$UQH,VDNVHQ 1LOV+HQULN6ROXP 67(36WRUJDWHQ
12VOR 1RUZD\
2VORDXJXVW
A-02
•
1998
$UQH,VDNVHQ
1LOV+HQULN6ROXP
,QQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHUIRU
$XVW$JGHU,QQVSLOOWLO
6WUDWHJLVN1 ULQJVSODQ
)D[
:HEKWWSZZZVROQRVWHS
67(3 SXEOLVHUHU WR XOLNH VHULHU DY VNULIWHU 5DSSRUWHURJ$UEHLGVQRWDWHU
67(3$UEHLGVQRWDWHU
, GHQQH VHULHQ SUHVHQWHUHU YL YLNWLJH IRUVNQLQJVUHVXOWDWHU VRP YL ¡QVNHU n JM¡UH WLOJMHQJHOLJH IRU DQGUH PHQ VRP LNNH KDU HQ IRUP VRP JM¡U GHP HJQHW WLO SXEOLVHULQJ L 5DSSRUWVHULHQ $UEHLGVQRWDWHQH NDQ Y UH VHOYVWHQGLJH DUEHLGHU IRUDUEHLGHU WLO VW¡UUH SURVMHNWHUHOOHUVSHVLHOOHDQDO\VHUXWDUEHLGHWIRU RSSGUDJVJLYHUH 'HLQQHKROGHU GDWD RJ DQDO\VHU VRP EHO\VHU YLNWLJH SUREOHPVWLOOLQJHU UHODWHUW WLO LQQRYDVMRQ WHNQRORJLVN ¡NRQRPLVN RJ VRVLDO XWYLNOLQJRJRIIHQWOLJSROLWLNN
67(3 PDLQWDLQV WZR GLYHUVH VHULHV RI UHVHDUFKSXEOLFDWLRQV5HSRUWVDQG:RUNLQJ 3DSHUV
67(3:RUNLQJ3DSHUV
,Q WKLV VHULHV ZH UHSRUW LPSRUWDQW UHVHDUFK UHVXOWV WKDW ZH ZLVK WR PDNH DFFHVVLEOH IRU RWKHUVEXWWKDWGRQRWKDYHDIRUPZKLFKPDNHV WKHP VXLWHG IRU WKH 5HSRUW 6HULHV 7KH :RUNLQJ 3DSHUVPD\EHLQGHSHQGHQWVWXGLHVSLORWVWXGLHV IRU ODUJHU SURMHFWV RU VSHFLILF DQDO\VHV FRPPLVVLRQHG E\ H[WHUQDO DJHQFLHV 7KH\
FRQWDLQGDWDDQGDQDO\VHVWKDWDGGUHVVUHVHDUFK SUREOHPV UHODWHG WR LQQRYDWLRQ WHFKQRORJLFDO HFRQRPLF DQG VRFLDO GHYHORSPHQW DQG SXEOLF SROLF\
6WLIWHOVHQ67(3
+HQYHQGHOVHURPWLOODWHOVHWLORYHUVHWWHOVHNRSLHULQJHOOHUDQQHQ PDQJIROGLJJM¡ULQJDYKHOHHOOHUGHOHUDYGHQQHSXEOLNDVMRQHQVNDO UHWWHVWLO
$SSOLFDWLRQVIRUSHUPLVVLRQWRWUDQVODWHFRS\RULQRWKHUZD\V UHSURGXFHDOORUSDUWVRIWKLVSXEOLFDWLRQVKRXOGEHPDGHWR 67(36WRUJDWHQ12VOR
LLL
'HWWHQRWDWHWRPIDWWHUHQVDPOLQJDYILUHQRWDWHUXWDUEHLGHWIRU1 ULQJVHWDWHQ L$XVW$JGHUI\ONHVNRPPXQHLIRUELQGHOVHPHGLQQVSLOOWLODUEHLGHWPHGQ\VWUD WHJLVNQ ULQJVSODQIRUI\ONHW,QQVSLOOHWVNXOOHWDXWJDQJVSXQNWLHWLQQRYD VMRQVSHUVSHNWLYVLGHQ1 ULQJVHWDWHQ¡QVNHWnInXWUHGHWQ UPHUHRPHWVOLNW SHUVSHNWLYNXQQHY UHIUXNWEDUWIRUQ ULQJVSROLWLNNHQRJWLOWDNVDUEHLGHWLI\O NHWVDPWKYDHWVOLNSHUVSHNWLYEHW\UQnUGHWJMHOGHUWLOQ UPLQJVPnWHUWLOUH JLRQDOQ ULQJVSROLWLNNVnYHOVRPPHUNRQNUHWHVWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHU 1RWDWHQHHUXWDUEHLGHWLSHULRGHQGHVHPEHUWLODXJXVW1RWDWHQHHU XQGHUYHLVGLVNXWHUWLXOLNHVDPPHQKHQJHUPHG1 ULQJVHWDWHQRJYLKDUInWW Q\WWLJHNRPPHQWDUHUWLOYLGHUHEHDUEHLGLQJDYQRWDWHQHLGLVVHP¡WHQH-¡UQ 5DQJQHVYHG1 ULQJVVHQWHUHWL9HVWIROGRJ-DPHV.DUOVHQYHG$JGHUIRUVNQLQJ KDURJVnJLWWQ\WWLJHLQQVSLOOWLOHQNHOWHDYQRWDWHQH
'HWI¡UVWHQRWDWHWRP·,QQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWRJUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHU² 3ULQVLSLHOOHEHWUDNWQLQJHU·HUHWUHQW·WHRULQRWDW·)RUPnOHWPHGGHWWHQRWDWHWHU nEHVNULYHKYDVRPPHQHVPHGEHJUHSHWLQQRYDVMRQUHGHJM¡UHIRUKYRUGDQLQQR YDVMRQIRUHJnULQ ULQJVOLYHWVDPWGLVNXWHUHKYDVRPXWIUDWHRUHWLVNHEHWUDNW QLQJHUNDQY UHUHOHYDQWHLQQRYDVMRQVSROLWLVNHYLUNHPLGOHURYHUIRUXOLNHW\SHU DYEHGULIWHU1RWDWHWHURJVnPHQWVRPHQIRUKROGVYLV·SRSXO U·LQQI¡ULQJRYHUIRU RSSGUDJVJLYHULWHPDHWIRU67(3JUXSSHQVSURVMHNWRJRJVnVRPHQEDNJUXQQ IRUGHUHVWHUHQGHQRWDWHQH
1RWDWRJDQDO\VHUHUXOLNHVLGHUYHGLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHWL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY²RJPHGEUXNDYXOLNHW\SHUGDWDRJPHWRGH'HWDQGUHQRWDWHWRP
·1 ULQJVVWUXNWXURJLQQRYDVMRQL$XVW$JGHU²6WDWLVWLVNDQDO\VH·JLUHQEUHG RYHUVLNWRYHUYLNWLJHIRUKROGYHGQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHURJLI\ONHWVILUHUHJL RQHU'DWDNLOGHQHHURIIHQWOLJVWDWLVWLNNRJRIIHQWOLJHGDWDUHJLVWUHRJGHWHUWLO GHOVVQDNNRPQ\HGDWDNLOGHUVRPKLWWLOKDUY UWOLWHEHQ\WWHWWLODQDO\VHUDY UHJLRQDOQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJ1RWDWHWVDPPHQOLNQHUIRUKROGYHGQ ULQJVVWUXNWXU XWGDQQLQJVQLYnIRUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJ)R8RJLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWL$XVW
$JGHUPHGWLOVYDUHQGHWDOOIRUODQGVJMHQQRPVQLWWHW
0HQVQRWDWDOWVnJLUHQEUHGRYHUVLNWRYHUYLNWLJHIRUKROGYHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYL WHWL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLYHUIRUPnOHWPHGQRWDWnIRUHWDJUXQGLJHVWXGLHUL QRHQXWYDOJWHEHGULIWHURJQ ULQJVVHNWRUHU1RWDWRP·,QQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWRJ LQQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHUL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY²FDVHVWXGLHU·VNDOV UOLJ VNDIIHIUDPNXQQVNDSRPKYRUGDQEHGULIWHUL$XVW$JGHULQQRYHUHURJRPKYD VRPHUYLNWLJHXWIRUGULQJHURJIODVNHKDOVHUYHGEHGULIWHQHVLQQRYDWLYHDNWLYLWHW 'HWHUNXQQVNDSVRPLNNHNDQIUDPVNDIIHVYLDRIIHQWOLJVWDWLVWLNNPHQVRP NUHYHUHJQHJUXQGLJHVWXGLHU1RWDWEDVHUHVVnOHGHVSnSHUVRQOLJLQWHUYMXPHG OHGHUHLXWYDOJWHEHGULIWHUVDPWSnDOOHUHGHJMHQQRPI¡UWHLQQRYDVMRQVDQDO\
VHULILUHUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHULI\ONHWQHPOLJLSODVWEnWLQGXVWUL,7 Q ULQJHQPDULWLPVHNWRURJWXULVWQ ULQJHQ'HEHGULIWHQHEOHYDOJWXWL
VDPUnPHGRSSGUDJVJLYHURJGHWRPIDWWHUEHGULIWHULXOLNHGHOHUDYI\ONHWLXOL NHEUDQVMHULXOLNHVW¡UUHOVHVJUXSSHURJVnYLGHUH
'HWVLVWHQRWDWHW·2SSVXPPHULQJRJIRUVODJWLOLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHUIRU$XVW
$JGHU·RSSVXPPHUHUYLNWLJO UGRPIUDGHWUHI¡UVWHQRWDWHQHEnGHQnUGHW JMHOGHUJHQHUHOOO UGRPRPUHJLRQDOLQQRYDVMRQVSROLWLNNRJVLWXDVMRQHQL$XVW
$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY3nEDNJUXQQDYNXQQVNDSHQHUYHUYHWLSURVMHNWHWKDUYLVn IRUVODJWLOLQQRYDVMRQVUHWWHWHVWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHUIRUXOLNHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHU
6HOYRPQRWDWHQHE\JJHUSnKYHUDQGUHKDUYLRJVnSU¡YGnVNULYHKYHUWQRWDW VOLNDWGHNDQOHVHVXDYKHQJLJDYKYHUDQGUH'HUPHGYLOGHWY UHOLWWRYHUODS SLQJPHOORPQRWDWHQHYHGDWGHQRYHURUGQHGHKHQVLNWHQPHGSURVMHNWHWHUEH VNUHYHWNRUWIDWWHWI¡UVWLKYHUWQRWDW
Y
)2525',,,
,11+2/'9
127$7,1129$7,9$.7,9,7(72*5(*,21$/(,1129$6-216675$7(*,(5 35,16,3,(//(%(75$.71,1*(5
,QQOHGQLQJ 8WIRUGULQJ*OREDOLVHULQJDYQ ULQJVOLYHW 8WIRUGULQJ1\GRPLQHUHQGHSURGXNVMRQVPnWH 2SSVXPPHULQJRPXWIRUGULQJHU 6YDU8WQ\WWJOREDOLVHULQJHQWLOnVNDIIHDUEHLGVSODVVHUXWHQIUD 6YDU%\JJVWHUNHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU (WIHOOHVVYDU6WLPXOHULQQRYDWLYHPLOM¡HU ,QQRYDVMRQHUVRPHQGULYNUDIWLQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ ,QQRYDVMRQHUHUVDPDUEHLGRJJMHQVLGLJO ULQJ 5HJLRQDOHIDNWRUHUNDQVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW 8OLNHYLUNHPLGOHUIRUXOLNHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHW 6WUDWHJL/RNDOIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDOEHGULIWHU 6WUDWHJL7LOI¡UHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUVWUDWHJLVNNRPSHWDQVH 6WUDWHJL.Q\WWH¶HQVOLJH·EHGULIWHUWLOQDVMRQDOHNRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HU 6WUDWHJL6NDS¶VW¡WWHPLOM¡·UXQGWQ\HWDEOHUH 2SSVXPPHULQJ(QPXOLJLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLIRU$XVW$JGHU +YDQn"
127$715,1*66758.7852*,1129$6-21,$867$*'(5²67$7,67,6.
$1$/<6(
,QQOHGQLQJ 'DWDPDWHULDOHW 9LNWLJHQ ULQJHUL$XVW$JGHU ,QQOHGQLQJ 1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL1RUJHRJ$XVW$JGHU 1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL$XVW$JGHUVUHJLRQHU
%HGULIWVVW¡UUHOVH
%RVWHGRJDUEHLGVVWHG 2SSVXPPHULQJQ ULQJVVWUXNWXU 8WGDQQLQJ ,QQOHGQLQJ
1 ULQJVYLVIRUGHOLQJDYXWGDQQLQJ 5HJLRQDOHXWGDQQLQJVP¡QVWUH 9LNWLJHXWGDQQLQJVUHWQLQJHUL$XVW$JGHU 2SSVXPPHULQJ8WGDQQLQJ )RUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJ)R8RJLQQRYDVMRQ )R8DNWLYLWHWLQRUVNHEHGULIWHU ,QQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHW 2SSVXPPHULQJ)R8RJLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHW .RQNOXVMRQ 127$7,1129$7,9$.7,9,7(72*,1129$6-21687)25'5,1*(5,$867
$*'(5615,1*6/,9²&$6(678',(5
,QQOHGQLQJ
%DNJUXQQLQQRYDVMRQHUVRPGULYNUDIWIRUQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ 3UREOHPVWLOOLQJHURJPHWRGH 8OLNHW\SHUEHGULIWHU²PHGXOLNHLQQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHU
·'HWHUQ¡GYHQGLJnY UHSnKXJJHWKHOHWLGHQ·
,QQRYDVMRQHUHUODQJVLNWLJHSURVHVVHU ,QWHUQNRPSHWDQVHRJKROGQLQJHUHUDYJM¡UHQGHYHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW ,QQRYDVMRQVSURVMHNWHUHU·WRSSVW\UWH·
·/HYHUDQG¡UHQHHUHQGHODYEHGULIWHQ·
0DUNHGVRULHQWHUWSURGXNWXWYLNOLQJ ,QQRYDVMRQ VDPDUEHLG 2SSVXPPHULQJRPLQQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHULGHEHGULIWHQH /RNDOHEUDQVMHNRQVHQWUDVMRQHU 3ODVWEnWLQGXVWULHQ ,7Q ULQJHQ 0DULWLPVHNWRU 5HLVHOLYVQ ULQJHQ 2SSVXPPHULQJDYEUDQVMHDQDO\VHQH +YDVnQnUGHWJMHOGHUVWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHU"
6DPPHQGUDJ 9HGOHJJ2YHUVLNWRYHUEHGULIWHUVRPHUPHGLLQWHUYMXXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ 127$72336800(5,1*2*)256/$*7,/,1129$6-216675$7(*,(5 ,QQOHGQLQJ (Q·EUHG·IRUVWnHOVHDYLQQRYDVMRQHU 5HODWLYWODYLQQRYDWLYDNWLYWHWL$XVW$JGHU ,QQRYDVMRQVXWIRUGULQJHUL$XVW$JGHU ,QQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU 6NUHGGHUV¡PDYYLUNHPLGOHU
