,QWHUDNVMRQPHOORPO UHUHRJ HOHYHULVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ
(QVWXGLHDYNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJ
*HLU1\ERUJ
$YKDQGOLQJIRUJUDGHQ3K' ,QVWLWXWWIRUVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLNN 'HWXWGDQQLQJVYLWHQVNDSOLJHIDNXOWHW
8QLYHUVLWHWHWL2VOR
© Geir Nyborg, 2008
Doktoravhandlinger forsvart ved
Det utdanningsvitenskapelige fakultet, Universitetet i Oslo.
No. 95
ISSN 1501-8962
Det må ikke kopieres fra denne boka i strid med åndsverkloven eller med avtaler om kopiering inngått med Kopinor, interesseorgan for rettighetshavere til åndsverk.
Omslag: Inger Sandved Anfinsen.
Trykk og innbinding: AiT e-dit AS, Oslo, 2008.
Produsert i samarbeid med Unipub AS, Oslo.
Avhandlingen blir kun produsert av Unipub AS i forbindelse med disputas.
Alle henvendelser vedrørende avhandlingen skal rettes til rettighetshaver eller enheten der doktorgrad er forsvart.
Unipub AS er et heleid datterselskap av
Akademika AS, som eies av Studentsamskipnaden i Oslo.
)RURU G
'HWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWKDUY UWNQ\WWHWWLOIRUVNQLQJVSURJUDPPHW23,2SSYHNVWYLONnU SUREOHPDWIHUGRJLQNOXGHULQJ3URJUDPPHWWDUEODQWDQQHWVLNWHSnn\WHHWHPSLULVNRJ WHRUHWLVNELGUDJIRUnYXUGHUHKYDVRPHUUHOHYDQWHRJWHRUHWLVNHRJYDOLGH
RSSYHNVWLQGLNDWRUHU0HGRSSYHNVWLQGLNDWRUHUIRUVWnUHQXWYLNOLQJVIUHPPHQGHIRUKROGRJ ULVLNRIDNWRUHU/HGHUDYSURJUDPPHWHUSURIHVVRU(GYDUG%HIULQJ
6HOYRPIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWKDUKDWWWLONQ\WQLQJWLO IRUVNQLQJVSURJUDPPHWKDUMHJKDWWVWRU JUDGDYIULKHWPHGKHQV\QWLOnXWIRUPHRJXW¡YHHJHWDUEHLG'HWKDUVWLOWNUDYWLO
VHOYVWHQGLJKHWRJVDPWLGLJJLWWURPIRUNUHDWLYLWHW-HJHUWDNNQHPOLJIRUGHQWLOOLWHQMHJHUEOLWW YLVW
-HJYLOWDNNHO UHUQHRJHOHYHQHVRPKDUGHOWDWWLVWXGLHQ'HWnODHQXWHQIRUVWnHQGHREVHUYHUH LVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJHQW\GHUSnWU\JJKHWRJIDJOLJHQJDVMHPHQW'HUHVELGUDJKDUY UW DYJM¡UHQGHIRUJMHQQRPI¡ULQJHQDYIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHW
0LQHWRYHLOHGHUHYHG,QVWLWXWWIRUVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLNNSURIHVVRU6YHQ1LOVHQRJSURIHVVRU (GYDUG%HIULQJKDUY UWYLNWLJHVW¡WWHVSLOOHUHLDUEHLGHWPHGDYKDQGOLQJHQ'HKDUVWLOW VS¡UVPnOVRPKDUVNDSWUHIOHNVMRQRJYLGHUHIUDPGULIW,WLOOHJJKDUGHELGUDWWPHGJRGHUnGRJ RSSPXQWULQJ-HJYLORJVnWDNNHDQGUHDQVDWWHYHG,QVWLWXWWIRUVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLNNRJ'HW XWGDQQLQJVYLWHQVNDSOLJHIDNXOWHWIRUQ\WWLJHLQQVSLOO
(QVWRUWDNNWLO.ULVWLQIRURPVRUJVW¡WWHRJIDJOLJHUnG-HJYLORJVnWDNNH¡YULJIDPLOLHRJ YHQQHUIRULQWHUHVVDQWHGLVNXVMRQHURJYHUGLIXOOHNRPPHQWDUHULWLONQ\WQLQJWLODUEHLGHW
%OLQGHUQGHVHPEHU
*HLU1\ERUJ
6DPPHQGU DJ
+RYHGWHPDHWIRUIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWHUnEHO\VHLQWHUDNVMRQPHOORPO UHUHRJHOHYHUL VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJVHWWLO\VDYNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJ%HJUHSHWPHGLHUW
XQGHUYLVQLQJE\JJHUSnHQVRVLDONRJQLWLYO ULQJVWHRUL RJGHILQHUHVVRPHQRSSO ULQJVSURVHVV KYRUHQO UHULLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHQHOHYELGUDUWLOnVWLPXOHUHHOHYHQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ 0HWRGLVNWLOQ UPLQJVRPEHQ\WWHVHULKRYHGVDNREVHUYDVMRQRJDQDO\VHYHGKMHOSDYYLGHR
'HWEOHI¡UVWJMHQQRPI¡UWHQNYDOLWDWLYXQGHUV¡NHOVHKYRUKHQVLNWHQYDUnXWYLNOHHW DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQW,QVWUXPHQWHWEHVWnUDYGHVHNVNULWHULHQHIRNXVHULQJHPRVMRQV\WULQJ XWYLGHOVHNRPSHWDQVHDWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJRJDQQHW'HWEOHXWDUEHLGHWWLOVDPPHQV\WWHQ RSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHUIRUNULWHULHQH'HUHWWHUEOHGHWJMHQQRPI¡UWHQNYDQWLWDWLYXQGHUV¡NHOVH KYRUXWYDOJHWEHVWRDYILUHFDVHPHGO UHU RJHOHYG\DGHU$QDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWEOHEHQ\WWHW IRUnDQDO\VHUHYLGHRRSSWDNDYILUHLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUIRUKYHUWFDVH$QDO\VHQHDY GDWDHQHNDQEHWHJQHVVRPQLYnGHOW'HWEOHIRUHWDWWDQDO\VHEnGHDYKYHUDYHQNHOWVHNYHQVHQH RJSnWYHUVDYVHNYHQVHQHWLOKYHUWFDVH1RUPHQEHQ\WWHWIRUnYXUGHUH
XQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWHQLHQNHOWVHNYHQVHQHYDUSURVHQWYLVIRUGHOLQJHQDYNULWHULHQHVHWWLO\V DYXQGHUYLVQLQJHQVLQQKROGRJHOHYHQVIXQJHULQJ'HWEOHIRUGHWPHVWHIXQQHWDWDQYHQGHOVHQ DYNULWHULHQHYDUJXQVWLJLHQNHOWVHNYHQVHQHLO\VDYGHWRNRQWHNVWXHOOHIDNWRUHQH1RUPHQ IRUnYXUGHUHNYDOLWHWHQSnWYHUVDYVHNYHQVHQHWLOKYHUWFDVHYDUXWHOXNNHQGHSURVHQWYLV IRUGHOLQJDYNULWHULHQH6W¡UVWPXOLJJUDGDYVSUHGQLQJEOHDQVHWWIRUnY UHJXQVWLJ'HWEOH KHUDYGHNNHWDWGHWIRUDOOHFDVHQHLOLWHQJUDGYDUVSUHGQLQJLEUXNHQDYNULWHULHQH
3nJUXQQODJDYIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWV WRXQGHUV¡NHOVHUHUGHWWUXNNHWHQ NRQNOXVMRQRPDW NYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJYDUODYLDOOHGHILUHFDVHQH'HWHNVLVWHUWHGHUPHGLOLWHQ JUDGIRUVNMHOOHULNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJLLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUPHOORPO UHURJ HOHYG\DGHUVRP GHOWRNLVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ
)RUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWEOHJMHQQRPI¡UWLSHULRGHQYHG'HWXWGDQQLQJVYLWHQVNDSOLJH IDNXOWHWHW,QVWLWXWWIRUVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLNN8QLYHUVLWHWHWL2VOR
,QQKROGVIRU WHJQHOVH
)RURUG 6DPPHQGUDJ
$YKDQGOLQJHQVGLVSRVLVMRQ
'HO,QWURGXNVMRQRJWHRUHWLVNUHIHUDQVHU DPPH
,QWURGXNVMRQ ,QQOHGQLQJ +RYHGIHQRPHQ )RUPnO 3UREOHPVWLOOLQJHU 7HRUHWLVNUHIHUDQVHUDPPH )HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRUL .RJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHW 0HGLHUWO ULQJ )HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULRJNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS .MHQQHWHJQYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS .RJQLWLYHIXQNVMRQHURJPHGLHUWO ULQJ 2SSVXPPHULQJDY)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULRJNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS ,QWHUYHQVMRQHURJIRUVNQLQJEDVHUWSn)HXHUVWHLQVWHRUL ,QWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW0,6&
$QDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20, )RUVNQLQJEDVHUWSn)HXHUVWHLQVWHRUL 8WG\SLQJDYNULWHULHQHLPHGLHUWO ULQJ )RNXVHULQJ (PRVMRQV\WULQJ 8WYLGHOVH .RPSHWDQVH
$WIHUGVUHJXOHULQJ .ULWLVNYXUGHULQJDY)HXHUVWHLQVWHRUL 7HRULHQWDUXWJDQJVSXQNWLWRIRUVNMHOOLJHDQDO\VHQLYn .DQWHRULHQKDJ\OGLJKHWLVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ"
5HGHJM¡UHOVHIRUVHQWUDOHEHJUHSHU )RNXVSnPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJLVWHGHQIRUPHGLHUWO ULQJ .YDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJ / UHU RJHOHYG\DGH ,QWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQV 6SHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ
$QYHQGHOVHDYGHQWHRUHWLVNHUHIHUDQVHUDPPHQ
'HO0HWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHURJLQVWUXPHQWXWYLNOLQJ
0HWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHU (QFDVHVWXGLH .ULWHULHUIRUXWYDOJDYFDVH / UHUQHRJHOHYHQH 6SHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJHQVRUJDQLVHULQJ 8QGHUYLVQLQJVLQQKROGHWLLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH
$VSHNWHUYHGREVHUYDVMRQVRPIRUVNQLQJVPHWRGH 9LWHQVNDSVWHRUHWLVNHV\QSnEUXNDYWHRULLSHGDJRJLVNREVHUYDVMRQVIRUVNQLQJ )RUGHOHURJEHJUHQVQLQJHUYHGEUXNDYYLGHRRSSWDN (UIDULQJHUIUDIRUSU¡YHQ 5HNUXWWHULQJDYGHOWDNHUHRJEHVNULYHOVHDYFDVHQH +HQVLNWVPHVVLJHREVHUYDVMRQVSURVHG\UHU 3ULRULWHULQJDYWLGVOHQJGHURJVWUDWHJLHU .YDOLWDWLYRJNYDQWLWDWLYPHWRGHLIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHW 0HWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHUYHGGHOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ 8WDUEHLGLQJDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHU 'HILQLVMRQHUDYNULWHULHQHLPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJ 9XUGHULQJDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHLDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20, 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHUYHGHQDEGXNWLYWLOQ UPLQJ 'DWDPDWHULDOHWWLOXWDUEHLGLQJDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQH 2EVHUYDVMRQVGDWDHQHIUDGHOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ 8WYHOJLQJDYWLGVSHULRGHUIUDFDVH 8WYHOJLQJDYWLGVSHULRGHUIUDFDVH 7UDQVNULSVMRQDYREVHUYDVMRQVGDWDHQH )RUGHOHUPHGWUDQVNULSVMRQ 8WIRUGULQJHUYHGWUDQVNULSVMRQDYWDOHVSUnN 8WIRUGULQJHUYHGWUDQVNULSVMRQDYQRQYHUEDODWIHUG 2YHUVLNWRYHUWUDQVNULSVMRQVQ¡NOHU
$QDO\WLVNWLOQ UPLQJIRUXWYLNOLQJDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQH 2SSVXPPHULQJDYJUXQQODJHWIRUXWYLNOLQJHQDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQH .RPELQDVMRQDYIRUWRONQLQJVDQDO\VHRJUHIOHNWHUHQGHDQDO\VH 8WDUEHLGLQJDYDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW )UDPJDQJVPnWHIRURSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQH 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHLDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHIRUNULWHULHWIRNXVHULQJ 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHIRUNULWHULHWHPRVMRQV\WULQJ 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHIRUNULWHULHWXWYLGHOVH 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHIRUNULWHULHWNRPSHWDQVH 2SHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHIRUNULWHULHWDWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJ .ULWHULHWDQQHW 6NMHPDWLVNIUDPVWLOOLQJDYDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW +HQV\QWLOEHJUHSVYDOLGLWHWRJUHOLDELOLWHWXQGHUXWDUEHLGLQJHQ
0HWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHULKRYHGXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ 8WG\SLQJDYXWYDOJVNULWHULHULWLONQ\WQLQJWLOKRYHGXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ 8WYDOJVNULWHULHULIRUELQGHOVHPHGFDVH
$QWDOOLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUIRUKYHUWFDVH 8WYDOJVNULWHULHULIRUELQGHOVHPHGVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJVWLPHU 8WYDOJVNULWHULHULIRUELQGHOVHPHGYLGHRRSSWDNHQH 6DPWDOHUPHGO UHUQH 3URVHG\UHUIRUDQDO\VHDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH 8WDUEHLGLQJDYWUDQVNULSVMRQHUDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH 3UDNWLVNDQYHQGHOVHDYDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWLVNnULQJVDUEHLGHW 8WIRUGULQJHUNQ\WWHWWLOVNnULQJDYO UHU\WULQJHQH 9XUGHULQJHUDYREVHUYDVMRQVUHOLDELOLWHW (NVHPSOHUSnDNWXHOOHWLOIHOGLJHIHLONLOGHU ,QWUDREVHUYDW¡UVDPVYDU ,QWHUREVHUYDW¡UVDPVYDU 2SSVXPPHULQJDYREVHUYDVMRQVUHOLDELOLWHW
'HO$QDO\VHNRQNOXVMRQGU¡IWLQJRJLPSOLNDVMRQHU
$QDO\VHDYFDVHQHVXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHW
&DVHUDSSRUW ,QIRUPDVMRQIUDVDPWDOHPHGO UHU 8WYHOJLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUIUDYLGHRRSSWDNHQH
$QDO\VHDYKYHUHQNHOWLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQV
$QDO\VHSnWYHUVDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH 6DPPHQKROGLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQHRJLQIRUPDVMRQIUDO UHUHQ
