• No results found

Paper III

N/A
N/A
Protected

Academic year: 2022

Share "Paper III"

Copied!
14
0
0

Laster.... (Se fulltekst nå)

Fulltekst

(1)

Paper III

C. Sætre, C. A. Barth, J. Stadsnes, N. Østgaard, S. M. Bailey, D. N. Baker,

G. A. Germany, and J. W. Gjerloev (2006)

Thermospheric nitric oxide at higher latitudes - Model

calculations with auroral energy input

Submitted to Journal of Geophysical Research

(2)
(3)

! " # $! % &$!!'# ( ) #&

$&'&$! * ! $'$& %+ '!

,- ./01234 ,- 5 - 6710894 :- .07;<=2<34 > - ?<0@771;34 .- A - 67BC2DE4 F- > - 67G2194

H- 5 - H21I 7=DJ4 7=; :- K - HL21CM2NO

PQRSTUVSW XYZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ cdef bZ[g\]h \[ ]YZ i`jZ^ ]YZ^k`glYZ^Z Ymg nZZ[ _mi_op

im]Zb nh m lY`]`_YZk \_mi k`bZi q`^ dea m[b _`k lm^Zb j\]Y kZmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]\Zgr

s

] Y\tYZ^ im]\]obZg ]YZ k `g] \kl`^]m[] _`[]^\no]`^ q`^ de bZ[g\]h \[_^ZmgZg \g Z[Z^tZ]\_

ZiZ_]^`[ l^Z_\l\]m]\`[r XYZ ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th \[lo] \g b\u\bZb \[ tZ`t^mlY\_ m^Zmg `q vw im]p

\]obZ m[b xyw i`[t\]obZ q`^ m _`[]\[o`og ]\k Z \[]Z^umi `q q`o^ bmhgr XYZ Z[Z^th \g bZp

^\uZb \[ ]j` jmhgz q^`k mo^`^mi oi]^mu\`iZ] c{|f m[b }p^mh k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g~ m[b Zg]\km]Zb

q^`k t^`o[b kmt[Z]`k Z]Z^ kZmgo^Zk Z[]gr XYZgZ m^Z ogZb mg \[lo] q`^ ]YZ lY`]`_YZkp

\_mi dea k`bZir XYZ {| m[b }p^mh k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g m^Z q^`k ]YZ {i]^mu\`iZ] kmtZ^ c{|f

m[b ]YZ €`im^ `[`glYZ^\_ }p^mh kmt\[t alZ^\kZ[] c€}f~ n`]Y `[n`m^b ]YZ €`p

im^ glm_Z_^mq]r ‚`^ ]YZ ]\kZ \[]Z^umig j\]Y`o] {| m[b €} kZmgo^Zk Z[]g~ m lm^mkZ]^\ƒmp

]\`[ `q ]YZ ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa q^`k t^`o[b kmt[Z]\_ kZmgo^Zk Z[]g jZ^Z ogZbr XY\g lm^mkZ]^\ƒmp

]\`[ jmg nmgZb `[ bm]m q^`k ]YZ …olZ^† s‡

bm]mnmgZ _`klm^Zb ]` {|ˆ€} bZ^\uZb

ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oaZgr XYZ lZ^]o^nm]\`[ \[ ]YZ g`o]Yjm^b t^`o[b k mt[Z]\_ _`kl`[Z[]

\g q`o[b ]` nZ i\[Zm^ih ^Zim]Zb ]` ]YZ l^Z_\l\]m]\[t ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa bZ^\uZb q^`k {|

m[b €} kZmgo^Zk Z[]gr XYZ ZuZ[] \g q^`k ‰Š s

l^\i cbmh ‹xŠf o[]\i y † mh ‹ŒŒ~ jYZ^Z

]YZ `[gZ] `q m tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k `__o^^Zb x †mh cbmh ‹xxfr XYZ k `bZiZb de bZ[g\]h

\g _`klm^Zb j\]Y de k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g q^`k ]YZ …]obZ[] d\]^\_ ea\bZ ali`^Z^ c…defr

XYZ ^Zgoi]g gY`j m[ `uZ^mii im^tZ^ k`bZiZb [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]h m] mo^`^mi im]\]obZg ]Ym[

jYm] jmg kZmgo^Zb nh …der XYZ im^tZg] b\g_^Zlm[_\Zg jZ^Z q`^ ]YZ bmh `q ]YZ g]`^k

`[gZ]~ jYZ[ ]YZ nm_Žt^`o[b m]k`glYZ^Z jmg b\g]`^]Zb nh `oiZ YZm]\[tr XYZ [Za] bmh~

jYZ[ ]YZ m]k`glYZ^Z Ymb gZ]]iZb b`j[~ ]YZ mt^ZZkZ[] nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k `bZi m[b ]YZ `np

gZ^um]\`[g jmg qm^ nZ]]Z^r

‘ ’“”•–—˜™”š–“

›œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ œ¤ ¥£ ¦§§£ž ¨© ª§¥£ž£ œª ¨ ©œ¤ ž Ÿ ¤«

ªœ¦£¤ ¬¥œŸ¥ ¥¨ª œ©§ ž¨¤ §ž §£žœ£ª ­ ž ¥£ ž¨¢œ¨œ®£

Ÿ  ¯œ¤° ¨¤¢ ­ ž ¥£ Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ Ÿ ©§ ªœœ ¤± ²¥£ ¯œ­£œ©£  ­

›³ ¨ ¥£ª£ ¨¯œ¦¢£ª œª ¨´ ¦  ¤£ ¢¨µ ­ ž ª¦¤¯œ Ÿ ¤¢œ«

œ ¤ª¶ ¨¤¢ ›³ Ÿ¨¤ ¥£¤Ÿ£ ­¦¤Ÿœ ¤ ¨ª ¨ ž¨Ÿ£ £¯£©£¤ ­ ž

¨© ª§¥£žœŸ © œ ¤± ²¥£ž£ ¨ž£ ¨¯ª  §ž£¢œŸœ ¤ª ¨¤¢  ´«

ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª ¥¨ ¥£ž© ª§¥£žœŸ ›³ Ÿ¨¤ ´£ ž¨¤ª§ ž£¢  

¯ ¬£ž ¨¯œ¦¢£ª ¬œ¥œ¤ ¨ ªž ¤° ¬œ¤£ž § ¯¨ž ® ž£¡   ¥£

ªž¨ ª§¥£ž£¶ ¬¥£ž£ ›³ Ÿ¨¤ ž£¨Ÿ ¬œ¥  · ¤£ ¸£±°± ¹º»º¼º½

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÄÅÆ Ç

À

½È

À

»»

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÅÉÉʶ ÅÉÉË̱ ͞£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¤£ž«

°£œŸ §¨žœŸ¯£ª Ÿ¨¦ª£ ¢œªª Ÿœ¨œ ¤¶ œ ¤œ·¨œ ¤ ¨¤¢ £¡Ÿœ¨œ ¤

 ­ ¥£ ¦§§£ž ¨© ª§¥£žœŸ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯£ª ¨¤¢ ¨ ©ª± ²¥£ £¡«

ÎÏÐÑÒÓÔÕÐÖÔ ×Ø ÙÚÛÜÝÞÜ ÒÖß àÐÞÚÖ×á×âÛã äÖÝåÐÓÜÝÔÛ ×Ø

æ

ÐÓâÐÖãç×ÓèÒÛé

êëÒì×ÓÒÔ×ÓÛ Ø×Ó íÔÕ×ÜÑÚÐÓÝÞ ÒÖß îÑÒÞÐ ÙÚÛÜÝÞÜãäÖÝåÐÓÜÝÔÛ

ר ï×á×ÓÒß×ã

æ

×ðáßÐÓã ï×á×ÓÒß×ãäîíé

ñò

Ð×ÑÚÛÜÝÞÒá óÖÜÔÝÔðÔÐãäÖÝåÐÓÜÝÔÛ ×Ø íáÒÜôÒãõÒÝÓìÒÖôÜã

íáÒÜôÒãäîíé

öïÐÖÔÐÓ Ø×Ó îÑÒÞÐ ÙáÒÜÕÒ ÒÖß íÐÓ×Ö×ÕÝÞ ÷ÐÜÐÒÓÞÚã

äÖÝåÐÓÜÝÔÛ ×Ø íáÒìÒÕÒ ÝÖ øðÖÔÜåÝááÐãøðÖÔÜåÝááÐãíáÒìÒÕÒãäîí

ùíÑÑáÝÐß ÙÚÛÜÝÞÜ

ë

Òì×ÓÒÔ×ÓÛãú×ÚÖÜ ø×ÑôÝÖÜ äÖÝåÐÓÜÝÔÛã

ëÒðÓÐáãûÒÓÛáÒÖßãäîíé

ï×ÑÛÓÝâÚÔ

9üüý

ìÛ ÔÚÐ íÕÐÓÝÞÒÖ òÐ×ÑÚÛÜÝÞÒá äÖÝ×Öé

ÙÒÑÐÓ ÖðÕìÐÓ é

ü3Jþÿü99 üýü é

üü

Ÿœ£¢ ¤œž °£¤ ¨ ©ª ¬œ¯¯ ž£¨Ÿ ¬œ¥ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯¨ž  ¡µ°£¤ ¨¤¢

°œ®£ §ž ¢¦Ÿœ ¤  ­ ›³± ²¥£ ©¨¡œ©¦© ¢£¤ªœµ  ­ ›³ œª œ¤

¥£ ¯ ¬£ž ¥£ž© ª§¥£ž£¶ ¨ž ¦¤¢ ÂÂÉ © ¨¯œ¦¢£± ›³ œª

©¨œ¤¯µ ¢£ªž µ£¢ ´µ §¥  ¢œªª Ÿœ¨œ ¤ ­ž © ª ¯¨ž ­¨ž ¦¯ž¨«

®œ ¯£ ž¨¢œ¨œ ¤¶ ¨¤¢ ¥£ ª¦´ª£¦£¤ ž£¨Ÿœ ¤ ¬œ¥ °ž ¦¤¢

ª¨£ ¤œž °£¤± ²¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ œ¤ ¥£ ¯ ¬£ž ¥£ž© ª§¥£ž£

®¨žœ£ª ¬œ¥ ¥£ œ©£  ­ ¢¨µ¶¥£ ª ¯¨ž ž¨¢œ¨œ ¤¶ ¨¤¢ ¥£ ¨¦«

ž ž¨¯ §¨žœŸ¯£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤± Í¥  £¯£Ÿž ¤ª §ž ¢¦Ÿ£¢ ­ž ©

ª ¯¨ž ª ­ «ž¨µª ¨¤¢ £¡ž£©£ ¦¯ž¨®œ ¯£ ¶ Ÿ¨¦ª£ ›³

œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£ ¨ ¨¯¯ ¯¨œ¦¢£ª ¬¥£ž£ ¥£ž£ œª ª¦¤¯œ°¥±  ¥œ°¥£ž

¯¨œ¦¢£ª ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤ ¢ ©œ¤¨£ª ¥£ ›³

§ž ¢¦Ÿœ ¤± ²¥£ œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£ œ¤ ›³ ­ž © ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤«

£ž°µ œ¤§¦ ¥¨ª ´££¤  ­ œ¤£ž£ª ­ ž ª£®£ž¨¯ ¢£Ÿ¨¢£ª±  ¢£¯ª

¥¨®£ ´££¤ £ª¨´¯œª¥£¢ ­ ž Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨œ¤° ¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ œ¤ ¥£

¯ ¬£ž ¥£ž© ª§¥£ž£±  ¬£®£ž¶¥£ Ÿ¥¨¤°£ª  ­ ›³ ¨ ¥£ ¨¦«

ž ž¨¯¯¨œ¦¢£ª ¨ž£ ªœ¯¯¤ ­¦¯¯µ ¨ŸŸ ¦¤£¢ ­ ž ´µ ¥£© ¢£¯ª¶

£ª§£Ÿœ¨¯¯µ Ÿ ¤ªœ¢£žœ¤° ¥£ ¥£¨œ¤° ££Ÿª  ¤ ¥£ ´¨Ÿ°ž ¦¤¢

¨© ª§¥£ž£¶ ¨¤¢ ž¨¤ª§ ž ´µ ¤£¦ž¨¯ ¬œ¤¢ª±

¹½È

¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÂÃÄÃ´Ì œ¤®£ªœ°¨£¢ ¥£ ®¨žœ¨œ ¤  ­ ¥£ž«

© ª§¥£žœŸ ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ ¢¦žœ¤° ¨¤ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ ª ž© ¨ ¯ ¬ ¨¤¢

©œ¢¢¯£ ¯¨œ¦¢£ª¶ ¬¥£ž£ ¥£ ££Ÿ  ­ £¤¥¨¤Ÿ£¢ §¨žœŸ¯£ ¨¤¢

 ¦¯£ ¥£¨œ¤° ¨¤¢ ª ¯¨ž ª ­ «ž¨µª ¬£ž£ ¢ ©œ¤¨¤ ­ ž ¥£

›³ ¢£¤ªœµ± ²¥£ Ÿ ©§¨¤œ ¤ §¨§£ž ¹½È

¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÂÃÄè̶

¨¤¨¯µ·£¢ ¥£ ž£ª§ ¤ª£  ­ ›³ ¨ ¥œ°¥£ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ª ¢¦žœ¤° ¨¤

¨¦ž ž¨¯ ª ž©± ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ª¥ ¬£¢ ¨ ­¨Ÿ ž

 ­ œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£ ­ž ©  ¤£ ¢¨µ §žœ ž   ¥£ ª ž©    ¤£ ¢¨µ

¨­£ž ¥£ ª ž©± ²  Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£ ¥œª ž£ª§ ¤ª£ ¥£µ ¦ª£¢ ¨ œ©£

¢£§£¤¢£¤ §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ ›³¡ © ¢£¯ ´¨ª£¢  ¤ ¥£ ¬ ž  ­

»

¾À

¸ÂÃÄË̱ ²¥£ ¥œª žµ  ­ ¥£ §¨žœŸ¯£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤ ¬œ¥

(4)

Ÿ¥¨ž¨Ÿ£žœªœŸ £¤£ž°µ ¨¤¢ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ­ ž ª§£ŸœŸ °£ °ž¨§¥«

œŸ¨¯ ¯ Ÿ¨œ ¤¶ ¬¨ª ¦ª£¢ ¨ª œ¤§¦   ¥£ © ¢£¯± ²¥œª ¬¨ª

¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ¨¤ £©§œžœŸ¨¯© ¢£¯  ­ °¯ ´¨¯ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤ §¨«

£ž¤ª Ÿ ¤ªž¦Ÿ£¢ ­ž © ¥£ ²³ ›³ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ §¨žœŸ¯£

 ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª ¸º

¿¾ ¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÄËÆ »»

¾ Ǻ

¾

»»

À

½È

À

½¶

ÂÃÄ̱ ²¥£ §¨žœŸ¯£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤ ¬¨ª  ž¢£ž£¢ ´µ ¨¤ ¨Ÿœ®«

œµ §¨ž¨©££ž¶ ¥£ ¥£©œª§¥£žœŸ §¨žœŸ¯£ § ¬£ž œ¤§¦ Ͷ

£ªœ©¨£¢ ­ž ©  ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª ´µ ›³ Ë ¨¤¢ ± ²¥£ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦«

¯¨£¢ ¯ ¬£ž ¥£ž© ª§¥£ž£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ¬¨ª Ÿ ©§¨ž£¢   ¥£

