Losers, winners and prisoner's dilemma in international subsidy wars

! "

# $% &''(

) *+

,, , ,

- . ./ * *

,, 0 1 ,

* 2. 3 +

0 . , 0 *

,, 0 * *

4 - , * 1 2.

, * 0 , * +

. +" .

56 * 56 7

" .

7$8 9:& $8 :& #8$.

, / ! " +

, ! 9 * 8' +:';: " . ) /

<-;=2::%:%(&& 7 3/ <-;=2::%:%:;8> !+ / ., ? . .

) @ * A

. 9 , 7 BC "C * D

5 " * 4 A . ,

, , 4. ) ,, . )

4 ! , D 7 7 4 +

5 ) 4/ ) @ * ,

-!D D 9 5 +D)+&''&+''&8(:2.

$

* * ,,

, , , .

+ * .

, , * ,

-" $%EE2.

E' %' * +

" , -$%E:2 * , *

* * / , , ^$. )

, , , +

* 3 0 0 .

* * * ,, 0

, 0 .

* 3 +

* , 4 - 3 , D 2

, / * 0 F

4 G @ -$%E(2 -$%%;2 4

3 0 . ) *

0 , ,, , *

. *

- . ./ 2 0

, ,,

.

H * , 1

* , 4 , . 9 +

* 4 0 * ,, ^&.

, I

, . ) 3 ,

! , , ⁸. +

* ! , H -!H2 - 2 *

* " * *

$" J K

- 7 8 $%%( ,,. (E2.

& " 5 + -&''(2 *

87 3 B -$%E:2 * 4 -&'';2. 7

&: &'': ,,. $; ,,. %'.

&

. ) , *

*

* , .

) * , " ,

-$%E:2 * *

, . , 0 *

* * C *

1 * .

, .

) * , I ,, , .

, @ 0

F

G * +" , , +

H ,, "

* , * . 9 * *

H @ " .

" , J K - &: &'': ,,. %'2.

) , , 4 4

/ * ,,

. , 0 3

B -$%E:2 4 , " 4 . 9 +

* * 3 , 4 .

* , + -H !H2 0 -"

2 4 - 4 " , $%E:2 0

* , 56 - $%%=2 *

@ 56 . )

* * ,

, / 56 . 9 * 4

0 * * /

* ,, 0 ^;.

1 -$%%=2 0

* 1 * , 56 -

, * 4 $%8;2. , 56 0

L * 0 + * *

;D , 5 @ -$%E%2 @ * * ,

-I 3, 2. 9 -$%%82

* * .

8

Note: Data available at www.oecd.org. GERD: gross domestic expenditure in R&D.

0 0.51 1.52 2.5 3 3.5

Austria Belgium

Canada Czech Republic

Denmark Finland

France Germany

Greece Hungary

Iceland Ireland

Japan Korea

Mexico Netherlands

New Zealand Norway

Poland Portugal Slovak Republic

Spain Sweden

Turkey United Kingdom

United States

Industry-financed GERD as a % of GDP Government-financed GERD as a % of GDP

7 $/ * * 0 56 M -&''$2

56 . 0 56 .

, " 0 + * *

56 . ) *

* 0 -" 2

4 , - 2 .

56

, 0 * , . 7

56 * , , 1 +

* * * 0 L , *

* .

) #!D * * ,, @ *

, @ * -0

$2. * 0 56

, 0 56 .

) , , * * * @

56 , ,

0 + * * .

, + , *

* ,,

,, 0

1 * - . ./ , 2. )

!H * 56 ,, ,

. ./ .

, , *

;

* * .

56 * ,

1 , * 0 .

, , , *

1 , N - * 4 $%8;2 0

3 - 4 $%%;2.

0 , * 1 * *

* + @ 1 , * * .

) , / !H H

- H * 42 0 ,

, / - !H2 " -

H 2. 7 * , +D ,

0 , 0 , 4 , 56 * .

0 , 4

* * , " 0 + * * 56 .

* @ 56 .

!

7 " , -$%E$2 " +

/

-$2

- " 2 ,

* 4 @ .

, 0 0 /

-&2

03 56 *

56 * !H * . 3,

" . "

. ./ .

