Do firms really share rents with their workers?

(1)

#L 6h4t +i@**) 5@hi +i?|t `| Aih `Lh!ihtq

#@_ @h}L*t

@?_ ki** B 5@*@?it

^|}

@) 2ff

FQUV/ WHDP 0 Xqlyhuvlwh gh Sdulv 4 Sdqwkhrq0Vruerqqh/ FUHVW0OPL dqg L]D1 Pdlolqj dgguhvv=

WHDP/ Pdlvrq ghv Vflhqfhv Hfrqrpltxhv/ Xqlyhuvlwh gh Sdulv 4 Sdqwkhrq0Vruerqqh/ 4390445 erxohydug gh o*Karslwdo/ :897: Sdulv Fhgh{ 46/ Iudqfh1 H0pdlo= pdujrolvCxqly0sdulv41iu1 Whohskrqh= .66 +34, 773: ;5951 Id{= .66 +34, 773: ;57:1

|Qruzhjldq Vfkrro ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Exvlqhvv Dgplqlvwudwlrq1 Pdlolqj dgguhvv= Ghsduwphqw ri Hfr0 qrplfv/ Qruzhjldq Vfkrro ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Exvlqhvv Dgplqlvwudwlrq/ Khoohyhlhq 63/ Q08368 Ehujhq/ Qruzd|1 H0pdlo= nmhoo1vdoydqhvCqkk1qr1 Whohskrqh= .7: +88, <8<6481 Id{= .7: +88, <8<8761

}Wkh dxwkrxuv zrxog olnh wr wkdqn Mrkq Derzg/ Sdxo Ghyhuhdx{/ Wruehuj Idofn/ Hulfd Jurvkhq/ Dqguhz Kloguhwk/ Wru Mdnre Nohwwh/ Iudqflv Nudpdu}/ Mduoh Prhq/ Dqguhz Rvzdog dqg Nhqqhwk Wurvnh/ dv zhoo dv sduwlflsdqwv dw vhplqduv dw Wkh Ddukxv Vfkrro ri Exvlqhvv/ wkh 5334 Vrflhw| ri Oderu Hfrqrplvwv phhwlqj/

wkh 5333 DHD dqqxdo phhwlqjv/ L]D/ Wkh Qruzhjldq Vfkrro ri Hfrqrplfv dqg Exvlqhvv Dgplqlvwudwlrq/

Vwdwlvwlfv Qruzd|/ VRIL dw wkh Xqlyhuvlw| ri Vwrfnkrop/ Xqlyhuvlwh gh Sdulv 4 Sdqwkhrq0Vruerqqh/ Xssvdod Xqlyhuvlw| dqg \run Xqlyhuvlw| +Wrurqwr,1

(2)

Mt|h@U|

`i ti 4@|Ui_ h4 Lh!ih T@?i* _@|@ uhL4 6h@?Ui @?_ Lh@) |L UL?t_ih LMtih@

|L?@**) i^@*i?| @*|ih?@|it |L |i )TL|itt |@| h4t t@hi ThL_U| 4@h!i| hi?|t |

|ih Lh!iht ? |i uLh4 Lu }ih @}it u|ih _LU4i?|?} |i 4@? t|)*3i_ u@U|c i ?_

|@| ?i|ih |i 4@? t|@|t|U@* i T*@?@|L?t E}hLT igiU|t ? hit_@*t @?_ 4i@thi4i?|

ihhLh ?Lh tiU|Lh@* tLU!t tii4 |L Mi hitTL?tM*i uLh |i LMtihi_ ULhhi*@|L? 5|@|t|U@*

iUL?L4U i T*@?@|L?t Ei?_L}i?i|) Lu ThL|tc L4||i_ @h@M*i M@tit ? |ih4t Lu ?__@*

ThL_U|i U@h@U|iht|Ut @hi t*}|*) 4Lhi tUUittu*c @t ?t|h4i?|@|L? hi_Uit |i t}

?U@?Ui *ii* ? 6h@?Ui |L HbI E@ @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i t|@h_@h_ ihhLh Lu |i it|4@|i Ai 4Lt| UL4T*i|i 4L_i*c | ?LMtihi_ i|ihL}i?i|) ? ML| |4i?@h@?| h4 UL4 Ti?t@|L? TL*U) @?_ |4i?@h@?| ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Utc ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it @?_ @ UL4T*i|i ti| Lu UL?|hL*t uLh Lh!ih LMtih@M*it @?_ tiU|Lh@* tLU!t hi?_iht |i ULiUi?|

?t}?U@?| uLh 6h@?Ui @?_ i@!i?t |t t}?U@?Ui uLh Lh@) At hit*| t ULihi?| |

|i 4*|*ii* M@h}@??} t|hU|hi uL?_ ? Lh@) @?_ |i Thiti?Ui Lu @ 4Lhi 4LM*i *@MLh uLhUi ? 6h@?Uic @*|L} | 4@) @*tL Mi _i |L ?tUi?| _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4

+it4i

Lt |*tL?t _it _L??iit *L?}|_?@*it @TT@hi**iit i4T*L)ihi4T*L)i TLh i@*ih _it i T*U@|L?t @*|ih?@|it @ *<)TL|iti ^i *it i?|hiThtit @iU T*t _i hi?|it _@?t *ih 4@hUi _i ThL_| *it T@h|@}i?| @iU *iht i4T*L)it tLt uLh4i _<? t@*@hi T*t i*ii Thit

@Lh _i4L?|hi *i u@| t|)*ti ?Lt |hLL?t î ? *it i T*U@|L?t t|@|t|ît Th?UT@*it Eihhih _i 4ithi i| igi|t _i }hLTi ? *it ULUt tiU|Lhi*t ?i ti4M*i?| i|hit *it hitTL?t@M*it _i Ui||i ULhhi*@|L? wit @*|ih?@|it t|@|t|îiUL?L4î Ei?_L}i?i|i _it ThL|tc M@t _i @h@M*it L4tit TLh *it U@h@U|iht|ît ThL_U|it ?__i**it L?| *i}ihi4i?| T*t _i tUUitc _@?t *@ 4ithi î *<?t|h4i?|@|L? hi_| *@ t}?U@||i _it ThL|t T@h |h@@**ih i? 6h@?Ui @ HbI E@ ?i @}4i?|@|L? _i *<iU@h| |)Ti wi 4L_i*i *i T*t UL4T*i|c @iU _i

*<i|ihL}i?i|i ?LMtihii _ U L|i _i *<i4T*L)ih i| _i *<i4T*L)ic @h@M*it ?t|h4i?|@*itc i| ? i?ti4M*i UL4T*i| _i @h@M*it _i UL?|h L*i TLh *it LMtih@M*it ?__i**it i| ULUt tiU|Lhi*t hi?_ *i ULiUi?| ?L?t}?U@|u TLh *@ 6h@?Ui i| hi_| *@ t}?U@||i TLh

*@ Lhi}i i hit*|@| it| ULihi?| @iU *it ?i}LU@|L?t UL**iU|it @ T*tiht ?i@

i? Lhi}i i| *@ Thiti?Ui _<?i uLhUi _i 4@?_<Lihi T*t 4LM*i i? 6h@?Uic 4@t ?i i T*U@|L? i? |ih4it _i 4@?^i _i _i}hit _i *Mih|i ?<it| T@t @ i U*hi

ki) `Lh_tG +i?| 5@h?}c @|Ui_ ,4T*L)ih,4T*L)ii @?i* #@|@c W?|ih?@|L?@* L4 T@htL?t

L|t U*itG @h|@}i _it hi?|itc _L??iit *L?}|_?@*it @TT@hi**iit i4T*L)ihi4T*L)ic UL4 T@h@tL?t ?|ih?@|L?@*it

a,w L_it % L_it a,wG ac 2

(3)

W?|hL_U|L?

Ai hiUi?| _ii*LT4i?| Lu 4@|Ui_ i4T*L)ihi4T*L)ii _@|@ @t LTi?i_ i?Lh4Lt TLtt M*|it ? |ih4t Lu |i @M*|) |L |it| ThiLt*)i t|?} iUL?L4U |iLhit ?i Lu |i

|iLhit |@| tii4t |i 4Lt| hTi uLh ?it|}@|L?c @?_ uLh U 4@|Ui_ h4Lh!ih T@?i*

_@|@ tii4t _i@**) t|i_c t |i |iLh) Lu hi?| t@h?} ? |i *@MLh 4@h!i|² UULh_?} |L

|t |iLh)c h4t |@| i@h? TLt|i iUL?L4U hi?|t L? |i ThL_U| 4@h!i| t@hi |i4 |

|ih i4T*L)iit ? hi*@|L? |L |i T@h|it< hi*@|i M@h}@??} TLiht t @ hit*|c Lh!iht i4T*L)i_ M) |i 4Lt| ThL|@M*i h4tc Ui|iht T@hMtc ** |i?_ |L i@h? 4Lhi |@? |Lti ?

*itt ThL|@M*i h4t @?_c ? T@h|U*@hc U|@|L?t ? ThL|t Lih |4i uLh @ h4 tL*_ Mi hiiU|i_ ? |i i@h??}t Lu Lh!iht |@| |i h4 i4T*L)t

Nt?} 4@|Ui_ h4Lh!ih T@?i* _@|@ uhL4 |i 4@?u@U|h?} tiU|Lht Lu 6h@?Ui @?_

Lh@)c i ?_ |@| |ihi t ?_ii_ @ TLt|ic t}?U@?| hi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih @?_ *L} @??@* i@h??}tc 4i@thi_ @| |i ?__@* Lh!ih *ii* iih|i*ittc

|ihi @hi 4@?) L|ih TLttM*i i T*@?@|L?tc Mit_it hi?| t@h?}c |@| UL*_ i T*@? |i t}?U@?| ULiUi?| Ai 4@? LMiU|i Lu |t T@Tih t |L UL?t_ih i@U Lu |iti @*|ih?@|i i T*@?@|L?t ti^i?|@**)c @?_ |L tii u @?) Lu |i4 t U@T@M*i Lu hi_U?} |i ULiUi?| L?

ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |L ?t}?U@?Ui

Ai t|hU|hi Lu |t T@Tih t @t uL**Lt u|ih ThL_?} @ h@T_ _tUttL? Lu Thi Lt hiti@hU _it}?i_ |L @__hitt |i hi?| t@h?} 4L_i* ? tiU|L? 2c i Mi}? ? tiU|L?

M) Thiti?|?} @ t4T*i 4L_i* Lu M@h}@??} U ?_ih*it 4U Lu |i *|ih@|hi L? hi?|

t@h?} `i |i? Thiti?| |i 4@? Et|)*3i_ u@U|( hi@* ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? |i 4@?u@U

|h?} tiU|Lht Lu 6h@?Ui @?_ Lh@) @hi t}?U@?|*)c @?_ TLt|i*)c hi*@|i_ |L hi@* u**)i@h i^@*i?| }hLtt i@h??}t uLh u**|4i i4T*L)i_ 4i? ? @? Lh_?@h) *i@t| t^@hit hi}hittL?

h ht| UL?Uih? t |L h*i L| |i M@t ? |i it|4@|i_ t|@?_@h_ ihhLht Lu |i ULiUi?|t _i |L |i it|4@|L? Mi?} U@hhi_ L| @| |i ?__@* *ii* *i ThL|t @hi 4i@thi_ @|

|i h4 *ii* E@?_ i @i 4*|T*i ?__@*t Tih h4 At ^it|L?c @__hitti_ ? _i|@*

M) Bhii?@*_ EbH @?_ _i4L?t|h@|i_ _h@4@|U@**) M) L*|L? Ebbf c t UL?t_ihi_ ? tiU|L? e 5iU|L? e @*tL _tUttit |i 4T@U| |@| 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc T@h|U*@h*) 4i@?

hiihtL? _i |L |@ ?Ui?|it |L _iuih ThL|t @?_ tThi@_ *Lttit @UhLtt tiih@* )i@htc 4}|

@i L? Lh it|4@|it

5iU|L? D |i? UL?t_iht |hii @*|ih?@|i i T*@?@|L?tc ?@4i*) |i Thiti?Ui Lu ?|ih

?_t|h) @}i _gihi?|@*t |@| @hi ?hi*@|i_ |L _Lt)?Uh@|U ThL|@M*|) @h@|L?c Mt?itt

4Vhh Derzg dqg Nudpdu} +4<<<, iru d uhfhqw uhylhz ri wklv olwhudwxuh1

5Rvzdog +4<<9, uhshdwhgo| phqwlrqv wkh srwhqwldo iru pdwfkhg up0zrunhu sdqho gdwd wr uhvroyh h{lvwlqj lvvxhv lq wkh uhqw vkdulqj olwhudwxuh1

6Zh frqgxfw rxu dqdo|vlv dw wkh lqglylgxdo zrunhu ohyho/ udwkhu wkdq dw wkh up ohyho/ vlqfh wklv doorzv xv pruh h{lelolw| lq wkh vruwv ri khwhurjhqhlw| iru zklfk zh fdq frqwuro/ prvw qrwdeo| lq whupv ri xqrevhuydeoh +wr wkh hfrqrphwulfldq, lqglylgxdo surgxfwlyh fkdudfwhulvwlfv1

(4)

|i *?! Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ i@h??}t t ?L| h4c M| h@|ih ?_t|h) Lh )i@hc tTiUU `i

?i | @__hitt |i ^it|L? Lu LMtih@M*i _gihi?Uit ? ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut ? tiU|L? S W| t TLttM*i |@| Uih|@? h4t @hi 4Lhi ThL|@M*i MiU@ti |i) t4T*) @i 4Lhi t!**i_

Lh!ihtc @?_ |iti Lh!iht @hi L?*) UL4Ti?t@|i_ uLh |i 4@h!i| @*i Lu |ih i |h@ t!**t L?_U|?} Lh @?@*)tt @| |i ?__@* *ii*c @t LTTLti_ |L |i h4 *ii*c @**Lt t |L i T*L| @h@|L? ? Lh!uLhUi UL4TLt|L? Lih |4ic |@| 4@) Mi hi*@|i_ |L ThL|@M*|)c ?

@ 4U 4Lhi _i|@*i_ 4@??ih^e

u|ih i U*_?} |i t|@?_@h_ tLhUit Lu L4||i_ @h@M*i M@t _itUhMi_ @MLic i |i?

