Discussion Papers No. 610, March 2010 Statistics Norway, Research Department
Cathrine Hagem
Promoting renewables and discouraging fossil energy consumption in the European Union
Abstract:
The European Union (EU) identified some positive and negative externalities related to energy production and consumption when adopting its Renewable Energy and Climate Change Package.
Given these externalities, we derive the optimal combination of policy instruments. Thereafter, we explore the second-best outcome, given constraints on the use of some policy instruments, due to political considerations and international regulations. We show that the choice of policy instruments to promote renewable energy production (subsidies versus green certificates) affects the optimal level of energy consumption taxes. A second-best optimum for the EU cannot be achieved without a coordination of energy taxes and renewable energy policy instruments in each country, given the externalities addressed in this paper.
Keywords: climate policy, energy policy, green certificates, energy subsidies, energy taxes JEL classification: D62, H21, H23, Q48
Acknowledgement: Valuable comments by Annegrete Bruvoll, Torstein Bye, Torbjørn Hægeland and Knut Einar Rosendahl on earlier versions of this paper are gratefully acknowledged. Financial support of the Norwegian Research Council is also highly appreciated.
Address: Cathrine Hagem,, Statistics Norway, Research Department.
E-mail: Cathrine.Hagem, @ssb.no
Discussion Papers comprise research papers intended for international journals or books. A preprint of a Discussion Paper may be longer and more elaborate than a standard journal article, as it may include intermediate calculations and background material etc.
Abstracts with downloadable Discussion Papers in PDF are available on the Internet:
http://www.ssb.no
http://ideas.repec.org/s/ssb/dispap.html
For printed Discussion Papers contact:
Statistics Norway
Sales- and subscription service NO-2225 Kongsvinger
Telephone: +47 62 88 55 00 Telefax: +47 62 88 55 95
E-mail: Salg-abonnement@ssb.no
"'%#('#"
*85 @EB@?C5 ?6 D89C @1@5B 9C D? 5F1<E1D5 D85 3?CD 5S53D9F5>5CC ?6 D85 3?=29>54 EC5 ?6 F1B9?EC 5>5B7I 1>4 3<9=1D5 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9> D85
<978D ?6 D85 B535>D<I 14?@D54 5>5B7I 1>4 3<9=1D5 @?<93I ?6 D85 EB?@51>
+>9?> + &EB 3?>DB92ED9?> D? D85 <9D5B1DEB5 ?> D85 45C97> ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9C D? C55; D? 945>D96I D85 +MC E>45B<I9>7 7?1<C 6?B 9DC 3<9=1D5 1>4 5>5B7I @?<93I 1>4 D1;5 D85C5 7?1<C 1C 1 @?9>D ?6 45@1BDEB5 6?B ?EB 5F1<E1D9?> ?6 D85 ?@D9=1< 3?=29>1D9?> ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC
> 535=25B D85 + '1B<91=5>D 17B554 ?> 1 (5>5G12<5 >5B7I 1>4 <9=1D5 81>75 '13;175 19=54 9>D5B 1<91 1D 13895F9>7 1D <51CD 1 B54E3D9?> 9> 7B55>8?EC5 71C 5=9CC9?>C 1>4 E@ D? 1 B54E3D9?> 9> D85 5F5>D 1 3?=@B585>C9F5 9>D5B>1D9?>1< 3<9=1D5 17B55=5>D 9C 5CD12<9C854 > 1449D9?> D85 '13;175 19=C 6?B 1 C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5C 9> ?F5B1<<
+ 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 2I C55 + 1 1>4 + 2 > ?B45B D? 5F1<E1D5 D85 3?CD 5S53D9F5>5CC ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9D 9C 3BE391< D? 81F5 G5<<45K>54 @?<93I 7?1<C C55 )?BB5<< 1>4 )9:=
-5 K>4 9D B51C?>12<5 D? 1CCE=5 D81D D85 E>45B<I9>7 7?1< 6?B 1 3?=
29>54 5>5B7I 1>4 3<9=1D5 @?<93I 9C D? 3?BB53D 6?B 5HD5B>1<9D95C 1DD13854 D? 3?>CE=@D9?> 1>4 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 5>5B7I
-85> >5G @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 1B5 9>DB?4E354 D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C D85I C55; D? 144B5CC 1B5 >?D 1<G1IC G5<< C@539K54 5F5> 96 D859B 5H9CD5>35 9C D85 B1D9?>1<5 6?B EC9>7 D85 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC ?G5F5B D85 + 945>D9 K54 C?=5 5HD5B>1<9D95C 6B?= 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 1>4 3?>CE=@D9?> G85>
@B?@?C9>7 D85 (5>5G12<5 >5B7I 1>4 <9=1D5 81>75 '13;175 + 1C54 ?> 3?==E>931D9?>C 6B?= D85 + C55 B565B5>35C 25<?G G5 1CCE=5 D81D D85 B1D9?>1<5 6?B D85 +MC 9>D5BF5>D9?> 9> D85 5>5B7I
=1B;5DC 9C D? 3?BB53D 6?B D85 6?<<?G9>7 D8B55 5HD5B>1<9D95C
9 *85B5 9C 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI B5<1D54 D? 5=9CC9?>C ?6 7B55>8?EC5 71C5C
99 *85B5 9C 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI B5<1D54 D? 3?>CE=@D9?> ?6 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 6E5<C 1C D89C 9>3B51C5C 45@5>45>3I ?> 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BDC
999 *85B5 9C 1 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI B5<1D54 D? D85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G 12<5 5>5B7I
&>5 ?6 D85 =?CD @B?>?E>354 5>F9B?>=5>D1< 3?>35B>C D?41I 9C 7<?21<
G1B=9>7 31EC54 2I 5=9CC9?>C ?6 7B55>8?EC5 71C5C 5HD5B>1<9DI *85 + 81C ?> C5F5B1< ?331C9?>C @B?=?D54 D85 >554 6?B B54E39>7 5=9CC9?>C
?6 > 1 @B5CC B5<51C5 6B?= D85 + + 9D 9C 1B7E54 D81D C5DD9>7 1 D1B75D 6?B D85 C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5C 9> ?F5B1<< 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 85<@C
*85 D1B75D 6?B 5=9CC9?>C B54E3D9?> 9C >?D 1> 5H3<EC9F5<I 4?=5CD93 B54E3D9?> D1B75D 1C D85 '13;175 1<<?GC 6?B C?=5 <9=9D54 DB145 9> 5=9CC9?>C 3B549DC G9D8 D89B4 3?E>DB95C
D? 453B51C5 B5<91>35 ?> 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 6E5<C G8938 =1;5C 5>5B7I CE@@<I
=?B5 35BD19> 6?B EB?@51> 39D9J5>C *89C 9=@<95C D81D D85 + 1DD1385C 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI D? 45@5>45>35 ?> 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 6E5<C <5149>7 EC D? 5HD5B>1<9DI 12?F5 $51CEB5C D? 453B51C5 45@5>45>35 ?> 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 6E5<C 31> 9>D5B 1<91 25 =?D9F1D54 2I E>CD12<5 @?<9D931< C9DE1D9?>C 9> <1B75 5H@?BD9>7 3?E>DB95C )55 #TC385< 5D 1< 6?B 1 49C3ECC9?>
12?ED 5>5B7I C53EB9DI
>?D85B 1B7E=5>D 6B?= D85 + CE@@?BD9>7 D85 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I D1B75D 9C 1> 1>D939@1D54 CE2C5AE5>D 2??CD 6?B 8978D538 9>4ECDB95C @B?