›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ´µ ¥£  ¯¨ž £ª ª§¥£žœŸ ¡§¯ ž£ž

± ²¥£ © ¢£¯  ®£ž£ªœ©¨£¢ ¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ¨ ¨¯¯ ¨¯«

œ¦¢£ª ´ ¥ ­ ž ¥£ ¦œ£ ¢¨µ ´£­ ž£ ¥£ ª ž© ¶¨¤¢ ­ ž ¥£

¢¨µ ¨­£ž ¥£ ª ž©± ²¥£ ¢œªŸž£§¨¤Ÿµ Ÿ ¦¯¢ ´£ ¢¦£   ¨   

¯¨ž°£ µœ£¯¢  ­ £¡Ÿœ£¢ ¨ ©œŸ ¤œž °£¤ ËÉ«Ê §ž ¢¦Ÿ£¢

­ž © £¤£ž°£œŸ £¯£Ÿž ¤ œ©§¨Ÿ  ¤ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯¨ž ¤œž °£¤± £ž«

œŸ¨¯ ¬œ¤¢ª œ¤ ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ ¨žŸ Ÿ ¦¯¢ ¨¯ª  ´£ œ©§ ž¨¤ œ¤

¢¨©§œ¤° ¥£ ›³ ž£ª§ ¤ª£   œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£¢ §¨žœŸ¯£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨«

œ ¤± ›£¦ž¨¯ ¬œ¤¢ ž¨¤ª§ ž  ­ ›³ ¬£ž£ ¤  ¨ŸŸ ¦¤£¢ ­ ž

œ¤ ¥£ © ¢£¯±  ¬¨ª ¨¯ª  £©§¥¨ªœ·£¢ ¥¨ ¨ © ž£ ¨ŸŸ¦ž¨£

œ©£ ¥œª žµ  ­ ¥£ §¨žœŸ¯£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤¶ ¥¨¤ ¥¨ ¢£žœ®£¢

­ž © ¨¤ £©§œžœŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯¶¬ ¦¯¢ ´£ ž£¦œž£¢±

¤ ¥£ž ®£žªœ ¤  ­ ¥œª §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯ ­ ž Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦«

¯¨œ¤° ¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ¬¨ª ¢£®£¯ §£¢ ´µ

À¿

¸ÂÃÃÅ̶ ¨¤¢

œ©§ž ®£¢ ­¦ž¥£ž ´µ

À

»

¾ ¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÅÉÉÅ̱ ͞£®œ ¦ª¯µ ¥£

© ¢£¯¥¨ª ´££¤ ž¦¤¬œ¥ ª ¯¨ž ª ­ «ž¨µ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª­ž ©

›³ ¨ª œ¤§¦ ­ ž §¥  £¯£Ÿž ¤ª¶­ ž £ªœ©¨œ ¤  ­ ›³ ¢£¤«

ªœµ ¨ ¯ ¬£ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ª ¸

À¿ À

½È

À

»

¾

¶ ÅÉÉ̱  ©§¨ž«

œª ¤ª ¬œ¥ ›³ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ­ž © ›³ ª¥ ¬£¢ ¨ ž£©¨ž¨´¯£

¨°ž££©£¤ ¨ ¯¨œ¦¢£ª ´£¯ ¬ É ¤ ž¥ ¨¤¢ ª ¦¥± ²¥£

§¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯ Ÿ¨¤ ¨¯ª  ´£ ¦ª£¢ ­ ž ¢£žœ®œ¤° ¥£  «

¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¢£§ ªœœ ¤ ­ž © ›³ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ´µ

›³± ¹

¿¾ ¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÅÉÉËÌ Ÿ ©§¨ž£¢ ¥œª £¤£ž°µ ¢£§ ªœœ ¤

­ž © ¥£ž© ª§¥£žœŸ ›³ ¢£¤ªœœ£ª¶ ¬œ¥ ¥¨ ¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž ©

œ©£«œ¤£°ž¨£¢ «ž¨µ ´ž£©ªªž¨¥¯¦¤° ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ­ž ©

ͱ ²¥œª ª¦¢µ ­ ¦¤¢ ¥¨ ¨ ¥œ°¥£ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ª ¥£ ›³¡

§¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯ ¦¤¢£ž£ªœ©¨£¢ ¥£ £¤£ž°µ ¢£§ ªœœ ¤

Ÿ ©§¨ž£¢   ¥£ Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª±

¤ ¥£ §ž£ª£¤ ¬ ž ¬£ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£¥£›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ¨ ¥œ°¥£ž

¯¨œ¦¢£ª ´µ ¥£ ¦ª£  ­ ¥œª §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯¶¬œ¥ ´ ¥

§¥  £¯£Ÿž ¤ ¨¤¢ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ œ¤§¦± ²¥£ ¨¦«

ž ž¨¯ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ¨¤¢ Ÿ¥¨ž¨Ÿ£žœªœŸ £¤£ž°µ ¨ž£ ¢£žœ®£¢ ¤ 

 ¤¯µ ­ž © Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ¨ª œ¤ ¹

¿¾ ¾¿ À

»Á¸ÅÉÉË̶ ´¦

­ž © ¨¤¢ Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª¶   £ªœ©¨£ ¥£ £¯£Ÿ«

ž ¤ £¤£ž°œ£ª ­ž ©  £   ÂÉÉ £± ¨¤¢ Í ¥¨¢

¨ °¯ ´¨¯ ®œ£¬  ­ ¥£ ¤ ž¥£ž¤ ¨¦ž ž¨¯  ®¨¯ ­ ž ÂÉ Ÿ ¤ª£Ÿ«

¦œ®£ ¥ ¦žª  ­ £¨Ÿ¥ ÂÄ ¥ ¦ž  ž´œ± œ¤Ÿ£ ¥£ ›³ °¨ª ¥¨ª

¨ ¯œ­£œ©£  ­  ¢¨µ œ¤ ª¦¤¯œ°¥¶ ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¤£ž°µ œ¤§¦

­ ž ¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯ ¤££¢ª   ´£ Ÿ ¤œ¤¦ ¦ª ¥ž ¦°¥ ¦ ¨¤

£®£¤±  ž ¥£ œ©£ œ¤£ž®¨¯ª ¬œ¥ ¦ ¨¤¢ Í ©£¨«

ª¦ž£©£¤ª¶ ¬£ ¦ª£ ¨ §¨ž¨©£žœ·¨œ ¤  ­ ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ

¦¡ ´¨ª£¢  ¤ °ž ¦¤¢ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª±

²¥£ Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª ´£¬££¤ ¥£ ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ ¢£¤ªœµ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦«

¯¨£¢ ´µ ¥£ §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯ œ¤Ÿ¯¦¢œ¤° ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¤£ž°µ

œ¤§¦¶ ¨¤¢ ¥£ ¢£¤ªœµ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ´µ ›³¶ ª¥ ¬ ¥¨ ¥£

© ¢£¯ °£¤£ž¨¯¯µ  ®£ž£ªœ©¨£ª ¥£ ¨© ¦¤  ­ ›³ ¨ ¥œ°¥£ž

¯¨œ¦¢£ª± ²¥£ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ §ž ¯£ª œ¤¢œŸ¨£ ¥¨

¥£ ž£ª§ ¤ª£  ­ ¥£ ¯ ¬£ž ¥£ž© ª§¥£žœŸ ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£   ¥£

£¤£ž°£œŸ £¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤¶ ¬¨ª ª¦§§ž£ªª£¢ ¥£ ¢¨µ  ­

¥£ ª ž©  ¤ª£± ²¥£ ª ¦žŸ£ ­ ž ¥œª ¢¨©§œ¤°¶ œª ¤  œ¤«

Ÿ¯¦¢£¢ œ¤ ¥£ © ¢£¯ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨œ ¤ª±  ž ¥£ ¢¨µ ¨­£ž ¥£

ª ž©  ¤ª£¶ ¬¥£¤ ¥£ ´¨Ÿ°ž ¦¤¢ ¨© ª§¥£ž£ ¬¨ª © ž£

ª¨´¯£ ¨°¨œ¤¶ ¥£ © ¢£¯£¢ ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ ¢£¤ªœµ œª œ¤ ´££ž

¨°ž££©£¤ ¬œ¥ ¥£  ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª±

‘ ’“”•˜ “” “— ” –—

!"#" $% &' % & ()*+,-./0(1*

²¥£ ¦¢£¤ ›œžœŸ ³¡œ¢£¡§¯ ž£ž ›³ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ¥£

›³ Ÿ ¯¦©¤ ¢£¤ªœµ œ¤ ¥£ ¯ ¬£ž ¥£ž© ª§¥£ž£± ²¥£ ª¨£¯«

¯œ£ ¥¨¢ ¨ ª¦¤«ªµ¤Ÿ¥ž ¤ ¦ª  ž´œ ¨ ÊÊË © ¨¯œ¦¢£¶ ¬œ¥

¥£ ¨ªŸ£¤¢œ¤° ¤ ¢£ ¨ ÂÉ2É 3²± ²¥£ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ £Ÿ¥«

¤œ¦£ ¬¨ª ¯œ©´ ª§£Ÿž¨¯  ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª  ­ ¥£ ¦ ž£ªŸ£¤Ÿ£  ­

›³ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯£ª ´µ ª ¯¨ž ž¨¢œ¨œ ¤± £¤Ÿ£¶ ¥£ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª

¬£ž£ ¢ ¤£  ¤ ¥£ ¢¨µªœ¢£  ­ ¥£ ›³  ž´œ  ¤¯µ± ²¥£

Ÿ ¯¦©¤ £©œªªœ ¤ ž¨£ ­ž © ¥£ ›³ ɶ °¨©©¨ ´¨¤¢ ¨

Å ¤©¶ œª ž£¯¨£¢   ¥£ ›³ Ÿ ¯¦©¤ ¢£¤ªœµ ´µ ¥£ §¥ «

 ¤ ªŸ¨£žœ¤° Ÿ £4Ÿœ£¤¶ Ÿ¨¯¯£¢ ¥£ °«­¨Ÿ ž ¸

À¿ ¾¿ À

»Á¶

ÅÉÉ̱ ²¥£ °«­¨Ÿ ž œª ¥£ § ªªœ´œ¯œœ£ª ­ ž ¨´ª ž§œ ¤  ­ ª¦¤«

¯œ°¥ ¨ ¨ ¬¨®£¯£¤°¥ ´µ ¨¤ ¨© ª§¥£žœŸ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯£¶ ¨¤¢ ¥£

ª¦´ª£¦£¤ ¦ ž£ªŸ£¤ £©œªªœ ¤±

¤ ¥œª ª¦¢µ ¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ¥¨ª ´££¤ ¨žž¨¤°£¢ œ¤ Ê ¯¨«

œ¦¢£ ¨¤¢ Å

¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ´ ¡£ª± ²¥£ ª§¨œ¨¯ ž£ª ¯¦œ ¤  ­ ¥£

›³ ›³ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ¬£ž£ Ê ¯¨œ¦¢£¶ ± © ¨¯œ¦¢£¶

¨¤¢ © œ¤ ¥£ · ¤¨¯ ¢œž£Ÿœ ¤±

!"!" % &5 6(7+8

²¥£ © ¢£¯ ­ ž ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ Ÿ¥£©œªžµ ¦ª£¢ œ¤ ¥œª ª¦¢µ

œª ¨ ¤£¬ ®£žªœ ¤  ­ ¨ §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯ ¸»

¾À

¶ ÂÃÄËÆ

¹½È

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÄô¶ ¨¶ ÂÃÃɶ ÂÃÃÊÆ

À¿

¶ ÂÃÃÅ̶ ¬œ¥ ¦§«

¢¨£¢ ž£¨Ÿœ ¤ ž¨£ Ÿ £4Ÿœ£¤ª ¨¤¢ £¡Ÿœ¨œ ¤ ž¨œ ª ­ž ©

À¿ ¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÂÃÃÃÌÆ

À

»

¾ ¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÅÉÉÅ̱  ž £¡¨©§¯£¶ ¥£

µœ£¯¢  ­ › ê9

­ž © ¢œªª Ÿœ¨œ ¤  ­ ›

ê

´µ £¤£ž°£œŸ £¯£Ÿ«

ž ¤ª¶ œª ž£¢¦Ÿ£¢   É±Ê ¸:;<

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÄÉ̱ ²¥£ © ¢£¯ œª

œ©£«¢£§£¤¢£¤ ¨¤¢  ¤£«¢œ©£¤ªœ ¤¨¯±  œ¤Ÿ¯¦¢£ª ®£žœŸ¨¯

ž¨¤ª§ ž  ­ › ö

¨¤¢ ›³ ´µ £¢¢µ ¨¤¢ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯¨ž ¢œ¦«

ªœ ¤± ²¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ ž¨¤ª§ ž œª Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£¢ ¦ªœ¤° ¥£ =>?@

© ¢£¯  ­ ¹º»º¼º½

¾¿ À

»Á¸ÂÃÄÄÌÆ ¹º»º¼º½

À

½È AB

¾

¸ÂÃÄÃ̶

¬¥œŸ¥ œ¤Ÿ¯¦¢£ª ¥£ £¤£ž°£œŸ £¯£Ÿž ¤ ž¨¤ª§ ž ¸

À

½

À

½È

C

ÀD

¶ ÂÃÉÌ ­ ž ´ ¥ §¥  £¯£Ÿž ¤ª ¨¤¢ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ª±

²¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯ ¦ª£ª §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ £¦œ¯œ´žœ¦©   Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦«

¯¨£ ¥£ ®£žœŸ¨¯ §ž ¯£ª  ­ ›³¶ › ö

¶ › ê9

¶ ›³E¶ ³E

ê

› E

ê

¶ ³ E

¨¤¢ ³ E

ê9

±²¥£ £¡ž£©£ ¦¯ž¨®œ ¯£ ª ¯¨ž ¦¡ ÅÉ«

ÂÉ ¤© œª Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£¢ ­ž © ¥£ © ¢£¯  ­ F½

¿¾¾DD¾ ¾¿ À

»Á

¸ÂÃÄÂ̶¬œ¥ ¥£ Âɱ ¤© ª ¯¨ž ž¨¢œ  ¦¡ ¨ª œ¤§¦ §¨ž¨©££ž±

²¥£ ª ¯¨ž ª ­ «ž¨µ œžž¨¢œ¨¤Ÿ£ ¦ª£¢ œ¤ ¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯ ¬¨ª

©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ´µ ›³ ¸

À

»

¾ ¾¿ À

»Á¶ÅÉÉÉ̱ ²¥£ §¥  £¯£Ÿž ¤

¦¡£ª ¦ª£¢ œ¤ ¥£ © ¢£¯ ¨ž£ ­ ¦¤¢   Ÿ žž£ª§ ¤¢ ¬£¯¯ ¬œ¥

©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ¦¡£ª ¸¹º»º¼º½

¾¿ À

»Á¶ÅÉÉÂ̱  ¢£¯£¢ ¤œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£

¢£¤ªœœ£ª ¨ ¯ ¬£ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ª §ž ¢¦Ÿ£¢ ­ž © £¤£ž°£œŸ §¥  «

£¯£Ÿž ¤ª¶ ¨ž£­ ¦¤¢   ´£ œ¤ °  ¢ ¨°ž££©£¤ ¬œ¥ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢

¢£¤ªœœ£ª ¸

À¿ À

½È

À

»

