A comment on LTV, risk and incentives in mortgage markets

(1)

0 2344567 36 89 6 62567 5 6 437 5 457

936 065 3556 6 5 3

3 56 7 3

05 37 !"#!$ %

(2)

012 3 145 647 89 1

3 642 8488 4 2 41

4 3 4 3 47 48 7 7 7 41 3 8 7 3 4 18647 2 641 7 3 2 641 42 2 47 3 8 7 3 4 6 2 47 3 47 3 1 3 11 4 0 0 3 1 47 48847 1 7 7 4 3 !4 8!647 4 3 2 18647 "

#82 41 3 $8 2 !7 41 9 4113 187 13 1 7 %&2 3 89 147 8 82 3 8

% 3 #82 418 7 5 '7 &43 87 7 847 3 47 "

#82 41 3 $8 2 " '7 &43 87 7 ()*( + , -7 47 14. #82 41 3 $8 2

/0 1235 3(5 23(45 5615 + // *4)55 6622

(3)

0 2344567 36 89 6 62567 5 6 43 7 5 4 57

9360653556 73657355 5745673236342 54456

!"#"$56

54%736&&'3556()3&63

*35366+7)3%,)365-."/""#010!2

34+655'3

6664657355 5745673236342

/#7/07

537%835+6&5'3()4&63

9:;<=>?<%^!9)52344567367)56255689735@5562566+4'53 23+67567)5552567)56622&$))767)5277+27+53)3+6 657456767)55@2557+673)3+645A36233767)56256753A5 7)53275A7)))58973436'37)4375564373573+7&

67A55758973737)557+673)3455B+7*$23)3453A6573+7757)5 62567536256897343643737)7223465@2557+673)3+6&

$7'57A55625665556A)557)5775575737)58973&

C5236A5673+252573273)))77)5625543737)7223465 ))58973&667643755634657+6757673223+67A5)3A7)5 )377546343755'22576))5897367)543753733A5 7)526652573546757)55625675&

!9)673332)49)455632344567&

(4)

0

2356789796

!" # $ %$&# &#'()*%

0+,,-!" . #/0++0# '1$%0++2-!( # //.'345- # # /&

6 %7$&& # ## #7 6&%#$ 8 9#'0++:-!

; &#&345$ #.

<=%# & =$ # '()*%0+,,-!⁰* />%)$ #)&'0+,+- 345 . ?#. #/ &

$ # #

#$$ '1>@- ###'1>;- !*

A #B$ '0+,0-#.=/$#3456 .# %#$&7 !<

= #&# =%345 '9# # %0++C-!

D #E& '0++2- / 345

$ =$$$ # $&% # $ 345## #$&# $&'()*%0+,,-!

F%$6 ?& # 345 % &= &#. / 6 G

4 3457 $& # . . !@= .=#345 $ #!" # $#= 3457 !"& . . ##.# BH$ #. 7 .# . 345!

< . . ' #B..',22,-

# -%I#

$= # . # =#. !<%=$

& # #.#=!

0;H #',22:-345 ## /& !

(5)

0

23456767896893663769343887393678 9696498867393678674798867366776 3676786343789368943883438893473467 7893689746893467375396394388436783 968963767667867943884

639396375766377963637 794367639367!"##$%37939786763649 5336786&3438837679936373367897867 939367343438839646&67849764336776367 43884!'46!())*%%5336786&63934+6&6673 37&93663753963936786747969389 6993353367876467763'34567637396893 663773438867873936786498867 7,-.95&3767&96776367936784

96344733776377646643396393678 67479689689678967763963669968963 /367837973936785394388743883767337 9363796375763798867347&6784388 67793678387336637/6966789+6&8673 93437576867788679396776367678 639797967393678 376736786636&

4378438893967438836963669968963 966786733797346778343887964379934 +6&633964388336396896894388093486797678 968963/67&69666787&36467967763 67896896343784388

939634476337976379639 39367867476734388167793678267837767 93386793678474393,-.66775&53968677 88676767637079396736636&73467 78766678937

456789:;<=>?<@;A;8=B;<B=9>C<DE8<FEG;EH>;8C<<<

5&4678678694+3I99396786 6775&+6&J74388K3678394

"%I K J

937393678674768675&99368399374 3476373673934+6&93464675&9 4388M_L97393678+6&!,-.%678993934

(6)

0

234567897542546294326927824258

₈₄₅₉₉₄₄₅

27948

!₈₂₃₇₇₆_"5326_#₉₄_{3 9} ₄₅₇₉₄_"26₅_"6_#5₇₈_2$56₉₂₄₉_%5₆₂ 4 5"265658657 23429"$24&'()*62"7469457"54 5264 5 +29949,+956$$62 75545-.22#2426$265944582694745/56#405 +621223835#423

1 5₄)

!