4E39>7 >5G 53?>?=93 1>4 5=@<?I=5>D ?@@?BDE>9D95C + 2 *85C5 1B7E=5>DC CE775CD D81D D85 + 1DD1385C @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9 D95C D? D85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I G8938 <514C EC D? C@539K31D9?>
12?F5
<D8?E78 D85B5 =1I 25 9=@?BD1>D C?391< G5<61B5 25>5KDC 6B?= >5D 9>3B51C5C 9> 5=@<?I=5>D D81D =1I B5CE<D 6B?= 9>3B51C54 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5C CD9=E<1D9>7 5=@<?I=5>D D8B?E78 @?<9395C D? 9>3B51C5 B5>5G 12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 9C @B?212<I >?D D85 =?CD 3?CD5S53D9F5 G1I ?6
@B5F5>D9>7 E>5=@<?I=5>D EBD85B=?B5 1<D8?E78 CD9=E<1D9>7 @B?4E3 D9?> 9> 9>4ECDB95C 31> 25 G5<61B5 9=@B?F9>7 96 D85B5 1B5 D538>?<?7931<
C@9<<?F5BC D81D 1B5 >?D D1;5> 9>D? 133?E>D 2I D85 @B?4E35BC C55 )D?>5=1>
1>4 ,93;5BC '9J5B 1>4 '?@@ D85B5 =1I 25 =?B5 5R395>D G1IC D? =1;5 D85 9>4ECDB95C 9>D5B>1<9J5 D85C5 5HD5B>1<9D95C D81> 2I CD9=
E<1D9>7 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I *85 B5<1D9?>C89@ 25DG55> D538
>?<?7931< 381>75 1>4 5>F9B?>=5>D1< @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 81C 255> G945<I 49C3ECC54 9> D85 <9D5B1DEB5 C55 57 !1S5 5D 1< "F5B>4?;; 1>4 (?C5>418< 9C385B 1>4 %5G5<< ?G5F5B 9> D89C CDE4I G5 4? >?D 1CC5CC D85 >1DEB5 ?6 ?B D85 B1D9?>1<5 6?B D85 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI D85 + 1CC?391D5C G9D8 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 2ED =5B5<I D1;5 9D 1C 1 @B5=9C5 6?B ?EB CDE4I > D85 3?>3<E49>7 B5=1B;C G5 49C3ECC D85
?ED3?=5 9> D85 12C5>35 ?6 CE38 1> 5HD5B>1<9DI 5HD5B>1<9DI
C 1 CD1BD9>7 @?9>D G5 KBCD 45B9F5 D85 ?@D9=1< 3?=29>1D9?>C ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 79F5> D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C 45K>54 12?F5 G9D8 >? 3?>CDB19>DC ?>
D85 38?935 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC ?G5F5B 4E5 D? 9>D5B>1D9?>1< B57E<1 D9?>C 1>4 ?B @?<9D931< 3?>C945B1D9?>C C55 5>>51B 1>4 )D1F9>C 9D 9C B51C?>12<5 D? 1CCE=5 D81D 1 B57E<1D?B 6135C 3?>CDB19>DC ?> D85 EC5 ?6
@?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC *85 3?>CDB19>DC ?> D85 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC G5 3?>
C945B 1B5 B5CDB93D9?>C ?> D85 EC5 ?6 9=@?BD D1B9SC 2531EC5 ?6 9>D5B>1D9?>1<
DB145 B57E<1D9?>C 1>4 B5CDB93D9?>C ?> D85 EC5 ?6 CE2C9495C D? 6?CC9< 6E5<
@B?4E3D9?> 2531EC5 ?6 @?<9D931< 3?>C945B1D9?>C
-5 B5<1D5 ?EB K>49>7C D? D85 3EBB5>D EC5 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9> D85
T8B9>75B 1>4 (?C5>418< C8?G D85 9>5R395>3I ?6 9>DB?4E39>7 1 D1B75D 6?B 7B55> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> G85> D85 @?<93I 19= 9C ?><I D? <9=9D & 5=9CC9?>C
+ > @1BD93E<1B 1C B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 9C @B?=?D54 2I CE2C9495C 9> C?=5
=5=25B CD1D5C 1>4 2I 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 =1B;5D 9> ?D85B =5=25B CD1D5C G5 K>4 9D ?6 9>D5B5CD D? 3?=@1B5 D85 651DEB5C ?6 D85C5 DG? 9>CDBE=5>DC
?B 1>1<IC9C ?6 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 =1B;5DC C55 =E>4C5> 1>4 $?BD5>C5>
$?BD8?BCD 5BD?<49 1>4 E<4
-5 C8?G D81D 1C <?>7 1C D85B5 1B5 >? 3?>CDB19>DC ?> D85 EC5 ?6 CE2C9 495C ?> 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> D85 B57E<1D?B 31> 13895F5 D85 KBCD25CD ?ED 3?=5 5F5> 96 D85B5 9C 1 3?>CDB19>D ?> D85 EC5 ?6 9=@?BD D1B9SC 6 D85B5 1B5 3?>CDB19>DC ?> D85 EC5 ?6 2?D8 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1>4 CE2C9495C ?> 4?=5CD93 6?CC9< 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> D85 B57E<1D?B 31>>?D 5>CEB5 1 KBCD25CD 4?=5C D93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C *85 C53?>425CD ?@D9=1< ?ED3?=5 31> 25 13895F54 2I 1 3?=29>1D9?> ?6 1 & D1H 1> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H 1>4 1 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> CE2C94I *85 C53?>425CD B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> CE2C94I 45F91D5C 6B?= D85 '97?F91> <5F5< 1C 9D 1<C?
