Visit number
sqrt(cd4)
1 2 3 4 5
0 5 10 15
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
• • •
• •
• •
•
Moist
yield
10 20 30 40 50 60
30 40 50 60 70 80
•
•
• • •
•
• • •
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
• •
• •
• •
•
•
•
• •
•
• •
• •
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
• • •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
• •
•
Site number
Nitrogen level in Parts Per Million
1 2 3 4 5 6
10 20 30 40
Year
Demand per capita
1950 1952 1954 1956 1958
400 600 800 1000 1200 1400
•
•
• •
• • • •
• • •
•
•
•
•
• • • •
•
• •
• • • • • •
• •
• • •
• • • • • • • •
• •
•
• • • •
• • • • • •
•
•
•
• • •
• • •
•
• •
•
• • • • • • •
• • •
2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0
Quintiles 0
1 2 3 4 5
Odds ratio
University of Oslo Department of Mathematics
A simulation study of methods for
estimation and testing in mixed effects models Harald Fekjær
Cand.scient. thesis
1999
! #"%$'&)(+*, .-/$#01 243657' 8"9*,$#:<;=?> 2! 2&(% A@,5#BC3,D E"F$#G4;57(H5I"J(H5#K,D CGL$'
BC@ #;M /> #-N(H"OBC$;= 2DP"/QSRT*, U;57(H5V5#! %(W57X1 2&VGL!$'BY;Z> 2! A&=(O[6 2DP;,"\:O* 2! BC@ #;
/> #-/(H"TB]$;= 2D^"57+ _`&V3,H5'-/(!P-257Da6"9 1QTb57K6 2D` #;cGL+$B<(+$3V$7Gd3657' %(!* #"J 57+ 1e
f Qgh #;=P-/&, ie
j\ A3k E57(! E;mlnopB] #5"9,! 2B] 2&=(W"qGL$'r365#(!` 2&=(W"`&U5p-ND&^-25#Dspt9n_uS(!!P57DvQwnp5#(H5
GL!$'Bx 2@57B]3,D f2y Qf2y `&zus_u{"9|,"9(! 2B}GL$UBC`@= E;h /> #-/(H"4BC$;= 2DP"M~9b6(!(+ 2DDv
ghD`DX1 A&a=u1(+!$38I$D?[6&,' 2
f2'
QOwD$'(S57! $&,D`|MGL$S-ND&XM&,BKk ATQ
Qs+^-/D(!! 1e
gh #5"9,! ABC 2&(U$7GU| AD^;)`&(+ 2&(9|=36 #"$7GU:O`&=(+ 2C:O*, E57(2S,&6;= Ah;Z> 2! A&=(
57BC$',&(H"O$7G3,! A3,D^5#&=(SBC$P"J(+,! 4&8(+*, U"9$`DQpn57(H5MGL+$BY A@,5#BC3,D 1Q Qf `&
us_u]"J|"J(+ 2BGL$'OBC@ #;U /> #-/(H"TB]$;= 2D^"S~Jb6`(!(! ADD A(S57DQ
fA'
Q
Qw&=0+$&,BC A&=(AQ
j\ A3k E57(! E;mBC E5"J! 2BC A&1(a$7Ga&(!+$' 2&CD A01 2D^"a&U(+*, pghP"!"9^"!"93,3,!`01 22Qnp5#(H5
57+ %GL!$B} A@,5#BC3,D 4oQ &us4u."J|"J(! ABGL$BC@ #; N> E-/(H"B]$;= 2D^"4~Jb6`(!(+ 2DD
2(S57DvQ
fA1
Q
o,Q-/$&,$'BC^-A"
n 2BV5#&6;M36 2-2573(H5%`&
f2
;=?> 2! 2&(O4uC"9(H5#(! #"O$#01 2O(!`BC 1Qnp57(W5M5#! 4GL!$B
2@57BC3,D` Qo`&Mus4up"9|,"9(! 2BGL$'rBC`@= E; /> #-/(W"BC$; 2D^"w~9b6(!(+ 2DD1 A(57DQ f2'1 Q
=QR E-*,&$D$'|e
57!P57(+$&U$#G(!*,P-X&, #"+"$#G"J`DP-/$&$&U:O52GL 2H"w`&U"J ABC,-N$&6;=q-/(!$'w3,!$;6-/(!`$&
~GL$'%;Z> 2! A&=("J`(! #"45#&6; :O52GL 2H"
Q]d@57B]3,D %GL+$B}o,Qoh`&)us4u8"9|,"9(! 2BYGL$'
BC@ #;U /> #-/(W"TBC$;= 2DP"~Jb6`(!(+ 2DD 2(S57DvQ f2' Q
Q,(+!(+$'&hUgh E;=^-/`&, 1e
j\ AD^57(+01 S!P"JXC$#GzK! #5'"J(S-25#&6-/ 2TGL$'p;=?> 2! 2&(O-H*,$'D #"9(! 2+$DD` 201 2DP"/Qnp57(W5C57+
GL!$'Bj#&,&, 20X.~
fA'
Q
p¡1¢U£O
RT*, %K,q"J& #"!"T$#G(!*, "9(H57(+^"9(!^-N^57&VP"T(!$-25#(H57D`|=¤A _(+*, "!-/` 2&(!Z[k-\D` #57+&,&,U3!$-/ #"+"/Q
¥
2$'! ¦OQ6rQ6§T$#@h~ f2f2E¨+
© gh|[qH"J("9(H5#(!^"9(!P-2" © ,!$'BY5#&8 #57+D|.57' 1atO*65201 57D:ª52|,"K6 2 A&h&(! A! #"9(! #;V&
+ #"J #5#H-H*57&6;%BV5#&a«¬"a1, #"9(GL$'wK6 2(!(+ 2X=&,$#:OD` #;= ª57K6$(®(+*,
:$!DP;z5#!$&6;z*,B¯Qgh|[6H"9(C&(!+$;=6-/(+$&°(!$±"9(H5#(!^"9(!P-2"
-25#BC :O*, 2&±t4:O5"U5#(U(!*, .5# V$7G(9:T 2D`01 157&6;:O5#&=(+ #;(!$
D` #57+& BC$'! 5#Kk$',(%(+*, 05#!P57(!`$&6"4$7G"9 #57K,`H;836$3,,DP57(+$&q"
5#!$&6;_B|O3657+ 2&(H"a*,$6"9 O5#(w E"J$;,;= A&M~v$+:O52|
QtkBV5';=
5;= #"9&.:O*, 2+ UtO-/$',&=(+ #;(+*, U"9 #57KH;"\`&85"J36 #-/?[-%5#! #5
2¨ {(!B] #"M5: 2 2XQ²`(!*³(!*,P"C;= #"9'&a4tC-/$',&=(+ #;zK,`H;,"
GL$'V5D(+(!D` h$#01 2$&, I|1 #57AS57&6;BM|{3657+ 2&=(W"C(H57*(B]
5#Kk$',(TB] #57&a#BC #;^57&5#&6;"J$B] O$(!* 2"J(H5#(!P"J(!P-257DBC 2(!*$;,"
"9,(W57K,D` dGL$';=H52:O`&,p-N$&6-/D`6"J`$&6"GL!$'BB|BV5#(! 2+^5#DQ`(!*
B|4&(! 2+ #"J(w`&M&q57(!! 1 201 2!|K6$;=|U(!*$,'*=(ªtr:O5'"®$'&,(!$
K6 #-/$'BC 5pK,$'D$'^"9(2K,(rGv57(+ :ª57&(! #;4(5#&,$(+*, 2:O52|1Q´s&6;
D`$1$X&,UK65'-X]$&, 4BV52|]57D^"9$C"9 2 "J$'BC 4"J`&6"O$7Gd5-/$BC`&,U"9(H5#(!^"9(!P-/^5#&aQ
u1 201 AH57D|1 #57W"%D^5#(! 2ATt57(!(+ 2&6;= E;)5I"J(W57(+^"J(+^-25#DS-/$H"J .5#(M(+*, .&,01 AH"J`(9|8$7G
µ
"JD`$,5#&6;±"J$1$&°! #5#D`¤2 #;8(!*65#(U(!*,P"_:O5'"U57&°^;= #5#D:O52| GL$BC (!$I-/$'BMK,`&, UB|
`&=(+ 2! #"9(r`&573,3D E;_BV5#(!*, 2Bc57(!P-2"/2`&=GL$+BV57(+$'&U(! #-H*,&,$'D$'|57&6;U 2& 2H5#Dk+ #"J E5-H*aQ
b57(+ 22:O*,`D .t_:ª5"%(! E5-H*,&,I5#(M(+*, 8u1 #-/(+$'&)$#G4gh E;=^-25#Du1(W57(+^"J(+^-2"NTt4:O5'"
`&=(+!$;=6-N #; (!$I 2(!(+ 2Mb5'57X1 1:O*,${"J*,$#:T E;¶B] M*,P"%^;= E5"_:O*^-H*D^5#(! 2UK6 #-25#BC
(+*, UK65"9^-_GL$'p(!*,P"p(!*, #"9^"NQmu1`&6-/ (!*, 2&·at\*q5E01 U3q57!(+^-/`3657(+ #;h&I"9 201 2W57D3,!$#¸! E-/(H"
5#&6;M(! E5-H*,&,¦5"+"J'&,BC 2&(H"5#(O(!*, 4u1 #-/(+$'&C$7G´gh #;^-25#Dui(H57(+^"9(!^-A"/,5#&6;Ct57B¹&,$#:
D`$1$X&,UGL$+:O57W;h(!$V-N$&(!&, #;C:$!XV*, A! %`&85#&8 2@=3q57&6;=`&,!$',3I:O(!*¯"J,36 2+K
-/$'DD` #57', #"T5#&6;:$+XC 2&0=`!$&BC 2&(2Q
tr:OP"J*(!$%(+*657&XCr A(!(! A\b5'57X1 1t&, º 2D`D^57&q;1§a¸H7+&Vg87D`D 2A1`D^"®b6P;Cºw¸!$+(2
RT*,$'! Sw AD^57&q;U57&6;»h¼5#! µ "9&, #"GL$'®Bc57&|p*, 2D`3=GL,D! 2BV5#!X"r5#&6;-/$&6"9^;= AH57(+$'&6"/Q
r A(!(! A_b5'57X1 *65"4Kk A 2&8(!*, UK6 #"9("J,36 2+0=P"J$tp-N$,DP;h 2(Ar5#&6;8(pP"F:O`(!*8'! #5#(
3,D` #5"9,! Ftd&$7:½D$1$X]K65-HXM$'&VBM|%[6W"J(O'DB]36"J S$7G´(!*, "9(H57(+^"9(!^-A57D+ #"J E57H-H*M[6 AD^;Q
s&q;_D^5'"J(K,,(&,$(´D #5'"J(2it57DP"J$p:OP"J*U(+$p"9 2&6;U5S"J36 #-/P57D(!*65#&,X,"(!$4ºp5#H5#D^;_I 2 #;$&a
B|mGv5#BCD`|C5#&6;B|+DZGL+ 2&6;hu1q"!57&&, %GL$"J,33k$'!(57&q;*, 2D`3h:O`(!*hB|:O!(+(! 2&
w&,'D^"9*aQ
¾F¿1À!¿Á?Â%ÃÄ!ÅÆNÇSÀ!ÈÉwÊ,Ë^Ì#ÄNÀWÍAËÎvÏCÐJÑÒÍNÁ?Ð7ÈÓ,ÔÊkÄUÕ'Ö7ÈSÕ'×1×1×
ßCàLá â=ã4äNå#ærçaè é
ê ëNì å#í#âaçærîå#àLâ ì å#âIí#ï ì çrâ6á ï ì çá±à^ðñ=ç{ñòñîå#äUá±âaçrñóôä õ
f Qf
gh`@= #; /> #-/(OBC$;= AD^"/öRT*, A$!|.5#&6; 2@57B]3,D #"QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
fAy
f Q µ &, "J36 #-N^57D-A5"J ieRT*, 4H57&q;=$B /> #-/(W"TBC$;= 2D÷Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q f o
ø ù ä/åEàôá±ï=å#àLâ ì ï ì çzå#ñä/å#à ìú à ì á±àðñç±ñòñîå#ä%á±âaçñ=óLä ê,û
Qf
"J(+BV5#(!`$&CBC A(!*,$;,"®GL$'OH5#&6;=$BÜ5#&6;BC`@= E;m /> #-N(H"8Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
f
Qf Qf s&65#D|"J^"T$#Gw0'5#!^5#&6-/ ~s µ s K65'"J #;V #"J(+BV5#(!`$&³Q%Q4Q%Q f
Qf Q g8t9_üpzg8tý4üp Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q f
Qf Q
g857@B,B<b6X1 AD*$1$;þ~vg b
Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
'
Qf
Qo j\ E"J(!+^-/(+ #;Cg85#@=`BM,B<b6`X1 2D`*,$1$;8~jSg b
Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
'
Qf Qÿ §O52|1 #"JP57&C #"9(!`BV57(+$&·ewRT*,
¥
K,Kq""+57BC3,D` 2 Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q '
Q
nP"J(+!K,(!`$&6"T$#G(!*, 4 #"9(!`BV57(+ #"YQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
Q Qf »p&,$#:O&h(!* 2$+ #"wGL$S(!*, ;=P"J(!+K,(!$'&6"T$7Gd(!*, 4 #"9(!Bc57(! E"/e%Q
Q Q
§O52|1 #"JP57&CBC A(!*,$;,"NeRT*, 573,+$'!;=P"J(!+K,(!$'&VQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
f
Q
Ra #"J(W"T&VBC`@= #;U /> #-/(W"TBC$;= 2DP" Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
'
Q Qf RT*, 45#D^; ¨ (! E"J(Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q '
Q Q b6X1 2D`*,$1$;CW57(!`$MKq5"J E;c(+ #"J(+&, Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
Q Q
RT*,
¨
(! #"9(VQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q
ù ä/åEàôá±ï=å#àLâ ì á±ñårâaçä%àì í#ï,îå#àLî1ï,óTæä2ñ ê
Qf
"J(+BV5#(!`$&CBC A(!*,$;,"T`&.-/$BCB]$&]"J(H5#(!P"J(!P-257Da3q5-HX5# #"°Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Qo
f
Q
n?> 2! 2&(T E"J(!`BV57(+$'&CBC 2(+*,$;,"
¨ µ &, 4&,BC 2+^-25#Dk A@,5#BC3,D Q%Q4Q%Qo'o
ß ì â ñ=í àLñÜâ=ãñ=ïí7óLàLñ=í â ì å#ñïí7óLâä/åEærçàôñä û
o,Q
f
RT*, p[6W"J(SD^5#! "9B,D^5#(!$'&C"9(!6;|eOu1:O5#DD`$7:½ gh$'&657*q57& Q4Q%Q4Q%Qo
o,Q µ
(!* 2S"J(+6;= E" Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q¹ f
o,Q u1(+D`D,&6"9$D`01 #;V, E"J(!`$&6"Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q¹ f
ß â ì å#ñï,í#óLâä/å#æçaèzâ=ãå ñhçàòñí7ñ ì åñä/å#àLá±ï=å#àLâ ì á±ñå âaçä !
