Research Paper
Mediators ofInflammation2,417-422(1993)
INCREASED plasma-andtissuelevels ofendothelin-1(ET- 1)during inflammatory diseases,havesuggestedaroleof ET-1 inthe pathophysiology ofinflammatory reactions.
The authors have studied theeffect ofET-1 on cytokine release from monocytes and monocyte-derived macro- phages. ET-1 increased secretion of TNF-, IL-1/I and
IL-6inadose- andtime-dependentmanner.Optimal ET-1 concentration ranged from 0.01 to 1nM. The maximal
response was a200 to 400%increase incytokine release.
Atime-coursestudyrevealedthatthe pattern ofcytokines induced by ET-1 wasdifferent inmonocytes andmacro- phages, althoughanearlyincrease inTNF-ffwasobserved in both monocyte and macrophage supernatants. Incon- clusion, ET-1 stimulates monocytes andmacrophages to release cytokines thereby demonstrating a potential role forET-1 inregulation ofinflammatory responses.
Keywords: Cytokines,Endothelin-1, IL-lfl,IL-6, Inflamma- tion,Macrophages, Monocytes, TNF-
Endothelin-1 stimulates human monocytes in vitro to release TNF- , IL-1/ and IL-6
E. Helset,1"cAT. Sildnes, R. Seljelid2 and
Z.S.
Konopski2Department of Anesthesiology, Institute of Clinical Medicine, and
2Department
of Experimental Pathology, Institute of Medical Biology, University ofTroms,
N-9038Troms,- Norway
CACorresponding Author
Introduction
Endothelin-1
(ET-1)
was originally described as a potent vasoactive peptide released from en- dothelialcells.1’2The observation thatmacrophages
and mast cells both release and have receptors for ET-1, hassuggested
that ET-1 possiblyplays
a roleas a modulator of
monocyte/macrophage
func- tion.3,4Increased
plasma-
and tissue levels of ET-1 arereported
in patients with inflammatory diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis, Mb.Crohn and septic shock.5- Elevatedplasma
levels of ET-1 are even associated with the severity of illness in patients with septicaemia. Furthermore, in a recentstudy
the authors have shown that ET-1 increases microvascular permeability in isolated ratlungs provided leukocytes
are present in theperfusate.
Against this
background
wehypothesized
that ET-1 mightplay
a role in the pathophysiology of inflammatory reactions. Therefore an investigation into whether ET-1 stimulation of monocytes andmacrophages
induced release of inflammatory mediators such asTNF-, IL-I
and IL-6, wasrequired. Thesecytokines
play
animportant rolein thedevelopment
of inflammatory diseases.9’Synergistic actions of these cytokines are further
suggested
to be of crucial importance for theoutcome ofseptic shock.9-1
In the present
study
human monocytes and monocyte-derivedmacrophages
were stimulated in vitro with ET-1 for specific time intervals, and the secretion ofTNF-oq IL-I
and IL-6 in thesupernatants was measured
by
bioassay.(C)1993Rapid Communications ofOxford Ltd
Materials and Methods
Reagents: Endqthelin-1
(human)
and endothelinantiserum were obtained from
Nova
Biochem (Liiufelingen,Switzerland).
HumanrTNF<z
with specific activity 2.0 x107 U/mg,
monoclonal anti- human TNF-0 antibodies, human rlL-6 with specific activity 2.0 x108 U/mg
and monoclonal anti human IL-6 antibodies were obtained from Boehringer-Mannheim(Mannheim, Germany).
Human
rlL-1/g
with specifiC activity 2.0 x108 U/mg,
and goatpolyclonal
anti-humanIL-lfl
antibodies were
purchased
from British Bio-technology (Oxon, UK).
Isolation and cultivation
of
monocytes and monocyte-derived macrophages: Highlypurified
monocytes were ob- tained using the method describedpreviously.
2 Briefly,unseparated
mononuclear cells(PBMC)
were isolated from
buffy
coat(The
Blood Bank, University Hospital ofTromso, Tromso, Norway) by
density centrifugation withLymphoprep
(Lym-phoprep, Nycomed
PharmaAS,
Oslo,Norway).