31@DEB5C D85 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 6B?= 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BDC EBD85B=?B5 G5 C8?G D81D D85 9>DB?4E3D9?> ?6 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 =1B;5D D? @B?=?D5 D85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 31> 5>CEB5 D85 C53?>425CD ?@D9=1<
?ED3?=5 2ED 45=1>4C 1 <?G5B 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H D81> 96 B5>5G 12<5 5>5B7I 9C @B?=?D54 2I 1 CE2C94I 5>35 D85 (5>5G12<5 >5B7I 1>4
<9=1D5 81>75 '13;175 @B?@?C54 2I D85 + 31>>?D 5>CEB5 1> 5R395>D
?ED3?=5 96 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 9C B57E<1D54 2I CE2C9495C 9> C?=5 B579?>C 1>4 2I D85 EC5 ?6 7B55> 5>5B7I 35BD9K31D5C 9> ?D85B B579?>C E><5CC D85 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H 9C 14:ECD54 133?B49>7<I
> D85 >5HD C53D9?> G5 @B5C5>D D85 =?45< > C53D9?> G5 45B9F5 1> ?@D9=1< 3?=29>1D9?> ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC G85> 2?D8 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1>4 75>5B1< @B?4E3D9?> CE2C9495C 1B5 1<<?G54 > C53D9?> G5 45B9F5 D85 ?@D9=1< 3?=29>1D9?> ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC G85> 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1B5 21>>54 2ED 75>5B1< @B?4E3D9?> CE2C9495C 1B5 1<<?G54 9F5> 1 21> ?>
2?D8 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1>4 CE2C9495C D? 4?=5CD93 6?CC9< 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> G5 45B9F5 D85 C53?>425CD 3?=29>1D9?> ?6 D1H5C 1>4 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I CE2 C9495C 9> C53D9?> 1>4 D85 C53?>425CD 3?=29>1D9?> ?6 D1H5C 1>4 7B55>
5>5B7I 35BD9K31D5 ?2<971D9?>C 9> C53D9?> > D85 3?>3<E49>7 B5=1B;C 9>
D85 <1CD C53D9?> G5 49C3ECC D85 49C3B5@1>3I 25DG55> ?EB B5CE<DC B571B4 9>7 ?@D9=1< @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 1>4 C?=5 ?6 D85 3EBB5>D EC5 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9> D85 +
!#
-5 3?>C945B 3<9=1D5 1>4 5>5B7I @?<93I 9> ?>5 3?E>DBI ?B 1 7B?E@ ?6 3?E>DB95C <9;5 D85 + C55;9>7 D? =1H9=9J5 :?9>D G5<61B5 6B?= 3?>CE=9>7 K>1< 5>5B7I 1>4 @B?4E39>7 5>5B7I C?EB35C -5 85>356?BD8 EC5 D85 C9>7<5 6?B= N3?E>DBIO 1<C? 6?B D85 31C5 G85B5 1 7B?E@ ?6 3?E>DB95C 9C CE2:53D D? D85 C1=5 B57E<1D?BI B579=5 *? C9=@<96I G5 3?>C945B ?><I DG? DI@5C
?6 5>5B7I 6?CC9< 1>4 B5>5G12<5 7B55> *85 3?E>DBI @B?4E35C 2?D8 6?CC9< 1>4 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I -5 4? >?D 3?>C945B 1>I 9>D5B>1D9?>1< DB145 9> B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 5>35 4?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 5AE1<C 4?=5CD93 3?>CE=@D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I *89C 1CCE=@D9?> 31>
25 :ECD9K54 2I 3?>CDB19>DC ?> DB1>C=9CC9?> 1>4 49CDB92ED9?> ?6 5<53DB939DI G8938 9C D85 =19> C?EB35 6?B DB1>C@?BD ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I ?G5F5B 6?CC9< 6E5<C 1B5 DB1454 ?> D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< =1B;5D
?B 3?>CE=5BC G5 1CCE=5 D81D 2?D8 DI@5C ?6 5>5B7I 1B5 @5B653D CE2 CD9DED5C *89C 9C 1 B51C?>12<5 1CCE=@D9?> 96 G5 ?><I 3?>C945B 5<53DB939DI G85B5 3?>CE=5BC 31>>?D C5@1B1D5 25DG55> 5<53DB939DI @B?4E354 2I B5>5G 12<5 ?B 2I 6?CC9< 5>5B7I C?EB35C CCE=9>7 @5B653D CE2CD9DED9?> G85> G5 1<C? 3?>C945B ?D85B ;9>4C ?6 5>5B7I EC5 9C ?2F9?EC<I 1 C9=@<9K31D9?> 2ED 49S5B5>D ;9>4C ?6 5>5B7I C?EB35C 253?=5 =?B5 3?=@5D9D9F5 ?F5B D9=5 6?B 9>CD1>35 D8B?E78 D85 EC5 ?6 29?6E5<C 1>4 5<53DB939DI 1C 1 CE2CD9DED5 D?
@5DB?< 9> D85 DB1>C@?BD C53D?B
*85 3?>CE=@D9?> ?6 5>5B7I 9C D85 CE= ?6 3?>CE=@D9?> ?6 6?CC9<
1>4 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I =51CEB54 9> D85 C1=5 5>5B7I E>9DC
#5D45>?D5 4?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I -5 1CCE=5 D8B?E78
?ED D85 @1@5B D81D D85 3?E>DBI 9C 1 >5D 9=@?BD5B ?6 5>5B7I *85 3?>
CE=@D9?> 71@ 6?B 5>5B7I 9C 3?F5B54 2I >5D 9=@?BDC ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I -5 1CCE=5 D81D D85 3?E>DBI G5 3?>C945B 9C 1 @B935 D1;5B 9> D85 9>D5B
>1D9?>1< 6?CC9< 5>5B7I =1B;5D 5>35 G5 97>?B5 1>I CDB1D5793 2581F9?B 9> D85 5>5B7I =1B;5D 9> ?B45B D? 9>LE5>35 5>5B7I @B935C
-5 3?>C945B D85 D8B55 5HD5B>1<9D95C 45C3B9254 9> D85 9>DB?4E3D9?>
-5 1CCE=5 D81D D85 3?E>DBI @1BD939@1D5C 9> 1> 9>D5B>1D9?>1< 3<9=1D5 17B55=5>D G9D8 AE1>D9K54 5=9CC9?>C D1B75DC G9D8 @?CC929<9D95C 6?B @5B
=9D DB145 CE38 D81D D85 3?CD ?6 5=9CC9?>C 5AE1<C D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @5B=9D
@B935 &D85B C@539K31D9?>C ?6 D85 5HD5B>1<9DI 3?CD ?6 5=9CC9?>C G?E<4
I 3?>C945B9>7 ?><I ?>5 DI@5 ?6 6?CC9< 6E5< G5 97>?B5 1>I 9=@13D ?> D85 49CDB92E D9?> ?6 3?>CE=@D9?> 13B?CC F1B9?EC C?EB35 ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I ?G5F5B D89C C9=@<9K31D9?>
4?5C >?D 81F5 1>I 9=@13D ?> D85 =19> 3?>3<EC9?> ?6 D85 @1@5B
*89C C9=@<9K31D9?> 9C 1 B51C?>12<5 45C3B9@D9?> ?6 D85 C9DE1D9?> 9> D85 + *85
>5D 5H@?BD ?6 5<53DB939DI 9C 3<?C5 D? J5B? *85 7B?CC 9=@?BD 1>4 5H@?BD 1=?E>DC D? 1@@B?H9=1D5<I ?6 5<53DB939DI @B?4E3D9?> 2I D85 + C55 EB?CD1D 9?=1CC 9=@?BDC 9> + 1B5 1<C? C=1<< > >5D 9=@?BDC 1C C81B5 ?6 D?D1<
@B9=1BI 29?=1CC CE@@<I 1=?E>D54 D? 1>4 ?6 D?D1< 9=@?BDC
*85 45C97> ?6 1 31B2?> D1H G85> D85 D5B=C ?6 DB145 5S53DC 1B5 133?E>D54 6?B DI@931<<I 3?=@B9C5C 1> ?@D9=1< D1B9S D5B= C55 ?<?=25; 5D 1< 1>4 ?5<
>?D 9>LE5>35 D85 3?>3<EC9?>C ?6 D89C @1@5B C55 49C3ECC9?> 9> D85 3?>
3<E49>7 B5=1B;C
*85 3?E>DBI =ECD 8?<4 @5B=9DC 3?BB5C@?>49>7 D? D85 5=9CC9?>C B5 CE<D9>7 6B?= 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?>
#5D45>?D5 D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @B935 ?> @5B=9DC @5B E>9D 6?CC9< 5>5B7I
#5D 45>?D5 D85 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 9=@?BDC #5D 45K>5 D85 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 1CC?391D54 G9D8 D85
@B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I
#5D 45>?D5 D85 25>5KD 6B?= 3?>CE=9>7 5>5B7I 1>4 1>4 4?=5CD93 3?CD 6E>3D9?>C 6?B @B?4E39>7 B5>5G12<5 1>4 6?CC9< 5>5B7I B5C@53D9F5<I -5 =1;5 D85 CD1>41B4 1CCE=@D9?> 12?ED @?C9D9F5 1>4 45 3B51C9>7 =1B79>1< 25>5KD ?6 3?>CE=@D9?> 1>4 @?C9D9F5 1>4 9>3B51C9>7
=1B79>1< 3?CD ?6 @B?4E3D9?> D81D 9C 1>4
% #$'!(!