@__hitt |i ^it|L? Lu |i i?_L}i?i|) Lu ThL|t ? tiU|L? . `i _L |t |hL} ?t|h 4i?|@* @h@M*it it|4@|L? i |c tiU|L? H UL?t_iht |@| TLttM*|) |@| _gihi?| h4t T@) LMtih@M*) i^@*i?| Lh!iht _gihi?|*)c M| ? tL4i i_ 4@??ih At L*_ Mi |i U@tic uLh i @4T*ic u _gihi?| h4t i4T*L)i_ _gihi?| ?Ui?|i UL4Ti?t@|L? TL*Uit At

@TThL@U @*tL @**Lt tc ? |i U@ti ihi hi?| t@h?} t Thiti?|c |L U@T|hi |4i?@h@?|

?LMtihi_ i|ihL}i?i|) ? h4 M@h}@??} TLih `i ?t ? tiU|L? b M) UL?t_ih?} |i 4Lt| }i?ih@* TLttM*i tTiUU@|L?c U @**Lt uLh |i TLttM*|) |@| @h@|L?t ? LMtih

@M*i @?_ ?LMtih@M*i ?__@* @?_ h4 i|ihL}i?i|) |@| 4@) Mi ULhhi*@|i_ | ML|

ThL|t @?_ i@h??}t @hi _h?} |i LMtihi_ hi*@|L? 5iU|L? f t44@h3it Lh ?_?}t

@?_ UL?U*_it #itUhT|i t|@|t|Ut uLh |i _@|@ ti_ @hi }i? ? @TTi?_ |@M*i c @?_

_@|@ UL?t|hU|L? t UL?t_ihi_ ? |i _@|@ @TTi?_

`i ?_ |@| i U@? hiiU| @*4Lt| @** LMtih@|L?@**) i^@*i?| i T*@?@|L?t uLh hi?|

t@h?} OLiihc |i i?_L}i?i|) Lu ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? 6h@?Ui tii4t |L Mi @ t}?U@?|

ttic ? |@| |i ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it it|4@|Lh MiUL4it ?t}?U@?| At t 4@?*) _i

|L @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh Lu |i it|4@|i E@?_ @ ThLM*i4 Lu i@! ?t|h4i?|tc Liih Ai L?*) LMtih@|L?@**) i^@*i?| i T*@?@|L? |@| 4}| Mi @M*i |L tTT*@?|

hi?| t@h?} t |@| Lu ?LMtihi_ i_ Lh!ih i|ihL}i?i|)( @*|L} |t |LL @Uiit |i ui@| Lu hi_U?} |i t}?U@?Ui Lu |i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t 4@?*) |hL} @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh Lu |i it|4@|ic h@|ih |@? @ hi_U|L? ? |i TL?| it|4@|i |L@h_t 3ihL

? |i 4Lt| UL4T*i|i tTiUU@|L? Ai ?Uhi@ti ? |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh t tUi?| |L 4@!i

|i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t ?t}?U@?| ? 6h@?Uic @?_ |L hi_Ui |t t}?U@?Ui Mi*L |i D TihUi?| *ii* ? Lh@) E@*|L} | hi4@?t t}?U@?| @| |i f TihUi?| *ii* 6h|ih i @4?@|L? Lu |i hi*@|i 4T@U| Lu ?t|h4i?|@|L? ihtt ?__@* i_ igi|t tLt

|@| ?t|h4i?|@|L? LMtUhit |i 4T@U| Lu ?LMtihi_ ?__@* i|ihL}i?i|) ? 6h@?Uic

@?_ |t Lh!ih tLh|?} M) ?LMtihi_ ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut 4@) ?_ii_ Mi @? 4TLh|@?|

@*|ih?@|i i T*@?@|L? uLh |i TLt|i ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ @}it

7Wklv frxog dovr eh grqh e| zhljkwhg hvwlpdwlrq dqg xvlqj zlwklq0up dyhudjhv ri revhuydeoh lqglylgxdo fkdudfwhulvwlfv/ exw vxfk dq dssurdfk zrxog qrw eh vxflhqw zkhq zh fruuhfw iru xqrevhuyhg lqglylgxdo khwhurjhqhlw| ehorz1 Dv d uhvxow/ zh suhihu xvlqj wkh vdph ohyho ri djjuhjdwlrq wkurxjkrxw1

2

(5)

2 hiLt +iti@hU L? +i?| 5@h?}

Ai t|@?_@h_ ?iLU*@ttU@* 4UhLiUL?L4U 4L_i* Lu |i *@MLh 4@h!i| 4T*it |@|c ?_ih TihuiU| UL4Ti||L?c h4t i^@|i |i @*i Lu 4@h}?@* ThL_U| Lu *@MLh EThL_U||) |

|t 4@h}?@* ULt| E@}it OLiihc | t t|** UL?|hLiht@* i|ih L|ih u@U|Lhtc tU

@t ?_t|h) Lh h4 U@h@U|iht|Utc ?i?Ui @}it @MLi UL4Ti?t@|?} _gihi?|@*t @?_

L4||i_ ?LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut Wu |ihi i t| Tihtt|i?| _gihi?|@*t ? @}it

@UhLtt ?_t|hit Lh h4tc |t 4@) Mi @ t}? |@| *@MLh 4@h!i|t @hi ?L?UL4Ti||ic @?_

iUL?L4U TL*Uit _hiU|i_ @| |i *@MLh 4@h!i| tL*_ Mi @_@T|i_ @UULh_?}*)

}hL?} *|ih@|hic _@|?} M@U! |L 5*U|ih EbDf c @TTi@ht |L ?_ Tihtt|i?| @}i _gihi?Uit uLh LMtih@|L?@**) i^@*i?| Lh!iht @UhLtt _gihi?| ?_t|hit Lh _gihi?| h4t Ai _gihi?Uit @*tL @TTi@h |L Mi t|@M*i Lih UL?|hit | ^|i _gihi?| @}i ti||?}

?t|||L?t ? |ih4t Lu _i}hii Lu ?L? ULih@}ic _i}hii Lu Ui?|h@*3@|L? Lu @}i M@h}@??}

i|U W? |i tTh| Lu 5*U|ih EbDf c @ tihit Lu T@Tiht ? |i *@|i bHft uL?_ t|hL?} ?|ih

?_t|h) @}i _gihi?|@*t uLh |i N5 ii? i? LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut @hi ?U*_i_

E#U!i?t @?_ k@|3 EbH. c khi}ih @?_ 544iht EbHH c hT) @?_ ALTi* EbH. W?

*?i | hi?|t@h?} |iLhitc tL4i Lu |iti t|_it @*tL tL |@| |i @}i _gihi?|@*t

@hi ULhhi*@|i_ | |i ?_t|hit< ThL|@M*|) Ai ?|ihThi|@|L? Lu |t hit*|c Liihc

|i?_t |L @h) M) @|Lh

?i *?i Lu @h}4i?| t}}it|t |@| ?|ihh4 Lh ?|ih?_t|h) @}i _gihi?|@*t L?*) hiiU| ?LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut Lh ?LMtihi_ LM U@h@U|iht|Ut At t @ u@Lhi_

i T*@?@|L?c t?Ui 4U Lu |i i_i?Ui Lh!t @}@?t| ML| UL4Ti?t@|?} _gihi?|@*t @?_

L4||i_ LMtihi_ U@h@U|iht|Ut Mi?} |i tLhUi Lu @h@|L?t Ai u@U| |@| tL4i t|_

it ?_ ?uLh4|) Lu @}i _gihi?|@*t @UhLtt LUUT@|L?t t @h_ |L hiUL?U*i | i|ih i T*@?@|L? Ai UL4Ti?t@|?} _gihi?|@*t )TL|itt @*tL @t _U*|it ? i T*@??}

_gihi?Uit ? ^| h@|it Lih ?_t|hitc ? |@| } @}i ?_t|hit |i?_ |L @i *Lih ^|

h@|it Ek@|3 @?_ 544iht bHb

Ai tti Lu i|ih |i )TL|itt Lu ?LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut 4@) i T*@?

?_t|h) Lh h4 _gihi?Uit t ?ti||*i_ ?i @) |L |it| |t i T*@?@|L? t M) |it|?}

i|ih Lh ?L| @}i U@?}it uLh Lh!iht 4L?} Mi|ii? tiU|Lht @hi Lu |i t@4i t3i @t |i

@ih@}i @}i _gihi?|@*t Mi|ii? tiU|Lht Ai ^@*|) Lu |i Lh!ih t tTTLti_ |L Mi i*_

UL?t|@?| i? i Lh ti 4Litc @?_ |t |i ?LMtihi_ i|ihL}i?i|) i T*@?@|L? 4T*it

|@| ?_t|h) _gihi?Uit tL*_ ?L| Mi LMtihi_ uLh 4Liht L| khi}ih @?_ 544iht EbHH @?_ itTiU@**) BMML?t @?_ k@|3 Ebb2 |it| |t )TL|itt U@hiu**)c @?_ |ih hit*|t _L ?L| tTTLh| |@| ?_t|h) @}i _gihi?Uit @hi _i |L ?4i@thi_ ThL_U||) _gihi?Uit Mi|ii? Lh!iht W? @?L|ih ti||?} ML_c kh@4@h3 @?_ @h}L*t Ebbb @?_

wiL?@h_ @?_ _i?hL_i EbbS tLc Liihc |@| ?LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut @hi

?_ii_ 4TLh|@?| ? i T*@??} @}i _gihi?Uit

(6)

?L|ih *|ih@|hic |L U |t T@Tih t 4Lhi U*Lti*) hi*@|i_c uLUtit L? U |iLhi|

U@* i T*@?@|L? U@? Mit| Mi ti_ |L ?|ihThi| |i @}i _gihi?|@*t ?i hiUi?| t|h@?_ Lu |i

*|ih@|hi uLUtit _hiU|*) L? |i ThL|T@) ULhhi*@|L? @?_ tit h4 *ii* T@?i* _@|@ EML_

EbHb c ML_ @?_ wi4i Ebbf c ML_ @?_ wi4i Ebb c *@?ULihc t@*_

@?_ 5@?ui) EbbS c V@? +ii?i? EbbS c O*_hi| @?_ t@*_ Ebb. Ai |iLhi|U@*

@TThL@U ? |iti T@Tiht t @ UL**iU|i M@h}@??} uh@4iLh! ? U ?L?3i_ Lh!iht M@h}@? Lih @ h4<t hi?|t *|L} _gihi?| T@Tiht ? |t *|ih@|hi Thiuih _gihi?| 4L_

i*t Lu UL**iU|i M@h}@??}c^D @** 4L_i*t ThL_Ui t4*@h @}i i^@|L? ihi @ ULhhi*@|L?

Mi|ii? @}it @?_ ThL|t t Thi_U|i_ 5iU|L? Mi*L ThL_it @? i @4T*i Lu |i tLh| Lu 4L_i* UL?t_ihi_ ? |t *|ih@|hi^S

Ai @MLi 4i?|L?i_ T@Tiht ti T@?i*t Lu h4 *ii* _@|@ uLh |i Nkc N5 @?_ @?@_@c

@?_ it|4@|i ihtL?t Lu |i @}i i^@|L? | hi?|t Tih Lh!ih ?U*_i_ 6h4 *ii*

T@?i* _@|@ @L_t @}}hi}@|L? ThLM*i4t ?_Ui_ M) t?} ?_t|h) *ii* UhLtt tiU|L? _@|@c

@?_ tL4i Lu |i T@?i*t ti_ @**L |i @|Lht |L UL?|hL* uLh tTiU@* 4@h!i| t|hU|hit @?_

|iU?L*L}it Uc ii? ?_ih TihuiU| UL4Ti||L?c UL*_ *i@_ |L } ThL|t @?_ }

@}it Ai hit*|t uhL4 |t *|ih@|hi ?_U@|i t|hL?}*) |@| 4Lhi ThL|@M*i h4t T@) }ih @}it i? LMtihi_ 4@? U@T|@* U@h@U|iht|Ut @hi ?U*_i_ @t i** @t h4 i_

igiU|t Ai T33*i t|** hi4@?t |L}c i|ih 4Lhi ThL|@M*i h4t T@) }ih @}it uLh _i?|U@* Lh!ihtc t?Ui L4||i_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut 4@) @UUL?| uLh |i ThL|T@) igiU|

u @ TLt|i ULhhi*@|L? i t|t Mi|ii? @}it @?_ ThL|t |@| LUUht @ |i L4ttL? Lu

?LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut

8Oderu ghpdqg/ ru uljkw0wr0pdqdjh/ prghov +ri zklfk prqrsro| xqlrq prghov duh dq h{wuhph irup, lqyroyh edujlqlqj ryhu zdjhv dorqh +Rvzdog +4<;5, / Kloguhwk dqg Rvzdog +4<<:, hwf111,1 Hflhqw frqwudfwlqj prghov +ri zklfk vwurqjo| hflhqw frqwudfwlqj lv d vshfldo fdvh,/ rq wkh rwkhu kdqg/ lpso| edujdlqlqj ryhu erwk zdjhv dqg hpsor|phqw +Derzg +4<;<, / Derzg dqg Ohplhx{ +4<<3, ,1 Pdqqlqj +4<;:, vxjjhvwv d wklug dowhuqdwlyh/ lq zklfk erwk zdjhv dqg hpsor|phqw duh edujdlqhg ryhu/ dowkrxjk wkh edujdlqlqj srzhu ri wkh sduwlhv lv glhuhqw lq hdfk qhjrwldwlrq1 Krvnhq dqg Pdujrolv +4<<:, whvw d vwuxfwxudo irup ri wkh Pdqqlqj +4<;:, prgho/ zklfk hqfrpsdvvhv erwk oderu ghpdqg dqg hflhqw frqwudfwlqj prghov lq Qhz \run Vwdwh sxeolf vfkrrov1 Wkh| uhmhfw oderu ghpdqg lq 433( ri wkhlu vfkrro glvwulfwv/ zkhuhdv hflhqw frqwudfwlqj iduhv voljkwo| ehwwhu1

9Vhh Rvzdog +4<;5, / Rvzdog +4<<9, dqg Qlfnhoo +4<<;, iru fulwlfdo uhylhzv ri wklv olwhudwxuh/ dqg hvshfldoo|

Qlfnhoo +4<<;, iru d fulwlfdo dvvhvphqw ri wkh wkhruhwlfdo prghov1

e

(7)

Ai @tUt

W? |t tiU|L?c i *@) L| @ t4T*i 4L_i* Lu M@h}@??} Lih @}it @?_ i4T*L)4i?|^. |@|

*i@_t |L 4T*U@|L?t uLh |i *?! Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ @}itc @?_ i _i4L?t|h@|i_ i4ThU@**)

M) ?L 4i@?t @||i4T| |L it|4@|i | ? @?) t|hU|h@* uLh4

54Ti @h}@??} L_i

L?t_ih @ M@h}@??} t|@|L? ? U @ h4 | @ ThL| u?U|L?