6

/6566494835 5

7 6 5₄8

! 6

3 565&'(975425427556"945. 59456924.53554 5"2654 5 2794

"6#5)&'(97995.535546589:;<8=8$84>?5<;:;<8=8 6 5₄

!

₎₅_>_?5<;:

;<8=946575739 5"2652596920@(4 5956545.53554 5652

$$6599244 5"26565)⁷4 5.75452"2659445 2794AB8&'(97 95492 5652$$659924)9#539758&'(9752 5652$$6599243 54 565 2$$65992457 5"265656 5₄)C5956548 5556594974569%5 3 54 5"2456$29977522462 2794"6#5552$"547)

*26 2"523456 55565949794545.2. 556552"2659445 2794 4.552$"54794"2654 2794"6#57) 5652$$6599245-557 5

"265658 5556594"#57&'(5-55 5$69594) 5"265655-557 5 652$$6599248 579924976556754 5 2"5234565-$56954575565277)D 54 5$695944 555659427524542 5686 5₄8 2"523456257425-$569545 4&'(55494 5$6575452 275$695623 )

565924.53554&'(4 55-57765642 2794954.25.767362" 5 542542765924.535542565746598797775.2694745E92#94 +2265FGG3)H569"599765724.5277"5 9 56556579"57 5652

$$6599244 54572&'()(-$657792474.59456$6557 57 266465924 .5355455654&'()C9899765749"$264 6569792"27357564 5242"9579445-65"579"$979.949953IJ"249492465945242"957 942694 2794$$659924794499".457"9 .93 545-57765642 2794 552$7)

7D5.76362"-57)

(7)

0

2356789989888798

!"#!!$%&'"!#()'*&")#(+,"#--#( *'"$'%'.(" /" &)!,0/10

)'( +"(-!$2'".-#($' (-%#"3!45 #((*#!'(!#"-!(-)'('%0.!$ !"'(--"'.!$

#(+'.(*#!'(/!$2'".-#()# !"#!,*'"!$%&'"!#()'*!$,"#--#(4 6-"7 $'. 2'".-#($' &") +"(-!$&"'+1!.(7890#(+:;7;4< &!!$ 1 !#(!##))%#!+=!0-#(*'"$'%'.(" /$-,#"#!'( #"#&&#"(!(!$#((#

$' &")-"'.!$',"!$&"'+4>(!$.#3'*1'!$!$2'".-#(1#(3(-)" #(+!$ (!"(#!'(#*(#()#)" /!$#((#$' &")-"'.!$!"(+(-#!,4?$2'".-#(

$' (-%#"3!$# # ' (0#".!$@)&!'(#0$-$"#! '*#&&")#!'(4

ABCDEFGHIGJKLBMNOGPKDQFGREBSFQGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGABCDEFGTIGUMMDNOGPKDQFGREBSFGCEKVWPGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGG

XKDESFIGJYAZYSKMGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGXKDESFIGJYAZYSKMG

[' &")-"'.!$(2'".#0"#!+!'#(%1"'**#)!'" /()+(-!$%'"!-#-"#!

\5((+ (#(+]#( (/:;7;^4<!''.(*#!'(%'"!-#-"#! (2'".#0"%#(+'.+ &!

$-$"#! '*#&&")#!'(4?$#'.+$'%'.(" /(#++!'(!'!$&")-#(/# 1 !#(!# ,"#--#(4>(*#)!/%#&&(-#((#_[`/&")#(+,"#--#( 1!.(789a#(+:;7;\# +*(+10@&" '(\b^^/6-"b $'. $'.!$#!!"'*!(+'%(#!+!$&")-#(\# %(-

!$#!!$c?d"#!'=#9;&")(!^4

ABCDEFGeIGfgYhGREBSFGNMiGOFjFENCFGCNBMQGGGGGGGABCDEFGkIGlPFGFmSFQQGEFWDEMGWKGPKDQBMCGSKLRKMFMWQGGGG

GG G

XKDESFIGJYAZYSKMGNMiGXWNWBQWBSQGJKEVNnGGGGGGGXKDESFIGJYAZYSKMGNMiGXWNWBQWBSQGJKEVNnG

(8)