&DVHUDSSRUW ,QIRUPDVMRQIUDVDPWDOHPHGO UHU 8WYHOJLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUIUDYLGHRRSSWDNHQH
$QDO\VHDYKYHUHQNHOWLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQV
$QDO\VHSnWYHUVDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH 6DPPHQKROGLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQHRJLQIRUPDVMRQIUDO UHUHQ
&DVHUDSSRUW ,QIRUPDVMRQIUDVDPWDOHPHGO UHU 8WYHOJLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUIUDYLGHRRSSWDNHQH
$QDO\VHDYKYHUHQNHOWLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQV
$QDO\VHSnWYHUVDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH 6DPPHQKROGLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQHRJLQIRUPDVMRQIUDO UHUHQ
&DVHUDSSRUW ,QIRUPDVMRQIUDVDPWDOHPHGO UHU 8WYHOJLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUIUDYLGHRRSSWDNHQH
$QDO\VHDYKYHUHQNHOWLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQV
$QDO\VHSnWYHUVDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQH 6DPPHQKROGLQJDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHQHRJLQIRUPDVMRQIUDO UHUHQ
$QYHQGHOVHDYEHJUHSHWXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWLDQDO\VHQ 6XPPHQDYDQWDOOHWVNnULQJHU 6NnULQJHQHVIRUGHOLQJSnNULWHULHQH 6DPPHQOLJQLQJDYXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWHQPHOORP FDVHQH
%HJUHSHWXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWYHGVDPPHQOLJQLQJ
)RUVNMHOOHULXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWPHOORPFDVHQH 'LVNXVMRQDYXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWHQLO\VDYO UHULQIRUPDVMRQ .MHQQHWHJQYHGO UHUQHVXQGHUYLVQLQJLO\VDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJ .RQNOXVMRQGU¡IWLQJRJLPSOLNDVMRQHU 2SSVXPPHULQJRJNRQNOXVMRQ 9DOLGLWHW
%HJUHSVYDOLGLWHW ,QGUHYDOLGLWHW 5HOLDELOLWHW
<WUHYDOLGLWHW 2SSVXPPHULQJDYYDOLGLWHW )RUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVRPWHRULXWYLNOLQJ
*UXQQODJIRUYXUGHULQJDYDUEHLGHWVRPWHRULXWYLNOLQJ
$UEHLGHWVELGUDJWLOWHRULXWYLNOLQJ
$UEHLGHWVHWWLO\VDYDQQHQIRUVNQLQJ )RUVNQLQJEDVHUWSnHQOLJQHQGHWHRUHWLVNUHIHUDQVHUDPPH 3HUVSHNWLYSnDUEHLGHWVELGUDJWLOIRUVNQLQJSnVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ ,PSOLNDVMRQHUDYIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHW ,PSOLNDVMRQHUIRUYLGHUHIRUVNQLQJ ,PSOLNDVMRQHUIRUSUDNVLVLVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ 7DEHOOLVWH /LWWHUDWXUOLVWH 9HGOHJJVOLVWH
$YKDQGOLQJHQVGLVSRVLVMRQ
$YKDQGOLQJHQHUE\JJHWRSSLWUHGHOHU
'HO,QWURGXNVMRQRJWHRUHWLVNUHIHUDQVHU DPPH
'HOKDUWRNDSLWOHU'HWI¡UVWHHULQWURGXNVMRQVNDSLWOHWKYRUIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVIRUPnORJ SUREOHPVWLOOLQJHUSUHVHQWHUHV$YKDQGOLQJHQLQQHKROGHUHQGHOSUREOHPVWLOOLQJRJHQ KRYHGSUREOHPVWLOOLQJVRPVHVLVDPPHQKHQJ$UEHLGHWPHGGHOSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQXWJM¡UHQ Q¡GYHQGLJIRUXWVHWQLQJIRUnEHVYDUHKRYHGSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQ,GHWDQGUHNDSLWOHWXWG\SHV DUEHLGHWVWHRUHWLVNHUHIHUDQVHUDPPHRJVRPOHGGLGHWWH EHO\VHVVHQWUDOHEHJUHSHUL SUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQH
'HO0HWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHURJLQVWUXPHQWXWYLNOLQJ
'HOEHVWnUDY ILUHNDSLWOHU)RUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWLQQHKROGHUWRXQGHUV¡NHOVHU'HQHQH EHWHJQHVVRPGHOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQPHQVGHQDQGUHRPWDOHVVRPKRYHGXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ,NDSLWWHO WUHUHGHJM¡UHVGHWIRUPHWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHUVRPHUIHOOHVIRUEHJJHXQGHUV¡NHOVHQH 'HOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQJMHQQRPI¡UHVLIRUELQGHOVHPHGDUEHLGHWVGHOSUREOHPVWLOOLQJ.DSLWWHOILUH WDUIRUVHJPHWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHUVRPEHQ\WWHVLWLONQ\WQLQJWLOGHOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ
'HOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQEHVWnUDYXWYLNOLQJHQDYHWDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWVRPVHQHUHEHQ\WWHVIRUn DQDO\VHUHDUEHLGHWVKRYHGSUREOHPVWLOOLQJ,NDSLWWHOIHPUHGHJM¡UHVGHWIRUXWYLNOLQJHQDY DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW,NDSLWWHOVHNVEHO\VHVPHWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHUVRPDQYHQGHVXQGHU KRYHGXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ
'HO$QDO\VHNRQNOXVMRQGU¡IWLQJRJLPSOLNDVMRQHU
'HOLQQHKROGHUWRNDSLWOHU,NDSLWWHOV\YDQDO\VHUHVNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJVRP SUDNWLVHUHVLKRYHGXQGHUV¡NHOVHQVILUHFDVHYHGKMHOSDYGHWXWYLNOHGHDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW 3nGHQQHPnWHQEHVYDUHVIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVKRYHGSUREOHPVWLOOLQJ'HWnWWHQGHNDSLWOHW EHVWnUDYNRQNOXVMRQGU¡IWLQJRJLPSOLNDVMRQHU
'HO,QWURGXNVMRQRJ WHRUHWLVN UHIHUDQVHUDPPH
,QWURGXNVMRQ
,GHWWHNDSLWOHWSUHVHQWHUHVIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVKRYHGIHQRPHQIRUPnORJSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHU
,QQOHGQLQJ
0\HDYDNWLYLWHWHQLVNROHQHUUHWWHWPRWnRSSQnHWKRYHGPnORPEHVWPXOLJO ULQJRJ XWYLNOLQJIRUGHQHQNHOWHHOHY/ UHUHQHUHQQ¡NNHOSHUVRQLVNROHQVYLUNVRPKHW/ UHUHQV YLNWLJVWHDQVYDUVRPUnGHHUXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ1nUO UHUHQVNDOSODQOHJJHnJMHQQRPI¡UH XQGHUYLVQLQJKDUKDQIOHUHIRUKROGGHWNDQWDVKHQV\QWLO(NVHPSHOKHUNDQY UHHOHYHQHV HYQHURJIRUXWVHWQLQJHUHOHYHQHVPRWLYDVMRQHPQHWGHWVNDOXQGHUYLVHVLDNWXHOWO UHVWRII PHWRGHRJPDWHULDOHRUJDQLVHULQJVIRUPHUNRPPXQLNDVMRQRVY
,XOLNHPLOM¡HUHNVLVWHUHUGHWIRUVNMHOOLJHPHQLQJHUNQ\WWHWWLOKYLONHIDNWRUHUO UHUHQE¡U YHNWOHJJHLSODQOHJJLQJRJJMHQQRPI¡ULQJDYXQGHUYLVQLQJPHGWDQNHSnHOHYHUV O ULQJVXWE\WWH6OLNHPHQLQJHUJMHQVSHLOHVEODQWDQQHWL SHGDJRJLVNHWHRULHU IRUVNQLQJVSURVMHNWHURJSROLWLVNHGHEDWWHU
)RUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWLGHQQHDYKDQGOLQJHQEHO\VHUHWDYJUHQVHWIHQRPHQNQ\WWHWWLO
XQGHUYLVQLQJVSURVHVVHQ6DPWLGLJHUGHWHUYLNWLJnInIUDPDWIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWE\JJHUSnHQ JUXQQOHJJHQGHDQWDJHOVHRPDWXQGHUYLVQLQJHUHQVDPPHQVDWWRJNRPSOLVHUWYLUNVRPKHW KYRUGHWHUVDQQV\QOLJDWIOHUHIDNWRUHULYDULHUHQGHJUDGYLONXQQHKDEHW\GQLQJIRUHQHOHYV O ULQJVXWE\WWH
+RYHGIHQRPHQ
'HWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWE\JJHUSnHQWHRUHWLVNUDPPHVRPHUXWYLNOHWDYGHQLVUDHOVNH IRUVNHUHQRJIRUIDWWHUHQ5HXYHQ)HXHUVWHLQ)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG )HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQHWDO)HXHUVWHLQHWDO(WNMHUQHEHJUHSLGHQQHWHRULHQHU
PHGLHUWO ULQJ0HGLHUWO ULQJNDQEHWHJQHVVRPHQSURVVHVKYRUHQYRNVHQLHQLQWHUDNVMRQ PHGHWEDUQJMHQQRP EUXNDYYLVVHNULWHULHUELGUDUWLOnVWLPXOHUHEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ
3QLQD.OHLQHQDQQHQLVUDHOVNIRUVNHUKDUEHQ\WWHWWHRULHQRPPHGLHUWO ULQJVRP
XWJDQJVSXQNWIRUIRUVNQLQJSnLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORPP¡GUHRJ\QJUHEDUQ.OHLQ )RUnEHO\VHNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUPHOORPP¡GUHRJEDUQ DQYHQGHU.OHLQLVLQHVWXGLHUHQIRUPIRUVWUXNWXUHUWREVHUYDVMRQKYRUKXQEUXNHUYLGHRRSSWDN WLOGDWDLQQVDPOLQJRJDQDO\VH+XQKDULGHQIRUELQGHOVHXWDUEHLGHWREVHUYDVMRQRJ
DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20,2EVHUYLQJ0HGLDWLRQDO,QWHUDFWLRQ20,LQQHKROGHUGHILQLVMRQHU DYIHPNULWHULHU'LVVHHUIRNXVHULQJHPRVMRQV\WULQJXWYLGHOVHNRPSHWDQVHRJ
DWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJ,WLOOHJJEHVWnU20,DYXWDUEHLGHGHRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHUIRUKYHUWDYGH IHPNULWHULHQH$QDO\VHDYYLGHRRSSWDNYHGKMHOSDY20,LQQHE UHUUHJLVWUHULQJDY DQWDOO JDQJHUGHQYRNVQHVDWIHUGIDOOHULQQHQIRURSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHRJGHUPHGNULWHULHQHIRU PHGLHUWO ULQJLO¡SHWDYHQGHILQHUWWLGVSHULRGH$WIHUGHQWLOPRURJEDUQVHVLUHODVMRQ'HW EHW\UDWPRUVDWIHUGNXQEOLUUHJLVWUHUWGHUVRPEDUQHWUHVSRQGHUHUSnPRUVDWIHUG9HGn VXPPHUHRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHIRUKYHUWDYNULWHULHQHNRPPHUIRUVNHUHQIUDPWLOPnOIRU NYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUPHOORPP¡GUHRJEDUQ.OHLQRJ$ORQ\
.OHLQ:LHGHU *UHHQVSDQ )HXHUVWHLQVLQWHRULRJ.OHLQVLQDQYHQGHOVHDY GHQQHWHRULHQXWJM¡UGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVWHRUHWLVNHIXQGDPHQW
,GHQQHVWXGLHQHUEHJUHSHWPHGLHUWO ULQJHUVWDWWHWPHGPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJIRUGL KRYHGIRNXVHWHUUHWWHWPRWO UHUHQVXQGHUYLVQLQJVHDYVQLWW0HGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJ GHILQHUHVVRP HQRSSO ULQJVSURVHVVKYRUHQO UHULLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHQHOHYELGUDUWLOn VWLPXOHUHHOHYHQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ%DNJUXQQHQIRUVWLPXOHULQJHQDYHOHYHQVNRJQLWLYH XWYLNOLQJHUDWLQWHUDNVMRQHQLQQHKROGHUYLVVHNMHQQHWHJQHOOHUNULWHULHUVRPELGUDUWLOHQVOLN SURVHVV$QWDJHOVHQRPDWGHQQHGHILQLVMRQHQDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJKDUJ\OGLJKHWNQ\WWHW WLOVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJJM¡UDWPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJEOLUDQVHWWIRUnY UHHWUHOHYDQWIHQRPHQ VRPXWJDQJSXQNWIRUHWVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLVNIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLG
)RU PnO
7HRULHQRPPHGLHUWO ULQJKDUY UWJUXQQODJIRUIOHUHVWXGLHU6KDPLU 7]XULHO
&KLVZDQGD.OHLQ $ORQ\.OHLQ .OHLQ:LHGHU *UHHQVSDQ 7HRULHQV\QHVLPLGOHUWLGLOLWHQJUDGnKDEOLWWDQYHQGWWLOIRUVNQLQJSnLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORP
O UHUHRJHOHYHULVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ'HQQHVWXGLHQKDUWRIRUPnO'HWHQHHUnXWYLGH WHRULHQVLWWDQYHQGHOVHVRPUnGHNQ\WWHWWLOVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLVNIRUVNQLQJ(WVOLNWIRUPnONDQ RPWDOHVVRPWHRULXWYLNOLQJ'HWDQGUHIRUPnOHWHU nYLQQH¡NWLQQVLNWLSUDNWLVN
VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJVYLUNVRPKHWVRPIRUHJnULVNROHQ
3U REOHPVWLOOLQJHU
3nEDNJUXQQ DYWHRULHQIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWE\JJHUSnRJVWXGLHQVIRUPnOEOLUGHWLGHWWH IRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWV¡NWnEHO\VHI¡OJHQGHWRSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHU
• 3nKYLONHPnWHUNRPPHUPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJWLOXWWU\NNLLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHU PHOORPO UHURJHOHYG\DGHUVRPGHOWDULVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ"
• ,KYLONHQJUDGHNVLVWHUHUGHWIRUVNMHOOHULNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJL
LQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUPHOORPO UHURJHOHYG\DGHUVRPGHOWDULVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ"
,WUnGPHG.OHLQVLQHVWXGLHUEOLUREVHUYDVMRQYHGKMHOSDYYLGHRRSSWDNEHQ\WWHWWLO