The cells were washed three times with HBSS
(Gibco, Glasgow, UK)
andresuspended
inmedium consistingof RPMI-1640 with 100IU/ml
penicillin,100/.zg/ml
streptomycin, andsupplemented
with 25% human serum.Peripheral
blood mononuclear cells(PBMC)
were then seeded in 24-well cultureplates (Falcon,
Becton Dickinson Labware,N J, USA)
in concentrationof 2 x106 cells/well.
After incubation at 37C for 90min the cell cultures werewashed threetimes with
pre-warmed
RPMI-1640 to remove non-adherent cells. Mono-MediatorsjofInflammation.Vol 2.1993 417
cyte cultures were either stimulated with ET-1 immediately, or further cultivated for 10
days
to obtain monocyte-derivedmacrophages.
The cellswere assessed morphologically with Wright stain,
showing >
90% monocytes, andtheir viability was>
90% as determinedby Trypan
blue exclusion.Stimulation
of
monocytes and monocyte-derivedmacrophageswith ET- The monocyte andmacrophage
cultureswere incubated with various concentrations of ET-1 ranging from 0.005nMto 100nMormediumonly (controls)
for 1,4,8and 24 h.To
exclude endotoxin contamination, cell cultures were incubated with ET-1 denaturatedby
boiling for 30min. Further- more,insomeexperimentsET-1 waspre-incubated with ET-1 antiserum prior to addition to the cell cultures. For positive controls, cultures were incubated with LPS 0.1g/ml
for 24h. The supernatants were harvested at the time points indicated and stored at -20C before beinganalysed
forTNF<z, IL-lfl
and IL-6.Supernatants
and ET-1 were tested for endotoxin using an
Endospecy
kit (SeikagakuKogyo
Co. Ltd,Tokyo, Japan).
No significant amounts of endotoxin weredetected.
Detection
of
TNF-" TNF-0 activity was determinedby
its cytotoxic effect on the fibrosarcoma celllineWEHI
164 clone 13, as described previously.13 Briefly, target cells were seeded in 96-well microplates(Falcon,
Becton Dickinson Labware,N
j,USA)
with different dilutions of culturesupernatants from ET-1 stimulated monocytes and
macrophages
and incubated for 24 h at 37C.Serial dilutions of human
rTNF- (Boehringer- Mannheim)
were included as a standard. The TNF-0 specificity ofthe assay was verified using a monoclonal antibody against rTNF-0 (Boehringer- Mannheim,Germany),
whichcompletely
neutral- ized the detected activity(data
notshown).
Resultsare
presented
aspg/ml +_
S.D. of triplicate determinations.Detection
ofIL-lfl: IL-1/
activity was determinedby
a two-stage bioassay. The first stage involves the mouse
thymocyte
IL-4 NOB-1 cell line, whichproduces
high amounts of IL-2 inresponse
to humanIL-lfl.
14 Serial dilutions of humanrlL-lfl
wereincludedasstandard. NOB-1 cellswereseeded in 96-well
microplates
with different dilutions of culture supernatants and incubated for 24 hat37C.Then,
100/1
aliquots of the supernatants were transferredto a replicate 96-well microplatefor thenextstage. Thisstage of theassayinvolved theIL-2
dependent
mouse T-cell line HT-2.s Aliquots(100/1)
of HT-2 cell suspension(1.5
x108 cells/
well)
were added to each well of the replicate microplate and incubated for a further 24 h. TheIL-lfl
activity was neutralizedby
apolyclonal
antibody
againstrIL-lfl (British Bio-technology) (data
notshown).
Results arepresented
aspg/ml
S.D. oftriplicate measurements.Detection
of
IL-6:IL-6 activity was determinedusingthe IL-6
dependent
mouse hybridoma cell line B.13.29 clone9.16
Briefly, serialdilutions of culture supernatants and rlL-6 as a standard, were incubatedin96-wellmicroplates
withcells(5 103 cells/well),
in a total volume of200/1,
at 37C for 72h. IL-6bioactivity
was neutralizedby
a monoclonal antibody against rlL-6(Boehringer-
Mannheim,Germany) (data
notshown).
