I>86A69K6C8:H>C=JB6C<:D<G6E=N:HE:8>6AANI=DH:=6K>C<ID9DL>I=CDCK>HJ6A G:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6C9I=:9NC6B>8HD;EDL:GII=:I>B:!#-;DAADL:98DCK:CI>DCHGDDI:9

>CAD<>86AEDH>I>K>HB6C96GI:H>6C<:DB:IGN6C98G>I>86A<:D<G6E=:GHL:G:8DC8:GC:9I=6I

!#-L6H7:>C<JH:9IDG:>C;DG8:IDE9DLC:ME:GI6C6ANH:HD;<:D<G6E=>8EGD7A:BH>C6 L6NI=6IA>B>I:9=DLI=DH:EGD7A:BH8DJA97:G:EG:H:CI:96C9HJ7H:FJ:CIAN699G:HH:9 I=GDJ<=EDA>8N-8=JJGB6C

#CI=:>CI:GK:C>C<N:6GH8G>I>86A!#-8>:C8:=6HG:HEDC9:9ID8DC8:GCH67DJII=:HD8>6A EDA>I>86A6C9:E>HI:BDAD<>86A>BEA>86I>DCHD;!#-7N9:K:ADE>C<C:L6EEGD68=:H9G6LC

;GDBFJ6A>I6I>K:G:H:6G8=B:I=D9HI=6I>C8AJ9:CDK:AI:8=C>FJ:H;DGG:EG:H:CI>C<BJAI>EA:

G:6A>I>:HD;H>C<A:>HHJ:HALDD9 .=:8DCH:FJ:C8:;DG!#-EG6M>H>H6C688:EI6C8:

I=6I:68=JC>FJ:DCIDAD<>86A>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;HE68:L>AA6AHDG:HJAI>C69>;;:G:CI :E>HI:BDAD<N99N .=>HG:8D<C>I>DCD;BJAI>EA:DCIDAD<>:HA>C@H!#-IDI=:

EAJG6A>IND;8A>B6I:8=6C<:"JAB:H7?TGC"6G<:CH)G>:C .=:

CDI>DCI=6I8A>B6I:8=6C<:=6H69>;;:G:CI:8=D9:E:C9>C<DC>C9>K>9J6AHcE:GHDC6A7:A>:;H LDGA9K>:LH6C99>G:8I:ME:G>:C8:EGDK>9:HI=:;DJC96I>DC;DGI=>HHIJ9ND;I=:8DCI>C<:CI C6IJG:D;HE6I>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH

-./3#'(,-,"+/-.#)(-

A>B6I:8=6C<:>H?JHIDC:D;B6CNINE:HD;H=D8@H6C9HIG:HHDGHI=6IAD86A

8DBBJC>I>:H;68:1>A76C@H6C9%6I:H #CDG9:GIDJC9:GHI6C9I=:G>H@H_6C9>C HDB:86H:HDEEDGIJC>I>:H_I=6I8A>B6I:8=6C<:EDH:HAD86A9:8>H>DCB6@:GHC::9

>C;DGB6I>DC67DJI>BE68IH6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN>CDG9:GIDEA6C6EEGDEG>6I:G:HEDCH:H.=:

6>BD;I=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC>HI=:G:;DG:ID8G>I>86AAN:M6B>C:HE6I>6AANG:;:G:C8:9>C;DGB6I>DC 67DJI8A>B6I:8=6C<:>BE68IH6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN;DGI=::MEA>8>IEJGEDH:D;696EI6I>DC

(14)

EA6CC>C< DJGG:H:6G8=FJ:HI>DCH<J>9:I=>H:MEADG6I>DC

1=6I6G:I=:EDI:CI>6AHD;6C9A>B>IHIDJH>C<8A>B6I:H8:C6G>DH>C696EI6I>DC EA6CC>C<

"DL9DE:DEA:JC9:GHI6C98A>B6I:8=6C<:6C9E:G8:>K:I=::;;:8I>K:C:HHD;

9>;;:G:CIG:HEDCH:H

1=N9DB6CNKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH;6>AID:C<6<:HI6@:=DA9:GH

1=6IB:I=D9H86C7:JH:9ID>CI:<G6I:6C9G:EG:H:CIFJ6A>I6I>K:8DCI:MIJ6A

>C;DGB6I>DCL>I=FJ6CI>I6I>K:H8:C6G>D76H:996I6

%!,)/(()(.2.

.=>H9>HH:GI6I>DCIDD@H=6E:L>I=>C6A6G<:>CI:G9>H8>EA>C6GNEGD?:8II=6I8DC8:EIJ6A>O:9 696EI6I>DC6H6HD8>6AEGD8:HHI=6I>HA>@:ANID7:A>B>I:97N9>;;:G:CI>6A>CI:G:HIHK6AJ:H 7:A>:;HEG>DG>I>:H6C9EDL:GG:A6I>DCH6AAD;L=>8=6G:;68IDGHI=6IB6NI=:BH:AK:H8=6C<:

>CG:HEDCH:IDDC<D>C<HD8>:I6AIG6CH;DGB6I>DCH)G>:C .=:DK:G6G8=>C<EGD?:8I 8DB7>C:9:BE>G>86AEA68:76H:9G:H:6G8=DC696EI6I>DCL>I=6C6ANH>HD;EA6CC>C<EGD8:HH:H 6C9>CHI>IJI>DC6AG:;DGBHI=6IID<:I=:G8DCI:MIJ6A>O:I=:EDI:CI>6AHD;6C9A>B>IHID

696EI6I>DC>C(DGL6N)G>:C6C9-:A7D: .=:EGD?:8IIDD@EA68:;GDBID 9JG>C<6E:G>D9D;>CI:CH:68I>K>IN68GDHHI=:A6C9H86E:D;(DGL:<>6C8A>B6I:

G:H:6G8=

#CI=:<DK:GCB:CI8DBB>HH>DC:96CD;;>8>6AEJ7A>8G:EDGIDC(DGL6NcH KJAC:G67>A>IN6C9I=:C::9ID696EIIDI=:>BE68IHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:.=:G:EDGIL6H HJ7B>II:9IDI=:'>C>HIGND;I=:CK>GDCB:CIILDN:6GHA6I:G()/ 6C9H=DLHI=6I 6K:G6<:6CCJ6AEG:8>E>I6I>DC>H:ME:8I:9ID>C8G:6H:JEID7NL>I=B6?DG

H:6HDC6A6C9G:<>DC6AK6G>6I>DCH"6CHH:C6J:G:I6A .=:G:L>AA6AHD7:6C>C8G:6H:

>CI=:CJB7:GD;96NHL>I==:6KNEG:8>E>I6I>DC6C9I=:6K:G6<:G6>C;6AADCI=DH:96NHL>AA 7:=><=:GI=GDJ<=DJII=::CI>G:8DJCIGN9JG>C<6AAH:6HDCHILDIDI=G::BDCI=G:9J8I>DC

>CI=:HCDLH:6HDC>H:ME:8I:97NI=::C9D;I=:8:CIJGN9J:ID=><=:GI:BE:G6IJG:H

*&(H::LLLHKJ>DCD>HH:C<A>H=G:H:6G8=EGD?:8IHEA6C

,:;:GG:9ID>CI=:AD86AA6C<J6<:6H6C()/;DG 8:0.;8//.7<520.=<:.-7270.:

(15)

K:G6<:6CCJ6AI:BE:G6IJG:>H:ME:8I:9ID>C8G:6H:7NIDWL>I=I=:<G:6I:HI L6GB>C<:ME:8I:9>CCDGI=:GC(DGL6N9JG>C<I=:L>CI:GBDCI=H#C699>I>DCIDI=:DK:G6AA L6GB>C<IG:C9I=:G:L>AA7:6C>C8G:6H:9CJB7:GD;96NHL>I=:MIG:B:I:BE:G6IJG:H L=>8=6G:9:;>C:96H696>ANB:6C67DK:W"6CHH:C6J:G:I6A

=6C<:H>CI:BE:G6IJG:EG:8>E>I6I>DC6C9:MIG:B:L:6I=:GL>AA=6K:8DCH:FJ:C8:HDC (DGL:<>6CC6IJG:6C9HD8>:IN()/ ADHHD;7>D9>K:GH>IN>H:ME:8I:9>CCDGI=:GC (DGL6N6C96I=><=6AI>IJ9:HH>C8:I=DH:6G:6H=6K:I=:=><=:HIEGD?:8I:9G6I:HD;8=6C<:

6C98DCH>HID;=67>I6IHI=6I6G:6AG:69NB6G<>C6A*=NH>86A>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:7J>A9>C<6HH:IH6C9 G:A6I:9;68>A>I>:HL>AA7::MEDH:9ID>C8G:6H>C<AN:MIG:B:L:6I=:G6HI>B:<D:H7N-E:8>;>8 KJAC:G67>A>I>:HK6GN7NH:8IDG7JI>CHJ;;>8>:CIB6>CI:C6C8:>HH::C6H68DBBDC8=6AA:C<:

I=6IL>AA7:6BEA>;>:97N8A>B6I:8=6C<:,/ 8=6EI:G>C()/ (:LDEEDGIJC>I>:H

;DG:8DCDB>8<GDLI=6G:EGD?:8I:9L>I=>CI=:EG>B6GN>C9JHIG>:H6C9I=::C:G<NH=>EE>C<

6C9IDJG>HBH:8IDGH6AI=DJ<=I=:EDI:CI>6A;DGB6A696EI6I>DC>H=><=.=:G:EDGICDI:H I=6I6JIDCDBDJH696EI6I>DCH>CG:HEDCH:ID6CI>8>E6I:9:K:CIHL>AA7:>CHJ;;>8>:CIID:CHJG:

6G:H>A>:CIHD8>:IN>CI=:;JIJG:I=:G:;DG:EG:K:CI>K:ADC<I:GB696EI6I>DC>C>I>6I>K:HBJHI 7:9:K:ADE:9:HE>I:H8>:CI>;>8JC8:GI6>CING:<6G9>C<I=:I>B>C<6C9B6<C>IJ9:D;8A>B6I:

8=6C<:I=:()/HI6I:H8A:6GANI=6I`L:@CDL:CDJ<=ID8DC8AJ9:I=6I:;;DGIHID696EI BJHI7:>CIGD9J8:9>BB:9>6I:ANa()/

#I>HI=:(DGL:<>6C<DK:GCB:CIcHD;;>8>6AEDH>I>DCI=6I8A>B6I:696EI6I>DCH=DJA9CDI 7:H:E6G6I:9;GDBDI=:GEA6CC>C<EGD8:HH:H%& .=>HG:FJ>G:HI=6II=:AD86A 6JI=DG>I>:HG:HEDCH>7A:;DG6E6GI>8JA6G6G:6D;HD8>:IN>:=:6AI=6C9H6;:IN7JH>C:HH6C9

>C9JHIGNE=NH>86AEA6CC>C<DGC6IJG6AG:HDJG8:B6C6<:B:CI:I8 BJHI6AHD7:B6C6<:I=:

>BE68IHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:7N>CI:<G6I>C<8A>B6I:8DCH>9:G6I>DCH>CIDI=:>GG:<JA6GEA6CC>C<

6C99:8>H>DCB6@>C<EGD8:HH:H.=:<DK:GCB:CIcH696EI6I>DCHIG6I:<N>HI=JHID

8I>DCH86C7:B6A696EI>K:>;I=:N>C8G:6H:KJAC:G67>A>IN'86GI=N:I6A DG:M6BEA:H=DGII:GB :8DCDB>8<6>CH;GDBD>A6C9C6IJG6A<6HEGD9J8I>DC6H6G:HJAID;6C>8:;G::G8I>886C7:G:<6G9:96H6 B6A696EI6I>DC7:86JH:>I8G:6I:H6EDH>I>K:;::9768@7N>C8G:6H>C<<G::C=DJH:<6H:B>HH>DCH>CI=:ADC<

I:GB

(16)

B6>CHIG:6B8A>B6I:8=6C<:>CID:M>HI>C<HE6I>6AEA6CC>C<6C9:B:G<:C8NB6C6<:B:CI .=:ILDEG>B6GN>CHIGJB:CIH86AA:9JEDCID:C67A:B6>CHIG:6B>C<6G:I=:*A6CC>C<6C9 J>A9>C<8ID;6C9I=:>K>A*GDI:8I>DC8ID;.=:*A6CC>C<6C9J>A9>C<

8IEGDK>9:HI=:;G6B:LDG@;DG6AAA6C9JH:EA6CC>C<>C(DGL6N.=:76H>8I:C:ID;I=:

A6L>HID69K6C8:6ADC<I:GBE:GHE:8I>K:>CEJ7A>8EA6CC>C<76H:9DCI=:EG:86JI>DC6GN EG>C8>EA:L>I=I=:CDGB6I>K:<D6AD;HJHI6>C67A:9:K:ADEB:CI.=:>K>A*GDI:8I>DC8I

>H9:H><C:9IDEGDI:8I=:6AI=6C9H6;:INE=NH>86A6HH:IH6C98G>I>86A>C;G6HIGJ8IJG:>C 69K:GH:H>IJ6I>DCH,>H@6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH6G:=><=A><=I:9>C7DI=A6LH7JIL>I=

HA><=IAN9>;;:G:CI:BE=6H:HI=:*A6CC>C<6C9J>A9>C<8IG:<JA6I:HG>H@H6C9KJAC:G67>A>I>:H 6HHD8>6I:9L>I=C6IJG6A=6O6G9H6C9I=:>K>A*GDI:8I>DC8I699G:HH:HG>H@H6C9

KJAC:G67>A>I>:H>CI=:8DCI:MID;:B:G<:C8NB6C6<:B:CI.=:H:6HH:HHB:CIH6G:>CI:C9:9 ID>9:CI>;NG>H@H6C9I=:EDHH>7A:8DCH:FJ:C8:HD;I=DH:G>H@HI=:G:7NEGDK>9>C<I=:76H>H

;DGEA6CC>C<EG:K:CI>K:B:6HJG:H.=:(DGL:<>6C>G:8IDG6I:;DG>K>A*GDI:8I>DC6C9 8DJCIN<DK:GCDG/A54.;6*77.7 G:8DBB:C9JH>C<!#-IDB::IHI6IJIDGNG:FJ>G:B:CIH;DG 6HH:HH>C<KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:-

,-,"-)*

.=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC_<GDJC9:9>C=JB6C<:D<G6E=NL>I=>IH:BE=6H>HDC=JB6C :CK>GDCB:CIG:A6I>DCH=>EHH86A:6C9EA68:76H:9HIJ9>:H_8DB7>C:HG:H:6G8=IG69>I>DCH

>C:CK>GDCB:CI6A<:D<G6E=N7:=6K>DG6A<:D<G6E=NKJAC:G67>A>INH8>:C8:6C9<:D<G6E=>8

>C;DGB6I>DCH8>:C8:!#-8>:C8: #=6K:6EEGD68=:9BNG:H:6G8=FJ:HI>DCHL>I=

B:I=D9DAD<>86AEAJG6A>HB6C9JH:9>C9J8I>DCID9G6L8DC8AJH>DCH67DJI=DLHE6I>6A

>C;DGB6I>DC86C7:8DBBJC>86I:9>C6B6CC:GI=6I;68>A>I6I:HG:HEDCH:HID8A>B6I:8=6C<:

6I68DAA:8I>DCL6H8DC9J8I:9>C(DGL6N6C6;;AJ:CI8DJCIGNI=6I>H=><=AN:MEDH:9ID

*A6CD<7N<C>C<HADK:CH::LLLADK96I6CDADK

->K>A7:H@NII:AH:HADK:CH::LLLADK96I6CDADK

)IEGECG H::LLLG:<?:G>C<:CCDC79D@JB:CI:GDIEGECG>9

':A9-I^ H::LLLG:<?:G>C<:CCDC79D@JB:CI:GB:A9HI>9

(17)

8A>B6I:8=6C<:6C96II=:H6B:I>B:8DCH>9:G:9G:H>A>:CIIDC:<6I>K:>BE68IH)cG>:C:I6A :K:ADE:98DJCIG>:H=6K::MI:CH>K:688:HHID;>C6C8>6A6C9I:8=C>86AG:HDJG8:H6C9 D;I:C=6K:6HIGDC<>CHI>IJI>DC6A76H:;GDBL=>8=696EI6I>DC86CD88JG-IJ9N>C<

:ME:G>:C8:H>C68DJCIGNA>@:(DGL6N86CI=:G:;DG:=><=A><=II=:HIGJ8IJG:HG:A6I>DCH=>EH 6C9EGD8:HH:HI=6IBD7>A>O:DGA>B>I 696EI6I>DC>CH><=IHI=6I6G:K6AJ67A:;DG9:K:ADE:9 6C99:K:ADE>C<8DJCIG>:H6A>@:

'NG:H:6G8=EGD8:HH>C8AJ9:96I=G::BDCI=K>H>IIDI=:(6I>DC6A:CI:G;DG

IBDHE=:G>8,:H:6G8=>CDJA9:GDADG69DIDLDG@L>I=H8=DA6GH>CI=:>G!#-EGD<G6B .=:;D8JHD;BNI>B:I=:G:L6HILD;DA9 EGD;:HH>DC6A9:K:ADEB:CI>CI=:>CI:<G6I>DCD;

C6IJG6A6C9HD8>6AH8>:C8:H96I6>C!#-6C9 6HH:HHB:CIHIG6I:<>:H;DG:MIG:B:=:6I KJAC:G67>A>IN>:1>A=:AB>6C9"6N9:C #L6H6AHD6<J:HI6II=: >CC>H=

CK>GDCB:CI#CHI>IJI:-3% L=:G:#8DCIG>7JI:9IDI=:9:H><C6C9>BEA:B:CI6I>DCD;6 KJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CI>CI=:(DG9>8G:<>DC

II=:=:6GID;I=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC>HI=::K6AJ6I>DCD;6!#-76H:9IDDA^86AA:9 ,0(^9:K:ADE:9ID8=6G68I:G>O:KJAC:G67>A>IND;I=::A9:GANID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>C I=:(DG9>8G:<>DC DGBDHI8DJCIG>:H>CJGDE:I=:8JGG:CI7JG9:CD;8DA9G:A6I:9 BDGI6A>IN>H<G:6I:GI=6CI=:7JG9:CD;=:6IBDGI6A>INC6A>I>H:I6A "DL:K:G 8:GI6>CEDEJA6I>DC<GDJEH6G:6AHDKJAC:G67A:ID=:6IG:A6I:9:K:CIH,D8@ATK6C9 DGH7:G<

6C9PHIGTB:I6A 9>H8JHHI=:H:8=6AA:C<:H>CI=:8DCI:MID;CDGI=:GCJGDE:

.=:ILDN:6GHIJ9N#E6GI>8>E6I:9>CL>I= >CC>H=6C9-L:9>H=8DAA67DG6IDGH6HH:HH:9I=:

KJAC:G67>A>IND;(DG9>8EDEJA6I>DCH6<:96C9DA9:GID:MIG:B:L:6I=:G8DC9>I>DCHI=6I

>C8AJ9:9=:6IG:A6I:9:K:CIH8DA9G:A6I:9:K:CIH6C9:MEDHJG:ID;G::O:I=6L8DC9>I>DCH 6GI:G:I6A .=:6>BD;I=:EGD?:8IL6HIDEGDK>9:C6I>DC6A6C9G:<>DC6AD;;>8>6AH G:HEDCH>7A:;DGI=:86G:6C9L:A;6G:D;I=::A9:GANL>I=6C>CI:G68I>K:H8G::C>C<IDDAID

:K:ADE:98DJCIG>:H6G:9:;>C:9=:G:6HE6GI>:HA>HI:9JC9:GCC:M#D;I=:/C>I:9(6I>DCH G6B:LDG@

DCK:CI>DCDCA>B6I:=6C<:/(

-::LLL<>HJ86G:9J67DJI

(18)

>9:CI>;NKJAC:G67>A>IN=DIHEDIHI=6I8DJA9L6GG6CI;JGI=:G>CK:HI><6I>DCB6E6EEA>86I>DC L6H9:K:ADE:9L>I=6C>CI:G;68:I=6I6AADLHJH:GHIDH:A:8I;GDB6;>M:9H:ID;>C9>86IDGH 6C9L:><=I=:B688DG9>C<I=:JH:GcH@CDLA:9<:6C9?J9<B:CI67DJII=:9:I:GB>C6CIHD;

KJAC:G67>A>IN ><JG: 'NEDHI=D8:K6AJ6I>DCD;I=:IDDA6C9=DLHI6@:=DA9:GHJH:9>I 9:BDCHIG6I:HI=6IKJAC:G67>A>IN>HI=::B:G<:CIEGDE:GIND;9>H8JHH>DCH67DJI8A>B6I>8G>H@H I=6I6G:>C;DGB:97JICDI9:I:GB>C:97NH8>:CI>;>8>CEJI

1=>A:I=6I86H:ADD@:96IHD8>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN;DGL:A;6G:EA6CC>C<EJGEDH:H6H:8DC9 86H:EG:H:CI:9>CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC>CK:HI><6I:9=DLE=NH>86AKJAC:G67>A>IN>H6HH:HH:9>CI=:

8DCI:MID;HE6I>6AEA6CC>C<-I6IJIDGNG:FJ>G:B:CIH>C(DGL6ND7A><:BJC>8>E6A>I>:HID 8DC9J8IKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH6I9>;;:G:CIHI6<:HD;I=:EA6CC>C<EGD8:HH.=:H:

6HH:HHB:CIH6G:I=:CJH:9ID>9:CI>;N696EI6I>DCC::9H6C9ID:K6AJ6I:HE:8>;>8

>CI:GK:CI>DCH/H>C<I=:86H:D;JG76C9:K:ADEB:CI>C6;ADD9G>H@ODC:>C)HAD#H=DL I=6IEA6CC:GH6C9B6G@:I68IDGH:68=E:G8:>K:8A>B6I>8KJAC:G67>A>IN9>;;:G:CIAN6 9>H8G:E6C8NI=6I>HI=:CDK:GADD@:9>C696EI6I>DC9:8>H>DCH6C9A:69HID;G6<B:CI6I>DC 68GDHH>CHI>IJI>DCH6C9;GJHIG6I>DC6BDC<6AA68IDGH.=6IH>B>A6G:;;:8IHL:G:;DJC9;DG 6HH:HHB:CIHD;7DI=HD8>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN6C9E=NH>86AKJAC:G67>A>INA:C9H8G:9:C8:IDBN

=NEDI=:H>HI=6IKJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIH6G:8DCI>C<:CIJEDCHJ7?:8I>K:;68IDGHI=6I

>C8AJ9:>C9>K>9J6A6C98DAA:8I>K:7:A>:;HLDGA9K>:LHBDI>K6I>DCH6C96HHJBEI>DCH .=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC>HEG:H:CI:96H;>K:HI6C96ADC:E6E:GHI=6IG:K:6AHDB:D;I=:A>B>IH 6C9DE:C>C<H;DG8DBBJC>86I>C<67DJI8A>B6I:8=6C<:6II=:>CI:G;68:7:IL::CH8>:C8:

6C9EDA>8N.=:;>GHI6GI>8A:ADD@H6II=:GDA:D;H8:C6G>DH;DGG:HEDC9>C<ID8A>B6I:8=6C<:

7N>9:CI>;N>C<6CJB7:GD;A>B>I6I>DCH6HHD8>6I:9L>I=9DLCH86A:98A>B6I:EGD?:8I>DCH 9:K:ADE:9ID=:AE9:8>H>DCB6@:GHEA6C;DGI=:;JIJG:.=:H:8DC96GI>8A:>H6C:BE>G>86A HIJ9ND;=DL8A>B6I:8=6C<:>C(DGL6N>HE:G8:>K:96C9=DLI=DH:E:G8:EI>DCH6;;:8I EG:;:G:C8:H;DG9>;;:G:CIEDA>8NG:HEDCH:H.=:I=>G96GI>8A:G:K>:LHKJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIEG68I>8:H>CA><=ID;I=G:::C67A>C<;68IDGHI=6I:C=6C8:I=:JEI6@:D;

(19)

6HH:HHB:CIG:HJAIHH6A>:C8:8G:9>7>A>IN6C9A:<>I>B68N*6E:G;DJG:MEADG:H=DLI=:

8DCI>C<:CIC6IJG:D;KJAC:G67>A>IN>CHE6I>6AEA6CC>C<>HG:K:6A:9.=:;>C6AE6E:GEGDEDH:H6 C:L6HH:HHB:CI6EEGD68=I=6IG:8D<C>O:HI=:>BEDGI6C8:D;68@CDLA:9<>C<6C9:C<6<>C<

L>I=69>K:GH>IND;>CI:G:HIH8DBB>IB:CIH6C9K6AJ:H6HL:AA6HI=:EDA>I>8H6C9EDL:G :B7:99:9>C696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<EGD8:HH:H.D<:I=:GI=:H:E6E:GHH=DLI=6I9>;;:G:CI