-5 KBCD 45B9F5 D85 ?@D9=1< EC5 1>4 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 D85 DG? DI@5C ?6 5>
5B7I 79F5> D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C 9P999 *85 G5<61B5 1CC?391D54 G9D8 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 1>4 @B?4E3D9?> 9C
G85B5 9C D85 9>9D91< 5>4?G=5>D ?6 @5B=9DC C5D 2I D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1<
3<9=1D5 17B55=5>D 1>4 9C D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @B935 ?> 9=@?BD54 6?CC9<
5>5B7I >C5BD9>7 6B?= 1>4 1>4 =1H9=9J9>7 GBD 1>4 I95<4C D85 6?<<?G9>7 KBCD?B45B 3?>49D9?>C
#5D 1>4 45>?D5 D85 C?<ED9?>C D? 1>4 C G5 3?>C945B 1 >5D 9=@?BD5B ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 1>4 1 79F5> G?B<4
=1B;5D @B935 ?> 5>5B7I 1 =1B79>1< 9>3B51C5 9> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> <514C D? 1 3?BB5C@?>49>7 9>3B51C5 9> 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BDC AE1D9?> D5<<C EC D81D D85 =1B79>1< 25>5KD ?6 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> C8?E<4 5AE1< D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @B935 ?> 6?CC9< 6E5< @<EC D85 3?CD ?6 5=9CC9?> @5B=9DC D? 3?F5B
D85 3?BB5C@?>49>7 5=9CC9?>C ?6 & 1>4 D85 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI ?6 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD AE1D9?> CD1D5C D81D =1B79>1< @B?4E3D9?> 3?CD
?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I C8?E<4 5AE1< D85 =1B79>1< 25>5KD ?6 B5@<139>7 ?>5 E>9D 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD 2I D85 4?=5CD931<<I @B?4E354 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @<EC D85 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 1CC?391D54 G9D8 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> ?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C 1<C? C1F5C >5D 9=@?BD 3?CDC 1>4 B54E35 D85 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD 45@5>45>3I 2ED 4?5C >?D B54E35 D85 5=9CC9?>C ?6 & 5>35 D85 =1B79>1< 25>5KD ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<
@B?4E3D9?> 5AE1<C5A
%' !$ !"''#"
> D89C C53D9?> G5 C8?G 8?G D85 B57E<1D?B 2I D85 EC5 ?6 D8B55 @?<93I 9>
CDBE=5>DC 31> 9>4E35 D85 4?=5CD93 3?=@5D9D9F5 175>DC D? 9>D5B>1<9J5 D85 D8B55 5HD5B>1<9D95C 1>4 D85B52I 13895F5 D85 G5<61B5 ?@D9=E= *85 B57E
<1D?B 9>DB?4E35C & D1H5C ?> 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 1> 9=@?BD D1B9S ?> 9=@?BD54 5>5B7I 1>4 1 CE2C94I ?> B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?
4E3D9?> *85 4?=5CD93 B57E<1D9?> ?6 & 5=9CC9?>C 3?E<4 1<D5B>1D9F5<I 25 5>CEB54 2I DB1412<5 @5B=9DC C55 25<?G
*85 4?=5CD93 3?>CE=5B @B935 ?> 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 5AE1<C D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @B935 @<EC D1B9SC 1>4 D1H5C <5F954 ?> 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD )9>35 1<< ;9>4C ?6 5>5B7I 1B5 1CCE=54 D? 25 @5B653D CE2CD9DED5C D85 3?>
CE=5B @B935 ?> 5>5B7I 31>>?D 49S5B 25DG55> D85 F1B9?EC DI@5C 96 1<<
DI@5C ?6 5>5B7I 1B5 D? 25 3?>CE=54 *89C 9=@<95C D81D D85 3?>CE=5B
@B935 ?> 1<< DI@5C ?6 5>5B7I 5AE1<C
*85 @B?4E35B @B935 ?> 1 4?=5CD931<<I @B?4E354 5>5B7I C?EB35 =ECD 9> 5AE9<92B9E= 5AE1< D85 3?>CE=5B @B935 <5CC 1>I >5D D1H5C D1H5C =9>EC CE2C9495C <5F954 ?> D85 5>5B7I C?EB35 5>35 D85 @B?4E35B @B935 ?>
B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 5AE1<C D85 3?>CE=5B @B935 @<EC D85 49B53D CE2C94I D? B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?>
?>CE=5BC 1<C? @1I 1 & D1H ?> 4?=5CD931<<I @B?4E354 6?CC9< 5>
5B7I ?>C5AE5>D<I D85 @B?4E35B @B935 9C 79F5> 2I
?>CE=5BC =1H9=9J5 D859B G5<61B5
*85 B5>5G12<5 1>4 6?CC9< 5>5B7I @B?4E35BCM@B?KDC 45>?D54 1>4
1B5 79F5> 2I B5C@53D9F5<I
>C5BD9>7 6B?= P 9>D? P 1>4 =1H9=9J9>7 G9D8 B5C@53D D?
1>4 B5C@53D9F5<I G5 K>4 D85 6?<<?G9>7 KBCD?B45B 3?>49D9?>C
%#$#&'#" !"
" ! # " ! " "
!