Resultsarepresented
aspg/ml -+-
S.D. oftriplicate determina- tions.MTT assay: Viability of the cells in the assays for
TNF-0, IL-1/
and IL-6 were testedby
incubationwith
MTT [3-(4, 5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5-di-
phenyl-tetrazoliumbromide]
(Sigma,USA)
as de-scribed previously.5 Microplates were read at
570nm
(ODsT0)
on aNovaPathTMMiniReader(Bio
Rad, Richmond,CA, USA).
Results
ET-1 stimulates monocytes and macrophages to release
TNF-,
IL-lfl
and IL-6: There was a donor todonor variability in the levels of cytokines
produced
in unstimulated control cultures, as alsoreported by
others.17However,
theresponse
pattern seen after ET-1 stimulation wasgenerally
the same in cultures of mononuclearphagocytes
obtainedfromdifferentdonors. Figure1 depictsthedose-response
of ET-l-inducedsecretionofTNF- (a), IL-lfl (B)
and IL-6(C)
from monocytes andmacrophages.
TheconcentrationsofTNF-0,IL-lfl
and IL-6 measured in the supernatants showed an inverse
U-shaped dose-response
curve. The max- imal cytokineproduction
was observed in aconcentration range of 0.01-1 nM ET-1. In this
range
the optimal ET-1 concentrationappeared
to be donordependent.
Furthermore,asshowninFig.1, monocytes secreted
generally
more TNF-0 andIL-lfl
thanmacrophages
inresponse
toET-I
stimulation. Denaturation
by
boiling orpre-
incubation with ET-1 anti-serum, neutralized the effect of ET-1 on cytokine release from monocytes andmacrophages (data
notshown).
For comparison, Table 1 shows the
response
to LPS0.1/g/ml.
After 24h, LPS stimulation causeda strong five- toten-fold increase in release ofTNF-0, IL-lfl
and IL-6 from monocytes andmacrophages.
Kinetics
of
ET-1 inducedTNF-oreleasefrom
monocytes and macrophages:As
shown in Fig. 2A, the time-coursestudy
revealed that ET-1 stimulationhad increased monocyteTNF-
production after 1 h incubation.A 400 350
300 250
200
50 100
5O
-11 -10 -9 -8 -7
ET-1 (log M)
B 350
300
250
I
200150
lO0
5O
0
C -11 -10 -9 -8 -7
ET-1 (log M)
450 4OO 35O 300 E 250 200 0 O0 5O
C -11 -10 -9 -8 -7
ET-1 (log M)
FIG.1.Endothelin-1 (ET-1)-inducedrelease ofTNF-(A),IL-lfl(B)and
IL-6(C) fromhuman monocytes andmonocyte-derived macrophages.
Monocyte and macrophage cultures were incubated with different concentrations of ET-1 or mediumonly (C" controls). Data represent the mean
___
S.D.oftriplicate measurementsof one of three representative experiments performed in duplicate.macrophages.
Vol2.1993 419
A 400
I
350
300
250
200
50
O0
50
C 300
4 8 24
Time (h)
250
200
150
O0
50
ND
4 8 24
Time (h)
25O
200
150
O0
5O B
4 8 24
Time (h)
FIG. 2.The time-coursestudy ofendothelin-1 (ET-1)-inducedreleaseof TNF- (A),IL-6(B),andIL-lfl(C)from monocytesandmacrophagesin responseto0.1 nM ET-1.This ET-1 concentration was in the optimal range formaximalcytokine releaseasshowninFig. 1. Themonocyte and macrophage cultures werestimulated withET-1 for 1,4, 8and24h.The results are expressedin% of controls,andgiven as the meanvalue 4-S.D.
ofthree tofourexperimentsperformedin duplicates. I,monocytes; [], macrophages.
Table1. LPS-induced secretion of TNF-z, IL-lfland IL-6 by
monocytes and monocyte-derived macrophages
Cytokine Cells Controls LPS,0.1 #g/ml
(pg/ml) for24h (pg/ml) TNF- Monocytes 290_+13 2008_+81
Macrophages 109_+10 585_+70 IL- fl Monocytes 109_+15 3876_+79
Macrophages 225_+50 814_+13 IL-6 Monocytes 202+_40 1226+_78 Macrophages 163_+30 1246_+34 The monocyte andmacrophagecultureswere incubated with LPS0.1 #g/mlor medium alone(controls)for24h.The culture supernatants were analysed for TNF-z. L-lfl and L-6 as
describedunder Materials and Methods.