0

2345678938733587279563643674789389 97839983477385789767365687 77386788854665833567898745773883 35678947738839976988 !64789 7884747676

"6568746658335678978457897673675#$%359 79997884784876367678&3978399'"

(399)5!3&39782)*36'489678399'63 783379+",8"-.3.7843/666784657!8 784683786.38!!865456-278847)5763!*537!3&3! /

084378999783148+",73248+",358 3485!6978678467897+",7378463466583356789 -27953/*63843867789!18437878467839968 37847738337897887387884747676676'784666347 779+",736.66786393668897#$%7476 78467897+",73

279509768877567383978876'4438!78979+",736 7388#$%35678947738839967667507 77893477383+",839933!"76 764789!3958347!3'78(33-22 /9788 76'66347779+",7363783996279506#$%3 3996883483+",736318248647!8 347738767148

56789:;<=;>?@:AA;9:B89C;BD;ED8A6C7;FCG;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;56789:;H=;IJ>K;LD9B7F7:;9FB:A;FCG;MNOK;; P:Q:9F7:;7F6CAK;MNORST;FCG;MNORUT;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;ED8A6C7;FVV9:@6FB6DC;6A;W6?:G;FB;S;V:9;@:CB;

;; ;

(9)

0

2345634789649646349648946858949456968444 634 3454!"#$49456%&4 4' 34563478964964()*+6349648 946856343349 3454!"#$49456%3"4686365634897494 634#4,49457686,4#-85' 3#4676546,4#-5634#6649%."94/ 38 08637896895456,489594596856349&86463858%

123456789:58;<:=>?8@A::

B5#64956,4##"6968586349&8646333499688978968968 5698"454#69"#4899469&8#-785789644%.897#6- 45894406C 49,50#6-5"746366349&8646378968994#646834938744!"6-%

D8944##-' 4"74636789689#6456833499&6489-E494568 FGHIFJKGIGLMNOPINQIRJQOSIOFTOINQSIUGVC%E%

887946349&8646349456968' 449,496#4948589)WXYX)Z[ 789649645)WXYX)Z[964894685'9446,4#-%3496#964944546384 63669493656833499&6489-%

3496#789649645044944\ ]^ _

` _ a

W_c^bWX 563496#9648946854!"#

d^::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::

a W` a _^bWX ` _c

e

e ::

23#4."940,463496#78964964898$549456'9446,4#-' 345 634964894685,9-'"94$763496#96489468589968 4!"#5$5494569446,4#-' 3457896496494##8 468,9-%

fXghW[ij[kl[)WXYX)Z[mWYgZg[WZY+[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[[fXghW[nj[kl[)WXYX)Z[WZY+[o[Z__W)XZYXp[

[ [[[[[[[[[[[[[ [[ ."9405$38 6349&86463334996857#6'0"6-46##"696,4 -%q5."940 44438 7896899478,456833499&648946W78964

(10)

0

2345678595365259492507565587352594563 2432943885226345234!"#23456325349

$4345%%52594&485925365%2633998852234639564646536 243263255%9488522634525634'()"#24352345639%!"#*23456

32534985269253653399885223464356485224326+59 5%9438852263452532529485%79429

,-./0123456789:736947;89<=6>?@643A69B8672<C6D7812:1

2994243556&7564324+3975%948526824E4529932542943254639%485 4594325349+54755959%939%3432346FG%832439%H39&I0J$824E4526 394834+6325366345%7485K566559%939%%794296+25%42985686 23439+525345%439+52%52594325946F6552964395L25265939%

M+524659&INIJ

642345324355O695945643548852234694852565956824E452 99325429432546&75F34264J92526^P39%366548535324355Q&5K65 363949485F85J54234946243524&

R T S

U ^V8625345683956 948532543532435548395694858554234946243524

88844853496%525942346753+64234373224352535946&

37948535949453 WJ

FJ

U "

R

"

U S

UX X

24852536993+5759748347854852485MHY3924326%52+547559 2346625345%44855K56625429486925632Z5648525349+547559485 32543532435539%48523494624352424854825566+5 255624855K566254294869F645&Z52295345J^[

P$552964395$39%52639%\69FINJ23255453665665942532%92639%253499485 +3999%642&78525%5253496325%49253655449&25%583245235639%92536526439 ++3969223572925365%264396366345%748354988522346