Qf q+ #1, 2&(!^"9(T #"9(!`BV57(+$H"Newg b6jSg b6g8tJ4üp)5#&6;hs
µ
s Q¹
=Q
f Qf
nP"J(+!K,(!`$&6"T$#G#"%$
&
E"J(!`BV57(+ #"pQ4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q¹
=Qf Q l$'!! AD^57(+$'&6"\$#GwW57&6;$BÜ-/$B]3k$'&, 2&(4~'"%$
& #"J(+BV5#(! #"³Q%Q4Q
=Q
f Q
º$#:³^"T(+*, 4DX1 AD*$1$;]GL$'S"JBV5#DD05#D, E"T$7G#"%$
&(
Q_QQ4Q%Q4Q
Q
§O5E|1 E"J^5#&C #"9(!Bc57(!`$&Cq"J& ¥ KK6"O"!5#BC3,D AQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
)
=Q Qf w*,`D$1"9$3,*^-25#DkP"!"9, #"/ö6l$BC3q57!`&,p(+*, p;Z> 2! A&=(5733,!$i5-H*, #" )
=Q Q n E"J'&85#&6;D`BC`(H57(+$'&U$7G(+*, "JB,DP57(!`$&]"J(+6;=| QQ4Q%Q4Q< f
=Q
Q
u1`BMD^57(+$'&C! #"9,D(W"_Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q<#
é ß â ì
å#ñï,í#óLâä/å#æçaèzâ=ãFçrà^òñ=í#ñ
ì
åå#ñ=äNå#à
ìaú
á)ñ1å âaçrä *
Qf
u1B,D^5#(!`$&$7G;=?> 2! 2&(T(+ #"J(+&,BC 2(+*,$;,"Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
Q RT*, 2$+ 2(!P-257D-N$&6"9^;= 2W57(+$&q"QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q =f
Q Qf
*|V;=$1 #"O(!* _{57DP;C(! #"9('01 4"9$M,&q-/ 2!(W57`&+ #"JD(H"
(
Q%Q4Q
Q Q
*|C^"T(+*, 4D`X1 2D`*,$1$;M(! E"J(S"J$]-/$'&6"J 2+0'57(!`01
(
QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
û
â
ì
î1óôæä2àLâ
ì ä õ6õ
iQ
f
u1,BCBV5#!| Q%Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
iQ j\ #-N$BCBC A&6;,57(+$'&6"rGL$S5733,D` #;V"J(H5#(!P"J(!P-/^5#&6"}Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q fAyy
1Q
Qf
jO #-/$'BCBC 2&6; #;% #"J(+BV5#(!`$&CBC A(!*,$;," Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
fAy=f
1Q Q jO #-/$'BCBC 2&6; #;%BC 2(+*,$;,"®GL$O(+ #"J(+&,H5#&6;=$'B-/$B]3k$'&, 2&(H" fAy
iQ §O5"JP"®GL$OGL,!(+*, 2S"9(!6;=` #" Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q fAy
ß â6á
æå#ñíUï,ó
ú
âkí#à^å á)äï
ì
ç,+å#í#àLî.-aä0/
ê21
sQf ¥
A&, 2H5#Da3,!$'W57BCBC`&,%3!&q-/3,D` #"8Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q fAy
sQ
u1B,D^5#(!`&,;,57(W5"J A(H":O`(!*VH5#&6;=$B /> #-N(H" Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
fAy
sQ q&6-/(!`$&6"®GL$'\GL+ #1, 2&(!^"9(T #"9(!`BV57(+$&]57&q;(! E"J(!`&, Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q fAy
sQo §O5E|1 E"J^5#&C #"9(!Bc57(!`&,
¨
p"9&,U(+*, §O ¥ uU365'-X'57' Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
f'ff
sQ¬ j\,&&,&,(!* %"9B,D^5#(!`$&6" Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
f'f2
sQ s&657D`|=¤A&,U(+*, 4! #"9,D(W")Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q f'f2
3 â6á
æå#ñíUí#ñ=äAâkæí#î1ñ=ä
êkê4
§pQf l$BC3,(! 2S"9|,"9(! 2BV"6"J E;c`&V(!*, "J(+6;=| Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q f'f
§pQ
u1$7GL(9:O5#! ;,5#(H5"9 2(S! /GL 2+ 2&6-/ E" QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
f'f
§pQ
sp-X&,$#:OD E;=BC A&=(W"MQ%Q4Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q%Q4Q4Q%Q4Q%Q4QQ_QQ4Q%Q4Q
f'f2
5TàLä/åâ=ã76Oà
ú
æí7ñä
êkê,û
5TàLä/åâ=ã78Tï49óôñä êkê õ
3Uà:9óôàLâ
ú
í7ï
6è
êqøê
g857(!* 2BV57(+^-2""J 2 ABV"®(+$U 2&6;=$#:$'&, 4:O(!*."9$BC 2(+*,&UDX1 5U&, 2:½"J 2&6"9 1Q
l*65#!D E"Onp57+:O&~
f'yE¨Wf1
n,+&,V(+*, MDP5"9(%; #-25; 1a(!*, BC@ #;V /> #-/(H"pBC$; 2Dw*65'"FK6 #-N$BC U$'&, M$#GS(!*,
BC$i"J(pq"J #;"9(H5#(!^"9(!P-257DBC$;= AD^"`& BC E;=^-25#Dw! E"J #5#H-H*aQCRaH5';=(+$&q57DD`|1a #"J(+BV5#(!`$&
`&UBC@ #;_ N> E-/(H"wBC$;= AD,*65"TK6 2 A&C;=$'&, S6"J`&,U;=?> 2! 2&(wX&6;"d$#G´q5;=W57(!P-"9,BV"
BC A(!*,$;,"NaK,,(%:O`(!*I&6-N! #5'"J #;-N$BC3,(!&C36$7: 2U5#&6; &, A:¹"J$7GL(9:ª57! irBC 2(+*,$;,"
D`X1 4! #"9(!+^-/(+ #;hg85#@=`BM,BÜb6X1 2D`*,$1$;~vg b
5#&6; ¥ `K,K6"p"+57BC3D&C*65201 %i57& #;
36$3,D^5#!(9|1Q
RT*,P"\W57^"9 #"S"J 201 2W57D1, #"9(!$'&6"S57K6$,((!*, FEV-N 2&6-N|M$#G(!*, ¦;=Z> 2+ 2&(O #"J(+BV5
¨
(+$&UB] 2(!*,$;"/K6$(+*M' 2&, 2W57D`D|57&6;U! AD^57(+01 (!$p #5'-*U$'(!*, A2Qw,$'T"9$BC #"J(+BV5#(!`$&
BC A(!*,$;,"O:T U*q5E01 ¦57&65#D|(!P-257D´"J$'D,(+$&q"GL$'p(!* ;=^"9(!!`K,,(+$&q"/K,(p:O(+*8,&=Kq57D
¨
5#&6-/ #;°;= #"J`&6"NO57&q57D|(!P-h"9$D(!$'&6"MK6 #-/$'BC V01 2!|{*657W;z$BC36$1"+"J`K,D V(!$I[6&6;Q
RT*,P"®BC E57&6"w(!*q57(O:T *65201 p(!$U+ 2D|U$'&h"9B,D^5#(!`$&"J(+6;=` #"/Q µ &, p$#Gw(+*, [6W"J(S"96-*
"9B,D^5#(!$'&p"9(!6; #"a:O5'"3,K,DP"J*, #;pK|%u1:ª57DD`$#:& f2=f ~9u1:O5#DD`$7: f2)f7 7GL$D`D$#:T #;
,38:O`(!*u1:ª57D`D$#:¹gh$&65#*657&°~
fA) o
QVb57(+ 22a(!* 2! U*65201 Kk A 2&8BV57&|.57+(!^-ND #"
$'&C$(+*, 2O"936 #-/^5#D-25"9 #"/:O*,^-H*M$#GL(! 2&]:O*, 2! K65"9 #;M$&c5%"J36 #-N^57D·573,3D^-A57(!`$&a1K,(
(+$UBM|UX&,$#:OD #; 4&,$D^57+ "J(+6;=` #"T*65201 4Kk A 2&V3,,K,D`^"J* #;C(!$U(!*^"O;,5#(! 1Q
u1:ª57DD`$#: ¹gh$&q57*65#&z~
f2) o
^"(+*, -/D^5'"!"9^-25#D57+(!^-ND %:O*^-H*I-/$&(H5#&6"Bc57&|
`&=(+ 2! #"9(!`&,M+ #"JD(H"NK,,("9$BC 1, #"9(!$'&6"p"9(!D`Dw! ABV57`&aQ µ &, U A@,5#BC3,D 4$#GO(!*^"p^"
(+*, 36 29GL$+BV57&6-N O$7G(!*
¥
KK6"T"+57BC3,D` 22QsO((!*, S(!`BC T$#Gu1:O5#DD$#: gh$'&657*q57&a«ÿ"
5#!(!P-/D U(+*,^"p #"9(!`BV57(+$4:O5'"%57D`BC$1"9(4&I&,$h3,W5-/(+^-25#D6"J 1K,,(4(4*65'"U"J`&6-/ (!*, 2&
K6 #-/$'BC V1,(+ h36$3,D^5#2Q µ (+*, 2]-/ 2&(!H5#DS #"J(+$&q"C57+^"J ¯57+$,&6;z(+*, 8;Z> 2! A&=(
(+ #"J(+&,4BC 2(+*,$;,"w6"9 #;M&BC`@= #;4 /> #-/(W"dB]$;= 2D^"NQwRa$;,52|M(+*, S5#D^;M(+ #"J(^"BC3D
¨
BC A&=(+ #;m`&."J 201 2W57D"9(H57(+^"9(!^-A57Da365'-X'57' #"/6K,,(S^"O(!*^"O5M'$1$;8-*,$'^-/
(
~ô 1Q,QOn$1 E"
36 29GL$!B ! E5"J$'&657KD V:T 2D`D´5"%(¦;=$1 #"%`&BC$1"9(_[6@ #; N> E-/(H"-25"9 #"
( QIRT*, .5#B
$#G(!*,P""9(!6;|h^"O(!$]"J* #;8"J$'BC 4D'*=(O$'&8(!*, E"J U1, #"9(!`$&6"N5#&6;h(!$]-/$B] _38:O(!*
3,W5-/(+^-25#D5;=0^-N FGL$'p6"9 #"\$#G #"J(+BV5#(!$'&V57&q;h(! #"9(!&MBC A(!*,$;,"O&.BC@ #;M N> E-/(H"
BC$; 2D^"NQ
S
ÚYÛPÙTC A UÛV<rÙ Ú Û Ù PBM÷Ú C ÙW= M<Ú C
= <%X ÝYC Ý[Z ÝYUÛÞ = Ù\C ÝY]wÞ
sDDBC$;= 2DP"O57! 4:O+$&,kK,(S"J$B] 457+ %6"9 /GL,D
¥
2$'!' UOQ6rQ6§T$#@.~ f2f22¨!