GDWDLQQVDPOLQJRJDQDO\VH,WLOOHJJEOLUGHIHPNULWHULHQHIRUPHGLHUWO ULQJVRPDQYHQGHVL 20,EHQ\WWHWVRPXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUnXWDUEHLGHHWHJHWDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWVRPNDQ EUXNHVL GHQQHVWXGLHQ+HQVLNWHQPHGIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVI¡UVWHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHUnXWDUEHLGH DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWVRPVHQHUHNDQEHQ\WWHVIRUnEHO\VHVWXGLHQVDQGUHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJ'HW NDQKHYGHVDWGHQI¡UVWHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQGHUPHGXWJM¡UHQQ¡GYHQGLJIRUXWVHWQLQJRJHW YLNWLJVWHJSnYHLHQPRWnEHVYDUHGHQDQGUHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQ6DPWLGLJNDQGHQDQGUH SUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQEHWHJQHVVRPRYHURUGQHWVLGHQGHWHUGHQQHVRPGDQQHUJUXQQODJIRUnIn IUDPLQIRUPDVMRQRPNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJVRPEOLUSUDNWLVHUWLNRQNUHWH VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJVVLWXDVMRQHU$YGHQJUXQQEOLUGHQI¡UVWHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQL
DYKDQGOLQJHQRPWDOWVRPGHOSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQPHQVGHQDQGUHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQEHWHJQHV VRPKRYHGSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQ
,IRUELQGHOVHPHGGHOSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQHUGHWEOLWWJMHQQRPI¡UWHQHJHQXQGHUV¡NHOVH'HQQH XQGHUV¡NHOVHQEOLULDYKDQGOLQJHQRPWDOWVRPGHOXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ,WLONQ\WQLQJWLO
KRYHGSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQHUGHWRJVnEOLWWJMHQQRPI¡UWHQXQGHUV¡NHOVH'HQQHEOLUL IRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWEHWHJQHWVRPKRYHGXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ
7HRUHWLVNUHIHU DQVHU DPPH
,GHWWHNDSLWOHWJM¡UHVGHWUHGHIRUIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWV WHRUHWLVNHUHIHUDQVHUDPPH)OHUH DVSHNWHUYHG)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULEOLUSUHVHQWHUW RJGLVNXWHUW,WLOOHJJEHO\VHV IRUVWnHOVHQVRPOHJJHVWLOJUXQQIRUVHQWUDOHEHJUHSHULSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQH
)HXHU VWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRU L
,GHWWHDYVQLWWHWJM¡UHVGHWUHGHIRU5HXYHQ)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULRPNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJRJO ULQJ, GHWPHVWHDYVLQIRUVNQLQJRJIRUIDWWHUVNDS UHWWHU )HXHUVWHLQIRNXVPRWEDUQRJYRNVQHPHG VSHVLHOOHEHKRY)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ)HXHUVWHLQ HWDO )HXHUVWHLQHWDO3HUVRQHUPHGVSHVLHOOHEHKRYNDQLGHQQHVDPPHQKHQJHQ IRUVWnVVRPLQGLYLGHUVRPSnEDNJUXQQDYJHQHWLVNHRUJDQLVNHHOOHUSV\NRORJLVNHYDQVNHU VWUHYHUPHGnPHVWUHDUEHLGVRSSJDYHUNUDYRJIRUYHQWQLQJHUEnGHSnVNROHQRJLIULWLGHQIRU NDVXVEHVNULYHOVHUVH)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG'HWnEHO\VHGLVVHSHUVRQHQHVSUREOHPDWLNN NQ\WWHWWLOXWYLNOLQJRJO ULQJV\QHVnY UHHWKRYHGPnOIRUIRUVNHUHQ7HRULHQWLO)HXHUVWHLQ NDQIUDPVWnVRPWRGHOWKYRUEHWHJQHOVHQHNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWVWUXNWXUDOFRJQLWLYH PRGLILDELOLW\RJPHGLHUWO ULQJPHGLDWHGOHDUQLQJH[SHULHQFHPDUNHUHUWRGHOLQJHQLWHRULHQ )UDPVWLOOLQJHQQHGHQIRUWDUXWJDQJVSXQNWLGLVVHEHWHJQHOVHQH
.RJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHW
*MHQQRPEHWHJQHOVHQNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWV¡NHU)HXHUVWHLQnIRUNODUHRJEHVNULYH DVSHNWHUYHGEDUQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ)HXHUVWHLQVHUIRUVHJDWPHQQHVNHVLQQHWEHVWnUDY IOHUHNRJQLWLYHIXQNVMRQHUHOOHUSV\NRORJLVNHVWUXNWXUHU(NVHPSHOSnVOLNHVWUXNWXUHUNDQ Y UHKXNRPPHOVHRJSHUVHSVMRQ(QSV\NRORJLVNVWUXNWXUKDUIOHUHNMHQQHWHJQ)RUGHWI¡UVWH NDQ GHQ VHVSnVRPHWV\VWHPEHVWnHQGHDYIOHUHNRPSRQHQWHUVRPHUNQ\WWHWWLOKYHUDQGUHRJ VRPSnYLUNHVJMHQVLGLJ'HWLQQHE UHUDWHQGULQJHULHQHOOHUIOHUHNRPSRQHQWHULNNHEDUH SnYLUNHUGHVRPHUGLUHNWHLQYROYHUWPHQRJVnDOOHDQGUHNRPSRQHQWHULVWUXNWXUHQ)RU HNVHPSHOYLOKXNRPPHOVHNXQQHLQQHKROGHRJODVHJSnYLUNHDYSHUVHSWXHOOHNRPSRQHQWHU VRPIRNXVHULQJLQWHOOHNWXHOOHNRPSRQHQWHUVRPnIRUVWnHWLQQKROGPRWLYDVMRQHOOH NRPSRQHQWHUVRPLQWHUHVVHIRUDWLQQKROGHWVNDOKXVNHVRJDQGUH)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG
)RUGHWDQGUHHUHQSV\NRORJLVNVWUXNWXUNMHQQHWHJQHWYHGPXOLJKHWHUIRURYHUI¡ULQJ 2YHUI¡ULQJRPKDQGOHULGHQQHVDPPHQKHQJHQWHQGHQVHUHQVWUXNWXUKDUWLOnHQGUHPnWHQn IXQJHUHSn6OLNHHQGULQJHUNDQREVHUYHUHVKRVHWEDUQLDNWLYLWHW)RUHNVHPSHOYLO HQ RSSJDYHVRPWLGOLJHUHNUHYGHP\HWLGnJMHQQRPI¡UHIRUEDUQHWNXQQHVNMHKXUWLJHUHRJPHU SUHVLVWYHGKMHOSDYHQGULQJHULHQSV\NRORJLVNVWUXNWXU)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG
(WWUHGMHNMHQQHWHJQHUVWUXNWXUHQVVHOYRSSKROGHQGHRJVHOYUHJXOHUHQGHHYQH'HWWHNRPPHU WLOXWWU\NNJMHQQRPHQVWUXNWXUVJMHQWDWWHDQYHQGHOVHQnUHWEDUQDQVHUDWDNWLYHULQJHUQ\WWLJ PHGWDQNHSnnO¡VHHWJLWWSUREOHPHOOHUPHVWUHHQVLWXDVMRQ)HXHUVWHLQRSSJLUHYQHQWLO SUHVLVMRQVRPHNVHPSHOSnHQSV\NRORJLVNVWUXNWXU(WEDUQVRPKDULQWHJUHUWSUHVLVMRQVRP HQGHODYVLQNRJQLWLYHIXQNVMRQYLONXQQHRSSWUHSUHVLVWRJQ¡\DNWLJLIRUKROGWLOHQDNWLYLWHW
%DUQHWYLONXQQHPHVWUHnLQQKHQWHUHOHYDQWHGDWDUHJLVWUHUHRJV\VWHPDWLVHUHGDWDHQHRJ GHUHWWHU NXQQHNRPPXQLVHUHGHQWLOHJQHGHLQIRUPDVMRQHQWLODQGUHPHGQ¡\DNWLJKHW'HQ VHOYUHJXOHUHQGHGHOHQDYHQSV\NRORJLVNVWUXNWXURPKDQGOHUPHQJGHQHQHUJLVRPEHK¡YHVIRU DNWLYHULQJ,IRUELQGHOVHPHGSUHVLVMRQPnEDUQHWVDQQV\QOLJYLVEHQ\WWHP\HHQHUJLIRUn VDPOHGDWDVRPEHK¡YHVIRUnO¡VHHQRSSJDYHI¡UGHQQHVWUXNWXUHQHUWLOVWUHNNHOLJ
VHOYUHJXOHUW0HQHWWHUDWSURVHVVHQKDUEOLWWJMHQWDWWIOHUHJDQJHUYLOEDUQHWVNM¡QQHKYRUGDQ DNWLYHULQJDYSUHVLVMRQLHQDNWLYLWHWEOLUHQNOHUH7LOVLVWYLOEDUQHWNXQQHQnHWQLYnKYRU XWI¡UHOVHQYLOY UHNDUDNWHULVHUWDYK¡\JUDGDYSUHVLVMRQRJODYEUXNDYHQHUJL)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG
%DUQPHGVSHVLHOOHEHKRYHURIWHJMHQVWDQGIRUDQDO\VHURJYXUGHULQJHUKYRUGHWEOLUWUXNNHW NRQNOXVMRQHURP KYDVODJVXWYLNOLQJVRPNDQIRUYHQWHVLQQHQIRUXOLNHIXQNVMRQVRPUnGHU .RQNOXVMRQHQHEOLUJMHUQHIDVWVOnWWSnEDNJUXQQDYIRUVNMHOOLJHIXQNVMRQVEHVNULYHOVHURJ EDUQDVSUHVWDVMRQHUSnXOLNHWHVWHU(WVHQWUDOWSRHQJIRU)HXHUVWHLQV\QHVnY UHDW SUHGLNVMRQHUDQJnHQGHHWEDUQVIUDPWLGLJHNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJHUSUREOHPDWLVNIRUGLGHWHU XPXOLJnIRUXWVHKYRUGDQEDUQHWVSV\NRORJLVNHVWUXNWXUHUYLOIRUDQGUHVQnUEDUQHWWDUGHOL JXQVWLJHVWLPXOHULQJHU)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ)HXHUVWHLQHWDO
%DUQVRPWDUGHOLJXQVWLJHVWLPXOHULQJHU RSSQnUGHW)HXHUVWHLQRPWDOHUVRPPRGLILVHUEDUKHW 0RGLILVHUEDUKHWYLOVL HQGULQJHUKYRUEDUQHWRSSQnUYHVHQWOLJHRJYDULJHIRUEHGULQJHUNQ\WWHW WLONRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJVRPVNLOOHUVHJLIUDGHWVRPEOLUDQWDWWIRUnY UHIRUYHQWHWXWYLNOLQJ )HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG.R]XOLQGHILQHUHUPRGLILVHUEDUKHWSnI¡OJHQGHPnWH
0RGLILDELOLW\LVGHILQHGDVDVWUXFWXUDOPRGLILFDWLRQLQWKHFRJQLWLYHIXQFWLRQLQJ
RIWKHLQGLYLGXDOGHSDUWLQJIURPWKHH[SHFWHGGHYHORSPHQWDOFRXUVH.R]XOLQ
.OHLQYLVHUWLODWPRGLILVHUEDUKHWRPKDQGOHUEDUQHWVHYQHWLOnIRUDQGUHVHJRJWLOn XWQ\WWHSULQVLSSHUIHUGLJKHWHURJVWUDWHJLHUVRP GHWKDUO UWWLGOLJHUH'HWWH IRUnWLOSDVVHVHJ Q\HVLWXDVMRQHU+XQ SHNHUSnDWPRGLILVHUEDUKHWNDQVDPPHQOLJQHVPHGHYQHQWLOnO UH KYRUGDQHQO UHU,PSOLVLWWLEHJUHSHWNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWOLJJHUPHGDQGUHRUGHQ IRUVWnHOVHDYDWPDQ DOOWLGPnY UHnSQHIRUDWHWEDUQ NDQRSSQnHQEHW\GHOLJRJ RYHUVNULGHQGHXWYLNOLQJVRPGHWLNNHHUPXOLJnIRUXWVL
%DUQHWVDOGHUEDNJUXQQIRUHYHQWXHOOHO UHYDQVNHURJDOYRUOLJKHWVJUDGDYYDQVNHUEOLURIWH IUDPVWLOWVRPXRYHUVWLJHOLJHEDUULHUHUPHGWDQNHSnnIUHPPHEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ )HXHUVWHLQDUJXPHQWHUHUIRUDWVOLNHEDUULHUHULNNHHUWLOKLQGHUIRUPRGLILVHUEDUKHW.RJQLWLY XWYLNOLQJNDQRSSQnVSnWURVVDYEHW\GHOLJHKLQGULQJHUKRVEDUQHWVHOYHOOHULEDUQHWV OLYVVLWXDVMRQ0RGLILVHUEDUKHWNDQLPLGOHUWLGLNNHRSSQnVDYHWEDUQSnHJHQKnQGPHQVWLOOHU EHW\GHOLJHNUDYWLOLQWHQVLYRJV\VWHPDWLVNLQWHUYHQVMRQIUDPLOM¡HW(QVOLNSURVHVVRPWDOHU )HXHUVWHLQVRPPHGLHUWO ULQJ)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG
0HGLHUWO ULQJ
,I¡OJH)HXHUVWHLQNDQEDUQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJVNMHJMHQQRP WRXOLNHSURVHVVHU'HQI¡UVWH RPWDOHVVRPO ULQJVRPI¡OJHDYGLUHNWHVDQVHHUIDULQJPHGVWLPXOL'HQQHW\SHQO ULQJVNMHU QnUEDUQWDULQQVWLPXOLIUDRPJLYHOVHQHXWHQDWHQYRNVHQIRUPLGOHULQQWU\NNHQH%DUQHW IRUKROGHUVHJGHUPHGWLORPYHUGHQHQSnHQGLUHNWHRJLNNHIRUPLGOHWPnWH%DUQHWPnGDVHOY VLOHXWYLNWLJRJXYLNWLJHVLGHUOHJJHPHQLQJLVDQVHHUIDULQJHQ RJVHHJQHVDPPHQKHQJHU PHOORPLQQWU\NNHQH,GHQQHSURVHVVHQYLOGHWY UHWLOIHOGLJKYRUGDQEDUQHWUHJLVWUHU RSSIDWWHURJWRONHURPYHUGHQHQ%DUQHNVSRQHUHVNRQWLQXHUOLJIRUVWLPXOLIUDRPJLYHOVHQH 6OLNVHWWYLOO ULQJVRPI¡OJHDYGLUHNWHVDQVHHUIDULQJDOOWLGXWJM¡UHKRYHGDQGHOHQDYHWEDUQV O ULQJVHUIDULQJRJGHUPHGKDEHW\GHOLJLQQYLUNQLQJSnHWEDUQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ
'HQDQGUHIRUPHQIRUNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJVNMHUJMHQQRPPHGLHUWO ULQJ0HGLHUWO ULQJ GHILQHUHVDY)HXHUVWHLQVRPHQNYDOLWHWYHGLQWHUDNVMRQHQPHOORPEDUQHWRJPLOM¡HW'HQQH NYDOLWHWHQVLNUHVDYHQSHUVRQVRPVWLOOHUVHJPHOORPEDUQHWRJGHQSRWHQVLHOOH
O ULQJVHUIDULQJHQ6OLNHSHUVRQHUNDQY UHIRUHOGUHO UHUHRJDQGUHSHUVRQHUVRPRSHUHUHU L
EDUQHWVQ UPLOM¡(QPHGLHUWO ULQJVVHNYHQVHUDNWLYRJLQWHQVMRQHOO3HUVRQHQYLOLNUDIWDY VLQHLQWHQVMRQHUHPRVMRQHOOHWLOVWDQGRJNXOWXUHOOHEDNJUXQQYHOJHXWRJRUJDQLVHUH RPJLYHOVHQH'HWVRPVNDOIRUPLGOHVIRUEHUHGHVWRONHVRJSUHVHQWHUHVSnHQPnWHVRPHU PHQLQJVIXOORJUHOHYDQWIRUEDUQHW)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQHWDO)HXHUVWHLQHWDO
)HXHUVWHLQDUJXPHQWHUHUIRUDWHWEDUQVRPKDUInWWWLOVWUHNNHOLJPHGHUIDULQJNQ\WWHWWLO PHGLHUWO ULQJYLOWLOHJQHVHJJRGHKDQGOLQJVP¡QVWUHRJKHQVLNWVPHVVLJHPnWHUnWLOQ UPH VHJRPYHUGHQHQSn%DUQHWYLOGHUPHGEOLPRGLILVHUWRJY UHLVWDQGWLOnXWQ\WWHSULQVLSSHU IHUGLJKHWHURJVWUDWHJLHUIRUnWLOSDVVHVHJQ\HVLWXDVMRQHURJIRUnWLOHJQHVHJQ\HHUIDULQJHU
%DUQHWYLOGHUPHGRSSQnHWJRGWSRWHQVLDO RJY UHUXVWHWWLO nNXQQHSURILWWHUHSnO ULQJVRP I¡OJHDYGLUHNWHVDQVHHUIDULQJ)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ)HXHUVWHLQHWDO'HWWH VNMHUYHGDWEDUQHWLQWHUQDOLVHUHUO ULQJVSULQVLSSHUNQ\WWHWWLOPHGLHUWO ULQJRJDQYHQGHUGHP VHOYVWHQGLJVHQHUH7]XULHO 7]XULHO +D\ZRRG
(QGHOEDUQKDUKDWWIRUInHUIDULQJHUPHGPHGLHUWO ULQJ'LVVHEDUQDNDQEHWHJQHVVRP NXOWXUHOWGHSULYHUW.XOWXUHOOGHSULYDVMRQYLVHUVHJYHGDWEDUQV\QHVnKDQHGVDWWHYQHWLOn WLOHJQHVHJNXQQVNDSHURJIHUGLJKHWHUJMHQQRPGLUHNWHVDQVHHUIDULQJ,HQVOLNVLWXDVMRQV\QHV IRUHNVHPSHOLNNHPDQJHOSnVWLPXOLLQ UPLOM¡HWnY UHDYJM¡UHQGH6HOYRPEDUQHWVPLOM¡HU SUHJHWDYOHNHUE¡NHURJVWLPXOHUHQGHJMHQVWDQGHUYLOEDUQHWVWUHYHPHGnQ\WWHJM¡UHVHJGHW VRPHUWLOJMHQJHOLJLPLOM¡HWPHGWDQNHSnO ULQJRJNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJ%DUQVRPHUNXOWXUHOW GHSULYHUW NDQYHGKMHOSDYLQWHUYHQVMRQHUWLOI¡UHVHUIDULQJHUPHGPHGLHUWO ULQJRJGHUPHG EOLPRGLILVHUW)HXHUVWHLQHWDO
)HXHUVWHLQIRUHWDUHWVNLOOHPHOORPIMHUQHRJQ UHIDNWRUHUQnUGHWJMHOGHUVWLPXOHULQJDY NRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJKRVEDUQ$UYPLOM¡IDPLOLHQVVRVLR¡NRQRPLVNHVLWXDVMRQRJHPRVMRQHOO IXQJHULQJEnGHKRVEDUQRJIRUHVDWWHRPWDOHVVRPHNVHPSOHUSnIMHUQHIDNWRUHU'HIMHUQH IDNWRUHQHYLOLNNHQ¡GYHQGLJYLVI¡UHWLO UHGXVHUWNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJIRUHWEDUQ0HGLHUWO ULQJ DQVHVIRUnY UHGHQQ UHIDNWRUHQKYRUIUDY UHOOHUODY NYDOLWHWYLOJLXWVODJL IRUPDY UHGXVHUWPXOLJKHWIRUNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJ)MHUQHIDNWRUHUNDQ LPLGOHUWLGKDEHW\GQLQJIRURP HW EDUQInUWLOVWUHNNHOLJPHGPHGLHUWO ULQJRJGHUPHGLQGLUHNWHKDEHW\GQLQJIRUHWEDUQV NRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ)RUHOGUHQHVHPRVMRQHOOHIXQJHULQJNDQIRUHNVHPSHOSnYLUNHKYRUYLGW IRUHOGUHQHHULVWDQGWLOnJLEDUQHWPHGLHUWO ULQJ)HXHUVWHLQHWDO