TNF-0productioncontinuedtoincrease
by
4 h and reached a maximum, with three-fold increase,by
8h.In the
macrophage
culture supernatants, ET-1 had increased TNF-0productionthree-foldby
1 h;whereas
by
4h and 8 h theTNF-
level had returned to baseline.By
24 h theTNF-
level had increasedby
250%.Kinetics
of
ET-l-induced IL-6 releasefrom
monocytes and macrophages:As
shown in Fig. 2B, ET-1 increased monocyte IL-6production
slightly after 4h stimulation, and levels were still elevated at24 h.In the
macrophage
cultures ET-1 had induced IL-6production by
1 h, reaching a two-foldpeak
concentration in the supernatants within 4h, and
declining,
but still increased ascompared
with controls,by
24 h.Kinetics
of
ET-l-induced IL-1 releasefrom
monocytes and macrophages:As
shown in Fig. 2C, ET-1 increased monocyteIL-lfl
production, as measured in the supernatants, after 8h, reaching more than a two-fold increaseby
24 h. Inmacrophage super-
natantsincreased
IL-lfl
levelswere detectedby
4h,reachingamaximaltwo-foldincreaseafter 24 h. No release of
IL-1/
was detected in monocyte ormacrophage
supernatants after1 hincubation time.Discussion
The present results show that
ET-I
stimulates human monocytes andmacrophages
to release TNF-0,IL-lfl
and IL-6 in a dose- and time-dependent
manner. So far, thepotential of ET-1 toaect
immune and inflammatory cells islargely unexplored.
Theonly
previouslyencounteredstudy
was done
by
Millull etal., who demonstrated that ET-1 stimulationofalveolarmacrophages
increased arachidonic acid(AA)
releaseby
amaximal 300%.18 In the presentstudy,
the same concentrationrange ofET-1, 0.1 to 1nM,
induced an optimalresponse
with a 200 to 400% increase in cytokine release.
The monocyte cultures secreted
generally
moreTNF-z
andIL-lfl
than did themacrophage
cultures,in
response
toET-1.Thesamepatternwas observedafterLPSstimulation inthe presentstudy.
These
findings
are in accordance with previous studies,concluding
that the capacity of mono- nuclearphagocytes
to secreteTNF-0 andIL-1/
mayvary
with their state of dit:ferentiation.19’2Stimulation with0.1
#g/ml
LPScaused afive- to ten-fold increase in cytokine release from mono- cytes andmacrophages.
Thegenerally
lower release ofcytokinesinresponse
toET-1,
indicates thatLPS and ET-1 activate dierent mechanisms for cytokine release in mononuclearphagocytes.
Denaturating ET-1
by boiling
did not increase cytokine production, whichexcludes thepossibility
that the observedeect
of ET-1 was causedby
contamination with endotoxin.
The time-course
study
revealed a sequential release ofTNF-, IL-lfl
and IL-6 from both monocytes andmacrophages.
TNF-0 was released prior toIL-lfl
and IL-6.A
similar pattern wasreported
previously after LPS stimulation of mononuclearphagocytes
in vitro, in septicaemia in experimentalanimalsandinpatientswithmeningo- coccal septicshock.9’11’20Previousreports have also documented that TNF-0,IL-lfl
and IL-6 mightinteract on the
production
and release of each other.1’11’17’21 IL-6 has beenreported
tosuppress
TNF-0 production in mononuclearphagocytes.
17’22This might explain the reduction of TNF-0 observed in the
macrophage
supernatants inparallel
withthepeak
concentration of IL-6. Inthe monocytecultures,
ET-1 causedonly
aslight
increase inIL-6 secretion, andno
parallel
reduction of TNF-0 was observed. This also demonstrates that ET-1 induces a differential modulation of TNF-0 and IL-6 secretion from monocytes andmacrophages.