,!$'B 2D` 2BC 2&(H5#!|"J(H5#(!P"J(!P-257Dq-/$,W"J #"N1(!*, S"9(H57&q;,57W;m+ 2+ #"!"9$&BC$;= AD=P"r:T 2D`D
X&,$#:O&ae
^,_a`cbedVf
:O*, A! 1e
g
`h_i`jlknmF^"T(!* %; #"J`&I~-/$#0'57+^5#(! BV5#(!+@Q
g
bV_b mop ^"T(+*, 43657W57BC 2(+ 2T01 E-/(!$'2Q
g
fq_af jropTP"T(!*, 4 2+!$'%~L! #"9( (! A!B8
:O(+*cfs_ ~:fput0vvv%tnf j
57&6;ef wyxQz¯~
y
t"%$
{ Q
~OQQ®`&6;= 236 2&q;= 2&(T&,$'!BV5#Da;=P"J(!+K,(! #;C 2+!$O(+ 2!Bc"/Q
sp"O:T ¦-257&I"9 2 1(+*, %BC$; 2Da^"Kq5"J E;h$&8&q;= 236 2&6;= A&=(S$K6"9 2!0'5#(!$'&6"/QRT*,P"^"
5h+ 2D 20'5#&=(BC$;= 2DGL$]"J$B] V"J`BC3,D ];= #"9'&6"/K,,(U`&)Bc57&| 3,W5-/(+^-25#DO-25'"J #"U:T
*65201 ;,5#(H5C(!*65#(4;=$V&,$'(GL,DZ[qDDa(!*^"p5'"!"JBC3,(!`$&aQ µ &, -/D^5'"!"9^-25#Dr 2@57B]3,D 4$7G(+*,^"
P"F+ 236 #57(+ #;BC #5'"J,+ 2BC 2&1(W"/:O*, A! C: C&B]$1"J(-25'"J #"%:O`DD*65201 ]57&±&6;0^;=65#D
/> #-N(T(!*q57(-/! #5#(! #"O; 236 2&6;= 2&(O$Kq"J 2+05#(!`$&6"NQ
µ &, "J$'D,(+$&.(!$C(+*,^"T3!$KD 2BÜ-/$',D^;CK6 %(+$C&6-ND6;= (!*, &6;=`0=P;=65#D /> #-/(S&
(+*, %365#H5#BC 2(! AH"/QSRT*,P"\P"p;=$'&, %K|V0&C #5-H*h`&6;=`0=P;=657Da`(H"O$#:O&83657W57BC 2(+ 2H"N
"J$B] 2(!*,`&,(!*65#(p&83,W5-/(+^-/ D #5';,"(+$C01 2!|VBV5#&=|V365#H5#BC 2(! AH"/QRT*,^"-257&{"J$'BC ¨
(!B] #"T:T$'!XCGL$4;57(H5C:O`(!*8BV5#&=|C+ 23,D`^-25#(!$'&6"/6K,,(&hB]$1"J(-25'"J #": U"9$1$&+,&
&(!$3,!$'K,D 2Bc"\$#GT$#01 2+3657W57BC A(!!`¤#57(+$'&aQSRT*, #"J U3!$KD 2BV"S57+^"9 5": U #"J(+BV5#(!
5hD^57+ V&,BMK6 24$#Gp365#H5#BC 2(! AH"FGL+$B 5h+ 2D^5#(!`01 2D|I"9BV57D`DT;57(H5'"J 2(AQ±RT*, V5';,;= #;
3657W57BC 2(+ 2H"O&q-/! #5'"J (!*, U,&q-/ 2!(W57`&=(9|V&8(+*, UBC$;= 2Dv5#&6;h:O(+*hGL 2: ! 236 2(+(+$&q"
GL$S #5-H*h`&6;=0^;657Da(+*, 4BC$;= 2Da:O`DDa$7GL(+ 2&W-/$D`D^5#36"J © :O(!*$,(S`0=`&,C5#&=|V'$1$;
#"J(+BV5#(! #"rGL$S(!* _3q57H5#BC 2(+ 2H"NQ
s"r$#01 2!365#H5#BC 2(!+¤#5#(!`$&pD` #5201 #"(+*, S"J(W57&6;57H;UBC 2(+*,$;_q"J 2D` #"!"a&UBV5#&=|3,H5'-
¨
(!^-A57D6-25'"J #"N=: B6"J(´D$1$XUGL$$(+*, 2BC 2(+*,$;,"w(!*65#(TK6 2(+(! 2&6-/D`6;= S;= A3k A&6;= 2&6-N #"
GL!$B ;= #"J`&6"O"96-H*h5'"\+ 236 #57(+ #;CBC #5'"J,+ 2BC 2&1(W"/Qt&(+*,^"O-H*65#3,(! 2A=: p:OD`D`01 45
K,!` /G&(!!$;6-/(!`$&I(!$.(!*, BC@ #;C /> #-/(W"pBC$;= 2DP"/a(!*65#("J$D`01 #"p(!*,P"p3,!$'K,D 2BÜK=|
5;,;=`&,]"J$]-257D`D #;MW57&6;$B /> #-/(W"T(!$U(!* %"9(H5#&6;,57W;h! 2'! #"+"J`$&VBC$;= 2DvQ
I± _£# . QO. U> ¢
¢
A
u1(H5#(!^"9(!P-2"w$7GL(! A&M`&=01$'D01 O; #57D`&,4:O(+*M+ 236 #57(+ #;UBC #5"9,! ABC 2&(;,57(W5=Qtý(-/$',D^;UK6
;,57(W5FGL!$'B0'57!`$6"w[6 2DP;,""J6-H*C5'"®BC E;=^-/`&, 12 #-N$&,$'BC^-2"57&q;MK,$'D$'|1QRT*,P"-/$,DP;
(J|3,P-257D`D|VK6 V"!5#BC3,D E"$#01 24(!B] _GL$ #5-H*I&6;=`0=P;=65#DQ µ &, 2@57BC3D U$7GS(+*,^"pP"
3,D$'(!(! E;m`&M[6! f Qf :O*, 2+ : \[6&q;M! 236 #5#(! #;Vlno%BC E5"J! 2BC A&=(W"·GL$'T365#(! A&=(W"
&.5U-/D`&,^-A57D(+!P57DkGL$'pstJn4uM3q57(!` 2&(H"
p Q
ui&6-/ S;57(H54-25#&MK6 SBC$;= 2D` #;_`&UBV57&|U;Z> 2! A&=(:O52|"/1:T O*65201 O(+$_Bc57X1 O"9$BC
5"!"9,BC3,(+$'&6"T! 2i57W;=&,U(+*, p,&q;= 2!D`|=`&,%B]$;= 2D(+$U36 2JGL$'!B5#&h5#&657D`|,"9^"NQg85E|K6
(!*, UBC$i"J(p$'K=0$'6"pBC$;= 2D:T$',D^;hK6 (!$.5"+"J,B] U(!*65#(_ E5-H*83k AH"J$'& *q5"_*^"A*, 2W"
$7:O&{K65"9^-UD& #574-N,!01 1a:O`(!*{"J$B] U&,$P"J V5#!$&6; (AQCtôGO: M&$7:¹5'"!"9,BC U(!*q57(
Kk$'(!*(+*,^"4&,$P"J 1(!*, &q;=0^;=q57D&(! 2W-/ 23,(W"p57&q; (!*, ]&6;=`0=P;=65#D"JD`$36 #"/5#DD57+
&,$+BV57D`D|C~ ¥ 576"+"J^5#&
;=^"9(!!`K,,(+ #;1:T p A&6-/$&=(+ 25%&,$+BV57D6D`&, #5#®B]@ #;% /> #-/(W"
BC$;= 2DvQtôGp: V&,$#:<*65201 e $'K6"J A!0'57(+$&q"/O(!*,P"%BC$;= 2Dª-257&°K6 :O+(+(! 2&±&±(+*,
GL$DD`$#:O&,%GL$'!BGL$'O #5-H*V&6;=`0=P;=65#De
^,_a`cbed ¢¡£d¤f
:O*, 2! ie
g
`¥_a`jom4^"T(+*, ;= #"J`&I~-N$70'5#!^5#(!