)HXHU VWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRU LRJNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS
,GHWWHDYVQLWWHWV¡NHVGHWnEHO\VHRP)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULV\QHVnK¡UHWLOLQQXQGHU NRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS.RJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSNDQEHWUDNWHVVRPHQRYHURUGQHWEHWHJQHOVH'HQQH EHWHJQHOVHQDQYHQGHVIRUnEHVNULYHHWIDJIHOWEHVWnHQGHDYWHRULHURJIRUVNQLQJVRPV¡NHUn VYDUHSnHSLVWHPRORJLVNHVS¡UVPnONQ\WWHWWLONXQQVNDSHURPPHQQHVNHW*DUGQHU (SLVWHPRORJLNDQ GHILQHUHVVRP
(SLVWHPRORJ\LVWKHV\VWHPDWLFFRQVLGHUDWLRQLQSKLORVRSK\DQGHOVHZKHUHRI NQRZLQJZKHQNQRZOHGJHLVYDOLGZKDWFRXQWVDVWUXWKDQGVRRQ 3DFNHUDQG
*RLFRHFKHD
(SLVWHPRORJLRPKDQGOHUPHGDQGUHRUGKYLONHNXQQVNDSHUVRPDQVHVVRPJ\OGLJHLQQHQIRUHW EHVWHPWIDJRPUnGH7HRULHURJIRUVNQLQJLQQXQGHUNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSNDQKHYGHVnE\JJHSn YLVVHIHOOHVNMHQQHWHJQDYHSLVWHPRORJLVNNDUDNWHU6OLNHNMHQQHWHJQ RPKDQGOHUEODQWDQQHW V\QHWSnPHQQHVNHOLJNXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVHDQDO\VHQLYnNRQWHNVWRJQHGWRQLQJDYVnNDOWH HNVWHUQHIDNWRUHUVLQQYLUNQLQJSnNRJQLWLYIXQJHULQJ*UHHQR *DUGQHU
1HGHQIRUJM¡UHVGHWI¡UVWUHGHIRUNMHQQHWHJQYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS'HUQHVWGU¡IWHV )HXHUVWHLQVWHRULRSSPRWNMHQQHWHJQHQHYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS7LOVLVWVDPOHVWUnGHQHLHQ RSSVXPPHULQJ
.MHQQHWHJQYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS
'HWHUYLNWLJnInIUDPDWNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSLNNHHUHWHQKHWOLJIDJIHOWKYRUGHWHQNHOWODUVHJ JM¡UHnRSSQnNRQVHQVXVNQ\WWHWWLOKYLONHIDNWRUHUVRPNMHQQHWHJQHUIDJIHOWHW$OOLNHYHOHUGHW QRHQNMHQQHWHJQVRPNDQKHYGHVnY UHNDUDNWHULVWLVNH*UHHQR *DUGQHU(Q JUXQQOHJJHQGHIRUHVWLOOLQJRPKDQGOHUIRUVWnHOVHQ DYPHQQHVNHOLJNXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVH0DQ VHUIRUVHJDWNXQQVNDSHUVRPHWLQGLYLGWLOHJQHUVHJNDQEHWUDNWHVnWLOK¡UHGHQQHSHUVRQHQ 'HWWHVNMHUYHGDWSHUVRQHQLQWHUQDOLVHUHUNXQQVNDSHQRJDWGHQQHODJUHVLIRUPDYHQGULQJHUL SHUVRQHQVLQGUHNRJQLWLYHVWUXNWXUHU*UHHQR$QGHUVRQHWDO ,GHQ
VDPPHQKHQJHQ NDQPDQEHQ\WWHEHWHJQHOVHQDXWHQWLVNNXQQVNDS'HWLQQHE UHUQHWWRSSDW NXQQVNDSHQHUVnJUXQGLJLQQDUEHLGHWRJIRUVWnWWDWGHQQ UPHVWKDUEOLWWHQGHODYRVVVHOY
%HIULQJ0HGEDNJUXQQLGHQQHIRUVWnHOVHQDYPHQQHVNHOLJNXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVHDQVHV GHWQ¡GYHQGLJRJUHOHYDQWnEHVNULYHRJEHO\VHLQWHUQHSURVHVVHULQQHLHQNHOWLQGLYLGHWPHG WDQNHSnnIRUNODUHPHQQHVNHOLJDWIHUGDNWLYLWHWRJWHQNQLQJ*UHHQR *DUGQHU 'HWV¡NHVLGHQIRUELQGHOVHnVNLOOHXWHWDQDO\VHQLYnHOOHUHWHJHWUHSUHVHQWDVMRQVQLYnDWVNLOW
IUDELRORJLVNHQHYURORJLVNHRJVRVLRNXOWXUHOOHIDNWRUHU'HWWHQLYnHWDQWDVnHNVLVWHUHPHOORP LQGLYLGHWVWLOI¡UVHODYLQIRUPDVMRQLQSXWRJGHKDQGOLQJHQHVRPI¡OJHUDYLQGLYLGHWVLQWHUQH EHDUEHLGLQJVSURVHVVHURXWSXW*DUGQHU
5HSUHVHQWDVMRQHQHVRPHQVHUIRUVHJHNVLVWHUHULPHQQHVNHWVVLQQNDQXWWU\NNHVYHGKMHOSDY V\PEROVNHUHSUHVHQWDVMRQHUVRPHNVLVWHUHUXWHQIRUPHQQHVNHVLQQHW+XWFKLQV,GHQ VDPPHQKHQJHQEHQ\WWHVGDWDPDVNLQHQVRPPHWDIRUIRUnEHVNULYHPHQQHVNHOLJNRJQLVMRQ 'DWDPDVNLQHQEHWUDNWHVL VHJVHOYVRPHW\WUH´HNVLVWHQVEHYLV´SnNRJQLVMRQ'HUVRPHQ PHQQHVNHODJHWPDVNLQNDQVLHVnXWI¡UHLQWHOOLJHQWHRSHUDVMRQHUVRPnUHVRQQHUHKDPnO UHYLGHUHDWIHUGRPGDQQHLQIRUPDVMRQRVYVnNDQOLNHOHGHVPHQQHVNHWNDUDNWHULVHUHVSn VDPPHPnWH9HGKMHOSDYGDWDPDVNLQPHWDIRUHQKDUGHWEOLWWXWDUEHLGHWGHWDOMHUWHPRGHOOHUIRU nEHVNULYHKYRUGDQPHQQHVNHVLQQHWIXQJHUHURJKYRUGDQNXQQVNDSLQGLYLGHWWLOHJQHUVHJNDQ ODJUHVLPHQQHVNHVLQQHW+XWFKLQV *DUGQHU
%HW\GQLQJHQDYEHJUHSHWNRQWHNVWYDULHUHU,RJPHGDWLQGLYLGHWVLQGUHSURVHVVHUUHJQHVIRUn Y UHGHWSULP UHDQDO\VHQLYnHWLNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSGHILQHUHVNRQWHNVWWLOnRPKDQGOHDOOH IRUKROGVRPRPJLULQGLYLGHW'HUPHGHUNRQWHNVWHQDWVNLOWIUDLQGLYLGHW'\VWKH(W VOLNWVNLOOHPHOORPLQGLYLGRJNRQWHNVWJLUIOHUHIRUGHOHUGHUVRPHQVNDOVWXGHUHHWLQGLYLGV NXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVH)RUHNVHPSHONDQPDQVHSnJHQHUDOLVHUEDUKHWHQDYSHUVRQHQVNXQQVNDS YHGnVWXGHUHDQWDOOVLWXDVMRQHUKYRUSHUVRQHQDQYHQGHUGHQVSHVLILNNHNXQQVNDSHQ*UHHQR $QGHUVRQHWDO
9HGJMHQQRPI¡ULQJDYIRUVNQLQJVVWXGLHUDQVHVGHWQ¡GYHQGLJnQHGWRQHEHW\GQLQJHQDYIOHVW PXOLJHHNVWHUQHIDNWRUHUVLQQYLUNQLQJSnPHQQHVNHOLJWHQNQLQJHOOHUNRJQLVMRQ6OLNHIDNWRUHU NDQY UHHPRVMRQHUXOLNHNRQWHNVWXHOOHIRUKROGVRPRPJLULQGLYLGHWVDPWNXOWXUHOOHRJ KLVWRULVNHDVSHNWHU2JVnLQQHQNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSDQWDVGLVVHHOHPHQWHQHnKDHQLQQYLUNQLQJ SnNRJQLVMRQPHQHQYHOJHUnVHERUWIUDGLVVH'\VWKH+XWFKLQV *DUGQHU 'HWDUJXPHQWHUVPHGDWGHUVRPHQVNXOOHWDKHQV\QWLODOOHGHHNVWHUQHYDULDEOHQHYLOOH NRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSOLJIRUVNQLQJEOLXPXOLJ,VWUHEHQHWWHUnLQNOXGHUHQHYQWHYDULDEOHU ULVLNHUHUPDQ nHQGHRSSPHGnIRUNODUHLQJHQWLQJ)RUVNHUHLQQHQNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSV¡NHU GHUIRULVW¡UVWPXOLJJUDGnVWXGHUHSUREOHPVWLOOLQJHUKYRUDGHNYDWHEHUHJQLQJHURJ NRQNOXVMRQHUNDQJM¡UHVYHGnWUHNNHLQQI UUHVWPXOLJHNVWHUQHYDULDEOHU*DUGQHU
.RJQLWLYHIXQNVMRQHURJPHGLHUWO ULQJ
)RUDQ EOHGHWIUDPKHYHWDW)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULNDQIUDPVWnVRPWRGHOWKYRUEHWHJQHOVHQH NRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWRJPHGLHUWO ULQJPDUNHUHUGHOLQJHQLWHRULHQ'HOHQVRPRPKDQGOHU NRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWNDQKHYGHVnE\JJHSnVHQWUDOHNMHQQHWHJQYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS NQ\WWHWWLOPHQQHVNHOLJNXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVHRJDQDO\VHQLYn+HUEHVNULYHU)HXHUVWHLQEODQW DQQHWNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJVRPHQDNNXPXOHULQJVSURVHVVKYRUEDUQHWWLOHJQHUVHJNXQQVNDSHU VRPODJUHVLGHLQGUHNRJQLWLYHVWUXNWXUHURJSnGHQPnWHQELGUDUWLOnIUHPPHEDUQHWV XWYLNOLQJ)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG'HQQHEHVNULYHOVHDYEDUQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJKDU EHW\GHOLJHOLNKHWHUPHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSRJGHQVIRUVWnHOVHDYPHQQHVNHOLJ
NXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVH,EHJJHDQWDVNXQQVNDSnWLOK¡UHLQGLYLGHWYHGDWNXQQVNDSHQODJUHVL IRUPDYHQGULQJHULLQGLYLGHWVLQGUHNRJQLWLYHVWUXNWXUHU
)HXHUVWHLQYLVHUVRPVDJWWLODWNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJKDQGOHURPLQGUHLQWHUQHSURVHVVHUL LQGLYLGHWRJKDQV¡NHUGHUIRUnEHVNULYHGLVVHSURVHVVHQH+DQNDQLVnPnWHKHYGHVnY UH RSSWDWWDYGHWVDPPHDQDO\VHHOOHUUHSUHVHQWDVMRQVQLYnHWVRPNMHQQHWHJQHUNRJQLWLY YLWHQVNDS5HSUHVHQWDVMRQHQHLQQHLLQGLYLGHWNDOOHUKDQIRUNRJQLWLYHIXQNVMRQHUHOOHU SV\NRORJLVNHVWUXNWXUHU'HWNDQLPLGOHUWLGDUJXPHQWHUHVIRUDW)HXHUVWHLQLVLQIUDPVWLOOLQJDY PHQQHVNHVLQQHWVLQGUHHUQRHYDJ+DQ SHNHUSnDWGHSV\NRORJLVNHVWUXNWXUHQHKDUEHVWHPWH HJHQVNDSHUPHQ KDQ V\QHVLPLGOHUWLGnY UHOLWHNRQNUHWLEHVNULYHOVHQDYKYLONH
NRPSRQHQWHUHQSV\NRORJLVNVWUXNWXUEHVWnUDY )HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG6OLNVHWWNDQ )HXHUVWHLQVEHVNULYHOVHDYPHQQHVNHVLQQHWVLQGUHV\QHVnVNLOOHVHJIUDPHUGHWDOMRULHQWHUWH IUDPVWLOOLQJHUHQILQQHULXOLNHUHWQLQJHULQQHQNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS
'HQDQGUHGHOHQDY)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULVRPRPKDQGOHUPHGLHUWO ULQJNDQKHYGHVnKDHWDQQHW IRNXV+HUHUIRUVNHUHQRSSWDWWDYKYRUGDQEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJNDQIUHPPHVJMHQQRP PHGLHUWO ULQJ)HXHUVWHLQJLUHQRPIDWWHQGHUHGHJM¡UHOVHIRUKYLONHHJHQVNDSHUYHG
LQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORPNRPSHWHQWHSHUVRQHULQ UPLOM¡HWRJEDUQHWVRPIUHPPHUGHWV NRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ)HXHUVWHLQHWDO'HWNDQ DUJXPHQWHUHVIRUDW)HXHUVWHLQLGHQQHGHOHQDYWHRULHQUHWWHUV¡NHO\VHWPRWHWKHOWDQQHW DQDO\VHQLYnHQQGHWLQGUHLQGLYLGRULHQWHUWHVRPNMHQQHWHJQHUNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS.R]XOLQ KHYGHUEODQWDQQHWDW)HXHUVWHLQJMHQQRP PHGLHUWO ULQJDQHUNMHQQHUEHW\GQLQJHQDYn UHWWHRSSPHUNVRPKHWHQPRWVRVLRNXOWXUHOOHNUHIWHUPHGWDQNHSnnEHO\VHHWEDUQVNRJQLWLYH XWYLNOLQJ
(WDQQHWPRPHQWYHGWHRULHQRPPHGLHUWO ULQJV\QHVLPLGOHUWLGW\GHOLJnY UHLWUnGPHG NMHQQHWHJQYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS3nOLQMHPHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSQHGWRQHU)HXHUVWHLQ EHW\GQLQJHQDYDQGUHIDNWRUHUHQQPHGLHUWO ULQJQnUGHWJMHOGHUnIUHPPHHWEDUQVNRJQLWLYH XWYLNOLQJ(NVHPSHOSnDQGUHDNWXHOOHDVSHNWHUNDQY UHDUYIDPLOLHQVVRVLR¡NRQRPLVNH VLWXDVMRQRJHPRVMRQHOOIXQJHULQJKRVEDUQRJIRUHVDWWH'LVVHIDNWRUHQHRPWDOHU)HXHUVWHLQ VRPIMHUQHHOOHUVHNXQG UH)HXHUVWHLQHWDO(QVOLNQHGWRQLQJDYIDNWRUHUILQQHUHQ RJVnLNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSKYRUHQV¡NHUnJMHQQRPI¡UHIRUVNQLQJVVWXGLHUYHGnWUHNNHLQQ I UUHVWPXOLJYDULDEOHULVWXGLHQH
6WXGLHQWLO.OHLQRJ$ORQ\NDQ WMHQHVRPLOOXVWUDVMRQSnIRUVNQLQJVRPE\JJHUSn )HXHUVWHLQVLQWHRULRJVDPWLGLJWUHNNHUInYDULDEOHULQQLIRUVNQLQJHQ VHDYVQLWW 'H JMHQQRPI¡UWHHWHNVSHULPHQWKYRUIRUPnOHWYDUnXQGHUV¡NHHIIHNWHUDYHQLQWHUYHQVMRQNQ\WWHW WLOnIRUEHGUHP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHJQHEDUQ)RUVNHUQH NRQNOXGHUWHPHGDWVWXGLHQYLVHUDWP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWNQ\WWHWWLOPHGLHUWO ULQJNDQIRUEHGUHV JMHQQRPLQWHUYHQVMRQRJ DWP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWLIRUELQGHOVHPHGPHGLHUWO ULQJNDQKD
EHW\GQLQJIRUEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ6WXGLHQWRNLOLWHQJUDGKHQV\QWLOKYRUGDQHYHQWXHOW DQGUHYDULDEOHUNDQ KDKDWWEHW\GQLQJIRUEDUQDVNRJQLWLYHIXQJHULQJ$QGUHDNWXHOOHYDULDEOHU NXQQHKDY UWP¡GUHQHVRJEDUQDVHPRVMRQHOOHIXQJHULQJIRUHOGUHQHVXWGDQQLQJVQLYnVDPW
¡YULJHVLGHUYHGNRQWHNVWHQVRPRPJDEDUQHWVRPIRUHNVHPSHOWLOJDQJHQSnOHNHURVY
2SSVXPPHULQJDY)HXHU VWHLQVWHRULRJNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS
.RJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSHUHQVDPOHEHWHJQHOVHIRUHWPDQJIROGLJIDJIHOW3nWURVVDYGHWWHHUGHW YLVVHNMHQQHWHJQNQ\WWHWWLOHSLVWHPRORJLVNHDVSHNWHUVRPHUIHOOHVIRUWHRULHURJIRUVNQLQJ LQQXQGHUNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS6OLNHIRUKROGRPKDQGOHUEODQWDQQHWV\QHWSnPHQQHVNHOLJ NXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVHKYLONHWDQDO\VHQLYnVRPE¡UDQYHQGHVYHGIRUNODULQJHUDYPHQQHVNHOLJ DWIHUGDNWLYLWHWRJWHQNQLQJIRUVWnHOVHDYEHJUHSHWNRQWHNVW RJ WURHQSnDWGHWHUQ¡GYHQGLJn QHGWRQHHNVWHUQHIDNWRUHUVLQQYLUNQLQJSnNRJQLWLYIXQJHULQJ*UHHQR *DUGQHU +HQVLNWHQRYHQIRUKDUY UWnEHO\VHRP)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULV\QHVnK¡UHWLOLQQXQGHU NRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS'HWHUSUREOHPDWLVNnWUHNNHQRHQNODURJHQW\GLJNRQNOXVMRQRPGHWWH 'HWVN\OGHVDW)HXHUVWHLQVLQWHRULIUDPVWnUVRPWRGHOW.RJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWV\QHVn E\JJHSnVHQWUDOHNMHQQHWHJQYHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSNQ\WWHWWLOPHQQHVNHOLJ