%## -5 C55 6B?= 3?=@1B9>7 P G9D8 P D81D KBCD25CD 9C
13895F54 6?B 1>4
-5 B565B D? 1>4 1C D85 '97?F91> D1H5C CE2C94I ?> &5=9C C9?>C 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD 1>4 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> B5C@53D9F5<I )? 61B G5 81F5 3?>C945B54 D85 EC5 ?6 4?=5CD93 & D1H5C D? 3?>DB?< &
5=9CC9?>C C G5 81F5 1CCE=54 1> 9>D5B>1D9?>1< 3<9=1D5 17B55=5>D G9D8 AE1>D9K54 5=9CC9?> D1B75DC D89C 9=@<95C D81D D85 B57E<1D?B =ECD DB145
@5B=9DC ?> D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @5B=9D =1B;5D 9> ?B45B D? 5>CEB5 3?=@<9 1>35 > 945>D931< ?ED3?=5 G?E<4 25 13895F54 96 1<< 4?=5CD93 5=9DD5BC 1B5 ?2<971D54 D? 8?<4 @5B=9DC 3?BB5C@?>49>7 D? D859B 5=9CC9?>C 1>4 1B5 1<<?G54 D? DB145 @5B=9DC ?> D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @5B=9D =1B;5D 1C
*85 EC5 ?6 1> 9=@?BD D1B9S G9<< =?CD <9;5<I @B?F?;5 3?=@<19>DC D? D85 -?B<4 *B145 &B71>9J1D9?> 1C 9D F9?<1D5C D85 &B71>9J1D9?>MC BE<5C > D85 >5HD C53D9?> G5 45B9F5 D85 B57E<1D?BMC ?@D9=1< D1H1D9?> C385=5C 79F5> 1 21> ?> 9=@?BD D1B9SC
$'! '* &! ("% " #" !$#%' '%.&
6 D85 B57E<1D?B 9C @B5F5>D54 6B?= EC9>7 9=@?BD D1B9SC D85 B57E<1D?B 31>
9> 1449D9?> D? 1 & D1H 1>4 1 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I CE2C94I 9>DB?4E35 1 75>5B1< CE2C94I ?> 1<< 4?=5CD93 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 1>4 1 D1H ?>
5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> *85 3?>CE=5B @B935 ?> 5>5B7I 9C D8EC 79F5> 2I
*85 @B?4E35B @B935 ?> B5>5G12<5 1>4 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 9C 79F5> 2I 1
>C5BD9>7 6?B D85 @B935 6E>3D9?>C P 9> P 1>4 =1H9=9J 9>7 G9D8 B5C@53D D? 1>4 G5 K>4 D81D D85 KBCD?B45B 3?>49D9?>C 3?BB5C@?>4 D? P 6?B9> B5@<1354 2I 1>49> P B5@<1354 2I
%#$#&'#" " $
! "
" " #
%## -5 C55 6B?= 3?=@1B9>7 G9D8 G85B5 9C B5@<1354 2I 1>4 3?=@1B9>7 P G9D8 P G85B59C B5@<1354 2I D81D
KBCD25CD 9C 13895F54 6?B
1>4
*85 B57E<1D?B =9=93C D85 ?ED3?=5 ?6 9=@?BD D1B9SC 2I D85 EC5 ?6
@B?4E3D9?> CE2C9495C 1>4 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H5C G85B5 2?D8 D85 CE2C94I 1>4 D85 D1H 3?BB5C@?>4 D? 1> ?@D9=1< D1B9S *85 ?@D9=1< D1B9S 9>3B51C5C 2?D8 D85 3?>CE=5B @B935 ?> 5>5B7I 1>4 D85 4?=5CD93 @B?4E35B @B935
?> 2?D8 DI@5C ?6 5>5B7I 2I *89C @B935 9>3B51C5 9C >?G B5@<1354 2I 1 3?BB5C@?>49>7 D1H ?> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 1>4 1 3?BB5C@?>49>7 CE2C94I ?> @B?4E3D9?>C ?6 2?D8 DI@5C ?6 5>5B7I CE38 D81D 2?D8 D85
@B?4E35B @B935C 1>4 D85 3?>CE=5B @B935C B5=19> D85 C1=5 1C E>45B 1>
?@D9=1< D1B9S *85 3?>CDB19>D ?> D85 EC5 ?6 9=@?BD D1B9SC 6?B35C D85 B57E<1D?B D? EC5 6?EB @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC D? 5>CEB5C D85 6E<K<<=5>D ?6 D85 D8B55 KBCD?B45B 3?>49D9?>C 6?B D85 KBCD25CD ?ED3?=5 P5>35 1<D8?E78 D85B5 9C >? 5HD5B>1<9DI 49B53D<I <9>;54 D? D85 3?>
CE=@D9?> ?6 5>5B7I 9> 75>5B1< D85 ?@D9=1< ?ED3?=5 31> 25 13895F54 2I D85 9>3<EC9?> ?6 1 75>5B1< D1H ?> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> EBD85B=?B5 1
75>5B1< CE2C94I ?> 4?=5CD93 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 9C 1<C? 1 @1BD ?6 D85 ?@
D9=1< D1H C385=5 *85 3?1< 9>4ECDBI 9C CE2C949J54 9> C5F5B1< EB?@51>
3?E>DB95C 1>4 D89C @?<93I 81C 255> 851F9<I 3B9D939J54 C55 57 &
-5 81F5 C8?G> D81D G85> 9>3B51C54 45@5>45>35 ?6 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 6E5<C 9C 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 1CC?391D54 G9D8 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD 1>4 D85B5 9C 1 21> ?> 9=@?BD D1H5C 9D 9C G5<61B5 9=@B?F9>7 D? CD9=E<1D5 4?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C
-9D8 9>3B51C54 5>F9B?>=5>D1< 3?>35B> 1=?>7 D85 @?@E<1D9?> 9D 31>
25 81B45B D? G9> 1335@D1>35 6?B 1 @?<93I D81D 9=@<95C 1 CE2C94I ?> 6?CC9<
5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> > D85 >5HD C53D9?> G5 3?>C945B D85 ?@D9=1< ?ED 3?=5 79F5> D81D D85 B57E<1D?B 31> 9=@<5=5>D >59D85B 9=@?BD D1B9SC >?B CE2C9495C ?> >?>B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?>
&'%'#"& #" ' (& # !$#%' '*& " "
% "%+ &(&&-#"&' #$'!
6 D85 B57E<1D?B 9C @B5F5>D54 6B?= EC9>7 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1>4 D85B5 9C 1
@?<9D931< 3?>CDB19>D ?> 9=@<5=5>D9>7 CE2C9495C ?> >?>B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I
@B?4E3D9?> D85 B57E<1D?B 31>>?D 9>LE5>35 D85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 9F5>
G5 C55 6B?= D81D 4?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C 9C 45 D5B=9>54 2I D85 5H?75>?EC 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @B?4E35B @B935 ?> 6?CC9< 6E5<C
+>45B D89C 3?>CDB19>D D85 B57E<1D?B 31>>?D 5>CEB5 D85 KBCD25CD @B?
4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C *85 C53?>425CD ?ED3?=5 ?6 D85 G5<61B5 ?@D9=9J1 D9?> @B?2<5= 9C 6?E>4 2I =1H9=9J9>7 CE2:53D D?
#5D 1>4 45>?D5 D85 C?<ED9?>C D? 1>4 P %?D5 D81D 6?B 1 3?>CD1>D =1B79>1< 3?CD ?6 1<< ?6 D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C 1>4 1>4 1B5 5AE1< D? D85 KBCD25CD ?ED 3?=5C
!$ !"'" ' &#" &'
> D89C C53D9?> G5 3?>C945B 1 D1H C385=5 D? 9=@<5=5>D D85 C53?>425CD C?<ED9?> -5 3?>C945B D1H ?> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 1 CE2C94I ?> B5
)E2C9495C D? 5>5B7I @B?4E35BC ECE1<<I D1;5 D85 6?B= ?6 7B1>DC <?1>C 1>4 D1H 5H5=@D9?>C C55 &
>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 1>4 1 & D1H 2ED >? CE2C94I ?>
5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> ?B 9=@?BD D1B9S *85 3?>CE=5B @B935 ?> 5>5B7I 9C 79F5> 2I *85 @B?4E35B @B935 ?> B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 9C 79F5> 2I
*85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 9C 79F5> 2I >C5BD9>7 6?B D85
@B935 6E>3D9?>C 1>4 9> 1>4 1>4 =1H9=9J9>7 G9D8 B5C@53D D? 1>4 G5 K>4 D85 6?<<?G9>7 KBCD?B45B 3?>49D9?>C
*85 5AE1D9?>C 45K>5 1>4 I 3?=@1B9>7 P G9D8 P G5 45B9F5 D85 6?<<?G9>7 @B?@?C9D9?>
%#$#&'#"
! "
" ! "
! " "
" " !
!" "
%## ?>C945B D85 6?<<?G9>7 D1H5C
-5 C55 6B?= P 1>4 P D81D D89C D1H
CDBE3DEB5 <514C D? D85 C53?>425CD ?@D9=1< C?<ED9?> 1>4 > D85 12C5>35 ?6 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1>4 75>5B1< 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> CE2 C9495C D85 C53?>425CD ?@D9=1< B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I CE2C94I 3?BB5C@?>4C D?
D85 CE= ?6 D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C 1CC?391D54 G9D8 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?>
1>4 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD >3B51C9>7 12?F5 <514C D? 89785B @B?