In experimentalanimals
TNF-
is showntocause aleukocyte dependent lung
injury, and to increase microvascularpermeability
in thepulmonary
circulation.23 Thus the ET-1 induced TNF-0 secretion from monocytes and
macrophages
as shown in the presentstudy,
might explain the earlier observation of ET-1 inducedleukocyte dependent lung
injury in isolated ratlungs.
8In patients with septic shock,
plasma
levels of ET-1 have beenreported
to be 20pg/ml.
This coincides with the lowerrange
of the ET-1 concentrations causing cytokine release from monocytes andmacrophages
in the presentstudy.
However,
many workers favour the belief that ET-1primarily
functions in an autocrine manner, and that circulating levels of ET-1only
reflect an overflow to the circulation,indicating
that localconcentrations ofET-1 are substantially higher.2 The present observations extend the under- standing of ET-1 as a vasoactive
peptide,
and2.1993 421
Vascular smooth muscle
Activated tissue macrophage
TNF-=
IL-6 IL-1
Monocyte TNF.=
"
IL.6
IL.1 ELAM-1
Vascular endothelium
CAM
RBC ET-1
Thrombin Shearstress
TNF.=
Ischaemia
ET-1
)
Activated tissue macrophage
FIG.3.Endothelin-1 (ET-1)isreportedtobe released fromendothelialcellsinresponseto thrombin, endotoxin,TNF-and injury caused byischaemia and shearstress.2’24-27Inthepresentstudyit isdocumented thatET-1stimulates monocytesand macrophagestorelease TNF-0,IL-1/tandIL-6. These resultssuggesta new possibility forinteractionsbetween mononuclear phagocytes and endothelial cells.
demonstrate that ET-1 is
capable
of activating mononuclearphagocytes, thereby
causingrelease ofTNF-0, IL-lfl
and IL-6. The present results also suggest a new possibility for the interactions between endothelial cells andmacrophages,
as illustrated in Fig. 3.References
1. YanagisawaM,KuriharaH,KimuraSetal.Anovel potentvasoconstrictor peptideproduced byvascular endothelial cells.Nature 1988;332: 411-415.
2. Liischer TF, Boulanger CM, Dohi Y, Yang Z. Endothelium-derived contractingfactors.Hypertension 1992;19: 117-130.
3. EhrenreichH, AndersonRW, Fox CH etal. Endothelins, peptideswith potentvasoactiveproperties produced byhumanmacrophages.JExp Med1990;172: 1741-1748.
4. Ehrenreich H, Burd PR, Rottem Met al. Endothelins belong to the assortmentofmastcell-derived andmast cell-boundcytokines. TheNew Biologist1992; 4: 147-156.
5. Miyasaka N,HirataY,AndoKetaLIncreasedproductionof endothelin-1 inpatientswithinflammatoryarthritides.Arthritisand Rheumatism 1992; 35:
397-400.
6. Murch SH,Braegger CP, SessaWC,MacDonald TT. Highendothelin-1 immunoreactivityinCrohn’s disease andulcerative colitis.Lancet1992; 339:
381-385.
7. Pittet JF, Morel DR, Hemsen A et al. Elevated plasma endothelin-1 concentrations associatedwiththeseverity ofillness in patientswith sepsis. AnnSurg1991; 213: 261-264.
8. Helset E, Kjmve J, Hauge A. Endothelin-l-induced increases in microvascularpermeabilityinisolated,perfusedratlungs requires leukocytes andplasma. CirculatoryShock 1993; 39: 15--20.
9. Waage A,Aasen AO.Differentrole ofcytokinemediatorsinseptic shock relatedtomeningococcaldisease andsurgery/polytrauma.ImmunolRev 1992;
127: 221-230.
10. BillauA,Vandekerchove F. Cytokinesand their interactions withother inflammatorymediatorsinthepathogenesisofsepsisandsepticshock.Eur
JClinInvest 1991;21: 559-573.
11. Fong Y, TraceyKJ,Lyle Letal. Antibodiestocachectin/tumornecrosis factor reduce interleukin fl and interleukin appearance during lethal bacteremia.JExpMed 1989 1"/0:1627-1633.