%HW\GQLQJHQDYGHWUHJLRQDOHQLYnHW
¶6\VWHPRULHQWHUWH·YLUNHPLGOHU )RNXVSnPHUHQQWHNQRORJLXWYLNOLQJ 2JVnO ULQJLYLUNHPLGGHODSSDUDWHW
NWIRNXVSnLQQRYDVMRQHU 6LNUHNRPSHWHQWDUEHLGVNUDIW
%LGUDWLOVDPDUEHLGRJQHWWYHUNVE\JJLQJ ,QVWLWXVMRQVE\JJLQJLUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHU 8OLNHWLOWDNLQ ULQJVNO\QJHQH 0HOORPPHQQIRU·HQVOLJHVYDOHU·
5HJLRQDOIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDOEHGULIWHU .Q\WWQ\HWDEOHUHUHWLOQHWWYHUN 0XOLJKHWHUIRUDNNYLVLVMRQ
LQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHU3ULQVLSLHOOH EHWUDNWQLQJHU
$Y$UQH,VDNVHQ
,QQOHGQLQJ
'HWWHHUGHWI¡UVWHQRWDWHWIUD67(3JUXSSHQLIRUELQGHOVHPHGHWRSSGUDJIRU
$XVW$JGHUI\ONHVNRPPXQHRPELGUDJYHGXWDUEHLGLQJDYHQQ\VWUDWHJLVNQ ULQJVSODQ613IRUI\ONHW$XVW$JGHU¡QVNHULNNHHQ¶WUDGLVMRQHOO·Q ULQJVSODQ LGHQQHRPJDQJ'HWV¡NHVHWWHUHQQ\¶YUL·VRPNDQJM¡UHQ ULQJVSODQHQWLOHW YLNWLJHUHLQVWUXPHQWIRUGHWQ ULQJVUHWWHWHWLOWDNVDUEHLGHWLI\ONHW
'HWWHQRWDWHWDUJXPHQWHWHUIRUDWHWLQQRYDVMRQVSHUVSHNWLYNDQY UHHQVY UW UHOHYDQW¶YUL·SnDUEHLGHWPHGQ ULQJVSODQHQ%HJUXQQHOVHQHUDWJMHQQRPI¡ULQJ DYLQQRYDVMRQHU²VRPQ\HHOOHUHQGUHGHSURGXNWHURJSURGXNVMRQVPnWHU²HU DYJM¡UHQGHIRUnRSSQnNRQNXUUDQVHVW\UNHLEHGULIWHURJUHJLRQHU%HGULIWHUNDQ LNNHKYLOHSnVLQHODXUE U'HPnVWDGLJRSSJUDGHUHSURGXNWHURJPnWHUnSUR GXVHUHSnIRULNNHnEOLXWNRQNXUUHUWDYPHULQQRYDWLYHNRQNXUUHQWHU
,HQVWUDWHJLVNQ ULQJVSODQPnHQYHOJHXWQRHQW\SHUYLUNHPLGOHUIUDPIRUDQ GUH'HWHULNNHVWUDWHJLnYHOJHVHJDOOH¶JRGH·WLOWDNSnHQJDQJ(QQ ULQJVSODQ VRPYHOJHUnNRQVHQWUHUHVHJRPKYRUGDQHQNDQEHGUHHYQHQLEHGULIWHURJQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUWLOnJMHQQRPI¡UHO¡QQVRPPHLQQRYDVMRQHUYLOQHWWRSSIRNXVHUHSn NDQVNMHGHQYLNWLJVWHGULYNUDIWHQLQ ULQJVOLYHWLGDJ
1RWDWHWVNDOEHVNULYHKYDHQLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLIRUQ ULQJVOLYHWPHUJHQHUHOW NDQJnXWSn1RWDWHWVNLVVHUHUI¡UVWQRHQYLNWLJHJHQHUHOOHXWIRUGULQJHUIRUQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHU'HWWHQNHVGDSnXWIRUGULQJHUVRPVWRUHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHWLI\ONHWPnIRUKROGHVHJWLO'HUHWWHUGLVNXWHUHVKYDVRPNDQY UH VYDUHWSnGLVVHXWIRUGULQJHQHRJVSHVLHOWLKYLONHQJUDGHQLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJL NDQP¡WHXWIRUGULQJHQH
8WIRUGULQJ*OREDOLVHULQJDYQ ULQJVOLYHW
+YLONHVWRUHXWIRUGULQJHUP¡WHUVnQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHU"9LVNDOEHVNULYH XWIRUGULQJHQHJMHQQRPnSHNHSnWRYLNWLJHXWYLNOLQJVWUHNNLQ ULQJVOLYHWQHP OLJ• JOREDOLVHULQJRJ
• IUDPYHNVWDYHQQ\GRPLQHUHQGHPnWHnRUJDQLVHUHQ ULQJVDNWLYLWHWSn 'HWRSXQNWHQHJLUVHOYI¡OJHOLJLNNHHQXWI\OOHQGHEHVNULYHOVHDYDOOHXWIRUGULQ JHQHIRUQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQPHQGHVDPPHQIDWWHUQRHQDYGHYLNWLJVWHIRUKRO GHQH
*OREDOLVHULQJEHQ\WWHVIRUnEHWHJQHHQXWYLNOLQJGHUVWRUHWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHO VNDSHUInU¡NWEHW\GQLQJGHWYLOVLVHOVNDSHUVRPKDUDNWLYLWHWVSUHGGUXQGWRP LYHUGHQ*OREDOLVHULQJHQKDUNRPPHWOHQJVWLVHNWRUHUVRPELOLQGXVWULRJHOHN WURQLNNLQGXVWULPHQGHWHUHQWUHQGVRPHUW\GHOLJLVWRUHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOL YHW*OREDOLVHULQJEHW\UDWWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU¡NHUVLQLQQIO\WHOVHRYHU VWDGLJVW¡UUHGHOHUDYGHWQDVMRQDOHQ ULQJVOLYHW'HWVNMHUJMHQQRPDWVHOVND SHQHHWDEOHUHUHOOHUNM¡SHURSSEHGULIWHULXOLNHGHOHUDYYHUGHQPHQRJVnJMHQ QRPDWIRUPHOWVHOYVWHQGLJHEHGULIWHUNQ\WWHVWLOGHWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHQH VRPOHYHUDQG¡UHU3nGHQPnWHQNQ\WWHVPDQJHEHGULIWHUVDPPHQLQHWWYHUN VW\UWGLUHNWHHOOHULQGLUHNWHIUDKRYHGNRQWRUHULWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU
*OREDOLVHULQJHQOHGHUWLODWWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU¡NHUVLQNRQWUROORYHUGHW ORNDOHQ ULQJVOLYHWSnEHNRVWQLQJDYUHJLRQDOHDNW¡UHU%HVOXWQLQJVP\QGLJKHW IO\WWHVIUDWLGOLJHUHVHOYVWHQGLJHEHGULIWHUL$UHQGDOHOOHU5LV¡UWLOVW\UHURPL 6WRFNKROP3DULVHOOHUHQDQQHQGHODYYHUGHQ'HWNDQI¡UHWLODWDQGUHIRUKROG OHJJHVWLOJUXQQYHGEHVOXWQLQJHURPIRUHNVHPSHOLQYHVWHULQJHOOHULNNHLHQEH GULIWL$XVW$JGHU/RNDOHHQWUHSUHQ¡UHURJEHGULIWVOHGHUHKDURIWHHWVWHUNW¡Q VNHRPnGULYHEHGULIWHQVLQYLGHUHVHOYLGnUOLJHWLGHU7UDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU KDUYLUNVRPKHWPDQJHVWHGHULYHUGHQRJHURIWHPLQGUHNQ\WWHWWLOnY UHORND OLVHUWSnEHVWHPWHVWHGHU+DUVHOVNDSHQHSUREOHPHUYHGHQEHGULIWHWVWHGNDQ RIWHYLUNVRPKHWUDVNWIO\WWHVWLODQGUHVWHGHU7UDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHUNDQVn OHGHVHWDEOHUHHOOHUIO\WWHEHGULIWHUGLWGHWHUPHVWJXQVWLJnY UHORNDOLVHUWIRU HNVHPSHOGHUGHNDQRSSQnODYHO¡QQVNRVWQDGHUVWRUHVNDWWHOHWWHOVHUHOOHURI IHQWOLJHNDSLWDOVXEVLGLHU
7UDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHUHUVnOHGHVEOLWWHQYLNWLJHUHDNW¡UL¡NRQRPLHQRJ VWUDWHJLHQWLOVOLNHVHOVNDSHUVSLOOHUHQVWDGLJVW¡UUHUROOHIRUQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ LPDQJHUHJLRQHU'HWEOHW\GHOLJLOOXVWUHUWDY¶(ULFVVRQVDNHQ·YLQWHUHQGD (ULFVVRQVOHGHOVHL1RUJHIRUHVORnIO\WWHHQVY UWYLNWLJEHGULIWIRU$UHQGDORP UnGHWWLOHQIUDPWLGLJHWHNQRORJLSDUNSn)RUQHEX6Y UWPDQJHDYGHVWRUHEH GULIWHQHL$XVW$JGHUHUGHODYWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU+YLONHPXOLJKHWHUKDU HQIRUnP¡WHHQVOLNXWYLNOLQJJMHQQRPGHQUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVSROLWLNNHQ")LQQHV GHWIRUHNVHPSHOYLUNHPLGOHUVRPNDQELGUDWLO¶IRUDQNUH·EHGULIWHUHLGDYWUDQ VQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHUVWHUNHUHLHWORNDOWQ ULQJVPLOM¡VOLNDWEHGULIWHQHEOLU PLQGUHXWVDWWIRUIO\WWLQJWLODQGUHVWHGHU"
'HWNDQY UHHQVWRUVW\UNHIRUHWRPUnGHnKDEHGULIWHUVRPHUGHOHUDYWUDQ VQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU7LONQ\WQLQJWLOHWVOLNWVHOVNDSNDQJLVW¡UUHXWYLNOLQJV PXOLJKHWHUIRUEHGULIWHQHHQQGHNXQQHRSSQnGGVRPHWUHODWLYWOLWHQDVMRQDOW ILUPD,HWVW¡UUHVHOVNDSNDQEHGULIWHUInEHGUHWLOJDQJSnNDSLWDONRPSHWDQVH WHNQRORJLRJVDPDUEHLGVSDUWQHUHYLDVHOVNDSHWRJGHNDQJMHUQHVNLOWHPHGHW PHUNHQDYQRJHWVDOJVRJPDUNHGVI¡ULQJVDSSDUDW%HGULIWHULVHOVNDSHQHNDQ ELGUDWLOnVSUHNRPSHWDQVHRJWHNQRORJLWLODQGUHGHOHUDYGHWORNDOHQ ULQJV PLOM¡HWIRUHNVHPSHOWLOORNDOHOHYHUDQG¡UHUHOOHUYLDEHGULIWHUVRPHU¶DYOHJJHUH·
IUDILOLDOEHGULIWHUWLOWUDQVQDVMRQDOHVHOVNDSHU$XVW$JGHUKDGGHQHSSHKDWWHQ ,7LQGXVWULDYQRHV UOLJRPIDQJGHUVRPPDQJHDYEHGULIWHQHLNNHKDGGHY UW GHOHUDYUHVVXUVVWHUNHVHOVNDSHU%DNGHOHQHYHGHQVOLNHLHUVWUXNWXUEOHW\GHOLJ LOOXVWUHUWDY(ULFVVRQVDNHQ
8WIRUGULQJ1\GRPLQHUHQGHSURGXNVMRQVPnWH
(WDQQHWYLNWLJXWYLNOLQJVWUHNNLQ ULQJVOLYHWHUIUDPYHNVWHQDYHQQ\GRPLQH UHQGHSURGXNVMRQVPnWHRJWDOOHWDQVHVRIWHVRPHWVNLOOHLGHQ¡NRQR PLVNHXWYLNOLQJHQLYHVWOLJHLQGXVWULODQGRJHQQ\PnWHnRUJDQLVHUHQ ULQJV YLUNVRPKHWSnKDUYRNVWIUDP
'HQJDPOHSURGXNVMRQVPnWHQEHWHJQHVIRUGLVPHHWWHU+HQU\)RUGVRPYDUSLR QHUHQLLQQI¡ULQJDYVDPOHEnQGVSURGXNVMRQ)RUGLVPHNMHQQHWHJQHVDYSURGXN VMRQLVWRUVNDODRJLVWRUHEHGULIWHU'HWHUVQDNNRPPDVVHSURGXNVMRQRJPDV VHNRQVXP'HQQDVMRQDOH¡NRQRPLVNSROLWLNNHQYDULQQUHWWHWPRWnVWLPXOHUHWLO
¡NWIRUEUXNIRUnRSSUHWWKROGHRJ¡NHSURGXNVMRQHQRJGHQQHSROLWLNNHQYDUVn OHGHVHQYLNWLJIRUXWVHWQLQJIRUIRUGLVPHQ
)RUGLVPHQYDUSUHJHWDYSULVNRQNXUUDQVHRJVWUDWHJLHQIRUnVHQNHSULVHUYDUn RSSQnVWRUGULIWVIRUGHOHULQQHQKYHUHQNHOWEHGULIW6WRUSURGXNVMRQEHW\UDW NRVWQDGHUWLOSURGXNWXWYLNOLQJPDUNHGVI¡ULQJDGPLQLVWUDVMRQRJOLNQHQGHNDQ VSUHVSnPDQJHHQKHWHUQRHVRPVHQNHUSULVHQSHUHQKHW'HWNUHYHULPLGOHUWLG RJVnHQVWDQGDUGLVHULQJDYSURGXNWHQHGHWYLOVLVWRUHVHULHUDYOLNHSURGXNWHU RJPRGHOOHUVRPNDQSURGXVHUHVPHGGHVDPPHPDVNLQHQH,GHQW\SLVNHIRUGLV WLVNHSURGXNVMRQHQVRPLNNHKDGGHGHWVWRUHRPIDQJHWL1RUJHYDUPDVNLQHQH VSHVLDOODJHWWLOpQW\SHSURGXNVMRQRJDUEHLGHUQHYDURSSO UWSnVPDOHDUEHLGV RSHUDVMRQHUODQJVVDPOHEnQGHW'HWWHJLUHQOLWHIOHNVLEHOSURGXNVMRQVLGHQGHW HUG\UWRJWXQJYLQWnRPVWLOOHWLOSURGXNVMRQDYHWQ\WWSURGXNWHOOHUHQQ\PR GHOO/LWHQIOHNVLELOLWHWRYHUIRUPDUNHGVVYLQJQLQJHUYDURJVnHQDYnUVDNHQHWLO DWIRUGLVPHQNRPXWLHQNULVHYHGWXUEXOHQVHQL¡NRQRPLHQIUDWDOOHWPHG ROMHNULVHURJVWDJQDVMRQRJQHGJDQJLHWWHUVS¡UVHOHQHWWHUPDQJHYDUHU
)RUGLVPHGRPLQHUWHVRPSURGXNVMRQVIRUPLYHVWOLJHLQGXVWULODQGIUDRPNULQJ WLOWDOOHW,O¡SHWDYSHULRGHQHWWHUWDOOHWKDUGHWYRNVWIUDPHQ Q\SURGXNVMRQVIRUPWLOHUVWDWQLQJIRUIRUGLVPHQ'HWHUEHW\GHOLJGLVNXVMRQ EODQW¶IRUVWnVHJSnHUH·RPKYDVRPNMHQQHWHJQHUGHQ¶Q\H¡NRQRPLHQ·3RVW IRUGLVPHHUEHQ\WWHWVRPHQVDPOHEHWHJQHOVHSnGHWQ\HVRPYRNVHUIUDP'H VLVWHnUHQHKDULPLGOHUWLGRJVnEHJUHSHUVRPHQ¶NRPSHWDQVHEDVHUW¡NRQRPL·RJ HQ¶O UHQGH¡NRQRPL·YXQQHWWLOVOXWQLQJVRPJRGHEHJUHSHUIRUnEHWHJQHGHQ Q\H¡NRQRPLHQ'HWDYVSHLOHUDWNRPSHWDQVHDQVHVVRPGHQYLNWLJVWHUHVVXUVHQ RJO ULQJVRPGHQYLNWLJVWHSURVHVVHQL¶GDJHQVQ ULQJVOLY·