;DGBHD;@CDLA:9<:6C9@CDLA:9<:H::@>C<6;;:8I=DLKJAC:G67>A>IN>HJC9:GHIDD96C9 I=JHB6C6<:9

.=:9>HH:GI6I>DC>HHIGJ8IJG:96H;DAADLH#CI=:C:MIH:8I>DC#9>H8JHHI=:EG>B6GN 8DC8:EIHI=6I=6K:H=6E:9BNI=>C@>C<6H#8DC9J8I:9I=>HG:H:6G8=#I=:C9:H8G>7:BN G:H:6G8=9:H><C7NEG:H:CI>C<I=:I=:DG:I>86AE:GHE:8I>K:HI=6IJC9:GE>CI=:9>HH:GI6I>DC6H L:AA6HI=:B:I=D9H6C996I6#=6K::BEADN:9;I:GEG:H:CI>C<9:I6>A:9HJBB6G>:HD;I=:

9>HH:GI6I>DCcH;DJGE6E:GH#HNCI=:H>O:I=:>G;>C9>C<H>C67G>:;9>H8JHH>DC#8DC8AJ9:L>I=6 G:86E>IJA6I>DCD;I=:9>HH:GI6I>DC6C9=><=A><=II=:>BEA>86I>DCHD;I=>HLDG@

/-:7+ 8)7++38.494,9.+2'55/3-94419.'9'114<8:8+78948+1+)9/3*/)'9478,7429.+

';'/1'(1+8)+3'7/48'3*2'59.+2/39.+/747/-/3'1:3/98'8<+11'8)42(/3+9.+2/394 )42548/9+/3*/)+84,549+39/'1/25')98'*'59/;+)'5')/9>'3*;:13+7'(/1/9>$.+9441/8

';'/1'(1+'9<<</';2'55/3-3+9%&+1*+71>

(20)

/('(.&)(*.-

.=:6>BD;I=>HH:8I>DC>HID9:;>C:I=:8DG:8DC8:EIHG:A:K6CIIDI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DCI=:

;D8JHD;L=>8=>H6HH:HH>C<KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:;DGI=:EJGEDH:D;>9:CI>;N>C<

696EI6I>DCC::9H#6BE6GI>8JA6GAN>CI:G:HI:9>C=DL!#-86C7:JH:9IDHJEEDGI6C6ANI>86A 6C99:A>7:G6I>K:EGD8:HH:H>CHE6I>6A9:8>H>DCB6@>C<.DI=6I:C9I=G::;JC96B:CI6A 8DC8:EIHL6GG6CI:MEA6C6I>DCKJAC:G67>A>IN696EI6I>DC6C9HE6I>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN

6HH:HHB:CI;DJGI=I:GBFJ6A>I6I>K:!#->H9>H8JHH:9ID;G6B:BNDK:G6AA6EEGD68=ID LDG@>C<L>I=HE6I>6A96I6

&#'.0/&(,#&#.3

A>B6I:8=6C<:6;;:8IHE:DEA:6C9EA68:H9>;;:G:CI>6AAN6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN>HI=:EG>B6GN B:6CH7NL=>8=IDJC9:GHI6C9=DL8A>B6I:>CI:G68IHL>I=AD86A8DCI:MIH0JAC:G67>A>IN 8=6G68I:G>O:H8A>B6I:G:A6I:9>BE68IH6C9I=:B:8=6C>HBHI=6I;68>A>I6I:8DE>C<G:HEDCH:H 9<:G .=:6C6ANH>HD;8A>B6I:KJAC:G67>A>INHI:BH;GDB=6O6G9HG:H:6G8=JGIDC:I 6A 6C9:CI>IA:B:CII=:DGN-:C I=6IID<:I=:G86C7:JH:9IDA>C@9>H8G:I:G>H@H L>I=I=:HD8>6A>CHI>IJI>DCHI=6I>C;AJ:C8:DJI8DB:HA6>@>::I6A .=:BDHIL>9:AN 6EEA>:9>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;KJAC:G67>A>INDG><>C6I:9>CI=:#*cH.=>G9HH:HHB:CI,:EDGI L=>8=DE:G6I>DC6A>O:9>I6H6;JC8I>DCD;I=:C6IJG:6C9B6<C>IJ9:D;8A>B6I:K6G>6I>DCI=:

9:<G::IDL=>8=6HNHI:B>H6;;:8I:96C9I=:67>A>IND;6HNHI:BID69?JHIDG8DE:L>I=I=:

8DCH:FJ:C8:H'86GI=N:I6A .=>H>CI:GEG:I6I>DC>CI:<G6I:HI=G:::A:B:CI6A 67HIG68I>DCH:MEDHJG:H:CH>I>K>IN6C9696EI>K:86E68>IN ><JG:

MEDHJG:G:;:GHIDHE6I>DI:BEDG6A:K:CIHI=6I>C9>86I:8A>B6I:8=6C<:6C9>H<:C:G6AAN G:EG:H:CI:96H6H=>;I>CHDB:B:6CHI6I:HJ8=6HI:BE:G6IJG:DGEG:8>E>I6I>DC-:CH>I>K>IN 9:CDI:HI=:G:HEDCH>K:C:HHD;6HNHI:B>:68>IN6E6GI>8JA6GEDEJA6I>DCDG6H:8IDG ID I=DH:HE6I>DI:BEDG6A:K:CIH-B>I6C916C9:A 6G<J:I=6I:MEDHJG:6C9

#CI:G<DK:GCB:CI6A*6C:ADCA>B6I:=6C<:

(21)

H:CH>I>K>IN6G:`>CH:E6G67A:EGDE:GI>:Ha9:E:C9:CIDCI=:>CI:G68I>DC7:IL::CAD86A 8DC9>I>DCH:<AD86I>DCIDED<G6E=NA6C9JH:A>K:A>=DD9H>C;G6HIGJ8IJG: 6C9

8=6G68I:G>HI>8HD;I=::K:CI>:;G:FJ:C8NB6<C>IJ9:6C99JG6I>DC 1=:C8DB7>C:9 :MEDHJG:6C9H:CH>I>K>IN:MEG:HHI=:EDI:CI>6A>BE68IHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:#BE68IH6G:

9:H8G>7:9=:G:6H`EDI:CI>6Aa7:86JH:I=:N9DCDI688DJCI;DG6JIDCDBDJH696EI6I>DCI=:

HEDCI6C:DJH69?JHIB:CIHIG><<:G:97NBD9:G6I:9:K>6I>DCH>CCDGB6A8A>B6I: VHH:A6C9

%A:>C

1=:G:I=:EGD767>A>IND;6EDI:CI>6A>BE68I>H@CDLCI=:I:GBG>H@>HJH:9,>H@>H JHJ6AANG:EG:H:CI:96HI=:EGD767>A>IND;D88JGG:C8:D;=6O6G9DJH:K:CIHDGIG:C9H BJAI>EA>:97NI=:H:K:G>IND;>BE68I7JII=:H:86A8JA6I>DCH86C7::>I=:GFJ6A>I6I>K:ANDG FJ6CI>I6I>K:AN$DC:H ,>H@>C9>86I:H6H>IJ6I>DC>CKDAK>C<:MEDHJG:ID96C<:GDGI=:

EDHH>7>A>IND;=6GB6C9>HI=:G:7N8ADH:ANG:A6I:9IDI=:8DC8:EID;KJAC:G67>A>IN

96EI>K:86E68>IN>HI=:67>A>IND;6HNHI:BID8DE:L>I=G>H@H6C9:MEAD>IDEEDGIJC>I>:H G:A6I:9ID8=6C<:-B>I6C916C9:A #I>H69NC6B>8EGDE:GINI=6IK6G>:HDK:GI>B:

/-:7+$.+)42543+3984,;:13+7'(/1/9>'3*9.+/77+1'9/438./594 '*'59'9/433++*84*/,/+*',9+7?88+1'3*1+/3

(22)

68GDHHHE68:6C96BDC<HD8>6A<GDJEH:I:GB>C6CIHD;696EI>K:86E68>IN>C8AJ9:688:HHID :8DCDB>8G:HDJG8:HI:8=CDAD<N>C;DGB6I>DC6C9H@>AAH6AAD;L=>8=6G:>C;AJ:C8:97N 9>;;:G:CIINE:HD;86E>I6A:<=JB6CB6I:G>6AHD8>6AEDA>I>86A BD9:HD;<DK:GC6C8:

HD8>6A>CHI>IJI>DCH6C9:CI>IA:B:CIHGDD@H:I6AJII:G:I6A0>C8:CI 96EI>K:86E68>IN>H6EDH>I>K:6IIG>7JI:D;6HNHI:BI=6IG:9J8:HKJAC:G67>A>IN7N:C67A>C<

69?JHIB:CIH`>CG:HEDCH:ID68IJ6ADG:ME:8I:98A>B6I>8HI>BJA>DGI=:>G:;;:8IHa'86GI=N :I6A #I>H>BEDGI6CIIDCDI:I=6IL=>A:696EI>K:86E68>IN>H8G>I>86A;DG

JC9:GHI6C9>C<L=6IB6@:HHD8>:I>:HBDG:DGA:HH,*9*+5.D;696EI>C<ID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>I 9D:HCDI6JIDB6I>86AANIG6CHA6I:>CID696EI>K:68I>DC:HE:8>6AAN6II=:AD86AA:K:A)G>:C:I 6A

0JAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>HI=JHI=:G:A6I>DCH=>E7:IL::CEDI:CI>6A>BE68IH6C9 696EI>K:86E68>IN;DG6<>K:CH:ID;8>G8JBHI6C8:H ><JG: HH:HHB:CIH86C7:;G6B:9>C I:GBHD;DJI8DB:HDG8DCI:MIH9:H8G>7:9>C9:I6>ADCE6<: 9:E:C9>C<DCI=:G:A6I>K:

L:><=I>C<D;:MEDHJG:H:CH>I>K>IN6C9696EI>K:86E68>IN)G>:C:I6A AI=DJ<=

KJAC:G67>A>INH><C>;>:H6EDI:CI>6AHI6I:6HDEEDH:9ID6G:6A>O:9DJI8DB:KJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIH6G:CDC:I=:A:HHJH:;JA;DG>9:CI>;N>C<696EI6I>DCC::9HI=6IB6N7:C:8:HH6GN DG7:C:;>8>6A>CG:HEDCH:ID8A>B6I:8=6C<:

1>I=I=:EJ7A>86I>DCD;>IH >;I=HH:HHB:CI,:EDGII=:#*CDL9:;>C:H

KJAC:G67>A>INH>BEAN6H`I=:EGDE:CH>INDGEG:9>HEDH>I>DCID7:69K:GH:AN6;;:8I:9a#*

.=:C:L9:;>C>I>DCD;;:GHL6NHD;:MEADG>C<AD86AH:CH>I>K>I>:H6C98DE>C<

86E68>I>:HL>I=DJI=6K>C<IDG:ANDCBD9:A76H:9EGD?:8I>DCHD;8=6C<:#IG:EG:H:CIH6G>H@

;G6B>C<8DC8:GC:9L>I=I=:EDI:CI>6A=6GBI=6IB6NG:HJAI;GDBI=::;;:8IHD;8A>B6I:

K6G>67>A>IN6C98=6C<:JG@:II:I6A "DL:K:GI=:C:L9:;>C>I>DCD;KJAC:G67>A>IN B6@:HI=:C::9;DGK6AJ:H76H:9:K6AJ6I>DCH67DJIL=6I8DCHI>IJI:H=6GB:K:CBDG:

:MEA>8>I,/ )G>:C6C91DA; #CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC#=6K:JH:9I=:#*cHDG><>C6A 9:;>C>I>DCD;KJAC:G67>A>INL=>A:8D<C>O6CID;I=:GDA:K6AJ:HEA6N>C:MEA6>C>C<I=:86JH:HD;

(23)

KJAC:G67>A>IN6C9>9:CI>;N>C<6EEGDEG>6I:G:HEDCH:H)G>:C DCH:FJ:CIAN>CBN JH:`KJAC:G67>A>INa>HCDIH>BEAN8DC8:GC:9L>I=I=:C:<6I>K:B6I:G>6ADJI8DB:H6HHD8>6I:9 L>I=8A>B6I:8=6C<:7JI6AHD=DLI=DH:DJI8DB:H6G:9>;;:G:CI>6AANE:G8:>K:96C9K6AJ:9

*..#)(.)&#'."(!