12. Boyum A.Isolationof mononuclear cells andgranulocytes from human blood. ScandjClinLabInvest1968; 97: 77-89.
13. EspevikT,Nissen-MeyerJ.A highlysensitivecell line,WEHI 164 clone
13, for measuring cytotoxic factor/tumor necrosis factor from human monocytes.JImmunol Methods 1986; 95: 99-105.
14. GearingAJH,BirdCR,BristowA,PooleS, Thorpe R. A simplesensitive bioassayfor interleukin-1 whichisunresponsiveto103 U/mlofinterleukin-2.
JImmunolMethods1987;99:7-11.
15. MosmannTR,CherwinskiH,BodnMW,GiedlinMA,Coffman RL.Two types ofmurinehelper Tcell clone. I.Definitionaccordingtoprofilesof lymphokineactivitiesandsecretedproteins.JImmuno11986;136: 2348-2357.
16. Aarden LA, De Groot ER, Schaap OL, Lansdorp PM. Production of hybridoma growthfactorbymonocytes.EurJImmuno11987;17 1411-1416.
17. SchindlerR,Mancilla J, EndresS,GhorbaniR, ClarkSC,DinarelloCA.
Correlationsandinteractions intheproductionof interleukin-6(IL-6),IL-1 andtumornecrosisfactor(TNF)inhumanblood mononuclear cells: IL-6 suppressesIL-1 andTNF.Blood 1990; 75: 40-47.
18. MillulV, Lagente V,Gillardeaux Oetal.Activationofguinea pigalveolar macrophages by endothelin-1. J Cardiovasc Pharm 1991; 17(Suppl 7):
$233-$235.
19. BurchettSK, WeaverWM,WestallJA,LarsenA,KronheimS,WilsonCB.
Regulationoftumornecrosisfactor/cachectinand IL-1secretion inhuman mononuclearphagocytes.JImmuno11988;140: 3473-3481.
20. EliasJA,SchreiberAD,GustiloKetaLDifferential interleukin-1 elaboration byunfractionatedanddensityfractionatedhuman alveolarmacrophagesand blood monocytes: relationship to cell maturity. J Immunol 1985; 135:
3198-3204.
21. DinarelloCA, CannonJG,Wolff SMetal.Tumornecrosisfactor(cachectin) is endogenous pyrogenand inducesproductionofinterleukin1.JExp
Med1986;163: 1433-1450.
22. AderkaD,LeJ,VilcekJ.IL-6inhibitslipopolysaccharide-inducedtumor necrosisfactorproductionincultured human monocytes, U937cells,andin mice.JImmuno11989;143: 3517-3523.
23. JohnsonJ,MeyrickB,JesmokG, BrighamKL.Humanrecombinanttumor necrosisfactoralphainfusion mimicsendotoxemiainawakesheep.JAppl
Physiol1989;66(3):1448-1454.
24. Lembeck TF, Decrinis M, Pertl C, Amann R, Donnerer J. Effects of
endothelin the cardiovascular system and smoothmusclepreparations indifferentspecies. Naunyn-Schmiedeberg’sArchPharmaco11989; 340: 744-751.
25. SugiuraM,InagamiT,KonV.Endotoxin stimulatesendothelin-releasein vivoandin vitro determinedby radioimmunoassay. BiochemBiophys Res Commun 1989;161: 1220-1227.
26. YoshizumiM, KuriharaH,Sugiyama Tetal. Hemodynamicshearstress stimulatesendothelinproduction bycultured endothelial cells.BiochemBiophys Res Commun 1989;161: 859-864.
27. Hieda HS, Gomez-Sanchez CE. Hypoxia increasesendothelin release in endothelial cells in culture, but epinephrine, norepinephrine, serotonin, histamineandangiotensin IIdonot.LifeSci1990; 47: 247-251.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.Thiswork carriedoutwith grant support from NordicInsulin Fond. The authors thank O. H. Olsen at the Blood Bank, University HospitalofTromso,for technicalassistancewithbuffycoats,andW.
Johnsenand KristinKjaerfortechnical assistance withcytokine analysis.
Received 9
J
u ly 1993"accepted in revised form 9 September 1993