4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 1>4 D85 9=@?BD ?6 6?CC9< 6E5< 61<<C 5>35 D85 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> CE2C94I 85<@C D? 3?BB53D 6?B D85 >571 D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI ?6 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BDC 9> 1449D9?> D? 3?BB53D9>7 6?B D85
@?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?>
> + 3?E>DB95CM3EBB5>D @?<9395C ?>5 31> ?2C5BF5 D1H5C ?> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 9> 1449D9?> D? & D1H5C 1>4 CE2C9495C ?> B5>5G12<5 5>
5B7I @B?4E3D9?>C 6?B 9>CD1>35 65549> D1B9SC C G5 81F5 C8?G> 85B5 9D 31> 25 ?@D9=1< D? C5D 1 65549> D1B9S 12?F5 D85 5HD5B>1< 25>5KD 6B?= B5
>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 96 3?E>DB95C 1B5 B5CDB93D54 6B?= EC9>7 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1>4 CE2C9495C ?> 6?CC9< 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?>
)? 61B G5 81F5 1CCE=54 D81D D85 B57E<1D?B EC5C 1 CE2C94I D? @B?
=?D5 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> >?D85B 1@@B?138 3EBB5>D<I 9> EC5
D? @B?=?D5 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 9C D85 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 CICD5= *85 CIC D5= B5AE9B5C D81D 3?>CE=5BC ?6 5>5B7I =ECD @EB381C5 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C 3?BB5C@?>49>7 D? 1 C81B5 ?6 D859B D?D1< 3?>CE=@D9?> *85 @B?4E35BC ?6 B5
>5G12<5 5>5B7I 81F5 D85 B978D D? 9CCE5 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C *85 =1B;5D 6?B 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C 45D5B=9>5C D85 @B935 6?B 35BD9K31D5C *89C CICD5= 4?5C
>?D 9=@<I 1>I 7?F5B>=5>D1< C@5>49>7 1C D85 CE2C94I 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 F1<E5 9C K>1>354 2I D85 5>5B7I 3?>CE=5BC *85 CICD5= 5>CEB5C D81D D85 D?D1< C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I ?6 D?D1< 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 5AE1<C D85
<5F5< C5D 2I D85 B57E<1D?B > D85 >5HD C53D9?> G5 3?>C945B D85 C9DE1D9?>
G85B5 D85 B5>5G12<5 CE2C9495C 1B5 B5@<1354 2I 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 CICD5=
%" %',' !%' #!" )'
'*
#5D 25 D85 C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 9> D85 ?F5B1<< 3?>CE=@D9?>
*85 3?>CE=5BC ?6 5>5B7I 1B5 ?2<9754 D? @EB381C57B55> 35BD9K31D5C 6?B 5138 E>9D 5>5B7I 3?>CE=54 1>4 @B?4E35BC 719> D85 B978D D? C5<< ?>5 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 6?B 5138 E>9D ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I D85I @B?4E35 #5D 45>?D5 D85 E>9D @B935 ?> 35BD9K31D5C -5 1CCE=5 D81D D85 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 CICD5= 9C 1449D9?>1< D? D85 & D1H 1>4 1 75>5B1< 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?>
D1H *85 3?>CE=5B @B935 ?> 5>5B7I 9C
*85 @B?4E35B @B935 ?> 5>5B7I C?EB35 5AE1<C D85 3?>CE=5B @B935
<5CC D85 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 3?CD 1>4 ?D85B >5D D1H5C ?> 5>5B7I C?EB35
@<EC D85 9>3?=5 6B?= 75>5B1D9>7 35BD9K31D5C 6?B!
?>CE=5BCMG5<61B5 6E>3D9?> 9C
*85 B5>5G12<5 @B?4E35BCM@B?KD 6E>3D9?> 9C 79F5> 2I
C 9> D85 @B5F9?EC C53D9?> 4?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C 9C 45D5B=9>54 2I D85 9>D5B>1D9?>1< @B?4E35B @B935 ?> 6?CC9< 6E5<C C55
*85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 9C 79F5> 2I $1H9=9J9>7 G9D8 B5C@53D D? 1>4 =1H9=9J9>7 G9D8 B5C@53D D? G5 K>4 D85 6?<<?G9>7 KBCD?B45B 3?>49D9?>C
B?= G5 31> GB9D5 D85 45=1>4 6?B 5>5B7I 1C 1 6E>3D9?> ?6 D85
@B935 ?> 5>5B7I 1>4 ?6 D85 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C 5H@5>49DEB5 @5B E>9D 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> B?= G5 K>4 D85 CE@@<I ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 1C 1 6E>3D9?> ?6 D85 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 @B935 1>4 D85
@B?4E35B @B935 6?B 5>5B7I *85 =1B;5D 3<51B9>7 3?>49D9?>
6?B 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C 9C D85B56?B5
B?= G5 K>4 D85 =1B;5D 3<51B1>35 @B935 ?> 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C 1C 1 6E>3D9?> ?6 1>4 D81D 9C
%#$#&'#"
! "
" # "
! ! "
" " # "
! "
%## #5D D85 & D1H 25 79F5> 2I D85 '97?F91> <5F5<C 9C 6?E>4 6B?= D85 B57E<1D?B 81C DG? @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 1>4 D?
B57E<1D5 D85 DG? F1B912<5C 1>4 P )53?>425CD ?@D9=1<9DI 9=@<95C D81D D85 B978D81>4 C945 ?6 P =ECD 5AE1< D85 B978D81>4 C945 ?6 P *85 C53?>425CD ?@D9=1< ?ED3?=5 9C 381B13D5B9J54 2I
1>4
G85B5 5>35
>DB?4E39>7 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 =1B;5D 9> 1449D9?> D? 1 & D1H 1>4 1 D1H ?> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 31> 13895F5 D85 C53?>425CD 1<<?31D9?> ?6 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 1>4 3?>CE=@D9?> 79F5> D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C
?G5F5B B5@<139>7 1 CE2C94I ?> B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> G9D8 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 CICD5= 45=1>4C 1 4?G>G1B4 14:ECD=5>D ?6 D85 5>5B7I
3?>CE=@D9?> D1H -5 31>>?D BE<5 ?ED D85 @?CC929<9DI D81D D85 C53?>4 25CD ?@D9=1< D1H ?> 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 9C >571D9F5 -5 C55 6B?= D85
@B??6 ?6 @B?@?C9D9?> D81D 6?B > D81D 31C5 D85 B57E<1D?B =ECD CE2C949J5 D85 EC5 ?6 5>5B7I D? 13895F5 C53?>4 25CD ?@D9=1< 1<<?31D9?> 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 CICD5= 9=@<95C 1 89785B 3?CD
?6 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> <D8?E78 D85 ?6 B5>5G12<5C 9C C5D 5AE1< D?