2YHUJDQJHQHIUDIRUGLVPHWLOSRVWIRUGLVPHHOOHUKYDHQYHOJHUnNDOOHGHWQ\H WLOVNULYHVJMHUQHHQGULQJHULPDUNHGVIRUKROGRJLWHNQRORJL)RUGHWI¡UVWHHUGHW UHODWLYWPLQGUHHWWHUVS¡UVHOHWWHUVWDQGDUGYDUHURJ¡NWHWWHUVS¡UVHOHWWHUQLVMH SURGXNWHU²RJRIWHYDUHUPHGK¡\NYDOLWHWVRPSURGXVHUHVLPLQGUHVHULHU(QG ULQJHQHJMHOGHURJVnWMHQHVWHURJLNNHNXQLQGXVWULSURGXNWHU)RUHNVHPSHOHU GHWUHODWLYWPLQNHQGHHWWHUVS¡UVHOHWWHURJnUHQHVIRUPHUIRUPDVVHWX ULVPHPHQKHOOHU¡NWHWWHUVS¡UVHOHWWHUPHUVSHVLDOV\GGHWXULVWWLOEXG(QVOLN PHUGLIIHUHQVLHUWHWWHUVS¡UVHOYDUGHWYDQVNHOLJIRUGHJDPOHVWRUIRUHWDNHQHn WDNOHPHGVLQ¶IRUGLVWLVNH·PnWHnJM¡UHWLQJSn'HWKDUJLWWPXOLJKHWHUIRUPLQ GUHEHGULIWHU²RJJMHUQHPLQGUHEHGULIWHUVRPLQQJnULXOLNHW\SHUDYQHWWYHUNV VDPDUEHLGPHGDQGUHEHGULIWHU²RJGHWKDUJLWWRSSKDYWLOHQGULQJHULPnWHUn IUDPVWLOOHSURGXNWHURJWMHQHVWHUSnRJLPnWHUnRUJDQLVHUHYLUNVRPKHWSn
'HQDQGUHYLNWLJHHQGULQJHQEDNRYHUJDQJHQIUDIRUGLVPHWLOSRVWIRUGLVPHHU VnOHGHVWHNQRORJLVNHHQGULQJHU,NMHUQHQDYGHWWHOLJJHUQ\GDWDLQIRUPDVMRQV RJNRPPXQLNDVMRQVWHNQRORJLVRPHUHQJHQHULVNWHNQRORJLGHWYLOVLHQWHNQR ORJLVRPInUEHW\GQLQJIRUGHIOHVWHGHOHQHDYQ ULQJVRJVDPIXQQVOLYHW,7 WHNQRORJLHQHUHQYLNWLJEDNJUXQQIRUJOREDOLVHULQJHQLGHWGHQJM¡UGHWODQJW OHWWHUHnVW\UHRJOHGHEHGULIWHURJQHWWYHUNVRPVWUHNNHUVHJRYHUKHOHYHUGHQ 'HUQHVWJLUWHNQRORJLHQJUXQQODJIRUHQKHOUHNNHQ\HSURGXNWHURJWMHQHVWHURJ EHW\GHOLJYHNVWLQ\HQ ULQJVVHNWRUHUVRPRIWHEHWHJQHVIRUK¡\WHNQRORJLVNH )RUGHWWUHGMHNDQWHNQRORJLHQEHQ\WWHVIRUnHIIHNWLYLVHUHRJ¡NHNRQNXUUDQVH VW\UNHQLGHIOHVWHQ ULQJHQH'DWDVW\UWHPDVNLQHUKDUIRUHNVHPSHOJMRUWGHW PXOLJIRUEHGULIWHUnEOLPHUIOHNVLEOHRJGHUPHGEHGUHLVWDQGWLOnWLOIUHGVVWLOOH HWWHUVS¡UVHOHQHWWHUPHUGLIIHUHQVLHUWHYDUHURJWMHQHVWHU0HGGDWDVW\UWHPD VNLQHUNDQIRUHNVHPSHOEHGULIWHUVWLOOHUDVNHUHRPIUDSURGXNVMRQDYHQPRGHOO WLOHQQ\
+YDHUVnXWIRUGULQJHQHIRUQ ULQJVOLYHWL$XVW$JGHURJIRUQ ULQJVSROLWLNNHQL I\ONHWLIRUKROGWLOGHQQHIUDPYHNVWHQDYHQ¶Q\¡NRQRPL·"8WIRUGULQJHQHHULNNH OLNHRSSODJWHVRPQnUGHWJMHOGHUWHQGHQVHQHWLOJOREDOLVHULQJ'HWHULPLGOHUWLG nSHQEDUWDWXWYLNOLQJHQVWLOOHUNUDYRP¡NWNRPSHWDQVHLQQHQGDWDRJ,7 WHNQRORJL²RJLNNHNXQLGDWDRJ,7EHGULIWHQH9LNWLJHUHIRUGHIOHVWHJHRJUD ILVNHRPUnGHUHUDWGHQQHQ\HWHNQRORJLHQWDVLEUXNIRUn¡NHNRQNXUUDQVHHY QHQLDQGUHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHW
'HUQHVWKDUGHQ¶Q\H¡NRQRPLHQ·¡NWEHW\GQLQJHQDYK\SSLJHPLQGUHLQQRYDVMR QHUIRUEHGULIWHUVNRQNXUUDQVHHYQH,IRUGLVPHQVNMHGGHLQQRYDVMRQHULVWRUJUDG LQWHUQWLVWRUHIRUHWDNRJVRPNRPPHUVLDOLVHULQJDYIRUVNQLQJVUHVXOWDWHUIUD IRUHWDNHQHVHJQH)R8DYGHOLQJHURJIUDIRUVNQLQJVLQVWLWXWWHU'HWWHHUIRUWVDWW HQULNWLJEHVNULYHOVHDYLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWLHQNHOWHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHW'HQ
¶Q\H¡NRQRPLHQ·HULPLGOHUWLGNMHQQHWHJQHWDYPHUNXQGHWLOSDVQLQJDYSURGXN VMRQHQPLQGUHSURGXNVMRQVVHULHURJK\SSLJHUHHQGULQJHUDYPRGHOOHU'HWVWLOOHU NUDYWLODWEHGULIWHUVWDGLJHQGUHUSURGXNWHURJPnWHUnSURGXVHUHSn²RJVRPYL VNDOVHVWLOOHUGHWWHNUDYRPVW¡UUHJUDGDYVDPDUEHLGIRUnKHQWHLQQVSHVLDOL VHUWNRPSHWDQVHIUDPDQJHDNW¡UHU'HWWHNUDYHWRPK\SSLJHLQQRYDVMRQHUHU RJVnHQEDNJUXQQIRUIRUHVWLOOLQJHQRPDWEHGULIWHUPnXWYLNOHVWLO¶O UHQGHRU JDQLVDVMRQHU·EHGULIWHUPnKHQWHLQQNRPSHWDQVHXWHQIUDRJE\JJHRSSNRPSH WDQVHLQWHUQWIRUVWDGLJnNXQQHRSSJUDGHUHSURGXNWHURJSURVHVVHU
2SSVXPPHULQJRPXWIRUGULQJHU
1 ULQJVOLYHWRJQ ULQJVSROLWLNNHQL$XVW$JGHUVWLOOHVRYHUIRUHQGHOYLNWLJHXW IRUGULQJHUVRPI¡OJHDYHQNHOWHVWRUHWUHQGHULQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQLYHUGHQ9L RSSVXPPHUHUGLVVHXWIRUGULQJHQH²RJPXOLJKHWHQH²LWUHKRYHGSXQNWHU
• cPRWYLUNHIDUHQIRUWDSDYYLNWLJHEHGULIWHURJDUEHLGVSODVVHUVRP¡NWJORED OLVHULQJNDQPHGI¡UHHYHQWXHOWnV¡NHnXWQ\WWHJOREDOLVHULQJHQWLOnKHQWH Q\HDUEHLGVSODVVHUXWHQIUD
• cXWQ\WWHYHNVWSRWHQVLDOHWVRPOLJJHUL¡NWEHW\GQLQJDYGDWDLQIRUPDVMRQV RJNRPPXQLNDVMRQVWHNQRORJLLDOOHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHWVSHVLHOWJMHQQRPn VNDIIHWLOYHLHGHQQ¡GYHQGLJHNRPSHWDQVHQ
• cRSSQnHWQ ULQJVOLYVRPHULQQRYDWLYWQRNWLOnNXQQHNRQNXUUHUHLGHQ
¶Q\HO UHQGH¡NRQRPLHQ·
6YDU8WQ\WWJOREDOLVHULQJHQWLOnVNDIIHDUEHLGVSODVVHU XWHQIUD
+YDHUVYDUHWSnGHQW\SHQXWIRUGULQJHUVRPHUQHYQWRYHQIRU"*URYWVDJWILQQHV GHWWRKRYHGPnWHUnGULYHWLOWDNVDUEHLGSnVRPRJVnHUUHOHYDQWHIRUnP¡WHGH RPWDOWHXWIRUGULQJHQH3n¶IRUVNHUVSUnNHW·EHQHYQHVGLVVHIRUKHQKROGVYLV¶WRS GRZQ·RJERWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLHU)RUVNMHOOHQHUHQRPHQVDWVHUSnnVNDIIHWLOYHLH EHGULIWHURJDUEHLGVSODVVHUXWHQIUD¶WRSGRZQ·HOOHURPHQE\JJHUYLGHUHSn HNVLVWHUHQGHEHGULIWHUQ ULQJVPLOM¡HURJUHVVXUVHULUHJLRQHQ¶ERWWRPXS·
¶7RSGRZQ·HUGHQWUDGLVMRQHOOHVWUDWHJLHQLQRUVNGLVWULNWVSROLWLNNRJWLOWDNVDU EHLG)UDPWLORPNULQJYDUKRYHGVWUDWHJLHQnRYHUI¡UHDUEHLGVSODVVHURJ LQYHVWHULQJHUIUDGHVHQWUDOHGHOHQHDYODQGHWRIWH2VORRJQ UPHVWHRPHJQWLO GLVWULNWHQHVRPLGHQQHVDPPHQKHQJHQRPIDWWHWKHOH$XVW$JGHU9HNVWRJXW YLNOLQJLGLVWULNWHQHVNXOOHNRPPHXWHQIUD5ROOHQWLOORNDOHP\QGLJKHWHULHQ VOLNVWUDWHJLKDUY UWnOHJJHIRUKROGHQHWLOUHWWHJMHQQRPXWE\JJLQJDYLQIUD VWUXNWXURJQ ULQJVDUHDOHUVOLNDWRPUnGHQHEOLUPHUDWWUDNWLYHIRUSULYDWHEH GULIWHUHOOHURIIHQWOLJHLQVWLWXVMRQHUVRPKDUEHKRYIRUnIO\WWHXWDY¶SUHVVRPUn GHQH·'HUQHVWPnI\ONHWHOOHUNRPPXQHQPDUNHGVI¡UHVLQHIRUWUHIIHOLJKHWHURJ InNRQWDNWPHGIRUHWDNVRPYXUGHUHnIO\WWHDNWLYLWHWHUHOOHUE\JJHQ\HEHGULIWHU 'LVWULNWHQHVIRUGHOHULGHQQHNDPSHQRP¶IO\WWEDUH·LQYHVWHULQJHUKDUV UOLJ Y UWDUEHLGVNUDIWRJODYHUHNRVWQDGHU'LVWULNWHQHKDUWUDGLVMRQHOWKDWWEHGUH WLOJDQJSnV UOLJXIDJO UWDUEHLGVNUDIW²RJGHKDULNNHPLQVWKDWWPHUVWDELO DUEHLGVNUDIWHQQLVHQWUDOHRPUnGHUSnJUXQQDYI UUHYDOJPXOLJKHWHUSnGHW ORNDOHDUEHLGVPDUNHGHW.RVWQDGHQHWLODUHDOHURJORNDOHUHUODYHUHRJGLVWULNW SROLWLVNHYLUNHPLGOHUKDU\WWHUOLJHUHVHQNHWNRVWQDGHQHLGHOHUDYGLVWULNWHQH 'HVHQHUHnUHQHHURJVnHWJRGWERPLOM¡WUHNWLQQVRPHWVSHVLHOWIRUWULQQIRUGLV WULNWHQH7DQNHQHUDWGLVWULNWHUNDQORNNHPHGPXOLJKHWHQHIRUnOHYHGHWJRGH OLYVOLNDWIRUHNVHPSHOHWDEOHUHUHWDUPHGVHJHQHJHQEHGULIWSnIO\WHODVVHWQnU GHIO\WWHUIRUnERVHWWHVHJLHWGLVWULNWVRPUnGH
¶7RSGRZQ·VWUDWHJLHQILNNPLQGUHUHOHYDQVXWRYHUSnWDOOHW9HNVWHQLDQ WDOOLQGXVWULDUEHLGVSODVVHUL1RUJHVWRSSHWQHPOLJRSSPLGWSnWDOOHWRJ GHUPHGEOHGHWI UUH¶IO\WWHNODUH·DUEHLGVSODVVHURJEHGULIWHUIRUGLVWULNWVNRP PXQHQHnNRQNXUUHUHRPnWUHNNHWLOVHJ1nUHQNRPLQQSnWDOOHWEOHRJ VnDUEHLGVOHGLJKHWHWVWRUE\SUREOHPOLNHP\HVRPHWGLVWULNWVSUREOHPVOLNDW VWRUE\HQHLVW¡UUHJUDGNMHPSHWRPnEHKROGH¶VLQH·EHGULIWHURJDUEHLGVSODVVHU IRUVHJVHOY'HWJDYRJVnPLQGUHPXOLJKHWHUIRUnO\NNHVPHGGHQQHVWUDWHJLHQ 6S¡UVPnOHWHUQnRPWHQGHQVHQHWLOJOREDOLVHULQJNDQUHYLWDOLVHUH¶WRSGRZQ·
VWUDWHJLHQ"*OREDOLVHULQJHQVDPPHQPHG,7WHNQRORJLRJEHGUHNRPPXQLNDVMR QHUKDUWUROLJJMRUWIOHUHEHGULIWHUWLO¶IO\WWHREMHNWHU·6WRUHNRQVHUQNDQIO\WWH EHGULIWHUWLOVWHGHUGHUGHILQQHUJRGHSURGXNVMRQVEHWLQJHOVHUHOOHUGHNDQE\JJH RSSEHGULIWHUSnQ\HVWHGHUIUDEXQQHQDY(QNDQGHUIRUWHQNHVHJDW$XVW
$JGHUQnNXQQHVDWVHVWHUNWSnnWUHNNHWLOVHJEHGULIWHUVRPWLOK¡UHUVW¡UUH NRQVHUQ²RJRJVnDQGUHW\SHUEHGULIWHU²DOWVnDWJOREDOVHULQJHQLNNHEDUHEOLU HQIU\NWIRUnPLVWHEHGULIWHUWLODQGUHVWHGHU
(QVOLNVWUDWHJLNDQWUROLJLNNHJMHQQRPI¡UHVSnVDPPHPnWHVRPGHQJDPOH
¶WRSGRZQ·VWUDWHJLHQ'HJDPOHORNNHPLGOHQHWLOGLVWULNWHQHHUQHPOLJLNNHOLNH DNWXHOOHVRPI¡U/DYHNRVWQDGHURJGLVWULNWVSROLWLVNHYLUNHPLGOHUHUVHOYI¡OJHOLJ IRUWVDWWYLNWLJ,GHQ¶Q\HO UHQGH¡NRQRPLHQ·YLOLPLGOHUWLGNRPSHWDQVHV UOLJ NRPSHWDQVHVRPHUUHOHYDQWIRULQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWY UHHQYLNWLJSURGXNVMRQV IDNWRU.RQVHUQHQHVHUGHUIRUHWWHUKYRUGDQGHWLQGXVWULHOOHPLOM¡HWHUSnHWVWHG GHUGHYXUGHUHUnORNDOLVHUHVHJ+DURPUnGHWNRPSHWHQWDUEHLGVNUDIWLQQHQUH OHYDQWHIDJRPUnGHUILQQHVGHWHWRSSGDWHUWVNROHWLOEXGHUGHWPXOLJKHWHUIRUn ILQQHIOLQNHOHYHUDQG¡UHURJDQGUHVDPDUEHLGVSDUWQHUH"
1nUVOLNHIRUKROGEOLUYLNWLJHnInRUGHQSnRPHQ¡QVNHUnNDVWHVHJLQQLNDPS HQRPGH¶IO\WWEDUH·EHGULIWHQHEOLUGHWPLQGUHIRUVNMHOOPHOORP¶WRSGRZQ·RJ
¶ERWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLHU'HYLNWLJVWHORNNHPLGOHQHIRUnInQ\HEHGULIWHUWLOHWRP UnGHHUDWGHWDOOHUHGHILQQHVHWRSSHJnHQGHQ ULQJVOLYGHU'HUPHGNDQHQ¶WRS GRZQ·VWUDWHJLRJVnEHQ\WWHVPHUVWUDWHJLVN'HWYLOVLDWHQNDQSU¡YHnInWDNL Q\HEHGULIWHULQQHQIRUHWIHOWGHUHWRPUnGHDOOHUHGHKDUHWPLOM¡'HWNDQY UH EHGULIWHUVRPNDQVW\UNHGHWEHVWnHQGHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HWIRUHNVHPSHOEHGULIWHU VRPNDQY UHOHYHUDQG¡UHUHOOHUNXQGHUIRUHNVLVWHUHQGHORNDOHEHGULIWHUHOOHU EHGULIWHUVRPNDQELGUDWLOnE\JJHRSSNRPSHWDQVHDQGUHEHGULIWHUKDUQ\WWHDY
6YDU%\JJVWHUNHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU
'HQDQGUHKRYHGVWUDWHJLHQLGLVWULNWVSROLWLNNHQRJWLOWDNVDUEHLGHWEHQHYQHVIRU
¶ERWWRPXS·*MHQQRPGHQQHVWUDWHJLHQVNDOGHWIUDPVNDIIHVKHOWQ\HDUEHLGV SODVVHULVWHGHWIRUNXQnRPIRUGHOHHNVLVWHUHQGHDUEHLGVSODVVHUIUDDQGUHRPUn GHU¶%RWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLHQHKDUWUDGLVMRQHOWY UWDYWRW\SHU'HQHQHHUnIn IUDPKHOWQ\HORNDOHEHGULIWHU'HWVNMHUIRUHNVHPSHOJMHQQRPXOLNHIRUPHUIRU PRELOLVHULQJDYIRONWLOLGHVNDSLQJRJRSSVWDUWLQJDYQ\HEHGULIWHUHOOHUJMHQQRP HWDEOHUHUVHQWUHRJVW¡WWHWLOQ\HWDEOHUH
(QDQQHQIRUPIRU¶ERWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLRPIDWWHUnYLGHUHXWYLNOHHNVLVWHUHQGHEH GULIWHURJQ ULQJVPLOM¡HULHWRPUnGHKHOOHUHQQnVW¡WWHHWDEOHULQJDYQ\HEH GULIWHU+YDVRPHUUHOHYDQWHYLUNHPLGOHUYDULHUHUDOWHWWHUKYLONHSUREOHPHURJ IODVNHKDOVHUPLOM¡HQHVWnURYHUIRU9LUNHPLGOHQHKDULPLGOHUWLGRIWHRPIDWWHW E\JJLQJDYQHWWYHUNEnGHPHOORPEHGULIWHURJPHOORPEHGULIWHURJORNDOHRUJD QLVDVMRQHUVRPVNROHUUnGJLYQLQJVRJIRUVNQLQJVLQVWLWXVMRQHUWHNQRORJLVHQWUH VDPWRIIHQWOLJHP\QGLJKHWHU