NXQQVNDSVWLOHJQHOVHRJDQDO\VHQLYn,GHOHQRPPHGLHUWO ULQJIRNXVHUHVGHWLPLGOHUWLGSnHW KHOWDQQHWDQDO\VHQLYn+HUHU)HXHUVWHLQRSSWDWWDYKYRUGDQHJHQVNDSHUYHGLQWHUDNVMRQHQ
PHOORPEDUQRJYRNVQHIUHPPHULQGLYLGHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ(WVOLNWLQWHUDNVMRQVIRNXV V\QHVLNNHnY UHLWUnGPHGNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS
6S¡UVPnOHWEOLUKYRUGDQYLVNDOWRONH)HXHUVWHLQVWHRUL.DQHQWHRULVRPEHVNULYHUWRVn IRUVNMHOOLJHDQDO\VHQLYnHUDUJXPHQWHUHVIRUnK¡UHWLOLQQXQGHUNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS"6DQQV\QOLJ PnGHWVYDUHVMDSnHWVOLNWVS¡UVPnO'HWNDQEHJUXQQHVPHGDWNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHW DQVHVIRUnY UHIXQGDPHQWHWVRPPHGLHUWO ULQJEDVHUHVSn5\H .OHLQ,RJ PHGDWNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWIUDPWUHUVRPJUXQQOHJJHQGHNDQGHWDUJXPHQWHUHVIRUDW PHGLHUWO ULQJKYLOHUSnHWIXQGDPHQWVRPV\QHVnY UHLWUnGPHGVHQWUDOHNMHQQHWHJQYHG NRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS'HWRYHURUGQHGHKRYHGIRNXVHWL)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULV\QHVGHUPHGnY UHn EHVNULYHGHNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJVSURVHVVHQHVRPIRUHJnULQQHLLQGLYLGHW8WIUDHQVOLN WRONQLQJNDQGHWDUJXPHQWHUHVIRUDW)HXHUVWHLQVLQWHRULIUDPVWnUVRPHQNRJQLWLYWHRUL
6DPWLGLJIUDPKHYHU)HXHUVWHLQDWPHGLHUWO ULQJHUGHQYLNWLJVWHNRPSRQHQWHQPHGWDQNHSn nIUHPPHLQGLYLGHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ*MHQQRPnLQNOXGHUHHWVOLNWLQWHUDNVMRQVIRNXVNDQ GHWKHYGHVDW)HXHUVWHLQ´E\JJHU´LQQHQVRVLDOGLPHQVMRQLWHRULHQ'HUPHGNDQ )HXHUVWHLQV WHRULEHWUDNWHVVRPHQVRVLDONRJQLWLYWHRULVRPV\QHVnK¡UHWLOLQQXQGHUVDPOHEHWHJQHOVHQ NRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDS
,QWHU YHQVMRQHU RJIRU VNQLQJEDVHU WSn)HXHU VWHLQVWHRU L
)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULKDUY UWDQYHQGWVRPJUXQQODJIRULQWHUYHQVMRQHURJIRUVNQLQJSn LQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORP\QJUHEDUQRJRPVRUJVJLYHUH,GHWWHDUEHLGHWKDU3QLQD.OHLQYHG%DU ,ODQXQLYHUVLWHWHWL,VUDHOY UWIUHPWUHGHQGH5\H1HGHQIRUJM¡UHVGHWUHGHIRU LQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW0,6&DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20,RJ WRIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLG
,QWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW0,6&
.OHLQKDUELGUDWWWLOnXWDUEHLGHLQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW0,6&0HGLDWLRQDO,QWHUYHQWLRQIRU 6HQVLWL]LQJ&DUHJLYHUV3URJUDPPHWHUSU¡YGXWLIOHUHODQGL$IULND$VLDRJ(XURSD.OHLQ
&KLVZDQGD.OHLQ +XQGHLGH ,QWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHWV
RYHURUGQHGHPnOHUVHQVLWLYHULQJDYRPVRUJVJLYHUHVOLNDWGHJMHQQRPLQWHUDNVMRQPHGEDUQ NDQELGUDWLOVWLPXOHULQJDYEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJGHUHVVRVLDOHRJHPRVMRQHOOH
IXQJHULQJRJnUXVWHEDUQHWWLOEHVWPXOLJnNXQQHSURILWWHUHSnIUDPWLGLJO ULQJ'HWWHRUHWLVNH UDVMRQDOHIRUSURJUDPPHWHUEDVHUWSn)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRUL.OHLQ
%DNJUXQQHQIRUXWIRUPLQJHQ DYLQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHWYDUHW¡QVNHRPnXQQJnSUREOHPHU NQ\WWHWWLOSnJnHQGHLQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHULIRUVNMHOOLJHODQGL$IULND$VLD86$RJ (XURSDKYRUP\HDYGHVDPPHYDQVNHQHEOHUDSSRUWHUW'LVVHLQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHQH KDGGHHQWHQGHQVWLOnInGHOWDNHUQHWLOnI¡OHVHJXQGHUOHJQHDYKHQJLJHDYPDWHULDOHHOOHU KMHOSXWHQLIUDRJIUHPPHGJMRUWLIRUKROGWLOHJHQKMHOSHUROOH0,6&VNLOOHUVHJIUDDQGUH LQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHUYHGDWSURJUDPPHWIRNXVHUHUSnNYDOLWHWHQDYLQWHUDNVMRQHQPHOORP HQRPVRUJVSHUVRQRJEDUQHWRJLNNHSnLQQKROGRJPDWHULDOHDQYHQGWLLQWHUDNVMRQHQ 3URJUDPPHWIRNXVHUHUGHVVXWHQSnKYRUGDQ HQ RPVRUJVJLYHUNDQRSSQnHQHQGULQJL LQWHUDNVMRQHQPHGEDUQHWEDVHUWSnEHYLVVWJM¡ULQJDYRPVRUJVJLYHUVSRVLWLYHVLGHUYHGHJHQ HNVLVWHUHQGHSUDNVLV'HWWHI¡UHUWLODWGHOWDNHUQHEOLUPHUPRWLYHUWRJLQWHUHVVHUWIRUGLGHInU HQI¡OHOVHDYNRPSHWDQVHNQ\WWHWWLOHJHQUROOHVRPRPVRUJVJLYHUQRHVRPDQVHVVRPYLNWLJ PHGWDQNHSnODQJWLGVHIIHNWHU7\SLVNHGHOWDNHUHNDQY UHIRUHOGUHSHUVRQDOHWDQVDWWYHG KHOVHVWDVMRQHUI¡UVNROHO UHURJO UHUH.OHLQ
'HIHPNULWHULHQHLPHGLHUWO ULQJHUXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUGHQSUDNWLVNHXWIRUPLQJHQDY LQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHWVHDYVQLWW*MHQQRP¡YHOVHUVRPOHJJHUYHNWSnDNWLY GHOWDNHOVHEOLUGHWIRUV¡NWnVHQVLWLYHUHRJEHYLVVWJM¡UHGHOWDNHUQHLIRUKROGWLONULWHULHQH (NVHPSOHUSnDNWLYLWHWHUNDQY UHDQVNXHOLJJM¡ULQJJMHQQRPUROOHVSLOOGLVNXVMRQHUNQ\WWHWWLO HNVHPSOHUIUDGHOWDNHUQHVGDJOLJHHUIDULQJHUPHGEDUQRJEUXNDYYLGHRKYRUILOPHUDY RPVRUJVSHUVRQRJEDUQVHNYHQVHUEOLUDQDO\VHUW
3UHVHQWDVMRQHQDYLQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW0,6&HUWDWWPHGKHUIRUnInIUDPDWWHRULHQRP PHGLHUWO ULQJLNNHEDUHNDQY UHJUXQQODJIRUIRUVNQLQJVRPWDUVLNWHSnnIRUHWDYXUGHULQJHU DQJnHQGHXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWLIRUELQGHOVHPHGVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ6HOYRP
WLOWDNVXWSU¡YLQJLNNHHUHQGHODYGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWJLUGHWHNVWUDLQVSLUDVMRQnYLWHDW WHRULHQRJVnNDQEHQ\WWHVVRPXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUXWIRUPLQJDYWLOWDNHOOHUSURJUDPPHUVRPNDQ ELGUDWLOnHQGUHHOOHUIRUEHGUHXQGHUYLVQLQJ
$QDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20,
(WVHQWUDOWPRPHQWL.OHLQVLQHVWXGLHUHUnEHO\VHNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJL
LQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUPHOORPP¡GUHRJ\QJUHEDUQ)RUnInIUDPGHQQHNYDOLWHWHQKDU.OHLQ XWDUEHLGHWRJDQYHQGWREVHUYDVMRQRJDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20, 2EVHUYLQJ0HGLDWLRQDO ,QWHUDFWLRQ.OHLQ.OHLQ $ORQ\ .OHLQ:LHGHU *UHHQVSDQ
$QDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20,NDQEHWHJQHVVRPHQW\SHVWUXNWXUHUWREVHUYDVMRQVRPEHQ\WWHVIRU nDQDO\VHUHYLGHRRSSWDNDYLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHUPHOORPP¡GUHRJEDUQ20,HUXWDUEHLGHW SnEDNJUXQQDYIHPNULWHULHUVRP.OHLQPHGEDNJUXQQL)HXHUVWHLQVLQXWYLNOLQJVWHRULDQVHU VRPVHQWUDOHNQ\WWHWWLOVWLPXOHULQJDYEDUQVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ'HIHP NULWHULHQHHU IRNXVHULQJHPRVMRQV\WULQJXWYLGHOVHNRPSHWDQVHRJDWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJ0HGXWJDQJVSXQNWL GLVVHNULWHULHQHKDUKXQODJHWHJQHRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHUIRUKYHUWNULWHULXP VRPEHQ\WWHVWLOn VNnUHWLOVWHGHY UHOVHQDYNULWHULHQHLQQHQIRUVHNYHQVHUPHGLQWHUDNVMRQ
$QDO\VHDYYLGHRRSSWDNYHGKMHOSDY20,LQQHE UHUUHJLVWUHULQJHOOHUNRGLQJDY DQWDOOJDQJHU GHQYRNVQHVDWIHUGIDOOHULQQHQIRURSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHRJGHUPHGNULWHULHQHIRUPHGLHUW O ULQJLQQHQIRUHQGHILQHUWWLGVSHULRGH'HWHUYLNWLJnXQGHUVWUHNHDWGHWNXQHUDWIHUGVXWWU\NN VRPNDQKHYGHVnUHSUHVHQWHUHNULWHULHQHVRPUHJLVWUHUHV$WIHUGHQWLOPRURJEDUQVHVL UHODVMRQ'HWEHW\UDWPRUVDWIHUGNXQEOLUUHJLVWUHUWGHUVRPEDUQHWUHVSRQGHUHUSnPRUVDWIHUG )RUHNVHPSHOYLOHQREVHUYDVMRQDYHQPRUVRPJLUHQOHNHWLOVLWWEDUQNXQEOLUHJLVWUHUW LQQHQIRUNDWHJRULHQIRNXVHULQJGHUVRPEDUQHWJLUHQUHVSRQVVRPVLJQDOLVHUHUJMHQVLGLJKHW /LNHOHGHVYLOPRUVIRUNODULQJNQ\WWHWWLOHQEHVWHPWKHQGHOVHNXQUHJLVWUHUHVLIRUELQGHOVHPHG NULWHULHWXWYLGHOVHGHUVRPEDUQHWSnYLGHRRSSWDNHWYLVHUDWIHUGVRPVDQQV\QOLJJM¡UDWEDUQHW VHUXWWLOnInPHGVHJIRUNODULQJHQ.OHLQ
20,KDUSnIOHUHPnWHUY UWHQ YLNWLJLQVSLUDVMRQVNLOGH)¡UVWRJIUHPVWYHGDWGHIHP NULWHULHQHL20,EOLUEHQ\WWHWVRPXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUXWYLNOLQJDY RSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHL DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWVRP EOLUDQYHQGWLGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHW9LGHUHEOLU
DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWEHQ\WWHWWLOVNnULQJDYRPVRUJVSHUVRQHUVLGHQQHVDPPHQKHQJHQO UHUHV DWIHUGVXWWU\NNLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGEDUQRJVnGHWWHLWUnGPHG20,6DPWLGLJVNLOOHU
DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWLGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVHJIUD20,SnIOHUHSXQNWHU'HWWHJMHOGHU EODQWDQQHWXWIRUPLQJHQDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQHVRP EOLUDQYHQGWWLOVNnULQJDYO UHUDWIHUG
RJ QRUPHQHVRP EOLUEHQ\WWHWLIRUELQGHOVHPHGnYXUGHUHNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJL LQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHU'HWYLOEOLUHGHJMRUWIRUGLVVHPRPHQWHQHVHQHUHLDYKDQGOLQJHQ
)RU VNQLQJEDVHUWSn)HXHU VWHLQVWHRUL
.OHLQKDUJMHQQRPI¡UWIOHUHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHUPHGXWJDQJVSXQNWLWHRULHQ RP PHGLHUWO ULQJ .OHLQ.OHLQ $ORQ\ .OHLQ:LHGHU *UHHQVSDQ 7RDYGLVVH VWXGLHQHSUHVHQWHUHVQHGHQIRU
.OHLQ:LHGHURJ*UHHQVSDQJMHQQRPI¡UWHHQILUHnULJORQJLWXGLQHOOVWXGLH8WYDOJHWL XQGHUV¡NHOVHQEHVWRDYP¡GUHPHGODYVRVLR¡NRQRPLVNVWDWXVRJGHUHVEDUQ)RUPnOHWPHG XQGHUV¡NHOVHQYDUnSnYLVHHQVDPPHQKHQJPHOORPP¡GUHQHVNYDOLWHWNQ\WWHWWLOPHGLHUW O ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHJQHEDUQRJEDUQDVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ$QDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20, EOHDQYHQGWIRUnYXUGHUHNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJ0¡GUHQHEOHILOPHWLOHNPHGHJQH EDUQ2EVHUYDVMRQHQHEOHIRUHWDWWGDEDUQDYDURJPnQHGHU%DUQDEOHLWLOOHJJ WHVWHWPHGNRJQLWLYHWHVWHUGD GHYDURJPnQHGHU.OHLQ:LHGHURJ
*UHHQVSDQYLVHUWLODWP¡GUHQHVNYDOLWHWNQ\WWHWWLOPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHG HJQHEDUQEHGUHSUHGLNHUWHEDUQDVVNnUHSnNRJQLWLYHWHVWHUGDEDUQDYDUILUHnUHQQEDUQDV VNnUHSnNRJQLWLYHWHVWHULVSHGEDUQVDOGHU8QGHUV¡NHOVHQYLVWHRJVnDWP¡GUHQHVNYDOLWHWDY PHGLHUWO ULQJRYHUIRUHJQHEDUQKDGGHVW¡UUHEHW\GQLQJIRUEDUQDVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJHQQ DQGUHYDULDEOHUVRPJUDYLGLWHWI¡GVHORJP¡GUHQHVXWGDQQLQJVQLYn
1RHQnUVHQHUHJMHQQRPI¡UWH.OHLQRJ$ORQ\HQRSSI¡OJLQJVVWXGLHKYRUIRUPnOHWYDUn XQGHUV¡NHHIIHNWHUDYHQLQWHUYHQVMRQNQ\WWHWWLOnHQGUHNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJL LQWHUDNVMRQPHOORPP¡GUHRJEDUQ8WYDOJHWLXQGHUV¡NHOVHQEHVWRDY PRU± EDUQG\DGHUIUD HWOLWHE\RPUnGHL,VUDHONMHQWVRPHWRPUnGHKYRUEHERHUQHKDGGHODYVRVLR¡NRQRPLVNVWDWXV )DPLOLHQHEOHWLOIHOGLJIRUGHOWLHQHNVSHULPHQWJUXSSHRJHQNRQWUROOJUXSSH'HWGHOWRN IDPLOLHULHNVSHULPHQWJUXSSHQRJLNRQWUROOJUXSSHQ
,QWHUYHQVMRQEOHJMHQQRPI¡UWEnGHLHNVSHULPHQW RJNRQWUROOJUXSSD,QWHUYHQVMRQHQL HNVSHULPHQWJUXSSDYDUEDVHUWSn0,6&SURJUDPPHW.OHLQ$NWLYLWHWHQHYDUXWIRUPHW PHGWDQNHSnnIRUEHGUHP¡GUHQHVNYDOLWHWNQ\WWHWWLOPHGLHUWO ULQJ,QWHUYHQVMRQHQEOH JMHQQRPI¡UWDYIDJSHUVRQHUVRPEHV¡NWHIDPLOLHQHHQWLPHXNHQWOLJL HQSHULRGHSnV\Y
PnQHGHU+YHUIDPLOLHILNNWLOSDVVHWHQLQGLYLGXHOOLQWHUYHQVMRQVSODQPHGXWJDQJVSXQNWL REVHUYDVMRQHUDYVDPVSLOOPHOORPPRURJEDUQ,QWHUYHQVMRQHQLQQHEDUKRYHGVDNHOLJSRVLWLY WLOEDNHPHOGLQJSnP¡GUHQHVVDPVSLOOPHGEDUQHWPHGXWJDQJVSXQNWLNULWHULHQHLPHGLHUW O ULQJ1RHIRNXVEOHRJVnODJWSnSnSHNLQJDYIHUGLJKHWHUVRPNXQQHYLGHUHXWYLNOHV 9LGHRRSSWDNEOHEHQ\WWHWRYHUIRUP¡GUHQHIRUnLOOXVWUHUHJRGHVDPVSLOOIHUGLJKHWHU,WLOOHJJ DQYHQGWHIDJSHUVRQHQHJMHQVWDQGHULP¡GUHQHVQ UPLOM¡IRUnYLVXDOLVHUHKYRUGDQGLVVHNXQQH DQYHQGHVLVDPVSLOOPHGEDUQHW,QWHUYHQVMRQHQRYHUIRUP¡GUHQHLNRQWUROOJUXSSHQEHVWRDY XQGHUYLVQLQJPHGXWJDQJVSXQNWLJHQHUHOOOLWWHUDWXUDQJnHQGHEDUQVXWYLNOLQJ