96EI6I>DC>H6EGD8:HHD;DC<D>C<69?JHIB:CIHI=6IH::@HIDBD9:G6I:DG6KD>9 =6GB DG:MEAD>I7:C:;>8>6ADEEDGIJC>I>:H6HHD8>6I:9L>I=8A>B6I:K6G>67>A>IN6C98=6C<:-B>I:I6A #I>H76H:9DCI=:6HHJBEI>DCI=6I696EI>K:86E68>IN86C7:JH:9IDB>C>B>O:

:MEDHJG:6C9H:CH>I>K>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:6C9G:8DK:G;GDBH=D8@HDGHIG:HHDGH ><JG:

96EI6I>DC>CKDAK:H6L>9:G6C<:D;68IDGH>C9>;;:G:CI:8=:ADCHD;HD8>:INL>I=>C7DI=

EG>K6I:6C9EJ7A>8HE=:G:H#I86C7:6JIDCDBDJH:<G:AD86I>C<6;I:G6;ADD9 6CI>8>E6IDGN:<EJG8=6H>C<;ADD9>CHJG6C8: DGEJGEDH:;JAANEA6CC:9:<G:ODC>C<

;ADD9EGDC:6G:6H EA6CC:9696EI6I>DC>HJC9:GI6@:CHDA:AN7N<DK:GCB:CIH6H69:A>7:G6I:

/-:7+"+1'9/438./58(+9<++3'*'59'9/43'3*;:13+7'(/1/9>

(24)

EDA>8N>C>I>6I>K:6C9>HI=:;D8JHD;I=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC96EI6I>DC>CI=:EJ7A>8H:8IDGB6N

=6K:8ADH:A>C@HL>I=9>H6HI:GEG:E6G:9C:HHEJ7A>8=:6AI=HJHI6>C67A:9:K:ADEB:CIJG76C EA6CC>C<L6I:GB6C6<:B:CI:I8:I:G6B6@>C<>I9>;;>8JAIIDH:E6G6I:696EI>K:68I>DCH;GDB B:6HJG:H>C>I>6I:97NDI=:GEG>DG>I>:H VHH:A

#C>IHBDHIG:8:CI6HH:HHB:CIG:EDGII=:#*68@CDLA:9<:9I=6IE:DEA:6C9HD8>:I>:H E:G8:>K:6C9G6C@8A>B6I>8G>H@H9>;;:G:CIAN76H:9DC9>;;:G>C<K6AJ:H6C9<D6AH.=:NLG>I:

I=6I`696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<6C9>BEA:B:CI6I>DC6I6AAA:K:AHD;<DK:GC6C8:6G:8DCI>C<:CIDC HD8>:I6AK6AJ:HD7?:8I>K:H6C9G>H@E:G8:EI>DCHG:8D<C>I>DCD;9>K:GH:>CI:G:HIH

8>G8JBHI6C8:HHD8>6A8JAIJG6A8DCI:MIH6C9:ME:8I6I>DCH86C7:C:;>I9:8>H>DCB6@>C<

EGD8:HH:Ha#* C6EEG:8>6I>DCD;I=:GDA:I=6IHJ7?:8I>K>INEA6NH>C

JC9:GHI6C9>C<8=6C<:86JH6A>IN6C9G:HEDCH:H>H;JC96B:CI6AIDI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DCK:CI=:

9>HI>C8I>DC7:IL::CB>I><6I>DC6C9696EI6I>DC8DBBDCANJH:9>CI=:8A>B6I:8=6C<:

A>I:G6IJG:>H6HJ7?:8I>K:>CI:GEG:I6I>DCD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:EDA>8NG:HEDCH:HI=6I9DCDI 6AL6NHG:A6I:IDA6NJC9:GHI6C9>C<H6C9EG68I>8:H)G>:C*:AA>C< .=JHJCA>@:

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

(25)

-*.#&0/&(,#&#.3----'(.-

:86JH:KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>H6G:A6I>K:8DC9>I>DC9:I:GB>C:97NI=:

8>G8JBHI6C8:HEGD8:HH:H6C9IG:C9HI=6IK6GN68GDHH=JB6CA6C9H86E:HHE6I>6A6C6ANH>H86C 7:JH:9ID>9:CI>;NI=:=6GB;JADGJCL6CI:98DCH:FJ:C8:HD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:#C;68I HE6I>6A96I6>CI:<G6I>DCL>I=!#-=6H7:8DB:6HI6C96G96EEGD68=;DG6HH:HHB:CIHD;

KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>@:A7DDB6C9$6CHH:C*G:HIDC:I6A7 9:-=:G7>C>C/(*

*G:HIDC:I6A7 =6K:>9:CI>;>:9ILD7GD696EEA>86I>DCHD;HE6I>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIHEGD7A:BDG>:CI6I>DC6C99:8>H>DCHJEEDGI)CDC:=6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIH86C7:JH:9ID7J>A96CJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;8A>B6I:K6G>67>A>IN6C98=6C<:7N

>9:CI>;N>C<I=:@:N6G:6HH:8IDGHDGEDEJA6I>DCHI=6I;68:L:6I=:G6C98A>B6I:G:A6I:9 8=6AA:C<:H.=>H>H68G>I>86A;>GHIHI:E_:B76G@:9JEDCL=:C8A>B6I:8=6C<:>H68DC8:GC 7JI>IHEDI:CI>6A>BE68IH6C9HE:8>;>8KJAC:G67>A>I>:H6G:CDIL:AAJC9:GHIDD9_I=6IL>AA INE>86AAN<J>9:HJ7H:FJ:CILDG@DC696EI6I>DC)CI=:DI=:G=6C9>C;DGB6I>DC67DJII=:

;68IDGHJC9:GAN>C<6HNHI:BcHKJAC:G67>A>IN86CH:GK:6H6C:CIGNED>CI;DG>9:CI>;N>C<

HJ>I67A:696EI6I>DC>CI:GK:CI>DCH96EI6I>DCG:FJ>G:H6CJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;I=:8DBEA:M>IN D;I=:HNHI:B6C9=DL>I8=6C<:H>C8AJ9>C<9:8>H>DCB6@>C<EGD8:HH:HEDA>8N

9:K:ADEB:CIDG<6C>O6I>DC6A8JAIJG:6C9>CCDK6I>DC6C9G>H@E:G8:EI>DC.=>HB:6CH ADD@>C<CDI?JHI6IL=6I6HNHI:B=6HI=6I:C67A:H>IID696EI7JI6AHD6IL=6I>I9D:HI=6I :C67A:H>IID696EI

HH:HH>C<KJAC:G67>A>INL>I=>C6HE6I>6A;G6B:LDG@INE>86AAN8JAB>C6I:H>C688:HH>7A:6C9 EDL:G;JA8DBBJC>86I>DC9:K>8:HJHJ6AAN>CI=:;DGBD;B6EH I=6I8DCK:N6I6<A6C8:

?1.:.KJAC:G67A:6G:6H6C9EDEJA6I>DCH:M>HI6C9?1AI=:N6G:KJAC:G67A:0JAC:G67>A>INB6EH 86CI=JH7:I=DJ<=ID;6H86GID<G6E=>8I:MIHI=6I<>K:B:6C>C<ID8A>B6I:8=6C<:

:E:C9>C<DC=DLI=:9G>K>C<;DG8:H6G::BE=6H>O:9>CI=:6C6ANH>HHE6I>6AKJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIH86C7:;G6B:96H6CDJI8DB:D;I=:EDI:CI>6A>BE68IHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:6H6

(26)

HD8>6A8DCHIGJ8I>DCI=6IB6C>;:HIH>CI=:8DCI:MID;>CHI>IJI>DC6A6C9<DK:GC6C8:HIGJ8IJG:H DG6H68DB7>C6I>DCD;7>DE=NH>86A6C9HD8>6AEGD8:HH:HI=6I9:H8G>7:AD86A8>G8JBHI6C8:H :>I=:GCDLDG>CI=:;JIJG: ><JG: )JI8DB:KJAC:G67>A>IN>H6FJ6CI>I6I>K:BD9:A76H:9 6C6ANH>HD;I=:H:CH>I>K>IND;6E6GI>8JA6GHNHI:BID8=6C<:H>C8A>B6I>88DC9>I>DCH:<

=><=:GI:BE:G6IJG:HA:HHG6>C;6AAG>H>C<H:6A:K:AH .=:6C6ANI>86A;D8JH>HI=:G:;DG:DCI=:

7>DE=NH>86A9:I:GB>C6CIHD;KJAC:G67>A>IN>::MEDHJG:ID8A>B6I:8=6C<: )JI8DB:

KJAC:G67>A>IN>C(DGL6N=6H7::C6HH:HH:9HE6I>6AANL>I=G:<6G9ID>BE68IHDC=N9GDAD<>86A EGD8:HH:H:A9G>C<:I6A JG76C9G6>C6<:HNHI:BH(>::I6A 6C96<G>8JAIJG:

/A:7:G<:I6A DCI:MIJ6AKJAC:G67>A>IN6HHJB:HI=6I:MEDHJG:ID8A>B6I:8=6C<:>H B:9>6I:97N696EI>K:86E68>INL=>8=EJIHI=:6C6ANI>86A;D8JHDCI=:HD8>6A9:I:GB>C6CIHD;

KJAC:G67>A>IN-E6I>6A6HH:HHB:CIHD;8DCI:MIJ6AKJAC:G67>A>ING:ANDC>C9>86IDGHIDG:EG:H:CI I=:HIGJ8IJG:HG:A6I>DCH=>EH6C9EGD8:HH:HI=6IBD7>A>O:G:HDJG8:HL>I=>C6HNHI:B"DA6C9 :I6A =6K:6HH:HH:9I=:8DCI:MIJ6AKJAC:G67>A>IND;BJC>8>E6A>I>:H>C(DGL6N7N 6EEAN>C<I=:-D8>6A0JAC:G67>A>IN#C9:M-D0# 6;I:GJII:G:I6A -D0#>H76H:9DC EG>C8>E6A8DBEDC:CI6C6ANH>HL=>8=G:9J8:HI=:6IIG>7JI:HD;696EI>K:86E68>IN>C:68=

BJC>8>E6A>INID6H8DG:I=6I8=6G68I:G>O:HKJAC:G67>A>ING:A6I>K:IDDI=:GBJC>8>E6A>I>:H HH=DLC>C ><JG:L=:C>CI:<G6I>C<I=:7>DE=NH>86A6C9HD8>6A9:I:GB>C6CIHD;

KJAC:G67>A>IN>I>H6AHDJH:;JAID9>HI>C<J>H=7:IL::C8JGG:CI6C9;JIJG:HI6I:HL=>8=;G6B:H I=:6HH:HHB:CI>CI:GBHD;H:CH>I>K>INIDH=DGII:GBH=D8@HDGADC<I:GBHIG:HHDGH)cG>:C :I6A L:G:6BDC<I=:;>GHIID:MEADG:I=:>CI:G68I>DC7:IL::C7>DE=NH>86A6C9HD8>6A EGD8:HH:HJH>C<6HE6I>6A_G6I=:GI=6C6EG:9>8I>K:_;G6B:LDG@N8DB7>C>C<

9>;;:G:CI>6A:MEDHJG:H:CH>I>K>IN6C9696EI>K:86E68>IN6II=:BJC>8>E6AA:K:AI=:NH=DL:9 I=6IKJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:K6G>:H<G:6IANL>I=>C(DGL6N68DJCIGN<:C:G6AAN 8DCH>9:G:9ID7:G:H>A>:CIIDI=:>BE68IHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:N9:BDCHIG6I>C<=DLI=:

G:A:K6C8:D;E6GI>8JA6G>C9>86IDGH8=6C<:HL>I=HE6I>6AH86A:6C99:<G::D;96I66<<G:<6I>DC )cG>:C6C9=:G8DAA:6<J:HH=DL:9I=6IKJAC:G67>A>IN6C9>IH86JH:H6G:EA68:76H:9&D86A

(27)

EA6CC:GH>C(DGL6NCDLG:<JA6GAN9DH>B>A6GLDG@IDK>HJ6A>O:L:6I=:G6C98A>B6I:G:A6I:9 G>H@H6C9B::IHI6IJIDGNG:FJ>G:B:CIHH::;DG:M6BEA:LLL@A>B6<>HCD

+/&#..#0!#-

!#->HA6G<:ANJC9:GHIDD96H6IDDA;DGI=:HIDG6<:6C96C6ANH>HD;FJ6CI>I6I>K:96I67JI

*6KADKH@6N6 =6H:M6B>C:9I=:8DCK:CI>DC6A6HHD8>6I>DCD;!#-L>I=FJ6CI>I6I>K:

B:I=D9H6C96G<J:HI=6I!#->HD;I:CCDI6HFJ6CI>I6I>K:6HB6CNEG68I>I>DC:GH6HHJB:H=:

HJ<<:HIHI=6II=:G:6G:`DE:C>C<HaI=6I:C67A:I=:JH:D;!#->CFJ6A>I6I>K:G:H:6G8=7N

>C8DGEDG6I>C<I=:HE6I>6A>IND;HD8>6AEGD8:HH:H'6EE>C<KJAC:G67>A>INI=:G:;DG:=6HI=:

EDI:CI>6AIDHJEEDGI8DAA67DG6I>K:EGD8:HH:H>CL=>8=9>K:GH:E6GI>8>E6CIH6JI=DG;A:M>7A:

HE6I>6AC6GG6I>K:HI=6I:MEADG:9>;;:G:CIEGD7A:BJC9:GHI6C9>C<H6H6B:6CHD;<:C:G6I>C<6 8DBBDCH=6G:9JC9:GHI6C9>C<

K:GN6EEA>86I>DCD;!#-G:FJ>G:H6II:CI>DCIDL=6IH=DJA97:G:EG:H:CI:96C9=DL .=:;JC96B:CI6AEGD7A:BD;!#->HI=6I`I=:LDGA9>H>C;>C>I:AN8DBEA:M7JI8DBEJI:G HNHI:BH6G:;>C>I:a&DC<A:N:I6A DCH:FJ:CIAN!#-6C6ANHIHBJHIHDB:=DL

!