¾

¶ ÅÉÉ̱ ²¥£ © ¢£¯ ­ ž ¥£ ´¨Ÿ«

°ž ¦¤¢ ¤£¦ž¨¯ ¨© ª§¥£ž£ œª ¥£ ›3 «ÉÉ © ¢£¯ ¸G

H º½

¾ ¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÅÉÉÅ̶ ¬¥£ž£ ¢¨œ¯µ ®¨¯¦£ª  ­ ¥£ Âɱ ¤© ª ¯¨ž

¦¡ ¨¤¢ ¥£ ¥ ¦ž § °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ œ¤¢£¡ ¨ž£ ¦ª£¢ ¨ª œ¤«

§¦ª± ²¥£ © ¢£¯ª ¨ž£ ´¨ª£¢  ¤ ¨ ¥µ¢ž ª¨œŸ © ¢£¯

 ­

À¿¾

¸ÂÃÊÃ̱

²¥£ ›

ê

œ ¤œ·¨œ ¤ ž¨£ ž£ª§ ¤¢ª ¢œž£Ÿ¯µ   ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤

£¤£ž°µ œ¤§¦± ²¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£ œª ¨¤ ¨ŸŸ¦©¦¯¨£¢

ž£ª§ ¤ª£  ­ ¥£ œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£¢ œ ¤œ·¨œ ¤ ¨¤¢ ¢œªª Ÿœ¨œ ¤± ²¥£

¨© ¦¤  ­ ›³ ¨¯ª  ®¨žœ£ª ¥ž ¦°¥ ¦ ¥£ ¢¨µ ¨ª ¨ ­¦¤Ÿœ ¤

 ­ œ¤ª ¯¨œ ¤±  ¬£®£ž¶ ¥œª ££Ÿ œª ©œ¤œ©¨¯ Ÿ ©§¨ž£¢  

¥£ ž£ª§ ¤ª£  ­ ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¤£ž°µ œ¤§¦ ¨ ¥œ°¥£ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ª±

²¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯ œ¤Ÿ¯¦¢£ª Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ ¨¤¢ ¢œ¦ªœ ¤ ¯ ªª §ž «

Ÿ£ªª£ª  ­ ›³±  ©£  ­ ¥£ª£ §ž Ÿ£ªª£ª ž¨¤ª­ ž© ›³ œ¤ 

 ¥£ž  ¢¢ ¤œž °£¤ ª§£Ÿœ£ª± Í¥  ¢œªª Ÿœ¨œ ¤  ­ ›³ ¨¤¢¥£

­ ¯¯ ¬œ¤° › ö

ž£¨Ÿœ ¤ ¬œ¥ ¨¤ ¥£ž ›³ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯£¶ ¥¨®£

¥£ £¤¢ §ž ¢¦Ÿ ›

ê

¨¤¢ ³± ²¥£ ££Ÿœ®£ ¯œ­£œ©£  ­ ¥œª

§ž Ÿ£ªª œª ÂÃ±Ë ¥ ¦žª ¸I½ ½ ½È ¹½È¶ ÂÃÃ̱

(5)

!" " '8+/,(1 ,+00/./0(1 .17 ' . ,(,.8

()*+,-./0(1*

²¥£ ¯ž¨®œ ¯£ ©¨°£ž ¸º

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÃÊÌ ¨¤¢

¥£ Í ¯¨ž  ¤ ª§¥£žœŸ «ž¨µ ©¨°œ¤° ¡§£žœ©£¤ Í

¸¼

º<

¾¿ À

»Á¶ÂÃÃÊÌ  ¤ ´ ¨ž¢ ¥£ Í ¯¨ž ª§¨Ÿ£Ÿž¨­¶©£¨ª¦ž£¢

¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ ªœ°¤¨¦ž£ª  ­ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ª  ­ ¦¯ž¨®œ«

 ¯£ £©œªªœ ¤ª ¨¤¢ «ž¨µ ´ž£©ªªž¨¥¯¦¤°± ²¥£ª£ ©£¨ª¦ž£«

©£¤ª §ž ®œ¢£ ¨ °¯ ´¨¯ ©¨§  ­ ¥£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ª±

Í ¬¨ª ¨ §œ¤¥ ¯£ Ÿ¨©£ž¨  ´ª£ž®œ¤° ¥£ «ž¨µ

´ž£©ªªž¨¥¯¦¤° œ¤ ¥£ £¤£ž°µ ž¨¤°£ «ÅÅ £± ²¥£ ª§¨«

œ¨¯ž£ª ¯¦œ ¤ ¬¨ª ÉÉ © ¨´ ®£ ¥£ ¤ ž¥£ž¤ ¥£©œª§¥£ž£¶

¬¥£ž£ Í ¯¨ž ¥¨¢ œª ¨§ °££ œ¤ ÂÃÃı ²¥£ ¢¨¨ §ž Ÿ£ªªœ¤°

 ­ ¥£ Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª œª ¢£ªŸžœ´£¢ œ¤

¿DÀÀ È

¾¿ À

»Á

¸ÂÃÃÃ̶ ¨¤¢ ¥£ ©£¥ ¢ ­ ž ¢£žœ®œ¤° ¨ ­ ¦ž §¨ž¨©££ž £¯£Ÿ«

ž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿž¦© ­ž © ¥£ Í ¢¨¨ œª ¢£ªŸžœ´£¢ œ¤

¿DÀÀ È

¾¿ À

»Á¸ÅÉÉɶ ÅÉÉÂ̱

 ´ª£ž®£ª ¦¯ž¨®œ ¯£ £©œªªœ ¤ª œ¤ ¥£ 3µ©¨¤«œž°£«

 §£¯¢ 3 ´¨¤¢± ²¥£ª£ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ¨ž£ ª£§¨ž¨£¢

œ¤ ¥£ 3«ª¥ ž ¨¤¢ 3«¯ ¤° ´¨¤¢ª± 3«¯ ¤° £©œª«

ªœ ¤ª ¨ž£ §ž § žœ ¤¨¯   ¥£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ

¦¡± ²¥£ ¢œ£ž£¤Ÿ£ œ¤ ¨´ª ž§œ ¤ ´µ © ¯£Ÿ¦¯¨ž  ¡µ°£¤  ­

¥£ ¬  3 ´¨¤¢ª §ž ®œ¢£ª œ¤­ ž©¨œ ¤  ¤ ¥£ ¨®£ž¨°£ £¤«

£ž°µ  ­ ¥£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ª± 9

¦£   ¥£ ¬ ´´¯œ¤°

 ­ ¥£ § œ¤¨´¯£ §£¢£ª¨¯  ¤ ¥£ Í ¯¨ž ª¨£¯¯œ£¶ ¥£ ª§¨«

œ¨¯ ž£ª ¯¦œ ¤  ­ ­ž © ¨§ °££ œª ¢£°ž¨¢£¢ ­ž © ¥£

¤ ©œ¤¨¯ ®¨¯¦£  ­ Ê ©   ¨§§ž ¡œ©¨£¯µ £¤ œ©£ª ¥¨

®¨¯¦£ œ¤ ¥£ ¢œž£Ÿœ ¤  ­ ¥£ ¬ ´´¯£± ²¥£ ª§¨œ¨¯ ž£ª ¯¦œ ¤

§£ž§£¤¢œŸ¦¯¨ž   ¥£ ¬ ´´¯£ ¢œž£Ÿœ ¤ œª ¦¤¨£Ÿ£¢± ²¥£

©£¥ ¢ ­ ž ¢£žœ®œ¤° ¨ ¬  §¨ž¨©££ž £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿ«

ž¦© ­ž © ¥£ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª œª ¢£ªŸžœ´£¢ œ¤

¾

¼

À

½

¾¿ À

»Á ¸ÂÃö ÂÃÃĨ¶ ´Ì±

²¥£ ©£¥ ¢  ­ ¢£žœ®œ¤° ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿž¦©

­ž © ¥£ª£ ¬  ¢œ£ž£¤  ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ £Ÿ¥¤œ¦£ª œª ¢£ªŸžœ´£¢

œ¤

¿DÀÀ È

¾¿ À

»Á¸ÅÉÉÂ̶¬¥£ž£ ¥£ ž£ª¦¯ ¨¯ª  ¥¨ª ´££¤ Ÿ ©«

§¨ž£¢ ¬œ¥ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿž¨ ­ž © 9

Í ¯ ¬«¨¯œ¦¢£

ª¨£¯¯œ£ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª± ²¥£ Ÿ ©´œ¤£¢ ¨¤¢ Í ©£¨«

ª¦ž£©£¤ª §ž ®œ¢£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿž¨ ­ ž ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤

£¤£ž°µ ž¨¤°£ «ÂÉÉ £ ±¯£Ÿž ¤ª ¬œ¥ ©£¨¤ £¤£ž°µ ¨ž ¦¤¢

Ê £¶ ¢£§ ªœ © ª  ­ ¥£œž £¤£ž°µ œ¤ ¥£ ¨¯œ¦¢£ ž£°œ ¤

œ©§ ž¨¤ ­ ž ›³ §ž ¢¦Ÿœ ¤ ´£¬££¤ ÂÉÉ ¨¤¢ ÂÂÉ © ¨¯«

œ¦¢£±

 ž ¥œª ¬ ž ¬£ ¦ª£¢ ¥££¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿž¨ ¨ª œ¤§¦

œ¤ ¥£§¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯›³¡ © ¢£¯± ²¥£ª§£Ÿž¨ ­ ž ÂÉ ©œ¤¦£

œ¤£ž®¨¯ª ¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ¨¤¢ Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª¶ ¬£ž£

¬  §¨ž¨©££ž ¨¡¬£¯¯ ª§£Ÿž¨± ²¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡

¨¤¢ ©£¨¤ £¤£ž°µ ¬£ž£ ¥£¤ ¨®£ž¨°£¢ ­ ž £®£žµ  ¤£ ¥ ¦ž œ¤«

£ž®¨¯ª± ²¥¦ª ¥£ ¥ ¦ž¯µ £¤£ž°µ §¨ž¨©££žª §¦ œ¤  ¥£

›³¡ © ¢£¯ ¬£ž£ ¨®£ž¨°£¢ ¨¡¬£¯¯œ¨¤ ª   Ë Ÿ ©´œ¤£¢

¨¤¢ Í ÂÉ ©œ¤¦£ ž£ª ¯¦œ ¤ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª± ²¥£ž£

¬£ž£ œ¤£ž®¨¯ª  ­ ¦§   ÂÉ ¥ ¦žª  ­ Ÿ ¤œ¤¦ ¦ª ©£¨ª¦ž£«

©£¤ª ­ž © ¨¤¢ Í ­ ž ¥£ £®£¤ ª¦¢œ£¢ ¥£ž£±

!"" '8+/,(1 ,+00/./0(1 .17 +(6.1+/0

+,/ ,)./0(1*

£Ÿ¨¦ª£  ­ ¥£ ¯¨Ÿ  ­ Ÿ ¤œ¤¦ ¦ª ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª  ­ ¥£

£¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤¶ ¬£ ¨œ©£¢ ­ ž ¦ªœ¤° °ž ¦¤¢ ©¨°¤£«

 ©££ž  ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª  ­ ¥£ °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤ª ¨ª

¨ §ž ¡µ ­ ž ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ œ¤§¦± ²¥£ ©¨œ¤

§¦ž§ ª£ ¬¨ª    ´¨œ¤ ¨ ©¨§  ­ ¥£ £¤£ž°µ œ¤§¦ ­ž © £¯£Ÿ«

ž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤¶ §£žªœª£¤  ®£ž ª£®£ž¨¯ ¢¨µª¶­ ž œ¤§¦ œ¤

¥£ ›³¡ §¥  Ÿ¥£©œŸ¨¯ © ¢£¯± ²¥£ ¤£¦ž¨¯ §¨žœŸ¯£ª ¨ž£

¤  ° ®£ž¤£¢ ´µ ¥£ ©¨°¤£œŸ ¨¤¢ £¯£ŸžœŸ £¯¢ª± ²¥£µ Ÿ «

ž ¨£ ¬œ¥ ¥£ ¨ž¥± £¤Ÿ£¶ ¥£ Ÿ  ž¢œ¤¨£ ªµª£© ¦ª£¢

œ¤ ¥œª Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ ¬¨ª °£ °ž¨§¥œŸ¨¯±

²¥£ °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ ¢œª¦ž´¨¤Ÿ£ª œ¤ ¥£ ¤ ž¥ ©¨°«

œ ¤ ª§¥£žœŸ Ÿ¦žž£¤ª ¤ ¬¤ ¨ª ¥£ £¯£Ÿž £ª± ²¥£ ¬£ª«

¬¨ž¢ £¯£Ÿž £¶ °œ®œ¤° ¨ ¤£°¨œ®£ ¢££Ÿœ ¤ œ¤ ›¶ œª ž£«

¯¨£¢   ¥£ ¨¯¯ Ÿ ¤¢¦Ÿ¨¤Ÿ£¶ ¬¥œŸ¥ ¨°¨œ¤ œª Ÿ ¤¤£Ÿ£¢  

¥£ £¤£ž°£œŸ £¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤ ¸£±°±

À ¼º

À

½½

À

½È

À

¼È

¾

¶ ÂÃÄÆ A

½

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÃÃÆ

¾

ȼ

¾

À

½È Fº¼

À

½½¶

ÅÉÉÂÆ

¿DÀÀ È

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÅÉÉÅ̱ ²¥£ £¨ª¬¨ž¢ £¯£Ÿž £ œª

¥ ¦°¥   ´£ © ž£ ªž ¤°¯µ ° ®£ž¤£¢ ´µ ¥£ £¯£ŸžœŸ £¯¢

¸

À ¼º

À

½½

À

½È

À

¼È

¾

¶ ÂÃÄÆ A

½

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÂÃÃÃÆ

¾

ȼ

¾

À

½È Fº¼

À

½½¶ ÅÉÉÂ̱ ²¥¦ª ­ ž ¥œª ¬ ž ¬£ Ÿ žž£¯¨£ ¥£

©¨¡œ©¦© ¤£°¨œ®£§£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤  ­ ¥£ ¯ Ÿ¨¯ ¤ ž¥ ©¨°¤£œŸ

Ÿ ©§ ¤£¤¶ ›É¶ ­ž © ¥£ °ž ¦¤¢ ´¨ª£¢ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª¶

¬œ¥ ¥£ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ ¦¡ ¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ¨¤¢

Í  ´ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª± ͞£®œ ¦ª ª¦¢œ£ª  ­ °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ œ¤«

¢œŸ£ª ¨¤¢ ¥£œž Ÿ ¤¤£Ÿœ ¤ª   £¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤¶ ¥¨®£

©¨œ¤¯µ ´££¤ ­ Ÿ¦ª£¢  ¤ ¥£ °¯ ´¨¯ œ¤¢œŸ£ª ¸£±°±

¾

ȼ

¾

À

½È Fº¼

À

½½¶ ÅÉÉÂÆ

¿DÀÀ È

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÅÉÉÅ̱ £ž£ ¬£ ¨§§¯µ

°ž ¦¤¢ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ¢¨¨ ­ž © ¥£ ¦§£ž ¢¨¨´¨ª£¶

¬¥œŸ¥ Ÿ ¤ªœªª  ­ © ž£ ¥¨¤ ÂÉÉ ª¨œ ¤ª ¯ Ÿ¨£¢ ¨ ¥œ°¥£ž

¤ ž¥£ž¤ ¯¨œ¦¢£ª± ²¥£ Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª ´£¬££¤ › ¨¤¢ §ž£«

Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ ¦¡¶¬£ž£ ©¨¢£ ¬œ¥œ¤ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ žª

 ­ ű

¬  §¨ž¨©££ž ¨¡¬£¯¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ª§£Ÿž¦© œª

¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ¨¤¢ Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ­ ž Ÿ ¤ª£Ÿ¦œ®£

ÂÉ ©œ¤¦£ œ¤£ž®¨¯ª± ²¥£¤ ¥£ ¥ ¦ž¯µ ©£¨¤  ­ ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤

£¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ¨®£ž¨°£¢  ®£ž ¨ ÅÉ ¯¨œ¦¢£ ´¨¤¢ Êɫɛ

¨ž ¦¤¢ ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯  ®¨¯¶ œª Ÿ ©§¨ž£¢   ¥£ ¥ ¦ž¯µ ©£¨¤

 ­ ¥£ ›É ®¨¯¦£ª ­ ž ¥£ Ÿ ¤Ÿ¦žž£¤ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢œ¤¨¯ ª£Ÿ ž±

ª ©£¤œ ¤£¢ ¨´ ®£¶¥£ › °ž ¦¤¢ §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤ª ¨ž£ Ÿ ¤«

¤£Ÿ£¢   ¥£ ¨¯¯Ÿ ¤¢¦Ÿœ®œµ¶¬¥œŸ¥ ¨°¨œ¤ œªž£¯¨£¢   ¥£

£¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤± ²¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°œ£ª Ÿ ¤žœ´¦œ¤°  

¥£ ¨¯¯Ÿ ¤¢¦Ÿ¨¤Ÿ£¨ž£ ¨´ ®£ £±²¥££¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ

͞£Ÿœ§œ¨œ¤° £¯£Ÿž ¤ «ÂÉÉ £ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡

¨®£ž¨°£¢  ®£ž ¨ ÅÉ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ ¯¨œ¦¢£ ´¨¤¢¶ §¯ £¢ ¨°¨œ¤ª

¥£ ©¨¡œ©¦© ¤£°¨œ®£ §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤  ­ ¥£ °ž ¦¤¢ °£ ©¨°«

¤£œŸ ¤ ž¥ Ÿ ©§ ¤£¤¶ ›É± ²¥£ ®¨¯¦£ª ¨ž£ ¥ ¦ž¯µ

©£¨¤ª¶ ¬œ¥œ¤ Å °£ °ž¨§¥œŸ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ žª¶ ­ ž ¢¨µª

ÂÅɶ ÂÅŶ ÂŶ ¨¤¢   ­ ÂÃÃı ²¥£ž£ ¨ž£ ÊÄà § œ¤ª œ¤

 ¨¯¶ © ª  ­ ¥£© ¨ ¯ ¬ ®¨¯¦£ª± ²¥£ Ÿ žž£¯¨œ ¤ Ÿ £4«

Ÿœ£¤ œª ɱʱ ²¥£ ¯œ¤£¨ž  ¥¨ª ¨ ª¯ §£  ­ ɱÉÂÉË ¸©! © "

ê

¤²"

Î

̱

(6)

 ¦ž¯µ ©£¨¤  ­ ¥£ ¤£°¨œ®£ °ž ¦¤¢ ¤ ž¥ °£ «

©¨°¤£œŸ §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤¶›É ´¯¨Ÿ¶¦¤œª ­ ¤²±¯£Ÿž ¤

£¤£ž°µ ¦¡ «ÂÉÉ £ ¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ¨¤¢ Í  ´«

ª£ž®¨œ ¤ª¶ ¥ ¦ž¯µ ©£¨¤ ¨®£ž¨°£¢  ®£ž ÅÉ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ ¯¨œ¦¢£

´¨¤¢ °ž¨µ¶ ¦¤œª  ­ ©! © "

ê

±  ¥ ¢¨¨ ª£ª ¨ž£ ¬œ¥œ¤

°£ °ž¨§¥œŸ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ ž ÅÂË«Åɶ ¢¨µ ÂÅÅ  ­ ÂÃÃĶ

¨¤¢ ¨ž£ §¯ £¢ ¨ª ­¦¤Ÿœ ¤ª  ­ ¦¤œ®£žª¨¯ œ©£± ²¥£ ¤¦©«

´£ž  ­ ª¨œ ¤ª ¦ª£¢   °£ ¥£ ›É ®¨¯¦£ª ¬œ¥œ¤ ¥œª Å

¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ ž œª œ¤¢œŸ¨£¢ œ¤ ¥£ ¦§§£ž ¯£­ Ÿ ž¤£ž±

¦¡ ¦ª£¢ œ¤ ¥£ª£ Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª œª ¦ª ­ ž ¥£ £¤£ž°µ ž¨¤°£

«ÂÉÉ £ ¶¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°œ£ª ¨ªª¦©£¢   °œ®£ Ÿ¥¨¤°£ª œ¤

¥£ ›É °ž ¦¤¢ °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ £¯¢±

²¥£ °¯ ´¨¯ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ¤£¬ ž¶ ¦§£ž ¶œª ¨ ¢¨¨

ª£ §ž ®œ¢£¢ ´µ © ž£ ¥¨¤ ÅÉÉ °ž ¦¤¢ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ª¨«

œ ¤ª ¸

¾

ȼ

¾

¾¿ À

»Á¶ÅÉÉ̱ ²¥œª ¤£¬ ž °œ®£ª °  ¢ °¯ ´¨¯

Ÿ ®£ž¨°£ ¨¤¢ Ÿ ¤œ¤¦ ¦ª ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª  ­ ¥£ °ž ¦¤¢ °£«

 ©¨°¤£œŸ §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤ª± ²¥£ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ¢¨¨ ¥¨ª ¨

Ÿ ©© ¤ ´¨ª£¯œ¤£ ž£© ®¨¯ £Ÿ¥¤œ¦£¶ ¥£ ª¨©£ œ©£ ž£ª ¯¦«

œ ¤ ¨¤¢ ¥£ ª¨©£ Ÿ  ž¢œ¤¨£ ªµª£© ± ¤ ¥£ §ž£ª£¤ ª¦¢µ¶

 ¤¯µ ¥£ ª¨œ ¤ª ­ ž ¥£ ¤ ž¥£ž¤ ¥£©œª§¥£ž£ ¨ž£ ¦ª£¢¶ œ¤

¨¯¯ © ž£ ¥¨¤ ÂÉÉ ª¨œ ¤ª±  ¬£®£ž¶ ¥£ž£ ¨ž£ ¨ž£¨ª ¯œ£

œ´£žœ¨ ¬¥£ž£ ¥£ž£ ©œ°¥  ¤¯µ ´£  ¤£  ž ¬  ª¨œ ¤ª ¨®¨œ¯«

¨´¯£ ¬œ¥œ¤ ¨ Å ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ ž± ²¥£ › §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤ª

œ¤ ¥£ª£ ª£Ÿ žª ¬£ž£ ­ ž ¥£ ­ ¦ž £®£¤ª œ¤®£ªœ°¨£¢ ¥£ž£¶

© ž£  ­£¤ ª¥ ¬œ¤° ¥œ°¥ ®¨¯¦£ª ¬¥£¤ ¥œ°¥ ¨¦ž ž¨¯ ¨Ÿœ®œµ

¥¨¤ ¤  ¢££Ÿœ ¤± ²¥¦ª ¬£ Ÿ¥ ª£   œ¤Ÿ¯¦¢£ ¨¯¯ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£

ª£Ÿ žª œ¤  ¦ž Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª± ²¥£ ª¨œ ¤ª ¨ž£ ©¨œ¤¯µ Ÿ ¤®£«

¤œ£¤¯µ ¯ Ÿ¨£¢ œ¤ Ÿ¯ ª£ §ž ¡œ©œµ   ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯  ®¨¯± ¤ ¥£

ª£Ÿ žª ¬¥£ž£ ¥£ ¤¦©´£ž  ­ ª¨œ ¤ª ¨ž£ ­£¬¶ ¥£ ª¨œ ¤ª

¨¯ª  ¥¨®£ ž£¯¨œ®£¯µ °  ¢ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢œ¤¨¯ Ÿ ®£ž¨°£±

²¥£ Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª ­ ž ¨¯¯ ¥£ ­ ¦ž ¢¨µª¶ ­ ž ¨¯¯ ª£Ÿ žª¶ ¨¤¢

¨¯¯ ¥ ¦žª  ­ ¨¤¢ Í ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª¶ ¨ž£ °¨¥£ž£¢ œ¤

 ¤£ ªŸ¨£ž §¯ ¶°¦ž£ ± ²¥£ Ÿ žž£¯¨œ ¤  ­ ¥£ ¢¨¨ ª£ª œª

ɱʱ !£ ¨ªª¦©£¥£ž£œª  ®£ž¨¯¯¤  £ªª£¤œ¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§«

œ¨œ ¤ ¬¥£¤ ›É± ²¥£ Ÿ¯¦ª£ž  ­ ¯ ¬«®¨¯¦£ § œ¤ª œª ¤ 

ª  ¥¨ ¨ ¯œ¤£¨ž  ¬ ¦¯¢ Ÿž ªª ¥£ µ«¨¡œª ´£¯ ¬ ·£ž ± £¤Ÿ£¶

¬£ ¥¨®£ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£¢ ¨ ¯œ¤£¨ž   ­ ¥£ Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª ¥ž ¦°¥

 žœ°œ¤¶ ¦ªœ¤° ¥£ ¯£¨ª ª¦¨ž£ ©£¥ ¢±

²¥£ Ÿ ©§¨žœª ¤ª ¬£ž£ ¢ ¤£ ­ ž ¨¯¯ ¥ ¦žª ¬¥£ž£ ¨¤¢

Í ¬£ž£ ©£¨ª¦žœ¤°¶¨¯ª  ­ ž œ©£ª ¨¤¢ ¨ž£¨ª ¬œ¥ ¯ ¬ ¨Ÿ«

œ®œµ± ž£¨ª  ¦ªœ¢£¥£ ¨¤¢ ͪ£¯¢  ­®œ£¬ª ¬£ž£

 ­ Ÿ ¦žª£ ¤  œ¤Ÿ¯¦¢£¢± ²  ¦¤¢£žª¨¤¢ © ž£  ­ ¥£ ¢£¨œ¯ª

´£¥œ¤¢ ¥£ ª§ž£¨¢œ¤°  ­ ¥£ ¢¨¨ § œ¤ª œ¤ °¦ž£ ¶ ¬£ ¥¨®£

§¯ £¢ ¥£ ¥ ¦ž¯µ ©£¨¤ª  ­ ¥£§£žœ ¢ª ¬œ¥ ›É ¨¤¢ ¥£

£¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ¨ª ­¦¤Ÿœ ¤ª  ­ ¦¤œ®£žª¨¯ œ©£± œ°¦ž£ Å

œª ¨¤ £¡¨©§¯£  ­ ¨ ¬£¯¯ Ÿ žž£¯¨£¢ ¥œ°¥ ¨Ÿœ®œµ £®£¤¶ ÅÂË«

Åɶ ¢¨µ ÂÅÅ  ­ ÂÃÃı ²¥£ ´¯¨Ÿ ¥œª °ž¨© œª ¥£ ¥ ¦ž¯µ

©£¨¤ ›É ­ ž ¥£ ž£°œ ¤¶ ¨¤¢ ¥£ °ž£µ ¥œª °ž¨© œª ¥£

¥ ¦ž¯µ ©£¨¤ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ͱ

²¥£ ©¨¡œ©¦© ¨Ÿœ®œµ ¬¨ª Å ¥ ¦žª ¨­£ž ©œ¢¤œ°¥ ­ ž ¥œª

ª£Ÿ ž± ³®£ž¨¯¯¶ ¥£ ¤œ°¥ ª£Ÿ ž ª¥ ¬ª ¨ ­¨œž¯µ °  ¢ Ÿ žž£«

£¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ œ©§¯œ£ª ¨ ¦œ£ ¯¨ž°£ž ¨Ÿœ®œµ ¥¨¤ ¥£

°ž ¦¤¢ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ¢¨¨± ¦Ÿ¥ ¨¤ £¡¨©§¯£ œª ª¥ ¬¤ œ¤

°¦ž£ ± ²¥£ž£ ¨ž£  °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ ª¨œ ¤ª ­ ž ¥œª ª£Ÿ ž¶

ª   ¤£ ¬ ¦¯¢ ¨ªª¦©£ ¥¨ ¥œª ¬¨ª ª¦4Ÿœ£¤ ­ ž ž£°œª£žœ¤°

¨¤µ œ ¤ ª§¥£žœŸ Ÿ¦žž£¤ ¨´ ®£ ¥£ ž£°œ ¤±   ­ ¥£ ª¨œ ¤ª

¨ž£¶ ¥ ¬£®£ž¶ §¨ž  ­ ¥£ ©¨°¤£ ©££ž ¨žž¨µ ¨ ¥£ ¬£ª

Ÿ ¨ª  ­ ž££¤¯¨¤¢± ­ ¥£ Ÿ¦žž£¤ª ž£¯¨£¢   ¥£ ¨¦ž ž¨¯

¨Ÿœ®œµ ¬£ž£ ¯ Ÿ¨£¢ ¦œ£ ª ¦¥  ­ ¥£ª£ ª¨œ ¤ª¶ ¨ ©¦Ÿ¥

­¨œ¤£ž ¢££Ÿœ ¤ ¬ ¦¯¢ ´£ ž£°œª£ž£¢± ªœ¦¨œ ¤ ¬¥£ž£

¥£ °£ ©¨°¤£œŸ ›É §£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤ª °¨®£ ž£¯¨œ®£¯µ ¯¨ž°£ž

®¨¯¦£ª ¥¨¤ ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ¢£žœ®£¢ ­ž © ¨¤¢

Ͷ œª ¢œª§¯¨µ£¢ œ¤ °¦ž£ ¶ ­ž © ¯ Ÿ¨¯ œ©£ Ÿ žž£«

ª§ ¤¢œ¤°   ÂÉ ² œ¤ ¥£ °¦ž£ ¨¤¢  ¤¬¨ž¢± ²¥£ £¯¢

 ­ ®œ£¬ª ­ ž ¨¤¢ Í ¬£ž£ ¦œ£ °  ¢ ­ ž ¥œª ¯ ¤«

°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ ž ¨¤¢ œ©£ œ¤£ž®¨¯± ²¥£ žª ®£ ¥ ¦žª  ­ ¥£

£®£¤¶ ¬¥£ž£ ¥£ ¨Ÿ¦¨¯ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ œ¤£ž®¨¯ ¬¨ª œ¤ ¥£ ¯ Ÿ¨¯