Z'RsEuc guog

?i}L|@|it | @ }hLT Lu Lh!ihtc ?L| ?iUitt@h*) @ ?L?c |@| @||i4T|t |L 4@ 43i |i i TiU|i_ }@? Lu |t 4i4Mihtc _i?i_ @t

L ' u

E

W? |i i^@|L?t }i? @MLic R t |i 4@h!i| ThUi uLh |i h4<t L|T|c sEuc g t |i ThL_U|L? u?U|L?c tTTLti_ UL?U@ic |u Mi?} i4T*L)4i?| @?_g Mi?} U@T|@* t

|i ?t_i EM@h}@?i_ @}ic *i t |i L|t_i ELTTLh|?|)c Lh 4@h!i| @}i 6?@**)c o t |i hi?|@* h@|i Lu U@T|@* @?_ t |i ?4Mih Lu 4i4Miht ? |i }hLT Lu Lh!iht |@|

t UL?_U|?} |i M@h}@??}

#i??} |i M@h}@??} TLih Lu |i Lh!iht @t c |i h4 @?_ |i Lh!iht i?}@}i ?

@t M@h}@??} Lih @}it @?_ i4T*L)4i?|c tU |@| |i ?i}L|@|i_ @}i @?_ i4T*L)4i?|

*ii* tL*i

4@ cu LZ³ '4@

cu

u

E

ERsEuc guog³

Ai M@h}@?i_ i4T*L)4i?| *ii* ? |t U@ti i^@|it |i @*i Lu 4@h}?@* ThL_U| | |i LTTLh|?|) @}ic i

ue tL*it RYs Yu '

@?_ |i M@h}@?i_ @}i ** Mi _i|ih4?i_ M) 'e'n

e Z ue

:Wklv prgho ri edujdlqlqj lv vlplodu wr wkrvh ghvfulehg lq Iduehu +4<;9, / dqg lv ri wkh vwurqjo| hflhqw w|sh +lq wkh yrfdexodu| ri Eurzq dqg Dvkhqihowhu +4<;9, ,1 Derzg +4<;<, kdv vkrzq wkdw froohfwlyh edujdlqlqj gdwd iurp wkh X1V1 lv frqvlvwhqw zlwk wkh lpsolfdwlrqv ri wklv w|sh ri edujdlqlqj prgho1 Derzg dqg Nudpdu}

+4<<6, whqg wr eh vnhswlfdo derxw wkh uhohydqfh ri hflhqw frqwudfwlqj lq Iudqfh1

D

(8)

At 4T*it |@| ?t_i @}it ** Mi @ u?U|L? Lu LTTLh|?|) @}itc ^@t hi?|t Tih Lh!ih EThL|t i@*@|i_ @| |i LTTLh|?|) ULt| Lu *@MLh @?_ hi*@|i M@h}@??} TLih

Wu i |hi@| M@h}@??} TLih @t @ UL?t|@?| ? |t t4T*i 4L_i*c |t UL4it _L? |L it|4@|?} |i tTiUU@|L?

c|'qfnZ_aEc|c|qn0c|c E

ihi ZaEc|c| ?L hiuiht |L ThL|t Tih Lh!ih^H ? |i h4 a |@| i4T*L)t |i ?__@*

@| _@|i | q t |i hi*@|i M@h}@??} TLih Lu |i Lh!ihtc tU |@| |i R@MtL*|i M@h}@??} TLih t i^@* |L _nq^q U Lu |i _tUttL? |@| uL**Lt ** Mi uLUti_ L?

_i|ih4?@?|t Lu |i L|t_i @}i E@MtLhMi_ ?|L |i qf ? |t t4T*it| tTiUU@|L? @?_

Lu |i hi*@|i M@h}@??} TLih q iih|i*ittc @t |i @MLi _tUttL? 4@!it U*i@hc |i LMtihi_ ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? |i h4 a ** Mi i?_L}i?Lt |L |i _i|ih4?@|L? Lu |i

?t_i @}i

2 Ai 5|)*3i_ 6@U|

Bi? |i @||i?|L? |@| hi?| t@h?} @t hiUii_ ? |i *|ih@|hic @?_ |i _i4@?_t uLh | Lu|i? i@h_ ? |i TLT*@h Thittc i Thiti?| ihi |i t4T*i ?@h@|i hi}hittL? Lu ThL|t Tih Lh!ih L? @}itc U tihit @t |i t|@h|?} TL?| uLh Lh @?@*)tt Ai t|@h|?} TL?|

t t4T*iG _L Lh!iht i4T*L)i_ M) h4t | }ih ThL|t i@h? t}?U@?|*) 4Lhi |@?

Lh!iht i4T*L)i_ M) h4t i@h??} *Lih ThL|tq

`i tTiUu) i@h??}t @?_ ThL|t ? *ii*t uLh |hii hi@tL?t 6ht|c MiU@ti Lu |i Thiti?Ui Lu

*Ltt4@!?} h4t ? Lh _@|@c 4i@th?} ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? *L}t L*_ @i ?iUitt|@|i_

_tU@h_?} LMtih@|L?t uhL4 TLLh*) TihuLh4?} h4t E@?_ TLttM*) ?|hL_U?} ti*iU|L?

M@t 5iUL?_c 4i@th?} ThL|t Tih Lh!ih @?_ @}it ? *ii*t h@|ih |@? *L}t 4i@?t |@|

? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |@| }i|t |h@?t*@|i_ ?|L @__|L?@* @}it 6?@**)c |i *ii*t*ii*t tTiUU@|L? t |i 4Lt| UL?tt|i?| | |i |iLhi|U@* 4L_i*t ?_ih*)?} |i M@h}@??}

*|ih@|hic @t ? tiU|L? @MLi

`| @ ?L|@M*i i UiT|L?t Lu ML_ @?_ wi4i Ebb @?_ ML_ @?_ **@? EbbS c |i i4ThU@* hi?| t@h?} *|ih@|hi @tt4it L4L}i?iLt hi?| t@h?} M) tTiUu)?} _i?

|U@* M@h}@??} TLih T@h@4i|iht uLh @** h4t At 4@) Mi @? ?hi@*t|U @tt4T|L?c tL i it|4@|i ML| L4L}i?iLt @?_ i|ihL}i?iLt M@h}@??} TLih 4L_i*t Ai L4L}i

?iLt 4L_i*t @tt4i |@| q ' q& ' q uLh @** c &c *i |i i|ihL}i?iLt M@h}@??}

;Wkh wkhruhwlfdo prgho uhihuv wr txdvl uhqwv shu zrunhu/ udwkhu wkdq surwv shu zrunhu1 Wklv uhtxluhv hydoxdwlqj oderu frvwv dw wkhlu pdunhw ydoxh1 Ehjlqqlqj lq vhfwlrq 9/ wkh lqfoxghg fryduldwhv doorz xv wr fdswxuh wklv pdunhw ydoxh ri oderu1 Qhyhuwkhohvv/ iru wkh vdnh ri fodulw| zlwk uhvshfw wr wkh frpprqo| khog lghd ri _surw vkdulqj%/ zh suhihu wr vshfli| wkh prgho lq whupv ri surwv shu zrunhu iurp wkh vwduw1

S

(9)

TLih 4L_i*t tTiUu) @ u?U|L?@* uLh4 uLh q_a W? T@h|U*@hc i tTTLti |@| |i hi*@|i M@h}@??} TLih Lu |i Lh!iht ? h4 U@? Mi h||i? @t

q 'k

7c|dc|DSDo 7c|dc|$Do

lq

ihi 7c| hiThiti?|t |i U@?}i ? ThL|t Tih Lh!iht ? h4 Mi|ii? | @?_ |c 7SD

t |i SD| TihUi?|*i ? |i _t|hM|L? Lu tU U@?}it Lih |i t@4T*i E2H bHfk6 uLh 6h@?Ui @?_ bHSfcHb !hL?ih uLh Lh@) @?_ 7D t |i D| TihUi?|*i EHe. bHfk6 uLh 6h@?Ui @?_ efDce !hL?ih uLh Lh@) ? |t _t|hM|L?^b qc ? |t U@tic MiUL4it

@ iU|Lh Lu ULiUi?|t At @TThL@U @**Lt |i M@h}@??} TLih Lu |i Lh!iht

|L @h) @t @? @t)44i|hU tT*?i | ?Uhi@tit @?_ _iUhi@tit ? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih Lu |ih i4T*L)?} h4 Ai tTiUU@|L? U@T|hit ML| M@h}@??} TLih @t)44i|h) ? h4t | } TihuLh4@?Ui @?_ *L TihuLh4@?Ui @t UL4T@hi_ |L |i ThiLt )i@hc @?_ ?|hL_Uit t4T*i _)?@4Ut ?|L |i 4L_i* 6?@**)c | tL*_ Mi ?L|i_ |@| @*|L} i it|4@|i |i 4L_i* L? ?__@* _@|@c |t 4L_i* t i^@*i?| |L |i i}|i_ hi}hittL? Lu ThL|t L?

@}it @| |i h4 *ii*c t?} h4 i4T*L)4i?| @t |i i}|^f

L_i* W ? |@M*it @?_ Thiti?| |i hit*|t Lu it|4@|?} |i Mi?U4@h! i^@|L?

| *?i@h ThL|t L?*) @?_ i^@|L? | i|ihL}i?iLt M@h}@??} L? Lh 6hi?U @?_

Lhi}@? _@|@ +iU@** |@| i hit|hU| Lh @||i?|L? |L u**|4i Lh!?} 4i? ? |i 4@?

u@U|h?} tiU|Lhc @?_ |@| |i _iTi?_i?| @h@M*i ? |iti hi}hittL?t t 4i@thi_ ? *ii*tc

?L| *L}t 6Lh 6h@?Uic Lh it|4@|i Luq ? |i L4L}i?iLt U@ti t ffe EU 4T*it @?

@MtL*|i M@h}@??} TLih Lu ff2c ihi@t Lh hit*|t uLh Lh@) @hi t*}|*) }ihc @|

ff2Df E@?_ |t @? 4T*i_ @MtL*|i M@h}@??} TLih Lu ff2ee L| Lu |iti it|4@|it

@hi t}?U@?|*) _gihi?| uhL4 3ihL Ai it|4@|it Lu |i UL?t|@?| |ih4t ? |i i|ihL}i?Lt U@ti @hi @*tL t}?U@?| @?_ t*}|*) *@h}ihc Mi?} ff.b uLh 6h@?Ui @?_ ffD uLh Lh@) Ai tT*?i |ih4t @hi ?i}@|i uLh i UiT|L?@**) *@h}i ?Uhi@tit ? ThL|tc @?_ TLt|i Lu i UiT|L?@**) *@h}i _iUhi@tit ? ThL|tc ? ML| 6h@?Ui @?_ Lh@) E@*|L} |i ?Uhi@ti

|ih4 ? |i tT*?i t ?L| t}?U@?| ? 6h@?Ui At t}}it|t tL4i t4LL|?} Lu @}it ? hitTL?ti |L U|@|L? ? ThL|t AL TLttM*i i T*@?@|L?t |@| @i Mii? T| uLh@h_ M)

|i *|ih@|hi |@| @hi UL?tt|i?| | |t hit*| @hi ?th@?Ui @?_ t*L @_t|4i?|² dW?tih| |@M*i @u @ML| ihio

<Urexvwqhvv whvwv xvlqj 793 dqg 788 lq wkh sodfh ri 798/ dqg 773 dqg 778 lq wkh sodfh ri 768|lhoghg uhvxowv wkdw zhuh erwk txdolwdwlyho| dqg txdqwlwdwlyho| yhu| vlplodu wr wkrvh suhvhqwhg khuh1

43Iru odfn ri pdwfkhg up0zrunhu gdwd/ wkh olwhudwxuh riwhq dgguhvvhv wklv sureohp xvlqj up ohyho gdwd1 Zh xvh lqglylgxdo ohyho gdwd iru uhdvrqv wkdw zloo ehfrph hylghqw1

44Wkh lqvxudqfh h{sodqdwlrq lv edvhg rq wkh lghd wkdw dowkrxjk d ulvn qhxwudo up pljkw vkduh lwv uhqwv zlwk lwv ulvn dyhuvh hpsor|hhv/ lw dovr lqvxuhv wkhp djdlqvw odujh xfwxdwlrqv lq zdjhv lq uhvsrqvh wr odujh xfwxdwlrqv lq surwv1 Wklv zrxog eh uhhfwhg/ lq rxu fdvh/ e| uhdo zdjhv wkdw lqfuhdvh e| voljkwo| ohvv wkdq h{shfwhg zkhq wkhuh lv d vkdus lqfuhdvh lq surwv/ dqg uhdo zdjhv wkdw jr grzq e| voljkwo| ohvv wkdq h{shfwhg zkhq wkhuh lv d vkdus idoo lq surwv1

45Wkh vorz dgmxvwphqw h{sodqdwlrq vxjjhvwv wkdw wkh rxwfrph ri edujdlqlqj ryhu zdjhv ghshqgv rq wkh

.