/-:7+4<*7/;/3-,47)+8,7'2+9.+'88+882+394,;:13+7'(/1/9>

4*/,/+*',9+7 7+8943'3*#9',,47*#2/9.

(28)

A>B>II=:6BDJCID;9:I6>AI=6I>H86EIJG:9L=:C9:K:ADE>C<6<:D<G6E=>896I676H:6C9 8G:6I>C<K>HJ6A>O6I>DCH=D>8:H6G:B69:I=GDJ<=DJII=:EGD8:HH6C96AA!#-

G:EG:H:CI6I>DCH6G:C:8:HH6G>ANE6GI>6A7:86JH:I=:NBJHI><CDG:G:6ALDGA9;:6IJG:HI=6I6G:

IDD8DBEA:MDGDI=:GL>H:6B7><JDJH%L6C LG>I:H67DJII=:HJ7?:8I>K>IND;I=DH:

L=DJH:!#-6C9I=:9:8>H>DCH>CKDAK:9>CH>BEA>;N>C<HE6I>6ABD9:AHID7J>A9

G:EG:H:CI6I>DCHD;I=:LDGA9":G8G>I>86A:M6B>C6I>DCD;!#-EG68I>8:HH=DLHI=6I9>;;:G:CI

>C9>K>9J6AHH::I=:LDGA9>C9>;;:G:CIL6NH6C9L=6I>HA:;IDJID;6G:EG:H:CI6I>DC>HD;I:C

?JHI6H>BEDGI6CI6HL=6I>H>C8AJ9:9.=>HL6HI=:EG>B6GN8DC8:GCD;8G>I>86A<:D<G6E=:GH

>CI=:H9JG>C<I=:9:76I:H67DJI!#-6C9HD8>:IN-8=JJGB6C-=:EE6G9

"JB6C<:D<G6E=:GH<:C:G6AAN6<G::I=6I6AAD7H:GK6I>DCH6G:I=:DGNA69:C6C96AA68IDGH 6G:>C=:G:CIAN7>6H:97NI=:>G8JAIJG6A:ME:G>:C8:H6C9LDGA9K>:LH99N 86EIJG:9I=>H>9:67N8D>C>C<I=:E=G6H:`<:DDCIDAD<>86A8DCI>C<:C8NaL=>8=HJ<<:HIHI=6I

<:D<G6E=>8>C;DGB6I>DC>HC:>I=:GG><=ICDGLGDC<7JI9:I:GB>C:97NL=DL=6IL=:G:

L=:C6C9=DL>I>HB6EE:9.D96N6;I:GBDG:I=6C69:869:D;9:76I:6BDC<!#- H8=DA6GH6C9EG68I>I>DC:GH>I>H8DBBDCANJC9:GHIDD9I=6I!#-9D:HCDIEG:H:CI6K6AJ:

C:JIG6AK>:LD;I=:LDGA96C9>CHI:69H>BJAI6C:DJHAN9:H8G>7:HB6H@H6C99>HIDGIHG:6A>IN 6GDA6C H6G:HJAI!#-=6H:KDAK:9ID688DBBD96I:HJ7?:8I>K:6EEG6>H6AHD;

E=NH>86A6C9=JB6CG:6A>I>:H7N>C8DGEDG6I>C<FJ6A>I6I>K:G:H:6G8=B:I=D9H6C9B>M:996I6 INE:H'6CNI:8=C>86A76GG>:GHID96I6>CI:<G6I>DC=6K:;6AA:C6C9FJ6A>I6I>K:!#-=6H :B:G<:96H6EG68I>8:I=6I68@CDLA:9<:HI=:EDH>I>DC6A>IND;!#-6C9I=:@CDLA:9<:I=6I 86C7:EGD9J8:9L>I=>I1>AHDC

.=:EG68I>8:D;FJ6A>I6I>K:!#-EG>DG>I>O:HHI6@:=DA9:G>CKDAK:B:CI>CDG9:GID7GD69:C I=:@CDLA:9<:76H:L=:C8=6G68I:G>O>C<HE6I>6AEGD7A:BH#I>H6HHJB:9I=6I7:II:G

9:8>H>DCH6G:>BEA:B:CI:9L>I=A:HH8DC;A>8I6C9BDG:HJ88:HHL=:CHI6@:=DA9:GH9G>K:

I=:B'86AA6C9JCC .67A:8DBE6G:H8DCK:CI>DC6A6C9FJ6A>I6I>K:;DGBHD;

DG:M6BEA:HI=6I9:H8G>7:I=>H:;;:8I>C!#-H::G6BEIDC "6GA:N %L6C %N:B 6C9>I@:C6C9'>8=:A

(29)

!#-EG68I>8:DI=6G:6HHD8>6I:9L>I=<G6E=>86AG:EG:H:CI6I>DCH>:B6EH I=6I=:AE 9:8>H>DCB6@:GHJC9:GHI6C96C9B6C6<:=JB6C68I>K>I>:H"DL:K:GI=:DJI8DB:HD;I=:

G:HE:8I>K:EG68I>8:H9>;;:G6C96G:68=>:K:9I=GDJ<=8DCIG6HI>C<6EEGD68=:H96I6>CEJIH B:I=D9H6C9G:EG:H:CI6I>DCHD;HE68:'J8=A>@:8DCK:CI>DC6A!#-EG68I>8:FJ6A>I6I>K:

!#-E:GI6>CHIDI=:B:6HJG:B:CI6C6ANH>H6C99>HEA6ND;96I67JI>IH::@HH>IJ6I:9

JC9:GHI6C9>C<HD;HD8>6A6C9:CK>GDCB:CI6AEGD7A:BHG6I=:GI=6CHI6I>HI>86A9:H8G>EI>DCHDG

<:C:G6A>O67A:EG:9>8I>DCH+J6A>I6I>K:!#-696EIH:M>HI>C<<:DHE6I>6AI:8=C>FJ:H;DGI=:

>CI:GEG:I>K:6C6ANH>HD;<:D<G6E=>8>C;DGB6I>DC_L=>8=86C7::MEG:HH:96HC6GG6I>K:H I:MIHE=DID<G6E=H9G6L>C<HK>9:DH6C96C>B6I>DCH_>CDG9:GIDG:EG:H:CIE:DEA:cH

`A>K:9:ME:G>:C8:Ha%L6C 1=:G:8DCK:CI>DC6A!#-G:A>:HDC6B6HI:GND;

HE6I>6AH8>:C8:I:8=C>FJ:HD7?:8I>K:L6NHD;@CDL>C<6C9EDH>I>K>HIB:I=D9H;DG9:8>H>DC B6@>C<FJ6A>I6I>K:!#-6II:BEIHIDBD9:A=JB6CG:6HDC>C<G:AN>C<DCFJ6A>I6I>K:G:H:6G8=

B:I=D9H6C9EGDBDI>C<HJ7?:8I>K:L6NHD;@CDL>C<I=6IG:HJAI>CBDG:>C8AJH>K:EDA>8N

>CI:GK:CI>DCHDE:6C9ALDD9

$'(1+ 425'7/8438(+9<++3)43;+39/43'1#'3*6:'1/9'9/;+#

43;+39/43'1# !:'1/9'9/;+#

5574').

&89-8?7

ME:GI9G>K:C76H:9DC6<<G:<6I:9

>C9>86IDGH

8<<86=9

!J>9:97NI=:EG:;:G:C8:H6C9K6AJ:H D;AD86AA:K:A68IDGH

'9' *:<.;2*7;9*<2*52<A

>H8G:I:D7?:8IH8DCI>CJDJH;>:A9H G6HI:G8:AAH6C9I=:>G6IIG>7JI:H

87*:<.;2*7;9*<2*52<A

DBEA:M8DCC:8I>DCH=JB6C:ME:G>:C8:

8DAA:8I>K:B:6C>C<H

+9.4*8

.-=,<2>.*7*5A;2;

AJHI:G9:I:8I>DC9:CH>IN6C9 9>HI6C8:B6E6A<:7G6G:<G:HH>DC

7-=,<2>.*7*5A;2;

-JGK:NH>CI:GK>:LH;D8JH<GDJEH

<:D8D9>C<<:DI6<<>C<IG>6C<JA6I>DC

#)'1+ .7.:*52B.;58,*5>*:2*<287

JID8DGG:A6I>DC8D:;;>8>:CIH

<:D<G6E=>86AANL:><=I:9G:<G:HH>DC

691*;2B.;27<.:*,<287;*,:8;;;,*5.;

'JAI>9>B:CH>DC6AK>HJ6A>O6I>DCHE6I>6A I:BEDG6AI=:B6I>8C6K><6I>DC

:9)42+8

*<*>2;=*52B*<287

!:C:G6A>O6I>DCHI6I>HI>86A G:EG:H:CI6I>DCH

78?5.-0.9:8-=,<287

MEA6C6I>DCI=:DG:I>86A G:EG:H:CI6I>DCH

(30)

1=:C>I8DB:HID6HH:HH>C<KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:8DCK:CI>DC6A!#-

HJBB6G>O:H>BEDGI6CI9:BD<G6E=>8:CK>GDCB:CI6A6C9HD8>D:8DCDB>88DC9>I>DCH:<

*G:HIDC:I6A L=:G:6HFJ6A>I6I>K:!#-8DC8:CIG6I:HDCI=:@CDLA:9<:6C9

:ME:G>:C8:D;EDEJA6I>DCH6IG>H@:<.:B7D #CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC#=6K:HDJ<=IID 8DB7>C:I=DH:6EEGD68=:H76H:9DCI=:6HHJBEI>DCI=6IB>M:9B:I=D9HD;;:G<G:6I:G

>CH><=IH>CIDI=:8DBEA:M>IN6C99NC6B>8HD;=JB6C:CK>GDCB:CI6A>CI:G68I>DCH DG :M6BEA:>C6HIJ9NI=6I:MEADG:9=DLBJAI>EA:HIG:HHDGH6;;:8IKJAC:G67>A>IN)G>:C:I6A B6EE:9>C9>86IDGHD;I=::MEDHJG:H:CH>I>K>IN6C9696EI>K:86E68>IND;#C9>6C;6GB EDEJA6I>DCHID7DI=8A>B6I:8=6C<:6C9<AD76A>O6I>DC.=:6JI=DGHHJE:G>BEDH:9I=:>G 8DBEDH>I:B6ED;KJAC:G67>A>INID8A>B6I:8=6C<:DK:G6CDI=:GH=DL>C<KJAC:G67>A>INID

<AD76A:8DCDB>88=6C<:6H6B:6CHD;>AAJHIG6I>C<I=::;;:8ID;BJAI>EA:HIG:HH:H.=:N 6J<B:CI:9I=::CHJ>C<B6EL>I=86H:HIJ9>:HJH>C<HJGK:NH6C9>CI:GK>:LHID>CI:GEG:II=:

HE6I>6AG:A6I>DCH=>EHI=:ND7H:GK:96C97:II:G:MEA6>CI=:>CI:G68I>DCD;<AD76A>O6I>DC6C9 8A>B6I:DCI=:A>K:A>=DD9HD;E6GI>8JA6GAD86AEDEJA6I>DCH.=:>GB:I=D98DGG:8IH;DGDC:D;

I=:A>B>I6I>DCHD;>C9>86IDG76H:96EEGD68=:HL=>8=6G:8DBBDCANJH:9>CHE6I>6A KJAC:G67>A>IN6HH:HHB:CIHN:I;6>AID69:FJ6I:ANG:EG:H:CI696EI>K:86E68>INN8DB7>C>C<