%HW\GQLQJHQDYGHQQHIRUPHQIRU¶ERWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLEHJUXQQHVEODQWDQQHW PHGHWVHQWUDOWUHVXOWDWIUDIRUVNQLQJHQRPVPnEHGULIWHU'HWIUDPKHYHVQHP OLJDWVPnEHGULIWHQHVSUREOHPLNNHHUVW¡UUHOVHQ²GHWDWGHHUVPn²PHQDWGH HULVROHUWHGHWYLOVLDWGHPDQJOHUVDPDUEHLGVSDUWQHUHRJHWVW¡WWHV\VWHPUXQGW VHJ*MHQQRP¶ERWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLVNDOHQSU¡YHnVWLPXOHUHWLOEHGUHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUGHWYLOVLDWQ ULQJVOLYHWLHWRPUnGHWEOLUPHUHQQNXQHWYLVVWDQ WDOOEHGULIWHU'HWVNDOY UHEHGULIWHUVRPVDPDUEHLGHUVRPIRUHNVHPSHOHUXQ GHUOHYHUDQG¡UHUIRUKYHUDQGUHRJEHGULIWHQHVNDONXQQHKHQWHNRPSHWDQVHKRV DQGUHDNW¡UHULORNDOVDPIXQQHW
¶%RWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLHQEHJUXQQHVRJVnPHGKHQYLVQLQJWLOXWYLNOLQJHQLVnNDOWH G\QDPLVNHVPnEHGULIWVUHJLRQHUGHUGHPHVWNMHQWHHNVHPSOHQHKHQWHVIUD
1RUG,WDOLD+HUILQQHVRPUnGHUVnNDOWHLQGXVWULHOOHGLVWULNWHUVRPGRPLQHUHV DYPLQGUHEHGULIWHUVRPLQQJnULPDQJHW\SHUIRUPHOOHRJXIRUPHOOHORNDOHQHWW YHUN'HRPWDOWHGLVNWULNWHQHKDGGHHQJXQVWLJXWYLNOLQJSnRJWDOOHW PHQVVWRULQGXVWULHQHOOHUVL,WDOLDVWDJQHUWH(WYLNWLJSRHQJHUDWGHWOLJJHUHQ EHYLVVWORNDOSROLWLNNEDNPDQJHDYGLVVHVXNVHVVKLVWRULHQHRJGHWHUVQDNNRP SROLWLNNVRPJMHUQHKDUYRNVWIUDPJMHQQRPPDQJHnUVSU¡YLQJRJIHLOLQJ3ROL WLNNHQJnUV UOLJXWSnnHWDEOHUHXOLNHW\SHUWHNQRORJLVHQWUHVRPHUVSHVLDOLVHU WHLQQHQEHVWHPWHEUDQVMHU9HGVHQWUHQHNDQVPnEHGULIWHUInLQIRUPDVMRQRP WHNQRORJLXWYLNOLQJRJPDUNHGVXWYLNOLQJLVLQEUDQVMHGHInUKMHOSWLOnLQQI¡UHQ\
WHNQRORJLGHNDQVHWWHVLNRQWDNWPHGHNVSHUWHUDQGUHVWHGHUGHInUNRQWDNW PHGDQGUHORNDOHEHGULIWHURJVnYLGHUH
'HWRKRYHGIRUPHQHIRU¶ERWWRPXS·VWUDWHJLHUVNDSLQJDYQ\HORNDOHEHGULIWHU YHUVXVXWYLNOLQJDYHNVLVWHUHQGHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUHUJMHQVLGLJIRUVWHUNHQGH)RU GHWI¡UVWHYLOJRGHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUWUROLJ¡NHHWDEOHULQJVIUHNYHQVHQ0DQ JHVWXGLHUWLOOHJJHU¶DYOHJJHUPHNDQLVPHQ·VWRUEHW\GQLQJYHGQ\HWDEOHULQJHURJ YHGRSSE\JJLQJDYORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU(WDEOHUHUHVWDUWHUVRPUHJHOHJHQEH GULIWLQQHQIRUHQEUDQVMHGHUGHKDUXWGDQQLQJRJHUIDULQJRJGHVWDUWHUVRPUH JHORSSGHUGHERURJDUEHLGHUXWHQnYXUGHUHDOWHUQDWLYHORNDOLVHULQJVPXOLJKH WHU,HWHNVLVWHUHQGHQ ULQJVPLOM¡NDQGHWY UHHQNOHUHnInWLOHQYHOO\NNHW HWDEOHULQJHQQIRUWLOVYDUHQGHSHUVRQHUVRPVWDUWHURSSXWHQHWVOLNWPLOM¡,HW PLOM¡YLOHQOHWWHUHILQQHEHGULIWHURJSHUVRQHUPHGUHOHYDQWNXQQVNDSVRPNDQ JLVW¡WWHYHGHWDEOHULQJHU3nGHQDQGUHVLGHQNDQQ\HEHGULIWHUNRPPHLQQPHG Q\HSURGXNWHURJO¡VQLQJHU²RJGHUPHGELGUDWLOXWYLNOLQJDYHNVLVWHUHQGHPLO M¡HU
(WIHOOHVVYDU6WLPXOHULQQRYDWLYHPLOM¡HU
'HXOLNHVYDUHQHVRPHUJLWWSnGHJHQHUHOOHXWIRUGULQJHQHIRUQ ULQJVOLYHWL
$XVW$JGHUSHNHULVDPPHUHWQLQJHQPnV¡NHnYLGHUHXWYLNOHORNDOHQ ULQJV PLOM¡HU6WHUNHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUHUHQPRWYHNWPRWJOREDOLVHULQJHQ'HWHU HWLQVWUXPHQWIRUnInWLOEHGUHORNDOIRUDQNULQJDYEHGULIWHUHLGDYWUDQVQDVMR QDOHVHOVNDSHUGHWYLOVLDWEHGULIWHUNDQDQVH¶JRGH·Q ULQJVPLOM¡HUVRPIRUQXI WLJHVWHGHUnY UHORNDOLVHUW+HUILQQHVIRUHNVHPSHOIOHUHPXOLJHVDPDUEHLGV SDUWQHUHRJOHYHUDQG¡UHUHWRSSJnHQGHIRUVNQLQJVRJVNROHPLOM¡NRPSHWHQWDU EHLGVNUDIWRJGHWHUXWYLNOHWVSHVLDOLVHUWNRPSHWDQVH6WHUNHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUNDQ YLGHUHY UHHWYLNWLJORNNHPLGGHORPHQSU¡YHUnNRQNXUUHUHRPnInWDNLQ\H EHGULIWHUXWHQIUD
0HQKYDPHQHVVnPHGVWHUNHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU"9LKDUWLGOLJHUHSnSHNWDW Q ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQLGDJNMHQQHWHJQHVDYDWNRPSHWDQVHRJO ULQJHUEOLWWYLN WLJHUHSURGXNVMRQVIDNWRUHURJDWEHGULIWHULPDQJHEUDQVMHUL¡NHQGHJUDGNRQ NXUUHUHUJMHQQRPLQQRYDVMRQHU6WHUNHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HULQQHKDUGHUPHG VSHVLDOLVHUWNRPSHWDQVHRJPLOM¡HQHVWLPXOHUHULQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWLEHGULIWHU 9LVNDOQnIRUNODUHQ UPHUHKYDVRPVNDOIRUVWnVPHGHWEHJUHSVRP¶LQQRYDWLYH Q ULQJVPLOM¡HU·RJKYLONHQUHOHYDQVHWVOLNWEHJUHSKDUIRUXWIRUPLQJDYORNDOW WLOWDNVDUEHLG'HWWHNUHYHULPLGOHUWLGDWYLI¡UVWGHILQHUHUKYDHQLQQRYDVMRQHU RJIRUNODUHUKYRUGDQLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWIRUHJnU
,QQRYDVMRQHUVRPHQGULYNUDIWLQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ
,QQRYDVMRQVNMHUQnUEHGULIWHUVHWWHUXWLOLYHWSURGXNWHUSURGXNVMRQVPnWHURJ PnWHUnRUJDQLVHUHYLUNVRPKHWHQSnVRPHUQ\HIRUGHPPHQQ¡GYHQGLJYLVLNNH IRUDOOHDQGUHEHGULIWHU1 UPHUHEHVWHPWRPIDWWHULQQRYDVMRQHU
• )RUQ\HOVHRJXWYLGHOVHDYSURGXNWRJWMHQHVWHVSHNWHUHW
• HWDEOHULQJDYQ\HPHWRGHUIRUSURGXNVMRQOHYHUDQVHUPDUNHGVI¡ULQJRJGLV WULEXVMRQ
• LQWURGXNVMRQDYHQGULQJHULOHGHOVHRUJDQLVDVMRQDUEHLGVIRUKROGRJNRPSH WDQVHLDUEHLGVVWRNNHQ
,QQRYDVMRQHUHUVnOHGHVHWVY UWYLGWEHJUHSVRPKDUnJM¡UHPHGHQGULQJRJ Q\XWYLNOLQJLEHGULIWHU,QQRYDVMRQHUKDUEnGHHQ¶KDUG·VLGHVRPHWQ\WWSUR GXNWRJGHWKDUHQ¶P\N·VLGHVRPI¡UVWRJIUHPVWHUQ\NRPSHWDQVHRJQ\HPn WHUnJM¡UHWLQJSn
,GHIOHVWHGHOHQHDYQ ULQJVOLYHWHULQQRYDVMRQHUKHOWVHQWUDOWIRUDWEHGULIWHU VNDONXQQHRSSUHWWKROGHVLQNRQNXUUDQVHVW\UNHSnODQJVLNW%HGULIWHUNDQLNNH KYLOHIRUOHQJHSnODXUE UHQH'HWJMHOGHULNNHPLQVWLHWK¡\NRVWODQGVRP1RU JH1RUVNHEHGULIWHUNDQVMHOGHQNRQNXUUHUHNXQSnSULV(QUHQSULVNRQNXUUDQ VHYLORJVnLGHWODQJHO¡SOHJJHSUHVVSnO¡QQVQLYnHWRJLVLVWHLQVWDQVSnYHO IHUGVVDPIXQQHW1RUVNHEHGULIWHUPnLVWRUJUDGKHQWHNRQNXUUDQVHHYQHQJMHQ QRPnY UHLQQRYDWLYHJMHQQRPnKDEHGUHSURGXNWHURJ¶VPDUWHUH·SURGXNVMRQ RJRUJDQLVDVMRQHQQNRQNXUUHQWHU
,QQRYDVMRQHUHULGHWKHOHWDWWVY UWVHQWUDOWLGHEDWWHQRPQDVMRQHUVRJUHJLR QHUVNRQNXUUDQVHHYQH9LWDOLWHWHQLLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVHQDQVHVVRPDYJM¡UHQGH IRUUHJLRQHUVNRQNXUUDQVHVW\UNHRJIUDPWLGLJHYHOVWDQG'HUPHGHUGHWKHOWYH VHQWOLJLHQVWUDWHJLVNQ ULQJVSODQnUHWWHVWRURSSPHUNVRPKHWPRWYLUNHPLGOHU VRPVWLPXOHUHULQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWRJVRP¡NHUHYQHQWLOLQQRYDVMRQHULEHGULI WHU6HOYRPPDQJHDQGUHIRUKROGVHOYI¡OJHOLJRJVnHUYLNWLJHIRUQ ULQJVXWYLN OLQJHQLHWRPUnGHVHWWHUHQPHGHWVOLNWIRNXVILQJHUHQSnNDQVNMHGHQDOOHU YLNWLJVWHIDNWRUHQIRUnRSSQnSRVLWLYQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJLHWRPUnGH²HQNRPPHU YLUNHOLJLLQQJUHSPHGJUXQQOHJJHQGHSURVHVVHULQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQ
'HQ¡NWHLQWHUHVVHQIRULQQRYDVMRQHUEODQWSROLWLNNXWIRUPHUHRJIRUVNHUHKDU OHGHWWLOGHWQRHQEHWHJQHUIRU¶K¡\WHNQRORJLVNVQREEHUL·QHPOLJV\QVSXQNWHWRP DWGHQ¡NRQRPLVNHXWYLNOLQJHQLHWRPUnGHDYKHQJHUDYHYQHQWLOnVNDSHQ\H K¡\WHNQRORJLVNHYLUNVRPKHWHUV UOLJGDWD,7RJHOHNWURQLNNEHGULIWHUVDPW ELRNMHPLVNHEHGULIWHU'HWWHHUpQYLNWLJGHODYELOGHW'HWHULPLGOHUWLGKHOWVHQ WUDOWnXQGHUVWUHNHDWLQQRYDVMRQHURJVnGUHLHUVHJRPDQQHWHQQK¡\WHNQRORJL /LNHYLNWLJ²HOOHUYLNWLJHUHIRUGHIOHVWHRPUnGHU²HUDWQ\WHNQRORJLWDVLEUXNL VHNWRUHUGHUHWRPUnGHKLVWRULVNVHWWKDUWUDGLVMRQHURJNRQNXUUDQVHIRUGHOHU 'HWEHW\UDOWVnnYLGHUHXWYLNOHGHWHNVLVWHUHQGHQ ULQJVOLYHWJMHQQRPWHNQROR JLVNRJNRPSHWDQVHPHVVLJRSSJUDGHULQJRJLNNHNXQSU¡YHnVNDSHIOHUHK¡\
WHNQRORJLVNHYLUNVRPKHWHU
,QQRYDVMRQHUHUVDPDUEHLGRJJMHQVLGLJO ULQJ
+YRUGDQIRUHJnUVnLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVHULQ ULQJVOLYHW"2JKYRUGDQNDQHQ JMHQQRPYLUNHPLGOHUVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW"
(WVHQWUDOWSRHQJHUDWIUDPEULQJHOVHDYLQQRYDVMRQHUVRPRIWHVWIRUHJnUJMHQ QRPVDPDUEHLGPHOORPPDQJHXOLNHDNW¡UHU%HGULIWHULQQRYHUHUQHVWHQDOGULSn HJHQKnQGGHInULQIRUPDVMRQRJKHQWHUNXQQVNDSIUDPDQJHNLOGHU3URWRW\SHQ SnHQLQQRYDW¡UHUGHUIRULNNHGHQHQVOLJH¶3HWWHU6PDUWW\SHQ·PHGHQJRGSUR GXNWLGpVHOYRPGHWWHRJVnHUHQGHODYELOGHW
,QQRYDVMRQHUVNMHUJMHUQHLHNVLVWHUHQGHYLUNVRPKHWHUVRPKDUNRQWDNWPHGHW PDUNHGRJVRPHQGUHUSURGXNWHUWMHQHVWHUHOOHUSURGXNVMRQVPnWHUXWIUDVLJ QDOHULPDUNHGHW,HQVOLNLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVYLOEHGULIWHQRIWHKHQYHQGHVHJWLO VLQHOHYHUDQG¡UHUVRPRJVnPnHQGUHVLQHSURGXNWHURJWMHQHVWHUIRUnKROGH WULWWPHGNXQGHQVQ\YLQQLQJHURJGHUPHGVNMHUGHWHQVSUHGQLQJDYWHNQRORJL RJNRPSHWDQVH9LGHUHPnEHGULIWHQNDQVNMHNRQWDNWHHWIRUVNQLQJVLQVWLWXWWHQ K¡\VNROHHOOHUOLNQHQGHIRUnInO¡VWSUREOHPHUXQGHUYHLVLLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVHQ 'HNDQKDNRQWDNWPHGHQ\UNHVVNROHPHG$UEHLGVIRUPLGOLQJHQHOOHUOLNQHQGH IRUnO¡VHHWEHKRYIRURSSO ULQJRJUHNUXWWHULQJVRPLQQRYDVMRQHQNDQNUHYH 'HKDUNRQWDNWPHGRIIHQWOLJHP\QGLJKHWHURJEDQNHUIRUnILQDQVLHUHLQQRYD VMRQVDNWLYLWHWHQRJVnYLGHUH
,QQRYDVMRQRPIDWWHUDOWVnPDQJHDNW¡UHUVRPPnVSLOOHSnODJRJGHWNUHYHVHQ SROLWLNNIRUnInODJVSLOOHWWLOnIXQJHUHEHVWPXOLJ%HJUHSHWLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHP EHQ\WWHVJMHUQHIRUnEHWHJQHGHDNW¡UHQHVRPEHVWHPPHUGHQLQQRYDWLYH\WHHY QHQWLOEHGULIWHU6\VWHPHWNDQLOOXVWUHUHVVRPLILJXUQHGHQIRU6\VWHPHWWUHQ JHULNNHY UHRJYLOVRPUHJHOLNNHY UHEHYLVVWGHVLJQHWIRUn¡NHLQQRYDVMRQV HYQHQPHQGHWRPIDWWHUDOWVnGHDNW¡UHQHVRPKDUVW¡UVWEHW\GQLQJIRUnVWL PXOHUHLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVHU)LJXUHQInUIUDPDWLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWHUHQNRO OHNWLYSURVHVVVRPLQYROYHUHUPDQJHDNW¡UHU