(10)

Ai ?|ihThi|@|L? Lu |i t3it Lu |iti ULiUi?|tc U U@? Mi @TT*i_ |L @** Lu |i it|4@|it |@| uL**Lc t Lh| _i**?} TL? L?t_ih?} |i L4L}i?iLt 4L_i*c Lh it|4@|it 4T*) |@| i? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? 6h@?Ui ?Uhi@ti M) fff uh@?Utc @}it ?Uhi@ti M) uh@?Utc *i ? Lh@) i? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ?Uhi@ti M) fff !hL?ihc i@h??}t

?Uhi@ti M) 2D !hL?ih W? *}| Lu |i t@4T*i t|@|t|Ut EuL?_ ? |@M*i Lu |i @TTi?_ c

|iti ULiUi?| it|4@|it ULhhitTL?_ |L i*@t|U|it Lu fff2 uLh 6h@?Ui @?_ ff uLh Lh@)c i i@h??}t tii4 E?|@**) 4U 4Lhi hitTL?ti |L ThL| U|@|L?t ? Lh@) |@? ? 6h@?Ui

4Lhi ?uLh4@|i 4i@thic Liihc 4}| Mi |i @ih@}i ?Uhi@ti ? @}it _i |L t@hi_ hi?|t ? i@U UL?|h) At t U@*U*@|i_ @t |i @ih@}i UL?|hM|L? Lu ThL|t |L

@}it EZq __i_ M) @ih@}i @}it ?i| Lu |t UL?|hM|L? E Zq Ai @ih@}i

?Uhi@ti ? @}it @t |i @_@?|@}i Lih @ t4T*i i*@t|U|) ? |@| | @**Lt L?i |L t|@|i

|i t3i Lu |i U@?}i ?_Ui_ M) ThL|t hi*@|i |L @ih@}i @}it ? |i @Mti?Ui Lu |t U@?}i W? |i U@ti Lu 6h@?Uic |t UL4it |L f2eIc *i hi?| t@h?} ? Lh@) EL? |i M@tt Lu |iti Thi*4?@h) it|4@|it ?_Uit @ TihUi?| ?Uhi@ti Lih @}it |L| hi?|

t@h?}

? @*|ih?@|i 4i@thi Lu |i hL*i Lu hi?| t@h?} ? @}i _i|ih4?@|L?c }*}|i_ M) t@*_ EbbS c t |i t@hi Lu @h@?Ui ? |i _t|hM|L? Lu @}it _i |L hi?| t@h?}

Bi? |@| bDI Lu |i 4@tt Lu @ t)44i|hU _t|hM|L? t |? T*t Lh 4?t 2 t|@?_@h_

_i@|L?t Lu |i 4i@?c |t @4L?|t |L ht| U@*U*@|?} |i _gihi?Ui ? |i UL?|hM|L?

Lu ThL|t |L @}it Mi|ii? @ h4 i@h??} |i 4i@? Lu ThL|t Tih Lh!ih T*t 2 t|@?_@h_

_i@|L?t @?_ @ h4 i@h??} |i 4i@? 4?t 2 t|@?_@h_ _i@|L?tc @?_ __?} |t

@4L?| M) |i _gihi?Ui ? @}it Mi|ii? @ TihtL? i@h??} |i 4i@? @}i T*t 2 t|@?_@h_

_i@|L?t @?_ @ TihtL? i@h??} |i 4i@? @}i 4?t 2 t|@?_@h_ _i@|L?t 6Lh 6h@?Uic i ?_ |@| @h@M*|) ? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih Ri T*@?t 2DSI Lu |i @h@M*|) ? @}it ? 6h@?Uic *i | i T*@?t bHHI Lu |i @h@M*|) ? @}it ? Lh@) t ?L|i_ ? tiU|L? 2c

lqirupdwlrq vhwv ri erwk sduwlhv +qrwdeo| wkh wkuhdw srlqw ri wkh up/ zklfk lv d ixqfwlrq ri lwv surwv,/

dqg wkdw wkh sduwlhv gr qrw ohduq derxw surwv dv wkh| rffxu/ exw udwkhu zlwk d odj1 Vlqfh wkh lpsolfdwlrq lv wkdw fxuuhqw zdjhv zrxog eh d ixqfwlrq ri sdvw surwv/ li fxuuhqw surwv duh kljkhu wkdq sdvw surwv/

zrunhuv vkrxog jhw d vpdoohu vkduh ri fxuuhqw surwv +fruuhvsrqglqj wr d {hg vkduh ri sdvw surwv,/ dqg fruuhvsrqglqjo| zdjhv zloo vhhp wr pdnh xs d odujhu vkduh ri fxuuhqw surwv zkhq surwv idoo1

46Jlyhq wkh olqhdulw| ri rxu prghov/ wklv fdofxodwlrq dprxqwv wr 4+ . 5, 4+ 5,

+z . 5z, +z 5z, @74

7z @ 4

z=

H

(11)

t@*_ EbbS ?L|it |@| ThiLt t|_it L? |i N?|i_ 5|@|it @i uL?_ @*it h@?}?}

uhL4 2eI |L .fIc @?_ @?@*)tit t?} _@|@ uhL4 |i N?|i_ k?}_L4 @i uL?_ t@hit }L?}

uhL4 eI |L 2DI

W| t U*i@h uhL4 |@M*it @?_ |@| ThL|t @hi TLt|i*) t}?U@?|*) hi*@|i_ |L i@h??}t

? ML| UL?|hitc @*|L} |i i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu |iti 4L_i*t t |?) `i @hi L?*)

@M*i |L i T*@? ff.I Lu |i @h@?Ui ? i@h??}t M) @h@|L? ? ThL|t uLh 6hi?U 4i?

? 4@?u@U|h?}c *i i i T*@? t*}|*) 4Lhi Ef2.I Lu |i @h@?Ui ? Lh@) Ai i|ihL}i?iLt M@h}@??} TLih 4L_i* _Lit ?L| @__ ii? @ ?_hi_| Lu @ TihUi?|@}i TL?|

|L |i i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? 6h@?Uic @*|L} | _Lit 4ThLi |i i T*@?@|Lh) TLih L? |i Lhi}@? _@|@ M) S L?i?_hi_|t Lu @ TihUi?|@}i TL?|

#itT|i |i u@U| |@| |iti 4L_i*t @i *L i T*@?@|Lh) TLihc |i t}?U@?Ui Lu |i ThL| ULiUi?| t |i TL?| Lu ?|ihit| Ai t}?U@?Ui Lu |t it|4@|i 4@) Mi @h|U@**)

?@|i_ |hL} @? it|4@|L? Lu |t t|@?_@h_ ihhLh |@| t M@ti_ _L?@h_t *|ih?@|i*)c

|i ULiUi?| it|4@|i |ti*u 4@) Mi M@ti_c Mi | |hL} L4||i_ @h@M*itc i?_L}i?i|) Lh

e 5|@|t|U@* Wttit

W? |t tiU|L?c i @__hitt |L t|@|t|U@* ttit |@| UL*_ @giU| |i it|4@|i_ t}?U@?Ui Lu Lh ThL|t @h@M*i 6ht|c i UL?t_ih |i TLttM*|) Lu }hLT igiU|t ? |i UL@h@?Ui 4@|h Lu |i ihhLhtc U UL*_ M@t |i it|4@|i_ t|@?_@h_ ihhLht |L@h_t 3ihL 5iUL?_c i _tUtt |i 4T@U| |@| 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh L*_ @i L? Lh it|4@|it

e BhLT ,giU|t

W? @? i*i}@?| i ihUtic L*|L? Ebbf _i4L?t|h@|i_ L @? i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*i |@| @t UL4T*i|i*) ?hi*@|i_ |L |i L|UL4i Lu ?|ihit| 4}| Mi it|4@|i_ |L @i @ t}?U@?|

hi*@|L? u |i @*it Lu |t @h@M*i ihi UL44L? @UhLtt 4@?) ?__@*t ? |i t@4i }hLT *|L} t i @4T*i hiuihhi_ |L @h@M*it |@| ihi UL?t|@?| @UhLtt @** ?__@*t

? |i t@4i t|@|ic uLh Lh @?@*)tt i @hi UL?Uih?i_ | }hLT igiU|t ?_Ui_ M) |i u@U|

|@| @** ?__@*t ? Lh _@|@ |@| @hi i4T*L)i_ M) |i t@4i h4 ? @ }i? )i@h ** @i

@UhLtt?__@* @h@|L? ? ThL|t |? |i t@4i h4 ? @ }i? )i@hc t?Ui |i ?_Uit

@hi Lu |i uLh4 aEc |c |

W? Lh _@|@c i @i EL? @ih@}i efD LMtih@|L?t Tih h4 Tih )i@h ? 6h@?Uic @?_

2S2 Tih h4 Tih )i@h ? Lh@)c^e @*|L} |t 4i@thi _it @ _i @hi|) ? h4 t3it

47Uhfdoo wkdw rxu Qruzhjldq gdwd lv gudzq iurp uhjlvwu| lqirupdwlrq dqg frqwdlqv doo Qruzhjldq hvwdeolvk0

b

(12)

Ai Thiti?Ui Lu tU }hLT igiU|t UL*_ *i@_ |L *i@t| t^@hit t|@?_@h_ ihhLht |@| @hi M@ti_

_L?@h_tc @?_ |t Lihit|4@|it Lu |i t}?U@?Ui Lu |i ThL| ULiUi?|

L_i* WW ? |@M*it @?_ @TT*it |i ULhhiU|L? uLh }hLT igiU|t @t ThLTLti_ M) OMih EbS. @?_ `|i EbHf ^D 5?Ui |t ULhhiU|L? L?*) U@?}it |i it|4@|i_ UL@h@?Ui 4@|h uLh |i it|4@|i_ ULiUi?|tc |i T@h@4i|iht @?_ +t^@hi_ _L ?L| U@?}i `i ?L|i

@ U*i@h ?Uhi@ti Lu @TThL 4@|i*) @ u@U|Lh S ? 6h@?Ui @?_ @ u@U|Lh D ? Lh@) uLh |i L4L}i?iLt 4L_i*c *i |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh ?Uhi@tit 4Lhi |@? uLhuL*_ uLh |i UL?t|@?|

|ih4 ? |i i|ihL}i?iLt 4L_i* ? 6h@?Ui E|i ?Uhi@ti t t|** DuL*_ ? Lh@)c M| |t t ?L| tUi?| |L hi_Ui |i it|4@|i_ |t|@|t|U L? |i *ii* ThL|t |ih4 Mi*L bS ?

@MtL*|i @*i ? @?) Lu |i uLh U@tit W| tL*_ Mi ?L|i_c Liihc |@| |i _iUhi@t?}

tT*?i |ih4t @hi ?L t}?U@?| ? ?i|ih 6h@?Ui ?Lh Lh@)c @?_ |i ?Uhi@t?} tT*?i |ih4 MiUL4it 4@h}?@**) t}?U@?| ? 6h@?Ui `| |iti UL?t_ih@|L?t ? 4?_c i UL?|?i |L

@TT*) |i }hLT igiU|t ULhhiU|L? |L |i it|4@|i_ UL@h@?Ui 4@|hUit ? @** Lu 4L_i*t i it|4@|i Mi*Lc | |i i UiT|L? Lu |Lti |@| @UUL?| uLh ?LMtihi_ h4 i|ihL}i?i|) t?Ui |iti 4L_i*t i T*U|*) 4L_i* |i }hLT igiU|^S

e2 i@thi4i?| ,hhLh

Bi? |@| |i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih hi4@?t t}?U@?| ? @ *i@t| t^@hit 4L_i*

|@| ULhhiU|t uLh }hLT igiU|t @| |i h4 *ii*c | t tiu* |L UL?t_ih |i hL*i |@| 4i@thi 4i?| ihhLh 4}| @i L? Lh it|4@|it W| t hi@tL?@M*i |L i TiU| |@| Lh ThL|t Tih Lh!ih

@h@M*i 4}| Mi 4i@thi_ | ihhLhc t?Ui | t _ihi_ uhL4 @UUL?|?} t|@|i4i?|t |@|

@hi uLh@h_i_ |L |i }Lih?4i?| uLh |@ hi@tL?t E@4L?} L|ihtc @?_ |i |@ UL_it @**L

h4t |L tThi@_ *Lttit L| Lih |4i |L hi_Ui |i |@ Mh_i? ? }ThL| )i@ht ,i? ?

|i @Mti?Ui Lu i T*U| Tih4ttL?c h4t U@? Lu|i? tu| @UUL?|?} hiUi@M*it @?_ T@)@M*it

?L| @ t4T*ic @__|i @?_ ?ULhhi*@|i_ 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc M| h@|ih | t 4i@?hiih|?}c

phqwv lq pdqxidfwxulqj/ zlwk doo lqglylgxdov dw hdfk hvwdeolvkphqw +djjuhjdwhg xs wr wkh hqwhusulvh ohyho,/

zkhuhdv rxu Iuhqfk gdwd lv d 4258 vdpsoh ri lqglylgxdov/ iru zklfk zh kdyh nhsw wkh revhuydwlrqv fruuhvsrqg0 lqj wr pdqxidfwxulqj dqg djjuhjdwhg wr wkh hqwhusulvh +up, ohyho1 Fruuhfwlqj iru vdpsolqj udwhv lpsolhv wkdw Iuhqfk hqwhusulvhv kdyh dq +hpsor|phqw zhljkwhg, dyhudjh hpsor|phqw ri mxvw ryhu 433 lqglylgxdov shu

|hdu1

48Rxu dqdo|vlv zdv fduulhg rxw lq Vwdwd/ dqg wkxv wkh Ryhu/ Mroolh dqg Irvwhu +4<<9, surfhgxuh iru vwdqgdug huuruv lq wkh suhvhqfh ri jurxs hhfwv zkhuh wkh jurxslqj yduldeoh lv nqrzq lv suhsurjudpphg lq wkh _foxvwhu%

rswlrq1 Vhh VwdwdFrus +4<<<, / s1 4:;04:< iru wkh h{solflw irupxodh1

49Lw lv zruwk qrwlqj d whfkqlfdo srlqw wkdw uhqghuv wkh huuru vwuxfwxuh ri wkh {hg hhfwv prghov voljkwo|

glhuhqw wkdq wkdw zlwk wkh jurxs hhfwv fruuhfwlrq phqwlrqhg khuh1 Lq wklv vhfwlrq/ zh frqvlghu d jurxs wr eh d xqltxh up0|hdu xqlw1 Lq wkh {hg hhfwv prghov/ wkh xqlw frqvlghuhg lv mxvw wkh up 1 Wkhuh h{lvw |hdu lqglfdwruv lq wkh {hg hhfwv prghov/ exw zh gr qrw h{solfwo| prgho wkh lqwhudfwlrq ri wkh {hg hhwv zlwk wkh |hdu lqglfdwruv ehorz lq wkh pdqqhu wkdw zh gr khuh1

f

(13)

? |i ti?ti |@| )i@ht | T@h|U*@h*) } ThL|t ** @i _iU*@hi_ ThL|t ?_ihhiTLh|?}

|i |hi @*ic @?_ )i@ht | } *Lttit ** @i _iU*@hi_ ThL|t E*Lttit LihhiTLh|?}

|hi ThL|t ELhc i^@*i?|*)c ?_ihhiTLh|?} |hi *Lttit^.