:

" #$

) , * 4 -$%8;2

, L *

0 + * * . " -$%%:2 0 ,

, , . 7 *

I , ,

, * . * , , *

0 + * . , " -$%%:2 0 .

* 0 , 56

, . ./ 56 * , * , .

) ,, 0 , / 0

, 56 * . ) 0

, 56 C * / , * , *

N 1 * . 0

* , 56 ^:.

+" 3 , "

0 + * * 56 ⁽.

% &

56 * 03 . , +

-$%%=2 , 56

03 . , 0 /

-82

+ 1 56 56

. 3 03

: , 56 * * 0 ,

4 , . 0

1 ,

56 @ 1 * * .

( 9 4 -$%%'2 0 + *

* - 4 2 C 0 3

+ 4 0 . ,

,, " + " ,

4 , .

(

!H * , ⁼. " ,

. ./ " * . )

, * "

.

) , , , * 4 -$%%=2

0 , 4 @ 56 * /

-;2

, * * * +

1 56 - 2 - 4 @ 2 *

- 2. ) * . )

J * 56 K.

' #$

56 - 2 *

* 56 0 ,, ^E.

56 /

@ 56 - . ./ 2>

!H * @ . ./ >

H * @ - . ./

2> @ !H

H - . ./ 2. 3,

,, + , , * . )

3 0 &.

( & ) *

7 8 0 . 0 *

* @ . * - ,

= * ,,

.

E 4 - )#2

, . # * -$%%:2.

=

US

EU Not-Subsidize

(s^*=0) Subsidize (s^*≠≠≠≠0) Not-Subsidize

(s=0) B US

Subsidize

(s≠≠≠≠0) EU EU+US

7 &/ D

Game

Stage B EU US EU+US

Stage 1 Subsidize versus not-Subsidize Stage 2 n.a. s s^* s,s^*

Stage 3 k^*

Stage 4 Airbus: Entry versus non-entry

Stage 5 k,q,q^*

(n.a.: not applies)

7 8/ )

, 0 2 56

0 . " .

4 . 0 "

- 2 .

% "

) * 4 . 9 * ,

* 1 *

, - 2 *

, , 56 .

) , 0 + -7#D2

. , , 3, ,

1 , 56 0 ,

, . , C I /

E

-:2

0 J , * K - . ./

56 * 2. ) , ,

, * .

) 0 56 * , 7#D . +

* , 4

* 0 56 . " .

" , 56 7#D /

-(2

) 0 I (

+ * 56 , * ^%.

56 +@ . )

0 56 , * , . ./

0 , 56 - " 2. # 56

+ @ . ) ,, 3 ,

0 56 , . ./ 0

, 56 - 2. )

56 7#D , /

-=2

56 3, "

/

-E2 -%2

I E % C 0 /

4 .

% 0 7#D 56 /

* , .

%

7 I E % " 1

* , 56 , *

0 ^$'. , 0 " - 0

, 2 * * , , *

- 0 , 2. 7 ) -$%E;2

* * " ^$$. )

I * * "

4 , * " .

0 , 56 0

, 56 . , * .

" . ) ,

4 4 , * , 0 . ) 4

, 0 3, - I &2 56

* - I E2. ,, , 1 56

, 0 3, , 0 /

-$'2

- #D2 - ,+

, 3 2 , 0 , . ,

- 2 , * . ./

4 . - 2 ,

3. , *

4 . 3

, * * , * .

* * , , 56

4 0 .

$' , , , ,

1 3

G @ -$%E(2 -$%%;2.

$$) ,, D , , +

- " . $%E:2 . ./ - I

" , 0 2. " . ./

1 56 " , * .

$'

' #$ + "

) , / 56 .

-" , $%E:2 + 4

, , , . )

!H * @ !H C I

, 0 - . ./ 2. !H *

, 56 !H 0 , 0

56 , /

-$$2

) ,, H * .

!H * - ,, 3 2/

-$&2 I $&

.

H * I /

-$82

7 I $8

. 1 I $&

I $8 " ,

56 . * * *

, 56 , 0 . )

@ I .

" I : E % $& $8 *

1 56 /

-$;2

$$

-$:2

-$(2

-$=2

, , 56 +

" + * , 56 * .

* 3 4 .