Bc57(!+@$7G´(!*, p[6@ #;C /> #-/(W"/Q
g
b_ab4mopP"T(!*, 4365#H57B] 2(! 2O01 E-/(!$'®GL$O(+*, p[6@ #;C /> #-/(H"NQ
¦¨§©«ª©©u¬:¯®°¬}±F²³µ´ ©u²·¶ ¸¹Iº¼».½¹º¼»¾¹¿ÀÁÂÀqÃ:ÄÃ}ª}²Å®°±¬²·¾Æ´µÇ'ÈÉʵª}ò·±0Ç.µ¸¹ÃrËK̾¹ª}ª:µ¸¹¸µª#©«¸Í½
ºnÎÎFÏе½
Visit number
sqrt(cd4)
1 2 3 4 5
0 5 10 15
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
• • •
• •
• •
•
r`,+ f Qf ew@57BC3,D` p$7G´! A3k E57(! E;cB] #5"9,! 2B] 2&=(d;,57(W5=ölnoD 201 AD^"rGL!$'B5U-/D`& ¨
P-257D(!!P57DGL$'Sspt9n_u3657(+ 2&(H"p~L3,D$'(!(! E;c$'&,D|GL$S-/D`&6-HXU&=BMK6 2ª
Q
g
Ò_[ ljro)ÓO^"T(+*, ;= #"J`&{~-/$#0'57+^57(+
BV5#(!!`@%GL$S(!*, 4W57&6;=$'B< /> #-/(W"/Q
g
¡Ô_Q¡ÕÓuopª^"O(!*, 01 #-/(!$'O$7GH5#&6;=$'B N> E-/(H"O /> #-/(W"\:O`(!*¡B_ ~¡Öpt0vvv%tu¡ÕÓ
57&6;סyw%xQz8~
y
tu"%$
Ø Ù Q
g
f_Úf jop4P"p(!*, 2!+$(! 2+B8:O(+* (+*, C0'57+^5#(!$'& $#GS(!*, ]$K6"9 2!0'57(+$'&~5'"
"!5#BC3,D`&, 2!+$p 2(W-Q
Qpt(4-25#&8K6 U:O!(+(! 2&¯5"fÛ_~}fptvvvtnf j
:O(+*f wÜx
z8~
y
tu"%$
{ Q
ÝCñá±ï,í -aä)Þ
g
-25#&5"!"9,BC w(+*657(Õ¡C*65'"¤2 2+$OBC #57&·/K6 #-25#6"J 57&|pBC E57&4-25#&4Kk `&6-/Dq;= #;
&V(!* F[q@= #;C /> #-N(H"/Q
g
.-25#&°57D^"9$8:O!`(! C(+*, VBC$;= 2D5"Ne¯z8~ßÑb#tFà w:O*, 2! ×à P"%(!*, C0'5#!^5#&6-/ ¨
-/$#0'57!P57&6-N _Bc57(!+@$7G´K6$(!*.(!*, 4W57&6;=$'B /> #-/(H"O5#&6;(+*, 4 2!+$O(+ 2!B8Q
g
RT*,^"aBC$;= AD7P":O!`(!(! A&FGL$'a$&, `&6;=0^;657Dv/K,,(a`(a^"a5#D^"J$O36$i"!"J`K,D (+$ 2@3,+ #"!"
5_' 2&, 2W57D,GL$+BM,DP5\GL$ª57D`D,&6;0^;=65#D^"NQwt&M(+*,^"-25'"J 11: B6"J(´! 236 #5#(T"9$BC
$7G(+*, 4H5#&6;=$B /> #-N(H"T(! A!BV""J 201 2W57D(!B] #"/Q
t&%(+*, S-/D`&,^-A57Dspt9n_u4(+!^5#D `:ODD1K6 S(!*, ª-/$#0'57!P57(+ #"w-/$'&,&, #-/(+ #;%(!$(!*, O0^"9(H"N
bC:O`DDK6 O(!*, 3657W57BC 2(+ 2H"GL$´(!*, $701 AH57D`D136$3,,DP57(+$&]-/,+01 57&6;fO(!*, BC #5'"J,+&,
2+!$'57&6;°"J(!$-H*65'"J(!P-0'57+^5#(!$'&5#!$&6;z(!*, VBC$; 2DQ°RT*,^"%P"m(+*, V6"Jq57DSD& #57
BC$; 2DT: *q5E01 ¯"J 2 A&)`&z(+*, V&(!!$;6-/(!$'!|°-/$',H"9 #"m`&"9(H57(+^"9(!^-A"/K,,(Kk E-2576"9
: %*65201 U! A3k E57(! E;hBC #5"9,! ABC 2&(H"®: UBMq"J(S 2@=(+ 2&6;h(+*, UBC$;= 2D´"J$'BC 2:O*65#(2Q4
(!*, 2+ /GL$+ %`&=(+!$;=6-N U(!*, U(+ 2!B¥ I¡)GL$'p(!*, U`&6;=`0=P;=657D /> #-/(W"/Qº 2+ á *65'"F(9:$
-/$D`,BC&6"%~µ >ptF
$ r:O*, 2+ >p^"p(!* C&(! 2W-/ 23,(F57&6;
$
(!*, ]"JD`$36 1Q8t&(+*, &, 2@(
-*65#3,(! A2: :O`DD4"9 2 I*,$#:}:T 8GL$V(!*,P"BC$; 2D4-25#&BV5#X1 I"J$'BC 8 #"J(+BV5#(! #"U$7G
Kk$'(!*V(!* p36$3,,DP57(+$&."9D$36 1(!*, &6;=`0=P;=65#Dk0'5#!^5#(!`$&V5#&6;C(!*, p0'5#!^5#(!`$&C$#G #5-H*
$K6"9 2!0'57(+$'&aQRT*,^"-/$',D^;4(J|3,P-257D`D|SKk 6"J E;FGL$´$K6"9 2!0&,S /> #-/(W"$#G(J:$p;Z> 2! A&=(
(!! E57(!B] 2&=(W"O~"J A F[q,+
f Q
Q
Visit number
State of disease
1 2 3 4 5 6
5 10 15 20 25 30
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
• •
• • • •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
•
• •
•
• • • •
• •
• • •
• •
•
•
•
• •
• •
• •
•
• •
•
• •
• •
• •
• •
•
• •
•
• • • •
• •
• • •
• •
•
•
•
• •
• •
• • • •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
•
• •
•
• • • •
• •
• • •
• •
•
•
•
• •
• •
• • •
• •
•
• •
• •
• •
• •
•
• •
•
• • • •
• •
• • •
• •
•
•
•
• •
• •
•
•
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
• •
•
• •
•
• • • •
• •
• • •
• •
•
•
•
• •
• •
Placebo Treatment
r',!
f Q
eR®|3,^-A57D+ 236 #57(+ #;CBC #5'"J,+ 2BC 2&(H"w;57(H5%GL!$'B5-/D`&,^-25#D6(!!P57DvQ
sS&,$(+*, 2 2@,5#BC3,D` ®P"(+*, OBC #5'"J,+ 2BC 2&(6$7G| 2DP;F`&U(! 2&(9|=36 #"r$#G:O&(! 2a:O*, E57(
,&6;= 2d;=Z> 2+ 2&=(´57B]$,&(H"r$#Ga3,+ 23,DP57&(rBC$'^"9(!,+ T&U(+*, S"J$'Dv1"J*,$#:O&&%[6',!
f Q
$2Q
tý&V(+*,^"T 2@57B]3,D S:T "J A _(+*657(S(!* _D`&, E57S"J(+!6-N(!,+ _P"TBMq-*BC$+ 4;=P"J(!`&6-/(A=:O(+*
5M-/D` #57D`&, #57O(+! 2&q;Q
t&{5;,;(!`$&I(!$V(!* #"J D`&, #57BC$;= 2DP"/: -/$,DP; 5#D^"9$*q5E01 &,$'& ¨ D`&, E57"J(+!6- ¨
(!,+ #"%5'"%"J A 2& `& [6',! f QoQhRT*, E"J ];,57(W5857! GL!$B 5hK$-H*, 2BCP-257D 2@3k A!B] 2&=(
BC #5"9,!`&,%01 AD$-/`(J|&.-/ ADD^":O(+*h5#&6;:O`(!*,$',(S(!! E57(!B] 2&=(K=|]w,!$'BM|-/`&4âN657&6;
*, 2! 4: 4"J 2 4(+*657(S(!*, -/!01 #"&6-/+ #5"9 4(!$5U3k$'&(2=GL$'O(!*, 2&V(+$C"9D$#:OD|V"9(H5#K,D`¤2 1Q
㼧©«ª©l®°¬:±²B´©«²I¶ ¸¹Õä.½å.½¹º%¾¹¿7ÀÁÀÃ}ÄÃ:ª}µ²®°±F¬²·¾¹´0Ç#'ȵʵª:òI±Ç µ¸¹ÃÕËK̾¹ª}ª:µ¸¹¸µªÕ©u¸Í½)º¼ÎÎFÏн
æçÑ´©«²I¶ ¸¹l®°¬:±²aÀFèêéëÌìÂÀíI²©u¿î©«¸ÕïðÖî ¾¹Ç ª}±sÀª©«ª}¾¹Ã}ª:¾¹ÊµÃ}ñË°§©«ª©Ál¿©u¸¹ÄÃ}¾¹Ãé4¬}±Ç î ʪ}Ã#§l¾òè
ó
¾¹Ã}¾¹±F¿7ôs©«ª}õÀ±«®°ªöÍ¿ ʽºnÎÎFäе½
Moist
yield
10 20 30 40 50 60
30 40 50 60 70 80
•
•
• • •
•
•
• • •
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
• • • •
• •
•
• •
• •
•
• •
• •
•
•
• •
• •
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
• •
• • •
r`,+ f Q eOw@,5#BC3,D` p$7GB]@ #;m N> E-/(H"S;,57(W5M:O(+*.-/D #5#D`&, E57S"J(+!6-N(!,+ 1ö4÷p AD^;
`&C(! 2&V(9|3k E"T$7G:O`&=(+ 2T:O*, E57(2Q
Concentration
Reaction velocity
0.0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0
50 100 150 200
T
T T T
T T
T T
T
T T
T
U U
U U U U
U U
U
U U
U = untreated T = treated
r`,+
f
Qo,ed@57B]3,D $7G;,5#(H5h"9,(W57K,D` %GL$5&$&ID& #574BC`@= #;C /> #-N(H"pBC$;= 2Dvö
2D`$-/(9|U&.-/ ADD^":O(+*h5#&6;:O`(!*,$',(O(!+ #57(+BC 2&(K=|Vw,+$B|,-N&aQ
f =f 'y f o o f
ff fA o f o
' f 'y y f0
f f'f =f o o
fA f2 f o
=f 'y
fA Q Q
' Q Q Q Q
'y
Q Q Q Q Q
'y
Q Q Q Q Q
Rr5#K,D
f Qf
enp57(W5U"J,`(H57KD GL$'O5%H5#&6;=$'B-/$B]3k$'&, 2&(BC$;= 2Dvö=S(!+$' 2&CBC #5'"J,+
¨
BC 2&(H"57D`$&,(!*, ghP"!"JP"!"93,3,jO01 A2Q
RT* TBC`@= #;O /> #-/(W"BC$;= 2D-N$,DP;_5#D^"9$pK6 ®' 2&, 2W57D`¤2 #;p:O`(!*4$(+*, 2´;=^"9(!!`K,,(+$&q"
(!*65#&U(!*, &,$+BV57D~ôi576"+"J^5#& QTui$BC -/$'BCBC$&4 2@57B]3,D #"6$7G(!*^"a&6-/D`6;= K,&,$'BC^5#D
57&6;hD`$P"J(+^-4;=^"9(!+K,,(+$'&6"/QSsD`D&¯57D`D6(!*, 4BC`@= #; /> #-/(SBC$;= 2DaP"5"J,36 2W"J 2(S$7G
2&, AH57D`¤2 E;mD`&, #5#BC$;= 2DP"\~ ¥ bg 1:O(+*C(W"®:O^; p"9 2(T$#G´;=Z> 2+ 2&=(;=P"J(+!K,(!`$&6"NQ
¥ $1$;°"J$H-/ #"_GL$'%D` #57+&,&,.BC$+ C5#K6$,(BC@ #;VBC$;= 2DP"/w5#! 1eWR,(+$+^57DO`&
§T$1"9(H5#(!^"9(!P-2"/ö6p"9&,U(+*,
¥
2&, 2W57Db6&, #5#Sgh@ #;Vgh$;= 2Da(+$C5#&657D`|,"9 %,&K657DP57&6-N #;
! 236 #5#(! #;BC #5'"J,W"5#&6;D`$&,'(!q;=&65#Dnp57(W5 © ~9l*655#&aMb5#H;³ u1D^5'"J$'
f2'
Hgh 2(+*,$;,"V57&6;³s3,3D^-A57(!`$&6"U$7G]b6&, E57.gh$;= 2DP" © ~vº$-X& f2' 57&6;Ú/us_u
"J|"J(! ABGL$Sgh`@= #;]gh$;= 2D^" © ~9b6(+(! 2D`D 2(S5#DQ fA' Q
uø ù
. ú
4£
¢£O¢ áû³O. ¢×á I± _£#Üa e.