+YHPVRPHUYLNWLJHDNW¡UHULLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHWYDULHUHUPHOORPXOLNHGHOHU DYQ ULQJVOLYHWRJPHOORPXOLNHRPUnGHU+YRUGDQLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHWVHUXWL XOLNHEUDQVMHUL$XVW$JGHURJKYDVRPHUYLNWLJHIODVNHKDOVHUHUYHVHQWOLJH VS¡UVPnOnVYDUHSnLDUEHLGHWPHG6136OLNHVS¡UVPnONRPPHUYLWLOEDNHWLOL SnI¡OJHQGHQRWDWHU)LJXUJLULPLGOHUWLGHQRYHUVLNWRYHUGHWVRPRIWHHUGHYLN WLJVWHDNW¡UHQHLLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU
)LJXU(QNHOLOOXVWUDVMRQDYHWLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHP
,VHQWUXPDYILJXUHQHOOHULQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHWILQQHVGHLQQRYDWLYHEHGULIWHQH 'HWHUEHGULIWHUVRPVDWVHUSnHQYLVVQ\XWYLNOLQJRJVRPKDUHQEHYLVVWLQQRYD VMRQVVWUDWHJL'LVVHEHGULIWHQHVDPDUEHLGHUDOWVnPHGPDQJHDNW¡UHU'HKHQWHU EODQWDQQHWP\HLQIRUPDVMRQIUDNXQGHURJOHYHUDQG¡UHU6WXGLHUYLVHUDWNXQ GHURJOHYHUDQG¡UHUMHYQWRYHUHUGHYLNWLJVWHLQIRUPDVMRQVNLOGHQHIRUEHGULIWHU YHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWPHQGHWWHYDULHUHUPHOORPEHGULIWHURJEUDQVMHU (QDQQHQYLNWLJDNW¡UHU)R8VHNWRUHQXQLYHUVLWHWHUK¡\VNROHURJDQGUH)R8 LQVWLWXVMRQHU)RUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJDQVHVLPLGOHUWLGLNNHVRPGHQSULP UH NLOGHQWLOLQQRYDVMRQHUVHOYRPGHWHUWLOIHOOHWLQRHQVY UWNXQQVNDSVLQWHQVLYH Q ULQJHUGHUNRPPHUVLDOLVHULQJDYIRUVNQLQJVUHVXOWDWHUVSLOOHUHQYLNWLJUROOH -HYQWRYHUHUGHWKHOOHUVOLNDWIRUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJNRPPHULQQVRPHQSUR EOHPVO¡VHUXQGHUYHLVLLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVHQGHWYLOVLDWEHGULIWHUKHQYHQGHU VHJWLO)R8PLOM¡HUIRUnInO¡VWEHVWHPWHSUREOHPHUHOOHUIRUHNVHPSHOInXWUHGHW DOWHUQDWLYHWHNQRORJLVNHO¡VQLQJHU
$UEHLGVNUDIWHQVNYDOLILNDVMRQHUHUYLNWLJIRULQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW'HUPHGYLORJVn LQVWLWXVMRQHUVRPJLUIDJRSSO ULQJYLGHUHJnHQGHVNROHUIDJVNROHUK¡\VNROHURJ
$UEHLGVPDUNHGVHWDWY UHYLNWLJHDNW¡UHULLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHW6RPQHYQWDQ VHVLQQRYDVMRQHUEHWUDNWHVVRPLQWHUDNWLYO ULQJJMHQQRPDWLQQRYDVMRQHUXW YLNOHVLVDPDUEHLGPHOORPEHGULIWHURJPHGDQGUHLQVWLWXVMRQHUVRPO UHUDY KYHUDQGUH0HQGHWHURJVnYLNWLJDWKHOHEHGULIWHQHUPHGLLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHV VHQVOLNDWGHWWHLNNHHUQRHVRPLQJHQL¡UHQHRJOHGHOVHQVWHOOHUPHGSn¶HQH URP·'HWVNDOVHOYI¡OJHOLJIRUVNQLQJVRJXWYLNOLQJVNRPSHWDQVHWLOnWDIUDPGH VWRUHUDGLNDOHQ\YLQQLQJHQH'HWHULPLGOHUWLGRJVnYLNWLJPHGPDQJHVPnRJ K\SSLJHHQGULQJHULSURGXNWHURJSURGXNVMRQVPnWHUIRUVWDGLJnIRUEHGUHYLUN VRPKHWHQ²RJGHWWHHUGHQYDQOLJVWHIRUPHQIRULQQRYDVMRQHU'DHUGHWJMHUQH DYJM¡UHQGHnInPHGVHJGHQHUIDULQJHQRJNRPSHWDQVHQVRPRJVnGHSn¶JXOYHW·
KDUVRPIRUHNVHPSHONDQVHEHGUHPnWHUnXWI¡UHEHVWHPWHDUEHLGVSURVHVVHU Sn
,QQRYDWLYH EHGULIWHU
.XQGHU /HYHUDQG¡UHU
)R8VHNWRUHQ .RQNXUUHQWHU 2IIHQWOLJH P\QGLJKHWHU
)LQDQVLHULQJVNLOGHU
$UEHLGVNUDIWHQV NRPSHWDQVH
/RNDOHKROGQLQJHU YDQHUHWF
2IIHQWOLJHP\QGLJKHWHUHUHQDQQHQYLNWLJDNW¡ULLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHW'HEL GUDUWLOnILQDQVLHUHP\HLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHW2IIHQWOLJHP\QGLJKHWHUXWIRUPHU GHVVXWHQORYHURJUHJOHURJXWI¡UHUHOOHUVDNWLYLWHWHUVRPIUHPPHUHOOHUKHPPHU LQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW3ULYDWHILQDQVLQVWLWXVMRQHUNDQRJVnY UHHQYLNWLJDNW¡U VSHVLHOWGHWVRPEHWHJQHVNRPSHWHQWNDSLWDOLQVWLWXVMRQHUVRPIRUVWnUVLWXDVMR QHQLGHQDNWXHOOHEUDQVMHQRJVRPRJVnNDQJnLQQPHGNRPSHWDQVHLEHGULIWHQH LIRUELQGHOVHPHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW
+ROGQLQJHURJYDQHUVDPWNXQQVNDSHUYHUYHWJMHQQRPHUIDULQJLGHWGDJOLJHDU EHLGHWNDQRJVnVSLOOHHQVWRUUROOHYHGLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW6OLNHIRUKROGYLOWLOHQ YLVVJUDGY UHKHOWORNDOH'HWHUVQDNNRPKROGQLQJHURJNRPSHWDQVHVRPILQ QHVLQRHQRPUnGHUPHQLNNHLDQGUH)RUHNVHPSHOKHYGHVGHWDWHQNHOWHRP UnGHUNMHQQHWHJQHVDYHWVnNDOWHQWUHSUHQ¡UPLOM¡GHUSHUVRQHUSnHQPnWHRSS PXQWUHVDYGRPLQHUHQGHKROGQLQJHULORNDOPLOM¡HWWLOnSU¡YHVHJPHGQRHQ\WW, DQGUHRPUnGHUNDQGHULPRWGRPLQHUHQGHKROGQLQJHUPRWYLUNHQ\VNDSLQJ
5HJLRQDOHIDNWRUHUNDQVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW
9LKDUVnODQJWLQRWDWHWDUJXPHQWHUWIRUDWGHWnVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHW RJELGUDWLO¡NWLQQRYDWLYHYQHLEHGULIWHUHUHQVHQWUDORSSJDYHLUHJLRQDOWRJOR NDOWWLOWDNVDUEHLG'HWEHJUXQQHVPHGDWLQQRYDVMRQHUHUJUXQQOHJJHQGHIRUDW EHGULIWHUVNDONXQQHRSSUHWWKROGHVLQNRQNXUUDQVHVW\UNHSnODQJVLNW²RJGHU PHGIRUDWUHJLRQHUVNDONXQQHRSSOHYHYHNVWRJXWYLNOLQJ9LGHUHKDUYLIUDP KHYHWDWEHGULIWHUVRPRIWHVWLQQRYHUHULVDPDUEHLGPHGDQGUHEHGULIWHURJLQVWL WXVMRQHU'HWnKDGHUHWWHLQVWLWXVMRQHQHLHWRPUnGHRJRSSQnQ UWVDPDUEHLG PHOORPGLVVHRPLQQRYDVMRQHUHUGHUPHGYLNWLJ'HWHURIWHVQDNNRPnELGUDWLO XWYLNOLQJDYV\VWHPHUHOOHUQHWWYHUNDYEHGULIWHURJLQVWLWXVMRQHURJLNNHpQRJ pQHQNHOWEHGULIW
,QWHUHVVHQLIRUVNQLQJRJSROLWLNNXWIRUPLQJKDULI¡UVWHRPJDPJY UWUHWWHWPRW QDVMRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHUKYRUGDQLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHQHLKYHUWHQNHOW ODQGIXQJHUHURJKYRUGDQGLVVHNDQEHGUHV'HVLVWHnUDKDUGHWLPLGOHUWLGRJVn Y UW¡NWLQWHUHVVHIRUUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU'HWRPIDWWHUGHDNW¡UHQHL HQUHJLRQVRPEHVWHPPHUEHGULIWHQHVHYQHWLOnLQQRYHUHLGHWVDPPHRPUnGHW, KYLONHQJUDGV\VWHPHUVRPGHQLILJXUNODUHUnIXQJHUHUJRGWLHQUHJLRQYLO VnOHGHVY UHPHGSnnEHVWHPPHP\HDYGHQODQJVLNWLJHQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQL UHJLRQHQ+YRUVWRUHQUHJLRQHULGHWWHWLOIHOOHWYLOYDULHUHPHOORPEUDQVMHU 6W¡UUHOVHQSnUHJLRQHQDYKHQJHUDYKYRUGHYLNWLJVWHDNW¡UHQHHUORNDOLVHUW ,QQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHQHNDQRPIDWWHGHOHUDY$XVW$JGHUKHOHI\ONHWPHQNDQ RJVnVWUHNNHVHJXWRYHUI\ONHVJUHQVHQ
5HJLRQDOHIRUKROGHUYLNWLJIRULQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWDYIOHUHJUXQQHU)RUGHWI¡UVWH YLONRUWJHRJUDILVNRJ¶NXOWXUHOO·DYVWDQGVWLPXOHUHVDPDUEHLGRJRSSE\JJLQJDY JMHQVLGLJWLOOLWPHOORPSHUVRQHUVRPHUDYJM¡UHQGHIRUnInWLOQ UWVDPDUEHLG RPLQQRYDVMRQHU.RUWDYVWDQGJM¡UGHWHQNOHUHnInWLOUDVNHRJK\SSLJHP¡WHU² RJGHW¡NHUPXOLJKHWHQIRUDWSHUVRQHUKDUVDPPHNXOWXUHOOHEDNJUXQQRJVDP PHIRUVWnHOVHDYIRUHNVHPSHOPXQWOLJHDYWDOHU
'HUQHVWYLOQRHQIRUPHUIRUNXQQVNDSKDHQVWHUNORNDOIRUDQNULQJ0\HNXQQ VNDSEHWHJQHVVRP¶WDXV·'HWHUNXQQVNDSVRPIRUHNVHPSHOHURSSDUEHLGHW
JMHQQRPODQJHUIDULQJPHGHQEHVWHPWW\SHQ ULQJVDNWLYLWHWLHWRPUnGH.XQQ VNDSHQHUWDXVIRUGLGHQLQQHKDVDYSHUVRQHURJOHYHUHVYLGHUHIUDSHUVRQWLO SHUVRQLGHWGDJOLJHDUEHLGHW'HWHUNXQQVNDSVRPLNNHIXOOWRJKHOWNDQGRNX PHQWHUHVLPDQXDOHURJO UHE¡NHUGHQHUEXQGHWWLOYDQHUQRUPHURJKROGQLQ JHUSnDUEHLGVSODVVHURJDOWVnWLOXIRUPHOONXQQVNDSVRPDUEHLGVWDNHUHKDURSS DUEHLGHW6OLNWDXVNXQQVNDSDQVHVIRUWVDWWVRPVY UWYLNWLJYHGPDQJHW\SHU LQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWVSHVLHOWIRUnRSSQnVWDGLJRSSJUDGHULQJDYSURGXNWHURJ SURGXNVMRQVPnWHU
8OLNHYLUNHPLGOHUIRUXOLNHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHW
'HWILQQHVLPLGOHUWLGLNNHHWWEHVWHPWYLUNHPLGGHOVRPHUGHWHQHUHWWHLQQHQIRU HQUHJLRQDOLQQRYDVMRQVSROLWLNN9LUNHPLGOHQHPnWLOSDVVHVGHXWIRUGULQJHURJ IODVNHKDOVHUVRPILQQHVLXOLNHW\SHUEHGULIWHU(QYLNWLJKHQVLNWPHGHWWHUI¡O JHQGHQRWDWHUHUVnOHGHVnDYGHNNHIODVNHKDOVHURJXWIRUGULQJHUIRULQQRYDVMRQV DNWLYLWHWLXOLNHGHOHUDY$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLYVRPHWJUXQQODJIRUnXWIRUPH YLUNHPLGOHUWLOSDVVHWXOLNHW\SHUEHGULIWHUQ ULQJVVHNWRUHURJRPUnGHU
3nSULQVLSLHOWJUXQQODJHUGHWLPLGOHUWLGPXOLJnDQW\GHUHOHYDQWHYLUNHPLGOHU LQQHQIRULQQRYDVMRQVIHOWHWIRUXOLNHW\SHUDYEHGULIWHU1HGHQIRUVNLOOHUYLPHO ORPILUHKRYHGW\SHUDYEHGULIWHURJYLGLVNXWHUHUPXOLJHVWUDWHJLHUIRUGLVVHEH GULIWVW\SHQH9LVHUSn
• )LOLDOEHGULIWHUGHWYLOVLEHGULIWHUVRPHUGHOHUDYHWVW¡UUHNRQVHUQIRUHNV HPSHOHWWUDQVQDVMRQDOWVHOVNDSPHGKRYHGNRQWRUXWHQIRU$XVW$JGHU
• 6HOYVWHQGLJHORNDOWHLGHEHGULIWHUVRPLQQJnULORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUGHWYLO VLDWGHWILQQHVQ UOLJJHQGHEHGULIWHULVDPPHEUDQVMHVnYHOVRPORNDOHOHYH UDQG¡UHU
• 6HOYVWHQGLJHORNDOWHLGHEHGULIWHUXWHQHWORNDOWQ ULQJVPLOM¡GHWYLOVLEH GULIWHUPHGHQDNWLYLWHWVRPGHWILQQHVOLWHDYHOOHUVLI\ONHW
• %HGULIWHUVRPHULIHUGPHGnHWDEOHUHV
6WUDWHJL/RNDOIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDOEHGULIWHU
%HGULIWHQHVRPHUGHOHUDYVW¡UUHNRQVHUQYLOJMHUQHLQQJnLQDVMRQDOHRJLQWHU QDVMRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU%HGULIWHQHNDQKHQWHPDQJHUHVVXUVHUWLOEUXNL VLQLQQRYDWLYHDNWLYLWHWIUDDQGUHGHOHUDYNRQVHUQHQH'HNDQVDPDUEHLGHPHG IRUVNQLQJVDYGHOLQJHUHOOHUDYDQVHUWHEHGULIWHULNRQVHUQHWRPIRUHNVHPSHOSUR GXNWXWYLNOLQJGHNDQKHQWHUnGRJVW¡WWHWLOPDUNHGVI¡ULQJRJVWUDWHJLXWYLNOLQJ RJVnYLGHUH
+DUILOLDOEHGULIWHQHVnQRHQQ\WWHDYORNDOHRJUHJLRQDOHUHVVXUVHULVLQLQQRYDWL YHDNWLYLWHW",QRHQWLOIHOOHUYLOEHGULIWHQHLNNHKDVWHUNHNREOLQJHUWLOGHWORNDOH Q ULQJVPLOM¡HWVOLNDWGHIUDHWLQQRYDVMRQVSHUVSHNWLYNXQQHY UWORNDOLVHUW QHVWHQKYRUVRPKHOVW9LKDUGHUIRUWLGOLJHUHLQRWDWHWIRUIHNWHWV\QVSXQNWHWRP DWpQVWUDWHJLLWLOWDNVDUEHLGHWNDQY UHnInWLOHQEHGUHORNDOIRUDQNULQJDY GHQQHW\SHQEHGULIWHU