©œ¢¤œ°¥   £¨ž¯µ © ž¤œ¤° ª£Ÿ ž¶ ¥£ Ÿ žž£¯¨œ ¤ ¬¨ª £¡«

Ÿ£§œ ¤¨¯¯µ °  ¢± ³¤ ¥£ ¤œ°¥ªœ¢£ ¥£ œ ¤ ª§¥£žœŸ Ÿ¦žž£¤

ªµª£©ª ¨ž£ ´£¯œ£®£¢   ´£ Ÿ ¤ž ¯¯£¢ ´µ ¥£ ¨¯¯ Ÿ ¤¢¦Ÿ«

¨¤Ÿ£ ¸£±°±

À

¼È

¾ À

½È

H

¾

¶ ÂÃÄÆ ¹

D

½º

¾¿ À

»Á¶ ÅÉÉÅÆ

¾

ȼ

¾

À

½È Fº¼

À

½½¶ÅÉÉÂ̱ ¤ ¥£ © ž¤œ¤° ª£Ÿ ž¶ ¥ ¬«

£®£ž¶ ¥£ Ÿ¦žž£¤ª Ÿ¨¤ ´£ © ž£ œ¤¦£¤Ÿ£¢ ´µ ¥£ £¯£ŸžœŸ

£¯¢ ¸

À

¼È

¾ À

½È ºB½¶ ÂÃÃËÆ

¾

ȼ

¾

À

½È Fº¼

À

½½¶

ÅÉÉÂ̱ ²¥¦ª ¥£ ž£¯¨œ®£ ¯¨ž°£ž ¨©§¯œ¦¢£ª  ­ ¥£ ›É

§£ž¦ž´¨œ ¤ª œ¤ ¥£ ¯¨£ž §¨ž  ­ ¥£ © ž¤œ¤° ª£Ÿ ž¶ ¬£ž£

§ž ´¨´¯µ Ÿ¨¦ª£¢ ´µ ¨¤ œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£¢ Ÿ ¤®£Ÿœ ¤¨¯ £¯£ŸžœŸ £¯¢¶

¨¤¢ ¬£ž£ ¤  ¢œž£Ÿ¯µ ž£¯¨£¢   ¥£ £¯£Ÿž ¤ §ž£Ÿœ§œ¨œ ¤

¥ž ¦°¥ œ¤Ÿž£¨ª£¢ ¨¯¯ Ÿ ¤¢¦Ÿ¨¤Ÿ£±

¨©£ µ§£  ­ §¯  ¨ª °¦ž£ Ŷ ­ ž ÅÄÄ«ÂŶ

¢¨µ   ­ ÂÃÃı

¨©£ µ§£  ­ §¯  ¨ª °¦ž£ Ŷ ­ ž ÅË«ÅÄĶ

¢¨µ ÂÅÅ  ­ ÂÃÃı

(7)

›œžœŸ  ¡œ¢£ ¢£¤ªœµ ¸© ¯£Ÿ¦¯£ªŸ© ñ

Ì ¨ ÂÂÉ © ¨¯œ¦¢£ ¨ª ­¦¤Ÿœ ¤  ­ ¦¤œ®£žª¨¯ œ©£ ­ ž ¥£

¢¨µª ÂÅÉ   ÂÅ  ­ ÂÃÃı ²¥£ ´¯¨Ÿ Ÿ¦ž®£ œª ¥£ © ¢£¯£¢ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ¶ ¨¤¢ ¥£ °ž¨µ Ÿ¦ž®£ œª ¥£ ›³

¢£¤ªœµ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ´µ ›³± ²¥£ ¯œ°¥ °ž¨µ ¥œª °ž¨© ¢œª§¯¨µª ¥£  ¨¯ £¯£Ÿž ¤ £¤£ž°µ ¦¡ ¸©! ¥© ê

Ì

¥£ §ž£Ÿ£¢œ¤° ¤œ°¥ ¨¤¢ © ž¤œ¤° ÂË ¥ ¦žª ­ ž £¨Ÿ¥  ­ ¥£ ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ žª  ­ ¥£ ›³ ¢¨µªœ¢£ ©£¨«

ª¦ž£©£¤ª± ¨Ÿ¥  ­ ¥£ ¢¨µª¶ ›³  ž´œ ¤¦©´£ž  ´£¬££¤ ÂÅÉ ¨¤¢ ¶  ŸŸ¦žž£¢ ¨ ÉÉ2É ²±

²¥£ ª¨£¯¯œ£ §¨ªª£ª ¥£¤ © ®£¢ ¬£ª¬¨ž¢± ²¥£  ž´œ ¤¦©´£ž Ë ­ ž ¯ ¤°œ¦¢£ª Ë

«ËÉ

¶¬¨ª ¨ ÂÉ2É

²± ¤¢ ¤¨¯¯µ¶  ž´œ ¤¦©´£ž Âʶ «ÂËĶ  ŸŸ¦žž£¢ ¨ Å2ÉÉ ²± ²¥£ ª£§ª ´£¬££¤ £¨Ÿ¥  ž´œ

(8)

X` gokkm^\ƒZ~]YZ _`klm^\g`[gnZ]jZZ[ Y`o^ih k Zm[

`q dŠ lZ^]o^nm]\`[g q^`k t^`o[b k mt[Z]`kZ]Z^

bm]m~ m[b Z[Z^tZ]\_ ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa q^`k {| m[b

€} `ngZ^um]\`[g q`^ tZ`t^mlY\_mi i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^g~

tmuZ m _`^^Zim]\`[ `qŠrvr Z [b ]Y\g^Zgoi] g\t[\_m[]~

m[b _`[_iobZ ]Ym] t^`o[b dŠ lZ^]o^nm]\`[g k mh nZ

ogZb ]`tZ]YZ^ j\]Y {| m[b €} bm]m ]` l^`u\bZ tZp

`t^mlY\_mi k mlg `q ]YZ Z[Z^tZ]\_ ZiZ_]^`[ l^Z_\l\]m]\`[

jY\_Y m^Z _`[]\[o`og \[ ]\kZr XYZ „o_]om]\`[g m^`o[b

]YZ i\[Zm^ lm^mkZ]^\ƒm]\`[ m^Z nZi\ZuZb ]` nZ k `^Z `^

iZgg iZuZiiZb `o] jYZ[ k`bZi _mi_oim]\`[g m^Z b`[Z q`^

gZuZ^mi _`[gZ_o]\uZ Y`o^g c Y`o^g m[b k `^Zfr

‘ ˜ ” –—

XYZ dea k `bZi _mi_oim]Zb ]YZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]h

\[ xyw i`[t\]obZ ]\kZg vw im]\]obZ n`aZgr XYZ \[lo] lmp

^mkZ]Z^g jZ^Z ]YZ muZ^mtZ mo^`^mi ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa

m[b _Ym^m_]Z^\g]\_ Z[Z^th~q`^ ]YZ gmkZ tZ`t^mlY\_mi m^p

Zmg~\[ `[Z Y`o^\[]Z^umigr XYZ k `bZiZb de bZ[g\]h jmg

_`klm^Zb ]` ]Ym] kZmgo^Zb nh …derXYZ _`klm^\g`[g

jZ^Z b`[Z mg qo[_]\`[g `q o[\uZ^gmi ]\k Z~ im]\]obZ~ mi]\p

]obZ~ m[b g`im^i`_mi]\k Z q`^glZ_\_ i`[t\]obZ \[]Z^umig

q`^ Zm_Y …de `^n\]r

[ to^Z v ]YZ de bZ[g\]h q^`k ]YZ k`bZi cnim_Ž

_o^uZf m[b ]YZ de bZ[g\]h q^`k …de k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g

ct^mh _o^uZ j\]Y b`]gf~ m] ‹‹Š Žk mi]\]obZ~ m^Z li`]]Zb

mg qo[_]\`[g `q o[\uZ^gmi ]\kZ q^`k bmh ‹xŠ o[]\i bmh

‹xy `q ‹ŒŒr XYZ q`o^ im]\]obZ gZ_]`^g nZ]jZZ[ vŠwd

m[b Šwd m^Z b\glimhZbr XYZ ]\kZ ^Zg`io]\`[ q`^ ]Y\g

li`] \g ‹rv Y`o^g cb\g]m[_Z nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ b`]gf~ jY\_Y

\g ]YZ ]\k Z nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ …de `^n\]gr XYZ i`_m]\`[ \[

i`[t\]obZ um^\Zg j\]Y xy bZt^ZZg q`^ Zm_Y `q ]YZgZ ]\k Z

g]Zlgr XYog ]YZ li`] t\uZg ]YZ `uZ^mii um^\m]\`[g \[ [\p

]^\_ `a\bZ \[ ]YZ i`jZ^ ]YZ^k`glYZ^Z bo^\[t ]YZ _`o^gZ

`q ]YZ tZ`k mt[Z]\_ g]`^k r s

ig` gY`j[ \g]YZ ]`]mi mo^`p

^mi ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa q`^ ]YZ l^Z_Zb\[t ‹ Y`o^g cq^`k

‹ …X ]YZ l^Zu\`og bmh ]` ‹Š …Xf q`^ ]YZ lm^]\_oim^

^Zt\`[g _`k lm^Zb ct^mh Y\g]`t^mkfr XYZ Z[Z^th „oaZg

m^Z bZ^\uZb b\^Z_]ih q^`k {|ˆ€} k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g~

m[b q`^ ]YZ Y`o^g jYZ[ {|ˆ€} b\b [`] _`uZ^ ]YZ

[`^]YZ^[ mo^`^mi `umi~ q^`k ]YZ k mt[Z]\_ lZ^]o^nm]\`[

lm^mkZ]^\ƒm]\`[r m_Y _`iok[ `q ]YZ Z[Z^th „oa Y\gp

]`t^mk _`[g\g]g `q ]YZ gok `q mo^`^mi m_]\u\]h q`^ ]YZ

lm^]\_oim^ i`[t\]obZ ^Zt\`[ q`^ ]YZ ZuZ[\[t~ [\tY]~ m[b

k`^[\[t Y`o^g nZq`^Z ]YZ …de k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g q`^ ]YZ

^Zt\`[r

XYZ ^g] bmh `q _`k lm^\g`[g~ ‹xŠ~ ]YZ k `bZi Ymg [`]

Ymb ]\k Z ]` ^Zgl`[b ]` ]YZ Z[Z^th \[lo] m[b jZ q`_og`[

]YZ _`k lm^\g`[g q`^ ]YZ [Za] ]Y^ZZ bmhg~ ‹x‹~ ‹xx m[b

‹x‰ `q ‹ŒŒr e[ bmh ‹x‹ ]YZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ m_]\u\]h jmg

i`j r XYZ^Z jmg~ Y`jZuZ^~ g`k Z ZiZ_]^`[ l^Z_\l\]m]\`[

m] im]\]obZ nm[bg vŠpvv d m[b vvp Š d ]Ym] l^`bo_Zb

m gk mii \[_^ZmgZ \[ ]YZ `ngZ^uZb [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]hr

XYZ dea k`bZi _mi_oim]\`[ k m]_YZb ]Y\g \[_^ZmgZ uZ^h

[\_Zihr XYZ^Z jmg mbb\]\`[mi ZiZ_]^`[ l^Z_\l\]m]\`[ m]

im]\]obZ nm[bg Šp v d m[b vpŠ d ]Ym] _mogZb ]YZ

 ¯¨ž ¯ Ÿ¨¯ œ©£ ®¨žœ¨œ ¤ª  ­ ¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯

Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨œ ¤ª ¨ ÂÉË © ¨¯œ¦¢£ ­ ž ¥£ ¢¨µª ÂÅÉ   ÂÅ  ­

ÂÃÃĶ­ ¦ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ ª£Ÿ žª ¨ž ¦¤¢ ÅË £¨ª± ²¥£ ª ¯œ¢ ´¯¨Ÿ

¯œ¤£ œª ¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£¢ ­ž © ¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯± ²¥£

ª¦¨ž£ª ¨ž£ ¥£ ›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ´µ ›³ ­ ž ¥£ §¨ž«

œŸ¦¯¨ž ž£°œ ¤± ²¥£ ¢ £¢ ¯œ¤£ œª ¥£ ›³ §¥  ¢œªª Ÿœ¨œ ¤

ž¨£¶¨¤¢ ¥£ °ž¨µ ¥œª °ž¨© ¢œª§¯¨µª ¥£ ›

ê

¨¦ž ž¨¯ œ ¤œ·¨«

œ ¤ ž¨£± ²¥£ ªŸ¨¯£ª ­ ž ¥£ª£ ¬  §¨ž¨©££žª ¨ž£ Ÿ¥ ª£¤

¨ž´œž¨žœ¯µ±

dea k`bZi ]` l^Zb\_] m[ \[_^ZmgZ \[ [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]h

]Ym] jmg [`] ^Z„Z_]Zb \[ ]YZ de kZmgo^Zk Z[]g q^`k

…der

XYZ [Za] bmh~ ‹xx~ jYZ^Z ]YZ `[gZ] `q ]YZ tZ`kmtp

[Z]\_ g]`^k `__o^^Zb Šv‰Š {X~ ]YZ^Z jmg m ^m]YZ^

t``b _`^^Zgl`[bZ[_Z nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ ]j` bZ[g\]h l^`iZg

l^\`^ ]` ]YZ g]`^k r ‚^`k ‹x ]` ‹v {X q`^ ]YZ ]Y^ZZ

k `g] [`^]YZ^ih gZ_]`^g~]YZ^Z jmgm bZ_^ZmgZ \[ ]YZ k Zmp

go^Zb de bZ[g\]h~ jY\iZ ]YZ^Z jmg m l^`q`o[b m_]\u\]h

(9)

kZmgo^Zb nh {| m[b €} q`^ ]YZgZ ^Zt\`[gr s

q]Z^

‹v {X ]YZ kZmgo^Zb bZ[g\]h \[_^ZmgZb g]^`[tih \[ m_p

_`^bm[_Z j\]Y ]YZ mo^`^mi Z[Z^th \[lo] ]` ]YZ k`bZir

`jZuZ^~ ]YZ mkli\]obZ `q ]YZ k Zmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h

jmg gong]m[]\miih iZgg ]Ym[ ]YZ k`bZiZb bZ[g\]hr o^p

\[t ]YZ img] Y`o^g `q bmh ‹xx m[b ]YZ ^g] Y`o^g `q bmh

‹x‰~ ]YZ kZmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h jmg m_]omiih Z[Ym[_Zb

jY\iZ ]YZ k`bZiZb de bZ[g\]h bZ_^ZmgZbr XY\g mig` `_p

_o^^Zb ]YZ img] Y`o^g `q bmh ‹x‰r

e[ bmh ‹x‰]YZ^Z jZ^Z q`o^`^n\]g bo^\[t]YZ ^g] Ymiq

`q ]YZ bmh jYZ^Z ]YZ^Z jZ^Z [` …de kZmgo^Zk Z[]gr

o^\[t ]YZ gZ_`[b Ymiq `q ]YZ bmh~ ]YZ mt^ZZkZ[] nZp

]jZZ[ ]YZ k `bZi _mi_oim]\`[g m[b ]YZ `ngZ^um]\`[g \kp

l^`uZbr [ im]\]obZ nm[bg Šp v d m[b vpŠ d~ ]YZ^Z

jmg m bZ_^ZmgZ \[ k Zmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h _`k lm^Zb ]`