Ai t|@?_@h_ 4T*U@|L? Lu 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc ic @__|i _ |i?Lti |)Ti 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc t @? @||i?@|L? M@t ? |i it|4@|i_ ULiUi?|c @?_ ?_ih t|@?_@h_

UL?_|L?t Lu ?ULhhi*@|i_ 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh Lih |4ic |i @||i?@|L? M@t t ?Uhi@ti_

i? T@?i* _@|@ |iU?^it tU |i |? @?_ ht|_gihi?Ui it|4@|Lht @hi ti_ EBh*Uit

@?_ O@t4@? bHS W? |i uL**L?} i **c Liihc @h}i |@| |i @||i?@|L? M@t uLh ThL|t _i |L |i ti Lu @ i_ igiU| it|4@|Lh t ?L| ?iUitt@h*) ?Uhi@ti_ @t UL4T@hi_

|L |i UhLtt tiU|L? @||i?@|L? M@tc @?_ |@| @UUL?|?} uLh 4i@? hiih|?} E?i}@|i*) ULhhi*@|i_ 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh U@?}it |i M@t uLh4*@i ii? 4Lhi

5TTLti |@| E4TihuiU|*) 4i@thi_ ThL|tc Zc|c U@? Mi h||i? @t Zc| 'Z_c|^W nDc|

ihi Z^W_c| q fc j_Z²^W

c|

t |i |hi ThL|t @?_ D q Efc j²_D t |i 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh tt4?} UL

Z_c|^W c Dc|

' fc |i t|@?_@h_ |i | MLL! hit*| t |@| |i ThLTLh|L?@* M@t ? it|4@|?} q t?} w5 t

R*4 q 'q j²_Z^W j²_Z^Wnj²

ihij²_ZW@?_j²@hi |i @h@?Uit Lu |i |hi ThL|t @?_ |i 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc hitTiU|i*) At 4T*it |@| |i it|4@|i Lu |i igiU| Lu ThL|t ** Mi @||i?@|i_ ? }i?ih@* Lc ?|hL _U?} ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? |i |hi ThL|t @?_ |i 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc icSJEZ_c|^W c v_c|9' fc

|i ThLTLh|L?@* M@t @t |i uL**L?} i ThittL?

R*4 q 'qj²_Z^W jZ^W

jZ^Wnj² E2

tLt |@| | @ ?i}@|i hi*@|L?tT Mi|ii? |i 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh @?_ |i |hi ThL|tc U i @h}i t |i U@ti i? UL?t_ih?} @UUL?|?} ThL|tc |i M@t U@? Mi t4@**ih |@?

? |i U*@ttU@* U@ti

L| Lu |i ThiLt hit*|t U@hh) Lih |L |i U@ti Lu T@?i* _@|@c M| ?L i @*tL @i |L

|@!i ?|L UL?t_ih@|L? |i U@?}it ? |hi ThL|t @?_ 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh @?_ |t TLttM*i

4:Wr dyrlg frqixvlrq/ lw vkrxog eh qrwhg wkdw wklv h{shfwhg phdq0uhyhuvlrq lq wkh phdvxuhphqw huuru whup grhv qrw lpso| dxwrfruuhodwlrq lq uhsruwhg surwv shu vh/ dowkrxjk lw pljkw whqg wr h{djjhudwh wkh lpsuhvvlrq ri wkh suhvhqfh ri d xqlw urrw lq d jlyhq up*v surwv shu zrunhu wlph vhulhv1 Wkh suhflvh hhfw zrxog dovr ghshqg rq wkh dxwruhjuhvvlyh surshuwlhv ri wkh up*v hpsor|phqw wlph vhulhv1

(14)

@|LULhhi*@|L? ? |hi ThL|t @?_ |i ihhLh Wu |i ht|_gihi?Ui i_ igiU| it|4@|Lh t ti_ | U@? Mi tL? |@| EBh*Uit @?_ O@t4@? bHS

R*4 q @?e, 'q dE4Z^W*E4voj_Z²^W

dE4_Z^W*E4_voj²_ZWnj² E

`i|ih |i ?UL?tt|i?U) Lh @||i?@|L? M@t _i |L E|i ?Lti 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh t

*@h}ih uLh |i T@?i* it|4@|Lh |@? |i w5 it|4@|Lh _iTi?_t L? |i hi*@|i t3i Lu 4_Z^W

@?_ 4_vcihi 4_Z^W ' SJ

Z_c|^W c Z^W_c|3

*@o Z_c|^W

@?_ 4_v ' SJEv_c|c v_c|3*@oEv_c| Nt@**)

|i @h}4i?| t |@| 4_Z^W:4_vc t?Ui @ ULhhi*@|L? ? |i |hi @*it @hi i TiU|i_c *i 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh t tTTLti_ |L Mi hi*@|i*) ?_iTi?_i?| Lih |4i Etiic uLh i @4T*ic

*|L? EbHS uLh |i U@ti Lu @}i U@?}it Ai hi@tL? ) |i @||i?@|L? M@t ?Uhi@tit _i |L 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh t |@| _gihi?U?} ?Uhi@tit |i ?Lti |L t}?@* h@|L ? |i L|ih

@?_c u4_Z^W 4_vc |i UL?U*tL? t LTTLt|i( |i @||i?@|L? t *Lih t?} @ T@?i* it|4@|Lh

|@? w5 EBh*Uit @?_ O@t4@? bHS 6h|ih4Lhic ?U*_?} @*tL @ ?i}@|i ULhhi*@|L?

Mi|ii? Z_c|^W @?_ D_c| 4T*it |@| |i hi*@M*|) Lu |i hit*|t uhL4 |i T@?i* it|4@|Lh t

?Uhi@ti_ @t tL? ? |i ThiLt i^@|L? EL?_ @?_ khi}ih bb

t @ hit*|c |i it|4@|i_ igiU| Lu ThL|t Lh hi?|t L? i@h??}t ** }i?ih@**) Mi @ *Lih ML?_ uLh |i |hi igiU| i? L?i _Lit ?L| ULhhiU| uLh 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh ? ThL|t 6h|ih 4Lhic | t ?L| LMLt |@| |i @||i?@|L? M@t ?Uhi@tit i? i ti T@?i* _@|@ it|4@|Lht

|L UL?|hL* uLh h4 Lh Lh!ih i_ igiU|t ? Lh @?@*)tit ? tiU|L?t H @?_ b Mi*L Oi?Uic u |i it|4@|i_ igiU| Lu ThL|t t i@!i?i_ i? @ i_ igiU| it|4@|Lh t ti_ |L UL?|hL*

uLh ?LMtihi_ Lh!ih Lh h4 i|ihL}i?i|)c | t *!i*) _i |L |i i_ igiU|t @?_ ?L| _i

|L @? i @UihM@|i_ 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh ThLM*i4

W| tL*_ Mi ?L|i_ |@| i @i ?L @*|ih?@|i tLhUit Lu ?uLh4@|L? L? R|hi ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |@| i 4}| ti |L ^@?|u) |i 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh ThLM*i4c @?_ i @i ?L i T*U| ThLh Mi*iut UL?Uih??} |i t3it ELh ii? |i hi*@|i t3it Lu |i @hLt UL4TL?i?|t Lu i ThittL?t E2 Lh E |@| 4}| }_i t ? @ TLttM*i ULhhiU|L? uLh |t M@t `i _Lc Liihc @i ?t|h4i?|t Etii tiU|L? . Mi*L W?t|h4i?|?} @ @h@M*i 4i@thi_ | ihhLh ** hi_Ui |i @h@M*|) ? |i ?t|h4i?|i_ @h@M*i ? |i 4L_i* Ei^@|L? c U

** |i?_ |L Lgti| |i @__|L?@* @h@M*|) ? |i @h@M*i ?|hL_Ui_ M) |i 4i@thi4i?|

ihhLhc @?_ |ihiM) hi_Ui |i M@t

D W?|ihW?_t|h) ,@h??}t #gihi?|@tc t?itt ) Uit @?_ 5iU|Lh@* 5LU!t

?i 4TLh|@?| @*|ih?@|i i T*@?@|L? |L |@| Lu hi?| t@h?} t |@| Lu ?|ih?_t|h) @}i _gihi?|@*t t ?L|i_ @MLi ? tiU|L? 2c Uih|@? tiU|Lht |i?_ |L T@) R@MLi 4@h!i| @}itc

2

(15)

ii? @u|ih UL?|hL**?} uLh 4Lt| LMtih@M*i ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut W| t UL4T*i|i*) TLttM*i

|@| |iti tiU|Lht @*tL @TTi? |L Mi |i 4Lt| ThL|@M*i tiU|Lhtc @?_ |t |i @MLi 4@h!i|

@}it @hi t4T*) |i hit*| Lu UL4Ti||L? L? |i _i4@?_ t_i Lu |ih *@MLh 4@h!i| 6h4t ? ThL|@M*i tiU|Lht U@? T@) 4Lhi |@? |Lti ? *itt ThL|@M*i tiU|Lhtc @*|L} |t Thi44 t

?L| @ _tL? Lu |i T@h|U*@h h4<t hi?|t Tih ti W? |i UL?|i | Lu tiU|L? c |t @4L?|t

|L UL?t_ih?} |@| _i4@?_t_i UL4Ti||L? M_t T

W? @ 4Lhi }i?ih@* uLh4*@|L?c |i iUL?L4) @t L*ic Lh t| @ tiU|Lh Lu |i iUL?L4)c 4@) Mi tMiU| |L _i4@?_ tLU!t |@| ?Uhi@ti hii?it W? Lh_ih |L t@|tu) |i @__|L?@*

_i4@?_c h4t ** |)TU@**) hitLh| E@| *i@t| ? |i tLh|h? |L Lih|4i t@}i MiuLhi @__?}

Lh!iht t |ihi t @ Thi44 ? Lih|4i T@)c |t ?_Uit @ tThLt ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii?

} @}it @?_ } ThL|t |@| t ?_iTi?_i?| Lu @ h4<t _iUtL? |L t@hi hi?|t^H

@ iU|Lh Lu |4i @?_ tiU|Lh ?_U@|Lhtc @?_ |ih ?|ih@U|L?tc @t

l_c|' 5 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 99 97

t|'|4?

_t|'|_4@

t7EaEc|'7eS|4?

t7EaEc|'7eS|4@

t|'|4?t7EaEc|'7eS|4?

_t|'|_4?t7EaEc|'7eS|4@

t|'|4@ t7EaEc|'7eS|4?

_t|'|_4@t7EaEc|'7eS|4@

6 :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :: :8

c

ihi |4? t |i i@h*it| _@|i ? Lh _@|@c |4@ t |i *@|it| _@|i ? Lh _@|@c7eS|4? t |i

ht| tiU|Lh ? Lh _@|@c^b7eS|4@ t |i *@t| tiU|Lh ? Lh _@|@c^2f7E t @ u?U|L? |@| 4@Tt

h4 _i?|iht |L tiU|Lh _i?|ihtc @?_ tu t @? ?_U@|Lh u?U|L? |@| |@!it L? |i @*i

i? |i tMtUhT|i_ i*i4i?| t |hic @?_ f L|ihti `| |t ?L|@|L?c i U@? h|i

4;Wklv lv rqh ri pdq| srvvleoh h{sodqdwlrqv wkdw zrxog lqgxfh d srvlwlyh fruuhodwlrq ehwzhhq sd| dqg surwv dqg wkdw zrxog eh fdswxuhg e| d vhw ri lqgxvwu|/ |hdu dqg lqgxvwu|0|hdu lqglfdwru yduldeohv1 Rwkhuv lqfoxgh lqfuhdvhg ghpdqg0vlgh frpshwlwlrq lq +srvvleo| vshfldol}hg, oderu pdunhwv/ jhqhudo htxloleulxp hhfwv/

fkdqjlqj sd|uroo wd{hv/ hwf111

4<Xvlqj wkh LVLF uhylvlrq 6 frghv dw wkh 5 gljlw ohyho/ wklv lv wkh pdqxidfwxuh ri irrg surgxfwv dqg ehyhudjhv +LVLF 48, vhfwru1

53Xvlqj wkh LVLF uhylvlrq 6 frghv dw wkh 5 gljlw ohyho/ wklv lv wkh uhf|folqj +LVLF 6:, vhfwru1

(16)

|i tTiUU@|L? it|4@|i_ ? 4L_i* WWW ? |@M*i @t

_c| 'q_fnZ_aEc|c|qnl_c|q₂n0_c|c Ee h hit*|t t}}it| |@| tiU|Lh@* tLU!t _L ?_ii_ ?i?Ui |i hi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t

@?_ i@h??}t ? Lh@)c @*|L} |i 4T@U| t ?L| ih) *@h}i Ai ULiUi?| L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih _hLTt uhL4 I |L 2I Lu ThL|t }L?} |L Lh!iht ? 6h@?Uic @?_ uhL4 2DI |L 22I ? Lh@) ? |i L4L}i?iLt tTiUU@|L?tc @*|L} ? |i i|ihL}i?iLt M@h}@??}

TLih tTiUU@|L? |i t@hi }L?} |L Lh!iht ? 6h@?Ui @U|@**) ?Uhi@tit uhL4 HI |L bI i? )i@h @?_ tiU|Lh UL?|hL*t @hi @__i_c ihi@t |i t@hi Lu ThL|t Tih Lh!ih }L?} |L i4T*L)iit ? Lh@) _hLTt ? |t tTiUU@|L? @t i** EuhL4 I |L 2HIAi u@U| |@|

|i 4Li4i?|t ? |i ULiUi?|t @hi _gihi?| ? |i i|ihL}i?iLt tTiUU@|L?t 4@) Mi hi*@|i_ |L |i u@U| |@| |i tT*?i |ih4t ihi @*hi@_) U@T|h?}c ? T@h|c |i igiU| Lu tLU!t

? ThL|t L? @}it

At _gihi?Ui ? *ii*t Mi|ii? |i 6hi?U @?_ Lhi}@? hit*|t U@? Mi @| *i@t| T@h

|@**) i T*@?i_ M) |i u@U| |@| Lih Lh t@4T*i TihL_ EbH.bbDc bbf @?_ bb i U*_i_ ? 6h@?Uic tiU|Lh*ii* UL**iU|i @}hii4i?|t @_ MiUL4i ?Uhi@t?}*) hhi*i@?| |L

@}i _i|ih4?@|L?c² ihi@t tiU|Lh*ii* UL**iU|i @}hii4i?|t t|** T*@) @? 4TLh|@?| hL*i