IDE9DLC6C97DIIDBJE6EEGD68=:HI=:6JI=DGHL:G:67A:ID688DJCI;DGI=:9NC6B>8 EGD8:HH:HI=6I>CI:G68I68GDHH<:D<G6E=>8H86A:H6C9>C;AJ:C8:KJAC:G67>A>INAD86AAN#C 6EEGD68=>C<I=:G:H:6G8=9:H><CD;I=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC#H6L6C::9IDK>:LKJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIH6H6EGD8:HHD;9:A>7:G6I>DC7:IL::C9>;;:G:CI696EI6I>DC68IDGHDC:I=6I

>C8DGEDG6I:H96I6;GDBBJAI>EA:H86A:H6C9JH:H6HJ>I:D;FJ6CI>I6I>K:6C9FJ6A>I6I>K:

B:I=D9HIDEG>DG>I>O:HI6@:=DA9:GE:GHE:8I>K:HDC:K:GNI=>C<;GDBEGD7A:B9:;>C>I>DCID I=:K6A>96I>DCD;G:HJAIH

(31)

,-,"-#!(

.=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC>H68DBE>A6I>DCD;;>K:E6E:GHI=6I>C9>K>9J6AAN699G:HHH:E6G6I:

6HE:8IHD;BNDK:G6G8=>C<G:H:6G8=FJ:HI>DC#=6K:CDI:BEADN:96H>C<A:B:I=D9DAD<N G6I=:G#=6K:JH:97DI=FJ6A>I6I>K:6C9FJ6CI>I6I>K:B:I=D9H6H6EEGDEG>6I:IDI=:

>C9>K>9J6AHJ7FJ:HI>DCH68=E6E:G>H6HI6C96ADC:LDG@I=6I>C8AJ9:H>C;DGB6I>DC67DJI I=:I=:DGN6C9B:I=D9DAD<NG:A:K6CIID>IHHE:8>;>8D7?:8I>K:H(:K:GI=:A:HHI=:8D=:G:C8:

D;I=:E6E:GHI6@:CID<:I=:GHI:BH;GDB6IG6CH9>H8>EA>C6GN;G6B:LDG@76H:9DC>CI:<G6A I=:DGN.=:C:MIILDH:8I>DCH9:H8G>7:BN>CI:AA:8IJ6AE6I=IDL6G9>CI:<G6AI=:DGN6C9I=:

G6I>DC6A:;DGEG>DG>I>O>C<6IG6CH9>H8>EA>C6GN6EEGD68=.=>HDK:GK>:LD;I=:G:H:6G8=9:H><C 8DC8AJ9:HL>I=6H:8I>DC9:H8G>7>C<I=:96I68DAA:8I:99JG>C<BN8DJGH:D;HIJ9N

'.."),.#& )/(.#)(-

.=:EG:86JI>DC6GNEG>C8>EA:>H69:8>H>DCB6@>C<HIG6I:<NI=6I<J>9:HEDA>8NB6@:GH6C9 DI=:GHD8>6A68IDGH>CH>IJ6I>DCHL=:G:I=:EDHH>7>A>IND;=6GB:M>HIHN:I8DBEA:I:H8>:CI>;>8

@CDLA:9<:DCI=:B6II:G>HA68@>C<.=:8DC8:EI>H:M:BEA>;>:97N86JI>DC6GN6E=DG>HBH A>@:`7:II:GH6;:I=6CHDGGNa6C9L6H;DGB6AAN9:;>C:97N6H:A;6EED>CI:9<GDJED;

H8>:CI>HIHE=>ADHDE=:GHA6LN:GH6C968I>K>HIH8DC8:GC:9L>I=I=:>BE68IHD;=JB6C 68I>K>I>:HDCI=::CK>GDCB:CI6C9=JB6C=:6AI=.=:;>C6AHI6I:B:CI;GDBI=:>G

1>C<HEG:69DC;:G:C8:DCI=:*G:86JI>DC6GN*G>C8>EA:H6NHI=6I`L=:C6C68I>K>ING6>H:H I=G:6IHD;=6GBID=JB6C=:6AI=DGI=::CK>GDCB:CIEG:86JI>DC6GNB:6HJG:HH=DJA97:

I6@:C:K:C>;HDB:86JH:6C9:;;:8IG:A6I>DCH=>EH6G:CDI;JAAN:HI67A>H=:9H8>:CI>;>86AANa .=:EG:86JI>DC6GNEG>C8>EA:8DCH>HIHD;;DJG9>G:8I>K:H

I6@>C<EG:K:CI6I>K:68I>DC>CI=:;68:D;JC8:GI6>CIN

H=>;I>C<7JG9:CHDCIDEGDEDC:CIHD;EDI:CI>6AAN=6GB;JA68I>K>I>:H

.=>H8DC;:G:C8:IDD@EA68:$6CJ6GN6I1>C<HEG:69>C,68>C:1>H8DCH>CI=:$D=CHDC DJC96I>DCcH:9J86I>DC6A8:CI:G9:KDI:9IDI=:;G:::M8=6C<:D;8DCHIGJ8I>K:6C9EJGEDH:;JA>9:6H.=:

8DBEA:I:I:MID;I=:1>C<HEG:69DCH:CHJH-I6I:B:CIDCI=:*G:86JI>DC6GN*G>C8>EA:>H6K6>A67A:6I LLLH:=CDG<L>C<=IBA

(32)

:MEADG>C<6L>9:G6C<:D;6AI:GC6I>K:HIDEDHH>7AN=6GB;JA68I>DCH6C9

>C8G:6H>C<EJ7A>8E6GI>8>E6I>DC>C9:8>H>DCB6@>C<

'6CN=6K:6G<J:9I=6I8A>B6I:8=6C<:>H6C6EEGDEG>6I:86H:;DGI=:6EEA>86I>DCD;I=:

EG:86JI>DC6GNEG>C8>EA::<"6AA:<6II:&:BE:GI)EE:C=:>B:G 6C9

>C9::9(DGL6NcH*A6CC>C<6C9J>A9>C<8I>CKD@:H>I6H69:8>H>DCB6@>C<HIG6I:<N;DG 696EI6I>DC,/ B6>CHIG:6B>C<9>H8JHH>DCDCE6<:

#C68DCI:MID;<GDL>C<6L6G:C:HH67DJIB6?DG:CK>GDCB:CI6A>HHJ:HHJ8=6H68>9G6>C DODC:9:EA:I>DC6C98A>B6I:8=6C<:_6AAD;L=>8=6G:8=6G68I:G>O:97N8DBEA:M>IN JC8:GI6>CIN6C9EDI:CI>6AANH:K:G:G>H@H;DG7DI==JB6CH6C9:8DHNHI:BH_ JCIDL>8O6C9 ,6K:IO 6HH:HH:9I=:H8>:CI>;>8>CEJIHIDEDA>8>:H9>G:8I:96I:CK>GDCB:CI6AEGD7A:BH .=:NEDH>I:9I=6IL=>A:`EDA>8>:H86CCDADC<:G7:6HHJB:9ID7:76H:9DCH8>:CI>;>8

>C;DGB6I>DC:C9DL:9L>I=6=><=9:<G::D;8:GI6>CINaG>H@B6C6<:B:CI9:8>H>DCH9DCDI>C

;68I`G:FJ>G:I=::A>B>C6I>DCD;JC8:GI6>CIN7JIG6I=:G>IH:;;:8I>K:B6C6<:B:CIa JCIDL>8O6C9,6K:IO #CI=:DG>O>C<67DJII=:>CI:G68I>DCD;HNHI:BH JC8:GI6>CI>:H6C99:8>H>DCHI6@:HI=:N9:;>C:96C:L6EEGD68=;DG699G:HH>C<<AD76A :CK>GDCB:CI6AEGD7A:BH86AA:9EDHICDGB6AH8>:C8: JCIDL>8O6C9,6K:IO

%J=C 9:H8G>7:9I=:`CDGB6AaK>:LD;H8>:C8:6H7:>C<;D8JH:9DCHDAK>C<

EJOOA:HI=6I6G:6HHJB:9ID=6K:HDAJI>DCHI=JHB6@>C<HNHI:BHJC8:GI6>CINADL(DGB6A H8>:C8:>HINE>86AAN68JG>DH>IN9G>K:C:M:G8>H:;G::D;:MI:GC6A>CI:G:HIHHDI=:9:8>H>DC HI6@:H6G:6AHDADL JCIDL>8O6C9,6K:IO 6G<J:I=6II=:EDA>8NC::9H 6HHD8>6I:9L>I=:CK>GDCB:CI6AG>H@H86CCDI7:B:I7NI=:EJOOA:HDAK>C<:M:G8>H:HD;

CDGB6AH8>:C8:7:86JH:I=:H8>:C8:D;:CK>GDCB:CI6A8=6C<:>H>HHJ:9G>K:C6C9I=JH K6AJ:A69:C 6C9GD7JHIHDAJI>DCH6G:CDI<J6G6CI::96C96G:I=:G:;DG:JC8:GI6>C ":C8:

:CK>GDCB:CI6AH8>:C8:>HEDHICDGB6A*DHICDGB6AH8>:C8:*(- >H6`B:I=D9DAD<ND;

>CFJ>GNa6EEGDEG>6I:>CH>IJ6I>DCHL=:G:I=:HI6@:H6G:=><=JC8:GI6>CI>:HA6G<:6C9 9:8>H>DCHJG<:CI.JGCE:CCN:I6A *(-:B7G68:H8DBEA:M>IN6C9JC8:GI6>CIN

(33)

DCI=:6HHJBEI>DCI=6I8DBEA:M>HHJ:HL>AAC:K:G7:;JAANJC9:GHIDD97:;DG:68I>DC>HI6@:C IDB6C6<:I=:B.=JH>;I=:EG:86JI>DC6GNEG>C8>EA:>H6;.7;2+5.G>H@B6C6<:B:CIHIG6I:<N

;DG8A>B6I:8=6C<:I=:C*(->HI=:DCAN,:.-2+5.G>H@B6C6<:B:CIHIG6I:<N7:86JH:

>GG:K:GH>7A:=6GB>HA>@:ANIDD88JG7:;DG:JC8:GI6>CI>:H67DJIEGD?:8I:98A>B6I:8=6C<:86C7:

:A>B>C6I:9

*(-8=6C<:HI=:BD9:AD;H8>:C8:;GDB;DGB6A>O:99:9J8I>DCID>CI:G68I>K:9>6AD<

I=GDJ<=I=:>CIGD9J8I>DCD;6C:MI:C9:9E::G8DBBJC>INI=6I:K6AJ6I:HH8>:CI>;>896I6 6ADC<H>9:`:MI:C9:9;68IHa>:K6AJ:?J9<B:CIH6C9DI=:GHJ7?:8I>K:8DCH>9:G6I>DCH >C DG9:GIDB6@:9:8>H>DCH67DJI8DBEA:MEGD7A:BH JCIDL>8O6C9,6K:IO .=:

:C=6C8:9>CKDAK:B:CID;HI6@:=DA9:GHI=GDJ<=I=:8DEGD9J8I>DCD;EDA>8NG:A:K6CI H8>:C8:>HL=6I6IIG68I:9B:ID*(-*6GI>8>E6I>DCD;I=>H@>C9EGDK>9:H688:HHID67GD69:G

@CDLA:9<:76H:I=6I>CIJGC>BEGDK:HEGD7A:B9:;>C>I>DCHIG:C<I=:CHI=:6C6ANH>H6C9

>C8G:6H:H688:EI6C8:D;I=:G:HJAIH#I>H>C8G:6H>C<ANG:8D<C>O:9I=6I8A>B6I:8=6C<:

:C8DBE6HH:HHD8>6A8JAIJG6A6C9EDA>I>86A7:A>:;HI=6IG:HJAI>C9>;;:G:CIJC9:GHI6C9>C<HI=:

EGD7A:B6C9>IHHDAJI>DC"JAB:)G>:C%6=6C:I6A .=:H:BJAI>EA:

6C9H>IJ6I:9 @CDLA:9<:HG:;A:8I>C9>K>9J6AHcHJ7?:8I>K:EDH>I>DCH67DJID7?:8I>K:9:I6>AH 6C986C7:8DB:76GG>:GHID9:8>H>DCB6@>C<L=:CI=:N6G:CDI69:FJ6I:ANI6@:C>CID 688DJCI'DH:G6C9@HIGDB!>;;DG9