]YZ k`bZi ^Zgoi] nZ]jZZ[ ‹‰‰Š m[b ‹vŠŠ {X r o^p

\[t ]YZ q`ii`j\[t _`oliZ `q Y`o^g ]YZ kZmgo^Zb bZ[g\]h

\[_^ZmgZb gY`j\[t m t``b mt^ZZk Z[] j\]Y ]YZ `ngZ^ump

]\`[gr

YZ[ \[]Z^l^Z]\[t ]YZgZ _Ym[tZg \[ [\]^\_ `a\bZ mg

qo[_]\`[ `q o[\uZ^gmi ]\k Z~ \] \g \k l`^]m[] ]` ^ZkZknZ^

]Ym] ]YZ i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^g m^Z [`] ]YZ gmkZ q^`k `[Z

kZmgo^ZkZ[] ]\kZ ]` m[`]YZ^r

‚\to^Z gY`jg ]YZ de bZ[g\]h um^\m]\`[g mg qo[_p

]\`[ `q g`im^ i`_mi ]\kZ q`^ `[Z `q ]YZ i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^g

cx wf ]Ym] ZalZ^\Z[_Zb m _iZm^ ^Zbo_]\`[ `q ]YZ kZmp

go^Zb de bZ[g\]hr XY\g ^Zbo_]\`[ jmg [`] ZalZ_]Zb~

g\[_Z ]YZ {| m[b €} bm]m _iZm^ih gY`jZb m[ \[lo]

`q mo^`^mi ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th q`^ ]Y\g ^Zt\`[~ mg gY`j[ nh

]YZ ^Zim]\uZih Y\tY d mo^`^mi \`[\ƒm]\`[ ^m]Z \[ to^Z r

XYZ _`^^Zgl`[b\[t o[\uZ^gmi ]\kZ q`^ ]YZ …de kZmp

go^Zk Z[]g q`^ ]Y\g i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^ jmg ‹v {X r XY\g

to^Z t\uZg ]YZ k`bZiZb de bZ[g\]h m] ‹Š Žk mi]\]obZ

cnim_Ž g`i\b _o^uZf mgm qo[_]\`[ `q g`im^i`_mi]\kZr s

ig`

gY`j[ \g ]YZ kZmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h mg gom^Zg~`[Z kZmp

go^Zk Z[] q`^ ]YZ glZ_\_ i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^ q`^ Zm_Y bmhr

XYZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ lY`]`b\gg`_\m]\`[ ^m]Z cb`]]Zb i\[Zf

m[b ]YZ d mo^`^mi \`[\ƒm]\`[ ^m]Z ct^mh Y\g]`t^mk f m^Z

n`]Y li`]]Zb `[ m[ m^n\]^m^h g_miZr XYZ mo^`^mi \`[\ƒmp

]\`[ ^m]Z \g b\^Z_]ih ^Zim]Zb ]` ]YZ \[lo] l^Z_\l\]m]\`[

ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa q^`k ]YZ {| m[b €} kZmp

go^Zk Z[]g~ m[b ]YZ …olZ^† s‡

lm^mk Z]^\ƒm]\`[r XYZ

lm^mkZ]^\ƒm]\`[ jmg muZ^mtZb `uZ^ mii ]YZ q`o^ im]\]obZ

gZ_]`^g~m[b YZ[_Z ]YZ Y`o^g jYZ^Z {| m[b €} Ymb

[` `ngZ^um]\`[g~]YZ Z[Z^th „oa jmg]YZ gmk Z q`^ mii]YZ

im]\]obZ gZ_]`^gr ‚`^ ]YZ ZamkliZ t\uZ[ \[ to^Z ~ jZ

gZZ ]Ym] q`^ ]YZ ]j` i`jZg] im]\]obZg ]YZ^Z jmg m qm\^ih

t``b mt^ZZk Z[] nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k`bZi m[b ]YZ …de bm]m

q`^ bmh ‹x‹r XYZ \[_^ZmgZ \[ ]YZ kZmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h

q`^ ]YZ [Za] bmh~ ‹xx~jmg[`] [Zm^ih im^tZ Z[`otY _`kp

lm^Zb ]` ]YZ k `bZiZb de bZ[g\]hr ‚`^ ]YZ ]j` ollZ^

im]\]obZ gZ_]`^g ]YZ k Zmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h m] ‹Š Žk

mi]\]obZ m_]omiih bZ_^ZmgZb gong]m[]\miih q^`k bmh ‹x‹

]` bmh ‹xx~ \[ gl\]Z `q ]YZ `ngZ^uZb mo^`^mi m_]\u\]h m]

]YZgZ im]\]obZgr ‚`^ mii im]\]obZg ]YZ^Z jmg m _iZm^ \[p

_^ZmgZ \[ ]YZ kZmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h q^`k bmh ‹xx ]` bmh

‹x‰r `jZuZ^~ \] gZZk g i\ŽZ ]YZ nmg\g `[ bmh ‹xx jmg

]`` i`j _`k lm^Zb ]` ]YZ k `bZiZb bZ[g\]h ]` t\uZ m t``b

mt^ZZkZ[] nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ ]j` l^`iZg `[ bmh ‹x‰ Z\]YZ^r

iZm^ih g`k Z]Y\[t YmllZ[Zb `[ bmh ‹xx ]Ym] g]^`[tih

goll^ZggZb ]YZ ZZ_] `[ [\]^\_ `a\bZ q^`k mo^`^mi l^Zp

_\l\]m]\`[r

¨©£ µ§£  ­ §¯  ¨ª °¦ž£ Ŷ­ ž ÅÉ £¨ª ¨¤¢

ËÉ«ËÊ

¤ ž¥±

‚\to^Z t\uZg m[ Zamk liZ `q Y`j ]YZ k `bZiZb de

bZ[g\]h \g im^tZ^ ]Ym[ ]YZ k Zmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h q`^ mii

]YZ q`o^ bmhgr XYZ qm_]`^ nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k `bZi ^Zgoi]

m[b ]YZ k Zmgo^Zb bZ[g\]h gZZkg ]` ^Zk m\[ ]YZ gmkZ

]Y^`otY`o] ]YZ Z[]\^Z lZ^\`br XY\g _mgZ \g q`^ xŠyw ~

Šwp vw d~ _`^^Zgl`[b\[t ]` xŠ {X q`^ ]YZ …de

k Zmgo^ZkZ[]gr {[i\ŽZ ]YZ ZamkliZ t\uZ[ \[ to^Z ~

]YZ …de `ngZ^um]\`[g gY`j m _iZm^ \[_^ZmgZ `q ]YZ de

bZ[g\]h `[ bmh ‹xx boZ ]` ]YZ tZ`k mt[Z]\_ g]`^k r

XYZ mi]\]obZ l^`iZg `q ]YZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]\Zg q`^

xxw  q`^ mii ]YZ q`o^ im]\]obZ gZ_]`^g q`^ bmh ‹xx colp

lZ^f m[b bmh ‹x‰ ci`jZ^f `q ‹ŒŒ~ m^Z gY`j[ \[ to^Z

r XYZ o[\uZ^gmi ]\kZ q`^ ]YZ …de kZmgo^Zk Z[]g m]

]Y\g i`[t\]obZ jmg ‹ {Xr XYZ k `bZiZb [\]^\_ `a\bZ

bZ[g\]h `[ bmh ‹xx jmg `uZ^mii im^tZ^ ]Ym[ ]Ym] k Zmp

go^Zb nh …derXY\g jmgZglZ_\miih Zu\bZ[] m] mi]\]obZg

mn`uZ ‹xŠ Žk r XYZ mo^`^mi ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th „oa ogZb

mg\[lo] q`^]YZ k`bZi jmg [`] lm^]\_oim^ih im^tZ q`^]Y\g

i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^bo^\[t Z\]YZ^ `q]YZgZ bmhgr Z gZZ ]Ym]

`[ bmh ‹xx~ ]YZ k`bZi b\glimhg [`[Z `q ]YZ g]^o_]o^Zg

`q ]YZ k Zmgo^Zb de l^`iZ mn`uZ ‹xŠ Žk mi]\]obZr

XYZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ mi]\]obZ l^`iZg jZ^Z nZ]]Z^ _`^^Zim]Zb

m] mii mi]\]obZg `[ bmh ‹x‰r s

qZj `q ]YZ _mgZg j\]Y

]YZ k`g] Zu\bZ[] b\Z^Z[_ZgnZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k `bZi m[b ]YZ

k Zmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h q`^ bmh ‹x‰ Ymb m ko_Y im^tZ^

b\Z^Z[_Z ]YZ bmh nZq`^Z cbmh ‹xxfr

‘ š™˜š–“

XYZ `n Z_]\uZ q`^ ]Y\g g]obh jmg ]` umi\bm]Z ]YZ _mip

_oim]\`[ `q i`jZ^ ]YZ^k `glYZ^\_ [\]^\_ `a\bZ m] Y\tYZ^

im]\]obZg nh m lY`]`_YZk\_mi k`bZi ~ ‹ŒŒxz

~ xŠŠxr €^Zu\`og j`^Ž j\]Y ]YZ gmkZ k `bZi

tmuZ t``b mt^ZZkZ[] j\]Y `ngZ^uZb [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\p

]\Zg m] i`j im]\]obZg jYZ^Z ]YZ ZZ_] `q ZiZ_]^`[ \klm_]

`[ ]YZ l^`bo_]\`[ `q [\]^\_ `a\bZ \g q^`k lY`]`ZiZ_]^`[g

jY\_Y m^Z l^`bo_Zb nh ]YZ m_]\`[ `q g`im^ g`q] }p^mhg

`[ k`iZ_oim^ [\]^`tZ[ m[b m]`k\_ `ahtZ[r

(10)

mf ‹ŒŒ‹xx

nf ‹ŒŒ‹x‰

›³ ¢£¤ªœµ ¨ ÅÅÄ £¨ª¶ ­ ¦ž ¯¨œ¦¢£ ž£°œ ¤ª¶ ¨ª ©£¨ª¦ž£¢ ´µ ›³ ¢ £¢ ¯œ¤£ ¬œ¥

Ÿž ªª£ª ¨¤¢ Ÿ¨¯Ÿ¦¯¨£¢ ­ž © ¥£ ›³¡ © ¢£¯ ª ¯œ¢ ¯œ¤£± ²¥£ ¦§§£ž ­ ¦ž §¯ ª ¨ž£ ­ ž ¢¨µ ÂÅŶ ¨¤¢ ¥£

¯ ¬£ž ­ ¦ž §¯ ª ¨ž£ ¥£ ª¨©£ ž£°œ ¤ª ­ ž ¢¨µ Âű ²¥£ ¦¤œ®£žª¨¯ œ©£ ­ ž ¥£ ›³ ©£¨ª¦ž£©£¤ª ¨

Ëɛ ¨ž£ °œ®£¤ œ¤ ¥£ ¯ ¬£ž žœ°¥ Ÿ ž¤£ž  ­ £¨Ÿ¥ §¯ ±

XYZ ^Zgoi]gq^`k ]Y\gg]obh gY`j ]Ym] ]YZ lY`]`_YZkp

\_mi k `bZi `uZ^Zg]\km]Zg~]` m um^h\[t bZt^ZZ~]YZ [\]^\_

`a\bZ bZ[g\]h \[ ]YZ i`jZ^]YZ^k`glYZ^Z bo^\[t tZ`k mtp

[Z]\_ m_]\uZ lZ^\`bgr XYZ j`^Ž `q ‹ŒŒm

jmg nmgZb `[ ]Y\g gmk Z lY`]`_YZk\_mi k `bZi~ m[b Ymb

mg \[lo] q`^ ]YZ mo^`^mi Z[Z^th bZl`g\]\`[ ]YZ YZk\p

glYZ^\_mi l`jZ^ \[bZa q^`k ]YZ de ss

k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g~

m[b m g]m]\g]\_mik `bZiq`^]YZ mo^`^mil^Z_\l\]m]\`[ lm]p

]Z^[r XYZ\^ k`bZi _mi_oim]\`[g tmuZ m qm^ t^Zm]Z^ de

bZ[g\]h m] Y\tYZ^ im]\]obZg ]Ym[ ]Ym] kZmgo^Zb nh …† r

XYZ\^ b\Z^Z[_Zg jZ^Z `q m qm_]`^ `q q`o^ `[ ]YZ bmh nZp

q`^Z ]YZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k ~ m[b m qm_]`^ `q ]Z[ mq]Z^

]YZ g]`^k r Y\iZ ]YZh ogZb m h\Zib `q Šr q`^ ]YZ l^`p

bo_]\`[ `q d cxf q^`k ]YZ ZiZ_]^`[ \k lm_] `[ dx~ jZ

ogZ m h\Zib `q Šrvy

~ ‹ŒŠr XYZ _mi_oim]Zb

[\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]h \g uZ^h gZ[g\]\uZ ]` ]Y\g n^m[_Y\[t

^m]\` m^]Y~ ‹ŒŒxr

Ym[t\[t q^`k Šr Š ]` Šrvy l^`p

bo_Zg m qm_]`^ `q ]j` _Ym[tZ \[ ]YZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]hr

‚^`k ]YZ {| m[b €} k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g jZ mig` tZ]

]YZ g]^o_]o^Z m[b ]\kZ Y\g]`^h `q ]YZ ZiZ_]^`[ l^Z_\l\p

]m]\`[~ j\]Y`o] Ymu\[t ]` ogZ m g]m]\g]\_mi k `bZir eo^

^Zgoi]g gY`j m qm_]`^ `q xp‰ b\Z^Z[_Z nZ]jZZ[ k`bZi

m[b …de k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g~ q`^ ]YZ bmh `q ]YZ g]`^k `[p

gZ]r XY\g \g m g\t[\_m[] b\Z^Z[_Z~ Y`jZuZ^~ o\]Z nZ]p

]Z^ ]Ym[ m qm_]`^ `q ‹Š b\Z^Z[_Zr XYZ t``b _`^^Zim]\`[

q`^ ]YZ i`jZ^ im]\]obZg \[ ]YZ l^Zu\`og g]obh nh

xŠŠy~mig` \[b\_m]Zg ]Ym] ]YZ ^Zu\gZb dc

f

h\Zib l^`u\bZg m k `^Z _`^^Z_] Zg]\k m]Z `q ]YZ [\]^\_ `ap

\bZ l^`bo_]\`[r XYZ ^Zgoi]g `q ]YZ l^ZgZ[] g]obh~ m^Z

gong]m[]\miih nZ]]Z^ q`^ ]YZ bmh mq]Z^ ]YZ g]`^k `[gZ]

c‹x‰f~ jYZ[ ]YZ m]k`glYZ^Z jmg _mik Z^r XY\g jmg mig`

(11)

]YZ _mgZ q`^ m[`]YZ^ ZuZ[]~ [`] l^ZgZ[]Zb YZ^Z~q`^ bmhg

‹ ]` ‹~ ‹ŒŒr XYZ bmh `q ]YZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k ~

‹~ ]YZ b\Z^Z[_Z nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k`bZiZb m[b ]YZ kZmp

go^Zb de bZ[g\]h jmg k`^Z ]Ym[ m qm_]`^ `q xr XYZ

[Za] bmh~ ‹~ ]YZ mt^ZZkZ[] nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k `bZi m[b

]YZ `ngZ^um]\`[g jmg ^Zk m^Žmnih t``br XY\g ZuZ[] jmg

m ^m]YZ^ \g`im]Zb tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k ~m[b `[ih ]YZ ZiZ_p