µ & -/$BCB]$&."J36 #-/P57D-A5"J U$#G(!*, UBC`@= E;c N> E-/(H"B]$;= 2D6^"S(!*, UW57&6;=$'B} /> #-/(W"
BC$;= 2DvQrt&(!*,P"wBC$;= 2D,(+*, T[6@ #;U /> #-/(^"6¸!6"9(T54-/$'&6"J(W57&(257&6;U(!*, SBC`@= #;4 /> #-/(W"
*65201 p&,$-/,+01 $'O$(+*, 2T3q57(!(+ 2!&·QRT*,^"TBC$; 2D6BV57X1 #"w(+*, p #"9(!Bc57(!`$&]"J$'BC 2:O*65#(
#5"9 2A,57&q;cGL! E, A&=(+D|U$-2-/H"O&V&657(+,! iQ
µ &, 4 2@57B]3,D O$#Gw(+*,^"TP"®(!* _+ 236 #57(+ #;CBC #5'"J,+ 2BC 2&1(w$#Gw&(!+$' 2&VD 201 2DP"rGL!$B
(!*, 4ghP"!"9^"!"93,3k+01 2¼üNQtý&](!*,P"® 2@57BC3D O:T *65201 p! 236 #5#(! #;BC #5"9,! ABC 2&1(H"aGL!$B
"J 201 2W57Dw3D^5-N #"p57D`$&,.(!*, !`01 22·57&6;8:T$'&6;= 24K6$(+*±57K6$(%(!* M0'57+^5#(!$'& :O`(!*,`&
57&6;K6 2(9:T 2 2&(+*, I;=?> A! 2&(C3,DP5-/ #"NQ¹RT*, I;,57(W5z5#! {"J*,$#:O&³&(H5#K,D
f Qf
57&6;
3,D$'(!(! E;c`&C[6,+
f
Q¬Q
ý§©«ª©Õ©«¬}ë®°¬}±F²µ´ ©u²·¶ ¸¹í½þå%¾¹¿ÀÁÂÀÜÃ}ÄÃ:ª}µ²®°±F¬²I¾¹´µÇ>¨Èɵʪ}òI±Ç µ¸¹Ã˰̾¹ª}ª}¸Æ¸.µª©u¸Í½º¼ÎÎFÏн
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
•
•
• •
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
• •
• •
•
Site number
Nitrogen level in Parts Per Million
1 2 3 4 5 6
10 20 30 40
r`,+
f
Qÿ=eww@57BC3D T$#G´5pH57&q;=$B¹-/$'BC36$&, A&=(wB]$;= 2Döi(+!$' 2&UBC #5'"J,+ 2BC 2&(H"
GL+$B<(+*, gh^"!"9^"+"J33,ajO01 2AQ
sp"4(!*, V;57(H585#! V,&K657DP57&6-N #; :O(+*V¸!6"9(%$& W57&6;$B /> #-N(2r(+*,^"%B]$;= 2D^"
-25#DD` #;C5%$& ¨ :ª52|&=K65#D^5#&6-/ #;CH5#&6;=$'B N> E-/(H"TBC$; 2D57&q;h-25#&K6 :O!(+(! 2&c5"/e
^,_ÿedB¡%w4dVf w
:O*, 2+ 1e
g
ÿ P"O5¦[q@= #;V-/$'&6"J(W57&(
g
¡^"T(!* _W57&6;$B /> #-/(O:O`(!*ס w xÅz¯~ y tu" $& GL$l_ f t0vKvKv°tu
g
f wS^"T(+*, 405#!P57(!`$&V$7Gd(!*, 4$Kq"J 2+05#(!`$&~v5"S"!5#BC3,D`&,% A!!$'O 2(H-'Q
:O(+*cf w#x z¯~ y tu"%$
{ GL$_ f t0vKvKv°tu<5#&6;á_ f tv°vKvKv°tëw
b57(+ 22w: V"J*q57DD6"J ](!*,P"_BC$;= AD®`& $',"J(+6;=|I$7GF;=Z> 2+ 2&(_ E"J(!`BV57(+&,.5#&6;
(+ #"J(+&,UBC A(!*,$;,"NQwRT*,P"\B]$;= 2DP"O-*$1"J A&h5'"\`(TP"TKk$'(!*I"9BC3,D` 136 2W"J3,P-/,$q"5#&6;
`&z:O^; #"J3,+ #5;zq"J 1O:O*,`D h`(V"J(+D`D3,+$36 2+D|-A57&`01 h6"]"J$B] h*,`&=(W"m$#GU:O*65#(
*65#3,36 2&6"O&V(!* _B]$! F-/$BC3D 2@-25'"J #"T$#GBC`@= #;U /> #-/(BC$;= 2DP"/Q
ÞhÛV<Ö= M ÛV<rÙ Ú M<Ú C Û Ý ÞhÛV<Ú <Ú
= <%X ÝYC Ý[Z ÝYUÛÞ = Ù\C ÝY]wÞ
d01 A!|(!*,`&,"J*,$',D^;CK6 %Bc5;= 45'""9BC3D 5"O3k$i"!"9K,D` 1,K,,(O&,$'(p"9BC3D 2AQ
sDK6 2+(Ow&q"J(! A&I~
f0
2¨HfA
'
t&8(!*, U3! 20$'6"p-H*6573,(+ 2p: U*65201 "J 2 2&8(+*, BC$;= 2DaGL$pB]@ #; /> #-N(H"/QRT*,P"
BC$; 2D-257&°"J A!01 V5'"M58"9 2(!(+&,hGL$'U(!*, V5#&657D`|,"9^"N®K,(%GL$57&|3,W5-/(+^-25#DT6"9 V$7G
(+*, hBC$; 2DT: h:OD`DO&, 2 #;±BC 2(+*,$;,"%GL$ #"J(+BV5#(!&8(!*, .,&,X&,$#:O&3657W57BC 2(+ 2H"NQ
"J(+BV5#(!`$&V&.BC@ #;M /> #-N(H"OBC$;= 2DP"\*65'"(!W5;=`(!`$&65#DD|]Kk A 2&I;=$& %K|h;Z> 2! A&=(
X&6;"$7G\65';=H5#(!P-M"9,BV"BC A(!*,$;,"NaK,,(4(!*, ];= 201 AD$3BC 2&(T&{-/$'BC3,,(+ 236$#:T A
*65'"C$36 2&, #;,3³&, 2:Ü3k$i"!"9K,`D(+ #"]"J6-H*³5"VDX1 AD*$1$;)K65'"J #;³573,3!$15'-* #"h5#&6;
¥ KK6""!57B]3,D`&,,Q´tý&(!*^"-*q573,(+ 2:T S:ODD6'01 S5_K! NGa&(!+$;=6-/(+$'&M(+$%(!* BC$i"J(
-/$'BCBC$'&M #"9(!`BV57(+$&]57&q;(! E"J(!`&,UBC 2(+*,$;,"T6"9 #;C&VBC`@= #;U /> #-/(W"TBC$;= 2DP"/Q
øÛ
%
¢
á IÜ× ¡U³®¢×á ¢
·± 4£¯>
! #"%$&(')*,+.-/103254687:9;<+>=?+@BA<C3(A<D E
RT*, .(!W5;=`(!$'&657DBC 2(!*$;)$7GF #"J(+BV5#(!& W57&6;=$'B -/$'BC36$&, A&=(W"mP"m(+*,!$',*³(!*,
165;H57(+^-CGL$!Bc"m$#G4(!*, Is µ s(H5#K,D 1Q½RT*, hKq5"JP-hBC 2(+*,$;)P"m(+$ #1657DS(!*,
$'K6"J 2+01 #;U"JB$#G"!165#! #"(!$4(!*, A 2@3k E-/(H5#(!$'&a57&6;]"J$D`01 O(!*, S #1657(+$'&6"®(+$F[q&6;
(+*, p #"9(!Bc57(! E"/Q µ &, 2@,5#BC3,D` $#Gw(+*,^"®GL$'O(!*, pKq57D^5#&6-/ #;C$'&, ¨ :O52|CH5#&6;=$'B N> E-/(H"
BC$; 2D1^"O"9*,$#:O&hK6 2D`$7:4e
u1$,W-/ 4$7G´0'57!P57(+$& n A! A #"T$7GGL! 2 E;=$B u1B$#G"+q57! E" w@=36 #-N(! #;CBC #5#&
"JB$#G"+q57! E"
§T 2(9:T 2 2& 3M
f N j
wPOëp
~ Q
wSR M Q
RTR
$ "%$
&
dB"%$
{VU
(!*& :MB
N j
wPOëp NXW
YOëp
~Q w#M Q
wZR $ "%$
{
Rr5#K,D Qf eTu1B<$7G"+q57! E"ªGL$'OK657DP57&6-/ E;cW57&6;$B /> #-/(W"TBC$;= 2DvQ
^,_aÿÛd ¡yw4d¤f w
:O* 2! 1e
g
ÿ8^"O5%[6@ #;V-/$&6"9(H5#&=(AQ
g ¡ w P"T(!*, 4W57&6;=$'B /> #-/(O:O(+*ס w xÅz¯~
y
t" $
& Q
g
f w^"U(!*, .0'57!P57(+$&°$7G4(+*, h$'K6"J A!0'57(+$& ~v5"C"+57BC3D&8 2!+$ 2(H-Q :O(+*
f wxÅz¯~ y t"%$
{ Q
g
l_
f
t0vvv%tuÜ57&6;[á_
f
tvvv%t\
Ra$8[6&6;)(+*, .sp
µ
ds² #"9(!`BV57(+ MGL$ "%$
{
T: C[6H"9(M #165#DO(!*, V:O(+*,&°"9,B $7G
"!1657+ #"p~"9 2 4(H57KD
Q f7
(!$U(W"T 2@3k E-/(H5#(!$'&ae
N j
wPOp N]W
Ù
YOëp
~Q wM Q
wSR
$_ ~':MB _^"%$
{ Q
s&6;C(!*, A&h"9$D`01 p(!*,P"\ E65#(!`$&V:O(+*+ 215#H;,"O(!$ "^ $
{
57&6;V 2(
^
" $
{
_a`b Ùced
`f
Ù
gcedhji Ùgk
i
Ùjlnmpo
j W k j Q
s"¦GL$'Û" ${
T:T V(!* 2&)[6&q;)(!* c" $&
sp µ s #"9(!Bc57(! ]K=|q"J& (+*, 8"9,B $7G
"!1657+ #"/aK,,(4(+*,^"(+BC 4: "J(H5#!(4:O(+* (+*, UK6 2(9:T 2 A&I"J,BÜ$7GS"+q57! E"m~v"J 2 U(W57K,D`
Q f#
e
N j
wPOp N]W
Ù
YOëp
~ Q
wZR M Q
RTR
$ _ ~'.M f7 ~ ^" $ d ^" $
RT*, A&: "J$D`01 p(!*^"T #1657(+$'&:O`(!*.! 2i57H;"\(+$ "%$^
&
657&q; A(
N j
wPOp NXW
Ù
YOëp
~ Q
wZR M Q
RTR
$¢_ ~rM f# ~ ^"%$
& d ^"%$
{sU &t
^
"%$
& d ^
"%$
{sU
_ `ub
Ùncvd
` f Ù gced hi
Ùwlk i llxmpo
j k p t
^
"%$
& _ ` b Ùncedhi
Ùwl k i llmo
hj k p m
M.y z o{
W Q
RT*,P"MK65"9^-8BC 2(+*,$;):$!X"C:T 2D`D\GL$'CK65#D^57&q-/ #;³;= #"J`&6"NQ&6; 2C&,$'!BV5#D(9|
5'"!"JBC3,(!`$&6"w`(w`01 #"r6"(!*, SK6 #"J(165;=W57(+^-O,&=K^5"9 #;U #"J(+BV5#(!$ª~ô 1Q,Qr(+*, S,&=K¨
5'"J #;C165';=H5#(!^-pK65'"J #;C #"9(!`BV57(+$:O(+*C(!*, F"JBV5#DD E"J(0'57!P57&6-N