,, 3 /

-$E2

7 I $E N

, 56 * !H H

$&

56 , * ^$&. ) 3

* , 3 56 .

* 0 . *

I $E , *

- 2 4 . 7 ,

I $' , !H - I $&2 /

-$%2

9 #D , 0 , * . )

, " !H 56

H 56 N ^$8.

( , , " -.

* ,

0 4 )

* -

2 I @ 56

* * .

" - ,, 3 , 2/

-&'2

, 0 ,

56 -" 2 0 ,

- 2 . # * 0 + * *

56 " * .

* 0 4

, 0 , / F

$& I $E , *

4 .

$8 !H , 03

56 - I 82 4.

56 , * 4 .

, !H 4 , -$%==2 *

. # * .

$8

* 0 *

, . 7 3 , G @ -$%E(2 -$%%;2

, * 0 *

- ,, 3 D2. ) - 3 2 , * 0

4 , * 0 .

) * 1 G @ -$%E(2

-$%%;2 . ) , G @

-$%E(2 -$%%;2 , * 0

3 ^$;. ) ,

* @ , *

.

) 0 I , ,

!H H - ,, 3 2/

-&$2

,, , *

,, - 2 ,, -" 2.

) I , * I +

&$ , , *

" . ) C !H *

* * - ,, 3 2/

-&&2

) !H 56 * , * +

* . !H , * 4

/ ,

4 " .

*

4 " , -$%E:2 * * +

* .

$; 1 G @ -$%E(2 -$%%;2 0 ,

, * @ 3, .

$;

3 0 - G @ $%E(

$%%;2 * ,, . D *

0 3 * , ,

, * 0 .

# 0

0 , * *

0 . 5 " , *

, * , . #

" * + * 56

, . 9 *

!H * " *

" 56

$:.

H * ,, " .

) , "

, H . D I H

* " 3 ,, . 7

H , * "

!H * - I &$2.

!H * , " , * * *

, H * - I &&2^$(.

/ + 0 1 " 2 .

) 4 3 , , *

, @

0 . *

N *

, / * - " , $%E:2.

* 4 1

56 - ,, 3 , 2/

$: !H * , " "

, 56 .

$() * H !H * *

* , * * .

$:

US

EU Not-Subsidize

(s^*=0) Subsidize (s^*≠≠≠≠0) Not-Subsidize

(s=0) (3,2) (4,1)

Subsidize

(s≠≠≠≠0) (1,4) (2,3)

7 ;/ !

-&82

) H H @ 56

H !H @

@ !H @ . ) !H

1 4 / !H !H

* * *

* * H * ^$=.

I 4 + , * I

* @

56 - 0 ;2^$E. 9 * +

!H , /

!H 1 * * . ) ,,

H @ 56 , +

* H 1 + *

$%.

) 3 ,

56 . ./ N *

$= I $E 4

!H H /

, * * . )

0 , , * .

$E 0 ; , 4/ $ 0 ,

; , .

$%9 , H * !H , *

56 .

$(

0 + , . , 3 +

4 3 +

- 4 $%%;2

, . ,, 3 " 4

,, 3 D 3 .

4 , " 0 +

* * , . 0 , C , * +

3, - ,, 3 " 2. # *

+ , " . 9 *

H !H ,

@ . ) , *

4 * * * * .

) , + 4

C , , . ) ,

1 4 , .

, 1

, * 4 3 .

, 0 , *

, 0 56 * ,

. * 0

4 56 *+

1 0 * * . 1 !H

4 - 0 2 * 56

4 " - 0 2 , 1

" * - I : I %2.

# 4 , * 03 / 0

* 03 . , 4

L , , * . 9 *

L * , 4

, * . )

0 * ,

* . ) 0 * , *

1 * 0 *

* * , .

) 4 3 - $%%;2

" 3 , * - 2^&'. )

&'5 -$%%$2 0 * 56 .

$=

US

EU Not-Subsidize

(s^*=0) Subsidize

(s^*≠≠≠≠0)

Not-Subsidize

(s=0) (2,2) (4,1)

Subsidize

(s≠≠≠≠0) (1,4) (3,3)

7 :/ !3 -" * , * 2

" . 4 +

* 3, * 0 C

, , - ,, 3 D2.