C53?>425CD D85 <5F5< ?6 3?>CE=@D9?> =1I 253?=5 D?? <?G 3?=@1B54 D? C53?>425CD 6?B > D81D 31C5 D85 3?>CE=@D9?>
?6 5>5B7I =ECD 25 CE2C949J54 D? 13895F5 D85 C53?>425CD <5F5< C @?9>D54
?ED 9> E>5 5D 1< 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C =1B;5D 9C >?D 1> 5R395>D 9>CDBE=5>D 6?B 3?BB53D9>7 6?B 5HD5B>1<9D95C ?G5F5B G5 81F5 C8?G>
D81D 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 =1B;5D 31> 25 45C97>54 D? 13895F5 C53?>425CD 5R395>3I 96 9D 9C G9D8 ?@D9=1< 45C97> ?6 5>5B7I D1H5C ED 9D 9C 9=@?BD1>D D? >?D5 D81D D85 C53?>425CD ?ED3?=5 1<C? 45=1>4C D81D D85 C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5C 9C C5D 1D D85 C53?>425CD ?@D9=1< <5F5< 5>35 D85 B57E<1D?B =ECD >?D ?><I 81F5 ;>?G<5475 12?ED D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C ?6 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> 1>4 @B?4E3D9?> 1C 9> C53D9?> 2ED 1<C? 12?ED D85 ?@D9=1< C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5C
>?D85B 9=@?BD1>D <5CC?> 9C D81D D85 3?=29>54 EC5 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE
=5>DC C8?E<4 25 3??B49>1D54 13B?CC 1<< 3?>CE=5BC *85 ?@D9=1< D1H ?>
5>5B7I 9> 31C5 ?6 1 7B55> 35BD9K31D5 CICD5= 49S5BC 6B?= D85 ?@D9=1< D1H 9> D85 31C5 ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I CE2C9495C *89C <514C D? D85 6?<<?G9>7 3?B?<<1BI
#%# %+ "
" " "
#
*85 + C55;C D? 81B=?>9J5 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H5C +
&EB B5CE<DC C8?G D81D 1 81B=?>9J1D9?> ?6 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H5C 45=1>4C 3??B49>1D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @?<9395C 13B?CC + =5=25BC D? 13895F5 1> ?@D9=1< ?ED3?=5 6?B D85 +
#" (" %!%&
> D85 9>DB?4E3D9?> G5 1B7E54 D81D 9> ?B45B D? 49C3ECC D85 3?CD 5S53D9F5
>5CC ?6 D85 EC5 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9D 9C 3BE391< D? 81F5 1 G5<<45K>54
@?<93I ?2:53D9F5 > D89C CDE4I G5 1CCE=54 D81D D85 B57E<1D?B G1>D54 D? 3?BB53D 6?B D8B55 5HD5B>1<9D95C 1 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 6B?= @B?4E3 D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 6B?= 6?CC9< 6E5< 9=@?BD 1>4 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 6B?= 6?CC9< 6E5< 3?>CE=@D9?> &5=9CC9?>C
*85C5 1B5 1<< 5HD5B>1<9D95C 6B?= 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 1>4 3?>CE=@D9?> D81D
1B5 5H@<939D<I 144B5CC54 2I D85 EB?@51> ?==9CC9?> 9> 9DC (5>5G12<5
>5B7I 1>4 <9=1D5 81>75 '13;175 9F5> D85C5 5HD5B>1<9D95C 9D 9C ?@
D9=1< D? CE2C949J5 4?=5CD93 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 6?CC9< 6E5<C 9> 1 C5DD9>7 G85B5 9=@?BD D1B9SC 1B5 21>>54 ?G5F5B D89C 4?5C >?D =51> D81D 3?E>DB95C D81D 6?B 9>CD1>35 CE2C949J5 D859B 3?1< @B?4E3D9?> >535CC1B9<I 9=@<5
=5>D 1 3?CD5S53D9F5 @?<93I *85 3<9=1D5 1>4 5>5B7I @?<9395C 9> =1>I + 3?E>DB95C 1B5 DI@931<<I 381B13D5B9J54 2I D1H 5H5=@D9?> B54E354 D1H B1D5C ?B CE2C949J54 5<53DB939DI 3?>DB13DC 6?B C@539K3 7B?E@C 9S5B5>D91D 9>7 D1H5C 1>4 CE2C9495C 13B?CC @B?4E35BC 1>4 13B?CC 3?>CE=5BC ?6 ?>5 DI@5 ?6 6E5< 9C >?D @1BD ?6 1> 3?CD5S53D9F5 3<9=1D5 1>4 5>5B7I @?<93I 79F5> D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C G5 81F5 3?>C945B54 9> D89C @1@5B
-5 81F5 1CCE=54 D81D D85 B57E<1D54 3?E>DBI 7B?E@ ?6 3?E>DB95C
@1BD939@1D5C 9> 1> 9>D5B>1D9?>1< 3<9=1D5 17B55=5>D G9D8 1> 9>D5B>1D9?>1<
@B935 ?> 5=9CC9?>C @5B=9DC 6 D89C 9C >?D D85 31C5 D85 D1H ?> 5=9CC9?>C C8?E<4 3?BB5C@?>4 D? D85 5HD5B>1< 3?CD ?6 & 5=9CC9?>C G81D5F5B D81D 9C @5B359F54 D? 25 << ?EB 3?>3<EC9?>C B571B49>7 C53?>425CD D1H1D9?> ?6 5=9CC9?>C B5<1D9F5 D? D85 KBCD25CD G9<< CD9<< 8?<4
*85 +MC (5>5G12<5 >5B7I 1>4 <9=1D5 81>75 '13;175 3?>D19>C C5F5B1< 5H1=@<5C ?6 9>5R395>D EC5 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 1>4 9>5R395>D B57E<1D9?>C ?B 9>CD1>35 D85 D1B75D 6?B D85 5=9CC9?>C B54E3D9?>C 9>
9C @1BD<I 13895F54 2I 5=9CC9?>C B54E3D9?>C 6B?= C?EB35C 3?F5B54 2I D85 +MC 5=9CC9?> DB149>7 C385=5 +*) 1>4 @1BD<I 2I 49S5B5>D91D54
>1D9?>1< D1B75DC 6?B C?EB35C >?D 3?F5B54 2I +*) + 1 3
?G5F5B 5=9CC9?> B54E3D9?>C 31> ?><I 25 13895F54 9> 1 3?CD5S53D9F5
=1>>5B 96 D85B5 1B5 >? 3?>CDB19>DC ?> 5=9CC9?>C DB149>7 13B?CC C53D?BC 1>4 3?E>DB95C )9>35 D85 +*) 49B53D9F5 C5DC B5CDB93D9?>C ?> D85 EC5 ?6 5=9CC9?>C DB149>7 6?B C53D?BC 3?F5B54 2I D85 +*) 3?CD 5S53D9F5>5CC G9<< >?D 25 13895F54 + 3
%1D9?>1<<I 49S5B5>D91D54 B5>5G12<5C D1B75DC 1B5 1>?D85B 5H1=@<5 ?6 9>5R395>3I *? 13895F5 D85 D1B75D ?6 1 C81B5 ?6 B5>5G12<5C 9> D85 +MC D?D1< 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D85 ?E>39< 81C 14?@D54 =1>41D?BI 496 65B5>D91D54 >1D9?>1< D1B75DC 6?B 5138 ?6 D85 =5=25B CD1D5C + 2 1@@5>49H &2F9?EC<I G9D8?ED 9>CDBE=5>DC D? 49CDB92ED5 D85 @B?4E3 D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 13B?CC 3?E>DB95C 3?CD5S53D9F5<I 49S5B5>D91D54
>1D9?>1< D1B75DC 9>3B51C5 D85 3?CD ?6 6E<K<<9>7 D85 ?F5B1<< B5>5G12<5 D1B75D ) *89C @1@5B 81C @?9>D54 D? I5D 1>?D85B @?D5>D91< C?EB35 6?B 9>5R 395>3I -5 81F5 C8?G> D81D D85 38?935 ?6 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC D? @B?=?D5 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> CE2C9495C F5BCEC 7B55> 35BD9K31D5C 1S53DC D85 ?@D9=1< <5F5< ?6 75>5B1< 5>5B7I D1H5C )? 61B D89C 9C >?D D1;5> 9>D?