57&6;C^"&V5#DBC$i"J(
5#DDO-A5"J E"% #5"9|(!$I-/$'BC3,,(+ 1Q8t&°5;,;(!`$&±(¦;=$1 #"%&,$'(C; 236 2&6; $'&57&|I&,$+BV57D
;=P"J(+!K,(!`$&V5'"!"JBC3,(!`$&6"wGL$O(+*, pK65'"J^-p #"9(!`BV57(+&,4(!* 2$+|1,5#&6;C01 E"®,&K,^5'"J #;
#"9(!`BV57(+$H" 201 2&MGL$'O&,$&.&,$+BV57D;^"J(+!`K,,(! E;C;,57(W5=Q
ß}|~upßYã+â6íCæ
ì
9ï,óLï
ì
î1ñççñ=ä2à
úì
ä
º$#: 201 22aGL$U,&K65#D^57&q-/ #;±;= #"9&q"m(+*, VK65"9^-Vsp µ ds²BC A(!*,$;±;=$1 #"U&,$'(U01
5h,&^1, ."J$D`,(!`$&aQ±Ra${5;,;=+ #"!"U(!*^"U3,!$'K,D 2B¯wº 2&q;= 2H"9$&±& fA ;= #"!-N!K6 #;
(+*,! 2 ];=?> A! 2&(4BC 2(!*$;,"p$7GS A&, 2H5#D`¤2&,V(+*, Vsp
µ
s 5#3,3,!$i5-H*±(!$8; #57D:O(!*
,&K65#D^57&q-/ #;CBC$;= 2DP"/QRT*, E"J %B] 2(!*,$;"T*65201 _K6 2 A&&q57BC #;Vº A&6;= 2W"J$&.gh 2(+*,$;htH
t+tO57&6;8t+t!tT$ #"J(+BV5#(!$'&hK65'"J #;h$'&IR®|36 t6t+t5#&6;8t!t+tOq5;=W57(!P-_GL$+BV"/QRT*, 2|
;=?> 2p$&D|hK|h(+*, ]65';=H5#(!P-2"6"9 #"p&8(!* M #"9(!`BV57(+$&.3,!$-N #"!"NQM§T AD$#::T :OD`D
'01 45U"9*,$+(`&=(+!$;=6-N(!$'&V(!$(!*, 4(!* #"J 4(!*! 2 4BC 2(+*,$;,"Ne
.ñ ì çrñí#ä2â ì 8è ñ ë
º A&6;= 2W"J$&IR|=36 ]t6"9 #"465';=H5#(!P-¦GL$'!BV"(+*657(¦57+ C5#&657D`$h(+$h(+*, U$&, ]6"J #;8&
"9(H57&q;,57W;M5#&657D`|,"9^"w$7G0'57+^57&q-/ 1Qw,$'®(+*, O,&K657DP57&6-N #;%H5#&6;=$B N> E-/(H"rB]$;= 2D:O(!*
_
f
t0vKvKv°vKtwL=(!* #"J 165;=W57(+^-GL$+BV"O57+ FGL$',&6;V&V(H5#K,D
Q Q
Ra$[6&6;8(!* Csp µ s E"J(!`BV57(+ %GL$ "%$
{
:T ]57i57&{ #q57D(!*, :O(+*,&{"JB}$7G
"+65#! #"T(+$M`(H"T 2@36 #-/(W57(!`$&a:O*,^-H*V`01 #"
N j
wPOp N W Ù
YOëp
~Q.wnM Q
wZR
$¢_~ N j
wPOëp
w)MB _^"%$
{ Q
RT*, A&8:T "J$'D01 U(+*, M E65#(!`$&8:O(+* + 215#H;,"p(+$
^
"%$
{
a(!$V 2(4(+*, U #"J(+BV5#(! 4GL$4(!*,
2+!$'O(! 2+B<5#&6;' 2(
^
"%$
{ _
`ub Ùnced
` f Ù g cvd hji
Ùgk
i
ÙwlmPo
Ùncvd W Ùk j Q
u1$,W-/ 4$7G´0'57!P57(+$& u1B<$7Gd"!1657+ #" w@36 #-/(! E;"9,B<$#G"!1657+ #"
§T 2(9:T 2 2&
N j
wwOëp
w~ Q
wSR M Q
RTR
$ ~µz?M
N j
wPOëp
U z
"%$
& d ~'aM f7
"%$
{
(!*&
N j
wwOëp NXW
Ù
YOëp
~Q w M Q
wZR
$ ~ N j
wPOëp w MB
" $
{
Rr5#K,D
Q
ecui,Bx$#G"!1657+ #"_GL$,&K657DP57&6-/ E; H5#&6;=$B /> #-/(W"_BC$; 2DQ.²P"_(+*,
(!$(W57Da&,BKk AT$7G´$Kq"J 2+05#(!`$&6"%~vOQ,Q¯z@_
N j
wPOëp
w Q
s"®GL$O(!* _ E"J(!`BV57(+$'&M$#G#"%$
&
,: p6"J 4(+*, "!57B] pBC 2(+*,$;C5"TGL$O(+*, 4K657DP57&6-N #;
-25"9 157&6;C"9 2(w(+*, K6 2(9: 2 2&"JB$7G´"!165#! #"w #1657D6(+$_`(H"w 2@36 #-/(H5#(!`$&aQ´p"J`&,4(!*,P"
:T 4 2(O(+*, pGL$D`D$#:O&,U E65#(!`$&ae
N j
wPOp w ~ Q
wZR M Q
RTR
$ _ ~zaM
N j
wPOëp
U z _^" $&
d~rM f# _^" $
{
*, 2&."J$'D0&,U(+*,^"T #165#(!$'&h:O`(!*V! 2i57W;,"\(+$
^
"%$
&
=: _' 2(
^
"%$
& _
`b Ùced W Ùhi
Ùwl k i llnmpo
k hj k p mz o{
k
`b Ùced
W
oÙ
Q
t&U(+*,^"a 2@57BC3,D` (!*, ª65';=H5#(!P-®GL$!Bc"r5#! S"JB $7G·"+65#! #"NK,,(´&"J$'BC T$'(!*, A
-25"9 #"rºS #;= 2W"J$&¦gh 2(!*$;Utk`01 #"a6"r165';=H5#(!^-wGL$+BV":O*^-H*%5#! &,$(w&$& ¨ &, 2i57(!`01
;= /[6&,`(! 157&6;V*, 2&6-N 457DP"J$&,$("J,B÷$7Gd"!1657+ #"/Q
s"m(+*, .sp µ s¹ #"J(+BV5#(!$4GL$CKq57D^5#&6-/ #;°;= #"9&q"/Oº E;= 2H"9$&°gh 2(+*,$;zt%P"
6"J65#DD`|V(! 4 #5'"J|C(+$C-N$BC3,(! 1Q´tý(O:$+X,"T[6&, 4&.0'57!P57&6-N %-N$BC36$& 2&=(BC$;= 2DP"/
K,,(4-25#&8&,$(Kk 6"9 #;h&.BC@ #;C /> #-/(W"\BC$; 2D^"NQ4RT*, UBC$;= 2D-A57&8&I"9$BC :O52|"
Kk c5;,5#3,(! #;(+$hBC`@= #;h N> E-/(H"~ôK|8(!! E57(!`&,h(+*, M[6@ #;8 /> #-/(W"%5"%W57&6;$B 2(H-Q
K,,(O(!* #"J 5733,!$i5-H*, #"O01 K,^5'"J #;V #"J(+BV5#(H"/Q
hñ
ì
çñ=í#ä2â
ì
ñ1å âaç
ë#ë
Þ
º 2&6;= AH"J$'&8gh 2(+*,$;ht+t® 2@(! A&6;,"Sgh 2(!*,$;.t®(+$CBC@ #;U /> #-/(W"\BC$; 2DQt&h-N$&6;=q- ¨
(!$'&Vgh 2(+*,$;Vt!tH=: [6H"9(O(!+ #57(O(+*, pH5#&6;=$'B< /> #-/(W"O5"®[6@ #;57&6;C(!* 2&V #"J(+BV5#(!
(!*, p3q57H5#BC 2(+ 2H"K=|D #5'"J(S"+65#! #"NQw (!*, 2&V6"9 4(!*, #"9 p365#H57B] 2(! 2W"®(+$!! ABC$#01 ©
(!*, U[6@ #;h /> #-/(AK|I"JK,(!W5-/(+&,V(!* M #"9(!`BV57(+ #;c[6@ #;8 /> #-/(p(+ 2!B¯QUt& (+*, M A&6;
:T 46"J gh 2(+*,$;Vt®$'&h(!* W-/$+! #-N(! #;
©
;57(H5Q
"J&p(!*, &,$(W57(+$&UGL!$'B"9 #-/(!`$&
f Qf
1(!*,P"rBC #5#&6"(+! #5#(!`&,·`×bdÛ I¡85'"[6@ #;
/> #-/(H"N #"9(!Bc57(!`&,
^
b°(!*,+$,'* D` #5"9(%"+q57! E"/57&6;I6"J`&,.º 2&6;= AH"J$'&Igh 2(!*$; t
57(I^ M`
^
bQ
RT*,P"%BC 2(!*$;¶:$+X,"U:T 2D`DT$'&zBC`@= #;8 /> #-/(W"U;,57(W5þ:O`(!*°&,$ `&=(+ 2H5'-/(!`$&K6 ¨
(9:T A 2& [6@ #;±57&6;±H5#&6;=$B Gv5'-/(!$'H"/K,,(:O(!*±`&=(+ 2H5'-/(!`$&K6 2(9:T A 2&±(! 2+BV"/w(+*,^"
BC$; 2D'01 #"TK,P5"9 #; #"9(!`BV57(+ #"/Qº A&6;= 2W"J$&.BC 2(+*,$;Vt!t®P"\q"J65#DD|Gv57+D|C E5"J|V(+$
-/$'BC3,,(+ 11K,,(O&,$]57&q57D|(!P-GL$!B,DP5"dGL$'S"!5#BC3,D`&,%0'5#!^5#&6-/ #"S57+ 4X=&,$#:O&aQ
.ñ
ì
çrñí#ä2â
ì ñ1å râaç
ë#ë7ë
Þ
º A&6;= 2W"J$&³gh A(!*,$;³t!t+tm6"9 #"V(! I5±;=?> 2! 2&(V5#3,3,!$i5-H*(+*657&³(!* þ[6W"J(V(9:T$
BC A(!*,$;,"NQt&6"J(+ #5;z$#GU6"9&,°5#&657D`$1"V(!$±(!* "9,B $7Gm"!1657+ #"MGL!$B "J(W57&6;,5#H;
5#&657D`|,"9^"w$7G·05#!P57&6-/ i(H5#(!*, A®q"J #"-/$'&=01 2&(!`$&65#D=D` #5"9("!1657+ #"57&65#D|"J^"w$#G&,$& ¨
$'!(!*$$'&657Dd;,57(W5=QSt&h3,W5-/(+^-/ 4(!*^"OBC #57&q"®[6(!(+&,]57&.$701 A!365#H57B] 2(! 2+¤2 E;mBC$; 2D
5#&6;V"J,K ¨ BC$;= AD^"/57&6;C6"9&,U(+*, 4! #"9(T(+ 2!BV"5'"165;H57(+^-\GL$'!BV"wGL$O(+*, 4 #"J(+BV5 ¨
(+$&V3,+$-/ #"+"/Q µ & _ A@,5#BC3,D S$7G´(!*^"T^"T`DD`6"J(+H57(+ #;C&8u1 #5#!D` U~
fA)
Q
º 2&q;= 2H"9$&½gh 2(!*$;t+t!tM'01 #"M&=K,P5"9 #; E"J(!`BV57(+ #"M 201 A&&³BC@ #;) N> E-/(H"
BC$; 2D^":O`(!*8`&=(+ 2H5'-/(!`$&8K6 2(9:T 2 A&þ[6@ #;85#&6; H5#&6;=$'B Gv5'-/(!$'H"/aK,(%(!* 2! UP"F&$
,&^1, "J$D`,(!`$&VGL$S(!*, ¦º 2&6;= AH"J$'&8gh 2(+*,$;ht+t!tT #"9(!`BV57(+ 1QTRT*^"OKk E-2576"9 %(+*, 2!