? @}i _i|ih4?@|L? ? Lh@) 6h|ih i_i?Ui Lu |t UL4it uhL4 |i _h@4@|U 4 ThLi4i?| ? |i 4L_i*<t i T*@?@|Lh) TLih i? tiU|Lh@* tLU!t @hi @__i_c | Lih . TihUi?| Lu |i @h@?Ui ? i@h??}t Mi?} i T*@?i_ t4T*) M) ThL|t @?_ tiU|Lh tLU!t ? |i i|ihL}i?iLt M@h}@??} TLih 4L_i* ? Lh@) Ehi*@|i |L % Lu @ TihUi?| |L| |iti tLU!t Ai hi*@|i 4ThLi4i?| ? i T*@?@|Lh) TLih t ii? *@h}ih ? 6h@?Ui E.%ff Lu @ TihUi?| |L 2HIc @*|L} |i 4L_i* hi4@?t u@h*) TLLh i? 4i@thi_ M) |i +t^@hi_

t|@|t|U

S Mtih@Mi W?__@ Oi|ihL}i?i|)

u ULhtic | t Th@U|U@**) ihit) @4L?} *@MLh iUL?L4t|t |L it|4@|i @| @4L?|t |L

@? i@h??}t i^@|L? |L| UL?t_ih?} LMtih@M*i ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut²² W| t ^|i

*!i*) |@| |i ThL| ULiUi?| t tMiU| |L tL4i L4||i_ @h@M*i M@tc _i |L |i @Mti?Ui Lu @h@M*it EtU @t |Lti hi*@|i_ |L |i 4@? U@T|@* t|LU! Lu |i Lh! uLhUi |@| L*_

@giU| t4*|@?iLt*) |i h4<t ThL|t EM) 4ThL?} ThL_U||) @?_ @}it Et?Ui |iti U@h@U|iht|Ut @i @*i L? |i *@MLh 4@h!i| W? |ih4t Lu i^@|L? Ec |t 4T*it @

54Vhh Pdujrolv +4<<6, iru ghwdlov1

55Lw vkrxog eh qrwhg wkdw dqdo|vhv ri uhqw0vkdulqj wkdw duh edvhg rq up0vlgh gdwd gr suhflvho| wklv/

e

(17)

ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? |i ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |ih4 @?_ |i _t|hM@?Ui Lu |i 4L_i* |@| UL*_

M@t it|4@|it Luq

6Lh4@**)c |t t}}it|t @ tTiUUu@|L? uLh Lh i@h??}t 4L_i* @*L?} |i *?it Lu

c|'qfnZaEc|c|qnlc|q2nfc|qn0c|c ED

|f_c|Mi?} @ ti| Lu LMtih@M*i ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut² Wu i^@|L? D ThL_it |i |hi tTiUU@|L?c |i *i@t| t^@hit it|4@|Lh uLhq ** Mi qe '

ZdlcfoZ₃

Zdlcfo^2e wi@t|

t^@hit it|4@|it Luq _ihi_ uhL4 i^@|L? e ** Mi Lu |i uLh4qh '

Z_dloZ₃

Z_dlo Wu .EZf 9' fc |i? qh 9' qe At ** |)TU@**) Mi |i U@ti u Lh!iht | 4Lhi 4@?

U@T|@* |i?_ |L Mi 4Lhi ThL_U|i @?_ |i *@MLh 4@h!i| t ?L| TihuiU|*) UL4Ti||i EtL

|@| |ihi t @ }@T Mi|ii? |i @}i @?_ |i @*i Lu 4@h}?@* ThL_U|^2D

L*4? WV Lu |@M*i Thiti?|t |i hit*|t Lu it|4@|?} tTiUU@|L? D W? ML| 6h@?Ui

@?_ Lh@)c |i @__i_ hi}hittLht i?|ih ?|L |i 4L_i* ? @ }*) t}?U@?| 4@??ihc @?_

|i i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu ML| 4L_i*t ? ML| UL?|hit ?Uhi@tit M) @ u@U|Lh Lu hL}*) 2. A@| t@_c |i it|4@|i_ ULiUi?|t _iUhi@ti L?*) t*}|*)c @?_ @ O@t4@? Eb.H |it|

_Lit ?L| hiiU| |i _i?||) Lu |i |L ULiUi?|t L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? 4L_i*t WWW @?_

WV ? i|ih tTiUU@|L? W? L|ih Lh_tc |i t}?U@?Ui Lu ThL|t ? |i _i|ih4?@|L? Lu i@h??}t t ?L| t4T*) _i |L @? L4||i_ @h@M*i M@t^2S

. ,?_L}i?i|) Lu hL|t

AL |t TL?|c i @i u@*i_ |L i T*@? @@) |i t}?U@?Ui Lu |i ThL|t Tih Lh!ih

@h@M*i ? @? i@h??}t i^@|L? L? 4i? ? 4@?u@U|h?} ? 6h@?Ui @?_ Lh@) M) t4T*i

*i@t| t^@hitM@ti_ |iU?^it @?_ M) *i@t| t^@hit @UUL?|?} uLh }hLT igiU|t ?i L|ih TLttM*i i T*@?@|L? uLh |t t}?U@?Uic Liihc t |@| ThL|t @hi i?_L}i?Lt |L @}it

`i? @}it ?Uhi@ti E@** i*ti i*_ i^@*c ThL|t u@** t?Ui @}it hiThiti?| |i ULt| Lu

|i *@MLh ?T| |L ThL_U|L?^2. u ULhtic |i 4T*i_ ULhhi*@|L? ihi t ?i}@|ic U

56Lq rxu fdvh/ zh frqvlghu wkh iroorzlqj lqglylgxdo revhuydeoh fkdudfwhulvwlfv= qxpehu ri |hduv ri hgxfdwlrq dqg lwv vtxduh/ mre vhqlrulw| dqg lwv vtxduh/ dqg srwhqwldo oderu pdunhw h{shulhqfh/ lwv vtxduh/ fxeh dqg irxuwk srzhu1 Qrwh wkdw wkh rqo| wlph0lqyduldqw lqglylgxdo fkdudfwhulvwlfv khuh duh wkh qxpehu ri |hduv ri hgxfdwlrq dqg lwv vtxduh1

57Wklv lv d vlpsoh dssolfdwlrq ri wkh Iulvfk0Zdxjk+0Oryhoo, wkhruhp +vhh Juhhqh +4<<:, iru ghwdlov,1 Lq wklv qrwdwlrq/ P^` lv wkh pdwul{ wkdw surmhfwv rqwr wkh vsdfh ruwkrjrqdo wr wkh yhfwru lq wkh vxevfulsw1

58Derzg hw do1 +4<<<, qg wkdw wklv lv lqghhg wkh fdvh iru Iudqfh ehwzhhq 4<:9 dqg 4<;</ xvlqj d vshfl0 fdwlrq vlplodu wr wkh rqh zh zloo xvh lq vhfwlrq < ehorz1

59Dowkrxjk fhuwdlq frhflhqwv lq prgho LY lq wdeohv 4d dqg 4e kdyh xqh{shfwhg vljqv/ lw lv zruwk uhfdoolqj wkdw zh hvwlpdwh rxu prghov lq ohyhov/ dqg qrw lq orjv1 Wklv pdnhv rxu uhvxowv qrw gluhfwo| frpsdudeoh wr wkrvh lq wkh pdmrulw| ri wkh hduqlqjv ghwhuplqdwlrq olwhudwxuh1

5:Lw vkrxog eh qrwhg wkdw vrph vwudqgv ri wkh olwhudwxuh/ qrwdeo| wkh frqwulexwlrqv ri Mrkq Derzg dqg frdxwkruv +Derzg dqg Doodlq +4<<9, / Derzg dqg Ohplhx{ +4<<6, ,/ irfxv h{solflwo| rq wkh vkduh ri wkh

D

(18)

t}}it|t |@| |i i?_L}i?i|) Lu ThL|t 4@) @U|@**) Mi M@t?} Lh ThiLt it|4@|it _L?@h_c @?_ |t |i |hi hi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ i@h??}t 4@) Mi ii? t|hL?}ih

|@? Thiti?|i_ ? |i 4L_i*t ? |@M*i

W? Lh_ih |L @UUL?| uLh |i TLttM*|) Lu i?_L}i?i|)c i hiit|4@|i i^@|L? D t?}

?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it h ?t|h4i?| ti| ?U*_it @** Lu |i @h@M*it UL?|@?i_ ? |i l

@?_f iU|Lhtc T*t |i ti| Lu @h@M*it ? |i~ ELh|L}L?@*3?} iU|Lh _itUhMi_ ? tiU|L?

b Mi*L 6h|ih4Lhic @t @__|L?@* i U*tL? hit|hU|L?tc i ?U*_i t@*it Tih Lh!ih^2H@?_

LTih@|?} tMt_it Tih Lh!ihc^2bML| UL?|i4TLh@?iLt @?_ L?Ui *@}}i_c @t ?t|h4i?|t uLh ThL|t Tih Lh!ih^f

W?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it it|4@|L? @t |i @__|L?@* @_@?|@}i |@|c u @ |i ?Lti 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh t Thiti?| ? ThL|tc |i igiU| Lu |t 4i@thi4i?| ihhLh M@t EU L*_ hi_Ui |i it|4@|i_ ULiUi?|c tii tiU|L? e2 L? |i it|4@|i_ ULiUi?| ** Mi i*4?@|i_ At t @?L|ih hi@tL?c Mi)L?_ t4T*i i?_L}i?i|)c |L i TiU| |i ?t|h4i?|@*

@h@M*it 4i|L_ |L )i*_ }ih TL?| it|4@|it |@? *i@t| t^@hit

L*4? V Lu |@M*i 2 ThL_it |i hit*|t Lu |t 4L_i*c 4@?|@??} |i ULhhiU|L? |L |i UL@h@?Ui 4@|h _i |L |i Thiti?Ui Lu }hLT igiU|t t t |)TU@* uLh ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it it|4@|L? Ehi*@|i |L *i@t| t^@hit it|4@|L? @*4Lt| @** Lu |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLht ?Uhi@tic 4Lt| T@h|U*@h*) |Lti L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih E@t i TiU|i_ W? |i U@ti Lu 6h@?Uic |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih t 2 |4it *@h}ih ? |i WV it|4@|it | }hLT igiU|t

|@? ? |i t@4i tTiUU@|L? M| ?_ih *i@t| t^@hit | }hLT igiU|t 6h|ih4Lhic |i it|4@|i_ +t^@hi_ ? 6h@?Ui MiUL4it ?i}@|i At t TLttM*i E? |iLh) @?_c @TT@hi?|*)c

? Th@U|Ui t?Ui |i ihhLh t4 Lu t^@hit t U@*U*@|i_ t?} |i LMtihi_ @*i Lu |i i?_L}i?Lt @h@M*i *i |i ULiUi?|t @hi it|4@|i_ | |i Thi_U|i_ @*i Lu |i i?_L}i?Lt @h@M*i At |i t4 Lu t^@hit Mi?} 4?43i_ M) |i *i@t| t^@hit |iU?^i

txdvl0uhqw shu zrunhu +uhqwv zkhq doo idfwruv duh sulfhg dw wkhlu rssruwxqlw| frvwv, wkdw jrhv wr zrunhuv/

udwkhu wkdq wkh vkduh ri surwv shu zrunhu1 Wklv phdvxuh lv qrw vxemhfw wr wkh vwudljkwiruzdug vrxufh ri hqgrjhqhlw| phqwlrqhg khuh/ dowkrxjk Derzg dqg Ohplhx{ +4<<6, pdnh d frqylqflqj fdvh iru txdvl0uhqwv shu zrunhu ehlqj hqgrjhqrxv wr zdjh ghwhuplqdwlrq qhyhuwkhohvv1

5;Rqh fdq wklqn ri vdohv shu zrunhu/ frqglwlrqdo rq wkh vhfwru ehlqj fruuhfwo| lghqwlhg/ uhsuhvhqwlqj d phdvxuh ri wkh up*v pdunhw srzhu1

5<Jrrovehh +4<<;, kdv udlvhg vrph grxewv derxw wkh ydolglw| ri rshudwlqj vxevlglhv/ zkhq lq wkh irup ri U)G vxevlglhv/ dv dq lqvwuxphqw iru surwv zkhq frqvlghulqj wkh hduqlqjv ri vflhqwlvwv dqg hqjlqhhuv1 Zh duh xqdeoh wr glvwlqjxlvk wkh w|sh ri rshudwlqj vxevlg| lq rxu gdwd/ dowkrxjk +e| wklv vwdjh, zh frqwuro iru wlph0ydu|lqj lqgxvwu|0vshflf vkrfnv/ dqg lq wkh qh{w wzr vwhsv zh frqwuro iru up dqg lqglylgxdo {hg hhfwv1

63Wkh uhvxowv ri wkh uvw vwhs lqvwuxphqwlqj htxdwlrqv duh jlyhq lq dsshqgl{ wdeoh 51 Lq erwk frxqwulhv rxu uvw0vwhs lqvwuxphqwlqj htxdwlrqv sdvv dq I0whvw iru wkh mrlqw vljqlfdqfh ri wkh lqvwuxphqwv dw wkh 3134( ohyho1 Whvwlqj wkh ydolglw| ri wkh lqvwuxphqwv e| lqfoxglqj wkhp lq wkh pdlq htxdwlrq dqg whvwlqj iru vljqlfdqfh vxjjhvwv wkdw odjjhg vxevlglhv/ dw ohdvw/ lv d ydolg lqvwuxphqw iru Iudqfh +ehlqj lqvljqlfdqw dw wkh 43( ohyho,/ zkloh frqwhpsrudqhrxv dqg odjjhg vdohv/ dqg frqwhpsrudqhrxv vxevlglhv duh ydolg h{foxvlrq uhvwulfwlrqv iru Qruzd| +e| wkh vdph fulwhulrq,1

S

(19)

LUUhhi?Ui t |)TU@**) @ t}? Lu i@! ?t|h4i?|tc @?_ |i *L i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu Lh E*@h}i ti| Lu UL@h@|it ? |i ht| t|iT i^@|L? EL?*) ffb.2 t}}it|t |@| |t t *!i*) |L Mi |i U@ti

OLiihc @t t}}it|i_ @MLic |i i?_L}i?i|) Lu ThL|t @t U*i@h*) M@t?} Lh it|4@|i_

*@h}ih ? 4L_i* V |@? ? 4L_i* WV uLh 6h@?Uic @*|L} | t t*}|*) t4@**ih ? Lh@)c i? L?i 4Lit uhL4 *i@t| t^@hit it|4@|L? |L ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it it|4@|L? #itT|i

|i u@U| |@| |i ?Uhi@ti ? |i TL?| it|4@|i t *@h}ic | t ?L| *@h}i i?L} hi*@|i |L |i

?Uhi@ti ? |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh |L 4@?|@? t}?U@?Ui uLh ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ? 6h@?Ui @| |i

fI *ii* E@*|L} | t t}?U@?| @| |i I *ii* hL|t Tih Lh!ih hi4@?t t}?U@?|

? Lh@) @| |i DI *ii*

H 6 i_ 6h45TiUU N?LMtihi_ Oi|ihL}i?i|)

?L|ih TLttM*|) t |@| |i ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? i@h??}t @?_ ThL|t t _i |L tL4i @tTiU|

Lu Lh! Lh}@?3@|L? Lh Lu |i ThL_U|L? ThLUitt |@| t tTiUU |L |i h4 hL_U|L?