V23252585965235722366566948532543524355639%4853455235&655 2964395]54522439%^5659FIVJ

[\484665952344856432499463665%4+5532324352478525F935235J 5360525944483432478525F935235J53652594

(11)

0

234567964476756776756534

!"#"$!#!!% &!'(! )(!#!#%((& %0*&!( +,-!((& %.*&!( +,-!/01("#(!#!( 2"!%!+,-!!&(3' %!+,-!$&''"(!4"!$!%%$!%%! )('!"&&!(')(!#!#%% 2/

53!'#(%!44%!4&!$#$$!%%$# "(((& % %!+,-!!'!$ ( 2%% '12/,(!'(&( (1'#!$!4 !!%#!!2 /

,!6# #!"!$!4!'#('"'%('"!6#

1 789+,-.*'0*&!( 3!&( 2:7_;<=_0* 7_;<=_.*/>%)&!?

"!1 +,-@.*'+,-@0*&!( 3'!%"!!4&!$#$'"'

'""!(1 !"!.*'0*&!( +,-$!%%36^0* 6^.* _/"'!4

&!$#$(!"" !A!$%"!$!%%"((& %0*&!( +,-! 6#

0B _.*

0

CD 6

,!4&!$#$&2!')(!#!"#%/('!%&!

""( &!$#$1(!%!"&&!(''(!%!"! .*&!( +,-$!%%/0"&!(%"!4(!&!CE0")(!#!#% (!'$!4 $ !A!$( 2"!((& %%!+,-!'(!1'12/

6F

D D 6_F

6F

D

G G G

.*

0*

G G

G

0*

G

0*

G

.*

G

.*

(12)

01

345678 8 74 7846 8 88 7867 645

!"#

$%&'()(*+,-..*/0'-/)(+*1-.&/)/02*)03+*&/.-'04*'0*+/.-+05)5*.)+6*0'&/0%*7*)+' (+*,*1&/50%*2&/)/,&)8,+&'&'9&/,+*)'*1:$;+)0&-'<$-%&5%8&5%00%*&/,*/0&=*'2-+)'4*88)'0%*

+&'6)''-,&)0*14&0%%&5%*+:$;+)0&-'2-+>-0%.-+05)5**')/1.-+05)5-+'4*2-,3'0%*,)(&0)8 '0+3,03+*-2%-3'&/5&/=*'0.*/0'<?%&8*,-/=*/0&-/)84%*/)/)87@&/5,-..*+,&)8+*)8*'0)0*A0%*

2-+.)81&'0&/,0&-/>*04**/(+&,*5)&/')/18*=*+)5*5)&/'&'0-0%*>*'0-2-3+6/-48*15*/-=*8 4%*/)/)87@&/5.-+05)5*2&/)/,*1%-3'&/5<

B3+'&.(8&'0&,)((+-),%&'&/0*/1*10->+&/5)''*''.*/0'-2%-3'&/52&/)/,*-/0-0%*').*(8)7&/5 2&*81)'0%*,)(&0)8'0+3,03+*)((+-),%0-,-..*+,&)8+*)8*'0)0*<C*&/5)2&+'0'0*(A&0'0&88)88-4'3' 0-%&5%8&5%0)/3.>*+-2.-+05)5*.)+6*02*)03+*'&/),-/=*/0&-/)8)/1/-/D0*,%/&,)84)7<E&+'0A 0)6&/5&/0-),,-3/00%*,)(&0)8'0+3,03+*-2%-3'&/5&/=*'0.*/0'AFGH2-+%-.*-4/*+'&''(8&0

>*04**/)(+&,*5)&/)/1)8*=*+)5*5)&/<?%*/0%*+*&'*I,*''+*03+/0-%-3'&/5A0%*8*=*+)5*5)&/ ,)/,-/0+&>30*'&5/&2&,)/0870-0%*FGH<J/1.-+*&.(-+0)/087A0%*8*=*+)5*5)&/,+*)0*'&/,*/0&=*' 2-+'%-+0'&5%0*1.-+05)5-+'0-&/,+*)'*0%*&+:$;+)0&-'<

K*,-/1A&/0+-13,&/5)+38*2-+,+*1&0+&'6(-8&,7).-/5.-+05)5**'4*'**%-4)%&5%*+:$;+)0&- 5-*'0-5*0%*+4&0%&/,+*)'*1+&'62-+.-+05)5-+'LJ.-+05)5-+&'8&20*1&/0-)%&5%*++&'6,)0*5-+7)0