H , I 0 / 0

" , * N - 2

. " * , * 3 +

I /

* !H H - 0 :2. * +

. )

0 " , -$%E:2/

* * * @

, * I , @ .

" * , * I 3

* @ +

, * 0 - 0 (2. 9 * H ,

. ) " +

, * * , H @

0 * .

) " , *

, * - 2 * * . )

3 * ,,

, , * *

0 !H * . ./ !H

. ) H

!H * . D I H

* * .

3 *

, * 0 . 9 +

$E

US

EU Not-Subsidize

(s^*=0) Subsidize

(s^*≠≠≠≠0)

Not-Subsidize

(s=0) (2,3) (4,1)

Subsidize

(s≠≠≠≠0) (1,4) (3,2)

7 (/ !3 -" * , * 2

* * 0 *

* * * . ) , +

, 0 *

I .

, , ,

0 4 G @ -&''82. *

-$%%;2 G @ -$%E(2 G @ -&''82 0

, ^&$. * * +

* * . *

* * , 1 , * I

4 . 3 * *

, 0 3 , * .

,/ 0 1 , *

* * * 56

, * 0 * . ) +

, , , ,

@ 56 *

* .

) 9 +

-$%:;2

, , 1 *

4 4. ) ,

-$%:;2 * J ,

, ,

, *

&$G @ -&''82 0 , * * 0

.

$%

* * 4 , ,

3, O K.

3

9 * ! - J 4K2F !

, +! , 4

. , ! , , +, *

* , , ,

4 ^&&.

! , 3 , , . "

, -$%E:2 , ,

3, @ 0 . 9 *

! ,

H ,, . ! *

, .

1 + * / ! , *

H !H C 3 ,

.

- 3 2 , *

! , ! ,

* 4 4 ,, ! )

,, *

4 - $%%; G @ $%E(2.

3, F +

, * * * " *

! , * ,,

, * " .

) , , * 3, +"

. , * 0

* * , * I +

4 . ) 0

0 + * * 56 * *

. I

&& 7 I D , C 4 J

0 K -I ) ! G $$ &''(

,, ) P ,,. $'2.

&'

,,

.

) , 4 . +

, * 56 * * *

1 , * *

. , * 3

, * * - ,

2 0 - ,

2.

) ,, ,

,

J * * , K. * *

1 * / 56 @

, , * . 9 *

, , 1 * * *

.

, , * * .

* , * ,

9 -$%:;2 , , 1 , 0 .

* C 56 1 ,

, * * * 0 - *

@ 56 2 * , * .

# , , * , ! .

) ,

. ! " , 1 /

, 1

1 * ,, .

44 5 * " )

+ 6 ) 0 #D I

& I : , * * /

- $2

) #D " . ) , #D

0 /

&$

- &2

#$ ) , , !H 56

1 - I $$ 3 2^&8/

- 82

I 8 , 0 /

- ;2

) I ; 0 *

1 3, / .

) , * I *

I 1 3, /

. I /

- :2

. !I ; /

- (2

* I ( , !H

- I $& 3 2.

) * H 56 I * !H

* . H 3, 8 ;.

I ; H . ) *

1 3, /

. ) , * I 4

. * , I

E 0 . /

- =2

) , , I ; H /

&8) * , , ,

,, + , .

&&

- E2

* /

- %2

* I % H 56

- I $8 3 2.

+ & ) " * , *

, 56 * . ) 4 4 *

56 I @ . * #D /

- $'2

, * #D .

) * , * /

- $$2

) * 3 *

, * 4 - 3 , ,

I * * 2.

4 I $E

, * . 7

,, .

, 7 -

- $&2

I $E 3 , .

&8

" - , .

- $82

I $E , .

,

- $;2

I $E , .

, ) 4 & *

I $E !H H 4 , * /

- $:2

&;

- $(2

) I , *

. 4

, * . ./ * ,

, * . , *

. ) 4

, 3, , * * I $.

* .

7 44 5 + - &

D 4 0 - 2

" - 2. 7 C , ,

* @ 3, . " 0 + * *

, " * I - 2.

" , 3 03 !H

, . * I $ 3 . )

/ $ H !H

, , > & ,, !H , 4

H , 4 > 8 " > ;

> : .