]^`[ Z[Z^th lm^mkZ]Z^g bZ^\uZb q^`k {| m[b €}

`ngZ^um]\`[g bo^\[t ]YZ ZuZ[]~ jZ^Z ogZb mg \[lo] ]`

]YZ dea k`bZi~ [`] m _`[]\[o`og Z[Z^th „oa mg q`^ ]YZ

ZuZ[] l^ZgZ[]Zb YZ^Zr

xŠŠ _`k lm^Zb ]YZ ]`]mi Z[Z^th bZl`g\p

]\`[ bZ^\uZb q^`k …de [\]^\_ `a\bZ kZmgo^ZkZ[]g nh

ogZ `q ]YZ lY`]`_YZk\_mi k`bZi~ j\]Y ]Ym] bZ^\uZb q^`k

€} kZmgo^ZkZ[]g q`^ uZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ ZuZ[]gr s

ig`

q`^ ]Ym] g]obh ]YZ k `bZi tmuZ m i`jZ^ mo^`^mi ZiZ_]^`[

\[lo] q^`k ]YZ …de k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g ]Ym] bZ^\uZb q^`k

€}r

XYZ b\g_^Zlm[_\Zg nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k`bZiZb de bZ[g\]h

m[b ]YZ k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g~ k \tY] \[ lm^] nZ boZ ]` ]YZ

ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th \[lo] ]` ]YZ k `bZi nZ\[t j^`[tr mgZb

`[ ]YZ t``b _`^^Zim]\`[ `[ i`jZ^ im]\]obZg

~ xŠŠy~ jZ nZi\ZuZ ]Ym] ]YZ k Z]Y`b q`^ ]YZ lY`p

]`ZiZ_]^`[g l^`bo_Zb nh g`im^ g`q] }p^mhg m[b Za]^Zk Z

oi]^mu\`iZ]~ ]` nZ o\]Z gm]\gqm_]`^h mig` q`^ ]YZ Y\tYZ^

im]\]obZgr s

ig` q`^ ]YZ ^Zgoi]g \[ ]Y\g g]obh~ ]YZ k`bp

ZiZb de bZ[g\]h mt^ZZb jZii j\]Y ]YZ `ngZ^um]\`[gjYZ[

]YZ mo^`^mi Z[Z^th \[lo] jmg i`j r XYZ mo^`^mi ZiZ_]^`[

Z[Z^th \[lo] q`^ ]YZ k `bZi jmg km\[ih q^`k {| m[b

€}r ‚`^ _`[]\[o\]h `q ]YZ Z[Z^th \[lo] ]YZ ZiZ_]^`[

Z[Z^th „oa jmg mig` bZ^\uZb q^`k t^`o[b tZ`kmt[Z]\_

kZmgo^ZkZ[]g q^`k ]YZ …olZ^†s‡ bm]mnmgZ~ \[ ]YZ

]\kZ \[]Z^umig j\]Y`o] {| m[b €} kZmgo^Zk Z[]gr

XYZ _Ym^m_]Z^\g]\_ Z[Z^th jmg q`^ ]YZgZ _mgZg gZ] ]` m

aZb umioZ `q y ŽZ|r XYZ ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th lm^mk Z]Z^g

jZ^Z bZ^\uZb q^`k ]YZ {| m[b €} k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g

nh og\[t ]j` b\Z^Z[] ]Z_Y[\oZg~ m[b ]YZ[ k m]_YZb

]`tZ]YZ^]` q`^k `[Z ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th glZ_]^ok r Z _`[p

g\bZ^ ]YZgZ ^Zgoi]g ]` nZ m gm]\gqm_]`^h k Zmgo^Z `q ]YZ

kZm[ ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th bZl`g\]\`[ \[]` ]YZ i`jZ^]YZ^k `p

glYZ^Z lZ^ Y`o^r XY\g Y`o^ih mo^`^mi Z[Z^th \[lo] q`^

]YZ k `bZi jmg nmgZb `[ cogomiihf g\a Z[Z^th glZ_]^m bZp

^\uZb q^`k {| m[b €} kZmgo^Zk Z[]gr ] \g b\_oi]

]` t\uZ m[ Zam_] umioZ q`^ ]YZ o[_Z^]m\[]h `q ]Y\g mo^`p

^mi Z[Z^th „oa m[b _Ym^m_]Z^\g]\_ Z[Z^thr XYZ^Z m^Z [`

g\t[g ]Ym] ]YZh k\tY] nZ ghg]Zkm]\_miih `uZ^Zg]\km]Zb~

m__`^b\[t ]` l^Zu\`og j`^Ž jYZ^Z ]Y\g kZ]Y`b jmg ogZb

~ xŠŠŠr

XYZ …olZ^† s‡

lm^mkZ]^\ƒm]\`[ jmg b\u\bZb \[ xyw

i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^gr XYZ i\[Zm^ ^Zim]\`[ nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ Z[p

Z^th „oa bZ^\uZb q^`k {| m[b €} k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g

m[b ]YZ dŠ lZ^]o^nm]\`[ `q ]YZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ Zib~

Ymb m _`^^Zim]\`[ `q Šrvr XYZ^Z jZ^Z i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^g

jYZ^Z ]YZ [oknZ^ `q kmt[Z]`k Z]Z^ g]m]\`[g jmg o\]Z

i`j ~ ZglZ_\miih \[ …\nZ^\mr XYZ bZ^\uZb Z[Z^th „oa \[

]YZgZ ^Zt\`[g k\tY] nZ o[bZ^Zg]\k m]Zbr XY\g _`oib nZ

]YZ ^Zmg`[ q`^ ]YZ b\Z^Z[_Zg \[ ]YZ k`bZi de bZ[g\]h

m[b ]YZ kZmgo^Zb `[Z `[ ]YZ [\tY] nZ]jZZ[ ‹xx m[b ‹x‰~

o[\uZ^gmi]\k Z~ m[b `[ ]YZ ZuZ[\[t `[ bmh ‹x‰r Z^Z ]YZ

…de kZmgo^Zk Z[]g `q de gY`jZb m[ \[_^ZmgZ~ jY\iZ

]YZ k`bZiZb bZ[g\]h jmg bZ_^Zmg\[tr ‚`^ ]YZ ^Zt\`[g m]

Ym[b~ ]YZ km\[ ZiZ_]^`[ \[lo] jmg bZ^\uZb q^`k k mtp

[Z]`k Z]Z^ bm]m~ m[b ]YZ gZ_]`^g Ymb qZj g]m]\`[gr

XYZ aZb ZiZ_]^`[ _Ym^m_]Z^\g]\_ Z[Z^th m] y ŽZ| q`^

]YZ …olZ^† s‡

lm^mk Z]^\ƒm]\`[ _`oib mig` _mogZ g`kZ

b\g_^Zlm[_hr `jZuZ^~ ]YZ mi]\]obZ l^`iZg `q de gZZk

]` nZ k`^Z t`uZ^[Zb nh ]YZ uZ^]\_mi j\[bg q^`k ]Zkp

lZ^m]o^Z t^mb\Z[]gr XYZ YZ\tY] `q ]YZ k ma\k ok de

bZ[g\]h jmg [`] lm^]\_oim^ih b\Z^Z[] q`^ ]YZ k `bZiZb

m[b ]YZ kZmgo^Zb l^`iZr XYZ _Ym^m_]Z^\g]\_ Z[Z^th `q

]YZ mo^`^miZiZ_]^`[g~m[b YZ[_Z ]YZ mi]\]obZ `q]YZ kmap

\kok Z[Z^th bZl`g\]\`[~ gZZkZb ]` nZ jZii bZg_^\nZb nh

n`]Y ]YZ {| m[b €} kZmgo^Zk Z[]g m[b ]YZ aZb

y ŽZ| umioZ q`^ ]YZ …olZ^† s‡ ZuZ[]gr

XYZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]\Zg q^`k …de bmhti`j k Zmp

go^ZkZ[]g Ymb m ]`]mi o[_Z^]m\[]h `q mn`o] xŠ

~ xŠŠyr YZ[ mig` _`[g\bZ^\[t ]YZ t``b ^Zp

goi]g nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ lY`]`_YZk \_mi k`bZi _mi_oim]\`[gm[b

]YZ k Zmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]h m] i`j im]\]obZg jYZ^Z lY`]`p

ZiZ_]^`[g m^Z ]YZ g`o^_Z `q]YZ ZiZ_]^`[ \klm_] ^Zm_]\`[g

m^]Y m[b m\iZh~ xŠŠy~ [Z\]YZ^ ]YZ …de de k Zmp

go^ZkZ[]g~[`^ ]YZ …de g`im^ g`q] }p^mh `ngZ^um]\`[g

gY`oib t\uZ ]YZ im^tZ b\g_^Zlm[_\Zg m] Y\tYZ^ im]\]obZgr

XYZ b\Z^Z[_Zg nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k `bZi m[b ]YZ kZmgo^Zp

k Z[]g jZ^Z k`^Z b`k\[m[] `[ bmh ‹xx~ ]Ym[ `[ bmh

‹x‰r XY\g jmg ZglZ_\miih Zu\bZ[] \[ ]YZ mi]\]obZ l^`iZg

`q ]YZ de bZ[g\]h cto^Z fr e[Z `q ]YZ km\[ b\Z^p

Z[_Zg nZ]jZZ[ ]YZgZ ]j` bmhg jmg ]YZ mk `o[] `q `oiZ

YZm]\[tr e[ bmh ‹xx ]YZ `uZ^mii `oiZ YZm]\[t mq]Z^ ]YZ

`[gZ] `q ]YZ tZ`k mt[Z]\_ g]`^k jmg im^tZ^ ]Ym[ `[ bmh

‹x‰ r e[ bmh ‹xx ]YZ ti`nmi `oiZ YZm]\[t Za_ZZbZb ‰ŠŠ

‡

q`^ mn`o] ‹Š Y`o^g cumioZg q^`k ]YZ s

gg\k \im]\uZ

† mll\[t `q `[`glYZ^\_ iZ_]^`bh[mk \_g c s

†f l^`p

_Zbo^Zfr XY\g \g _`[g\bZ^Zb ]` nZ m k`bZ^m]Z mk`o[] `q

YZm]\[tr e[ bmh ‹x‰ \] jmg mn`uZ ‰ŠŠ

‡

q`^ `[ih y

Y`o^g \[ ]`]mir o^\[t lZ^\`bg `q g\t[\_m[] `oiZ YZm]p

\[t~ ]YZ m]k `glYZ^Z m] mo^`^mi im]\]obZg j\ii Zalm[b~

m[b t\uZ m[ \[_^ZmgZ `q k `iZ_oiZg ^Zim]\uZ ]` m]`k g \[

]YZ i`jZ^ ]YZ^k`glYZ^Zr eo]g\bZ ]YZ mo^`^mi `umi~ m\^

]Ym] Ymg m i`jZ^ _`[_Z[]^m]\`[ `q k`iZ_oiZg \g ]^m[gp

l`^]Zb b`j[jm^b

~ xŠŠ r XYZ m[]\go[p

jm^b [Zo]^mi j\[b m_^`gg ]YZ l`iZ~ boZ ]` \`[p[Zo]^mi

_`oli\[t m[b ]YZ _`[uZ_]\`[ lm]]Z^[~ j\ii ni`j ]YZ b\gp

]o^nZb d ^\_Y m\^ q^`k mo^`^mi ^Zt\`[g ]` k\bbiZ im]\p

]obZg m^`o[b i`_mi k \b[\tY]r sg ]YZgZ ^Zt\`[g _`p^`]m]Z

j\]Y ]YZ m^]Y~ ]YZ b\g]o^nm[_Z \g ZuZ[]omiih n^`otY]

]` ]YZ bmj[ gZ_]`^r s

] k \bpim]\]obZg~ ]YZ^Z \g m l`iZp

jm^b ^Z]o^[ „`j `q ]YZ [Zo]^mi j\[bg~ n^\[t\[t m\^ ]Ym]

Ymg m i`jZ^ d k \a\[t ^m]\` ]` Y\tYZ^ im]\]obZg cm^`o[b

‹‰Š Žk mi]\]obZfr XY\g d l``^ m\^ k mh ]YZ[ nZ i`_m]Zb

nZ[Zm]Y ^Zt\`[g `q d ^\_Y m\^

~

xŠŠ r q

]Y\g YmllZ[g~ ]YZ Yhb^`g]m]\_ nmim[_Z \g n^`ŽZ[ q`^ ]YZ

i`jZ^ ]YZ^k`glYZ^\_ ^Zt\`[gr XYZ k`bZi q`^ ]YZ nm_Žp

t^`o[b m]k`glYZ^Z ogZb YZ^Z~ d†……pŠŠ~ \g nmgZb

(12)

Zo\i\n^\ok

~ ‹ŒvŒr Z[_Z~ q`^ lZ^\`bg jYZ[

]YZ^Z \g gong]m[]\mi `oiZ YZm]\[t~ ]YZ d†……pŠŠ

k`bZi j\ii [`] nZ go_\Z[] q`^ k`bZi\[t ]YZ _`^^Z_] ^Zp

gl`[gZ `q ]YZ m]k`glYZ^Zr [g]Zmb~ m ti`nmi _\^_oim]\`[

k`bZi go_Y mg ]YZ d s

X†p

‡

† k `bZi~ _`oib nZ

ogZb ]` bZ]Z^k \[Z ]YZ nm_Žt^`o[b [Zo]^mi m]k`glYZ^Z

bo^\[t b\g]o^nZb _`[b\]\`[g~ m[b ]YZ[ ]YZ dea `[Zp

b\kZ[g\`[mi k`bZi _m[ nZ ogZb q`^ _mi_oim]\[t ]YZ [\p

]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]hr XYZ YZm]\[t `[ bmh ‹xx jmg _`[g\bp

Z^mniZ Z[`otY ]Ym] ]YZ m]k`glYZ^Z jmg [`] \[ Yhb^`p

g]m]\_ Zo\i\n^\ok ]Y\g bmh~ m[b ]YZ de `ngZ^um]\`[g

_`oib ]YZ^Zq`^Z [`] nZ k `bZiZb _`^^Z_]ih nh ]YZ dea

k`bZi j\]Y ]YZ d† ……pŠŠ Zg]\k m]\`[ q`^ ]YZ nm_Žp

t^`o[b m]k`glYZ^Zr ‚`^ ]YZ i`jZ^ m[b k \bbiZ im]\]obZg

]YZ m]k `glYZ^Z jmg [`] mZ_]Zb ]` ]Ym] Za]Z[] nh ]YZ

mk `o[] `q `oiZ m[b lm^]\_iZ YZm]\[tr XYZ ^Zgoi]g q`^

]Y\g g]obh m^Z YZ[_Z [`] \[ _`[„\_] j\]Y ]YZ l^Zu\`og

Y\tY _`^^Zim]\`[ ^Zgoi]g q`^ ]YZ ]^`l\_g

~xŠŠyr XYZ nZ]]Z^ _`^^Zim]\`[g`[ bmh ‹x‰ gY`j ]Ym]

jYZ[ ]YZ m]k`glYZ^Z gZ]]iZg b`j[ m[b ]YZ ZZ_] `q ]YZ

`oiZ YZm]\[t \g [`] mg b`k \[m[]~]YZ dea k `bZi j`^Žg

ko_Y nZ]]Z^r `jZuZ^~ g\[_Z ]YZ l^`_ZggZg ]YZ bmh nZp

q`^Z jZ^Z [`] qoiih _`uZ^Zb nh ]YZ k`bZi~]YZ _mi_oim]Zb

\[_^ZmgZ `q]Z[ tmuZ ]`` Y\tY bZ[g\]h q`^ bmh ‹x‰ mg jZiir

‘ ˜ • “— ™–“™ ˜š–“

XYZ mo^`^mi ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th Ymg nZZ[ bZ^\uZb q^`k