0¡GUHQHVNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHJQHEDUQEOHYXUGHUWPHG DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHW20,,WLOOHJJEOHEDUQDVNRJQLWLYHIXQJHULQJYXUGHUWSnEDNJUXQQDY IOHUHNRJQLWLYHWHVWHU'HWEOHLQQKHQWHWGDWDIRUEHJJHJUXSSHQHLIRUNDQWHWW RJWUHnUHWWHU LQWHUYHQVMRQHQ5HVXOWDWHQHSnSUHWHVWYLVWHLQJHQIRUVNMHOOHUPHOORPP¡GUHQHLHNVSHULPHQW RJNRQWUROOJUXSSHQHNQ\WWHWWLONYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHJQHEDUQ(WWHU LQWHUYHQVMRQHQEOHGHWIXQQHWVLJQLILNDQWHIRUVNMHOOHUPHOORPJUXSSHQHKYRUP¡GUHQHVRP GHOWRNLLQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW0,6& EOHYXUGHUWnKDEHGUHNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWO ULQJ 5HVXOWDWHQHSnSUHWHVWYLVWHLQJHQIRUVNMHOOHUPHOORPEDUQDLHNVSHULPHQW RJ
NRQWUROOJUXSSHQHSnGHNRJQLWLYHWHVWHQH5HVXOWDWHQHSnSRVWWHVWYLVWHVLJQLILNDQWHIRUVNMHOOHU KYRUEDUQDLHNVSHULPHQWJUXSSDVNnUHWK¡\HVW'HWEOHRJVnIXQQHWDWEDUQDL
HNVSHULPHQWJUXSSDVSRQWDQWXWWU\NWHIOHUHEHJUHSHUYLVWHPHUHQJDVMHPHQWVWLOWHIOHUH VS¡UVPnORJYLVWHPHUWLOIUHGVVWLOOHQGHDWIHUGRYHUIRUVLQHP¡GUH
.OHLQRJ$ORQ\NRQNOXGHUWHPHGDWXQGHUV¡NHOVHQLOOXVWUHUWHDWP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWDY PHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHJQHEDUQNDQIRUEHGUHVYHGKMHOSDYHW
LQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPRJDWP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWLIRUELQGHOVHPHGPHGLHUWO ULQJNDQKD EHW\GQLQJIRUEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHIXQJHULQJ
'HWHUIOHUHPRPHQWHUVRPHUIHOOHVIRUGLVVHVWXGLHQHRJIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVRPGHW UHGHJM¡UHVIRULGHQQHDYKDQGOLQJHQ'HE\JJHUSn)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULRPPHGLHUW O ULQJ(WDQQHWIHOOHVPRPHQWHUDWGHWEHQ\WWHVREVHUYDVMRQYHGKMHOSDYYLGHRWLO
GDWDLQQVDPOLQJRJDQDO\VHRJDWGHWDQYHQGHVHWDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWIRUnYXUGHUHNYDOLWHWHQ DYPHGLHUWO ULQJVRPIRUHJnULVHNYHQVHUPHGLQWHUDNVMRQPHOORPYRNVQHRJEDUQ
6DPWLGLJHUGHWIOHUHIRUVNMHOOHUPHOORPGLVVHVWXGLHQHRJIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWLGHQQH DYKDQGOLQJHQ(QYHVHQWOLJIRUVNMHOOHUDWVWXGLHQHWLO.OHLQV¡NHUnSnYLVHVDPPHQKHQJHU PHOORPP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQPHGHJQHEDUQRJEDUQDVNRJQLWLYH XWYLNOLQJ,GHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWHU LNNHHOHYHQHVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJHQYDULDEHOVRPGHW EOLUWDWWKHQV\QWLO(QDQQHQNODUIRUVNMHOOHUDWGHWL GHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWVRP GHWEOH DQW\GHWIRUDQEOLUEHQ\WWHWDQGUHQRUPHUIRUnYXUGHUHNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJHQQ GHW.OHLQEHQ\WWHULVLQHVWXGLHU,WLOOHJJEOLUGHWLGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWLVW¡UUHJUDG V¡NWn V\QOLJJM¡UHRJSUREOHPDWLVHUHPHWRGLVNHWLOQ UPLQJHUNQ\WWHWWLODQYHQGHOVHDY
DQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWHQQGHWVRPV\QHVnNRPPHIUDPL.OHLQVLQHVWXGLHU'HWWHHUDVSHNWHU VRPYLOEOLXWG\SHWVHQHUHLDYKDQGOLQJHQ
8WG\SLQJDYNU LWHU LHQHLPHGLHU WO U LQJ
0HGLHUWO ULQJVRPIRUHJnULLQWHUDNVMRQPHOORPHQYRNVHQRJHWEDUQNDQEHVNULYHVYHGKMHOS DYWROYIRUVNMHOOLJHNULWHULHU)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ7UHDYGLVVHHUIRNXVHULQJ HPRVMRQV\WULQJRJXWYLGHOVH'HWHUGLVVH)HXHUVWHLQDQVHUIRUnY UHGHPHVWVHQWUDOHIRUGL GHWHUGHWUHVRP I¡UVWRJIUHPVWGDQQHUJUXQQODJIRUXWYLNOLQJDYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWIRUEDUQHW +DQSHNHUSnDWGH¡YULJHQLNULWHULHQHLVW¡UUHJUDGHU RSSJDYH RJNXOWXUDYKHQJLJH
)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG.OHLQEHQ\WWHUIHPDYGHWROY NULWHULHQHL LQWHUYHQVMRQVSURJUDPPHW 0,6&RJL VWXGLHUKYRUKXQV¡NHUnPnOHNYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJ.OHLQ.OHLQ
$ORQ\ .OHLQ:LHGHU *UHHQVSDQ+XQKDULWLOOHJJWLOGHWUHNULWHULHQHVRP )HXHUVWHLQEHWUDNWHUVRPGHYLNWLJVWHYDOJWnDQYHQGHNULWHULHQHNRPSHWDQVHRJ
DWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJ
,GHWWHDYVQLWWHWEOLUGHWJMRUWUHGHIRULQQKROGVIRUVWnHOVHQDYGHIHPNULWHULHQH%HW\GQLQJHQ DYNULWHULHQHEOLUEHVNUHYHW RJIRUPnOHWPHGGHP EOLUXWG\SHW6LGHQGHQQHDYKDQGOLQJHQ UHWWHUV¡NHO\VHWPRWVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJEOLUVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJVVLWXDVMRQHUIOHUHVWHGHUL WHNVWHQEUXNWVRP HNVHPSOHUIRUnLOOXVWUHUHRJ InIUDPEHW\GQLQJHQDYNULWHULHQH
)RNXVHULQJ
.OHLQJLUHQVOLNEHVNULYHOVHDYGHWWHNULWHULHW
,QVLPSOHWHUPVWKLVFULWHULRQFRXOGEHGHVFULEHGDVDQDWWHPSWRQWKHSDUWRIWKH PHGLDWRURUFDUHJLYHUWRIRFXVWKHFKLOG¶VDWWHQWLRQWRVRPHWKLQJLQWKHFKLOG¶V VXUURXQGLQJV7KHUHPXVWEHDFOHDULQGLFDWLRQRIWKHDGXOW¶VLQWHQWLRQDOLW\WR PHGLDWHDQGRIWKHFKLOG¶VUHFLSURFLW\.OHLQ
.ULWHULHWRPKDQGOHUPHGDQGUHRUGKYRUGDQHQRPVRUJVSHUVRQIRUV¡NHUnOHGHEDUQHWV RSSPHUNVRPKHWPRWQRHVRPHNVLVWHUHULEDUQHWVRPJLYHOVHU,WLOOHJJPnGHWIRUHOLJJHHQNODU LQWHQVMRQIUDGHQYRNVHQVVLGHRPOHGHOVHDYEDUQHWVRSSPHUNVRPKHW'HVVXWHQPnEDUQHW UHVSRQGHUHSnHQPnWHVRPV\QOLJJM¡UDWKDQHOOHUKXQKDUIDQJHWRSSGHQYRNVQHVVLJQDOHU
)RUPnOHWPHGRPVRUJVSHUVRQHQVEUXNDY NULWHULHWVWUHNNHUVHJLPLGOHUWLGXWRYHUnOHGHEDUQHWV RSSPHUNVRPKHWLGHQNRQNUHWHVLWXDVMRQHQ
$GHHSHUDQDO\VLVRIWKHPHQWDOSURFHVVHVHQJHQGHUHGE\WKHLQWHUDFWLRQDQLPDWHG E\LQWHQWLRQDOLW\ DQGUHFLSURFLW\UHYHDOVWKDWWKLVPRGDOLW\RILQWHUDFWLRQHYHQ ZKHQGRQHRQHOHPHQWDU\OHYHOVFUHDWHVLQWKHPHGLDWHHDQDZDUHQHVVRIWKH OHDUQLQJSURFHVVDQGRIWKHGLGDFWLFSULQFLSOHVXQGHUO\LQJLW7KHPHWDFRJQLWLYH FRPSRQHQWVIRUPDQLPSRUWDQWSDUWRIWKHPHGLDWLRQDOLQWHUDFWLRQWDNLQJWKHIRUP RILQGXFHGVHOIUHIOHFWLRQLQVLJKWDQGDUWLFXODWLRQRIWKHWRWDOILHOGLQWRLWV FRPSRQHQWV7KLVRULHQWDWLRQRQFHLQWHUQDOL]HGEHFRPHVWKHVWHHULQJSRZHU WRZDUGVPRUHHIILFLHQWOHDUQLQJDQGLQWXUQOHDGVWRKLJKHUOHYHOVRIPRGLILDELOLW\
)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ
1nUHQYRNVHQEHQ\WWHUIRNXVHULQJRYHUIRUHWEDUQNDQGHWI¡UHWLODWEDUQHWWLOHJQHUVHJ IHUGLJKHWHUNQ\WWHWWLO KYRUGDQGHWNDQ VNDIIHVHJNXQQVNDSHURPRPYHUGHQHQ6OLNH SULQVLSSHUNDQIRUHNVHPSHORPKDQGOHHYQHWLOnUHWWHRSSPHUNVRPKHWHQPRWHWGHILQHUW IRNXVKDRSSPHUNVRPKHWSnHQWLQJDYJDQJHQ RJnRSSUHWWKROGHNRQVHQWUDVMRQRYHUWLG )HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ YLVHUWLODWEDUQVRPWLOHJQHUVHJVOLNHIHUGLJKHWHUYLONXQQH EOLLVWDQGWLOnEHQ\WWHGLVVHVHOYVWHQGLJVHQHUH'HUPHGYLOEDUQHWVHYQHWLOnWLOHJQHVHJQ\H NXQQVNDSHUNXQQH¡NH
.OHLQYLVHUWLOHWDQQHWSRHQJYHGU¡UHQGHWLOHJQHOVHDYNXQQVNDSLIRUELQGHOVHPHG NULWHULHWIRNXVHULQJ(QYRNVHQNDQIUDPVWnVRPPRGHOOIRUHWEDUQQnUGHWJMHOGHUHYQHQWLOn IRUPLGOHXOLNHWHPDHUWLODQGUH'HWLQQHE UHUDWQnUHWEDUQInUWDGHOLKYRUGDQHQYRNVHQ JMHQQRPEUXNDYIRUVNMHOOLJHVWUDWHJLHUInUEDUQHWWLOnIRNXVHUHSnXOLNHREMHNWHUYLOEDUQHW NXQQHDQYHQGHGHVDPPHVWUDWHJLHQHQnUGHWVHOYLQQJnULLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGDQGUH
,VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJNDQIRNXVHULQJE\SnXWIRUGULQJHUIRUHQO UHU/ UHUHQPnDNWLYWV¡NHn InHOHYHQWLOnUHWWHRSSPHUNVRPKHWHQPRWXQGHUYLVQLQJVLQQKROGHWVRPVNDOIRUPLGOHVWLO HOHYHQ'HWVWLOOHUNUDYWLOWLOVWHGHY UHOVHHQJDVMHPHQWRJVHQVLWLYLWHWLVLWXDVMRQHQ,VWDUWHQ DYHQXQGHUYLVQLQJVVHNYHQVNDQHOHYHQIRUHNVHPSHOKDRSSPHUNVRPKHWHQPRWQRHDQQHWL URPPHWHOOHUKDWDQNHQHXWHQIRUNODVVHURPPHW/ UHUHQPnGDEHQ\WWHDWIHUGVXWWU\NNDYHQWHQ YHUEDOHOOHUQRQYHUEDONDUDNWHUIRUnVW\UHHOHYHQVRSSPHUNVRPKHWVOLNDWHOHYHQNODUHUnUHWWH IRNXVHWPRWXQGHUYLVQLQJHQ'HUHWWHUPnO UHUHQV¡NHnRSSUHWWKROGHHOHYHQVHQJDVMHPHQW / UHUHQNDQGDIRUV¡NHnUDPPHLQQ RJnJM¡UHXQGHUYLVQLQJVLQQKROGHWVnDWWUDNWLYWRJOHWW IRUVWnHOLJVRP PXOLJ,GHWWHDUEHLGHWYLOKXQHNVHPSHOYLVGHOHRSSJDYHUHOOHUSUHVHQWDVMRQHU LQQLPLQGUHHQKHWHURJEHQ\WWHVHJDYXOLNHIRUPHUIRUNRQNUHWLVHULQJHU(QVOLNLQQUDPPLQJ I¡UHUWLODWYLVVHVLGHUWUHUIUDPLO\VHWPHQVDQGUHKDYQHULEDNJUXQQHQ%UXNHQ DYNULWHULHW IRNXVHULQJYLOVOLNVHWWE\JJHSnSULRULWHULQJHU
(PRVMRQV\WULQJ
,I¡OJH.OHLQUHWWHVV¡NHO\VHWLGHWWHNULWHULHWPRWGHHPRVMRQHOOHVLGHQHYHGHQLQWHUDNVMRQ
$QDGXOW¶VEHKDYLRXUZKLFKH[SUHVVHVYHUEDORUQRQYHUEDODSSUHFLDWLRQRUDIIHFW LQUHODWLRQWRREMHFWVDQLPDOVSHRSOHFRQFHSWVDQGYDOXHV7KHPHGLDWRUHQGRZV WKHVHVWLPXOLZLWKIHHOLQJDQGPHDQLQJVRWKDWWKH\³VWDQGRXW´LQWKH&KLOGV H[SHULHQFH.OHLQ
.ULWHULHWNDQWRONHVGLWKHQDWGHHPRVMRQHOOHXWWU\NNHQHHQYRNVHQEHQ\WWHULWLONQ\WQLQJWLOHW WHPDVRPSUHVHQWHUHVHOOHUGLVNXWHUHVPHGHWEDUQYLONXQQHWLOI¡UHEDUQHWHQ
PHQLQJVGLPHQVMRQLVDPPHQKHQJPHGGHWDNWXHOOHWHPDHW'HWNDQVNMHYHGDWGHQYRNVQH XWWU\NNHUIRUHNVHPSHOHQWXVLDVPHHOOHUHQJDVMHPHQW
)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ YLVHUWLODWPHGLHULQJDYNULWHULHWHPRVMRQV\WULQJNDQKDWR KRYHGIRUPnO'HWI¡UVWHNDQLOOXVWUHUHVPHGXWJDQJVSXQNWLVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ'HUVRPHQ O UHUXWWU\NNHUEHJHLVWULQJLWLONQ\WQLQJWLO DUEHLGPHGHWO UHVWRIINDQGHWI¡UHWLODWHOHYHQ RSSOHYHUDWGHWHUYLNWLJnWLOHJQHVHJO UHVWRIIHW'HUPHG¡NHUHOHYHQVPRWLYDVMRQQRHVRPL QHVWHRPJDQJNDQI¡UHWLOVW¡UUHVDQQV\QOLJKHWIRUDWHOHYHQWLOHJQHUVHJGHWDNWXHOOH
O UHVWRIIHW(WIRUPnO NDQPHGDQGUHRUGY UHnV¡NHRJ RSSQn¡NWPRWLYDVMRQKRVHOHYHQLHQ NRQNUHWVLWXDVMRQ
'HWDQGUHIRUPnOHWNDQVHVSnVRPPHURYHURUGQHW)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ HURSSWDWW DYKYRUGDQYRNVQHVPHGLHULQJDYHPRVMRQV\WULQJHULLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGEDUQNDQI¡UHWLODW EDUQDLVW¡UUHJUDGO UHUVHJnV¡NHHWWHUPHQLQJLWLOY UHOVHQJHQHUHOW%DUQE¡UJHQHUHOW XWYLNOHHYQHQ WLOnVWLOOHNULWLVNHVS¡UVPnO RJWLOnV¡NHHWWHUEHJUXQQHOVHUIRUKYRUIRUKDQHOOHU KXQYHOJHUnKDQGOHSnEHVWHPWPnWHU'HWNDQGHEOLIOLQNHUHWLOJMHQQRPnWDGHOLYRNVQHV HPRVMRQV\WULQJHU
6DPWLGLJJLUHPRVMRQV\WULQJHUIUDHQYRNVHQWLOHWEDUQJUXQQODJIRUHWLVNUHIOHNVMRQ'HWNDQ VWLOOHVVS¡UVPnOYHGPHGKYLONHQUHWWHQYRNVHQNDQIRUPLGOHRJSnG\WWHHJQHPHQLQJHUSnHW EDUQVLGHQGHQYRNVQHVDWIHUGVXWWU\NNNDQSnYLUNHEDUQHWVDWIHUGLNNHEDUHLVLWXDVMRQHQPHQ RJVnIUDPWLGLJHPHQLQJHURJKDQGOLQJHU'HQQHW\SHQUHIOHNVMRQHUKDUEODQWDQQHWI¡UWWLO SHGDJRJLVNHUHWQLQJHURJXQGHUYLVQLQJVPHWRGHUKYRUO UHUHLVW¡UUHJUDGKDUIRUV¡NWnRSSWUH PHVWPXOLJQ¡\WUDOWRJWLOEDNHKROGQH)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ WDUDYVWDQGIUDHQVOLN SHGDJRJLVNSUDNVLV'HNULWLVHUHUEnGHGHWPRGHUQHVDPIXQQHWRJVNROHQIRUnY UHIRUOLWH PHQLQJVRULHQWHUWLVLQIRUPLGOLQJWLOGHQRSSYRNVHQGHVOHNW'HYLVHUWLO DWPDQJHOSn PHGLHULQJDYPHQLQJIUDYRNVHQL\WWHUVWHNRQVHNYHQVNDQI¡UHWLODWEDUQHWInUHQRSSOHYHOVH DYPDQJHOSnPHQLQJLWLOY UHOVHQJHQHUHOW
)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ SHNHUSnDWEDUQHWVHYQHWLOVHOYVWHQGLJnV¡NHPHQLQJL WLOY UHOVHQNXQNDQXWYLNOHVJMHQQRPNRQWLQXHUOLJPHGLHULQJIUDYRNVQH,GHQIRUELQGHOVH VWLOOHVGHWNUDYWLOGHQYRNVQHVSHUVRQOLJHHJHQVNDSHU RJUHODVMRQHQWLOGHWDNWXHOOHEDUQHW, VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJVVDPPHQKHQJNDQGHWLQQHE UHDWHOHYHQPnRSSOHYHO UHUHQVRP EHW\GQLQJVIXOOIRUDWHOHYHQVNDORSSOHYHO UHUHQVHPRVMRQV\WULQJHUVRPEHW\GQLQJVIXOOH
8WYLGHOVH
.OHLQJLUI¡OJHQGHEHVNULYHOVHDYNULWHULHWXWYLGHOVH