5#! p(+$1$CBV57&|"JBV"®$#G"+65#! #"S520'57DP57K,D` 157&6;V(!*, A! 45#! 4&,$!,D` #"dGL$'O:O*,^-H*."J 2(
$#GS"JBV"$7G\"!1657+ #"_(+$V6"J 1QRT*, A! ^"457DP"J$V&,$.57&65#D|(!P-m3,+$1$7GS(+*657(4(W"4"J,BV"S$7G
"+65#! #"*65201 S57&|%$3(!Bc57D3,!$'3k A!(!` #"GL$'® E"J(!`BV57(+&,O0'5#!^5#&6-/ -/$B]3k$'&, 2&(H"N7K,(
(+*, 4BC 2(!*$;c*q5"O(!,+&, #;$',(S(!$Kk ¦(! 6"J /GLDr`&3H5-N(!^-A57D5733,DP-257(+$&q"/QRT*,
BC A(!*,$;hP"_5#D^"9$8"J$'BC 2:O*65#(4BC$+ ;= 2BV5#&6;=&(+$.-/$BC3,(! U(+*657&B] 2(!*,$;Itp5#&6;
t+tK,,(O:O`(!*V(!$;,52|«¬"TGv5"9(p-/$'BC3,,(+ 2H"(!*,P"T^"T6"9657D`D|C&$M3,+$K,D` 2B8Q
t&4$,´"J`BC3,D ´ 2@,5#BC3,D` r$#G5\$'&,
¨
:O52|4,&K657DP57&6-/ E;FW57&6;$B /> #-/(W"BC$; 2D2(+*,^"
5#3,3,!$i5-H*8`01 #"p;=?> A! 2&(\GL$'!B,D^5'"ªGL$'4 #"J(+BV5#(!$'&aQ_ui(!D`D6(!*, 5'-/(!q57Dw #"9(!`BV57(+ #"
5#! 4&V3,W5-/(+^-/ p(+*, "!5#BC 1Q
_0r 3 e4
t& f2 f j5#$~vj5#$ f2 f ¿ ~jS57$ f2 fv 3,!$'36$1"J E;)5#&°57D(+ 2!&q57(!`01 U #"J(+BV5#(!`&,
BC A(!*,$;CGL$pW57&6;=$'B} /> #-/(W"\BC$; 2D^"NQ4RT*,^"B] 2(!*,$;V&,$#: '$1 #"p,&6;= 2(!*, U&65#BC
gh`&,B,B$'!B üq5;=W57(!P-C&K,^5'"J #;8"9(!Bc57(!`$&°~g8t9_üp
QRT*,P"FB] 2(!*,$;
BC`&,B¤N #"57&°~w6-/D`^;= #5#& &,$+BY,&6; 2p(!* U! #"9(!!P-/(!`$&6"O(!*q57(4(!*, U E"J(!`BV57(+$S^"
5q5;=W57(!P-FGL$'!B$7G(+*, %$'K6"J A!0'57(+$&q"p57&6;V,&K,^5'"J #;QSt&V3,H5'-/(!P-/ 4(!*,P"\B] 2(!*,$;
:O`DDO&, 2 E;)3,+$W"mGL$]Kk$'(!*³(!*, .H5#&6;=$B -/$B]3k$'&, 2&(H"57&6;z A!!$'C(! A!B8Q³p"9&,
(+*, z8~'ß4b#tFà &,$'(H57(+$'&hGL$S(!*, 4BC`@= #; /> #-/(OBC$;= AD~GL$&6;`&8"J E-/(!`$& f Qf7 6:T
-25#&V:O!(+ p(!* #"J 43,+$W"T&V$& %-N$70'5#!^5#&6-/ 4BV5#(!!`@Ûà
hj
m
=:O*,P-*V&q-/D6; pK6$(!*.(!*,
W57&6;=$'B-/$'BC36$&, 2&(H"O5#&6;(+*, 4 2!+$O(+ 2!B8Q
,$4$& CD`&, #57-/$'BMK&65#(!$'&8$7GS(+*, MW57&6;$B /> #-N(H"ur(!*, ] #"J(+BV5#(!$'&8^"
;=$'&, C6"9&,.(!*, c65';=H5#(!P-mGL$+BQ_pQkQ.,$U(+*,^"65';=H5#(!P-mGL$+Bx: MD` 2(¹K6
(!*, "J|BCBC N(!+^-wBV57(+!`@_:O*^-H*UBC&,`BM`¤2 A"1~qà
hj
m à
hj
m 1,&6; 2(!*, -/$&q;=(+$&q"
`\_ y 57&6;H1~D à _ _9QSº 2+ áàw+ /GL 2H"O(!$](!*, ¦-/$+! 2DP57(!`$&8BV5#(!+@UGL$p(+*,
H57&q;=$B /> #-/(ª-/$+! #"936$&6;=`&,C(+$[9Q
ui:O57D`D$#:{ u1 #5#!D` O~
fA
1
;= #;6-/ #;p"9 201 2W57D E"J(!`BV57(+$W"kK65'"J #;4$&%(+*,^"B] 2(!*,$;
GL$4"9$BC ¦-/$BCB]$&.;= #"9&q"/Qsp":T "9 2 %`&8(!*, A57!(+^-/D` 16(!*,P"BC 2(+*,$;h;=$1 E"F&$(
*65201 O;=$pK6 "J$'D01 #;4K=|4(+ 2H5#(!`$&aQ´RT*,^"rBc57X1 #"(+*, OBC 2(+*,$;_BC$'! ª"J,`(! #;_GL$'wD^5#! A
;,57(W5"J A(H"T(!*q57&h(+*, 4g b¯57&6;VjSg bh #"9(!`BV57(+$H"&(!+$;=6-/ #;&C(+*, 4&, 2@(O"J E-/(!`$&aQ
tý&¯5;,;(!$'&a(+*, g8t9_üpz;=$1 E"&,$(! #1,+ U5#&=|V&,$'!BV5#D(9|V5'"!"9,BC3,(+$&q"/57&6;
^"T(!* 2! /GL$'! pq"J /GL,Da A01 2&C:O*, 2&.:T 4(!* _&6;= 2+D|&,¦;=^"9(!!`K,,(+$&q"O57! 4,&X=&,$#:O&aQ
t&3,W5-/(+^-/ 8(+*, IBC$1"9(V-/$B]BC$&±3,+$W"V57! ¤¡ _ 1 5#&6;afÅ_ f 45'"C(!*, #"9
3,!`$H"SD #5';,"p(!$C #"936 #-/^5#DD`| E5"J|¯-257DP-/,DP57(!`$&6"NQ%g8t9_üpz:O`(!*8(+*, #"J U3!$'H"457+
$7GL(! A&8! /GL 2+! #;V(!$V5'"pg8t9_üpO~ y1 Q_uiBC`D^57+D|1(!*, U(+ 2!BÜg8t9_üpO~ f# ,+ /GL 2S(!$
g8tJ4üp¶:O`(!*V3,+$W"¡_
ê
5#&6;f _ f Q
tôGc;,57(W55#! ±B,D(+&,$'!BV5#DD?|³;=^"9(!+K,,(+ #;4(!*,P"þ E"J(!`BV57(+$.^"h(!* )&=K,P5"9 #;
65';=H5#(!P-FGL$+B #"J(+BV5#(!$$7G(!* U"JBc57DD` #"J(0'57!P57&6-N 1QORT*,P"\*65'"D E;c(+$C(!* %(! A!B
á)à^&,`BU,B¥ w5#!P57&6-/ 65';=H5#(!P-hæa&=K,P5"9 #;zñ"J(+BV5#(!$]~g8t4üp Qwt&z(+*, VK657D¨
57&6-/ E;þW57&6;=$'B} /> #-/(W"p"J 2(+(!`&,,g8t_üpz'01 #"S6"p(!*, ]"!5#BC U #"J(+BV5#(! #"S5"p(+*,
sp µ s± #"J(+BV5#(! #"N! A157W;=D E"!"®$#G(!*, F-*,$'^-/ S$7G3!$'H"NQtý&(!* p,&K657DP57&6-/ E;C-25"9
(!*, 4 #1657(+$'&6"O57+ % #5'"JD`|C"9$D`01 #;C&=,B] 2!P-257D`DZ|iQ
g8t9_üp±-/$',D^;V5#D^"J$K6 U"9$D01 E;c+ #-/,W"J`01 2D|1'D 2(+(!&U(!*, 4 #"9(!Bc57(!`$&6"$7GDP5"9(
(! AH57(+$'& K6 (!*, 3,!`$W"F$#GS(!*, &, 2@(p`(! 2W57(!`$&aQ]&6;= A_&$!Bc57D`(9|h5'"!"9,BC3,(+$&q"
(!*,P"TD #5';,"T6"O(!$U(!* %jSg b8 #"9(!Bc57(! iQ
#Y¡ (¢C¤£C ¥¦§#+>¨ ©= -ª¥}7
q+$B "J #-N(!$'& f Qf w: C! 2B] 2BUK6 2(+*657(U(+*, CBC`@= E;h /> #-/(H"4BC$;= 2Dve^h_ `cbVd
I¡d×f,-/$',D^;MK6 p A@=3,+ #"!"9 #;5"T54BMD(!`0'57!P57(+ O&,$+BV57D;=P"J(!+K,(!$'&z ~Í`cb#tFà
:O*, 2! à{&6-ND6;= E"K6$(+*M(+*, S05#!P57&6-/ O$#Ga(+*, OH5#&6;=$B N> E-/(H"w5#&6;U 2!+$(! 2+B8QI
&,$#: 6"9 U(!*, UD`X1 2D`*,$1$;GL$'_(+*, UB,D(+0'57+^57(+ 4&,$+BV57D´;=^"9(!+K,,(+$'&a(!$C[6&q;þ(+*,
DX1 AD*$1$;mGL$S #5-H*C`&6;=0^;657D&V$,SBC`@= #;U /> #-/(W"TBC$;= 2Dve
«]~:b#tFà¬s _3¬¯® àu¬
k d
o_°
k d
o¯±
h
k²
k´³
mSµ¶B·
d h k²
k´³
mj¸
§T #-257q"J p(+*, 4&6;=`0=P;=65#D^"T5#! 4&q;= 236 2&6;= A&=(A=(!*^"TBC #5#&6"®(+*, ¸!$`&=(DX1 AD*$1$;MK6 ¨
-/$BC E"
«]~:b#tFà¬s
_ ® j
wPOëp@¹
¬
e®
àu¬
k d
o k d o ±hk Ù²
k´³ mpµ¶B·
d hk Ù²
k´³ m
¸»º
:O*,P-*C'01 #"T(+*, pGL$D`D$#:O&,UD`$ ¨ D`X1 2D`*,$1$;e
¼U~}b¯tà1¬/ _M
p
$#½
D$'¾)¬e® àu¬n¿·d N j
wPOëpÀ
~ßÑwbMVÿ à k p
~'ß4wbMVÿ ÂÁ_Ã
tôGO: MBV5#@=`BC¤A _(+*,^"pGL$(!*, CKq57D^5#&6-/ #;8H5#&6;=$'B /> #-/(W"FB]$;= 2Da: C 2((!*,
"+57BC p E"J(!`BV57(+ #"T5'"\: ;= #;=6-N #;MGL$O(!* Usp
µ
s B] 2(!*,$;QTu1(!`DDGL$'(+*, 4,&=Kq57D¨
5#&6-/ #;C-A5"J E"®:T 2(ª;=Z> 2+ 2&=( #"9(!`BV57(+ #"/15#&6;MGL$(!*, #"9 4-25'"J #"T: p;=$U&$(T' 2(S57&|
2@3,D`^-/`(a57&q57D|(!P-rGL$!B,DP5=Qwu1$GL$'r(+*, T,&K65#D^57&q-/ #;_B]$;= 2D1:T BMq"J(a6"9 S"J$B] T"9$+(
$#G&=BC 2!P-257DBC 2(+*,$;,"TGL$57&8&(! AH57(+01 4"9$D`,(!`$&8$7Gd(!*, #q57(!`$&aQt&h3,W5-/(+^"J
(+*,^"TP"T$7GL(! A&h;$&, 4K|C0'57!P57&(H"O$7G´(!*, A:O(!$&
¨
jS573,*q"J$&I5#D'$!`(!*,B ~Jb6&q;,"J(+!$B
§O57(! E" f2) Q
w01 2&UGL$(! -/$'BC3,D A@_B]$;= 2D^"N1BC$;= 2+&C-/$'BC3,,(+ 2H"6"J65#DD`|%[6&6;M(+*, pg85#@
¨
`BM,B b6X1 2D`*,$1$;% #"9(!`BV57(+ #"3! 2(+(J|4Gv5"9(25"(!*, OD`X1 2D`*,$1$;%`&UBC$1"9(-25"9 #"w^"r E5"J|
(+$%BV5#@=`BC¤N 1Q µ &, p A@,5#BC3,D $7G´(!*,P"®P"®(!* pD`X1 2D`*,$1$;¦GL$'T(+*, 4gh^"+"JP"!"J`3,3,6!`01 22«ÿ"
D` 201 2D^"T$#GS&,(+!$' 2&{;,57(W5CBC 2&(!$'&, #;V&{"J #-/(+$'&
f Q
QCsp"S:T ]"J 2 %GL+$BY[6',!