99N 9:8DCHIGJ8I:9H>IJ6I:9@CDLA:9<:>CI=:8DCI:MID;HJHI6>C67>A>IN6C9 8DC8AJ9:9I=6I>I>H>BEDHH>7A:ID6KD>9:>I=:GD7?:8I>K>IN>C9:I:8I>C<`L=6II=:G:>HaDG HJ7?:8I>K>IN>C9>H8:GC>C<`=DL>IB><=I7:a":LG>I:H`I=:H6B:E=:CDB:C686C7:

ADD@:96I;GDBBJAI>EA:E:GHE:8I>K:H6IBJAI>EA:H86A:H]6C97:H>BJAI6C:DJHANK6AJ:9 9>;;:G:CIAN688DG9>C<ID9>;;:G:C8:H>C8>G8JBHI6C8:a99N ":C8::K:GN

>C9>K>9J6A7G>C<H;DGI=6C99>H8ADH:H69>;;:G:CI6C9E6GI>6A;68:ID;G:6A>IN76H:9DCL=D I=:N6G:6C9=DLI=:NH::I=:LDGA999N 86AAHI=>HI=:<:DDCIDAD<>86A 8DCI>C<:C8NL=>8=6HH:GIHI=6I=JB6C@CDLA:9<:>H9:I:GB>C:97N6H:ID;>CI:GC6A

(34)

7DJC96GN8DC9>I>DCH8DCH>HI>C<D;HJ7?:8I>K:;>AI:GHI=6I>CI:GEG:I6H:ID;:MI:GC6A7DJC96GN 8DC9>I>DCH76H:9DCI=:HE6I>6A6C9I:BEDG6A8=6G68I:G>HI>8HD;I=:8DCI:MI#CDI=:GLDG9H 6C>C9>K>9J6AcHEG68I>86ADG>:CI6I>DCID6C>HHJ:>H76H:9DC6`8DB7>C6I>DCD;96I6

@CDLA:9<:6C9B:6C>C<I=:>CI:GG:A6I>DCHD;L=>8=>CKDAK:CDCA>C:6G>CI:G68I>DCD;

>C9J8I>K:6C99:9J8I>K:G:6HDC>C<EGD8:HH:Ha99N 99NcH6C6ANH>HD;H>IJ6I:9

@CDLA:9<:>H9:G>K:9;GDB>CI:<G6AI=:DGN1>A7:GH7?TGC"6G<:CH L=>8=

6AHDJC9:GE>CHI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC

#CI:<G6AI=:DGNEGDK>9:H68DC8:EIJ6A;G6B:LDG@;DGEJGEDH:;JAG:8JGH>K:96I6 :MEADG6I>DC;GDBBJAI>EA:K>:LED>CIH76H:9DCI=:;JH>DCD;DCIDAD<N:E>HI:BDAD<N6C9 B:I=D9DAD<NH7?TGC"6G<:CH99N #I>H8DC8:EIJ6A>O:96HFJ69G6CIHI=6I G:EG:H:CI;DJG76H>8E:GHE:8I>K:H;GDBL=>8=6CNI=>C<86C7:HIJ9>:9:ME:G>:C8:8JAIJG:

7:=6K>DG6C9HNHI:BH ><JG: .=:FJ69G6CIH;DGB6II=:>CI:GH:8I>DCD;ILDEDA6G>I>:H I=6I9:H8G>7:I=:HJ7?:8I>K:6C9D7?:8I>K:6C9I=:>C9>K>9J6A6C98DAA:8I>K:9J6A>I>:HD;

E=:CDB:C6'DG:>BEDGI6CIANI=:>C9>K>9J6AFJ69G6CIH9DCDIHI6C9>C>HDA6I>DC7JI G6I=:G>CI:<G6I:6C9H=6E:DC:6CDI=:G#CI:<G6AI=:DGN>H6B:I6I=:DGNI=6IJC>;>:HILD DEEDH>C<E=>ADHDE=>:HD;H8>:C8:H8>:CI>;>8G:6A>HB6C9BD9:GC>HII=>C@>C<DCI=:DC:

=6C96C9HD8>6A8DCHIGJ8I>K>HB6C9EDHIBD9:GC>HBDCI=:DI=:G1>A7:G .=:G:6A>HIDCIDAD<NH6NHI=6II=:LDGA9>H67HDAJI:6C9H=DJA97:HIJ9>:9I=GDJ<=

EDH>I>K>HIB:I=D9DAD<>:HI=6IL>AAA:69:E>HI:BDAD<>86AANIDJC>K:GH6AIGJI=H,:6A>HB<6K:

G>H:IDJCEG:8:9:CI:9H8>:CI>;>8@CDLA:9<:I:8=CDAD<>86AEGD<G:HH6C9B6I:G>6AL:6AI=>C I=:1:HI:GCLDGA9 9JG>C<I=:I=8:CIJGN7JI;68:98G>I>8>HB;GDBEDHIBD9:GC>HIHL=D FJ:HI>DC:9I=:JC>K:GH6A6EE:6AD;1:HI:GCK6AJ:H6C96G<J:9>CHI:69I=6IG:6A>IN>H>C;68I AD86AAN8DCHIGJ8I:9:CIDC6C9G6>7 DCHIGJ8I>K>HIHJH:B:I=D9HI=6I6G:

:MEADG6I>K:6C9>CI:GEG:I6I>K:L=>8=G:HJAIH>C@CDLA:9<:I=6I>H6AL6NHH>IJ6I:91>A7:G H6LEDHIBD9:GC>HB6H6EDH>I>K:>CI:AA:8IJ6A9:K:ADEB:CI>CI=:H:CH:I=6I>I 9:8DCHIGJ8I:9DEEG:HH>K:=>:G6G8=>:H:BE=6H>O:98DCI:MI6C9:B7G68:9EAJG6A>HI>8K6AJ:H

(35)

7JI>C9D>C<HD>I8JII=:H:E:GHE:8I>K:H;G::;GDB6CN<GDJC9>C<>CD7?:8I>K:G:6A>INDG JC>K:GH6A>IN&>@:8G>I>86AG:6A>HBDAA>:G >CI:<G6AI=:DGN6II:BEIHIDG:>CIGD9J8:I=:

>9:6D;JC>K:GH6A>IN>CIDH8>:C8:L=>A:G:I6>C>C<I=:EDHIBD9:GCJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;

9>;;:G:C8:6C99>K:GH>IN#IH::@HID>CI:<G6I:D7?:8I>K:6C9HJ7?:8I>K:L6NHD;

JC9:GHI6C9>C<I=:LDGA9>CID68D=:G:CI:E>HI:BDAD<>86A;G6B:LDG@I=6IG:HEDC9HIDI=:

L6NHE:DEA:68IJ6AAN:ME:G>:C8:G:6A>IN

#CI:<G6AI=:DGNG:8D<C>O:HI=6IHJ7?:8I>K:E:GHE:8I>K:H6G:A>C@:9IDB6CNA>C:HD;

=JB6C9:K:ADEB:CII=6I>C8AJ9:8D<C>I>K::BDI>DC6A>CI:GE:GHDC6A6C9BDG6A86E68>I>:H

#CI:<G6AI=:DG>HI-:6CH7?TGC"6G<:CH LG>I:H`I=:H:86E68>I>:H6G:D;I:C I=DJ<=ID;6HI=:BJAI>EA:>CI:AA><:C8:HI=6I:68=E:GHDC=6HI=:>9:67:>C<I=6I:68=D;JH

>HBDG:9:K:ADE:9>CHDB:6G:6HI=6CDI=:GHa.=:9:K:ADEB:CI6AA>C:H6G:>BEDGI6CIID

>CI:<G6AI=:DGN7:86JH:I=:N>9:CI>;N9>HI>C8I6HE:8IHD;:68=FJ69G6CII=6I9:BDCHIG6I:

:KDAJI>DC6C9EDI:CI>6A7JII=:N6G:CDII=:;D8JHD;I=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC,6I=:GBN>CI:G:HI

>H>CI=:FJ69G6CIHI=:BH:AK:HL=>8=G:EG:H:CII=:DCIDAD<>86A6C9:E>HI:BDAD<>86A 9>;;:G:C8:H7:IL::CI=:E=NH>86A6C9HD8>6AH8>:C8:H6HL:AA6H9>K>9:H>CHD8>6AI=:DGN CIDC>D6C9A6G@ #=6K:9G6LCDC>CI:<G6AI=:DGNI=GDJ<=DJII=>H9>HH:GI6I>DCID

/-:7+39+-7'19.+47>:8+86:'*7'39894+=51'/3.4<

*/,,+7+39,47284,034<1+*-+)42(/3+/394')4.+7+39<.41+

(36)

8G:6I:6HE68:;DG:C<6<:B:CII=6I>9:CI>;>:HL=6IB6II:GHBDHIL>I=>CI=::MI:C9:9E::G 8DBBJC>I>:HD;*(-NG:8D<C>O>C<I=6II=:G:6G:9>;;:G:CIJC9:GHI6C9>C<HD;8A>B6I:

8=6C<:I=6ID;I:C8DB:68GDHH6H7>C6GN6C9EDA6G>O>C<>:7:A>:K>C<6C9CDI7:A>:K>C<>C 6CI=GDED<:C>88A>B6I:8=6C<:6C6ANI>86A:BE=6H>HDCDJI8DB:KH8DCI:MIJ6AKJAC:G67>A>IN EG>DG>I>O6I>DCD;I:8=C>86AHDAJI>DCHDK:GHIGJ8IJG6A8=6C<:H >CI:<G6AI=:DGN86C7:JH:9ID 8DCC:8I8A>B6I:>C;DGB6I>DCIDDI=:G=JB6CEGD8:HH:H6C9=6GBDC>O:I=:BJAI>EA:

E:GHE:8I>K:HI=6I6G:>C=:G:CIID<GDJE9:8>H>DCB6@>C<

.,(-#-#*&#(,#.3('#2'."))&)!3

#CI:<G6I>C<BJAI>EA:DCIDAD<>:H;DGI=:EJGEDH:D;:;;:8I>K:9:8>H>DCB6@>C<86AAH;DG C:LL6NHD;8DC9J8I>C<G:H:6G8=6C98DBBJC>86I>C<>IHG:HJAIH)G>:C A>B6I:

8=6C<:>H68DBEA:MHD8>6A>HHJ:C:8:HH>I6I>C<6C6EEGD68=I=6I>HEGD7A:BDG>:CI:96 B:I=D9DAD<NI=6I>HI6>ADG:9IDI=:8DCI:MI6C96EGD8:HHI=6I>H>CI:G68I>K:6C9G:;A:M>K:

'6JH:G:I6A #CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC#=6K:I=:G:;DG:I6@:C6IG6CH9>H8>EA>C6GN6EEGD68=

JH>C<FJ6A>I6I>K:6C9FJ6CI>I6I>K:B:I=D9H6I9>;;:G:CIHI6<:HD;I=:G:H:6G8=

.G6CH9>H8>EA>C6G>IN86C7:9:;>C:96H6`G:;A:M>K:]EG>C8>EA:6>B>C<6II=:HDAJI>DCDG IG6CH>I>DCD;HD8>:I6AEGD7A:BH]7N9>;;:G:CI>6I>C<6C9>CI:<G6I>C<@CDLA:9<:;GDB K6G>DJHH8>:CI>;>86C9HD8>:I6A7D9>:HD;@CDLA:9<:a&6C<:I6A #I>H

9>HI>C<J>H=:97N>IH ;D8JHDCG:6ALDGA9EGD7A:BH G:HEDCH>K:B:I=D9DAD<NH:A:8I>DC 6C9 8DAA67DG6I>K:@CDLA:9<:<:C:G6I>DC7:IL::CG:H:6G8=:GH6C9HI6@:=DA9:GH1>8@HDC :I6A H68DCH:FJ:C8:I=DH:;:6IJG:HG:EG:H:CII=:I=G::9G>K>C<EG>C8>EA:H7:=>C9 I=:B:I=D9DAD<>86A9:H><CD;I=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC

.=:G:6ALDGA9EGD7A:B699G:HH:9>CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC>H=DL>C;DGB6I>DC67DJI

>BE68IH6C9KJAC:G67>A>IN86C7:8DBBJC>86I:9>C6B6CC:GI=6I;68>A>I6I:H696EI6I>DC

<>K:CBJAI>EA:E:G8:EI>DCH6C9L6NHD;@CDL>C<.=:8DBEA:M>IND;8A>B6I:8=6C<:=6H

<>K:CG>H:IDI=:9:K:ADEB:CID;HE:8>6A>O:97DJC96GNH:GK>8:H6>B:96I9:8>H>DCB6@:GH

(37)