ThLUittit ?L*?} _@?}ihLt Lh! |@| L*_ hi^hi T@)?} UL4Ti?t@|?} _gihi?|@*t M|

|@| @*tL U@? ThL_i |i h4 | }ih i TLt| ThL|tc Lh @? Lh}@?3@|L? Lu Lh! |@|

tMt|||it iUi?U) @}it E? @ 5@ThL @?_ 5|}*|3 EbHe c i^*Mh4 ?i4T*L)4i?|

|)Ti 4L_i* uLh tTihtL? @hi |L tLh|t Lu ?LMtih@M*ic h4 tTiUU U@h@U|iht|Ut |@|

UL*_ ?_Ui @ ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? LMtihi_ i@h??}t @?_ ThL|t |@| L*_ ?L| | ? |i hi?| t@h?} uh@4iLh!c t?Ui |i i@h??}t Thi44 _Lit ?L| U|@|i | _Lt)?Uh@|U U|@|L?t ? ThL|t ?Ui @}@?c |i 4T*U@|L? t |@| |ihi UL*_ Mi @ ULhhi*@|L?

Mi|ii? |i ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |ih4 @?_ |i _t|hM@?Ui Lu i^@|L? E |@| L*_ M@t it|4@|it Lu q

,t|4@|?} @ 4L_i* |@| @**Lt uLh tU ?LMtihi_ U@h@U|iht|Ut |L Mi ULhhi*@|i_ |

|i h4<t ThL|t hi^hit T@?i* _@|@ ? U @| *i@t| L?i TihtL? t LMtihi_ ? |i h4 uLh tiih@* )i@ht E?L| ?iUitt@h*) |i t@4i TihtL? ih @?_ @MLi |i u@U| |@| i ti Lh 4@|Ui_ Lh!ihh4 T@?i* _@|@ |L 4ih}i ? ThL|t |L i@U ?__@*<t i@h??}t LMtih@|L?tc

|t t @?L|ih UL?t|h@?| |L U L?*) _@|@ Lu |t tLh| U@? hitTL?_ OLiihc u L?i _Lit

64Rxu lqvwuxphqw vhw zdv fkrvhq vr dv wr lqfoxgh rqo| yduldeohv wkdw zhuh dydlodeoh iru erwk frxqwulhv/ dqg lq vdpsohv zlwk wkh odujhvw fryhudjh ri wkh pdqxidfwxulqj vhfwru1 Dgglwlrqdo lqvwuxphqwv ehfrph dydlodeoh +lq Iudqfh, zkhq fkrrvlqj qduurzhu hvwlpdwlrq vdpsohv/ exw wklv frphv dw wkh frvw ri uhgxflqj rxu delolw|

wr lghqwli| wkh up dqg zrunhu hhfwv lq vhfwlrq < ehorz +vhh Derzg hw do1 +4<<<,iru ghwdlov rq lghqwlfdwlrq lq wkh vhfwlrq < prgho,1

.

(20)

@i @ T@?i* ? |i h4 _4i?tL? | |4i @h@|L? ? ThL|tc @}it @?_ LMtih@M*itc L?i U@? it|4@|i |i 4L_i* ? _gihi?Uit uhL4 h4 4i@?t

6Lh4@**)c i _i?i |i iU|Lh Lu h4 ?_U@|Lht 8c|c ihi 8c| t Lu _4i?tL? a Eihi t |i ?4Mih Lu _gihi?| h4t ? |i t@4T*ic e.D uLh 6h@?Ui @?_ HeH uLh Lh@) @?_ @ |)TU@* i*i4i?| Lu 8c|c U@** | 8_c| c t @? ?_U@|Lh @h@M*i 8_c| ' taEc|' At i h|i |i 4L_i* i it|4@|i @t

c| 'qf nZ_aEc|c|qnlc|q2nfc|qn8c|qen0c| ES Bi? |@|

qe '

Zdlcfc8 oZ₃

Zdlcfc8 o ' k

Z_{d8 o} _dlcfo_{d8 o}Zl₃

Z_{d8 o} _dlcfo_{d8 o} c

|t t i^@*i?| |L |i hi}hittL? _itUhMi_ M) i^@|L? Dc ihi @** Lu |i @h@M*it _c|c Z_aEc|c|c l_c|c @?_ f_c| @hi hiT*@Ui_ M) |ih @*it _gihi?Ui_ uhL4 |? h4 4i@?t Lu |i

h4 'aEc | |@| |i ?__@* t ? @| _@|i c |

L*4? VW Lu |@M*i 2 Thiti?|t |iti hit*|t Ai i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu |i 4L_i* 4Tt _h@4@|U@**) ? 6h@?Ui |L |i TL?| ihi i U@? i T*@? hL}*) 2D TihUi?| Lu |i @h@?Ui

? *L} hi@* u** )i@h i^@*i?| i@h??}t M) Lh ti| Lu i T*@?@|Lh) @h@M*it @?_ |i h4 igiU|t

? ML| UL?|hitc ii? UL?t_ih?} |@| i @hi t|** ?t|h4i?|?} ThL|t Tih Lh!ih @?_ |t t^@hi EU hi_Uit |i i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu |i 4L_i* W? |t uh@4iLh!c |i ThiUtL?

Lu Th@U|U@**) @** Lu |i it|4@|i_ T@h@4i|iht ?Uhi@titc @?_ |i E?t|h4i?|i_ ThL|t Tih Lh!ih MiUL4it t}?U@?| @}@? ? 6h@?Ui

OLiihc |i 4Lt| ?L|@M*i igiU| Lu UL?|hL**?} uLh ?LMtihi_ i_ h4 i|ihL}i?i|) t

|i _iUhi@ti ? |i ThL| ULiUi?| |L hL}*) L?i |h_ Lu |i @*i uL?_ ? |i ?t|h4i?|@*

@h@M*it tTiUU@|L? ? 6h@?Uic² @*|L} |L @ *ii* |@| t hL}*) |4it @t *@h}i @t ?

|i 4Lt| UL4T*i|i *i@t| t^@hit tTiUU@|L? it|4@|i_ E4L_i* WV Ai TL?| it|4@|i ? Lh@) _iUhi@tit ii? 4Lhic M) eeI hi*@|i |L |i ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it it|4@|Lh At t}}it|t |@| |ihi t ?_ii_ ?LMtihi_ i|ihL}i?i|) ? h4 UL4Ti?t@|L? Th@U|Uit |@|

?_Uit @ tThLt TLt|i ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ i@h??}tc @*|L} ii? ? |i

@Mti?Ui Lu tU @ tThLt ULhhi*@|L?c _Lt)?Uh@|U U|@|L?t ? h4 ThL|t tii4 |L Mi

|h@?t4||i_ |hL} |L Lh!ih i@h??}t

b `Lh!ih @?_ 6h4 N?LMtihi_ Oi|ihL}i?i|)

?@* TLttM*i i T*@?@|L? uLh |i t}?U@?| hi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ i@h??}t |@| @t )i| |L Mi tTiUU@**) @__hitti_ t |i hL*i Lu ?LMtihi_ ?__@* U@h@U|iht|Ut ,i? u

65Wkh ghfuhdvh lq wkh surw frhflhqw iru Qruzd| lv pxfk ohvv vxevwdqwldo/ zklfk lv uhdvrqdeoh jlyhq wkdw wkh frhflhqw zdv hvwlpdwhg zlwk d pxfk kljkhu suhflvlrq lq prgho Y1

H

(21)

|i *?! Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ i@h??}t t ?L| @? @h|iu@U| Lu _gihi?Uit @UhLtt h4t Lih |4i ? 4@? U@T|@* @t 4i@thi_ M) i_U@|L?c LM ti?Lh|) @?_ TL|i?|@* i Tihi?Ui Eu | ihic

|i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t ? 4L_i* WV L*_ ?L *L?}ih @i Mii? t}?U@?|c | t TLttM*i

|@| |t igiU| t _i |L @h@|L?t ? |i UL4TLt|L? Lu |i Lh!uLhUi @*L?} ?LMtihi_

_4i?tL?t

6Lh i @4T*ic @ h4 4@) _iU_i |L ?Uhi@ti |i @ih@}i ^@*|) Lu |i ?L Lu Lh!iht EuLh

@ }i? ?4Mih Lu )i@ht Lu i_U@|L? @?_ i Tihi?Ui _h?} )i@ht ? U _i4@?_ uLh |t ThL_U| t @M?Lh4@**) }c | |i _i@ |@| i@U Lu |iti Lh!iht ** Mi 4Lhi ThL_U|i

?L| tgih |i ?i}@|i hiT|@|L?@* igiU|t |@| Mi?} @? ?hi*@M*i tTT*ih 4}| @i At Lh!ihtc @*|L} LMtih@|L?@**) E|L |i iUL?L4i|hU@? i^@*i?| |L *Lih ^@*|) Lh!ihtc ** |i?_ |L i@h? 4Lhi L? |i *@MLh 4@h!i| 6h|ih4Lhic |i ?Uhi@ti ? @ih@}i Lh!ih ^@*|) E@?_ |t @}it ** LUUh @| |i t@4i |4i @t h4t @hi @M*i |L ?Uhi@ti

|ih 4@h}?t E_i |L |i } _i4@?_ tLU!c @?_ |t @| @ |4i i? |i) ** Mi 4@!?}

}ih ThL|t Ai hit*| ** Mi @? LMtihi_ TLt|i hi*@|L? Mi|ii? i@h??}t @?_ ThL|tc ii? UL?_|L?@* L? @** Lu |i L|ih @h@M*it ?U*_i_ T ?|* ihic |@| t _i i U*ti*)

|L U@?}it ? Lh! uLhUi UL4TLt|L?c @?_ ?L| |L hi?| t@h?}

,t|4@|L? Lu tU @ 4L_i* t UL4T*U@|i_ Ai u** *i@t| t^@hit tL*|L?c ii? @u|ih _gihi?U?} |? ?__@*tc L*_ t|** *i@_ |L @ 4L_i* |L Mi it|4@|i_ M) *i@t| t^@hit Lu _4i?tL? i** Lih e.fff ? 6h@?Ui @?_ Lih 2fff ? Lh@) ML_ i| @* Ebbb ThL_i

@? iUL?L4i|hU |iU?^i |@| @**Lt t |L hiULih E?_ih Uih|@? UL?_|L?@* Lh|L}L?@*|)

@tt4T|L?t ?M@ti_ it|4@|Lht Lu @** Lu |i T@h@4i|iht Lu ?|ihit| ? Lh 4L_i*c @?_ ? T@h|U*@h |i iU|Lh Lu ULiUi?|tq Wu i _i?i @ iU|Lh Lu ?__@* ?_U@|Lh @h@M*itc (c|c ? @ 4@??ih t4*@h |L |i _i?|L? Lu 8c| ? tiU|L? H @MLic i U@? h|i |i 4L_i*

Lu ?|ihit| @t

c| 'qfnZaEc|c|qnlc|q2 nfc|qn8c|qen(c|qD n0c| E.

Ai _i@ t |L ?_ @ ti| Lu @h@M*it ~ tU |@| .

Zd~o8

' fc .

ld~o8 ' fc .

fd~o8

' f @?_ .

(d~o8

c| 'qfnZaEc|c|qnlc|q2nfc|qn(c|qD n~c|bn0c| EH M) _gihi?Uit uhL4 |??__@* 4i@?t |L hiULih UL?tt|i?| it|4@|it Luq @?_ q2 @?_

Lu |i |4i@h)?} UL4TL?i?|t Lu q __|L?@* t|iTt @hi ?ii_i_ |L hiULih qe @?_ |L

66Iru wkh sxusrvhv ri wklv sdshu/ zh ghqhg wkh wkh ] yhfwru dv wkh wkh vhw ri lqwhudfwlrqv ri hgxfdwlrq dqg dyhudjh +ryhu doo revhuydwlrqv iru wkh lqglylgxdo, h{shulhqfh zlwk wkh vhw ri 55 lqgxvwu| lqglfdwruv/

dyhudjh up vl}h/ dyhudjh vdohv dqg dyhudjh rshudwlqj vxevlglhv +doo ryhu wkh vhw ri |hduv ri gdwd dydlodeoh iru wkh hpsor|hu,1 Irupdoo|/ wklv lv wkh nurqhfnhu surgxfw ri wkh 50glphqvlrqdo yhfwru ri {hg lqglylgxdo fkdudfwhulvwlfv dqg wkh 580glphqvlrqdo yhfwru ri {hg up fkdudfwhulvwlfv1

b

(22)

tiT@h@|i*) _t|?}t q_D uhL4 |i |4i?@h@?| UL4TL?i?| Luq 6?@**)c @ ULhhiU|L? E|L ULhhiU|*) 4i@thi |i ihhLh t4 Lu t^@hit @?_ |L @UUL?| uLh |i ihhLh _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 t @*tL ?ii_i_ ? Lh_ih |L hiULih @? it|4@|i Lu |i UL@h@?Ui 4@|h Lu |i it|4@|i_

T@h@4i|iht^e

L*4? VWW Lu |@M*i 2 ThL_it |i hit*|t Lu it|4@|?} |t 4Lt| UL4T*U@|i_c @?_

4Lt| i?UL4T@tt?} tTiUU@|L? W? |t tTiUU@|L?c @** |4i?@h@?| tLhUit Lu tThLt ULhhi*@|L? L? |i h4 @?_ Lh!ih t_i @hi i*4?@|i_c @?_ @ *@h}i t@hi Lu |i LMtih@M*i

|4i@h)?} U@h@U|iht|Ut @hi UL?|hL**i_ uLh @t i** 6h|ih4Lhic i @hi t|** ?t|h4i?|?}

ThL|tc |L UL?|hL* uLh TLttM*i i?_L}i?i|) Wu |ihi hi4@?t @?) t}?U@?| hi*@|L? Mi|ii?