,QVLPSOHWHUPVH[SDQGLQJLVSUHVHQWZKHQWKHFDUHJLYHUWULHVWRH[WHQGWKHFKLOG¶V XQGHUVWDQGLQJRIZKDWLVLQIURQWRIKLPE\H[SODLQLQJFRPSDULQJRUDGGLQJQHZ H[SHULHQFHVWKDWP\QRWEHQHFHVVDU\IRUWKHRQJRLQJLQWHUDFWLRQ.OHLQ .ULWHULHWNDQWRONHVWLOnRPKDQGOHHQVLWXDVMRQKYRUHQYRNVHQV¡NHUnXWYLGHEDUQHWV IRUVWnHOVHRPNULQJGHWWHPDHWVRPHULVHQWUXPIRULQWHUDNVMRQHQ'HWWHNDQVNMHYHGDW RPVRUJVSHUVRQHQHQWHQNRPPHUPHGIRUNODULQJHUVDPPHQOLJQLQJHUHOOHUWLOI¡UHUQ\H
HUIDULQJHUVRPLNNHGLUHNWHIUDPVWnUVRPXPLGGHOEDUWQ¡GYHQGLJHLGHQSnJnHQGH LQWHUDNVMRQHQ
0HGLHULQJDYNULWHULHWXWYLGHOVHKDUIOHUHIRUPnO)RUGHWI¡UVWHNDQEDUQHWInPXOLJKHWWLOnVH VDPPHQKHQJHUPHOORPWLGOLJHUHWLOHJQHWNXQQVNDSRJNXQQVNDSVRPWHPDWLVHUHVLHQ SnJnHQGHLQWHUDNVMRQ6OLNVHWWYLOLQIRUPDVMRQVRPIRUPLGOHVDYHQYRNVHQNXQQHEOLPHU VROLGIRUDQNUHWLEDUQHWVIRUVWnHOVHIRUGLEDUQHWYLOVHDWGHQQHNDQUHODWHUHVWLOXOLNH VLWXDVMRQHU(OHYHQVNXQQVNDSYLOVnOHGHVNXQQHEHWUDNWHVVRPPHUIOHNVLEHO)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ
(WDQQHWIRUPnOHUnXWYLNOHEDUQHWVHJHQHYQHWLOnV¡NHHWWHUQ\NXQQVNDS
7KLVFULWHULRQUHODWHVWRWKHIDFWWKDWWKURXJKDQ0/(W\SHRILQWHUDFWLRQWKHJRDO RIWKHLQWHUDFWLRQLVH[SDQGLQJDQGJRLQJEH\RQGWKHLPPHGLDWHH[SHULHQFHIURP LWVLPPHGLDWHSUHFHGHQWDQGFRQVHTXHQFHVWRRWKHUVUHPRWHLQWLPHDQGVSDFH$
PHGLDWHGH[SHULHQFHLVQRWUHVWULFWHGWRWKHVDWLVIDFWLRQRILPPHGLDWHQHHGV,WLV E\JRLQJEH\RQGWKHLPPHGLDWHWKDWVWUXFWXUDOFKDQJHVRFFXULQWKHFKLOG VWUXFWXUDOFKDQJHVLQWKHVHQVHRIDQWLFLSDWLRQVHDUFKIRUQHHGIRULQIRUPDWLRQ EH\RQGWKHLPPHGLDWH.OHLQ
.OHLQVSRHQJV\QHVnY UHDWEDUQVRPKDUK\SSLJHUIDULQJPHGYRNVQHVPHGLHULQJDY NULWHULHWXWYLGHOVHNDQWLOHJQHVHJVWUDWHJLHUVRPJM¡UDWEDUQHWNRQWLQXHUOLJYLOY UHV¡NHQGHL IRUKROGWLOXWYLGHOVHDYHJHQ NXQQVNDSJHQHUHOW(WVOLNWEDUQIUDPVWnUJMHUQHVRPQ\VJMHUULJ RJXWIRUVNHQGH2YHUI¡UWWLOVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJHUGHWVDQQV\QOLJDWHQO UHUVRPDNWLYW MREEHUIRUnVWLPXOHUHHOHYHUNQ\WWHWWLONXQQVNDSVXWYLGHOVHYLONXQQHRSSQnLQWHUDNVMRQHU PHGHOHYHUKYRUEHJJHSDUWHUMREEHUPRWHWIHOOHVPnORPXWYLGHOVHXWYLNOLQJRJRYHUVNULGHOVH DYHNVLVWHUHQGHNXQQVNDS
,VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJYLONULWHULHWLSUDNVLVNXQQHYLVHVHJYHGDWO UHUHQELGUDUPHG IRUNODULQJHUVDPPHQOLJQLQJHURJHUIDULQJHULWLONQ\WQLQJWLOO UHVWRII(WHNVHPSHOKHUNDQ Y UHHQO UHUVRPXQGHUYLVHUHQHOHYVRPVWUHYHUPHGPDWHPDWLNN7HPDHWXQGHU
LQWHUDNVMRQHQHUDGGLVMRQPHGWDOOXQGHUWL,WLOOHJJWLOnIRNXVHUHSnGHWHNQLVNHVLGHQHYHGGH PDWHPDWLVNHRSHUDVMRQHQHHUO UHUHQRSSWDWWDYnPHGLHUHWLOHOHYHQLKYLONHSUDNWLVNH VDPPHQKHQJHUHOHYHQNDQInEUXNIRUnNXQQHDGGHUHPHGWDOO/ UHUHQSU¡YHULGHQ IRUELQGHOVHnNRQNUHWLVHUHNM¡SRJVDOJVVLWXDVMRQHUPHGEUXNDYSHQJHU(WDQQHWHNVHPSHO NDQRPKDQGOHXWYLGHOVHDYHOHYHQVEHJUHSVIRUVWnHOVH/DRVVVLDWGHQVDPPHJXWWHQVWUHYHU PHGnNQ\WWHHWLQQKROGWLOGHEHJUHSHQHKDQOHVHU,HQXQGHUYLVQLQJVVHNYHQVV¡NHUO UHUHQ
GHUIRUnInHOHYHQWLOn¡NHIRUVWnHOVHQDYEHJUHSHWVQ¡,GHQIRUELQGHOVHSU¡YHUO UHUHQRJ HOHYHQJMHQQRPGLDORJnNRPPHIUDPWLONDUDNWHULVWLVNHNMHQQHWHJQRJHJHQVNDSHUYHG IHQRPHQHWVQ¡
)HXHUVWHLQRJ5DQGYLVHUWLODWO UHUHVRPMREEHUPHGHOHYHUPHGO UHYDQVNHURIWHKDU HQWHQGHQVWLOnQHGSULRULWHUHEUXNHQDYNULWHULHWXWYLGHOVH'HWNDQEODQWDQQHWVN\OGHVDW O UHUQHPDQJOHUWLOWURRJIRUKnSQLQJHUWLOGLVVHHOHYHQHVXWYLNOLQJVSRWHQVLDO,O\VDYGHWWH V\QVSXQNWHWNDQ GHWY UHHQXWIRUGULQJnIRUV¡NHRJ EHYLVVWJM¡UHO UHUHVRPMREEHUPHG VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJRPKYRUVHQWUDOWPHGLHULQJDYNULWHULHWXWYLGHOVHNDQY UHIRUHQHOHYV NXQQVNDSVXWYLNOLQJ
.RPSHWDQVH
1nU)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ RJ.OHLQRPWDOHUNULWHULHWNRPSHWDQVHV\QHVGHn JLGHWHWLQQKROGVRPSnQRUVNNDQRYHUVHWWHPHGEHJUHSHWURV0HQL RJPHGDWGLVVH IRUIDWWHUQHEHQ\WWHUNRPSHWDQVHVRPEHWHJQHOVHSnNULWHULHWDQYHQGHVGHWWHEHJUHSHWRJVnL GHQQHDYKDQGOLQJHQ1nURUGHWNRPSHWDQVHEHQ\WWHVLDYKDQGOLQJHQKDUGHWLPLGOHUWLGHW LQQKROGVRP NDQ DQVHVIRUnKDHQOLJQHQGHEHW\GQLQJVRP EHWHJQHOVHQ URV
(Q KHQVLNWPHGnEHQ\WWHNULWHULHWNRPSHWDQVHLHQLQWHUDNVMRQHUnELGUDWLODWEDUQHWRSSQnU HQ¡NWRSSOHYHOVHDYPHVWULQJLWLONQ\WQLQJWLOGHDNWLYLWHWHQHVRPEDUQHWXW¡YHUL HQNRQNUHW VLWXDVMRQ%nGH)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ RJ.OHLQIUHPPHULPLGOHUWLG V\QVSXQNWHUVRPYLVHUDWPHGLHULQJDYNRPSHWDQVHRJVnHUYLNWLJLHWVW¡UUHSHUVSHNWLY )HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQSHNHUEODQWDQQHWSnDWHWEDUQVHNVLVWHQVLVHJVHOYLNNHJLU QRHQJDUDQWLIRUHQJHQHUHOORSSOHYHOVHDYPHVWULQJ9LPHQQHVNHUKDULOLWHQJUDGNRQWUROO RYHUGHIDNWRUHQHVRPSnYLUNHUYnUHOLY(QHUNMHQQHOVHDYDWYnUHNVLVWHQVHUDYKHQJLJDY WLOIHOGLJKHWHUI¡UHUWLODWYLRIWHNDQRSSOHYHPDQJHOSnPHVWULQJLWLOY UHOVHQJHQHUHOW%DUQ WUHQJHUDYGHQJUXQQDWYRNVQHKMHOSHUGHPWLOnVHKYDGHNDQPHVWUHRJKYRUGDQGHNDQIn EUXNWVLQHIHUGLJKHWHUSnIRUVNMHOOLJHDUHQDHU
1RHDYGHWVDPPHSHUVSHNWLYHWWUHNNHVIUDPDY.OHLQ
7KURXJKPHGLDWLRQRIIHHOLQJVRI FRPSHWHQFHWKHFKLOGDFTXLUHVDVHQVHRI PDVWHU\DIHHOLQJWKDWKHVKHLVFDSDEOHDQGVXFFHVVIXOZKLFKFRQWULEXWHVQR GRXEWWRDZLOOLQJQHVVWRH[SORUHWKHQHZDQGWRDWWHPSWWRDSSO\RQHVHOIWRQHZ
DQGFKDOOHQJLQJHQGHDYRXUV,IZHZDQWWRHQFRXUDJHFXULRVLW\DQGDFWLYH
H[SORUDWLRQZHPXVWHQFRXUDJHPHGLDWHGIHHOLQJRIFRPSHWHQFH.OHLQ
*MHQQRPYRNVQHVPHGLHULQJDYNRPSHWDQVHNDQEDUQ RSSQnHQRSSOHYHOVHDYPHVWULQJRJHQ I¡OHOVHDYDWGHHUG\NWLJH'HWWHNDQLJMHQ JLVHJXWVODJLDWEDUQHWVWLPXOHUHVWLOQ\VJMHUULJKHW DNWLYXWIRUVNQLQJRJV¡NLQJHWWHUXWIRUGULQJHU
1nUGHWJMHOGHUKYRUGDQEDUQVNDOInPHVWULQJVRSSOHYHOVHUSHNHU)HXHUVWHLQSnQRHQVHQWUDOH DVSHNWHU
:KDWWKHQLVWKHVRXUFHRIIHHOLQJVRIFRPSHWHQFH"2IFRXUVHLQRUGHUWRIHHO FRPSHWHQFHRQHKDVWREHFRPSHWHQW2WKHUZLVHWKHIHHOLQJRIFRPSHWHQFHLV XQUHDODQGKDVLWVRUJLQVRQO\LQIDQWDV\OLIH%XWSRVVHVVLQJFRPSHWHQFHGRHVQRW JXDUDQWHHDFRQYLFWLRQWKDWRQHSRVVHVVHVLW7KHIHHOLQJKDVWREHUHIOHFWHGLQWKH YLHZVRIRWKHUVDQGLQWKHLQWHUSUHWDWLRQJLYHQE\WKHPWRRQHVEHKDYLRXUDV PDQLIHVWLQJFRPSHWHQFH)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ
)RUGHWI¡UVWHPnEDUQHWY UHNRPSHWHQWLWLONQ\WQLQJWLOGHRSSJDYHQHGHWVNDOJMHQQRPI¡UH
%DUQHWVPHVWULQJDYRSSJDYHUHULPLGOHUWLGLNNHWLOVWUHNNHOLJ9LGHUHHUPHVWULQJVRSSOHYHOVHU LNNHEDUHHWGLUHNWHSURGXNWDYEDUQHWVNDSDVLWHWNQ\WWHWWLOHQRSSJDYHPHQOLNHP\HHW SURGXNWDYGHWRONQLQJHUYRNVQHPHGLHUHUWLOEDUQQnUGHWJMHOGHUEDUQVXWI¡ULQJDYRSSJDYHU 1HGHQIRUGLVNXWHUHVQRHQXIRUGULQJHUNQ\WWHWWLOO UHUHVEUXNDYNULWHULHWNRPSHWDQVHL VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ
1nUHQO UHUVNDOWLOUHWWHOHJJHIRUPHVWULQJVRSSOHYHOVHUIRUHQHOHYPnO UHUHQJHQHUHOWV¡NHn WLOSDVVHXQGHUYLVQLQJHQVOLNDWHOHYHQP¡WHUIOHVWPXOLJHVLWXDVMRQHUVRPJLUPXOLJKHWIRU PHVWULQJ'HWYLOEODQWDQQHWLQQHE UHDWO UHUHQWDUXWJDQJVSXQNWLO UHVWRIIVRPPnY UH WLOSDVVHWHOHYHQVO UHIRUXWVHWQLQJHU'HUVRP O UHVWRIIHWHUIRUNRPSOLVHUWHOOHUIRUIMHUQWIUD HOHYHQVHUIDULQJVYHUGHQYLOGHWXDQVHWWKYRUG\NWLJO UHUHQHUY UHXPXOLJnInWLOJRGH PHVWULQJVRSSOHYHOVHUIRUHOHYHQ$YVWDQGHQPHOORPHOHYHQVO UHIRUXWVHWQLQJHURJO UHVWRIIHW YLOY UHIRUVWRU,WLOOHJJPnO UHUHQIRUV¡NHnWLOUHWWOHJJHKYHUHQNHOWO ULQJVDNWLYLWHWSnHQ VOLNPnWHDWHOHYHQKDUPXOLJKHWIRUnPHVWUHGHQHQNHOWHDNWLYLWHWHQ,SUDNVLVNDQGHWEODQW DQQHWLQQHE UHnJLHOHYHQWLOVWUHNNHOLJPHGLQIRUPDVMRQIRUnO¡VHHQEHVWHPWRSSJDYHRJ KMHOSHHOHYHQWLOnRSSQnHQKYLVJUDGDYSUHVLVMRQLXWI¡ULQJHQ/ UHUHQPnPHGDQGUHRUG IRUV¡NHnUDPPHLQQRSSJDYHQRJVLWXDVMRQHQSnHQVOLNPnWHDWHOHYHQNODUHUnXWI¡UH RSSJDYHQPHVWPXOLJNRUUHNW
,IRUELQGHOVHPHGO UHUHVDUEHLGPHGHOHYHUPHGVSHVLHOOHEHKRYHU)HXHUVWHLQRJ5DQG RSSWDWWDYnInIUDPXWIRUGULQJHUVRPO UHUHVWLOOHVRYHUIRU0DQJHHOHYHUVRPPRWWDU VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJNDQRIWHKDHQVNROHEDNJUXQQSUHJHWDYK\SSLJHRSSOHYHOVHUDYPDQJHO SnI¡OHOVHDYPHVWULQJ'HVHUDWGHLNNHEHKHUVNHURSSJDYHURJXQGHUYLVQLQJVDNWLYLWHWHUOLNH JRGWVRPDQGUHEDUQ'LVVHHOHYHQHVJMHQWDWWHRSSOHYHOVHUDYIDJOLJWLONRUWNRPPLQJJM¡UDWGH NDQKDEHKRYIRUHQEHW\GHOLJPHQJGHURVSnVLQHSUHVWDVMRQHUIRUnRSSQnHQI¡OHOVHDY PHVWULQJ6DPWLGLJSHNHU)HXHUVWHLQRJ5DQGSnDWHQGHODYGLVVHHOHYHQHP¡WHUIRUIn XWIRUGULQJHULVNROHVDPPHQKHQJ1RHQO UHUHNDQEOLIRUIRNXVHUWSnGLVVHHOHYHQHVWULYVHO (QNRQVHNYHQVNDQGDEOLDWHQNHOWHO UHUHURVHUHOHYHQHXDQVHWWKYRUGDQSUHVWDVMRQHQHU'HW NDQKHYGHVDWRSSOHYHOVHDYnPLVO\NNHVLIRUNDQWDYnEHKHUVNHHQRSSJDYHRJVnHUHWOHGGL GHWnRSSOHYHPHVWULQJ/ UHUHVEUXNDY URVE¡UGHUPHGYXUGHUHVXWIUDGHQHQNHOWHHOHYVLQH LQGLYLGXHOOHEHKRY RJGHQDNWXHOOHVLWXDVMRQHQ
/LNHYLNWLJVRPDWYRNVQHHUEHYLVVWKYRUGDQGHDQYHQGHUURVRYHQIRUEDUQNDQGHWY UHDW URVHQI¡OJHVRSSPHGNRQNUHWHWLOEDNHPHOGLQJHUSnSUHVWDVMRQHQH'HWHURIWHLNNHQRNn IRUPLGOHWLOHWEDUQDWHQRSSJDYHHUJRGWXWI¡UW'HDVSHNWHQHYHGSUHVWDVMRQHQVRPYDUJRGH E¡UNRQNUHWLVHUHVRJEHVNULYHV'HWKDUIOHUHKHQVLNWHU)RUGHWI¡UVWHNDQEDUQHWEOL
EHYLVVWJMRUWKYLONHVLGHUYHGSUHVWDVMRQHQVRPYDUEUD'HUPHG¡NHUVDQQV\QOLJKHWHQIRU RYHUI¡ULQJWLODQGUHVLWXDVMRQHU,WLOOHJJYLOGHQYRNVQHVPHGLHULQJIUDPVWnVRPPHUWURYHUGLJ IRUGLEDUQVDPPHQOLJQHUHJQHRJDQGUHVSUHVWDVMRQHU'HUVRPGHVHUDWDQGUHEDUQXWI¡UHU RSSJDYHUHQGDEHGUHHQGHPVHOYHUGHWHQPXOLJKHWIRUDWGHQYRNVQHVURVLNNHYLOELGUDWLO PHVWULQJVRSSOHYHOVHUXWHQDWURVHQEOLUNRQNUHWLVHUW)HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ
$WIHUGVUHJXOHULQJ
,IRUELQGHOVHPHGNULWHULHWDWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJSnSHNHU.OHLQI¡OJHQGH
7KHDGXOWE\PRGHOOLQJGHPRQVWUDWLQJRUE\VFKHGXOLQJREMHFWVRUHYHQWVLQWLPH DQGVSDFHLQWURGXFHVDSDWWHUQSODQRIDFWLYLWLHVIRUWKHFKLOGWKXVUHJXODWLQJWKH SDFHDQGUHGXFLQJWKHFKLOG¶VLPSXOVLYHQHVVLQSHUFHSWLRQHODERUDWLRQDQG H[SUHVVLRQ5HJXODWLRQRIEHKDYLRXUHQWDLOVPDWFKLQJWKHFKDUDFWHULVWLFVRIWKH WDVNWREHSHUIRUPHGZLWKWKHFKLOG¶VFDSDFLWLHVDQGLQWHUHVWVDVZHOODVWURXJK RUJDQL]LQJHQGVHTXHQFLQJVWHSVWRZDUGVXFFHVV.OHLQ
$WIHUGVUHJXOHULQJRPKDQGOHUKYRUGDQHQYRNVHQJLUHWEDUQLQIRUPDVMRQVRPNDQKMHOSH EDUQHWWLOnO¡VHHQ RSSJDYHHOOHUJMHQQRPI¡UHHQDNWLYLWHW,QIRUPDVMRQHQGHQYRNVQHJLU
ELGUDUWLODWEDUQHWNODUHUnWLOSDVVHDWIHUGHQSnHQVOLNPnWHDWXWI¡UVHOHQDYDNWLYLWHWHQEOLU EHGUHHQQGHWEDUQHWKDGGHNODUWSnHJHQKnQGXWHQGHQYRNVQHVUHJXOHULQJ
,OLNKHWPHGGHIRUHJnHQGHNULWHULHQHVWUHNNHUIRUPnOHWPHGGHWWHNULWHULHWVHJRJVnXWRYHUn KMHOSHEDUQHWLHQNRQNUHWVLWXDVMRQ.OHLQYLVHUWLODWEDUQVRPK\SSLJInUWLOJDQJWLO YRNVQHVPHGLHULQJDY GHWWHNULWHULHWLVW¡UUHJUDGNODUHUnUHJXOHUHHJHQDWIHUGLDUEHLGPHG RSSJDYHU'HWNDQIRUHNVHPSHOEHW\DWEDUQHWEOLUIOLQNHUHWLOnSODQOHJJHI¡UGHWKDQGOHURJ DWJMHQQRPI¡ULQJHQLIRUOHQJHOVHQEOLUPHUSUHVLV7R¡YULJHDVSHNWHU.OHLQWUHNNHUIUDPHUDW EDUQO UHUnEOLPHUPnOUHWWHWLVLQHKDQGOLQJHURJInUEHGUHSUREOHPO¡VQLQJVHYQH
7RPRPHQWHU)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ WUHNNHUIUDPLIRUELQGHOVHPHGNULWHULHW DWIHUGVUHJXOHULQJHUHYQHWLOLQKLELWLHULQJRJLQLWLHULQJDYDWIHUG1nUHWEDUQPRWWDUVWLPXOLIUD RPYHUGHQHQYLOGHWPnWWHIRUKROGHVHJWLOGLVVHVWLPXOLHQH'DYLOLQKLELWLHULQJRJLQLWLHULQJ DYDWIHUGY UHWRVWUDWHJLHUEDUQHWWUHQJHUnKDXWYLNOHWIRUDWUHVSRQVHQHVNDOY UHPHVWPXOLJ WLOSDVVHWGHQDNWXHOOHVLWXDVMRQHQ
1RHQEDUQKDUHQWHQGHQVWLOnY UHIRULPSXOVVW\UWH'HWKDUVRPNRQVHNYHQVDWGHJMHUQH UHDJHUHURJKDQGOHULIRUKROGWLOVWLPXOLI¡UGHKDUInWWWHQNWVHJRP'HUPHGEOLUKDQGOLQJHQH JMHUQHOLWHSUHVLVH(NVHPSHOIUDVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVLQJNDQY UHHQHOHYVRPEOLUEHGWRPn RSSJLVYDUSnHQPDWHPDWLNNRSSJDYHRJVRPJMHWWHUVYDUHWXWHQnWDVHJWLGWLOnEHDUEHLGH UHJQHVW\NNHWI¡UO¡VQLQJVIRUVODJHWSUHVHQWHUHV(WVOLNWEDUQYLOKDEHKRYIRUKMHOSWLOnO UH VHJnWHQNHVHJRPI¡UVYDUHWSUHVHQWHUHV(YQHQWLOnWDVHJGHQQ¡GYHQGLJHWLGHQNDQ RPWDOHVVRPLQKLELWLHULQJDYDWIHUG7UHQLQJSnLQKLELWLHULQJDYDWIHUGNDQLQQHE UHDWO UHUHQ ELGUDUWLOnEHYLVVWJM¡UHHOHYHQSnQ¡GYHQGLJKHWHQDYnKROGHWLOEDNHUHVSRQVHUI¡UHOHYHQKDU VNDIIHWVHJWLOVWUHNNHOLJRYHUVLNWRYHUVLWXDVMRQHQ