{| m[b €} kZmgo^Zk Z[]g `q mo^`^mi {| Zk \gg\`[g

m[b }p^mh n^Zk gg]^mYio[tr ‚`^ ]YZ ]\kZg jYZ[ ]YZ ]j`

\[g]^okZ[]g jZ^Z [`] kZmgo^\[t ]YZ [`^]YZ^[ mo^`^mi

`umi~ ]YZ ZiZ_]^`[ Z[Z^th jmg Zg]\k m]Zb q^`k t^`o[b

tZ`k mt[Z]\_ k Zmgo^ZkZ[]gr XYZ mo^`^mi Z[Z^th jmg

m^^m[tZb \[ tZ`t^mlY\_mi n`aZg `q vw im]\]obZ m[b xyw

i`[t\]obZ gZ_]`^gr ] jmg _`[]\[o`og \[ ]\k Z `uZ^ q`o^

bmhg~ q^`k bmh ‹xŠ o[]\i bmh ‹xy `q ‹ŒŒr XY\g lZ^\`b

_`uZ^Zb ]YZ `[gZ] `q m tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k `[ ]YZ k `^[p

\[t `q bmh ‹xxr XYZ mo^`^mi Z[Z^th jmg ogZb mg ]YZ

\[lo] ]` m lY`]`_YZk\_mi k`bZi q`^ [\]^\_ `a\bZr XYZ

Z[Z^th \[lo] q^`k lY`]`ZiZ_]^`[g jmg mig` m__`o[]Zb

q`^r XYZ k `bZiZb de bZ[g\]h \[ ]YZ i`jZ^]YZ^k`glYZ^Z

nZ]jZZ[ im]\]obZg vŠw m[b Šwd jmg _`k lm^Zb j\]Y ]YZ

de bZ[g\]h kZmgo^Zb nh …de q`^ ]YZ gmkZ tZ`t^mlYp

\_mi m^Zmr Zq`^Z ]YZ `[gZ] `q ]YZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k ~

]YZ k`bZi gZZk Zb ]` j`^Ž jZii jYZ[ ]YZ mo^`^mi ZiZ_p

]^`[ Z[Z^th \[lo] jmg ^m]YZ^ i`j r XYZ ^Zgoi]g `q ]Y\g

_`klm^\g`[ gY`jZb m[ `uZ^Zg]\km]\`[ `q]YZ de bZ[g\]h

nh ]YZ lY`]`_YZk\_mi k `bZir XY\g _mi_oim]\`[ \g uZ^h

gZ[g\]\uZ ]` ]YZ n^m[_Y\[t ^m]\` `q ZiZ_]^`[ \klm_] b\gp

g`_\m]\`[ `q [\]^\_ `a\bZ ]` l^`bo_Z dc

f m]`k gr XYZ^Z

mig` gZZkZb ]` nZ nZ]]Z^ mt^ZZk Z[] nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k`bZi

m[b k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g`[Z bmh mq]Z^ ]YZ g]`^k ~ZuZ[ ]Y`otY

]YZ tZ`k mt[Z]\_ m_]\u\]h ^Zkm\[Zb Y\tYr Z nZi\ZuZ ]YZ

`oiZ YZm]\[t ZZ_] `[ ]YZ nm_Žt^`o[b m]k `glYZ^Z jmg

[`] l^`lZ^ih _ml]o^Zb nh ]YZ d† ……pŠŠ k`bZi q`^

]YZ bmh `q ]YZ g]`^k ~ m[b ]Ym] ]Y\g iZb ]` ]YZ im^tZ

`uZ^Zg]\k m]Z `q ]YZ de bZ[g\]h q`^ ]Ym] bmhr XYZ bmh

mq]Z^~ jYZ[ ]YZ m]k `glYZ^Z jmg _mik Z^~ ]YZ b\Z^Z[_Z

nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k`bZiZb m[b kZmgo^Zb de bZ[g\]\Zg jmg

gk miiZ^r XYZ ^Zm_]\`[g \[u`iuZb \[ ]YZ k `bZi~ m[b ]YZ\^

^Zm_]\`[ ^m]Zg m[b n^m[_Y\[t ^m]\`g~ m^Z l^`nmnih goqp

_\Z[]ih m__o^m]Z ]` _mi_oim]Z ]YZ _YZk \_mi l^`bo_]\`[

m[b i`gg `q [\]^\_ `a\bZ \[ ]YZ i`jZ^ ]YZ^k`glYZ^Zr ] \g

u\]mi~ ]Y`otY~ ]` YmuZ ]YZ nm_Žt^`o[b m]k `glYZ^Z _`^p

^Z_]ih l`^]^mhZbr …`kZ `q ]YZ ^Zm_]\`[g m^Z b\^Z_]ih bZp

lZ[bZ[] `[ ]YZ [Zo]^mi ]ZklZ^m]o^Z `q ]YZ m]k `glYZ^Zr

s

ii `q ]YZ ^Zm_]\`[g [ZZb m _`^^Z_] bZg_^\l]\`[ `q ]YZ

bZ[g\]h `q ]YZ [Zo]^mi _`[g]\]oZ[]gr

X` _`[_iobZ~ ]YZ lY`]`_YZk\_mi k`bZi q`^ de~ j\]Y

d† ……pŠŠ mg ]YZ k`bZi q`^ ]YZ nm_Žt^`o[b m]k `p

glYZ^Z~ \g o[mniZ ]` _mi_oim]Z l^Z_\gZih ]YZ _`^^Z_] de

bZ[g\]h \[ ]YZ i`jZ^ ]YZ^k`glYZ^Z q`^ lZ^\`bg j\]Y g\tp

[\_m[] `oiZ YZm]\[tr mgZb `[ ]YZ ^m]YZ^ t``b mt^ZZp

k Z[] nZ]jZZ[ ]YZ k`bZiZb [\]^\_ `a\bZ bZ[g\]h m[b ]YZ

k Zmgo^ZkZ[]g nZq`^Z m[b mq]Z^ ]YZ tZ`kmt[Z]\_ g]`^k ~

jZ nZi\ZuZ ]Ym] ]YZ _YZk\_mi l^`_ZggZg`q]YZ dea k`bZi

m^Z m _`^^Z_] bZg_^\l]\`[ `q ]YZ [\]^\_ `a\bZ l^`bo_]\`[

m[b i`gg \[ ]YZ mo^`^mi ^Zt\`[r

àÚÐ ç×ÓèÐâÝÒÖ ÒðÔÚ×ÓÜÔÚÒÖô ÔÚÐ ÷ÐÜÐÒÓÞÚ ï×ðÖÞÝáר ç×ÓèÒÛ

Ø×Ó ÖÒÖÞÝÒá ÜðÑÑ×ÓÔé

õ×Ó ÔÚÐ âÓ×ðÖß ÕÒâÖÐÔ×ÕÐÔÐÓ ßÒÔÒ èÐ âÓÒÔÐØðááÛ ÒÞôÖ×èá

ÿ

ÐßâÐ àÚÐ î

ÿ

÷íûÙ ÏÒÔÒìÒÜÐã Ùó ÙÓרé é ðÕ×Ô× ÒÖß ÏÓé

é îÚÝ×ôÒèÒ àÚÐ îÙóÏ÷ ßÒÔÒìÒÜÐ óÖÔÐÓÕÒâÖÐÔ àÚÐ ÝÖÜÔÝÔðÔÐÜ

èÚ× ÕÒÝÖÔÒÝÖ ÔÚÐ óûíò ÕÒâÖÐÔ×ÕÐÔÐÓ ÒÓÓÒÛ íí÷ó ßÒÔÒã Ùó

ÙÓרé áÐâ àÓ×ÜÚÝÞÚÐå ÏÒÖÝÜÚ ûÐÔÐ×Ó×á×âÝÞÒá óÖÜÔÝÔðÔÐã ûÓé áÐ

÷ÒÜÕðÜÜÐÖ ÒÖß ÙÓ×ÐÞÔ îÞÝÐÖÔÝÜÔ ÏÓé úðÓâÐÖ ÒÔÐÓÕÒÖÖ ÔÚÐ

ïí÷óîûíã Ùó ÏÓé óÒÖ ûÒÖÖ àÚÐ ûíïïî ÑÓ×âÓÒÕã ÙóÜ ÏÓé

é úé øðâÚÐÜ ÒÖß ÏÓé ûé

ÖâÐìÓÐÔÜ×Ö ÒÜ èÐáá ÒÜ ÔÚÐ

ò Ð×ÕÒâ

ÿ

ÖÐÔÝÜÕ äÖÝÔ ×ØÔÚÐ òÐ×á×âÝÞÒáîðÓåÐÛ ×Ø ïÒÖÒßÒòóûíãÙó ÙÓרé

ú×ÚÖ áÜ×Ö ûíîä÷ã äïëí óòÙÙ ÒÖß õá×ÓÝßÒ óÖÜÔÝÔðÔÐ ×Ø

àÐÞÚÖ×á×âÛ äîòîã ÏÓé úÐÓÐÛ úé ë×åÐ ûíòóïã Ùóé ÏÓé ïé

÷×ìÐÓÔ ïáÒðÐÓîíû

æ

íãÙó ÏÓé ØÔÛÚÝÒ ÐÜÔÒ

93ü

ïÚÒÝÖãÙó é

ðÕ×Ô× îíûçàã Ùó ÙÓרé õÒÓÝßÐÚ ø×ÖÒÓÛ óûíòã Ùó ÏÓé

íÓÝÝáÒÖÐÖé

Ð ÒáÜ×ÔÚÒÖô

ò ÒÖâ

ë

ð Ø×Ó ú×ðáÐ ÚÐÒÔÝÖâ ßÒÔÒ ØÓ×Õ ÔÚÐ íûó

Õ×ßÐáé

•“™

íÚÖã

æ é øéã

æ

éíé ÕÐÓÛãøé éÓ×ÐÚáãÒÖß éÒÕÝßÐ

3 ã

ïáÝÕÒÔ×á×âÝÞÒá ÞÚÒÓÒÞÔÐÓÝÜÔÝÞÜ ×Ø ÔÚÐ ÒðÓ×ÓÒá Ý×Ö×ÜÑÚÐÓÐ ÝÖ

ÔÐÓÕÜ ×Ø ÐáÐÞÔÓÝÞ Ðáß ÒÖß Ý×Ö×ÜÑÚÐÓÝÞ Þ×ÖßðÞÔÒÖÞÐã ! "#$%

&'()

! *#

)

!ã +,-ã

3ü ã

üE3 é

æ

ÒÝáÐÛã îé ûéã àé çé××ßÜã ïéíé

æ

ÒÓÔÚã îé ïé î×á×Õ×Öã

ë é ÷é

ïÒÖÐáßãÒÖß ÷é×ÓßÐ

9üüü

ãûÐÒÜðÓÐÕÐÖÔÜ ×ØÔÚÐ Ü×áÒÓ ÜרÔ

.

ÿ

ÓÒÛ ÝÓÓÒßÝÒÖÞÐ ìÛ ÔÚÐ îÔðßÐÖÔ çÝÔÓÝÞ

. ÝßÐ

.

Ñá×ÓÐÓ õÝÓÜÔ

ÒÖÒáÛÜÝÜ ÒÖß ðÖßÐÓ/ÝâÚÔ ÞÒáÝìÓÒÔÝ×ÖÜã ! "#$

&'()

! *#

)

!ã +,0ã

9 ã

3 é

æ

ÒÝáÐÛãîéûéãïéíé

æ

ÒÓÔÚãÒÖß îéïéî×á×Õ×Ö

9üü9

ãí Õ×ßÐáר

ÖÝÔÓÝÞ ×

.

ÝßÐ ÝÖ ÔÚÐ á×èÐÓ ÔÚÐÓÕ×ÜÑÚÐÓÐã ! "#$

&'()

! *#

)

!ã +,1ã

39üý é

æ

ÒÖôÜã Ùé ûéã ÒÖß íé õé çÒâÛ

3 ü

ã ï×ÖÞÐÓÖÝÖâ ÔÚÐ ÝÖ/ðÐÖÞÐ

ר ÐáÒÜÔÝÞ ÜÞÒÔÔÐÓÝÖâ ðÑ×Ö ÑÚ×Ô×ÐáÐÞÔÓ×Ö ÔÓÒÖÜÑ×ÓÔ ÒÖß ÐÜÞÒÑÐã

! "#$

&'()

! *#

)

!ã 10ã

3ü9 é

æ

ÒÓÔÚãïé

39 ãçÝÔÓÝÞ ×

.

ÝßÐ ÝÖ ÔÚÐ á×èÐÓÔÚÐÓÕ×ÜÑÚÐÓÐã2345#6!

7

&

48#

7 89!ã -,ã

E3O é

æ

ÒÓÔÚã ïéíéãÒÖß îéûé

æ ÒÝáÐÛ

9üüJ

ã ï×ÕÑÒÓÝÜ×Ö ×Ø Ò ÔÚÐÓÕ×

ÿ

ÜÑÚÐÓÝÞ ÑÚ×Ô×ÞÚÐÕÝÞÒá Õ×ßÐá èÝÔÚ îÔðßÐÖÔ çÝÔÓÝÞ

. ÝßÐ

.

ÿ

Ñá×ÓÐÓ îç

×ìÜÐÓåÒÔÝ×ÖÜ ×Ø ÖÝÔÓÝÞ ×

.

ÝßÐã ! "#$

&'()

! *#

)

+,:í

üEEüJ ã ß×Ý

3ü é

3ü99üüE úí

ü3ü99 é

æ

ÒÓÔÚã ïé íéã îé ûé

æ

ÒÝáÐÛã ÒÖß îé ïé î×á×Õ×Ö

3 ã î×áÒÓ

ÿ

ÔÐÓÓÐÜÔÓÝÒáÞ×ðÑáÝÖâ î×áÒÓ ÜרÔ

.

ÿ

ÓÒÛÜ ÒÖß ÔÚÐÓÕ×ÜÑÚÐÓÝÞ ÖÝÔÓÝÞ

×

. ÝßÐã "#$

&'()

! *#

)

! ;#66!ã <=ã é

Referanser

RELATERTE DOKUMENTER

In our analysis, we are not only interested in the overall agreement between predictions and data, but also on the sensitivity of the predictions to uncertainties of the

The temperature inversion generates a sharp jump of the temperature gradient at the tropopause (b). Static stability distribution derived from the observations at Ny Ålesund

(2017), an energetic electron precipitation (EEP) event in April 2010 has been studied using a full range energy spectrum (FRES) covering 1–750 keV (corresponding to

Søkeordene har vært: ARDS, ALI, adults, nitric oxide, inhaled nitric oxide, nursing, critical care, critically ill, sedation, analgesia, guidelines, intensive care unit,

Paper III A Bayesian model for lithology/fluid class prediction using a Markov mesh prior fitted from a training image.. Håkon Tjelmeland, Xin Luo and Torstein Fjeldstad Submitted

Short-term effects of inhaled nitric oxide and prone position in pulmonary and extrapulmonary acute respiratory distress syndrome American Journal of Respiratory and Critical

Direct and indirect electron precipitation effect on nitric oxide in the polar middle atmosphere, using a full-range energy spectrum.. Christine Smith-Johnsen 1 , Hilde Nesse Tyssøy 2

[ 29 ] The development of the nitric oxide abundance at higher latitudes during the start of a geomagnetic storm event on 2 May 1998, has been compared directly with the