ThL|t @?_ i@h??}tc | U@? L?*) Mi _i |L _Lt)?Uh@|U U|@|L?t ? ThL|t |@| @hi _hiU|*) UL?ih|i_ ?|L i@h??}t

At @__|L?@* ULhhiU|L? uLh U@?}it ? |i ?LMtihi_ U@h@U|iht|Ut Lu Lh! uLhUi UL4TLt|L? tii4t |L Mi tUi?| |L hi_Ui |i ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |ih4 |L ?t}?U@?Ui

? 6h@?Uic @?_ |L hi_Ui |t t}?U@?Ui *ii* Mi*L DI ? Lh@) E@*|L} | hi4@?t t}?U@?| @| |i fI *ii* Ai TL?| it|4@|it Lu |i ULiUi?|t L? ThL|t u@** t*}|*)c

*i |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh ?Uhi@tit ?L|ih t}? Lu |i 4TLh|@?Ui Lu ?LMtihi_ ?__@*

U@h@U|iht|Ut uLh |i i T*@?@|L? Lu i@h??}t t |i ?Uhi@ti Lu |i i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu |i 4L_i* M) SbI |@| LUUht ? ML| UL?|hit i? ?__@* i_ igiU|t @hi @__i_

?i U@? ?L|c |ihiuLhic hiiU| |i )TL|itt Lu @? @Mti?Ui Lu hi?| t@h?} ? 6h@?Uic

@*|L} |t u@*hi |L hiiU| t _hi? *@h}i*) M) |i _iUhi@ti_ ThiUtL? ? Lh it|4@|i_

ULiUi?| ? |i L|ih @?_c |t hi4@?t |i 4Lt| *!i*) i T*@?@|L? uLh Lh@) *|L}

|i it|4@|i_ ULiUi?| L? ThL|t @}@? _hLTt M) eIc | hi4@?t t}?U@?|*) hi*@|i_ |L

|i *L} Lu hi@* u** )i@h i^@*i?| }hLtt i@h??}t Ai i T*@?@|Lh) TLih Lu |i 4L_i* t

?_ii_ ?Uhi@ti_ M) |i @__|L? Lu ?LMtihi_ ?__@* i|ihL}i?i|) ? ML| UL?|hitc tU |@| i U@? i T*@? hL}*) ef TihUi?| Lu |i @h@?Ui ? i@h??}t ? 6h@?Ui @?_ DfI

? Lh@)^D

67Vhh Derzg hw do1 +4<<<, iru ghwdlov1

68Lw vkrxog eh qrwhg khuh wkdw rxu hvwlpdwhv ri wkh prgho ghvfulehg lq : lqglfdwh d orzhu h{sodqdwru| srzhu wkdq wkh prgho hvwlpdwhg e| Derzg hw do1 +4<<<, 1 Wkhlu htxlydohqw ri wkh froxpq YLL hvwlpdwlrq h{sodlqhg ::153( ri wkh yduldqfh lq orj uhdo ixoo |hdu htxlydohqw frpshqvdwlrq frvwv/ zkloh zh h{sodlq 6<163( ri wkh yduldqfh lq orj uhdo ixoo |hdu htxlydohqw jurvv hduqlqjv1 Wkhuh duh vhyhudo srvvleoh vrxufhv ri wklv glhuhqfh1 Iluvw/ zh frqvlghu wkh shulrg 4<;:04<<8 +4<<3 dqg 4<<4 h{foxghg,/ zkloh wkh| frqvlghu wkh shulrg 4<:904<;9 +4<;4 dqg 4<;6 h{foxghg,1 Dv qrwhg deryh/ vhfwru0ohyho froohfwlyh edujdlqlqj judgxdoo| ehfdph revrohwh ryhu wkh 4<;3v/ dqg wkhvh froohfwlyh djuhhphqwv frxog kdyh ehhq yhu| lpsruwdqw ghwhuplqdqwv ri hduqlqjv1 Vhfrqg/

wkh| frqvlghu phq dqg zrphq +doehlw vhshudwho|,/ zkloh zh frqvlghu rqo| phq1 Wklv lv ehfdxvh ri wkh wklug glhuhqfh/ wkdw zh frqvlghu rqo| pdqxidfwxulqj/ zkloh wkh| frqvlghu wkh hqwluh hfrqrp|> wkhuh duh wrr ihz uhshdw revhuydwlrqv rq lqglylgxdov lq wkh ihpdoh gdwd zkhq uhvwulfwlqj rqh*v dwwhqwlrq wr pdqxidfwxulqj1 Wklv uhvwulfwlrq zdv qhfhvvdu| vlqfh pdqxidfwxulqj lv wkh rqo| vhfwru ri wkh hfrqrp| iru zklfk Qruzhjldq gdwd zdv dydlodeoh1

2f

(23)

f L?U*tL? @?_ W?|ihThi|@|L?

W? |t T@Tihc i @i T| |i hi?| t@h?} |iLh) |hL} @ tihit Lu ?_hiU| |it|t |@| @hi _it}?i_ |L @**L t |L h*i L| LMtih@|L?@**) i^@*i?| i T*@?@|L?t Lu |i TLt|i ULh hi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih @?_ @}it `i @i tL? |@| |i TLt|i ULhhi*@|L?

t ?L| _i |L iUL?L4i|hU ihhLht M@ti_ L? }hLT igiU|t ? hit_@*t Lh 4i@thi4i?| ihhLhc

| t ?L| _i |L L4||i_ @h@M*i M@t ? LMtih@M*i ?__@* ThL_U|i U@h@U|iht|Utc | t ?L| _i |L ?|ih?_t|h) @}i _gihi?|@*tc |i Mt?itt U)U*i Lh tiU|Lh@* tLU!tc | t ?L|

_i |L i?_L}i?i|) Lu ThL|t E? Lh@) @?_ | t ?L| _i |L |4i?@h@?| ?LMtihi_

i|ihL}i?i|) ? ThL_U|L? ThLUittit Lh Lh! Lh}@?3@|L? @| |i h4 *ii* `i _L ?_c Liihc |@| EUL?_|L?@* L? @** Lu |i ThiLt i T*@?@|L?t U@?}it ? |i ?LMtih@M*i U@h@U|iht|Ut Lu |i Lh! uLhUi |i?_ |L hi_Ui |i _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 @@*@M*i uLh it|4@|?}

|i UL@h@?Ui 4@|h c U ?Uhi@tit |i it|4@|i_ t|@?_@h_ ihhLh M) i?L} |L hi?_ih |i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih ?t}?U@?| ? 6h@?Ui W? Lh@)c Liihc |i t}?U@?|

hi*@|L? L*_t ii? ? |i 4Lt| UL4T*i|i tTiUU@|L? *|L} i |hi@| hi?| t@h?} @t @ hit_@* i T*@?@|L? uLh |i t}?U@?Ui Lu |i ULiUi?|c | t|** thit ? Lh@) @| |i

f TihUi?| *ii*

`) 4}| i i TiU| |t |L Mi |i U@tiq t ?L|i_ @MLic UL**iU|i M@h}@??} T*@)i_

@ 4U 4Lhi 4TLh|@?| hL*i ? i@h??}t _i|ih4?@|L? ? Lh@) Lih Lh t@4T*i TihL_

|@? | __ ? 6h@?Ui 6h|ih4Lhic UL**iU|i M@h}@??} ? Lh@) t @ 4*|t|iT ThLUittc

| tiU|Lh_i uh@4iLh! @}hii4i?|t Mi?} ti||*i_ ht|c @?_ |i? tiT@h@|i @}hii4i?|t Mi?} ?i}L|@|i_ @| tUUitti*) ?ih *ii*t Lu _t@}}hi}@|L?c ii? _L? |L |i T*@?| *ii*

W? @ UL**iU|i M@h}@??} @}hii4i?|c i@h??}t @hi i_ @t @ u?U|L? Lu U@h@U|iht|Ut Lu

^@*U@|L?t @?_ LUUT@|L?t Ai @}hii4i?| 4@)c Liihc ?U*_i i T*U| ThL| t@h?}

ThLtL?t Ai ee TihUi?| hi_U|L? ? |i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t ? Lh@) |@| LUUhhi_

i? i @__i_ h4 i_ igiU|t t}}it|t |@| |t t @? iUL?L4U@**) 4TLh|@?| Ti?L4 i?L? Bi? |iti ?i}L|@|i_ @}itc Lhi}@? h4t ti |ih i M*|) ? h?} @?_ h?}

|L |h) |L @_@T| |ih Lh!uLhUi UL4TLt|L? |L ?U*_i Lh!iht |@| ** }i?ih@|i ThL|t Ai hi*@|i*) 4TLh|@?| hL*i Lu @}i _hu| @MLi |i UL**iU|i*) M@h}@?i_ *ii*t EOL*_i? bHb t}}it|t |@| tL4i Lu |t ?LMtihi_ ^@*|) t Mi?} UL4Ti?t@|i_c @?_ i?Ui |i 4TLh

|@?Ui Lu |i hi_U|L? ?t}?U@?Ui _i |L ?__@* i_ igiU|t iih|i*ittc @*|L}

|i t}?U@?Ui Lu |i hi*@|L? t hi_Ui_ ? Lh@)c | t ?L| i*4?@|i_

W? 6h@?Uic @?L|ih t|Lh) 4@) Mi hi*i@?| #itT|i t|hU| h*it EM) Lh| 4ihU@? t|@?

_@h_t UL?Uih??} *@)Lgt EwiuiMhi bbSc 4@?) 6hi?U Lh!iht @hi @M*i |L t|U i4T*L)iht

|L| 4U ?|ihi??} ?i4T*L)4i?| E@h}L*t uLh|UL4?} h hit*|t ? tiU|L? b t}}it| |@| @| 4@) Mi @TTi??} t |@| |i Lh!iht | ?LMtihi_ E|L |i iUL?L4i

|hU@? U@h@U|iht|Ut |@| @hi Lh| |i 4Lt| L? |i *@MLh 4@h!i| @hi tLh|i_ ?|L h4t |@|

MiUL4i ThL|@M*i Ai U@t@*|) h???} uhL4 ?LMtihi_ Lh!ih U@h@U|iht|Ut |L @}it

2

(24)

L*_ i T*@? |i hL*i Lu |i ?t|h4i?|@* @h@M*it ? hi?_ih?} |i ULiUi?| ?|@**) ?L?

t}?U@?|c *i |i 4Lt| UL4T*i|i 4L_i* @**Lt t |L _hiU|*) U@T|hi |t i|ihL}i?i|)c

|ihiM) hi?_ih?} |i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t ?t}?U@?|

W| tL*_ Mi ?L|i_ |@| |@| |i ULiUi?| L? ThL|t MiUL4it ?t}?U@?| ? |@M*i 2

|hL} @? ?Uhi@ti ? |i t|@?_@h_ ihhLhc @?_ ?L| |hL} @ _iUhi@ti ? |i TL?| it|4@|i Lu |i igiU| Lu ThL|t L? @}it OLiihc }i? |i i@!?itt Lu Lh ?t|h4i?|tc i i TiU|

|i t|@?_@h_ ihhLht Lu Lh it|4@|it |L Mi ih) *@h}i 6h|ih4Lhic |i 4Lt| UL4T*i|i tTiUU@|L? UL?t4it Lih @ |h_ Lu |i _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 @@*@M*i | |i ?__@*

_i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 E@*|L} |ih @hi t|** 2HDS _i}hiit Lu uhii_L4 *iu| |L _i?|u) |i

@h@?Ui Lu |i _t|hM@?Ui t @ uh|ih UiU! L? |i hL*i Lu ?t|h4i?|?} ihtt i_

|i t|@?_@h_ ihhLh Lu |i ThL| ULiUi?| @t Lu @ t4*@h Lh_ih Lu 4@}?|_i |L |i 4L_i*

VW hi}hittL?t EHD2,f ? 4L_i* VWW |L| ?t|h4i?|t ihtt fS,f ? 4L_i* VW OLiihc |i TL?| it|4@|i @t |L Lh_iht Lu 4@}?|_i t4@**ih |@? |i 4L_i* VW it|4@|it Ee.D,fe ? 4L_i* VWW |L| ?t|h4i?|t ihtt S2S,f2 ? 4L_i* VW At t}}it|t

|@| |ihi 4@) ?_ii_ Mi @ R|h*) ?t}?U@?| ULiUi?| L? ThL|t Tih Lh!ih |@| UL4it

@t @ hit*| Lu ?U*_?} ?__@* i_ igiU|tc ? |i ti?ti |@| | t ?i|ih iUL?L4U@**) ?Lh t|@|t|U@**) t}?U@?|c @*|L} tU @ UL?U*tL? 4t| Mi |hi@|i_ U@hiu**) @t | _iTi?_t L? @ 4L_i* |@| _Lit ?L| ?t|h4i?| |i EU*i@h*) i?_L}i?Lt ThL|t Tih Lh!ih @h@M*i

W? *}| Lu @** Lu |t i_i?Uic |i @?tih |L Lh ?|@* ^it|L? _itihit @ 4 i_ hitTL?ti

Lt| @*|ih?@|i i T*@?@|L?t uLh |i TLt|i ULhhi*@|L? Mi|ii? ThL|t @?_ @}it u@** M)

|i @)t_ic @*|L} |i hL*i Lu tLh|?} Lu ?__@*t M) |ih ?LMtihi_ U@h@U|iht|Ut 4@) 4ih| uh|ih @||i?|L? W? Lh U@tic |i hi_U|L? ? ThiUtL? Lu Lh it|4@|it |@|

tU @ ThLUi_hi 4T*it 4i@?t |@| i U@? ?L *L?}ih hiiU| |i )TL|itt Lu 3ihL hi?|

t@h?} ? 6h@?Uic @*|L} |t )TL|itt hi4@?t @*_ @| |i f TihUi?| *ii* ? Lh@)

22

Do firms really share rents with their workers?

#L 6h4t +i@**) 5@hi +i?|t `| Aih `Lh!ihtq

#@_ @h}L*t

@?_ ki** B 5@*@?it

@) 2ff

 W?|hL_U|L?

2 hiLt +iti@hU L? +i?| 5@h?}

Ai @tUt

 54T*i @h}@??} L_i*

2 Ai 5|)*3i_ 6@U|

e 5|@|t|U@* Wttit

e BhLT ,giU|t

e2 i@thi4i?| ,hhLh

D W?|ihW?_t|h) ,@h??}t #gihi?|@*tc t?itt ) U*it @?_ 5iU|Lh@* 5LU!t

S Mtih@M*i W?__@* Oi|ihL}i?i|)

. ,?_L}i?i|) Lu hL|t

H 6 i_ 6h45TiUU N?LMtihi_ Oi|ihL}i?i|)