;DGI=::MEG:HHEJGEDH:D;>CI:GEG:I>C<H8>:CI>;>8G:HJAIH6C9;G6B>C<EDA>8NDEI>DCH'DH:G 0D<:A:I6A "DL:K:G9:HE>I:I=:6K6>A67>A>IND;7DJC96GNH:GK>8:HI=6I9:A>K:G EDA>8NG:A:K6CI>C;DGB6I>DCI=:G:>HA>IIA::K>9:C8:D;EDA>I>86A68I>DCDC696EI6I>DCID96I:

'DH:G6C9@HIGDB =><=A><=IB6CN:MEA6C6I>DCH;DGHJ8=A>B>I:968I>DC

>C8AJ9>C<I=:`9::EAN=:A9K6AJ:H6C97:A>:;HI=6I>C;AJ:C8:=DLE:DEA:E:G8:>K:>CI:GEG:I 6C9I=>C@67DJIG>H@H6C9I=:>GB6C6<:B:CIaJGG:CIJC9:GHI6C9>C<D;I=:76GG>:GHID 696EI6I>DCHJ<<:HIHI=6I8A>B6I:8=6C<:>H9>;;>8JAIID<G6HE;DGBDHIA6N6J9>:C8:H7:86JH:

>I>H;JC96B:CI6AAN6C6B7><JDJHEGD7A:BI=6I>H:6H>ANIGJBE:97NBDG:9>G:8I:ME:G>:C8:H

!>;;DG9,:H:G:I6A #I=:G:;DG:H:IDJIID9:K:ADEC:LHIG6I:<>:H;DG6HH:HH>C<

KJAC:G67>A>IN76H:9DCI=::ME:G>:C8:H6C9K6AJ:HD;9>K:GH:68IDGH>C6C:;;DGIIDB6@:I=:

G:HJAI>C<>C;DGB6I>DCBDG:8G:9>7A:6C9H6A>:CI

6GDA6C 6G<J:HI=6I6HEGD7A:BH7:8DB:BDG:8DBEA:M6C9BDG:9>HI6CI>C I:GBHD;9>G:8I:ME:G>:C8:B:I=D9DAD<>86AEAJG6A>HB7:8DB:H6C>BEDGI6CIHIG6I:<N;DG 9:K:ADE>C<I=:IGJHII=6I>HC::9:9ID7G>9<:H8>:C8:6C9EDA>8N.=:EGD7A:B#H:IDJIID

>CK:HI><6I:8DJA97:699G:HH:9>C6CNCJB7:GD;6869:B>89>H8>EA>C:HI=6I;6AAJC9:GI=:

7GD69JB7G:AA6HD;:CK>GDCB:CI6AHIJ9>:H6C9G>H@8DBBJC>86I>DCI=:G:;DG:CDH>C<A:

B:I=D9DAD<N86C7:G:6HDC67ANEG:H8G>7:9#=6K:I=:G:;DG:7GD@:CBNEGD7A:B9DLC>CID 9>;;:G:CIE:GHE:8I>K:H:MEG:HH:96HG:H:6G8=FJ:HI>DCHI=6IA:C9I=:BH:AK:HIDH:E6G6I:A>C:H D;>CFJ>GNL>I=>C=JB6C<:D<G6E=N.67A: .=:JH:D;BJAI>EA:B:I=D9H6AADLHI=:

G:H:6G8=EGD7A:BID7::M6B>C:9;GDB9>;;:G:CIK>:LED>CIHG:HL:AA 6C9I=>H 6EEGD68==6H6AADL:9B:ID7:I=:BDHIG:HEDCH>K:IDI=:9>;;:G:CI8DCI:MIHJC9:G

>CK:HI><6I>DC

,:<6G9>C<EGD8:HHBDHII=:DG>HIH9:H8G>7:IG6CH9>H8>EA>C6GN8DAA67DG6I>DC6H@CDLA:9<:

<:C:G6I>DC7:IL::CG:H:6G8=:GH6C9HI6@:=DA9:GH&6C<:I6A'6JH:G:I6A 1>8@HDC:I6A .=:C:L@CDLA:9<:9:K:ADE:9>CI=>H9>HH:GI6I>DC=6HCDI7::C8D 8G:6I:97:86JH:I=:G:H:6G8=L6HCDI9:H><C:96H6JC>;>:986H:HIJ9N,6I=:GI=:

(38)

9>HH:GI6I>DC>H6I=:DG:I>86A:MEADG6I>DCD;=DLKJAC:G67>A>IN>H:MEG:HH:96C9I=::;;:8ID;

I=6I:MEG:HH>DCDCI=:INE:HD;696EI6I>DCHI=6I6G:>9:CI>;>:96C9EG>DG>I>O:9"DL:K:G 8G>I>86AH:A;G:;A:8I>DCL6H;DHI:G:9I=GDJ<=E6GI>8>E6CID7H:GK6I>DCHJGK:NH>CI:GK>:LH6C9 8DCI:MIJ6A6C6ANH>HL=>8=EGDK>9:9:K>9:C8:;DG=DLKJAC:G67>A>IN>CKDAK:H@CDLA:9<:

6HHD8>6I:9L>I=D7?:8I>K::MI:G>DG9>B:CH>DCHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:I=6I;D8JHDCC:<6I>K:

B6I:G>6ADJI8DB:H6HL:AA6HHJ7?:8I>K:>CI:G>DG9>B:CH>DCHI=6I699G:HHI=:B:6C>C<6C9 G:A:K6C8:D;I=DH:DJI8DB:H;DGHE:8>;>8>C9>K>9J6AH6C9<GDJEH'N>CI:G68I>DCL>I=

9>;;:G:CI696EI6I>DC68IDGH>C(DGL6N6C967GD69=6H:MEDH:9I=:6HHJBEI>DCHA>B>I6I>DCH 6C99>HIDGI>DCH8DCI6>C:9L>I=>C9>;;:G:CIJC9:GHI6C9>C<HD;KJAC:G67>A>IN>C8AJ9>C<I=:

E6GI>6A>IND;BNDLCJC9:GHI6C9>C<#CI=>HL6N#=6K:6EEGDM>B6I:9I=:G:;A:M>K>IN86AA:9

;DG7N6IG6CH9>H8>EA>C6GN6EEGD68=

$'(1+$.+-+4-7'5./)7+8+'7).6:+89/43897'*/9/438'3*2+9.4*8 :8+*/39./8*/88+79'9/43

,:H:6G8=+J:HI>DC ,:H:6G8=.G69>I>DC ,:H:6G8=':I=D9

1=6I6G:I=:EDI:CI>6AHD;6C9 A>B>IHIDJH>C<8A>B6I:H8:C6G>DH

>C696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<

CK>GDCB:CI6A!:D<G6E=N )7H:GK6I>DC6C96C6ANH>H

"DL9DE:DEA:JC9:GHI6C9 8A>B6I:8=6C<:6C9E:G8:>K:I=:

:;;:8I>K:C:HHD;9>;;:G:CI G:HEDCH:H

CK>GDCB:CI6A*:G8:EI>DC

:=6K>DG6A!:D<G6E=N -JGK:NHL>I=FJ6CI>I6I>K:

6C6ANH>H

1=N9DB6CNKJAC:G67>A>IN 6HH:HHB:CIH;6>AID:C<6<:

HI6@:=DA9:GH

0JAC:G67>A>IN-8>:C8: -E6I>6AC6ANH>H

>CI:GK>:LH6C9;D8JH

<GDJEH 1=6IB:I=D9H86C7:JH:9ID

>CI:<G6I:6C9G:EG:H:CI FJ6A>I6I>K:8DCI:MIJ6A

>C;DGB6I>DCL>I=FJ6CI>I6I>K:

H8:C6G>D76H:996I6

!:D<G6E=>8#C;DGB6I>DC -8>:C8:

+J6A>I6I>K:!#-

(39)

'.")-(.

.=>HH:8I>DC688DJCIH;DGI=:<:C:G6AB:I=D9H6C9@:N68IDGHI=6I>C;DGB:9I=>H 9>HH:GI6I>DC:I6>A:9>C;DGB6I>DC8DC8:GC>C<HE:8>;>8G:H:6G8=B:I=D9H6C996I6>H EGDK>9:9>CI=:>C9>K>9J6AE6E:GH

DG*6E:G#L=>8=699G:HH:HI=:JH:D;8A>B6I:H8:C6G>DH>C696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<#

E6GI>8>E6I:9>CC6I>DC6ALDG@H=DEH6C9AD86A;DGJBHL=:G:HI6@:=DA9:GHc>C;DGB6I>DCC::9H L:G:9>H8JHH:9EE:C9>M 6C9#G:K>:L:9EJ7A>89D8JB:CIH67DJIG:8DBB:C9:9IDDAH 6C9EDA>8N>CHIGJB:CIH;DG696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<II=:HI6GID;BN*=EGD<G6B>C I=:G:L6H6<:C:G6AH:CH:D;=DE:6BDC<AD86A9:8>H>DCB6@:GHI=6II=:9DLCH86A:9 H8:C6G>DHD;8A>B6I:8=6C<:7:>C<9:K:ADE:9;DGI=:<DK:GCB:CIcHD;;>8>6AEJ7A>8G:EDGIDC (DGL6NcHKJAC:G67>A>IN,/ E6<: LDJA9G:BDK:BJ8=D;I=:JC8:GI6>CIN67DJIEGD?:8I:9 8=6C<:H6II=:AD86AA:K:A.D<:I=:GL>I=I=::HI67A>H=B:CID;7DJC96GNH:GK>8:HA>@:I=:

A>B6I:-:GK>8::CI:G6C96H:8G:I6G>6I;DG8A>B6I:696EI6I>DCAD86A68IDGH7:A>:K:9I=6I BJ8=D;I=:<J:HHLDG@LDJA9HDDC7:G:BDK:9;GDB696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<.=>HA:9B:ID 6H@=DLH8:C6G>DHL:G:7:>C<JH:9>CDI=:G8DJCIG>:H6C9L=6I>BE68II=:(DGL:<>6C

>CK:HIB:CILDJA9A>@:AN=6K:DCAD86A696EI6I>DCEA6CC>C<

.=:<:C:H>HD;*6E:G##L6H68DJGH:DCEHN8=DAD<>86AE:GHE:8I>K:HDC8A>B6I:8=6C<:

I=6I#IDD@9JG>C<BNEGD<G6BD;HIJ9NHJGK:NEE:C9>M L6H69B>C>HI:G:9>C -:EI:B7:GIDJC9:G<G69J6I:HIJ9:CIHB6?DG>C<>C:8DCDB>8HDG7JH>C:HH

69B>C>HIG6I>DC6II=G::(DGL:<>6CJC>K:GH>I>:H/C>K:GH>IND;-I6K6C<:G-D<CD< ?DG96C:

/C>K:GH>INDAA:<:>C-D<C96A6C9#(DGL:<>6C-8=DDAD;'6C6<:B:CI>C)HAD.=:96I6 L:G:8DAA:8I:9;DG6C>CI:GC6I>DC6A8DBE6G6I>K:HIJ9NDHIGDB:I6A I=6IHDJ<=IID 8DCIGDA;DG8JAIJG6A9>;;:G:C8:H7NH:A:8I>C<G:HEDC9:CIHL>I=H>B>A6G:9J86I>DC6A

:ME:G>:C8:H.=:9:8>H>DCIDHJGK:NHIJ9:CIHB6?DG>C<>C:8DCDB>8HDG7JH>C:HH 69B>C>HIG6I>DCL6HI=DJ<=IIDB>C>B>O:I=:G>H@I=6II=:G:HEDC9:CIHLDJA97:

-::LLL@A>B6H:GK>8:H:CI:GCD

-::LLL@A>B6I>AE6HC>C<CD

Referanser

RELATERTE DOKUMENTER

To a large extent our current assessments of the ecosystem effects of climate change have been most effectively demonstrated by reference to the observed spatial and temporal changes

Four projects have been carried out: 'Improved local Winter Index to assess Maintenance Needs and Adaptation Costs in Climate Change Scenarios' (IRWIN), 'Pavement

Keywords: Cuba, climate change, economic change, vulnerability and adaptive capacity, social

To be fully aligned with the DNSH-requirement related to climate change adaptation, Maersk needs to demonstrate that climate risk assessments, and implementation of

34 Conflicts may also arise between Russia, Canada and Denmark over parts of the Arctic shelf, as it may be argued that the Lomonosov Ridge is an extension not only of

First, I engage with two of the cogs in the wheels of climate change—crimes that contribute to climate change and responses to climate change—by analysing the

This note discusses the issue of integration of climate change with the help of reviewing and comparing the regulative environment in three Nordic cases: adaptation to climate change

As climate change and gender focused research previously have described women’s vulnerability in relation to climate change (Djoudi et al., 2016, p. 249), this project