Qf
5#&6; Q ,(O*65'"5"JB]$1$(!*V$'&, %(+$3,36 #;VDX1 AD*$1$;M(!*65#(O^"O #5"9D`|MBV5#@=`BC?¤2 #;Q
qÄ ÅX+@BA´')*A+@=Æ (¢C¤£C ¥¦§#+@D¨ = -sÅX ¥}7
sp"w: 4"J*65#DD·"J 2 pDP57(+ 2$&V(!*, Fg857@B,Bb6`X1 2D`*,$1$;M*65'"®$& _$'K=0$'6"®: #57X&, #"+"/Q
§T #-A576"9 M$#GS(!*, C E"J(!`BV57(+$'& $#Gp(+*, m[q@= #;I /> #-/(H"Nw(4`01 #"%5VBC$;= 2W57(+ CK,^5'"FGL$'
(+*, pH5#&6;=$'BY-N$BC36$& 2&=(W"/Qw`(!*V(!*,P"T&VBC`&6;w57(+(! 2W"J$'&hRT*$BC36"9$&I~ fA f7
"9,' #"J(+ #;M$& pBC$;=?[-257(+$'&M$#Ga(!* 4g857@B,Bb6X1 2D`*,$1$;UBC 2(+*,$;U(!$U; #57D:O(!*
(+*, 43,!$'K,D 2B¹$7GdK,^5'"J #;C #"9(!Bc57(! E"/QwRT* _B] 2(!*,$;C*65'"\K6 2 A&&q57BC #;]jg bQ6RT*,P"
6"9657D`D|V"9(H5#&6;,"GL$j\ E"J(!+^-/(+ #;Vg857@B,B<b6X1 AD*$1$;kK,(p5BC$+ %5#3,3,+$3,+^57(+
(+ 2!B:T$',D^;8K6 CjO #"9^;=65#Dg857@B,BYb6`X1 2D`*,$1$;5"p`(p:T$'!X"F$'& (+*, ! #"9^;=65#D^"
52GL(! 2O #"9(!`BV57(+$&(!* F[q@= #;C /> #-N(H"/Q
t&6"J(+ #5;C$#GwBV5#@=`BC?¤2?&,4(!*, DX1 AD*$1$;C5"O5U:O*,$D` 1=`(O;=`0=P;= #"(!*, 4D`X1 2D`*,$1$;
`&=(+$h(9:T$8365#!(W"/Q±RT*,P"%;=`0=P"J$'&±^"%;$&, ."J$I(!*q57(U(!* c[qH"J(U3q57!(UP"%&0'57!P57&(%(+$
(+*, h[6@ #;z /> #-/(Û`×bTS:O*,D` h(+*, + #"J(]^"V;= 236 2&6; 2&=(]$&³`cbQp"J`&,(+*,^"N:T
-25#& E"J(!`BV57(+ %(+*, m[q@= #;8 /> #-/(W"GL!$B}(+*, U365#!(%(+*657(^"4;= 236 2&q;= 2&(p$&V`×bT5#&6;
#"9(!`BV57(+ #"·GL$'T(+*, W57&6;$B¹ /> #-/(H"rGL+$B(!* 365#!((!*q57(TP"w&05#!P57&(®(+$s`cbQw(!*
(+*,^"573,3,+$15'-*V:T F-257&V A(T,&K,^5'"J #;C #"9(!`BV57(+ #"GL$O(+*, pW57&6;=$'B< /> #-/(W"/Kk E-2576"9
: ® E"J(!`BV57(+ w(!* ®W57&6;$B /> #-/(W":O`(!*,$',(r(+*, 3,!$'K,D AB$#G6,&6-N 2!(W57&p[6@ #;p /> #-/(W"/Q
t&C3,W5-/(+^-/ S(!*^"T`01 #""JD`*(!D`|C5';2¸!6"9(! #;C #"9(!Bc57(! E"r$7G´(!*, 4W57&6;=$'B-/$'BC36$&, 2&(H"N
:O*,`D p(+*, p[6@ #;C /> #-/(T E"J(!`BV57(+ #"®+ 2BV5#&C`&=(W5-/(AQ
,!$'B¹"J #-/(+$'& f Qf 1: + 2BC 2BUK6 2(!*65#((!*, pB]@ #;_ /> #-N(H"wBC$;= 2Dq-257&K6 :O+( ¨
(+ 2&5'"^h_ z¯~:`cb#tFà r:O*, 2+ cà &6-/D`6;= #"pK6$(+*±(!*, CW57&6;$B /> #-N(H"%5#&6;(!*,
20
40
60
Error term 50
100 150
Random effect
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
Relative likelihood
Maximum likelihood solution
Likelihood function of Mississippi nitrogen level data
r',!
Qf
eb6X1 AD*$1$;þGL,&(!$'&GL$%(+*, .gh^"+"J^"+"J`3,3,!`01 22«ÿ"FD` 201 2DP"F$#Gp&(!+$' 2&
;,57(W5mBC A&=(+$& #;m`&."J #-/(+$'& f Q QwT5#D, E"O57! 4+ 2D^5#(!01 (!$U(!* _Bc57@05#D, iQ
35 40
45 50
55
Error term 20
30 40 50 60 70 80
Random effect
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
Relative likelihood
Likelihood function of Mississippi nitrogen level data
r',! Q es-/D`$1"J AO0=` 2:$#Gw(+*, 4D`X1 2D`*,$1$;mGL,&6-N(!$'&."J 2 2&V`&c[q,+ Qf Q
2+!$'(+ 2!B8Q µ &, :O52|V$7G$K,(W57`&,&,c5MD`X1 2D`*,$1$;cGL$'(+*, UH5#&6;=$BÜ /> #-/(W"\:O*,P-*
P"T&05#!P57&(O(!$(!*, 4[6@= E;c N> E-/(`cb,^"O(!*,+$,'*8(!*, 4(+H57&q"ýGL$+BV57(+$'&^ÈÇ·_ÊÉ^M
:O*, A! [ÉO_?ËÌM`{~:`H` k p
` ^QCRT*, &, 2: BV57(+!`@c^ÌÇ_P"F&$7:¹"9&,',D^5#4$7GOW57&,X
zaMÎÍ6:O*, 2+ zÜ^"O(!* %&,BMK6 2$7G$'K6"J A!0'57(+$&q"p57&6;}ÍV^"O(!* _&,BK6 2O$7Gw[q@= #;
365#H5#BC 2(! AH"/Q¯»F&$7:O`&,8(!*^"/w: C$&D|:$,DP; :O5#&=(U(+$86"J czÏMÐÍ!$#:S"%$7G(!*,
BV5#(!+@C`&8(!*, U #"9(!`BV57(+$&·Qpt(4-25#&8Kk "9*,$#:O&z~9u1 #5#!D ¦ºS 2&6;= 2W"J$'&
f2
(!*65#(
(+*, 4DX1 AD*$1$;]GL$'p(!*^"O&, 2: ;,5#(H5MBc57(!+@ ^ Ç P"\`&=0'5#!^5#&=(O(+$Û`cb657&q;h(!*65#(p(!*,
#"9(!`BV57(+ #"w! 2BV5#&C(+*, "!5#BC GL$S5#&=|.-H*,$P-/ p$#Gw(+*, zaMÍ+$7:S"TGL!$'B@^ Ç v
RT*,P"(+H57&q"ýGL$+BV57(+$'&-257&5#D^"J$Kk O3! #"9 2&=(+ #;p:O(+*"J$B] T$(+*, 2 #1657(+$&q"/D`X1
º$-HX&,V~
f2'
:O*,$];= #;=6-N #;C(J:$M& 2:D`X1 2D`*,$1$;,"NQTu1(!`DD,K6$'(!*hB] 2(!*,$;"T01
(+*, p"+57BC O E"J(!`BV57(+ #"57&6;M(+*, OGL$DD`$#:O&,4D$' ¨ D`X1 2D`*,$1$;¦GL$'T(+*, W57&6;$B¹ /> #-/(H"¯àSe
¼U~µà¬s _
M p$
D$uˆu„M
p
$
D`$u¬` à k p
`„M
W k m
$
D$'# à k p
M
W k m
$
D`$Òf dD`$[Ó
$Ô
W k meÕ,Ö
l$'BC3657+ #;M(+$M(+*, pGL$DD`$#:O&,UD`X1 2D`*,$1$;mGL$'(+*, g b85#3,3,+$15-H*ae
¼U~µà¬s _×M
p$
D$uˆu„M
W$
D$# à k p
M
W$ ±f d{D$S~ e®
U ¸
:O*, A! _]QEMc`~}`HKà>` ` k p à k p
QU57&6;¦Í^"w(!*, SH5#&,X$7GÕ`QO~9u1 2 4b6(+(! 2D`Dk A(T5#DQ
fA Q