%&5%*++)0*'-2)((+*,&)0&-/'-+8-4*+.-+05)5*+)0*'A0%*%&5%*+0%*:$;+)0&-<

$%&+1A0-&883'0+)0*4%7.-+05)5**')+*4&88&/50-&/,+*)'*0%*&+(-+02-8&-+&'6>7)88-4&/52-+%&5%*+

:$;+)0&-'A4*&/0+-13,*/-.&/)8+*03+/0)+5*0')/1+*8)0*0%*=)83*-2).-+05)5**0-0%*M%-.*N

*O3&07+)0&-&/&0'.-+05)5*(-+02-8&-<P/0%*(+*'*/,*-2*I,*''+*03+/0-%-3'&/54*'%-40%*

&/,*/0&=*'2-+),,*(0&/5%&5%*+:$;+)0&-'/-4*I&'0&/5)0>-0%'&1*'-20%*.-+05)5*.)+6*0<

E&/)887A6/-4&/5%-4.-+05)5**'Q1&22*+*/0+*03+/')+*+*8)0*10-0%**O3&075)&/-2&0'.-+05)5-+' )/10%*%-.**O3&07+)0&-&/&0'.-+05)5*(-+02-8&-A4*1*+&=*0%*+&'6(+*.&3./*,*'')+70-

*8&.&/)0*0%*5)&/'),,-.()/7&/5).-+05)5**Q'%&5%*+:$;+)0&-<P20%*+&'6(+*.&3.&'

(13)

00

23456627283985923483878449822398984998234242369887844 895395423868446233722378429522323692398923 873284232344892369233236878448953954237892349988 2378392846237848249233942846989889

!"

#$%!&"#'('&")*"+'",'"-.!"/01223&4586682367238668794898835423727843 7829828378694:;<=><<;?@ABCDEFAG?HIJK5992492749

L M&"-'".%"N'"O"P. )"/011Q3&R?FD?FCSEAT;@C@=EU843V398392382923WX243 Y848

L)*!&"Z'"#'".%"('")[\!"/01203&"]^_`abbcde_ad_fagehihc_jgaklkmnkimnelop_qr?sCrA t><;@E<<AC@uAv=?@?w;=AxEy;Ez69723

{|.}[!&"P'",'&"{'"~.*.".%"O'", |.*|.$"/0113]83595795835423 835887242342338522258698278opxEy;EzA?Av=?@?w;=A:@Cw;=<

077

O$ .&"-'"'&"-'"P$[.$".%"#'"P$|"/01213]andh_figce_id_ec_ndidknim

24246_ cad_¡ag_ec_egcop_¢?>F@CrA?AT;@C@=;CrA£SCs;r;S77¤0

+*|.%\&"~'"'"/2¥3"]34579233U83943252293492394o¢?>F@CrA?A

. .",$®!)"#$\|)\")"¯)°.ª00«]±24²5900³8´2337289 239oµ

~.%&"{'&"¶'")!".%"N'"·"/011¥3]V3392343Y5988987U8783

2359889¸8486989889op_´88±8488¹36¹493Y23U78

~))%|.\&"{'".%"L'"¶)}."/011º3]548U2784388293987873op

»¼?FuAxEy;EzA?Av=?@?w;=AB?r;=ª0«770¬

¶.!&"P'".%"#'".®®"/223&½8867295957958½¾¿EA¢?>F@CrA?AT;@C@=E ÀV90Á6¤¬¬

ÂP"/01223

"

^]542³^´2³³⁷⁸³^´2³³⁷²⁵⁹²²⁹^Ã^¹7⁹^¹42^74¸o^Ä?Fr^uA^v=?@?w;^=A

»>Sr??¨58798800

()\.M&"¯'".%"-'"P))"/2Q3]829784opA¢?>F@CrA?AB?r;S;=CrAv=?@?wA0¬ª¤«

7700

N\M)\&"'".%"-'"¯!"/011Å3"4V498¹69689±9284586±24¸4¢?>F@CrA?A T;@C@=;CrAxE<ECF=¿776¬

,.$%!&"#'&".%"L'"·!)"/01123&4X3X34246¹398583294±24

3492323V37839284¢?>F@CrA?AT;@C@=;CrA£EFy;=E<AxE<ECF=¿0ÁW¤770¬60Á¬

,\&"-'"{'&"/2Å3"4U2784323582398542389³X82936 783986687944¾¿EAÆ>CFSEFrA¢?>F@CrA?Av=?@?w;=<§A77¤Á6