+YRUGDQNDQHQVnInWLOEHGUHORNDOIRUDQNULQJ"7DUHQXWJDQJVSXQNWLWDQNH JDQJHQPHGLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHUMDPI¡UILJXUNDQEHGUHORNDOIRUDQNULQJDY ILOLDOEHGULIWHURSSQnVYHGDWGHWLRPUnGHWILQQHV)R8LQVWLWXVMRQHUPHGUHOHYDQW
NRPSHWDQVHIRUEHGULIWHQHNRPSHWHQWDUEHLGVNUDIWRJDNWXHOOHOHYHUDQG¡UHU 'HWNDQPHGI¡UHDWILOLDOEHGULIWHUILQQHUVWHGHWDWWUDNWLYWVLGHQGHNDQVDPDU EHLGHRPLQQRYDVMRQHUPHGIRUVNHUHYHGHQ)R8LQVWLWXVMRQPHGORNDOHOHYHUDQ G¡UHURJVLGHQGHWHUJRGHPXOLJKHWHUIRUUHNUXWWHULQJDYQ\HNRPSHWHQWHPHG DUEHLGHUH)\ONHVQLYnHWVUROOHLGHQQHVDPPHQKHQJHQNDQV UOLJY UHnV¡UJH IRUUHOHYDQWRJJRGIDJXWGDQQLQJRJRSSO ULQJVDPWELGUDWLOnXWYLNOHORNDOH OHYHUDQG¡UHUVOLNDWGHNDQLQQJnLODQJYDULJVDPDUEHLGPHGILOLDOEHGULIWHQH .DQVNMHNDQRIIHQWOLJHP\QGLJKHWHUVDPDUEHLGHPHGVWRUEHGULIWHQRPXWSHNLQJ DYIHOWHUGHUQ\HHOOHUHNVLVWHUHQGHEHGULIWHUNDQY UHOHYHUDQG¡UHURJRPnXW PHLVOHNRQNUHWHWLOWDNIRUnRSSQnOHYHUDQG¡UHUPHGK¡\NRPSHWDQVHRJNYDOL WHW
6WUDWHJL7LOI¡UHORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUVWUDWHJLVN NRPSHWDQVH
/RNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUHUHQV UOLJYLNWLJPnOJUXSSHIRUUHJLRQDOLQQRYDVMRQV SROLWLNNRJGHWILQQHVLGHWPLQVWHW\GHOLJHWLOO¡SWLOQRHQVOLNHPLOM¡HUL$XVW
$JGHUPHG,7LQGXVWULSODVWEnWLQGXVWULRJWUHYDUHLQGXVWULVRPGHPHVWNMHQWH (WDQQHWEHJUHSIRUGHWVDPPHIHQRPHQHWHUUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUVRPEH W\UDWGHWVNDOY UHIOHUHEHGULIWHULQQHQGHQVDPPHQ ULQJVVHNWRUHQLHWRPUn GHRJEHGULIWHQHVNDOVDPDUEHLGHPHGKYHUDQGUHIRUHNVHPSHOJMHQQRPNXQGH OHYHUDQG¡UIRUKROG
6OLNHUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUDQVHVDYPDQJH¶IRUVWnVHJSnHUH·VRPHWWV\QOLJ XWVODJDYGHQW\SHQVWRUHHQGULQJHULQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQVRPEOHRPWDOWWLGOLJH UHLQRWDWHWQHPOLJRYHUJDQJHQIUDIRUGLVPHWLOHQ¡NRQRPLPHUGRPLQHUWDY K\SSLJHLQQRYDVMRQHURJQLVMHSURGXNVMRQDYNXQGHWLOSDVVHGHNYDOLWHWVYDUHU5H JLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUHUYLGHUHHWIHQRPHQVRPDQWDVnInVWDGLJVW¡UUHXWEUH GHOVH*UXQQHQHUDWJRGHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUXWJM¡UGHWEHVWHJUXQQODJHWIRUnInWLO HWLQQRYDWLYWQ ULQJVOLY'HUPHGHUGHQQHPnWHQnRUJDQLVHUHQ ULQJVYLUNVRP KHWSnHWWVYDUSnGHXWIRUGULQJHQHVRPQ ULQJVOLYHWRJQ ULQJVSROLWLNNHQQn VWnURYHUIRU'HWnE\JJHRSSRJYLGHUHXWYLNOHUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHU²GHU GHWWHHUPXOLJ²HUGHUIRUHWYLNWLJLQVWUXPHQWIRUnRSSQnYHNVWLDQWDOODU EHLGVSODVVHURJYHOVWDQGLHQUHJLRQ
5HJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUHOOHUORNDOHLQGXVWULPLOM¡HUHULPLGOHUWLGLNNHHWJRGH LVHJVHOY'HWILQQHVEnGHG\QDPLVNHQ ULQJVNO\QJHURJNO\QJHUVRPLNNHIXQ JHUHUVRPVWDJQHUHURJHWWHUKYHUWIRUVYLQQHU+YDHUVnUHOHYDQWHYLUNHPLGOHU IRUnVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWLEHGULIWHULUHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHU",JMHQ HUVYDUHWDWYLUNHPLGOHUPnVNUHGGHUV\VWLOYDULHUHQGHEHKRYLGHHQNHOWHNO\Q JHQH(WRYHURUGQHWPnOHULPLGOHUWLGnInGHWUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHWL NO\QJHQHWLOnIXQJHUHEHGUH'HWEHW\UnVLNUHUHOHYDQWRJJRGIDJXWGDQQLQJ VDPWJRGWVDPDUEHLGPHOORPEHGULIWHQHLNO\QJHQ
(WSUREOHPLPDQJHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUHUVDPDUEHLGHWPHG)R8LQVWLWXVMRQHU'HW JMHOGHUVSHVLHOWGHUNO\QJHQGRPLQHUHVDYPDQJHPLQGUHEHGULIWHU6OLNHEHGULI WHUKDUVMHOGHQUHVVXUVHUWLOnVDPDUEHLGHPHG)R8PLOM¡HU²RJKHOOHULNNHUHV VXUVHUWLOnJMHQQRPI¡UHV UOLJIRUVNQLQJRJXWYLNOLQJLHJHQUHJL,PDQJHUHJLR QDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUDQVHVGHUIRUWHNQRORJLVHQWUHIRUVWnWWLEUHGPHQLQJVRPHW VSHVLHOWUHOHYDQWYLUNHPLGGHO6OLNHWHNQRORJLVHQWUHNDQKDIOHUHIXQNVMRQHU(Q
HUnRSSWUHVRPPHOORPPDQQGHWYLOVLNQ\WWHNRQWDNWPHOORPEHGULIWHULNO\Q JHQRJNRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HUIRUVNQLQJVLQVWLWXVMRQHUNRQVXOHQWHUDYDQVHUWHEH GULIWHUHWFDQGUHVWHGHU,WLOOHJJNDQWHNQRORJLVHQWUHQHJMHQQRPI¡UHHQYLVV XWYLNOLQJVDNWLYLWHWLHJHQUHJLPHQLVDPDUEHLGPHGORNDOHEHGULIWHUVNROHURJ HYHQWXHOWUHOHYDQWHPLOM¡HUXWHQIRURPUnGHWGHNDQJLUnGJLYQLQJRJKMHOSWLO EHGULIWHUVDPWVWLPXOHUHUWLO¡NWVDPDUEHLGPHOORPEHGULIWHU,UHJLRQDOHQ ULQJVNO\QJHUILQQHVIOHUHEHGULIWHUVRPEDVHUHUVLQYLUNVRPKHWSnGHVDPPH NXQQVNDSVEDVHURJVRPIRUHNVHPSHORSSOHYHUGHVDPPHIODVNHKDOVHQHLVLQ NRPSHWDQVH'HWHUGDYLNWLJnInWLOHQWHNQRORJLVNRJNRPSHWDQVHPHVVLJRSS JUDGHULQJLGHWVWRUHIOHUWDOOHWDYEHGULIWHULNO\QJHQ
6WUDWHJL.Q\WWH¶HQVOLJH·EHGULIWHUWLOQDVMRQDOH NRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HU
0DQJHEHGULIWHUHULPLGOHUWLG¶HQVOLJHVYDOHU·LVLWWRPUnGHGHKDUInHOOHULQJHQ DQGUHORNDOHEHGULIWHUnVDPDUEHLGHPHG7DQNHJDQJHQRPUHJLRQDOHLQQRYD VMRQVV\VWHPHUHULNNHV UOLJUHOHYDQWLVOLNHWLOIHOOHU2IIHQWOLJHP\QGLJKHWHU NDQLNNHV¡NHnVWLPXOHUHWLO¡NWVDPDUEHLGRPLQQRYDVMRQHUPHGIRUHNVHPSHO DQGUHOLNQHQGHEHGULIWHUOHYHUDQG¡UHURJ)R8PLOM¡HULQ UKHWHQQnUGLVVHLNNH ILQQHV'HWnJMHQQRPI¡UHLQQRYDVMRQHUHULPLGOHUWLGDYJM¡UHQGHIRUODQJVLNWLJ NRQNXUUDQVHHYQHRJVnIRUGHQQHW\SHQEHGULIWHU+YDHUVnGHUHOHYDQWHYLUNH PLGOHQHIRUnVWLPXOHUHLQQRYDVMRQHULGHQQHW\SHQEHGULIWHU"
(WWUHOHYDQWYLUNHPLGGHONDQEHWHJQHVVRPPHOORPPHQQ'HWWHHULQVWLWXVMRQHU VRPVNDOELGUDWLODWYLNWLJNRPSHWDQVHLUHJLRQDOHRJQDVMRQDOHNRPSHWDQVH PLOM¡HUEOLUWLOJMHQJHOLJIRUDQGUHHQQGHEHGULIWHQHVRPSnHJHQKnQGRSSV¡NHU VOLNHPLOM¡HU1RHQ¶HQVOLJHVYDOHU·YLOQHPOLJY UHVY UWUHVVXUVVWHUNHEHGULIWHU VRPDOOHUHGHHUGHOHUDYHWQDVMRQDOWHOOHULQWHUQDVMRQDOWQHWWYHUNRJVRPIRU HNVHPSHOVDPDUEHLGHUEUDPHG)R8PLOM¡HURJDQGUHDYDQVHUWHEHGULIWHUXWHQ IRU$XVW$JGHU6OLNHEHGULIWHUNDQKDPDQJHIHOOHVWUHNNPHGILOLDOEHGULIWHQH VRPEOHRPWDOWIRUDQPHGXQQWDNDWGHJMHUQHHUVWHUNHUHIRUDQNUHWJMHQQRP ORNDOWHLHUVNDSRJRJVnLQRHQWLOIHOOHUJMHQQRPEUXNDYORNDOHQDWXUUHVVXUVHU 6RPIRUILOLDOEHGULIWHQHHUUHOHYDQWH¶LQQRYDVMRQVUHWWHWH·YLUNHPLGOHURYHUIRUVOL NHEHGULIWHUnV¡UJHIRUVNUHGGHUV\GGXWGDQQLQJRJRSSO ULQJVDPWVWLPXOHUHWLO IOHUHORNDOHXQGHUOHYHUDQVHU
$QGUHW\SHU¶HQVOLJHVYDOHU·KDUVW¡UUHEHKRYIRUKMHOSWLOnILQQHDNWXHOOHVDPDU EHLGVSDUWQHUHDQGUHVWHGHU²RJYLJMHQWDULJMHQDYVDPDUEHLGRJLQQKHQWLQJDY VSHVLDOLVHUWNRPSHWDQVHHUHQVY UWYHVHQWOLJDNWLYLWHWYHGLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHV VHU9LNDQEHO\VHPHOORPPDQQIXQNVMRQHQPHGnYLVHWLO1\VNDSLQJVRJWHN QRORJLSURJUDPPHWIRU1RUG1RUJH17SURJUDPPHW'HWHUHWSURJUDPVRP KDUJMRUWPDQJHDYGHUHWWHJUHSHQHQnUGHWJMHOGHUnELGUDWLOLQQRYDWLYDNWLYL WHWLEHGULIWHU3URJUDPPHWKDUVRPHQYLNWLJRSSJDYHnNQ\WWHNRQWDNWHUPHO ORPEHGULIWHURJNRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HUEnGHL1RUG1RUJHRJDQGUHVWHGHU'HWWHHU YLNWLJLSHULIHUHRPUnGHUGHUGHWPDQJHVWHGHUHUODQJWPHOORPEHGULIWHQHRJ W\QQHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU'HWHUVRPVDJWYDQVNHOLJnVNDSHUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQV V\VWHPHULVOLNHRPUnGHUDYPDQJHOSnSRWHQVLHOOHVDPDUEHLGVSDUWQHUHEnGH EODQWEHGULIWHURJ)R8LQVWLWXVMRQHU6NDOEHGULIWHQHXWYLNOHVHJPnGHNQ\WWHV WLOPLOM¡HUDQGUHVWHGHURJGHWnVWLPXOHUHVOLNWVDPDUEHLGJMHQQRPIRUHNVHP SHOHQIRUPIRU¶IDGGHUVWLSHQGHU·NDQY UHHWUHOHYDQWYLUNHPLGGHO
6WUDWHJL6NDS¶VW¡WWHPLOM¡·UXQGWQ\HWDEOHUH
(QVLVWHW\SHEHGULIWHUHUGHVRPHULIHUGPHGnEOLHWDEOHUWHOOHUVRPHUSnLGp VWDGLHWcVW¡WWHRSSRPQ\HWDEOHULQJHUYLORJVnY UHHQYLNWLJGHODYHQUHJLRQDO LQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLVHOYRPODQJWIUDDOOHQ\HEHGULIWHUHULQQRYDWLYH1\HEH GULIWHUNDQLPLGOHUWLGNRPPHLQQPHGQ\HO¡VQLQJHULSURGXNWHURJSURGXN VMRQVPnWHURJGHNDQGHUPHGOHJJHHWSUHVVSnGHHNVLVWHUHQGHEHGULIWHQHRPn LQQRYHUH'HWHURJVnPDQJHHNVHPSOHUSnDWQ\HEHGULIWHUKDUKDWWVWRUHULQJ YLUNQLQJHULHWRPUnGHRJIRUHNVHPSHOJLWWRSSKDYWLOQ\HORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU 'HWKDUJMHUQHVNMHGGJMHQQRP¶DYOHJJHUPHNDQLVPHU·SHUVRQHUVRPKDUDUEHLGHW LGHQHOOHUGHI¡UVWHSLRQHUEHGULIWHQHRJO UWVHJHWIDJKDUVLGHQVWDUWHWIRUVHJ VHOY6OLNHULQJYLUNQLQJHUNDQV UOLJIRUHNRPPHLVHNWRUHUGHUGHWHUYRNVHQGH PDUNHGHURJODYHHWDEOHULQJVWHUVNOHUGHWYLOVLGHUNUDYHQHWLONDSLWDONRQWDN WHURJVSHVLDOLVHUWNRPSHWDQVHLNNHHUVSHVLHOWVWRUHGHQI¡UVWHWLGHQ6OLNH¶DY OHJJHUPHNDQLVPHU·IRUHNRPLVLQWLGIUD6WUDWRQLFVRPQnKHWHU.LWURQRJIUD SODVWDYGHOLQJHQYHGWLGOLJHUH$QFDV%nWE\JJHULSn7URP¡\D'HVLVWHnUDHUIRU
¡YULJGHVDPPHPHNDQLVPHQHREVHUYHUWYHGHWDEOHULQJDYQHWWVHOVNDSHURJPXO WLPHGLDEHGULIWHUL2VORRPUnGHW
6W¡WWHWLOQ\HEHGULIWHUKDUJMHUQHY UWVRPGLUHNWHHWDEOHULQJVVW¡WWHRJUnGJLY QLQJWLOHQNHOWEHGULIWHUHOOHUHWDEOHUHUH'HWWHHUHWYLNWLJYLUNHPLGGHORYHUIRU GHQQHW\SHQEHGULIWHU'HWKDULPLGOHUWLGYLVWVHJVRPRPWUHQWXPXOLJnSOXNNH XW¶YLQQHUH·SnIRUKnQG$QDO\VHUYLVHUDWHWOLWHDQWDOOQ\HEHGULIWHUYRNVHU VY UWUDVNWPHQVIOHUWDOOHWDYQ\HEHGULIWHUIRUEOLUVPnRJHQVY UWVWRUDQGHO QHGOHJJHVHWWHUQRHQInnU7DOOIUDPDQJHODQGYLVHUIRUHNVHPSHODWQHVWHQ KDOYSDUWHQDYDOOHQ\HEHGULIWHUHURSSK¡UWHWWHUIHPnU