)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ YLVHULGHQVDPPHQKHQJHQWLODWQRHQO UHUHNDQEOLIRU SURGXNWRULHQWHUWHLVLQXQGHUYLVQLQJ'HWLQQE UHUDWGHEOLUIRURSSWDWWDYDWHOHYHUO¡VHU RSSJDYHUUDVNWRJNRUUHNWRJLNNHIRNXVHUHUSnKYRUGDQHOHYHQHNRPIUDPWLO
O¡VQLQJVIRUVODJHW6OLNHO UHUHNDQKDWHQGHQVWLOnEOLIRUXWnOPRGLJHPHGWDQNHSnnInHOHYHU WLOnNRPPHPHGGHWUHWWHVYDUHW 'HWWHNDQI¡UHWLODWO UHUHQVHOYRSSJLUVYDUHWHOOHUJLUDQGUH HOHYHUPXOLJKHWHQWLOnNRPPHPHGIRUVODJWLORSSJDYHO¡VQLQJ(OHYHUVRPKDUEHKRYIRUWLG NDQGDOHWWEOLYXUGHUWVRPLQNRPSHWHQWH.RQVHNYHQVHQNDQEOLDWHQNHOWHHOHYHUIRUV¡NHUn XWWU\NNHVYDUIRUVODJOHQJHI¡UGHLUHDOLWHWHQHUNODUHWLOnJLHQUHVSRQV(QVOLNW\SH
O UHUDWIHUGNDQELGUDWLOnKLQGUHXWYLNOLQJDYHOHYHQHVHYQHWLOnUHJXOHUHHJHQDWIHUGRJ KHOOHUELGUDWLOnIUHPPHLPSXOVVW\UWDWIHUG
)RUDQGUHEDUQYLOLPLGOHUWLGGHWPRWVDWWHY UHWLOIHOOHW'HHUIOLQNHWLOnWDVHJWLGWLOn EHDUEHLGHLPSXOVHURJnVNDIIHVHJRYHUVLNW'HVWUHYHULPLGOHUWLGPHGnXWWU\NNHUHVSRQVHU HOOHULJDQJVHWWHKDQGOLQJHU'LVVHHOHYHQHNDQKDEHKRYIRUWUHQLQJSnnO UHRJLQLWLHUH KDQGOLQJHUUDVNHUH9LVHUKHUKYRUGDQXQGHUYLVQLQJNQ\WWHWWLOLQKLELWLHULQJRJLQLWLHULQJDY DWIHUGE¡UWLOSDVVHVGHQHQNHOWHHOHYVLQHEHKRY)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG
$OOHGHIHPNULWHULHQHVRPHUSUHVHQWHUWRYHQIRUKDUWLOIHOOHVDWGHHUJXQVWLJHnEHQ\WWHIRUHQ YRNVHQHOOHUHQO UHULHQNRQNUHWVLWXDVMRQ%UXNHQDYNULWHULHWIRNXVHULQJNDQI¡UHWLODWHQ HOHYNODUHUnUHWWH RSSPHUNVRPKHWHQPRWO UHVWRIIHW(PRVMRQV\WULQJNDQELGUDWLODWHOHYHQ EOLUHQJDVMHUW8WYLGHOVHNDQOHGHWLODWHOHYHQRSSQnU¡NWLQQVLNW.RPSHWDQVHNDQI¡UHWLODW HOHYHQInU¡NW WLOWURWLOHJHQSUHVWDVMRQVHYQH$WIHUGVUHJXOHULQJNDQJLHOHYHQLQIRUPDVMRQRP KYRUGDQ KDQNDQDUEHLGHPHGO UHVWRII9LGHUHKDUDOOHNULWHULHQHGHWWLOIHOOHVDWGHLI¡OJH .OHLQRJ)HXHUVWHLQ RJ)HXHUVWHLQ LQQHKDUHJHQVNDSHUVRPJM¡UDWGHNDQI¡UH WLODWEDUQHWJHQHUHOWEOLUIOLQNHUHWLOnSURILWHUHSnIUDPWLGLJHO ULQJVHUIDULQJHU
'LVVHIHPNULWHULHQHEOLULGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWEHQ\WWHWVRPXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUnXWDUEHLGH RSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHUWLODQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWHWVRPVHQHUHDQYHQGHVLWLONQ\WQLQJWLOnEHO\VH KRYHGSUREOHPVVWLOOLQJHQ.ULWHULHQHNDQ VnOHGHVKHYGHVnELGUDPHGHWWHRUHWLVNIXQGDPHQW VRPJLUQRHQUDPPHUIRUXWYLNOLQJHQDYRSHUDVMRQDOLVHULQJHQH
.U LWLVNYXU GHU LQJDY)HXHU VWHLQVWHRU L
,WHRULNDSLWOHWKDUGHWVnODQJWEOLWWODJWYHNWSnnSUHVHQWHUHXOLNHDVSHNWHUYHG)HXHUVWHLQV XWYLNOLQJVWHRUL'HQQHYHNWOHJJLQJHQVN\OGHVDWWHRULHQIUDPVWnUVRPVY UWVHQWUDOL
IRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHW,GHWWHDYVQLWWHWEOLUQRHQNULWLVNHPRPHQWHUNQ\WWHWWLOnDQYHQGHWHRULHQL VWXGLHQ GLVNXWHUW
7HRULHQWDUXWJDQJVSXQNWLWRIRU VNMHOOLJHDQDO\VHQLYn
'HWKDUWLGOLJHUHIUDPNRPPHWDW)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULNDQIUDPVWnVRPWRGHOW RJDWEHWHJQHOVHQH NRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWRJPHGLHUWO ULQJPDUNHUHUGHOLQJHQ DYWHRULHQ)HXHUVWHLQ
)HXHUVWHLQ)HXHUVWHLQ HWDO )HXHUVWHLQHWDO,DYVQLWWHWVRPWRNIRUVHJ )HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULRJNRJQLWLYYLWHQVNDSEOHGHWEHVNUHYHWKYRUGDQGLVVHWRGHOHQH V\QHVnIRNXVHUHSnIRUVNMHOOLJHDQDO\VHQLYnHU0HGDQDO\VHQLYnPHQHVKHUGHWWHRULHQ UHWWHU V¡NHO\VHWPRWPHGWDQNHSnnEHO\VHPHQQHVNHOLJDWIHUGDNWLYLWHWHOOHUWHQNQLQJ
'HQGHOHQDYWHRULHQVRPRPKDQGOHUNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWV\QHVVRPI¡UQHYQWn EHVNULYHGHSURVHVVHQHVRPVNMHULQQHLLQGLYLGHWLIRUELQGHOVHPHGNRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJ .RJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWHUEHWHJQHOVHQSnHQSURVHVVVRPVNMHUKRVLQGLYLGHWQnU YHGNRPPHQGHRSSQnUHQYHVHQWOLJRJYDULJIRUEHGULQJNQ\WWHWWLONRJQLWLYXWYLNOLQJVRP VNLOOHUVHJIUDGHWVRPEOLUDQWDWWnY UHIRUYHQWHWXWYLNOLQJ7HRULHQ V\QHVKHUnE\JJHSnHW NXQQVNDSVV\Q VRPWLOVLHUDWNXQQVNDSHUQRHPHQQHVNHWLOHJQHUVHJRJVRPODJUHVLQQHL LQGLYLGHWLIRUPDYHQGULQJHUDYLQGUHNRJQLWLYHVWUXNWXUHU$QDO\VHQLYnHWVRPWUHUIUDPL IRUELQGHOVHPHGNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWHUGHUPHGLQGLYLGHWVLQGUHNRJQLWLYHSURVHVVHU
'HQDQGUHGHOHQDYWHRULHQVRPRPKDQGOHUPHGLHUWO ULQJEHO\VHUNMHQQHWHJQ HOOHU HJHQVNDSHUYHGLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORPLQGLYLGHU+HUUHWWHVGHWGHUPHGV¡NHO\VPRWHWDQQHW DQDO\VHQLYnHQQLGHWVRPRPKDQGOHUNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHW,IRUELQGHOVHPHGDWWHRULHQ EHVNULYHUWRVnXOLNHDQDO\VHQLYnHUNDQGHWKHYGHVDWGHWHNVLVWHUHUVSHQQLQJHULWHRULHQ(W UHOHYDQWVS¡UVPnOLIRUOHQJHOVHQEOLURPWHRULHQGHUPHGIUDPVWnUVRPPRWVHWQLQJVIXOOHOOHU RPGHQNDQEHWHJQHVVRPHQVDPPHQKHQJHQGHRJKHOKHWOLJWHRUL"
(WDYGHPHVWVHQWUDOHHOHPHQWHQHL)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULV\QHVnY UHDWLQGLYLGHWI¡UVW RJIUHPVWNDQRSSQnNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWJMHQQRPPHGLHUWO ULQJ)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG )HXHUVWHLQ )HXHUVWHLQ+HQVLNWHQPHGPHGLHUWO ULQJHUGHUPHGVWLPXOHULQJDY LQGLYLGHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ'HWRGHOHQHNRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHWRJPHGLHUWO ULQJNDQDY GHQJUXQQLNNHVHVLVROHUWPHQPnVHVLVDPPHQKHQJ'HWNDQKHYGHVDWNRJQLWLY
PRGLILVHUEDUKHWIUDPVWnUVRPIXQGDPHQWHWVRPPHGLHUWO ULQJKYLOHUSn,WUnGPHGHQVOLN WRONQLQJNDQWHRULHQEHWHJQHVVRPHQKHOKHWOLJWHRULGHUPHGLHUWO ULQJPnIRUVWnVLO\VDY NRJQLWLYPRGLILVHUEDUKHW$YGHQJUXQQV\QHVWHRULHQnY UHHWHJQHWWHRUHWLVNSHUVSHNWLYVRP JUXQQODJIRUHWVSHVLDOSHGDJRJLVNIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLG
.DQWHRULHQKDJ\OGLJKHWLVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ"
,GHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWEOLU)HXHUVWHLQVWHRUL DQYHQGWVRPXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUnDQDO\VHUH LQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORPO UHUHRJHOHYHULVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ%HJUXQQHOVHQIRUnEHQ\WWH WHRULHQHUDWGHQSnEDNJUXQQDYDUJXPHQWDVMRQHQRYHQIRUNDQKHYGHVnELGUDPHGHWQ\WWLJ SHUVSHNWLYNQ\WWHWWLOnEHO\VHKYRUGDQHOHYHUVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJNDQVWLPXOHUHVL
XQGHUYLVQLQJVVDPPHQKHQJ%DNHQVOLNWRONQLQJOLJJHUWURHQSnDWO UHUHVEUXNDYPHGLHUW O ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGHOHYHUNDQELGUDWLOnIUHPPHHOHYHUVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ
(WNULWLVNVS¡UVPnOLGHQIRUELQGHOVHHURP)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULNDQKHYGHVnIDQJHRSS YLUNHOLJKHWHQ(UGHWVOLNDWO UHUHVDQYHQGHOVHDYPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGHOHYHU IDNWLVNELGUDUWLOnIUHPPHHOHYHUVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJLSUDNVLV"1DWXUOLJQRNE\JJHUGHWWH IRUVNLQJVDUEHLGHWSnHQDQWDJHOVHRPDW)HXHUVWHLQVXWYLNOLQJVWHRULKDUUHOHYDQVLSUDNVLVIHOWHW +YLVLNNHYLOOHGHWKDWWOLWHQKHQVLNWnDQYHQGHWHRULHQ'HWNDQKHQWHVVW¡WWHIRUHWVOLNWV\QIUD XOLNHKROG)HXHUVWHLQKDUJMHQQRPHWODQJWOLYXWDUEHLGHWRJXWYLNOHWWHRULHQ+DQKDUKHQWHW LQVSLUDVMRQIUDDQGUHIRUVNHUHVRPIRUHNVHPSHO3LDJHWVDPDUEHLGHWPHGDQGUHIRUVNHUHRJ JMRUWHJQHNOLQLVNHHUIDULQJHU%XUJHVV'HWNDQKHYGHVDW)HXHUVWHLQVVROLGHDUEHLGL VHJVHOYELGUDUWLOnVW\UNHWHRULHQVEHUHWWLJHOVH,WLOOHJJKDUWHRULHQY UWDQYHQGWLIRUELQGHOVH PHGIRUVNQLQJSnLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHOORPRPVRUJVJLYHUHRJ\QJUHEDUQ,GHWWHDUEHLGHWKDU VRPWLGOLJHUHLQWURGXVHUW 3QLQD.OHLQY UWWRQHDQJLYHQGH,IOHUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHUKDUKXQ ELGUDWWWLOnSnYLVHKYRUGDQP¡GUHVNYDOLWHWNQ\WWHWWLOPHGLHUWO ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGHJHW EDUQKDUEHW\GQLQJIRUEDUQHWVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ.OHLQRJ$ORQ\.OHLQ.OHLQ :LHGHU *UHHQVSDQ.OHLQVVWXGLHUNDQELGUD\WWHUOLJHUHWLOnVW¡WWHRSSXQGHUWHRULHQV UHOHYDQVIRUSUDNVLVIHOWHW
6DPWLGLJHUGHWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWUHWWHWPRWHQDQQHQNRQWHNVWHQQ GHQVRPHULIRNXVL .OHLQVLQHVWXGLHU'HWNDQGHUPHGVWLOOHVVS¡UVPnOYHG.OHLQVLQHVWXGLHUVEHW\GQLQJQnUGHW JMHOGHUnVW¡WWHDW)HXHUVWHLQVWHRULKDUJ\OGLJKHWLVDPPHQKHQJPHGO UHUHOHYLQWHUDNVMRQHUL VSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ,GHQIRUELQGHOVHNXQQHGHWKDY UW¡QVNHOLJPHGVW¡WWHIUDIRUVNQLQJ VRPKDUJMHQQRPI¡UWHIIHNWVWXGLHUDYO UHUHVDQYHQGHOVHDYPHGLHUWO ULQJRYHUIRUHOHYHUL XQGHUYLVQLQJVVDPPHQKHQJ3nWURVVDYOLWWHUDWXUV¡NKDUGHWLPLGOHUWLGLNNHY UWPXOLJnVSRUH RSSVWXGLHUVRPWDUIRUVHJHQVOLNSUREOHPVWLOOLQJ1RHQYLONDQVNMHDYGHQJUXQQKHYGHDWHW Q\WWLJXWJDQJSXQNWIRUHJHWIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGYLOOHY UHnVWXGHUHQHWWRSSHIIHNWHUDYPHGLHUW O ULQJLXQGHUYLVQLQJVVLWXDVMRQHU-HJNRPIUDPWLODWHQVOLNW\SHVWXGLHEOHIRUDPELVL¡VRJ UHVVXUVNUHYHQGHLIRUELQGHOVHPHGHJHWGRNWRUJUDGVDUEHLG
$OOLNHYHOHUGHWHQXQGHUE\JJHQGHDQWDJHOVHIRUGHQQHVWXGLHQDWO UHUHVEUXNDYPHGLHUW O ULQJLLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGHOHYHUNDQKDHQSRVLWLYHIIHNWSnHOHYHUVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ,RJ PHGDWGHWLNNHV\QHVnHNVLVWHUHIRUVNQLQJVRP GLUHNWHVW¡WWHUHWVOLNWV\QHU)HXHUVWHLQV WHNVWHUHQYLNWLJNLOGHIRUnVW\UNHGHQQHDQWDJHOVHQ+DQYLVHUWLODWWHRULHQKDUUHOHYDQVRJ J\OGLJKHWXDYKHQJLJDYNRQWHNVWXHOOHIRUKROGRJGHUPHGRJVnLO UHURJ HOHYLQWHUDNVMRQHU, WLOOHJJXWWU\NNHUKDQHNVSOLVLWWDWO UHUHVXQGHUYLVQLQJVNYDOLWHWLWLONQ\WQLQJWLOPHGLHUWO ULQJ LLQWHUDNVMRQHUPHGHOHYHUKDUEHW\GQLQJIRUHOHYHQHVNRJQLWLYHXWYLNOLQJ+DQDQYHQGHU GHVVXWHQK\SSLJHNVHPSOHUIUDO UHURJ HOHYLQWHUDNVMRQHUQnUKDQ VNDOLOOXVWUHUHHNVHPSOHUSn PHGLHUWO ULQJ)HXHUVWHLQ 5DQG
'HWNDQSnSHNHVVRP HQVYDNKHWYHGHJHWIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGDWGHWE\JJHUSnHQWHRULKYRUGHW LNNHV\QHVnIRUHOLJJHHPSLULVNIRUVNQLQJVRPVW¡WWHUDWWHRULHQKDUJ\OGLJKHWL GHQNRQWHNVWHQ KYRUVWXGLHQEOLUJMHQQRPI¡UW3nGHQDQQHQVLGHHUEODQWDQQHW<LQRSSWDWWDYDWVWXGLHUNDQ E\JJHSnWHRULHUVHOYRPNXQQVNDSVEDVHQVRPVW¡WWHUWHRULHQNDQV\QHVPDQJHOIXOO6WXGLHQ YLOLVnPnWHNXQQHKHYGHVnKDHQHNVSORUHUHQGHNDUDNWHU<LQ(QVHQWUDOGHODYHJHW IRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGLQQHE UHUnXWDUEHLGHRJSU¡YHXWHWDQDO\VHLQVWUXPHQWIRUnYXUGHUH NYDOLWHWHQDYPHGLHUWO ULQJHOOHUPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJVRPIRUHJnULLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHU PHOORPO UHUHRJHOHYHULVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ'HWWHIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWNDQDYGHQJUXQQ KHYGHVnY UHDYHNVSORUHUHQGHNDUDNWHU RJNDQVnOHGHVELGUDWLOnVWLPXOHUHWLO\WWHUOLJHUH IRUVNQLQJLQQHQRPUnGHW
5HGHJM¡U HOVHIRU VHQWU DOHEHJU HSHU
,KHQKROGWLO SUREOHPVWLOOLQJHQHHUGHWQRHQEHJUHSHUVRPWUHUIUDPVRPVHQWUDOH'HWHUYDOJW nUHGHJM¡UHIRUGLVVHEHJUHSHQHHWWHUXWG\SLQJHQDYWHRULHQVRPIRUVNQLQJVDUEHLGHWE\JJHUSn 'HQQHSULRULWHULQJHQVN\OGHVDWIRUVWnHOVHQDYEHJUHSHQHWLOGHOVHUEDVHUWSnWHRULHQ
%HJUHSHQHGHWKHUHUWDOHRPHUPHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJEHWHJQHOVHQNYDOLWHWLIRUELQGHOVHPHG PHGLHUWXQGHUYLVQLQJO UHURJHOHYG\DGHLQWHUDNVMRQVVHNYHQVHURJVSHVLDOXQGHUYLVQLQJ 1HGHQIRUJM¡UHVGHWUHGHIRUIRUVWnHOVHQDYGLVVHEHJUHSHQHLDYKDQGOLQJHQ