133?E>D 9> D85 + 1C D85 + =5=25B CD1D5C 1B5 6B55 D? 38??C5 4?=5CD93 9>CDBE=5>DC D? @B?=?D5 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 9>45@5>45>D<I ?6
D859B 5>5B7I 3?>CE=@D9?> D1H1D9?> )53?>425CD ?@D9=E= 6?B D85 + 31>>?D 25 13895F54 G9D8?ED 1 3??B49>1D9?> ?6 5>5B7I D1H5C 1>4 B5>5G 12<5 5>5B7I @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC 9> 5138 3?E>DBI 79F5> D85 5HD5B>1<9D95C 144B5CC54 9> D89C @1@5B
-5 81F5 D1;5> 1C 1 CD1BD9>7 @?9>D D81D D85 + 1DD1385C 1 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI D? D85 @B?4E3D9?> ?6 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I *89C G1C 21C54 ?>
D85 +MC 1B7E=5>D D81D D85 B5>5G12<5 49B53D9F5 9>D5B 1<91 3?E<4 79F5 1 2??CD D? 8978D538 9>4ECDB95C >5G 53?>?=93 ?@@?BDE>9D95C 1>4 :?2C -5 1B7E54 9> D85 9>DB?4E3D9?> D81D D85C5 3?>C5AE5>35C 3?E<4 @B?212<I 25DD5B 25 144B5CC54 2I ?D85B @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC =?B5 49B53D<I 19=54 1D CE@@?BD9>7 8978D538 9>4ECDB95C ?B 5=@<?I=5>D 6 D81D 9C 4?>5 D85 B5=19>9>7 @?C9D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 6B?= B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> G?E<4
@5B81@C 25 ?6 =9>?B F1<E5 ?G5F5B 4?=5CD931<<I @B?4E354 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I 9C 1 CE2CD9DED5 6?B 9=@?BD54 6?CC9< 5>5B7I 1>4 1C <?>7 1C D85B5 9C 1 >571D9F5 5HD5B>1<9DI 6B?= 6?CC9< 9=@?BD 9D 9C C53?>425CD ?@D9=1< D?
CD9=E<1D5 B5>5G12<5 5>5B7I @B?4E3D9?> 96 D85B5 1B5 B5CDB93D9?>C ?> D85 EC5 ?6 9=@?BD D1H5C 1>4 6?CC9< 5>5B7I CE2C9495C *89C 31> 25 C55> 6B?=
D85 @B??6 ?6 @B?@?C9D9?> 1C 6?B
%"&
/0 =E>4C5> ) 1>4 ! $?BD5>C5> *85 1>9C8 B55>
5BD9K31D5 )ICD5= C?=5 C9=@<5 1>1<ID931< B5CE<DC >5B7I 3?
>?=93C P
/0 E>5 ( ( ?<?=25; ) "9DD5<C5> 1>4 " (?C5>418<
#925B1<9J9>7 EB?@51> >5B7I $1B;5DC > 3?>?=93
>1<IC9C 85<D5>81= +" 4G1B4 <71B 'E2<9C89>7
/0 5>>51B # 1>4 ( )D1F9>C )53?>425CD D85?BI 1>4 D85 EC5
?6 =E<D9@<5 @?<93I 9>CDBE=5>DC >F9B?>=5>D1< 1>4 (5C?EB35 3?
>?=93C P
/0 5BD?<49 ' 1>4 * E<4 *B1412<5 35BD9K31D5C 6?B B5>5G12<5 5<53DB939DI 1>4 5>5B7I C1F9>7C >5B7I '?<93I P
/0 T8B9>75B 1>4 " (?C5>418< B55> C5BF5C D85 49BD9 5CD &> D85 9>D5B13D9?> 25DG55> 2<13; 1>4 7B55> AE?D1C 1335@D54
=1>EC3B9@D !?EB>1< ?6 (57E<1D?BI 3?>?=93C
/0 + ?E>39< 9B53D9F5 ?6 &3D?25B &6 K391< !?EB>1< ?6 D85 EB?@51> +>9?>
/0 + N$$& 41D5 !1>E1BIO +(&'Q@B5CC B5<51C5C
/0 + 1 ) &% %? ?6 D85 EB?@51> '1B<91
=5>D 1>4 ?6 D85 ?E>39< &R391< !?EB>1< ?6 D85 EB?@51> +>9?>
/0 + 2 (* , ?6 D85 EB?@51> '1B<91=5>D 1>4 ?6 D85 ?E>39< &R391< !?EB>1< ?6 D85 EB?@51> +>9?>
/0 + 3 (* , ?6 D85 EB?@51> '1B<91=5>D 1>4 ?6 D85 ?E>39< &R391< !?EB>1< ?6 D85 EB?@51> +>9?>
/0 EB?CD1D >5B7IQ.51B<I )D1D9CD93C EB?@51> ?=
=9CC9?>
/0 9C385B 1>4 ( %5G5<< >F9B?>=5>D1< 1>4 D538>?<?7I
@?<9395C 6?B 3<9=1D5 =9D971D9?> !?EB>1< ?6 >F9B?>=5>D1< 3?>?=93C 1>4 $1>175=5>D P
/0 ?<?=25; ( 175= 1>4 $ ?5< R395>D 9>3?=@<5D5 9>D5B>1D9?>1< 3<9=1D5 17B55=5>DC (5C?EB35 1>4 >5B7I 3?>?=93C /0 ?5< $ )8?E<4 1 31B2?> D1H 25 49S5B5>D91D54 13B?CC C53 P
D?BC !?EB>1< ?6 'E2<93 3?>?=93C P
/0 HD5>454 >5B7I 1<1>35C 549D9?> G9D8 41D1 >D5B>1D9?>1< >5B7I 75>3I
/0 !1S5 ( %5G5<< 1>4 ( )D1F9>C >F9B?>=5>D1< @?<93I 1>4 D538>?<?7931< 381>75 >F9B?>=5>D1< 1>4 (5C?EB35 3?>?=93C /0 "F5B>4?;; ) 1>4 " (?C5>418< <9=1D5 @?<9395C 1>4 P
<51B>9>7 2I 4?9>7 =@13DC 1>4 D9=9>7 ?6 D538>?<?7I CE2C9495C (5 C?EB35 1>4 >5B7I 3?>?=93C P
/0 #TC385< + $?C<5>5B 1>4 * (U225<;5 >4931D?BC
?6 5>5B7I C53EB9DI 9> 9>4ECDB91<9J54 3?E>DB95C >5B7I '?<93I /0 $?BD8?BCD ' B55> 35BD9K31D5C 1>4 5=9CC9?> DB149>7P
>5B7I '?<93I P
/0 & >F9B?>=5>D1<<I 1B=6E< )E2C9495C 81<<5>75C 6?B (56?B= & 'E2<9C89>7
/0 '9J5B - 1>4 '?@@ >4?75>9J9>7 D538>?<?7931<
381>75 $1D389>7 5=@9B931< 5F945>35 D? =?45<9>7 >554C >5B7I 3?>?=93C P
/0 ) O>>5H D? D85 9=@13D 1CC5CC=5>DO ?==9CC9?> )D1S -?B;9>7 ?3E=5>D ) ?==9CC9?> ?6 D85 EB?@51>
?==E>9D95C
/0 )?BB5<< ) 1>4 ! )9:= 1B2?> DB149>7 9> D85 @?<93I =9H
&H6?B4 (5F95G ?6 3?>?=93 '?<93I P
/0 )D?>5=1> ' 1>4 ! ,93;5BC *85 1CC5CC=5>D *85 53?>?=93C
?6 D538>?<?7I @?<93I &H6?B4 (5F95G ?6 3?>?=93 '?<93I 9PHF9