6HWWIUDHWLQQRYDVMRQVSHUVSHNWLYHUGHWYLNWLJnSnSHNHDWRSSJDYHQODQJWIUDHU IHUGLJQnUEHGULIWHQHUEOLWWHWDEOHUW%HGULIWHUPnIRUWVHWWHnY UHLQQRYDWLYH RJVnHWWHUHWDEOHULQJHQGHUVRPGHLNNHVNDOKDYQHLGHQKDOYGHOHQDYQ\HEH GULIWHUVRPIRUWEOLUQHGODJW'HVVXWHQPnGHWSnSHNHVDWHWDEOHULQJHUHOOHULQQ RYDVMRQHUIRUGHQVDNHQVVN\OGLNNHNXQHUHWWHNQRORJLVNDQOLJJHQGHVRPnIn HWQ\WWSURGXNWWLOnIXQJHUH(WDEOHULQJRJLQQRYDVMRQRPIDWWHUHQUHNNHDQGUH VS¡UVPnOVRPnInRYHUVLNWRYHUHWPDUNHGRUGQHILQDQVLHULQJInNRQWDNWPHG OHYHUDQG¡UHUUHNUXWWHUHDUEHLGVNUDIWPHGQ¡GYHQGLJHNYDOLILNDVMRQHUInXWUH GHWEHVWHPWHSUREOHPHUKRVHQ)R8LQVWLWXVMRQRJVnYLGHUH2IWHHUHWDEOHUHUH VSHVLDOLVWHUSnWHNQRORJLHQPHQVGHNDQPDQJOHNXQQVNDSRPPDQJHDYGHDQ GUHVLGHQHYHGHQHWDEOHULQJHOOHUHQLQQRYDVMRQ5nGJLYQLQJRJVW¡WWHXWRYHU WHNQRORJLVNHIHOWHUHUGHUPHGYLNWLJ/LNHVnIUDPVWnUGHWVRPYLNWLJnNQ\WWH EHGULIWHUWLOHWLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHQWHQGHWHUWLOUHJLRQDOHDNW¡UHUGHUGHWWH ILQQHVHOOHUWLOQDVMRQDOHDNW¡UHU
3HUVSHNWLYHWPHGLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHUHUVnOHGHVRJVnVY UWUHOHYDQWIRUnXW PHLVOHUHOHYDQWHYLUNHPLGOHURYHUIRUQ\HWDEOHUWHEHGULIWHU'HIOHVWHQ\HEHGULI WHUHUVY UWVPn²RJKDUNDQVNMHLHQGDVW¡UUHJUDGHQQDQGUHPLQGUHEHGULIWHU HWSUREOHPPHGnY UH¶LVROHUWH·GHWYLOVLDWGHPDQJOHUDQGUHEHGULIWHURJLQVWL WXVMRQHUnVDPDUEHLGHPHG'HWnELGUDWLONRQWDNWRJVDPDUEHLGPHGDQGUHUH OHYDQWHDNW¡UHUHUGHUPHGHQVY UWDNWXHOOVWUDWHJLIRUQ\HWDEOHULQJHU
'HQJDPOHDNNYLVLVMRQVVWUDWHJLHQNDQRJVnEHQ\WWHVIRUnInLQQQ\HEHGULIWHUWLO HWRPUnGH'HWEHW\UnSU¡YHnInEHGULIWHUVRPHUSn·IO\WWHIRW·WLOnYHOJH$XVW
$JGHUVRPORNDOLVHULQJVVWHGHOOHUSU¡YHnInKHOWQ\HEHGULIWHUWLOnYHOJHn HWDEOHUHVHJL$XVW$JGHU6RPQHYQWWLGOLJHUHLQRWDWHWNDQHQSU¡YHnEUXNH DNNYLVLVMRQVWUDWHJLVNJMHQQRPnInWDNLQ\HEHGULIWHULQQHQIRURPUnGHUGHUGHW DOOHUHGHILQQHVHWQ ULQJVPLOM¡L$XVW$JGHU'HWNDQIRUHNVHPSHOY UHEHGULI WHUVRPNDQY UHNXQGHUHOOHUOHYHUDQG¡UHUIRUDOOHUHGHHNVLVWHUHQGHEHGULIWHUL
$XVW$JGHU'HWHUP\HVRPW\GHUSnDWEHGULIWHUL¡NHQGHJUDGYXUGHUHUGHW RPNULQJOLJJHQGHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HW²RJKYLONHQQ\WWHGHVHOYNDQKDDYGHWWH²QnU GHOHWHUHWWHUDOWHUQDWLYHORNDOLVHULQJVVWHGHU
2SSVXPPHULQJ(QPXOLJLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLIRU$XVW
$JGHU
1RWDWHWKDUDUJXPHQWHUWIRUDWLQQRYDVMRQHUHUHQDYJM¡UHQGHNRQNXUUDQVHIDN WRULQ ULQJVOLYHWLGDJ%HGULIWHUNDQLNNHRYHUODQJWLGOLWHSnVLQHHNVLVWHUHQGH SURGXNWHURJWMHQHVWHUHOOHUPnWHUnJM¡UHWLQJSn'HPnLQQRYHUHIRUnIRUVYDUH VLQSODVVLQ ULQJVOLYHW,QQRYDVMRQHUVNMHULVWRUJUDGVRPK\SSLJHPLQGUHHQG ULQJHULSURGXNWHURJPnWHUnSURGXVHUHSn'HWNDQLPLGOHUWLGRJVnIRUHNRPPH VW¡UUHHQGULQJHUVRPNDQVNDSHEHW\GHOLJHRPYHOWQLQJHULPDQJHQ ULQJVVHNWR UHU,GDJIUDPVWnUQ\LQIRUPDVMRQVRJNRPPXQLNDVMRQVWHNQRORJLVRPpQYLNWLJ IDNWRUVRPNDQHQGUHNRQNXUUDQVHVLWXDVMRQHQLPDQJHVHNWRUHU
)RUnJMHQQRPI¡UHLQQRYDVMRQHUPnEHGULIWHUE\JJHRSSVSHVLDOLVHUWNRPSHWDQVH LQWHUQWLEHGULIWHQ'HWHULPLGOHUWLGRJVnYLNWLJnKHQWHLQQNRPSHWDQVHIUD PDQJHHNVWHUQHNLOGHU²RJEHGULIWHUO UHUQ\WWLVDPDUEHLGPHGDQGUHDNW¡UHU 'HWHURJVnVOLNDWEHGULIWHULQQRYHUHUSnVY UWXOLNHPnWHURJGHKDUXOLNHEH KRYLLQQRYDVMRQVSURVHVVHQ
8WIUDHQVOLNIRUVWnHOVHDYYLUNHOLJKHWHQIRUHVOnVGHWDW$XVW$JGHULVLQ6WUD WHJLVNH1 ULQJVSODQIRNXVHUHUSnYLUNHPLGOHUVRPNDQVW\UNHEHGULIWHUVLQQRYD WLYHDNWLYLWHW+YDHUVnGHQQHW\SHQDYYLUNHPLGOHU"'HWPnDYJM¡UHVJMHQQRP HPSLULVNHDQDO\VHUDYLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHWLXOLNHW\SHUEHGULIWHURJJMHQQRP DQDO\VHDYIODVNHKDOVHURJEHKRYLXOLNHGHOHUDYQ ULQJVOLYHW3nSULQVLSLHOW JUXQQODJKDUYLLPLGOHUWLGVDWWRSSI¡OJHQGHW\SHUDYYLUNHPLGOHUVRPVSHVLHOW DNWXHOOHLHQLQQRYDVMRQVVDPPHQKHQJMDPI¡UWDEHOO
• 6¡UJHIRUEHGUHORNDOHIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDOEHGULIWHUJMHQQRPEODQWDQQHWWLOUHW WHOHJJLQJDYXWGDQQLQJRJRSSO ULQJWLOSDVVHWGLVVHEHGULIWHQHVEHKRYRJVWL PXOHULQJDYORNDOHOHYHUDQG¡UHUWLOILOLDOEHGULIWHQH,GHWKHOHWDWWDQVHVXW GDQQLQJPHGUHJQHWHWWHUXWGDQQLQJRJRPVNROHULQJVRPHQDYGHYLNWLJVWH DNWLYLWHWHQHLGHQ¶Q\HO UHQGH¡NRQRPLHQ·'HWEHW\UDWQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJRJ XWGDQQLQJPnVHHVLQ UVDPPHQKHQJ
• 9LGHUHXWYLNOHUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHUGHUGHWILQQHVHWORNDOWQ ULQJVPLOM¡HOOHUHQUHJLRQDOQ ULQJVNO\QJHHOOHUHWSRWHQVLDOIRUnGDQQHGHW WH(WWUHOHYDQWYLUNHPLGGHOHUWHNQRORJLVHQWHUVRPNDQRUJDQLVHUHVSnXOLNH PnWHU(QYLNWLJKHQVLNWPHGVHQWUHQHHUnVDPDUEHLGHPHGEHGULIWHULNO\Q JHQRPRSSDUEHLGLQJDYNRPSHWDQVHSnVWUDWHJLVNYLNWLJHIHOWHUIRUEHGULIWHQH LNO\QJHQVWLPXOHUHWLOVDPDUEHLGVSURVMHNWHUPHOORPEHGULIWHURJVnYLGHUH
• 9 UHPHOORPPHQQIRUVHOYVWHQGLJHEHGULIWHUVRPLNNHLQQJnULHOOHUNDQQD WXUOLJLQQJnLORNDOHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HU'HWEHW\UnELGUDWLODWVOLNHPLOM¡HU NRPPHULNRQWDNWPHGUHOHYDQWHNRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HUDQGUHVWHGHU
• %LGUDWLODWQ\HEHGULIWHUNQ\WWHVWLOUHOHYDQWHUHJLRQDOHHOOHUQDVMRQDOHLQQR YDVMRQVV\VWHPHUIRUnVLNUHLQQRYDVMRQRJXWYLNOLQJRJVnHWWHUHWDEOHULQJHQ 'HWHURJVnDNWXHOWnInLQQQ\HEHGULIWHUJMHQQRPDNNYLVLVMRQ²RJVSHVLHOW DUEHLGHIRUnInLQQEHGULIWHUVRPNDQXWI\OOH¶KXOOHU·LHNVLVWHUHQGHQ ULQJV PLOM¡HURJUHJLRQDOHLQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU
7DEHOO2SSVXPPHULQJDYDNWXHOOHLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHUIRUXOLNHW\SHUDY EHGULIWHU
%HGULIWVW\SH +RYHGPnOPHGVWUDWHJL
HQ 5HOHYDQWHYLUNHPLGOHU )LOLDOEHGULIWHU /RNDOIRUDQNULQJDYILOLDO
EHGULIWHU 6NUHGGHUV\XWGDQQLQJ 6WLPXOHUHIUDPYHNVWDY ORNDOHOHYHUDQG¡UHU 6HOYVWHQGLJHEHGULI
WHULORNDOHQ ULQJV PLOM¡HU
9LGHUHXWYLNOHUHJLRQDOH
LQQRYDVMRQVV\VWHPHU %LGUDWLOHWDEOHULQJDY
¶WHNQRORJLVHQWUH·
6HOYVWHQGLJHEHGULI WHUVRPHU¶HQVOLJH VYDOHU·
.Q\WWHEHGULIWHQWLONRP SHWDQVHPLOM¡HUDQGUHVWH GHU
9 UHPHOORPPDQQ
1\HWDEOHULQJHU .Q\WWHEHGULIWHUWLOLQQR
YDVMRQVV\VWHPHU 9 UHPHOORPPDQQ
$NNYLVLVMRQ
+YDQn"
'HWWHI¡UVWHQRWDWHWIUD67(3JUXSSHQKDUDUJXPHQWHUWIRUDW$XVW$JGHUE¡U YHOJHHQLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLVRPXWJDQJVSXQNWIRUDUEHLGHWPHGVLQ6WUDWHJLVNH 1 ULQJVSODQ(QVOLNVWUDWHJLDQVHVVRPHWUHOHYDQWVYDUSnGHXWIRUGULQJHQH VRPQ ULQJVOLYHWLI\ONHWP¡WHUJMHQQRP¶VWRUH·XWYLNOLQJVWUHNNL¡NRQRPLHQ
*MHQQRPnIRNXVHUHSnLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWYLOGHVVXWHQ1 ULQJVSODQHQRPIDWWH JUXQQOHJJHQGHGULYNUHIWHUEDNUHJLRQDOQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJ(QLQQRYDVMRQVVWUD WHJLPnLPLGOHUWLGWLOSDVVHVXOLNHW\SHUDYEHGULIWHURJQRWDWHWKDUGLVNXWHUWDN WXHOOHVWUDWHJLHUIRUILUHKRYHGW\SHUDYEHGULIWHU'HWnVNUHGGHUV\XWGDQQLQJWLO Q ULQJVOLYHWVEHKRYYLGHUHXWYLNOHORNDOHLQQRYDWLYHQ ULQJVPLOM¡HUVDPW NQ\WWHEHGULIWHUWLONRPSHWDQVHPLOM¡HUDQGUHVWHGHUIUDPVWnUVRPDNWXHOOHYLU NHPLGOHUIRUIOHUHW\SHUDYEHGULIWHU
,GHWYLGHUHELGUDJHWWLODUEHLGHWPHG613IRU$XVW$JGHUVNDO67(3JUXSSHQ V UOLJDUEHLGHPHGnNRQNUHWLVHUHGHRPWDOWHIRUVODJHQHWLOYLUNHPLGOHU'HWWH QRWDWHWPnDQVHVVRPHWIRUV¡NSnnDYNODUHKYDVRPHUYLNWLJHJHQHUHOOHXWIRUG ULQJHUIRUQ ULQJVOLYHWRJKYDVRPHUPXOLJHVWUDWHJLHULGHWUHJLRQDOHRJORNDOH WLOWDNVDUEHLGHWIRUnVYDUHSnGLVVHXWIRUGULQJHQH,GHWYLGHUHDUEHLGHWEHQ\WWHV WLOQ UPLQJVPnWHQLQRWDWHWVRPHWUHGVNDSIRUnNRQNUHWLVHUHQ UPHUHKYDHQ LQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLIRU$XVW$JGHUNDQEHVWnL
)RUGHWIRUPnOHWVNDOGHWJMHQQRPI¡UHVWRW\SHUDYDQDO\VHU)¡UVWIRUHWDVHQ NDUWOHJJLQJDYYLNWLJHVLGHUYHGQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQJHQL$XVW$JGHUYHGKMHOSDY WLOJMHQJHOLJVWDWLVWLNNQRWDW'HWVNDOEODQWDQQHWDYJUHQVHVYLNWLJHQ ULQJHU RJQ ULQJVNO\QJHUL$XVW$JGHU'HUQHVWJMHQQRPI¡UHVHQUHNNHSHUVRQOLJHLQ WHUYMXHUPHGEHGULIWVOHGHUHRJDQGUHYLNWLJHLQIRUPDQWHUQRWDW+HQVLNWHQHU nXQGHUV¡NHKYRUGDQLQQRYDWLYDNWLYLWHWJMHQQRPI¡UHVL$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLY RJKYDVRPHUYLNWLJHXWIRUGULQJHURJIODVNHKDOVHUIRUnEHGUHGHQLQQRYDWLYHDN WLYLWHWHQRJNRQNXUUDQVHHYQHQLEHGULIWHQH
3nEDNJUXQQDYGHRPWDOWHDQDO\VHQHXWDUEHLGHVWLOVLVWIRUVODJWLONRQNUHWH VWUDWHJLHURJYLUNHPLGOHUIRUXOLNHW\SHUDYEHGULIWHUQRWDW
$JGHU²6WDWLVWLVNDQDO\VH
$Y1LOV+HQULN6ROXP
,QQOHGQLQJ
'HWWHQRWDWHWHUXWDUEHLGHWVRPHQGHODY67(3JUXSSHQVRSSGUDJIRU$XVW
$JGHUI\ONHVNRPPXQHVRPJMHOGHUELGUDJYHGXWDUEHLGLQJDYQ\VWUDWHJLVNQ ULQJVSODQ613IRUI\ONHW'HWWHHUQRWDWQULGHQQHVDPPHQKHQJHQ'HWI¡U VWHQRWDWHWJDHQRYHUVLNWRYHUQRHQVWRUHWUHQGHULGHQ¡NRQRPLVNHXWYLNOLQJHQ RJGHWEOHDUJXPHQWHUWIRUDW$XVW$JGHUE¡UYHOJHHQLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLVRP XWJDQJVSXQNWIRUDUEHLGHWPHG613VRPHWWVYDUSnGHVWRUHWUHQGHQH1RWDW QUGLVNXWHUWHRJVnKYDHQLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLNDQRPIDWWH
,GHWIRUHOLJJHQGHQRWDWHWJLVHQRYHUVLNWRYHUYLNWLJHVLGHUYHGQ ULQJVXWYLNOLQ JHQL$XVW$JGHUGHWYLOVLQ ULQJVVWUXNWXUXWGDQQLQJVQLYnRJLQQRYDWLYDNWL YLWHW1RWDWHWGDQQHUHQGHODYJUXQQODJHWIRUXWDUEHLGLQJDYIRUVODJWLOLQQRYD VMRQVVWUDWHJLHUIRUXOLNHGHOHUDY$XVW$JGHUVQ ULQJVOLYLGHWVRPVNDOEOLQR WDWQUIUD67(3JUXSSHQLRSSGUDJHWIRU$XVW$JGHUI\ONHVNRPPXQH
'HWIRUHOLJJHQGHQRWDWHWEDVHUHVSnWLOGHOVKHOWQ\HVWDWLVWLVNHGDWDVRPRPIDW WHULQIRUPDVMRQRPQ ULQJVIRUKROGL1RUJH)¡UGHQDQDO\WLVNHGHOHQSUHVHQWH UHVJLVHQNRUWIDWWHWSUHVHQWDVMRQDYGDWDPDWHULDOHW'HWWHPDWHULDOHWEUXNHVVn WLOnVLQRHRPKYLONHQ ULQJHUVRPHUVSHVLHOWYLNWLJHL$XVW$JGHURJJLHQEH VNULYHOVHDYXWYLNOLQJHQLQQHQGLVVHQ ULQJVRPUnGHQH'HUHWWHUYLOYLVHSnVL WXDVMRQHQLQQHQ$XVW$JGHUJMHQQRPnGHOHI\ONHWRSSLILUHUHJLRQHU7LOVOXWW YXUGHUHVLQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHWLQQHQI\ONHWVEHGULIWHUVSHVLHOW