, 0 /

-"$2

3, ,, " . * +

, 3, " /

&:

-"&2

) 3, 3, * /

I "& ,,

.

3, 3,

" @ * * . )

!H I /

-"82

) 1 I /

-";2

) * , * * /

-":2

7 7#D 0 I ":

I . 7 " 7#D/

-"(2 I "(

* /

-"=2

) 1 3, . )

. ./ ^&;.

7 H " 0 + * *

, . ) , 0 /

-"E2

&;) , 0 /

4 .

&(

7 " 7#D I "E

I . ) * .

44 5 5 &

) 4 D 0 "

, C , . " - 2

0 * I 03 - 2 N

, 3 . * I $ 3 . )

/ $ ,

, > & * * *

3, > 8 0 , ^&:.

) , I /

-D$2

) 3, * I

D$/ ,,

.

) 0 , 3

I "8 "; ":. * " 7#D 1 +

3, . , 0

/

-D&2

H . ) 4 3 ,

, 3 /

-D82

* /

I D8 .

&: " * 0 .

&=

7 , * 3, , 3,

3, * /

-D;2

-D:2

-D(2

-D=2

* , * , ^&(/

-DE2

) I 4 , * . )

1 /

-D%2

&() 4 I @ * .

&E

3 * ,, .

4 1 !H

* /

-D$'2

-D$$ 2 -D$$ 2 -D$$ 2

, 4 I D$$ D$$ , * . )

,, I D$$ I * 3

/ . I

DE , * , .

7 H 4 1 0 . )

0 " , * N - 2

3, /

-D$&2

-D$8 2 -D$8 2 -D$8 2

!I D$8 D$8 * , * .

, I D$8 I * 3

/ . ) .

" , * * N - 2

, 0 H

4 /

-D$;2

&%

-D$: 2 -D$: 2 -D$: 2

) 4 I D$: ,

I D$8 . 7 I D$: I * 3

/ I DE . 0

, .

I D$: I * 3 /

. I DE

, .

# )

Q$R " B. -$%%:2 JD # * K #

$ E ,,. &=$+&E'.

Q&R " 5. 5 + 7. -&''(2 J!

/ * 4 K D! 5 ,

:(=$.

Q8R " . -$%EE2 J K D / G ) .

Q;R " . , ". -$%E:2 J!3,

G 4 5 * K % & $E ,,. E8+

$''.

Q:R " .> 4 , . B , . -$%E:2 JG 4

# , / D , K % '

( %8 ,,. ;EE+:$$.

Q(R D , 5. 5 @ 5. -$%E%2 JH D

) # , K )

:( ,,. $&%+$;'.

Q=R G @ . -$%E(2 J!3, 9 * / D

!1 FK % $% ,,. 8;=+8:'.

8'

QER 3 . B . -$%E:2 J) H

! K " ) =: ,,.

$8%+$:&.

Q%R 7 . ) . -$%E;2 J) 7 +D !1 ,, +

9 4K " )

=; ,,. 8($+8((.

Q$'R 9 . 9. 4 . G. -$%%'2 J! )

, / 4 D !I K #

$ & ,,. &%+;(.

Q$$R 9 9.+ . D. -$%%82 J + *

D ) # , K % &

8; ,,. =8+%8.

Q$&R . * 4 . -&'';2 J * " 5 * / +

D , G 4 K % &

(; ,,. &&8+&;:.

Q$8R 9. -$%:;2 J#, ) 1 5 K )

&$ ,,. $;&+$:8.

Q$;R . . -$%%=2 J ) 56

# , K " ) E= ,,. (;&+(&.

Q$:R G @ G. -&''82 J) , ) + 5 +

* K =$ ,,.

$(%:O$=&:.

Q$(R . -$%%;2 JD /

* 9 , FK % &

8= ,,. $%=+&$E.

Q$=R 5 5. -$%%$2 J5 * , 7

@ K ) % && ,,. ;$$+;&%.

Q$ER , G. -$%==2 J! D , * # , +

K $ % E ,,. :8;+:;;.

8$

Q$%R 5. -$%%:2 J 5 D , +

* ) K / . B. 5 1 - .2 *

& + , - / +9 .

Q&'R * 4 9. -$%8;2 J. # K A /

, .

8&