'HVLVWHnUHQHHUGHWEOLWWUHWWHWVWRURSSPHUNVRPKHWPRWLQQRYDVMRQVHYQHVRP HWYLNWLJNULWHULXPIRUEHGULIWHUVVnYHOVRPUHJLRQHUVRJQDVMRQHUV´RYHUOHYHOVHµ RJYHNVW.RUWVDJWYLOXWYLNOLQJHQLGHIOHVWHPDUNHGHUHQGUHNRQNXUUDQVHEHWLQ JHOVHQHRYHUWLG'HUPHGEOLUGHWVY UWYLNWLJnSURGXVHUHQ\WWEHGUHHOOHUELOOL JHUH*MHUQHQ\WWEHGUHRJELOOLJHUH7LOWURVVIRUWUHGHOLQJHQDYQRWDWHWLQ ULQJVVWUXNWXUXWGDQQLQJVQLYnRJLQQRYDVMRQPnGHIRUVNMHOOLJHGHOHQHVHHVL VDPPHQKHQJPHGKYHUDQGUH)RUnNXQQHSHNHXWKYLONHQ ULQJHUVRPHUVSH VLHOWYLNWLJHIRU$XVW$JGHUPnPDQYXUGHUHV\VVHOVHWWLQJVP¡QVWUHQ ULQJV VWUXNWXUDQWDOOEHGULIWHUORNDOLVHULQJRJDQQHW'HWYLORJVnY UHQ\WWLJnVHRP VLWXDVMRQHQPDQEHVNULYHUIRUI\ONHWVRPHQKHOKHWHUHJQHWRJVnWLOnEHVNULYH VLWXDVMRQHQLQQHQI\ONHWVXOLNHUHJLRQHU7LOVOXWWHUGHWYLNWLJnYXUGHUHVLWXD VMRQHQLQQHQIRUVNMHOOLJHW\SHULQQRYDVMRQVDNWLYLWHWLRPUnGHW'HWKDUYLVWVHJ WLGOLJHUHDWQ ULQJVVWUXNWXULVHJVHOYHUHQYLNWLJIRUNODULQJVPHNDQLVPHIRUX OLNHLQQRYDVMRQVVWUDWHJLHULXOLNHUHJLRQHU
'HVWDWLVWLVNHGDWDHQHWLOQRWDWHWHUVWRUWVHWWIUHPVNDIIHWDY+HLGL:LLJ
'DWDPDWHULDOHW
8WJDQJVSXQNWHWIRUDQDO\VHQHLQRWDWHWHUGDWDVHWWODJHWJMHQQRPVDPPHQNRE OLQJHQDYXOLNHRIIHQWOLJHUHJLVWUH,GHWWHWLOIHOOHGUHLHUGHWVHJRPNREOLQJHU6WD WLVWLVN6HQWUDOE\Un66%KDUJMRUW'DWDVHWWHWRPWDOHVRIWHVRPµV\VVHOVHWWLQJV ILOHQHµRJEHVWnUDYGDWDIUD5LNVWU\JGHYHUNHWV$UEHLGVJLYHUUHJLVWHU66%VSHU VRQVWDWLVWLNN0RPVUHJLVWHUHWGDWDIUD6NDWWHHWDWHQRJQRHQDQGUHPLQGUHUH JLVWUH'LVVHUHJLVWUHQHJLURVVEODQWDQQHWRSSO\VQLQJHURPXWGDQQLQJLQQWHNW RJDUEHLGVSODVVIRUDOOHSHUVRQHUPHOORPRJnUERVDWWL1RUJH'HWWHLQNOX GHUHURPODJI¡UWLWXVHQPHGXWHQODQGVNVWDWVERUJHUVNDS'DWDVHWWHWRPIDWWHU RYHUWUHPLOOLRQHUSHUVRQHUPHGKYHUWVLWWHOHNWURQLVNHNDUWRWHNNRUWPHGXOLNH RSSO\VQLQJHU
6HOYRPGHWWHHUQ\HRJULNHGDWDNLOGHUHUGHWYLNWLJnKDNODUWIRUVHJDWGHLNNH EOHODJHWIRUIRUVNQLQJVIRUPnO'HWHUYDULHUHQGHNYDOLWHWSnUHJLVWUHQHRJVnL IRUKROGWLOGHDGPLQLVWUDWLYHIRUPnOHQHGHHUODJHWIRU'HEOHLNNHODJHWIRUn NREOHVVDPPHQGYVDWGHWHULNNHEUXNWHWIHOOHVVHWWDYGHILQLVMRQHUHOOHUUH JLVWUHULQJVUXWLQHU)RUHO¡SLJHUHQEDUHLVWDUWIDVHQQnUGHWJMHOGHUDUEHLGHWPHG KDUPRQLVHULQJDYLQIRUPDVMRQHQLGHXOLNHUHJLVWUHQH)RUPHQVYLWLGOLJILNNHW SHUVRQQXPPHUHUGHWI¡UVWPHGRSSUHWWHOVHQDYGHWVnNDOWH(QKHWVUHJLVWHUHWL DWGHWRJVnHUODJHWHWIHOOHVQXPPHUIRUDOOHRUJDQLVDVMRQHUEHGULIWHURI IHQWOLJHHWDWHUXOLNHLQVWLWXVMRQHU7LGOLJHUHKDUPDQRIWHEUXNWHWHJHWQXP PHULXOLNHUHJLVWUH+HOOHULNNHLGHWLOIHOOHQHGHUHQKDUEUXNWVDPPHQXPPHU KDUGHWY UWIHOOHVUXWLQHUIRURSSUHWWHOVHHQGULQJRJVOHWWLQJDYQXPUH'HSUR EOHPHQHVRPRSSVWnUSnJUXQQDYGHWWHVNDOYLLNNHJnQ UPHUHLQQSnKHU 'HWKDURJVnVNMHGGHQXWYLNOLQJDYKYDVRPEOLUUHJLVWUHUW9LKDUIHNVLNNH VDPPHQOLJQEDUHGDWDRPVM¡OYVWHQGLJHQ ULQJVGULYHQGHIRUnUHQHRJ GHUIRUVNDOYLKHUEDUHWDIRURVVXWYLNOLQJHQIRUO¡QQVWDNHUH$YGH GU¡\WPLOOLRQHUV\VVHOVDWWHL1RUJHXWJM¡UO¡QQVWDNHUQHQRHRYHUPLOOSHU VRQHU
2SSO\VQLQJHQHHUJLWWDY$QGHUV(NHODQGDQVYDUOLJIRUGDWDEDVHQYHG67(3JUXSSHQ 'LVVHWDOOHQHIUD6WDWLVWLVNcUERNHULNNHEDVHUWSnRIIHQWOLJHUHJLVWUHPHQSn$UEHLGV NUDIWXQGHUV¡NHOVHQ$.8$.8HUHQRPIDWWHQGHPnQHGOLJVS¡UUHXQGHUV¡NHOVHVRP VnHURSSVNDOHUW'HWJLUHQYLVVXVLNNHUKHW,YnUWVWDWLVWLVNHPDWHULDOHXWJM¡UO¡QQVWD NHUQHPLOOSHUVRQHU'HQPHVWQ UOLJJHQGHnUVDNHQWLOIRUVNMHOOHQLGLVVHWDOOHQHHU DWGHRIIHQWOLJHUHJLVWUHQHKDUYDQVNHOLJHUHIRUnIDQJHRSSGHPVRPMREEHUOL
WHVSRUDGLVN6DPPHQOLJQHUYLO¡QQVWDNHUQHVIRUGHOLQJSnQ ULQJHULYnUGDWDEDVHPHG GHQYLILQQHUL$.8HUGHWVQDNNRPQRHQInWLHQGHGHOHUSURVHQWSRHQJLIRUVNMHOO)RU VNMHOOHQHGDQQHULNNHQRHP¡QVWHU$WWDOOHQHIUD$.8RJUHJLVWUHQHLNNHVWHPPHKHOW RYHUUHQVHULNNHRYHUUDVNHQGHWDWWLEHWUDNWQLQJDWGHHUVDPOHWLQQSnKHOWIRUVNMHOOLJ YLV,QJHQDYGHPHUIDVLWHQPHQGHWJLUHQVLNNHUKHWIRUKROGEDUHWDOOQnUGHVWHPPHU JRGWRYHUHQV
9LNWLJHQ ULQJHUL$XVW$JGHU ,QQOHGQLQJ
9LVNDOQnVDPPHQOLNQHQ ULQJVVWUXNWXUHQL$XVW$JGHUPHGVWUXNWXUHQLODQ GHWVRPKHOKHWIRUnILQQHIUDPWLOQ ULQJHUVRPHUUHODWLYWVHWWYLNWLJHL$XVW
$JGHU,GHWWHWLOIHOOHHUQ ULQJVLQQGHOLQJHQEDVHUWSnGHQVnNDOWH1$&(
NODVVLILVHULQJHQ'HQQHLQQGHOLQJHQEHVWnUDYHQNRGHPHGILUHVLIIHU'HWRI¡U VWHVLIUHQHJLUHQLQGLNDVMRQSnKRYHGQ ULQJHQLQQHQKYHUHQNHOWEHGULIWIRU HNVHPSHOWHNVWLOSURGXNVMRQPHG1$&(PHQVLQQGHOLQJHQHUJDQVNHGHWDO MHUWSnILUHVLIIHUQLYnIRUHNVHPSHO3URGXNVMRQDYWHSSHURJU\HUPHG1$&(
)RULNNHnInKHOWXRYHUVLNWOLJHWDEHOOHUKDUYLKHUDJJUHJHUWQ ULQJHQH QRHVOLNDWYLVLWWHULJMHQPHGQ ULQJVJUXSSHU
.DSLWOHWWDUIRUVHJILUHDVSHNWHUYHGQ ULQJVVWUXNWXUHQ
6\VVHOVDWWHRJEHGULIWHULQRUVNHI\ONHUIRUGHOWSnQ ULQJHUQ ULQJVVWUXNWXU L1RUJH
6\VVHOVDWWHRJEHGULIWHULNRPPXQHURJUHJLRQHUL$XVW$JGHUIRUGHOWSnQ ULQJ
%HGULIWHUL$XVW$JGHUIRUGHOWSnVW¡UUHOVHDQWDOODQVDWWH
%RVDWWHL$XVW$JGHUHWWHUDUEHLGVVWHGI\ONHVYLVLQQHQ$XVW$JGHURJXW YDOJWHUHJLRQHUXWHQIRUI\ONHW
1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL1RUJHRJ$XVW$JGHU
'HQDOOHUI¡UVWHWDEHOOHQJLUHQRYHUVLNWRYHUKYLONHKRYHGVHNWRUHUERVDWWHLKHQ KROGVYLV$XVW$JGHURJKHOH1RUJHHUV\VVHOVDWWHL0¡QVWHUHWL$XVW$JGHUVNLO OHUVHJLNNHLVWRUJUDGIUDODQGVJMHQQRPVQLWWHWPHQGHWHUQRHXQGHUYHNWDY DUEHLGVWDNHUHLSULYDWWMHQHVWH\WLQJHWFRJQRHRYHUYHNWDYLQGXVWULV\VVHOVDWWH RJDQVDWWHLRIIHQWOLJDGPLQLVWUDVMRQ
7DEHOO1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL1RUJHRJ$XVW$JGHU*URYVHNWRULQQGHOLQJHWWHU DQWDOODQVDWWH
6HNWRU $QWDOO
$QVDWWH $XVW$JGHU 1RUJH 8YHLGVQLWW
-RUGEUXNVNRJEUXNRJILVNH
,QGXVWUL
%\JJRJ$QOHJJ.UDIWRJYDQQIRUV\QLQJ
3ULYDWWMHQHVWH\WLQJWUDQVSRUWSRVWWHOHRJDQQHQNRPPXQLNDVMRQ 2IIHQWOLJDGP8WGDQQLQJRJ+HOVHRJVRVLDOWMHQHVWHU
$QGUHVRVLDOHRJSHUVRQOLJHWMHQHVWHU
$XVW$JGHU
'HWXYHLGHJMHQQRPVQLWWHWHUJMHQQRPVQLWWHWIRUDOOHI\ONHQH'HWIUHPNRPPHUJMHQQRPnVXP PHUHUHVXOWDWHWIRUKYHUWHQNHOWI\ONHRJGHOHGHWWHSn'HWWHNDQJLHWPRGLILVHUWELOGHDYGHW µW\SLVNHµI\ONHWHWWHUVRPEHIRONQLQJVVW¡UUHOVHLNNHInUQRHXWVODJ
3nHWPHUGHWDOMHUWSODQEOLUIRUWVDWWELOGHWP\HGHWVDPPHPHQLQQHQGHHQNHO WHVHNWRUHUHUGHWRJVnIRUVNMHOOHU,WDEHOOHQHXQGHUWDEHOORJHUGHWVDWWRSS HQRYHUVLNWRYHUIRUGHOLQJHQDYDQWDOOEHGULIWHURJDQWDOODQVDWWHLQQHQKYHUQ ULQJVJUXSSH7DEHOOHQHHUVDWWRSSVOLNDWGHYLVHUKYHUQ ULQJVSURVHQWYLVHDQ GHODYDOOHDQVDWWHLQQHQXWYDOJWHI\ONHU0HGDQGUHRUGYLOHQYDULDVMRQPHO ORPIRUGHOLQJHQLGHHQNHOWHI\ONHQHNXQQHVLQRHRPHNVLVWHQVHQDYVSHVLHOOH Q ULQJVVWUXNWXUHU1nUGHWJMHOGHUDQWDOOEHGULIWHUHUGHWVW¡UVWUHODWLYRYHUYHNW IRU$XVW$JGHUDYEHGULIWHULQQHQJXPPLRJSODVWLQGXVWULWUHLQGXVWULSURGXN VMRQDYWUDQVSRUWPLGOHURJWHNVWLOLQGXVWUL$OOHGLVVHHUUHODWLYWVPnLQGXVWULHU EnGHL$XVW$JGHURJSnODQGVQLYn
7DEHOO1 ULQJVVWUXNWXUL1RUJHRJXWYDOJWHI\ONHUHWWHUDQWDOOEHGULIWHU
1 ULQJ 2VOR
$NHUVKXV
7HOHPDUN $XVW
$JGHU 9HVW
$JGHU
$QGUH I\ONHU
1RUJH 9HLG 2YHU 8QGHUYHNW
$JHQWXURJHQJURVKDQGHO
$QGUHVRVLDOHRJSHUVRQOLJHWMHQHVWHU
$QQHQLQGXVWULSURGXNVMRQ
%HUJYHUNVGULIWRJUnYDUHXWYLQQLQJ
'DWDEHKDQGOLQJVYLUNVRPKHW
(LHQGRPVGULIWRJXWOHLHYLUNVRPKHW
(OHNWURQLNNLQGXVWUL
)LQDQVLHOOWMHQHVWH\WIRUVLNULQJRJVW¡WWHWMHQHVWHU
)R8RJDQQHQIRUUHWQPWM
*UDILVNLQGXVWUL
*XPPLRJSODVWLQGXVWUL
-HUQRJPHWDOOLQGXVWUL
-RUGEUXNVNRJEUXNRJILVNH
.MHPLVNHSURGXNWHUUDIILQHULQJDYNRNVRJROMH
%\JJRJ$QOHJJ.UDIWRJYDQQIRUV\QLQJ
0DVNLQLQGXVWUL
1 ULQJVRJQ\WHOVHVPLGOHU
2IIDGP8WGRJ+HOVHRJVRVLDOWMHQHVWHU
3DSLULQGXVWUL
3RVWRJWHOHNRPPXQLNDVMRQHU
6WHLQOHLUHRJJODVV
7HNVWLOEHNOHGQLQJRJO U
7UDQVSRUWRJWLONQ\WWHGHWMHQHVWHU
3URG7UDQVSRUWPLGOHU
7UHLQGXVWUL
9DUHKDQGHORJKRWHOORJUHVWDXUDQW
2YHUYHNWRJXQGHUYHNWDYEHGULIWHUHOOHUDQVDWWHIRUHQQ ULQJUHJQHVXWJMHQQRPn GHOHDQGHOHQL$XVW$JGHUPHGDQGHOHQIRU1RUJH(WIRUKROGVWDOOSnYLVHUDWQ ULQ JHQKDUOLNHVWRUEHW\GQLQJL$XVW$JGHUVRPLODQGHWVRPKHOKHW(UWDOOHWPLQGUHHQQ HUQ ULQJHQXQGHUUHSUHVHQWHUWLI\ONHW(UWDOOHWK¡\HUHHQQHUGHULPRWQ ULQJHQ RYHUUHSUHVHQWHUWL$XVW$JGHU
2PPDQVHUSnDQWDOODQVDWWHEOLUELOGHWQRHDQQHUOHGHV,WDEHOOHUYDULDVMR QHQHVW¡UUHLIRUKROGWLOODQGVJMHQQRPVQLWWHW0HGXQQWDNDY´RIIHQWOLJDGPL QLVWUDVMRQKHOVHRJXWGDQQLQJµ´E\JJRJDQOHJJRJNUDIWRJYDQQIRUV\QLQJµRJ
´YDUHKDQGHOKRWHOORJUHVWDXUDQWµHUGHWLQJHQQ ULQJHUVRPV\VVHOVHWWHUPHU HQQIHPSURVHQWDYDUEHLGVWDNHUQH$QGHOHQHLQQHQGLVVHVHNWRUHQHHUUHODWLYW MHYQWIRUGHOWRYHUKHOHODQGHWPHGYLVVHVPnXQQWDN,UHVWHQDYGHWWHQRWDWHW YLOYLNXQNRPPHQWHUHGLVVHµWUHVWRUHµPHQUHJLRQDOWMHYQWIRUGHOWHVHNWRUHQH GHUVRPGHWVNXOOHY UHHWV UVNLOWJUXQQODJIRUGHW(WWSRHQJNDQLPLGOHUWLG QHYQHVQnUGHWJMHOGHUDQVDWWHLRIIHQWOLJDGPLQLVWUDVMRQKHOVHRJXWGDQQLQJ KDU$XVW$JGHUGHQK¡\HVWHDQGHOHQDYDOOHI\ONHUV¡UIRU1RUGODQG
$YDQGUHQ ULQJHUSHNHUHOHNWURQLNNLQGXVWULRJWUDQVSRUWPLGGHOLQGXVWULI¡UVW RJIUHPVWVNLSRJEnWHUVHJXWVRPEUDQVMHUPHGHQK¡\V\VVHOVHWWLQJVWHWWKHWL
$XVW$JGHU)\ONHWKDURJVnHQRYHUYHNWDYDQWDOODQVDWWHLQ ULQJHUVRPNMH PLVNHSURGXNWHUPDVNLQLQGXVWULSRVWRJWHOHNRPPXQLNDVMRQHURJWUHLQGXVWUL (WWVLVWHSRHQJHUDWEUDQVMHUPHGHQK¡\UHODWLYDQGHODYGHDQVDWWHPHQHQODY DQGHODYDQWDOOEHGULIWHUHUSUHJHWDYVWRUHHQKHWHUIRUHNVHPSHOHOHNWURQLNNLQ GXVWUL0RWVDWWYLOHQODYUHODWLYDQGHODYGHDQVDWWHRJHQK¡\DQGHODYDQWDOO EHGULIWHULQGLNHUHDWGHHUSUHJHWDYVPnHQKHWHUIRUHNVHPSHOJXPPLRJ SODVWLQGXVWUL
